CYLINDER #3 MISFIRE / HIDE CYLINDER

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 07. 2024
  • We experienced a misfire on cylinder #3 during our coast-to-coast road trip. Details are in the video, as are the diagnosis and repair. Here is a chapter list:
    00:00 - Intro
    00:46 - Background
    02:08 - Symptoms
    06:53 - Ignition Coils
    08:31 - Dealer Troubleshooting
    12:49 - Return to Stock
    14:08 - Driving Home Unrepaired
    15:35 - Diagnosis at Home
    16:25 - Coolant Leak Follow-Up
    17:20 - Driving Impressions
    18:25 - Why No Parts In Stock?
    20:23 - Cause of Failure?
    My Amazon Storefront: www.amazon.com/shop/stealthgti
    Mods to the car and links to blog write-ups (all links go to my blog, most are shortened):
    APR Programming w/Downpipe and Intercooler - wp.me/P7YnQB-dP
    RSR Clutch w/DMF by HS Tuning - wp.me/p7YnQB-su
    Baun Performance Catback Exhaust - wp.me/p7YnQB-1KJ
    Steel Oil Pan - wp.me/p7YnQB-wv
    Lots of Electronics - stealthgti.com/electronics/
    EcoHitch by TorkLift - wp.me/P7YnQB-hW
    Group 48 AGM Battery - wp.me/p7YnQB-1ev
    Gun Metal Gray Nogaro Wheels - wp.me/p7YnQB-Dg
    Various Accessories - stealthgti.com/accessories/
    My Camera Setup:
    Samsung Galaxy Note20 Ultra 5G for Close-Quarters
    Canon 80D Video Creator Kit - amzn.to/36EJDiG
    Rode VideoMic - amzn.to/2RyOYnk
    Lapel Microphone for Smartphone - amzn.to/3aU5Dt5
    ZOMEi 75'' Tripod - amzn.to/3aRYBFl
    Neewer Camera LED Video Light - amzn.to/36Dbznc
    Studio Lighting - amzn.to/36uEycM
    Glide Gear Teleprompter (for long videos) - amzn.to/3hIABXo
    Galaxy Tab S4 (for Teleprompter) - amzn.to/33BwRlE
    Corel VideoSuite Ultimate - amzn.to/3kviMgb
    Visit me at StealthGTI.com.
    Visit my Facebook page at / stealthgti
    Visit my Instagram page at / stealth_gti
    DISCLAIMER: StealthGTI is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases if you purchase a product with a link that I provide. There is no additional charge to you!
    #stealthgti
  • Auta a dopravní prostředky

Komentáře • 151

  • @lukeheffernan
    @lukeheffernan Před 3 lety +3

    Your videos are so well-thought-out. Love the expressionless face at the beginning when you're accelerating! Thank you for the updates.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Glad you like them! To be honest, this was the third run on shooting this. I record on a smartphone in the car. I have a new phone and getting the sound right has been a challenge since it does not have a microphone jack. I shot the first version of this video back in November... Didn't like it. I shot another version later in a hotel room. Didn't like it. HAHA! By the time I shot this, I had done it enough times that I had my talking points down. I still didn't like the sound, but have been using a program that has decent audio editing so that I could work with my microphone challenges. Thanks for visiting.

  • @devriesjp
    @devriesjp Před 3 lety +2

    Thanks for the awesome, in depth info. And so sorry for your loss 😞

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      My pleasure! Thanks for visiting!

  • @TheWilliec1999
    @TheWilliec1999 Před 3 lety +1

    That thermostat leak is to my knowledge the only problem every mk7 gti has and will have. Mine started leaking at 60000 miles like clockwork. To hear you hadn't had it surprised me. But hearing about your mystery coolant issue I had thought about it but never brought it up for sounding wrong. That and you've already had people look at it. Glad to hear you got the car fixed! And the documentation is wonderful!

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Thanks for the note!

    • @jasong9472
      @jasong9472 Před 9 měsíci

      yup mine too that water pump change was a bear to do...

  • @EDDIE92126
    @EDDIE92126 Před 3 lety +2

    Thank you for your content, makes me plan ahead a put money aside for repairs !

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Great to hear! You cannot go wrong with having an emergency fund. Thanks for visiting.

  • @giuseppepaoli2961
    @giuseppepaoli2961 Před 8 měsíci

    Very informative, thank you!

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 8 měsíci

      Glad it was helpful! Thanks for visiting.

  • @edmondvallarde3894
    @edmondvallarde3894 Před 2 lety +1

    I spent the better part of my Saturday swapping the locations of the coil packs and spark plugs then doing a compression test on cylinder #3 only to come across your video later in the day. LOL. Thanks for the play by play and mentioning who you got to do the work on your car. Well, off to Euro Pros I go to get my #3 fuel injector replaced. Thanks again.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      Sorry to hear of your troubles! Did you find an issue with #3? Or are you assuming it's the injector since everything you checked is good? Be advised that they may recommend replacing all injectors. The reasoning is that there is a lot of labor involved with replacing even one injector. If another fails next month, then all of the same labor has to be done again. Sure, he gets paid either way and will do the job twice. But there may be long-term savings to be had with replacing them all together. I'm detail-oriented and wanted them all done together, as if they might be "balanced." They're not, but I'm glad to know they're good for a while. Good Luck!

    • @edmondvallarde3894
      @edmondvallarde3894 Před 2 lety

      @@StealthGTI My code reader says the #3 is misfiring. The compression, Spark plug, and coil packs checkout good. The fuel injector is the only thing I'm unable to check. I'm experiencing the exact same problems you were having. I have the 1.8T engine so I reached out to Euro Pros for an estimate. Thanks for the info.

  • @jondonnelly4831
    @jondonnelly4831 Před 2 lety +1

    Thanks man, had same code, learned a lot.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      Glad I could help! Thanks for visiting!

  • @GTI_CHHA
    @GTI_CHHA Před 3 lety +1

    Scott, nice to see you confirm my suspicion of the faulty injector.... A pity it happened while on the road, at home you would have gotten it sorted right a way... Anyway, she's all fresh again. Your next trip is awaiting you ;-)

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      YES, road trip engine problems suck! I'm glad the car was drivable and could be addressed at home. We'll see if the GTI redeems itself on the next big trip. ;-)

  • @ELVENEVN
    @ELVENEVN Před 2 lety

    I’m going to check your mechanic out thanks for the info.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      I hope this was helpful. Thanks for visiting.

  • @Muamerikosss
    @Muamerikosss Před rokem

    thanks ! it was a great Video. I replaced my PCV Valve without Sucess, but now i see what the next Issues might be.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Good luck! Let me know how it works out.

    • @Muamerikosss
      @Muamerikosss Před rokem

      @@StealthGTI
      today i have looked inside my Combustion Chamber. Here is the Video
      czcams.com/video/_sk4USaFOb0/video.html

  • @nielvanderwesthuizen3083

    Thanks for the video. I have a polo doing the exact same thing. Will replace the injector also. And hopefully will get the problem sorted

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      Glad it helped. Let me know if it fixes your issue. Thanks for visiting!

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      @UC50klj0TJbRYm2V90ML96qw - WOW! That's a big move for troubleshooting. I do not think it's the throttle body since a fault there would affect all cylinders, even if just sporadically. If you've swapped the injectors, plugs, and coils, all without the fault moving to another cylinder, I have to wonder if you have a compression problem. With that said, I'm not a mechanic and could be wrong. It may be time to take the car to someone with more knowledge and experience. Good Luck!

    • @cruiseedwards4657
      @cruiseedwards4657 Před 4 měsíci

      Did you sort the issue? Was it injector or bad compression?

  • @petetrimby
    @petetrimby Před 2 lety

    I've just come across your vid while searching for info on my MK7 issues. Same thing with EPC and judderring. We limped home from Wales to Leeds in the UK (around 200 Miles) driving in 4th most of the way without boost. A diagnostic scan when we got back showed misfires on 1 and 3 so I'll be getting it booked in. Thanks for the info on this vid 👍🏻

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety +1

      If you're going to a pro, hopefully, they'll quickly isolate the coil packs or spark plugs before going straight to injectors. Please be sure to check back to share your diagnosis. Thanks for visiting!

    • @malakiakapenda7542
      @malakiakapenda7542 Před 5 měsíci

      What was the problem on your vehicle?

    • @petetrimby
      @petetrimby Před 5 měsíci

      Fortunately it was just as suspected, coil packs and spark plugs. Changed the lot which sorted the issue out.

  • @ryantornai945
    @ryantornai945 Před 2 lety +5

    Failed/stuck fuel injectors are easy to catch. If youre only getting 1 cyl misfire and its not the coilpack just pull the plug and it should be wet with fuel. Also exhaust smokes and smells like fuel.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      My failure was not a hard failure. It worked fine at light and medium loads. So, the visual inspection did not reveal any problems. Still, I'm glad to have it fixed. Thanks for visiting!

  • @chazteb
    @chazteb Před 3 lety

    That is just cars unfortunately! they do go wrong sometimes, but it's part of the journey :) Great Video Scott!

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      You got that right! Thanks for visiting.

  • @japmkam
    @japmkam Před 3 lety

    The entry message is way better. Good to hear your name and channel name

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Thanks! Adding it was something that I considered during our road trip series. Ironically, I've been contemplating a name change for the channel. Same content... just a broader name that can include other projects.

  • @mzuvele
    @mzuvele Před 3 lety +1

    Howzit Scott from Durban South Africa.....lovely video

  • @ITB_E86
    @ITB_E86 Před 3 lety +1

    Injector issues seem to be the Achilles heel of the gen3 motor. You were lucky and it didn’t get stuck open flooding the cylinder with gasoline. Had a local friend in the VB MQB group have that happen and cylinder 1 said “nope.” Granted he was making close to 500 whp on stock internals

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      I've been very tempted to go IS38. But, the way I drive, I'd hardly use the power... so, not really worth the money. Thanks for visiting.

  • @joelnierling-wi1ix
    @joelnierling-wi1ix Před rokem

    Same codes I have just had APR stage three tune and 6054 turbo installed. I have new water pump to install and think I will put injectors in at same time. Mine only sets codes on hard acceleration in higher gears. Thanks for your video

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Does APR have a tune for the 6054? I honestly don't know the turbo. Is that setup capable of exceeding the fuel needs that can be delivered by the stock injectors? Thanks for visiting!

  • @NoZenith
    @NoZenith Před 3 lety

    YAAAAYYYYYY!

  • @5kidsand2dogs
    @5kidsand2dogs Před 4 měsíci

    Hey Scott. What would be your suggestions on exhaust systems and cold air intakes? If you have any.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 4 měsíci

      I'm not fond of cold air intakes. They're for noise and entertainment, IMO. ;-) Exhaust upgrades are subjective. I think just about anyone can get tired of a drone, especially on a long trip. I've gone back to more sound suppression. See my "Baun Performance" playlist for details. Given the ongoing experimentation required to get the sound that you want, I think I'll leave the exhaust alone on my next car. I can even see myself returning to an IS20 turbo and restoring the stock downpipe if my IS38 turbo ever needs replacing. I won't do anything before that, but the downpipe and IS38 contribute to a bit of extra sound. Sure, it sounds great, but it gets old on a long trip, especially if the car is loaded. Thanks for visiting!

    • @5kidsand2dogs
      @5kidsand2dogs Před 4 měsíci

      @StealthGTI thanks for responding back. I appreciate it

  • @SterlingRobertson
    @SterlingRobertson Před rokem

    Great information. I just had the same cylinder 3 misfire and even had judder under heavy boost and a few epc lights. I am thinking it's the injector too. Just changed cyl 3 coil last week and didn't fix the issue.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Thanks for sharing. Good luck with your search!

    • @SterlingRobertson
      @SterlingRobertson Před rokem

      @@StealthGTI new fuel injectors didn't fix my issue. Ugh. Now need to see if boots have any leaks, plugs and coils.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      @@SterlingRobertson - Oh my! You didn't start with the coils/plugs? Then a compression test? Do you get a CEL and a stored code?

  • @acefighterpilot
    @acefighterpilot Před 3 lety

    I never experience fuel injector failure on my horse drawn wagon, so clearly the car is at fault.
    Glad it was a simple fix. Something to consider is that the APR (or any) tune may cause the injectors to approach their duty cycle more often and thus fail sooner. But for the performance you get out of it, I would just make injector replacement a 100k mile service item.
    I really appreciate that you're forecasting the future of my car. Great to see you cutting up the Back of the Dragon as well.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Yes, APR Stage 2 and towing over mountains may have stretched the injectors to a higher duty cycle. BUT, I had to wonder why none of the other injectors were affected. We'll see if I have problems on the next trip. BTW, next week's video is about the BOTD run. :-)

    • @acefighterpilot
      @acefighterpilot Před 3 lety

      @@StealthGTI I doubt the specific trip had too much to do with it, as opposed to overall time in service. Do you use any fuel system cleaner products?
      Looking forward to the video.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      @@acefighterpilot - I hadn't used any fuel additives. I do refuel at top tier stations, though. I may add cleaners to my periodic maintenance.

  • @lucienl9465
    @lucienl9465 Před 3 lety

    Did you get your intake valve clean ? (walnut blasting)

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      The intake had been cleaned recently. See my "Four Year" video at czcams.com/video/ec07OfUok5U/video.html. Thanks for visiting!

  • @samiginonacerdepaoli2413

    hows the GTI holding up? how many miles now? any Crank walk issues?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      The car has 134,000 miles now. It's driving great and does not appear to have any issues. Thanks for visiting!

  • @samerbayoumi6378
    @samerbayoumi6378 Před 2 lety

    samething just happened to me. got the hide cylinder code. cyl 1 and 3 missfire car engine light was flashing. really hope its just injectors and nothing more crazy,

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      Don't be in a rush to swap the injectors unless you have eliminated the possibility that spark plugs or coil packs are culprits. Also, pull the plugs to make sure they're clean. Although I haven't seen it on my GTI, I once had a 1.8T (pre-E888) valve cover gasket leak that let a tiny amount of oil into the spark plug well. That could cause similar results. In short, eliminate the cheap problems before jumping on the expensive ones. Good Luck!

  • @magogliati
    @magogliati Před 3 lety

    Love the video Scott - but when was this shot? If this is January, why are there green leaves on the trees?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Thanks for the note, Michael. The video was shot on Christmas Eve. A lot of the green that you're seeing is actually shrubbery and smaller trees or pines. If you look higher in the frame, you'll see that taller trees are indeed leafless. Thanks for visiting.

    • @magogliati
      @magogliati Před 3 lety +1

      @@StealthGTI Thanks for the response Scott! I went to Lynchburg College and didn't think it got that warm this early.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      @@magogliati - It's not getting warm early; it hasn't gotten really cold yet. We've seen freezing temps just a few days. February is usually our coldest month.

  • @thetickler4487
    @thetickler4487 Před rokem

    @StealthGTI hi.very good input. I know this is a year later.
    My sons polo is doing the very same thing so yesterday i swapped the 3rd cylinder injector for number 1 injector just to see.
    Checked everything like the garage that robbed you when you was away did and i get the same fault cylinder 3 as in the UK we get crap fuel.
    Do you think it could be the throttle body.
    Code P0303 always comes up.
    Any extra help would be great. Thanks

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      The throttle body seems unlikely. I *think* it would intermittently affect ALL cylinders. With that said, I'm not a mechanic or a trained technician. If you've swapped the plugs, coils, and injectors; and checked the compression, then it may be time to take the car to a trained pro. Good luck and thanks for visiting!

    • @cruiseedwards4657
      @cruiseedwards4657 Před 4 měsíci +1

      @thetickler4487 did you find the issue in the end? I have the same problem

  • @mikey_seven5138
    @mikey_seven5138 Před 2 lety

    Having misfire and hide cylinder on cylinder 3 and misfire cylinder 1 new spark plugs as well with 1k miles, I am going to replace coil packs and injectors... I hope it fixes issues . If this doesn’t fix the issue what else could cause misfires from your knowledge ??? Ty

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      I'm not sure if your troubleshooting efforts are logical or if they're following diagnostic trouble codes and a good process of elimination. Are your spark plugs OE and properly gapped? Swap coil packs between good and bad cylinders first to see if the fault moves. If the fault does not move, then trying swapping spark plugs next. If the fault moves for either of those swaps, then you don't need to go through the cost and hassle of replacing injectors. Always start cheap. If those don't move or resolve the fault, then perhaps you have an injector problem. BUT, don't take my mechanical advice before spending lots of money one expensive parts. Seek competent assistance. Good Luck!

  • @alexmartineau1060
    @alexmartineau1060 Před rokem

    speaking of coil packs, I have a stage 3 tune on my mk7 APR, stock coils and they have yet to fail on me.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Yes! I think OEM coil packs are either best or at least enough. My daughter has APR coils, but more because they're "Cookie Monster Blue" than anything else. ;-) Thanks for visiting!

  • @FourCeez
    @FourCeez Před 14 dny

    Unitronic Stage 2 tune on my mk5. I replaced all coils and sparks and it's still misfiring. A week before that I bought ecs tuning fuel injectors because the fourth one was stuck open so I went ahead and replaced all four of them but they were on the cheaper side. 340 dollars compared to the 1000 dollar oem ones. I have a cylinder 4 and 2 misfire under heavy load and up hills. Do you think it would be from the none oem fuel injectors??

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 11 dny +1

      I cannot be sure. The earlier cars are known for bad coil packs, but you also have a mix of aftermarket parts. Even at IS38 tuning, I'm still using factory coils, injectors, and OEM R7 spark plugs. IF you're confident in your plugs, coils, and injectors, then check your compression and leakdown. Good Luck!

    • @FourCeez
      @FourCeez Před 10 dny +1

      @@StealthGTI Compression is even on all cylinders so the engine is healthy thankfully. Leak down test it is appreciate it.

  • @kevinc9515
    @kevinc9515 Před 3 lety

    This is your 2nd/3rd thermostat housings at 116k miles?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      No. First failure. I had suspected a leak over the years, but never got to the bottom of it. I'm not even sure if this leak is the same one at a later time or something different altogether. I don't care, though. It's fixed. Thanks for visiting.

  • @samshepperrd
    @samshepperrd Před 3 lety

    There are cheap scan tools that could have caught that misfiring injector. It's either fuel.or spark.
    I had a 96 golf gl with mystery ignition problems. If I pushed it, the engine seemed to lock up. One day I had to have it towed home. Pulling the Bosch plat plugs, two had blown up. Ceramic shards inside the combustion chamber. I fished them put with a rag soaked in STP (sticky).
    Then filled the combustion chambers with kerosene with cool disconnected. I turned the engine oner, sending a spout of kerosene into the air. Cleaned out those spark plug shards.
    It turned out the engine grounding strap had a bad connection. Two spark plugs were firing at the same time. The car ran fine after the second ground strap. Though one of the cylinders had a little bit low compression.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Thanks for sharing your experience. I have a tool that's specific to VW/Audi. It reads more than just OBD2 codes. Regardless, the tool can only track to a cylinder; it cannot distinguish between an injector issue and a spark issue... only a misfire on a specific cylinder. That's where troubleshooting comes into play. Thanks for visiting.

  • @cullen5419
    @cullen5419 Před 3 lety

    Great information. You were right about the leakdown. I’m looking to buy a mk7 gti. How are they on reliability? I sold my 08 STI for that reason. Oh and I’m only looking at 6 speed

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      I still love the car. I'm on a return trip to CA and will see if I make it without issue. I'll be sharing a playlist along the way. Thanks for visiting.

    • @cullen5419
      @cullen5419 Před 3 lety

      StealthGTI thank you! I’m getting the car compression tested and hopefully all looks good. I love the mk7 gti

  • @jacobsmith7176
    @jacobsmith7176 Před 2 lety

    Are you still running the is38?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      Yes. However, I added the IS38 several thousand miles after producing this video. Thanks for visiting!

  • @MabiPlayerOhanus
    @MabiPlayerOhanus Před 3 lety

    Hey Scott, I just purchased a 2013 VW CC 6-speed manual and the day I bought it ran just fine. However before I bought it the engine would have a noticable ticking noise that I didn't recognize due to inexperience, and the day after I tried to drive it to work and it threw that flashing engine light and epc light at me. I pulled over into a park and felt the engine bogging and stuttering at low rpms, and I figured it was misfiring. I opened the hood to listen to and feel the engine, it had that same ticking sound and it was unusually shaking a lot. My dad thought it could be a problem with the sensor for the throttle pedal, so we bought a replacement. Replacing that took the epc light away, but I don't know if it will come back. I want to replace the coil packs and plugs, but now that I've watched your video I really am concerned about it being the fuel injectors. Problem is I put my all into the car financially, and I didn't even pay for it in it's entirety, my father lent me money. So I'm extreeeeemely parsimonious right now. Do you mind helping me figure this out? Thank you for this video! It was very educational.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Armando - I cannot give adequate assistance from afar. Without a diagnostic trouble code (DTC), replacing the accelerator pedal sensor seems like guesswork from my point of view. You'd be doing yourself a huge favor to acquire a scan tool, preferably one that reads VW DTCs such as OBDEleven, VCDS, or Carista, and work with real diagnostic info. Good Luck!

    • @ELVENEVN
      @ELVENEVN Před 2 lety

      @@StealthGTI I’m going to get one of those. I just picked up a 2006 A3 for cheap in VA so I have extra funds to get the scan tool.

  • @SKYRIDR
    @SKYRIDR Před 3 lety

    How does the car feel after carbon cleaning? How much was it?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      I had the carbon cleaning done before the trip and, therefore, before my injector problem. The intake really wasn't too dirty. So, I couldn't tell the difference. It was just peace of mind. Take Care!

    • @SKYRIDR
      @SKYRIDR Před 3 lety

      @@StealthGTI thanks for response. Looking fwd to more videos.
      By the way how does ceramic coating holding up? Especially after such a long trip?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      @@SKYRIDR - The ceramic coating is doing great! However, I still need to polish away some mineral deposits that marred the finish under the roof rack pads. I'm hoping that once thin or remove the ceramic coating in those areas.

  • @warchieft2k
    @warchieft2k Před 2 lety +1

    So it was the injectors.... I have the same issue! dang here goes a ton of money!

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety +1

      Have a shop diagnose and provide an estimate. It may be something else if you haven't exhausted the ignition coils, spark plugs, or other cylinder problems. Good Luck!

  • @harryevans7624
    @harryevans7624 Před 2 lety

    I’m currently experiencing the cylinder 3 misfire myself, the misfire would only begin when the engine is left to idle, if I kept the revs above 1k all 4 cylinders would stay firing correctly… I’ve changed the coil, spark plugs, and fixed some fault wiring on the cylinder 3 coil connector… which led me to believe the previous owner has attempted it before, my next step now is to replace the injector, and clean the manifold whilst I’m there. Really bugging me now.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      If you choose to replace an injector, just do them all at once. If one is really bad, how long before you have to do all of the labor again to replace another... and then another. Doing the same labor over and over would be a hassle. Hopefully, an injector is the correct diagnosis for you. Good Luck!

    • @harryevans7624
      @harryevans7624 Před 2 lety

      @@StealthGTI turns out motors blown, no comp in cylinder 3, new engine time unfortunately, but a very good video by yourself and Thankyou for the reply

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      @@harryevans7624 - Ah, yes! I forgot to consider compression, as a good mechanic would before tearing anything apart. Are you buying a new engine? Finding salvage? Good Luck!

    • @harryevans7624
      @harryevans7624 Před 2 lety

      @@StealthGTI I’ll be looking for a salvage engine, around £1,700 in the U.K and around £400 for labour costs. Not a happy man, but we move on, thanks buddy.

  • @danielbowersmusic
    @danielbowersmusic Před 5 měsíci

    Unfortunately I've swapped the coil pack, spark plug, Injector #3 with #2 and I'm still getting a #3 misfire.. I've even changed the coil pack connector and nothing changed. Getting correct voltage. At this point I'm thinking it's the ECU.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 5 měsíci

      You need to run a compression check and leakdown test. The ECU is unlikely to be the problem. Have you made any progress since you posted this?

    • @danielbowersmusic
      @danielbowersmusic Před 4 měsíci

      @@StealthGTI thank you for the reply. Yes a buddy and I did both tests and we confirmed low compression on the cylinder.. Most likely an exhaust valve as there was movement on the exhaust end.

    • @HBV3
      @HBV3 Před 27 dny

      @StealthGTI you’re GOATed

  • @danafokinwhite9816
    @danafokinwhite9816 Před 2 lety

    I still have the issue after changing spark plugs, injectors, knock sensor :( any idea what else it cld be? I recently built my engine with forged parts and it can’t seem to pull pass 6.2k rpm. The epc light comes on and the engine chokes

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 2 lety

      I'd find a VW specialist and have them diagnose. I'm not an expert. As you may have gleaned from the video, a VW dealer is essentially worthless when troubleshooting a modified car. Good Luck!

  • @mexifinn7830
    @mexifinn7830 Před 3 lety

    A few comments and a few questions:
    The waterpump/thermostat/housing are all kind of related and that's a weak point on the EA888Gen3. We have 2 MK7's (Alltrack & R) and BOTH suffered failures under warranty. I believe the newer water pumps have more aluminum and less plastic and might be more reliable. The other EA888Gen3 weak point is the rear main seal - when I upgraded the clutch on my 6MT R to accomodate the Stage1 93 octane (high torque) tune, I had them install an upgraded RMS. Alltrack is still stock and untouched.
    Maybe it was the crappy gas that was the straw that broke the camel's back regarding the bad injector!
    I'm so happy to hear about the general longevity of the car - makes me feel like I made some good purchases. But 2 questions (feel free to use these for your next Q&A)
    1) If your GTI died today (tree falls on it, bursts into flames, drives into the ocean) and you needed a new car right away, what would you buy?
    2) Looking down the road 3-4 years and it's time to put the GTI out to pasture, are there any cars coming down the road (hybrid, electric, etc...) that you would want to buy to replace the GTI?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      I thought about the fuel quality issue, too. BUT, if it was a fuel problem, it seems to me that it would have taken out more than one injector. I think the one had finally met its match. I'll find out soon: I'm about to do the trip again with another trailer. I'm not sure if I should be excited or apprehensive about that. HAHA!
      It's funny that you chose "tree falls on it" when talking about my GTI dying. I used that term in an upcoming video segment where I talk about other cars. To be honest, I'm not sure what I would get. I don't like the Mk8 at the moment. So, I'd consider a 2020 GTI. But I've also been keeping my eyes on Subaru Crosstreks (for small off-road adventures), Atlases (for slightly larger off-road adventures), and small cargo vans for conversion ideas. NONE of those can compare to the fun have in a tuned GTI. Still, I seldom unleash my GTI's full power and almost never push it to its handling limit. So, even if I got a Crosstrek with only 182 hp, odds are fair that I'd still enjoy it since it would likely be more comfortable and able to take me places that a GTI cannot touch. I hope to have a long time to think about my options.

  • @bulldogkarma
    @bulldogkarma Před rokem

    So what was the breakdown of the cost that finally repaired your misfire? Share the wealth..

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem +1

      I don't recall, especially since there was additional labor involved with replacing the engine cooling parts. Plus, the injectors are more expensive today than they were in 2020. Thanks for visiting.

  • @jorgemontesdeoca895
    @jorgemontesdeoca895 Před rokem

    Did yours smoke?

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Mine did not. However, my daughter experienced a very similar issue which led to discovering a low-compression issue in cylinder #3. She probably needs an engine. :-(

  • @JoseMelendez
    @JoseMelendez Před 3 lety

    My cylinder 3 just triggered my check engine light. Cold start and let my car warm up before use every time I drive it and about halfway through the oil temp meter hitting 280 it rumbles the car a little then goes away. Not sure what the issue is but my local auto zone reported a bad cylinder 3. Car still runs fine, but I’m worried to keep going on it.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Take it to a competent VW mechanic. It may be an injector or it may be just an ignition coil. Good Luck!

  • @DeeMan17
    @DeeMan17 Před 8 měsíci

    My Golfs cylinder 3 is also misfiring. Unfortunately for me it’s damaged piston rings. Not a good result, I’m hoping it’s just gummy piston rings fixed with a special oil, but highly unlikely. Car itself’s not worth enough to pull apart the engine. Wish I knew all this before I just had the timing chain done.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 8 měsíci

      Bummer! Good luck with a solution. I replaced the engine in my daughter's 2015 Golf recently. Thankfully(?), I hadn't sunk a bunch of money into it beforehand. Now, I hope it will last long enough for the investment to have been worthwhile. Thanks for visiting!

    • @DeeMan17
      @DeeMan17 Před 8 měsíci

      @@StealthGTI thanks mate, so far so good with the solution. 🙏

    • @cruiseedwards4657
      @cruiseedwards4657 Před 4 měsíci

      ​@benshaw9098 what did you do with the car in the end?

    • @DeeMan17
      @DeeMan17 Před 4 měsíci

      @@cruiseedwards4657 basically nothing, it was all going fine until I paid for a timing chain replacement. It’s still running quite rough but getting me to work and back, I probably should do a diagnostic scan again. It’s not our main car but I enjoy driving it and would still like to solve the problem If it’s not overly expensive.

  • @Chocobohunter
    @Chocobohunter Před rokem

    Oh man i have the same problem on my 2020 audi s3, misfire cylinder 3 and hide cylinder. No CEL, but got a warning yellow symbol “drive system malfunction”. Would only happen when I floor it or semi floor it. It would have vibration when flooring it then will get the warning light and car would go on limp mode. The problem will be fixed when I turn off and on the car.
    The thing is my car is almost new, only has 13000km(8k miles) car has a stage 1+ ecu tune unitronic. So im not sure what the problem is, my bro who used to be an audi tech said it could be the coils. Hopefully its nothing major i barely even drive it lol and i baby my car. 😢

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      "Hide Cylinder" is protecting the engine from a problem. Restarting the car is just allowing the problem to continue without the ECU protecting the engine. You need a diagnosis. Good Luck! -Scott

    • @Chocobohunter
      @Chocobohunter Před rokem

      @@StealthGTI fixed it, the ignition coil on the 3rd cylinder had some lubricant that wasn’t spread properly causing the misfire, everything looked good and was clean and dry, even the spark plugs looked new. I already bought the apr pcoils so i replaced it but i will keep the stock ones for back up since theyre expensive. 130$ for oem coils and 60$ for the apr ones(each)

  • @dasauto44
    @dasauto44 Před rokem

    Wait a minute. You make it sound like changing the coil pack is easy. Can you please do a how-to video please.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před rokem

      Perhaps someday. But I'm not inclined until it warms up. I work outside. Thanks for visiting!

  • @sonofevil77
    @sonofevil77 Před 3 lety

    I'm doing injectors and carbon clean asap. Random Misfires on all cylinders.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      When you say "doing injectors," do you plan to just replace them without diagnosing them? It's possible that your carbon build-up alone is sufficient to create your problem. Good Luck!

    • @sonofevil77
      @sonofevil77 Před 3 lety +1

      @@StealthGTI I am getting a carbon cleaning and changing the injectors at the same time to avoid taking the intake off again. It's more of a preventative measure than anything. My gli runs fantastic but I get Misfires galore but no check engine lights or codes.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      @@sonofevil77 - Excellent! Seems like a good plan.

  • @4GuitarTrance
    @4GuitarTrance Před 3 lety

    If mechanics are paid by commission then run...run away VERY fast. That is, unless you know the mechanic and they can be trusted. Lots of dealers -- especially independent service locations -- put their mechs on commission actually HOPING they will push and/or exaggerate parts/services needed in order to boost their salaries, and the owner makes more money in the process. I am extremely suspicious [especially these days] of mechanics on commission. It's the first thing I ask service location consultants!
    BTW... were you driving on either the Yorktown or Jamestown Parkway(s) in this video? Looks REALLY familiar... those arched underpasses. VERY beautiful in that area of Virginia. I used to take girls out on either of those Parkway's river edges (pseudo-beaches) at night when there were full moons reflecting off of the James or York rivers as a teen with my first car. Girls LOVED riding on those parkways at night. Ahhhh, the memories of youth! *sigh*. :-P

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Sometimes, such as when traveling far from home, we have little choice but to suck-up whatever service we can get. Thankfully, my situation allowed me to drive the car home and have a trusted mechanic address this. As for the road, yes, I was on the Colonial Parkway. Sometimes I record on that road or on one of Yorktown's one-way tour roads where I can drive sedately without worry of cross-traffic. Thanks for visiting!

  • @eliseocortes0228
    @eliseocortes0228 Před 3 lety

    I have misfire cyl number 1, scanner says is coil, so i bought the apr blue coils pack, and bosch double iridium spark plugs ..i hope that help restore the misfire and the futures

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      Can you share your code? I wonder how it distinguishes between a coil, spark plug, or injector. I hope it's a cheap fix for you. Good Luck!

  • @propertyh3823
    @propertyh3823 Před 3 lety

    Watched this video to see if it’s a good idea to drive while the car has a Hide fault so I guess I’ll still drive on it I hope my engine doesn’t get hurt.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety +1

      I think I detailed in this video, but I think it's a bad idea to drive the car with a "hide cylinder" fault if the car is misbehaving. In my case, the code was stored, but drove normally at light loads. Good Luck!

    • @mariopeak
      @mariopeak Před 3 lety

      I’m here right now
      Pray for me

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      @@mariopeak - How did it go?

    • @mariopeak
      @mariopeak Před 3 lety +1

      I didn’t chance it
      I order the parts and waiting for it to be delivered
      But thanks this video was very educational

    • @mariopeak
      @mariopeak Před 3 lety

      @Madian Banegas bro
      It’s still there and I change everything related to this problem
      Any help??????

  • @nerko0genius
    @nerko0genius Před 3 lety

    dude those dealers are mostly scammers same here in Europe. I had similar situatuin with VW-Skoda dealer

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 3 lety

      Yes. They either tried to scam me or are quite inept. Either could be true. Thanks for visiting.

  • @zomgosz1503
    @zomgosz1503 Před 6 měsíci

    don't need 100 chapters for a 20 min video.

    • @StealthGTI
      @StealthGTI  Před 6 měsíci

      Viewers who watch the entire video don't care about chapters. Those who want only the minimal info appreciate being able to click straight to that point. Thanks for visiting!

    • @HBV3
      @HBV3 Před 27 dny

      Don’t be such a ho when someone is trying help, giving us context and then making FWD marks for you to skip the things you don’t want to listen to @zomgosz1503

  • @Noel127
    @Noel127 Před rokem

    too much talking