"How Do We Understand The Hadīth Regarding The Prohibition of Plucking The Eyebrows?" | Ask YQ
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 10. 2020
- Today's Question: "How Do We Understand The Hadīth Regarding The Prohibition of Plucking The Eyebrows?"
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Outro Nasheed:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official CZcams Channel
I stopped plucking my eyebrows a few years ago after I heard this hadith. At first, It was one of the most difficult things I had to do cause I have very large eyebrows but Allah swt helped me through it. It hardly bothers me now. This Q & A was certainly an eye opener, however, I will continue not to pluck my eyebrows just to be on the safer side and Allah knows best.
I was in the same boat, sA. I will InshAllah continue not to pluck.... may Allah help me.
@1990m t I don't know if you're trying to undermine the sisters efforts to not conform or this was just a passing comment... but thick eyebrows were never the trend until recently, true, but they are "tamed thick". A lot of Muslim women really do buck trends and societal pressure when they choose to dress modestly or leave their eyebrows untouched.
I'm sorry if i found your intent incorrect, but i'd advise you to stick to encouragement vs downplaying someones struggle to do something (basic as u may think it is).
I don't know what to say. But I'm really sad to see how Shaykh YQ is searching loopholes to legitimize things like this. I hold the traditional views, strongly. But I'm not intolerant or something as he said, it seems like a plain accusation.
@@muhammadanasp3825 did u watch a different lecture as I took the total opposite of what you took... it's ok if you want to take literal meaning but dont presume auzobillah that you are more right.
@@yorkshirecobble8331 having different views is totally accepted, especially for a Scholar. But searching words and views of great scholars to make a conclusion favors our desires is different. I don't know if you get it. May Allah guide us.
Unlike many scholars, Y.Q covers all the aspects of the issue and equips us to take the opinion...Its an awesome way of teaching......May Allah preserve him....
Ameen
آمین یارب العالمین 🤲🤲۔۔
Ameen. Question though, does this video YQ make it so that its halal for men to trim their eyebrows as well?
You just not giving information but also make us ability to think for ourselves and not just simply blinded follows the instruction
Mashallah Sheikh... Really appreciate your view on this. The way you teach us to think rationaly is really eye opening. May Allah be pleased with you.
This is exactly why i love Shaikh YQ
Jazak Allah khair Sheikh. I have understood this issue for the very first time. May Allah bless you with long life.
JazakAllah khair, this issue has been on mine and my wife's mind for a while now. Thank you for explaining it in a way that is intellectual and fact-based. It was very eye opening.
Great video. May Allah reward him massively for presenting the difference of opinion.
Extremely helpful lecture, such a great explanation. Allah reward you 🙌
Love you sheikh May Allah have mercy on you and bless you in all that you do
Love you bro. May Allah bless and protect you and your loved ones. Amin
This is so beneficial.... For those who are wanting to benefit 👌🏽
Alhamdulillah
May Allah grant us patience and true understanding ameen
Dr. Yasir qadhi bless your soul. You are one of the most learned 'ulama and you go as far back as possible in your reasearch. You are deep and logical. Intolerance for alternative views is what is killing our religion. You are a true scholar for bringing out this position.
Jazak Allah brother Yasir Qadhi...You are amazingly intelligent..You are among my favorite speaker...You are bless..It's awesome the way you put things in people' minds....I soooo like hearing you & may Allah help me & all muslim women to understand & correct ourselves..Ameen
STAY BLESS SHAYKH QADHI 🤲🌷🌷🌷🌷
Jazak Allahu khairan for discussing the different opinions.
Alhamdulillah for our Shaykh!
May Allah reward Shaykh Yasir Qadhi for all his efforts and grant him long and content life ameen
May Allah sw protect our beloved shaikh; he digs deep into Islamic issue helping us to understand our beautiful deen. Alhamdolillah for such scholars and for modern technology which allows us to benefit from scholars who are thousands of miles away.
Jazak Allah khairun Shiekh for discussing this topic. This Hadith has quite often caused me anxiety. Many times, I have pondered on the similar questions as the scholars who hold the second opinion. Therefore, your video makes a great sense.
This was a really eye brow opening video.
...
My question is if ladies are allowed to do this only for their husbands then they have to stay home all the time or wear niqab that covers the eyebrows; to avoid non-mahram men from seeing it.
Mashaallah Great Tafseer
Shocking for me, who grew up in a family where no man and no woman ever thought that eyebrouws-plucking could exist ,the pressure that a muslim husband can make to ask eyebrowe-plucking of his spouse, instead to respect her physical integrety and also her own ( personal and religious) choice.
Islam comes to free women and not to enslave , what a strange custom.
Ask yourselves, would you still pluck your eyebrows if the new trend amongst society is growing out the eyebrows naturally? What is the real reason you are plucking? Husband, cleansiness or just simply following the trend?
good point
May Allah grant him jannatul firdows💖💖
JazakAllahu khayran shaykh for your explanation of other views. You should do a meet up with mufti abu layth please.
Why would he do a meet up with someone so misguided
can someone clarify does he mention in the video that you are allowed to pluck the hair between the eyebrow? are you allowed to do that?
Salaam from Nottingham Uk
Can anybody help me out how to ask questions to yasir qdhi
Would there be similar explanation and exceptions to wearing wigs or hair extensions? Just wondering if it would be allowed to please husband or after hair loss due to medical treatment.
SalamuAlikum wa Rahamtu Allah wa Baraktu sis
There are resources on this but my understanding is that even the strictest schools of Fiqh allowed wearing wigs for women who lost hair due to medical treatment such as chemotherapy
But please I am not a mufti so do your own research and may Allah SWT guide you to the best of knowledge
If it’s not the act (plucking), but the lifestyle associated with the act (prostitution), then wouldn’t single and/or divorced ladies be allowed to pluck as well? Confusing. How is it deception if she’s going to end up plucking anyways after marriage? If we’re allowed to “beautify” ourselves for our guests, couldn’t this be considered the same? Also if we DONT wear niqab are we not allowed to pluck?
Sometimes he goes into detail but it always leads me to more questions lol. He should run these by his wife and daughters to figure out the plot holes.
I personally believe that if you do not know how to look good for yourself, you will never know how to look good for someone else. Self care comes from self love which is essential.
Lol I thought the same thing about single ladies as well lol. I think he's just trying to stay within the traditional paradigm and perspectives
I was wondering about this too. If single woman does not need to beautify herself, just so she is not deceiving a man and he accepts her as she is, then why does she need to beautify herself after marriage for him? He shouldn't have an issue with her bushy eyebrows after marriage too. She should carrying on being how she is and whatever she feels comfortable with.
I just tweeted something along the same line. Maybe we all should tweet so he addresses it 😀
@@nodametakumi4656 great point! Huge struggle for newly married women who have been modest up till then in their life and then have to learn how to be the complete opposite to please our husbands! Need to learn how to manage yourself first!
The issue of not observing proper hijab comes along with "plucking for husband" permissibility.
One could be plucking eyebrows for husband but the beautification is available to be seen for rest of the world as well. :(
May ALLAH swt help and guide us all
Aameen
This is an amazing and very intelligent argument!
Mashallah good point.
I think - it depends on the niyyah
I am sorry what is wrong with looking beutiful? You thibk Allah will love you only if you would want to lokk ugly for everyone except your husband? It doesnt make any sense. There is alwqys balance. If you look like a monkey you have to take some hair out to look as a person. Its pure logic. If you want to take out hair to look sexy is different. What i want to say you should look clean and tidy but not vulgar. I mean its logic. Just use it please.
Moreover besides looking tidy for others people also want to look tidy for thrmselves and for Alllah SWT. When i go to pray even i dont wanna look like a mobkey abd if my eyr brows makr me look like that i eill plug them to a reasonavle degree to look clean and tidy. And there is nothing wrong with that! It concerns both men and women!
but what if you want to make certain changes to your appearance that are very minimal & barely noticeable only for yourself & not for anyone else? i'm a teenager so i'm still far from getting married but i have very messy eyebrows & they really irritate me. i've never plucked my eyebrows before & i was looking forward to doing so this year since i thought i was finally old enough, but then i came across this hadith & decided against it. upon further research i learned the reasoning behind said hadith & like you mentioned i found out that the beautification of eyebrows is not allowed since by doing so you change Allah swt's creation & that it's only permissible for some married women. but what if i'm not married & just want to do it to make myself feel happier about my appearance/less insecure about my eyebrows & only make very minor changes that are barely noticeable & basically make my eyebrows still look the same but just a little more neat & clean looking rather than completely different?
Pshhhh 3 years later, what was your decision? Trust and believe from a woman in her 30’s. I started getting my eyebrows done when I was 13, then I transitioned to getting them only “cleaned up” with only removes he stragglers at the end and underneath. 8 years ago I stopped doing them completely, let me TELL YOU these thick eyebrows are in fashion now but NOW my brows are “messy” and patchy!” If you have mA healthy brows, leave em be and Allah swt with beautify them for you!! The standard of society will always change. Be a trendsetter not a follower! ❤💪🏾
PLEASE do hair fades next shaykh
lol
Asc. can you please do an episode about having family pictures in the house. May Allah have mercy on you
Also I ask want to know this -
Yes I would like to know as well!
Assalamualikum Shaykh, If you want any Graphic Designs. I'm free and ready to help.
Mashallah!
it is like shaykh yasir qadhi was sent esp.for this generation ...the 90s kids ...may allah bless him wd a long lyf
Jazak Allah khairan kaseera shaykh u r picking topics which are seriously needed to talk & noone is addressing.Another much needed Can girl post photo on socialmedia which again noone is addressing, pls tell about this.
Why wouldn't they be allowed?
As salam alaikoum, is waxing premissible?
Dear Brother and sister - I have question if anyone can answer- my sister works in beauty parlor and she wanted if it’s ok for her to keep the job since she has to do eyebrows threading part of her job? Please help .
We are not allowed jobs that include haram, such as interest / riba, alcohol, zina, plucking, etc.
With the incident about the Asr prayer, it’s not about intended meaning versus literal commands. Stop lumping in Dhahiris with Wahhabis. Because we also have literal commands about praying on time. So it’s about weighing which command overrules the other command in a time when you didn’t fulfill the goal of hastening properly. So to me the correct decision would be to pray the prayer before arriving. The reason being is that we have the over arching rules of not intentionally delaying a prayer. Plus we have the prohibit of time to pray wherein there is no Asr prayer: namely when the sun is close to setting and has become orange. So either you make it in time before then and prayed there, and that is the best scenario and what is intended. However, if you don’t make it, the overarching rule is to pray on time, so you pray on time. This has nothing to do with literal verses intended meaning. The command to print on time is also literal, is it not? I’m Dhahiri-leaning, actually.
Is it also allowed for men to do this for her woman?
Could you do a lecture on drawing living things?
@@gaznawiali I understand your logic, but I would be careful passing statements without proof.
@Maha that’s good question, you can send him an email
@@omranhashim1028 what he said is logical and right
I've heard yasir qadi's lecture that making any 3d sculpture is haram but 2d is okk..
I think in series of jahannam
czcams.com/video/xr_ALNRjQK8/video.html
Jazakallah khair Sheikh
Stopped plucking my brows and life has become a bit easier now alhamdulillah.
as a men with extremely bushy eyebrows, can i also trim my eyebrows? imagine getting a haircut that is uneven or awkward. it’s more hairy on one side than the other. of course you would want to clean it up and straight it. due to this, I just want to clean it up. I won’t make it too thin as to impersonate women but rather as a male. Please help me. Is this halal?
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته،
Thank you for this video. I’ve always wondered why certain points of this Hadith were not discussed properly before. Turns out, they were, they just don’t tell us. It’s irritating that when you look for a fatwa on this issue, all you get is that the majority opinion is that it is completely haram, but some scholars allowed it for the married woman, which turns out to not even be the proper truth, but a twisted one.
This lecture answers many questions, however, not all of them. I’ve always wondered about the curse not fitting the action (which was discussed) and found the Hadith strange, in that regard, especially that it only talks about women, not men, when the prohibition applies for both. The conclusion that I reached was that the Prophet pbuh must have meant a certain type of women that lived back then and did these things, which this too was answered in this lecture. But... what about the “changing God’s creation” part?
Scholars understand the Hadith in the sense that plucking the eyebrows is of the changing of the creation of God and therefore who does that is cursed. As was discussed that does not make sense and the curse is on the “fajirat” and not the action itself, but that actually does not explain the part of changing God’s creation. The Hadith seems to imply that the reason for the curse is trying to change God’s creation, which, yes it applies to the tattoo (and even that not necessarily), but does not apply to the eyebrows, if it did, then anything of many things mentioned in the lecture of a hairstyle or makeup or even piercing the ears would be haram.
Scholars understand that doing these things is of changing God’s creation and therefore haram, but you can also understand it in the sense that those who do it with the intention of changing Allah’s creation are cursed.
And to be completely honest, I don’t even see the explanation that it is haram for the single lady because she could deceive a suitor to be really plausible, especially in our days where it has become a normal thing and almost everybody does it. Because.. it would be one of 2 cases, either the brows would be perfectly and obviously defined that nobody would even think that they’re natural, or the woman could only remove a couple hairs just to make her brows look a little bit nicer, in which case there is room for deception, but her brows are going to look similar to their original shape anyway and aren’t really going to make her look different, in that case as well, you could say that removing a few hairs is worse than removing many hairs and that doesn’t make sense either, not to mention that in both cases, the woman does not have to deceive anybody and can tell the man, be warned, this is not what my natural eyebrows look like. Besides, a single woman would want to beautify herself for herself and her family members as well, it doesn’t have to be for other men.
Just wanted to add my own thoughts to this platform. I think this issue is going to continue to be a matter of confusion. 😅
i feel the same... im single and my eyebrows are broad and sparse. its very not good looking. i go back and forth between plucking just a little and growing full. i have no idea what to do. i keep making dua for hidaayaat. my point is that we are allowed to correct deformities. my eyebrows are definitely not normal looking. but i still dont know. i fear the curse of Allaah.
@@homeschoolislaamiyyah2967 yeah, I know exactly what you mean. May Allah guide us to the truth.
Ameen. Were you able to find an answer to this question or has still remained a confusion? I ask because I am going through something similar. One issue I had is I am a male, and although this hadith refers to females, I’ve heard the same thing applied to male as forbidding to pluck their eyebrows. However, I am not sure what is permissible for the man in this field. I wish this was addressed in the video. I also have many unanswered questions
I think better to stick with the safer side as the Shaykh said.
What if I wanna beautify myself so I’m not so insecure. Im not married but I’m not trying to fix my eyebrows for other people to look at me. I’m just really REALLY insecure and feel ugly because of it. I hope he responds(probably won’t)😞
(17:00-23:00) he gave the answer and then at the end he said ONLY for married women???
“So I’m not insecure”. So you are doing it in front of other men in order to feel more beautiful. Where is this exception mention? Either it is totally impermissible or it is the plucking which is impermissible and not the shaving, or it is for other than the husband. Those are the three main views here. none of that applies to what you’re saying
Dear if it makes you measurable you can take out to a reasonable degree. Being miserable and living with waswasa is a sin too. So please be happy.
You shpuld find balance. If you need to look clean nad tidy taking out some excessive hair will not make you sinner. You will just look cleaner and Allah lices cleannes and tidiness. There is fifference between shaping eye brows to look sexy and attractivr and to look clean. It concerns both men and women. Pleasr be logical. Allah gave us brain to use.
MashaAllah ❤️❤️..
Sheikh. ...How to email you?
Is microblading eyebrows also part of this category of permanent change in shakal? Kindly throw some light on this as well.
Microblading is a form of tattooing
Micro blading doesn’t last that long as a tattoo because of the fact that it doesn’t go that deep into the skin I guess, however there is still ink that is tattooed into the skin. Any form of ink tattooed into the skin is considered haram in Islam. Hope that answers your question:)
@@zd2686 Jazakumallah. Confusion cleared.
I was searching for ruling of microblading among the comments, I made quick searched about it before I made it done, they said it is not like tattoo it is halal, ok. But now I searched again they just gave quick ruling it is like tattoo, what will I do? I have made it done and my husband loved it, I really like it as well :(
What about men shaykh about unibrow prob. Plz reply
Does the narration mention men?
Is plucking the eyebrow directly linked with beautification? I mean if it’s just tidying it up it’s not really beautification is it? Also the hadith of Aisha RA didn’t he say that she said a woman can remove any hair on her face that irritates her? I don’t know if i missed it but Aisha RA didn’t differentiate between married and unmarried women?
Amazing
What about men specially with joint eyebrow and trimming eyebrows for shaping them.
Same query here brother
Only for his wife or mens have exception in this case because the hadith mentions women and the scholar mentioned about prostitutes
Unibrow gang lol
36:32
@@Kamal_AL-Hinai I'm not married so i can't get rid of unibrow?
I would love a list of ALL the characteristic that were symbolic of that profession at the time, is there a hadith referring to the list? For one to reflect and assess how many of them and which ones exactly are now normalized and become “standard” social practice’s may Allah Azawajal forgive us.
how to ask a question?
Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu.
I am from philippines.
I have some questions about this topic, shaver or haircut.
if a muslim has a barbershop the people are go to his barbershop to cut their hairs each clients have requested to haircut against that what Prophet muhammad swt said about haircut.
What should i do if they are requesting to haircut against Allah probihited Allah will cures them.
Kazaa'a..
I do not know that there is a style of haircut that is prohibited by Allah. But assuming that is so then in Islam every individual is responsible for his or her actions in Islam. So if a customer requests a barber to give him or her a "prohibited" haircut, it is that individual's responsibility, not the barber's to dictate what haircut is allowed and what is not!
Asalamualikum.. Sheikh what about men. Can men shape their eyebrows?
did you find an answer to this umer? i too am a man and would like to shape my eyebrows but this hadith scares me
The rules are the same for men and women.
For academic integrity, you should indicate whether this narration from Aa'ishah (radiyallaahu anhaa) is authentic or not Shaykh especially as you studied hadeeth sciences and people are getting the impression it is strong enough to counter or restrict the prophetic hadeeth. Aboo Is'haaq's wife, the narrator from Aa'ishah is classed as unknown and the other route has break between the narrator and Aa'ishah.
On top of that, the narration mentions forehead or parts of it and does not explicit mention the eyebrows.
If this is the case, then you should not have mentioned it at all in opposition to the clear and authentic prophetic hadeeth. Allaah knows best.
PLEASE WHERE do we ask questions???
@Mohamed Ismail Thank you brother
As usual, Shaykh na, Yasir Qadhi, has brought scholarly research to bear on a subject that would otherwise have been taken at its literal meaning perhaps by all who do not have the benefit of the information the Shaykh has brought forth. But here’s, for me, the other interesting thing about Shaykh Yasir Qadhi’s Fatwahs: he may side with a particular opinion where there are different opinions on an issue, but he doesn’t condemn the other opinions provided they are also based on some valid arguments. He would just lay it all out for you. And he would show clearly why he sides with a particular opinion. Shaykh YQ doesn’t just give fatwas, he also encourages research and teaches critical thinking within the confines of the Qur’an and the Sunnah, which is important in all aspects of living.
May Allah SWA Continue to Help him purify his intention, increase him in beneficial knowledge, preserve him in good health so the Ummah may continue to benefit from his noble works, protect him and his family in this difficult world we are living in, and Grant him Al-Jannatul Firdaus and unite us all therein, ameen thumma ameen.
Can someone give a timestamp where he summarises his answer please?
35:00
jazakAllah Khair
Can unmarried women do shaping eyebrows?
@@kaycoonill3591 married women only he said.
@@otea5967 if single women do that
Will she be sinful?
So am I correct in thinking that a married woman CAN pluck her eyebrows??
Yes, many of the classical scholars permitted for married women to pluck, trim and neaten their eyebrows ‘slightly’ for their husbands, however, not 'excessively' trimming into a 'thin fine line'.
@@faysalahmed9157 thank you for the response. I'm still confused though, if a lot of classical scholar's deemed it ok to neaten the eyebrows then why do every mainstream scholar we come across say it's forbidden? I've not come across another scholar who's said it's ok?
How about removing unwanted facial and body hair apart eyebrows like arms legs upper lips side locks ,chest, thighs please note im not married and im a girl
Ustad, it is a HUGEE, problem for me over here, alot of people want dental veneers, the same hadith calls for LANAT on the people who file their teeth. As a dentist i have to file teeth , to put veneers. Ever since ive heard this hadith i dont do veneers unless someone is medically compromised, I DONT DO VENEERS on people who have OK smile, but want veneers solely for beautification. What should i do
@Hamza dear, im a cosmetic dentist, i respectfully disagree, the degree of shaving the tooth depends on the degree of malalignment, very rarely do we come across a case which requires no modification
@Hamza
GoSuckOnTheClitOf(Illat) as abu bakr would say
Furqan I would check with other ulema as well. Check specifically with Al-Azhar, Dar ul ifta. I'm sure you'll find that this is acceptable
That would be permanent.. like tattoos. And that is surely not allowed.
Not people - WOMEN. Stop applying this generally. Men are not mentioned. As a man, you are exempt from this ruling unless you can bring another authentic narration which clearly mentions that men are included.
If all scholars explained ahadith like this our ummah would have less issues and arguments
Sir can u give your views on a scholar named sir ghamdi?
@Hamza Khan true and they are not even supported by the companions or the hadith or the taba tabaeen
@Hamza Khan They are all new and modernistic views which didn't exist back at the time of the prophet or the 3 generations
if u want a wife that dosen’t do her eyebrows marry someone with eyebrows like that don’t marry a young lady than force her to change her ways for the ones that want to be ultra conservative
@00justSomeAccount00 compromise my friend
@00justSomeAccount00 I think changing for the sake of Allah is stronger motivation than for love of another person. I'll take your point though.
to be clear, I think what OP is saying is wise.
JzkAllahu khayran
Which country Yasin kadi is from?
pakistani living in usa
At least spell his name correctly
@@zeeshanmansoor5298 I think his forefathers were from India. His parents are settled in USA and he grew up and completed his studies in USA. By the way he got his degree in chemical engineering before going to Madinah university in Saudi Arabia. I hope I have. mentioned correctly.
My question is..why is this only for women eyebrow...why should we then clean our hair in private parts ..and why are men circumcised..that is all from allah????
Thank you shaykh Yasir Qadhi for showing the truth.
I'm sure *_extreme_* Salafis are punching the air these days because you're being different from them.
Literally 😂😂
@@PiewPiew306
Friend, I know that Madhabs can be strict in some cases and I have no problem in that and it's absolutely ok because great scholars of the 4 madhabs reached these results.
But salafis don't even recognize madhabs and when there are a difference of opinions in an issue, they fight everybody by saying that they have reached the ultimate and only truth and everyone who is different is astray and I can give u example on that from the tongues of salafi scholars.
This is an example of hundreds of examples u can find
czcams.com/video/QdMAtq35KOQ/video.html
Othman Al-Khamis
عثمان الخميس
Popular Salafi scholar say in this video that the scholars who said music is permissible are astray and they are wrong.
When it's famous whenever there's a خلاف معتبر/ sound difference of opinion, no scholar should attack the other side but he should say that this is his madhab and he doesn't attack others.
There are hundreds of these examples when the attack the other sides and I can give u proofs if u want.
تحيتي و دعواتي لك من سورية 👍👍
@@MohammedAlSharif2002 don't conflate using your brain for "liberalism and philosophy"
@@PiewPiew306 There's no such thing as Wahabi. Why are you mocking Shaykh Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab? I hope you know he was Hanbali in fiqh but he doesn't make Taqleed
@@PiewPiew306 What is important here is to understand is Sh YQ is not belittling any views here but pointing out that there are valid legal views both sides of the camps which should not be intolared. Sh YQ pointed out that there were classical early imams who of the Sunnah who looked at the objective of the hadith. Having researched on this matter myself, I would not say there is an ijmaa on this issue. Many contemporary scholars allow married women to shape their eyebrows for their husband to a certain extent with certain conditions.
12:00
I would like to know what is the daleel behind the explanation that the hadith it's actually referring to prostitutes. Without proof now every prohibition can be made halal because it's all based on interpretation of people. Also, I would like to know the authenticity and strenght of the narration from A'ishah and which came first. The one from A'ishah or the one from Ibn Mas'ud.
may allah reward you. I had similar questions in mind. the interpretation may have been from the rest of the narration. remember the narration was longer than just the plucking part. these are just some thoughts that come to mind. allah knows best but I dont know what the rest of the narration states
@@brother6862 no, the narration(hadith) does not say that prophet Muhammed cursed the prostitutes for making deception by plucking eyebrows. It only says he cursed women(general) for plucking eyebrows, tattooing etc. The idea that it must have referred to prostitutes doing this is the later interpretation of some Muslim scholars
Nope this is not about “literalism” the prophet saw commanded to stay away from the doubtful matters. And if he here is an opinion which is doubtful stay away from it.
n-Nu`man ibn Bashir (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated: I heard the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) say:
“The halal (lawful) is clear and the haram (prohibited) is clear, and between them are unclear matters that are unknown to most people.
Whoever is wary of these unclear matters, has absolved his religion and honor. And whoever indulges in them, has indulged in the haram (prohibited).
It is like a shepherd who herds his sheep too close to a preserved sanctuary, and they will eventually graze in it.
Every king has a sanctuary, and sanctuary of Allah is what He has made haram (prohibited).
There lies within the body a piece of flesh. If it is sound, the whole body is sound; and if it is corrupted, the whole body is corrupted. Verily, this piece is the heart.” (Bukhari and Muslim
make a video on music
Yea I sent an email asking for an extensive analysis on it. Inshallah he replies
Music is obviously very haraam. Why make a video
@@kulfilover001 what is your proof?
@@Andalusian_ I apologize I guess it is not “obvious” to everyone. You can find a good explanation here czcams.com/video/-3GMg7J9ZXU/video.html
Completely overlooked that these opinions were under the norm of niqaab in those days. Now proper niqaab and sitaar is a rarity, and tabaruuj is a norm. This sort of fiqh is always one eyed and missed a lot of the context we live in, just to appease the audience looking for easier fatawa. Its not valid if you don't have niqaab and walk about in the public where men will stare at how you've beautified yourself
As a layperson, I will neither allow nor disallow something just because a scholar did. I'd only do so if I understood the scholar's reasoning behind their fatwa and agreed with it. For instance, I do not understand the rationale behind allowing women to pluck their eyebrows "if their husband agrees", because this is not based on any evidence from the Qur'an or hadiths. I'm saying this as a woman.
I, as a nonreligious person, what do you think about the rule Islam that men can marry Christian and Jewish women but women can't?
@@user-wl7zi6pc3j I don't care about women not having that 'right' because I see it as a hindrance rather than a help to marry a Christian or Jewish person. People inherit their surname and identity mainly from their father, this is true around the world including the west, so I understand why the Qur'an commanded it.
@@pombear127 so, what? Because people inherit fathers' surname, and because the Muslim child will inherit his/her non-Muslim father's surname; so that's the problem? Weird.
@@user-wl7zi6pc3j Surname and identity.
@@pombear127 still don't understand. Due to your surname, people who don't know you personally would assume that since your father is a non-Muslim, you must also be a non-Muslim. So what? Who cares what other people think. There are many people with Muslim names like Ahmed, Fatma who are not Muslim(for example, because they left Islam) but don't change their name. There are many Christians who convert to Islam but don't change their name. I think that's not a good argument.
I don't understand why this is even a debate. When Aisha (r.) allowed it, finish - end of debate. She is the wife of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and our mother. Who better to understand the words of the Messenger of Allah ?
But you forgot that the one who said it is LAANAH is the messenger of Allahu and there where no exceptions where given to this by HIM.
So you should start with what Messenger of Allah said than his Wife.
Ibnu MasUd understood it as clear as it said by The Messenger (S.A.W) and followed it without an exception.
@@MrKarungo as Imam Ali (as) said to the Khawarij: "your words are true, but you're using them incorrectly"
Teaching people that the average Muslim can understand everything they need to know about a specific topic, from one recorded narration, is incorrect, and arrogant. This is why ulema spend decades learning the texts and methods, before they can make rulings. If it was so easy, why even take the time to learn? May Allah protect this ummah from such misguidance.
Because Ibn Masu'd is a big deal, and you can't just ignore what he said. That's not how the sciences of hadith and fiqh work, and yes it is a science. It must be approached with a certain methodology
CORRECTION: I did not rule anything, I was trying to make @MezBricks understand that he can't just say that there is no need for debate because the wife of prophet allowed it to someone.
But also Ibnu MasUd followed what prophet said without exception. So debate has to be there and do not make your understanding only to be correct one.
@@MrKarungo @Mohamed Ndayishimiye yes but you implied that others somehow didn't follow it or followed it with exceptions.
You also said how the Prophet said it with NO exceptions, when that's not necessarily how fiqh works. What if there are other pieces of information which provide context to the hadith? What if there are other clear narrations from the Prophet which would lead an alim to understand it differently? Would this alim be in error if he was also using evidence from Rasulallah (s)? No, he wouldn't be.
If you were just trying to say that we should be mindful because ibn Masud is extremely knowledgeable, as well as Aisha, then that's probably what you should have said, right brother?
JazakAllah khair
Just research, really
What about single ladies that want to shave eyebrows "not pluck"
Thin plucked eyebrows are hideously ugly. People now make fun of the 80s style of very thin plucked eyebrows, garish eye shadow, etc. What is trendy now will be seen as ugly in a few years.
Yasir qadhi, the greatest public sheikh in the west
I agree, look into shabir ally. Him and YQ are my favourite
Weird thing is , while what YQ did was to just introduce the another opinion that seems to be forgotten, yet the people in the comment section are so happy about it. May be because now they can go to parlour tomorrow and start plucking their eyebrows. According to one group of scholars this is not sinful, but when you always try to find out softer opinions in the field fiqh then it is really alarming. Keep on doing this and you will find yourself caring all about this world and nothing about hereafter. That is why I have seen scholars who dont even want to quote the other opinion, due to the tendency of the people to use that as an excuse to not staying in safer side. Then you end up dressing according to school A, praying according to school B, beautifying according to school C, think according to school D. A mashup of softer and unpopular opinions. So, please, before adopting any opinion, ask yourself why you are adpoting it, whats your priority this world or the hereafter.
Epic findings bro. 👍
The Prophet (s) said this is a deen of ease. No one should be faulted for following a respectable opinion, on any matter of fiqh, especially if it brings them ease. Anyone can be strict with fiqhi rulings but it doesn't mean that this is the correct, Islamic, way.
@@hassanabdaladl Yeah but talfiq really cannot be done if you're only trying to make things easier on yourself. Your intentions have to be good.
@@HilyahAsSalaf if your intention is trying to understand the valid opinions on a matter, because you want to please Allah, then this should be commendable. If one of the opinions would be easier upon you, then you should take it. If you end up blending up rulings from different schools, about one particular matter, then the ruling ends up outside of all of the schools, and this would be impermissible. If you're searching out extremely minority opinions to do something which you know inside is wrong, then this is wrong, as actions are judged by their intention.
@@hassanabdaladl I see what you're saying now, makes sense. JazakAllah khair for the comments 👍
Why can’t a single woman do it to beautify herself for herself if she doesn’t have a husband?
I think it's because unnecessary exposure of beauty that should be restricted to her husband only. However, if the eyebrows look deformed and defected then it is permissible for even non-married women to turn them into a more normal size according to many scholars.
becoz , single lady can attract men becoz of her beautification but anyways face cover is fard on all muslim women
@@bullseye9723
Face cover is not farz for women in Islam lol. Some women chooses to do it witch is fine however not doing it doesn’t make your sinful. The description of hijab and modesty is very clear in the Quran and it doesn’t include the face, hands and feet:)
@@zd2686 nah bro, face cover is indeed fard ! there is consesus among scholar that if immodesty(fitna) increases faces cover is mandatory !! and about feet , Feet should be always covered as surah noor verse 31 is ver clear about it , feet can only be shown at the time of jihad
@@bullseye9723
Well where do you get that from?
If you read the verses it will be clear to you that the face isn’t included and it is a matter of fact that it doesn’t say that you can’t show your feet. It says quote on quote _”Let them not stomp their feet, drawing attention to their hidden adornments.”_
Now go a check the definition of what stomping means. Bruh it definitely doesn’t mean to show. And by the way this is not something scholars say, this is what the Quran says. The Quran has the highest authority in Islam and in this matter it is really clear what it says in regards to modesty. Therefor we can conclude that face covering isn’t farz:)
So eyebrow plucking is allowed for married women but not single girls - does Islam really discriminate women based on their marital status? Or is that our culture 🤔
Yasir Qadhi has the potential to bring down the salafiyyah
That means single women can not do it?
no, the reason is only for beautification for her husband only
@@bullseye9723 Then it sinful?
@@kaycoonill3591 yes according to hadith yes it is
@@bullseye9723 ohh can you tell about makeup?
@@kaycoonill3591 look up tabarruj. Even doing this as a married woman is highly questionable. The exception is not given in the narration.
After reading the life of shah waliullah dehlewi (rh) it's ironic that he changed his rigid views and was more open minded with regards to strict hanafi rules AFTER studying under scholars in hijaz. I wonder what his reaction would be if he visited the more rigid school in Saudi! How the tables have turned!
Why do you find Hanafis strict? Do you mean them all or specific people?
And can you explain what kind of rules you are talking about, I am very curious:)
@@zd2686 I'm talking about hanafi scholars back in the Indian subcontinent where I studied. Very rigid.
@@zak2509
Okay I get it now. However I don’t hope you think that all Hanafis are like those that you came across. Can you give an example of what they believe that you find extreme? I would like to know since I am Hanafi lol.
@@zd2686 I'm a hanafi myself and studied theology in this. Some extreme views were magnified by the public like if a person prays without covering his head, the prayer, he is frowned upon even considered invalid!
@@zak2509
Wow really. I didn’t know that some hanafis actually believed in something like that. This is the first time that I actually hear about this which might be because I am not from that region.
What about men?
not allowed
why not. the hadith doesn’t mention men
i’m curious too btw
@@aaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh because imitating women is haram
@@orakbabama1.0 Who said trimming your eyebrows are for women? It's like taking a haircut. Is it for man or for woman? Especially today, lots of men trim their eyebrows to groom them and keep them nice and clean
He is talking to much, but i like him.
That is so impolite. And not true.
As a Muslim, I find these issues very funny and ridiculously illogical. This is why even the so-called 'Sahih Hadith' falls under scrutiny.
@muftitariqmasood