Shirk according to the Qur'an.
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 02. 2023
- In this presentation I discuss the topic of Shirk and what it truly means according to the Qur'an. The Qur'an is filled with Verses warning against Shirk and how we must never associate anyone or anything with Allah.
All the things you are saying were recently going through my mind I’m SO GLAD you are speaking on this thank you!!
Thank you bro. Allah is the only source of guidance my friend!
Coming up to a year when I first became shocked watching this and said enough is enough. And it still took me a few attempts to get through it all.
Every time something happens when I listen to this. I think this hurts the Shayaateen amongst the Jinn and Ins the most.
Allah bless you Br Negeto. 🙏
This is life changing.
Lonely at times.
But worth it.
Al Hamdu li Allah, Rabb Al-Aalameen.
Our only Rabb.
The Praise goes to Him (swt).
Muhammad praised Him.
The most? Frequently?
Is that what Muhammad means?
Allah hu alam.
Thank you my brother and may Allah bless you as well. Indeed, this is probably the most important topic and we must strive against the Shaytan and our nafs to make sure we NEVER fall into shirk! Audhubillaah!
I remember watching Yasir Qadis "Seerah" series and stopped watching after the first episode! You know why? He claims (and most Muslims) that the name 'Muhammad' means: the praised one. And he made a comment saying:
"Every single human being, whether directly or indirectively is praising Muhammad"
Yeah, okay mate! So, show me where the Qur'an says this!! You see how they equate others with Allah and claim that they love Allah?
The word 'Muhammad' comes from the word HAMD which means praise or to praise. And the prefix 'MU' makes it into someone who praises! Just like the word Islam - the 'MU' prefix makes it MU-slim which is someone who submits! The word 'safar' means to travel. So, the 'MU' prefix makes it MU-safir - a traveller!
Hope this makes sense?
Peace 😊
@@negeto2460 This helps massively. I'm screenshotting this and sharing it. Its so plain to see if anyone pauses and thinks. SubhanAllah. Very clear. Most appreciated once again brother.
Jazakum Allahu khayr brother. 6:121 would have been great to add to your presentation because it allows us to get a deeper understanding of what shirk actually is. May Allah reward you for all your great work.
Thank you for your comments Shaima. Yes, brother Shukri from my channel reminded me of verse 6:121 and i regret not including it in the presentation. However, I did mention that the Qur'an has many verses regarding this subject and that we should do our own homework. May Allah bless you.
Great video. I'm glad thatmore people are reasoning. I am a recent revert to Islam. The quran has, is and will forever be a mind altering, profound revelation to me. I began reading it and trying to practice what was said in it. Then i was introduced to the hadiths and everything that came with it. It doesn't take long to realize that it DEFINITELY isn't revelation, amd amongst other nonsensical things, some of these hadiths disrespect and mock our prophet and prophets before him. Ridiculous. They elevate and give this unreal level to the sahaba, scholars, schools of thought, hadith etc. How hard is it to understand that Allah's book is sufficient?! I really can't understand the level of brainwashing that alot of our Muslim families have been subjected to. Has the quran just become something that is just to be rattled off during taraweeh?
The verse that says in 25.30 that states
"The Messenger will say, "My Lord, This Qur'an was abandoned by my people," , rings very true to me. Because i see people today abandoning the quran for every other thing available.
Thank you for this channel brother.
Well said my brother in Islam. Unfortunately, this Qur'an has reached us together with a whole lot of baggage (hadith, sunnah, maddhab, etc). I myself used to be a fanatic Salafi where the Hadith rules over all (even the Qur'an) and it didn't take me long before I realised the lies and the fabrications of the Traditional muslims. Stay strong my brother and may Allah keep us on the Straight Path (Siraatal Mustaqeem).
Thanks for creating this content. Don't be discouraged by the small audience, the garden is the inheritance of the few high quality men and women. Many of the people you meet in your life, in fact probably the vast majority, will be assigned to the Gehenna Quranically, they do not reason, they only guess.
Thank you for your positive comments brother Ilyas. My aim is not to try convincing the majority because they (akthara - majority) don't truly believe as stated in the Qur'an. My aim is to share my 2 cents worth with the few people who have woken up! May Allah guide us and increase us in knowledge.
@@negeto2460 May Allah reward you brother for your effort.
@@kamolegamberdiev7793 thank you my brother and may Allah guide and keep us all on the straight path!
Thanks again for being so clear. Allah bless you and your family for the good work you do
Thank you again for your lovely comments sister Fatima. I pray that Allah blesses you as well and increases us all in knowledge & wisdom.
Hazakal Allah Brother
May Allah Bless and protect you
This is Pure Quran and pure Islam.
JazakAllah
Thank you brother Mohamad. May Allah bless you to!
Asslamoalikum brother.
You are making an amazing effort.
A humble request brother.
Our family listens to your lectures.
If you consider a collar mic , it can make a huge difference.
Lots of love and support from Pakistan.
Keep teaching us the Word of Allah SWT
Most men won't believe. Most men won't believe without adding partners. Keep up the good work brother, their will be people coming who will benefit from your lectures, as do I and my family.
Thank you for your comments brother Mohammed. As you said: "most men won't believe" and the Qur'an testifies to this fact! My aim is to reach out to the small numbers of people who have woken up inshaAllah.
Peace
Good job . Totally agree with that you say. Allah protects you
Brother salamualaikum. I like your videos. I think your presentation can be much better and easy to understand for those who are not so into quraan. I would like to sugeest few points below. If you think it is acceptable, so please make your next video's keeping following in your mind.
1. Please ensure that tv screen is not against light reflection. It is difficult to take a note of aya referred in the topics.
Secondly, please read entire aya slowly and the explain .
Thirdly please try not to block tv screen while changing the screen.
Your observations are truly remarkable. I hope inshaAllah in future lots of people will subscribe your channel and will benefit from your videos. May Allah guide us. Aameen
Thank you for your comments and may Allah bless you brother Nazim. Unfortunately, I do not have very good presentation skills but any type of advice or feedback is welcomed. And I'm surely looking at ways to improve on myself and will try to do better in the future Insha'Allah. Thanks again 🙂
Mashallah brother Negeto. Fear Allah and expose those keeping the Muslim people in status quo of dual source revelations.
My doubts about the Tashahhud are finally clarified. Once again. My eternal gratitude. I hope you don't mind. I'm gonna replicate your video from the Tashahhud bit and place it on one of our CZcams Channels insha'Allah.
Not a problem at all my brother. In fact, I'm even happy to share all my powerpoint slides with anyone who seeks the truth! May Allah bless you and your family.
Thankyou brother
Alhamdulillahi…
May Allah bless you and your family…….
From Bangladesh…
Thank you brither Samir. May Allah bless you as well 🙂
جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا
Wa iyyaakum my brother 😊
Masha E'llah brother Nice presentation you matter how they said but we need the Truth
Thank you brother and may Allah bless you.
@@negeto2460 my respect to you sheikh
SubhanAllah
Exactly!
Assalam alaiykum brother
Alhamdulillah, great presentation. I benefit a lot from this .Could you show us the best way to do salaah without doing any shirk.
Salaam brother,
Thank you for your comments brother. I recommend you watch my video regarding Salat. I explain in there that no matter what you believe Salat is, as long as we all follow the do's and dont's as outlined in the Qur'an. I suggest that you re-evaluate your current Salat and make it inline with the Verses of Allah. A good start would be to abandon this so-called Tashahhud which has no support from the Qur'an whatsoever!
Peace
Nice bro 🥰
Salam. Could you do a video on fasting
Salaam sister. I'm not planning on doing one at this stage but maybe in the near future 🙂
medina constitution and hudaibiyah treaty is from prophet muhammad but not secondary source right?
what verse tell us about these 2 important official document?
Salam bro,
Thank you for your comments and may Allah increase us in understand and wisdom.
Please refer to the following Verse:
"" That was a nation which has passed on. It will have [the consequence of] what it earned, and you will have what you have earned. And YOU WILL NOT BE ASKED ABOUT WHAT THEY USED TO DO."" {2:134}
The Verses before this one make mention of Ibrahim, Ishaq, Ismael, and Yaqub ( peace be upon them). And Allah says that YOU won't be questioned about what they did! Question for you my friend:
"Is Allah going to ask YOU or ME about the so-called Medina constitution, the hudaibiyah treaty, or any of the wars that happened at THAT TIME???"
No doubt, they may of been important at that time. The prophet and his followers formed a constitution based on what Allah revealed to him (Qur'an) and also based on justice, fairness, and equity. If you wanted to research or study into these purely out of curiousity or for academic reasons, then no problem. But these are not essential for our Deen or our salvation my brother.
Peace
Nej
Brother, Salam, I think a video on the Euphrates River should be done as a Great Sign has been revealed. People are recording monstrous screaming coming from it. I think that is where the people of Pharoah were drowned. In Sura Zukhruf, A’LLah says he left them as an example for the akhira. A’LLah knows best.
Allah knows best akhi
@@negeto2460’LLah knows best. Look into it, Brother. it is still something to take note of. It’s a really strange happening.
Traditionalists are invoking prophet…scary 😳
That's exactly what they're doing brother Nedim! Just look at the arabic and you can see it. May Allah keep us far away from ascribing partners to Him!
Peace
Very good video, is it possible to get into personal contact from you to learn from you?
Thank you brother Ali. You can email me and I'm happy to share these powerpoint slides with you. My email is:
nejdet_m@hotmail.com
Peace
Is there forgiveness if there is repentance for shirik?
My understanding is that the doors of 'repentance' is open until your death. We must look at the entirety of the Qur'an and then draw our conclusions.
Thank you. May Allah bless you
Very good. One other thing. Stop saying ya for Allah. That is very disrespectful to Allah. Never mentioned in Quran. All the best to you
Thank you for your comments. I was simply quoting the hadith in which starts with the supplication: "Ya Allah". Personally, I always supplicate with "Ya Rabbi".
Peace 🙂
Aallah ka Quraan bagiar samjhe padhna aur amal suni sunayee baate firko ki kitaboo per kerna ye shirke azeem hai😊
Not sure what you mean? English please 😊
"The majority of those who believe in Allah do not do so without committing shirk." 12:106
This translation is misleading
Where did you get it from?
@@RR-vg5hg It just choice of words to the nearest translation. What´s the misleading?
[12:106] And (Wa) most of them (Ak'tharu-hum) do not (Maa) believe (Yu'minu) in GOD (Billahi)
except (illa) while (Wa) they (Hum) are polytheists (idolaters) (Mush'rikuun).
@@shah555 your translation “the majority of those who believe in Allah” implies its talking about the Muslims, but it’s not, it’s referring to mushriks who believe in Allah yet associate partners with Him.
Allah knows best.
@@shah555 plus you are not supposed to just randomly translate the Quran with your “choice of words”
@@RR-vg5hg You cannot find a 100% correct translation. There is none. Different translators have different choice of words but the meaning is the same. For example you can use the word " help " while someone else uses the word " assist ". It doesn't change the meaning. Misleading would be when you change the meaning of translation.
Therefore the words " most of them " and "majority " have the same meaning.
You simply make the verse complicated in your understanding when it is actually very clear to what it said.
The verse is precisely talking about those who believe in Allah, these include muslim, christian and anyone who believes in God. It just you don´t want to believe that muslim can be mushriks when in reality most are. It is just that the majority of muslim don't realise it.
Isn´t the Christian population much greater than muslim population? Christian were once in the straight path. If Satan can mislead the Christian from the straight path and gone astray, do you think muslims are immune from Satan's deception?
No, not all monotheists are true Muslims, nor are all Muslims Muslim.This is not a puzzle I assure you. To explain, we need to distinguish between the tag assigned to people saying "Muslim", and the content of the heart of a person which defines him as being a true Muslim or not. A monotheist is simply someone who believes that God is One. However, the majority of those who believe in the One God are also committing shirk - verse 12:106. Anyone who is committing shirk by definition is not a genuine Muslim. A genuine Muslim is someone who not only believes that God is One, but also submits to God alone in every sense of the word. A person committing shirk is not submitting to God alone, but has other idols whom he allows to share some of God's exclusive rights.
Now let me show you another Quranic verse with some very significant words:
Abraham was neither a Jew, nor a Christian; but he was a 'hanifan' (monotheist) Muslim (Submitter) and was not one of the mushrikeen. 3:67
The question that must be raised here is:
If being a monotheist means that a person is also a Muslim, or that he is not committing shirk, then why did God add the words "Muslim. He was not one of the mushrikeen" after the word "montheist"?
Surely by saying "monotheist" this would have included being a Muslim who does not commit shirk? Or does it? The answer is that being a monotheist is no guarantee that a person is a genuine Muslim, nor that a person
You see millions of muslims kissing the black stone and revere it. Some also think that the stone will erase their sins.
The Quran says:
O you who believe, intoxicants, gambling, stone altars and arrows of chance are afflictions that are the work of the devil; you shall stay away from him so that you may succeed. 5:90
All throughout the Quran God commands believers to stay away from stone idols and altars, for they have no power to benefit or harm any one. The story of Abraham and how he destroyed the stone idols of his people is a clear reminder. However, during the visit to the Kaaba, at one of its corners, Muslims from all over the world push and shove their way ferociously to get to what is called the 'Black Stone' in order to touch it and kiss it. In addition, when they are doing 'tawaf' (going around) the Kaaba, every time they pass the Black Stone they say Allah Akbar! If saying Allah Akbar to a stone is not an act of idolatry, what is? What is quite extraordinary is that if you were to ask any of them: why are you kissing this stone? They would say:
Because the Prophet kissed it! If you then ask why did he kiss it? You will not get any rational answer! However, could there be a rational answer as to why any believer should kiss and cherish a stone that can neither harm nor benefit any one? Undoubtedly, they would not be pushing and shoving to touch that stone unless they thought that there is some blessing in doing so!
In addition, could a genuine Prophet of God ever disregard God's instructions and instead kiss a stone in a flagrant act of idolatry? This idolatrous ritual has no reference or authorisation in the Quran whatsoever, but originates from a number of fabricated hadith which state that the Black Stone had descended from Heaven since the time of Abraham and is thus sacred! The hadith further states that the Prophet used to kiss it! When one reads these hadith and then sees the millions believing it and committing such gross acts of idolatry by idolising such a stone, one cannot help wonder, have these people not read the Quran? The Quran informs us that Abraham destroyed all the stone idols that his people were worshipping and said:
Do you worship beside God what does not benefit you in any way nor harm you? 21:66
The ones who kiss and idolise the Black Stone will readily say: We do not worship the stone, we only kiss it because the Prophet kissed it, so it must be holy/sacred! This reply exposes their idolatry. The fact that they regard a piece of stone sacred in any way, is in itself, an act of idolatry, if they only knew. They prefer to believe a dubious hadith which is in total violation of the Quran, rather than believe God when God declares that no stone can ever harm or benefit the human being.
HANIFAN MUSLIMAN WORSHIP AL RAHMAN in QURANIC VERSES of KALAM ALLAH KITABULLAH and SUNNATULLAH of THE MILLAT IBRAHIM'S HANIFS RELIGION AL HANIFIYYAH AL FITRA TAWHID of MILLA of ALLAH NATURAL LAWS
shirk is also emotional
Not sure what you mean by emotional?
As a muslim can i have a friend thats the oppisite gender
May I ask what is the point of asking this question? Does it even relate to the topic of Shirk?
What are you doing and others, such as, Al Moses PhD, Qur'anic Islam, Qur'an Study... is great.
But I think, as you all possess waste knowledge, especially linguistic one, the time is due, to start explaining Qur'an key terms, without engaiging too much in traditional "ilm" and "ulema" in trying to expose wrong beliefs and "doctrines". For every normal person it is enough to download a hadith collection application and start reading too see how disgusting they are.
So please try to join your efforts with people mentioned above and start doing valuable definitions of the key terms by posing two questions WHAT (is SHIRK)? and WHY (SHIRK is unforgivable sin)?
Please, if you can, try to answer these WHAT and WHY, in cooperation with similar people mentioned above.
God bless you and your family
Thank you for your comments brother. This is pretty much my 2 cents worth and I often recommend my viewers to do their own research. There are many great channels as well out there like the ones you mentioned (Al Moses PhD, Qur'anic Islam, etc).
May Allah guide us all and increase us in knowledge!
Peace
You sound like a fanatical Quranist. That makes you an enemy of 90 % of Muslims.
@@joal9235 people can call me what they want. Even the prophets of God had enemies - so what?
الله لا تقبل التوبة كفر بعد الإيمان
يا هارون يحيى
Allah will vanish the the scientific research you have done.
If you really want to understand what "haneefan... monotheist" means and also what the Quran says about SHIRK, then read/ponder/think/reflect on this verse:
6:121 And (do) not eat of that, not has been mentioned (the) name (of) Allah on it, and indeed, it (is) *grave disobedience.* And indeed, the devils *inspire* to their friends so that they dispute with you, and *if you obey them, indeed, you (would) be the polytheists.* (mushreeks)
It is all about OBEDIENCE to Allah and the one and only way to obey what Allah says is by obeying the Quran Alone!
If you obey what people say about Allah... no matter how long his beard or robe is... or, how he covers his head... in short "IF YOU OBEY what PEOPLE SAY" then that is pure, unadulterated SHIRK!
Also, Ibrahim was a "haneefan... not of the mushreeks," right?
Ask yourself, did Ibrahim obey/listen to any other human say anything about God?
Once you understand this concept, the following verse becomes more enlightening:
17:46 And We have placed over their hearts coverings, lest they understand it, and in their ears deafness. And when you mention your Lord in the *Quran Alone,* they turn on their backs (in) aversion.
Another interesting word to try and understand in 6:121 is the part where it says, _"the Shaytan inspire their awliyah"_
The word "inspire" is from the Arabic root "WAHI" ... which means even the Devil can "WAHI" you!
Was the Quran "sent down" or "inspired?"
This is another interesting topic for you to look into.
salam.
Salaam my brother is Islam,
May Allah bless you and reward you for your thought provoking comments!
Thank you for reminding about verse 6:121 and I regret not including it in the presentation. Indeed, the devils do inspire their friends and obeying them means SHIRK!! SubhanAllah 😟
Verse 17:46 is also a beautiful verse that reads:
"itha thakarta rabbaka feelqur-ani wahdahu" - And when you make mention of your Lord IN THE QUR'AN ALONE. it does NOT say your Lord alone - it LITERALLY says: "feel-qur'ani wahdahu". Unfortunately, most people do not reason.
Finally, you asked:" was the Quran "sent down" or "inspired?". Excellent question and I answer this in my video called "What was revealed to prophet Muhammad?". The short answer is BOTH my brother, and this can be shown in the following verse:
Alif, Lām, Rā. These are the verses of the clear Book. Indeed, We have SENT IT DOWN (anzalnahu) as an Arabic Qur’ān that you might understand. We relate to you, [O Muḥammad], the best of stories in what We have REVEALED (awhayna) to you of this Qur’ān although you were, before it, among the unaware. {12:1-3}
The arabic word 'anzalnahu' comes from the root: Noon Zay Lam - which means to send down, decend, etc. And the word 'awhayna' comes from the root: Waw Ha Ya - which means to inspire, reveal, etc.
Therefore, this leaves no room whatsoever that Allah 'sent down' or 'inspired' to prophet Muhammad (a.s) anything other than the Qur'an! The traditional so-called sunnah (secondary wahi) has no legs to stand on and I prove this without a doubt in that video. Please watch it and let me know your thoughts.
Take care brother Shukri and God bless!
Nej
@@negeto2460 salam bro Negeto... was the Quran "sent down" or "inspired/revealed?"
Regarding 12:3, especially the part where it says, _"We have REVEALED (awhayna) to you _*_OF THIS QURAN_*_ ..."_
Can you feel the difference between _"inspired/revealed OF THIS QURAN"_ and "the Quran was sent down?"
If you were to take this in context of "the best stories" ... then... the best stories are revealed/inspired to you through the Quran that was sent down to you!
Did I manage to explain that to you?
Take time to run this through... inshaallah it will come to you.
@@shukriyusof2104 wa alaykum salam brother Shukri. I understand what you are saying but I think the best way to understand this is to refer to Verse 42:51. It reads:
""And it is not for any human being that Allāh should speak to him (yakallimahullaahu) except by revelation (wahyan) or from behind a partition (hijaabin) or that He sends a messenger (yarsila rasoolan) [i.e., angel] to reveal, by His permission, what He wills. Indeed, He is Most High and Wise."" {42:51}
This verse is telling us that Allah ONLY SPEAKS (verbal communication) to human beings in 3 forms/ways: wayhan, behind a veil, or He sends a Messenger. And I show my veiwers in my video called "What was revealed to prophet Muhammad?" that Allah SPOKE (verbally) to prophet Muhammad (a.s) in 2 ways / forms. That is, via Wahyan AND through a Messenger (Gibreel bringing it down). And I quote numerous Verses proving this fact. However, I cannot find any evidence that Allah spoke to Muhammad (a.s) from behind a veil. Therefore, the Qur'an was delivered to prophet Muhammad (a.s) in 2 different forms or ways! Not only was it INSPIRED (wayhan) to him but it was also SENT DOWN (nazzala) to him!
Here's an analogy to get you thinking:
Your boss (at work) can SPEAK (verbal communication) to you in PERSON, OR via TELEPHONE (electronically), OR he can send you a RECORDED VIDEO. All 3 of these are different forms of Verbal communication!
Another thing to ponder over is that Allah not only SPOKE (verbal communication) to Muhammad (a.s) but He also communicated (non-verbally) to him in the form of dreams (manaami) and visions (arru'ya). This is important because it answers so many questions about whether the prophet received any revelations outside of the Qur'an.
Please refer to that video and we can have further discussions from there if that's cool with you? May Allah bless you brother.
Peace 🙂
@@negeto2460 salam bro... if you don't mind it would be more practical to have this mini discussion here because all the points are in this thread.
Please reread 42:51 again especially the part where it says _"for any HUMAN"_
Do you think it is for all humans or just the so-called *"chosen few?"*
Whenever you read the Quran ALWAYS leave everything you think you know behind.
While it is true that the Quran was sent down to the last prophet but when it comes to inspiration/revelation even the _"bee"_ received inspiration/revelation. Also even the Satan can inspire/reveal thoughts to you.
Furthermore, inspirations/revelations in dreams aren't true. Please quote a verse from the Quran that supports the assumption that dreams come true in real life... exactly & precisely as you dreamed them?
peace.
@@shukriyusof2104 salaam again my brother. I totally agree when you said:
""Whenever you read the Quran ALWAYS leave everything you think you know behind"".
Unfortunately, it's sometimes very difficult to fully let go of the baggage that was drilled into us by the Traditional Shiekhs / Imams. But we are slowly waking up and seeing the TRUTH in the Qur'an!
The Qur'an tells us that Allah inspired/revealed (awha) to the bee (verse 16:68) and He also inspired/revealed (awhayna) the mother of Moses (verse 28:7). However, whenever the derived forms of that word 'WAHI' is used for prophet Muhammad, it's ALWAYS descibed in SINGULAR (pronoun) form, and it's NOTHING but the Qur'an that was inspired/revealed to him! Furthermore, Allah LITERALLY SPOKE to prophet Muhammad (a.s) through the Qur'an! There are too many verses to mention here but I cover all this in my other video on my channel.
Finally, I do NOT believe that dreams (manaami) or visions (arru'ya) are forms of inspirations/revelations. If that was the case, then millions of people worldwide would claim they're being inspired by Allah, which is absurd! Dreams and visions given by Allah are simply forms of non-verbal communication to whomsoever He wills. Simply put:
Dreams/visions = NON-VERBAL communication. Dreams can be true or NOT true. NOT Wahi.
Wahi = VERBAL communication. Allah literally speaks or gives Words to you.
As you said, even Shaytan can inspire/reveal things to you! Scary 😧
I hope this makes sense akhi?
Following Prophet Muhammad (SAW) doesn't mean we worship him (nauzubillah), in fact Allah order us in the Qur'an to follow prophet (SAW) and invoke Allah's blessings on him.
The Quran itself commands Muslims to follow the example of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
3:31, Allah says: "Say, [O Muhammad], 'If you should love Allah, then follow me, [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful.'"
*3:32* "Say: 'Obey Allah and obey the Messenger. ' If they turn away from this then know that Allah does not love those who refuse to obey Him and His Messenger.""
*4:59* "O ye who believe! Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you...."
*4:69* "And whoever obeys Allah and the Messenger - those will be with the ones upon whom Allah has bestowed favor of the prophets ..."
*24:54* "Say: Obey Allah and obey the Messenger, ... If you obey him, you shall be on the right guidance"
The Prophet Muhammad's actions and sayings, which are recorded in the Hadith, provide a detailed example of how to implement the teachings of the Quran in one's daily life.
*33:21* "In God's messenger you have indeed a good example for everyone who looks forward with hope to God and the Last Day ..."
Therefore, rejecting the Hadith is tantamount to rejecting the example of the Prophet Muhammad and, by extension, rejecting the Quran's command to follow his example.
*4:64* "And We did not send any messenger except to be obeyed by permission of Allāh. And if, when they wronged themselves, they had come to you, [O Muḥammad], and asked forgiveness of Allāh and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found Allāh Accepting of Repentance and Merciful."
*4:65* "But no! By your Lord, they will never be ˹true˺ believers until they accept you ˹O Prophet˺ as the judge in their disputes, and find no resistance within themselves against your decision and submit wholeheartedly."
*33:56* "Indeed, Allah showers His blessings upon the Prophet, and His angels pray for him. O believers! Invoke Allah’s blessings upon him, and salute him with worthy greetings of peace."
Zayd ibn Thabit reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “May Allah brighten the face of a person who hears a tradition from us and he memorizes it until he can convey it to others. Perhaps he will convey it to one who understands better than him, and perhaps one who conveys knowledge does not understand it himself.”
Source: *Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3660*
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
We find that many Companions recorded hadiths. For example, `Abdullah ibn `Amr was permitted and even encouraged by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) to write down Hadith. In addition, some 50 Companions and many followers are said to have possessed manuscripts (sahifah, Arabic plural suhuf), which was used as a term to designate compendia of Hadith that emerged during the century before the formation of the classical collections. The original manuscripts have been lost, but a very few copies have survived. An example is the manuscript of Hammam ibn Munabbih, who learned from Abu Hurairah and from him he wrote his manuscript which contains 138 hadiths. This manuscript is believed to have been written down around the middle of the first century after the Hijrah
Furthermore, the Hadith contains detailed explanations and interpretations of the Quranic teachings, which can help Muslims better understand and implement the Quran's guidance in their daily lives. Rejecting the Hadith means rejecting this valuable source of guidance and interpretation, which can lead to misunderstandings and misapplications of the Quranic teachings.
You will not be "Quranist" after reading this Insha'Allah
bit.ly/3ENMI44 Highly Recommended if you are sincere
videos for those who don't like reading
Reliability of hadith
czcams.com/video/dWwbHO5Owpc/video.html
why do we need hadith
czcams.com/video/GDSoZcG6W-Q/video.html
czcams.com/video/bB4cARWalY4/video.html
Salaam brother,
The real question you need to figure out for yourself is: "what does OBEYING and FOLLOWING the Messenger mean?" And this is the main focus of my videos. I am certainly familiar with all those Verses you quoted (3:31-32, 4:59, 4:69, 24:54, 33:21, 4:64-65, 33:56, etc) and they are either taken out of context or they're plucked out from the Qur'an while ignoring the totality of the text.
Verse 33:56 is probably the most misunderstood and abused verse from the Qur'an. I urge you to please take a look at verses 33:43, 9:99, and 9:103. In these verses, it says that Allah AND His angels do the SAME THING (yusallee) to the believers and the Messenger Muhammad (a.s) was commanded to do the SAME THING (Salawat, Sallee) to them as well. Does that mean that the prophet chanted the words:
- Allahumma salli ala Abu Bakr, Umar, etc??
or
- Salloo ala Uthman, Bilal, Aisha, etc??
Did the prophet do this in his Salat?? Did he greet himself (assalamu alayka ayyuhannabi) in his salat?? Did he then return his salaams back to himself?? Did he also send blessing to himself in his salat?? If you want to blindly believe this without refelecting upon the Qur'an, then what can I say?
Ask yourself sincerely what does 'obedience' and 'following' the Messenger really mean! Look at it from this percpective:
At the time of Muhammad (a.s), how did the people (jews, mushriks, christians) HEAR the Verses of Allah?? And in order for them to OBEY and FOLLOW the Verses of Allah, didn't they have to OBEY and FOLLOW the MESSENGER??
If OBEDIENCE to Allah was only ever possible or achievable THROUGH the Messenger, then OBEDIENCE to the Messenger means what?
Literally, the formula is this:
*Obey Allah = Obey the Messenger *
Verse 4:80 gives us this GOLDEN formula.
Once you 'see' this, you cannot unsee it my brother. Therefore, before you continue to go through your Imams and Shiekhs, please reflect / ponder / think about the Verses of Allah. Blindly following traditions will not get you far my brother.
Take care,
Nej
@@negeto2460 Wa Aleikum Salam
Your first point is that these verses have been plucked out and take without context but really you take sahih hadeeth out of context and pluck out 20 of them of 15 thousand sahih hadith in sahih Bukhari and Muslim to show how these hadith are nonsense while ignoring the totality of the text.
Meticulous preservation and transmission of hadiths by the early Muslim scholars, who developed a rigorous science of hadith criticism to ensure their authenticity.
Immense value and guidance provided by hadiths, which serve as a practical and detailed explanation of the
teachings of the Quran and the example of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
33:21 "Surely there was a good example for you in the Messenger of Allah, for all those who look forward to Allah and the Last Day and remember Allah much." talking to the believers since they look forward to Allah and last day.
You make the interpretation of this "GOLDEN formula" yourself as why would Allah need to say every time that obey Allah and obey messenger if they were the same thing or are you saying Allah say those extra words without any difference of meaning(Nauzubillah) and he could have said obey Allah or he could have said obey messenger.
4:59 "O ye who believe! Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you...."
no would you say "obey those charged with authority among you = Obey Allah" lets make a new golden rule shall we!.
some people at the time of prophet said the same thing that we will no accept your decision and only Allah's decision so Allah revealed in the Quran
4:64 "And We did not send any messenger except to be obeyed by permission of Allāh. And if, when they wronged themselves, they had come to you, [O Muḥammad], and asked forgiveness of Allāh and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found Allāh Accepting of Repentance and Merciful."
4:65 "But no! By your Lord, they will never be ˹true˺ believers until they accept you ˹O Prophet˺ as the judge in their disputes, and find no resistance within themselves against your decision and submit wholeheartedly."
And Allah knows best ofcourse.
@@reachedcertainty Salaam akhi,
Could you or your Shiekhs explain to me the following Verses:
"" If you do not, then beware of a war with Allah AND His Messenger! But if you repent, you may retain your principal-neither inflicting nor suffering harm. "" {2:279}
Question 1: Is this verse referring to 2 SEPERATE or INDEPENDANT wars? One from Allah and one from the Messenger?
"" And those with excuses among the bedouins came to be permitted [to remain], and they who had lied to Allāh AND His Messenger sat [at home]. There will strike those who disbelieved among them a painful punishment."" {9:90}
Question 2: is this Verse referring to 2 SEPERATE or INDEPENDANT lies? Did the people first lie to Allah and then went and lied to the Messenger? Or the other way round?
"" Indeed, those who abuse Allāh AND His Messenger - Allāh has cursed them in this world and the Hereafter and prepared for them a humiliating punishment. {33:57}
Question 3: is this verse referring to 2 SEPERATE or INDEPENDANT harms or abuses? How does someone harm or abuse Allah exactly??
I'm anticipating your responses. You may need to dial a Shiekh for this one! 😉
@@negeto2460Wa aleikum Salaam,
My shieykh is Prophet Muhammad pbuh himself I don't need other sheikhs, anyway,
Answer 1: if this verse would have said "then beware of a war with Allah and a war with his messenger" then it would have been two wars separate and independent.
Answer 2: if this verse would have said "... who had lied to Allah AND lied to his messenger ..." then it would have been 2 SEPERATE or INDEPENDANT lies.
Answer 3: if this verse would have said "those who abuse Allah and abuse his messenger ..." then it would have been 2 SEPERATE or INDEPENDANT harms or abuses.
4:59 "O ye who believe! Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you...."
now my Question to you is, is this verse referring to 3 seperate or independent obeying or 1 obeying?
Allah knows best.
@@reachedcertainty Salaam akhi,
Well, if you want to continue on your journey believing that these verses are referring to 2 SEPERATE and INDEPENDENT obediences / wars / lies / abuses, then what can I say? It is Allah who guides my friend.
As for verse 4:59, do you really believe this is referring to 3 SEPERATE / INDEPENDANT obediences? Ask yourself this question and reflect:
How did the contemporaries (jews, christians, mushriks) of prophet Muhammad (a.s) HEAR the Verses of Allah? And if they believed and wanted to OBEY and FOLLOW the Verses, how did they do it? How would they OBEY or FOLLOW the Verses of Allah if it wasn't for the Messenger?
Answer: OBEDIENCE to Allah (Qur'an) was only ever achievable or possible by OBEYING the Messenger! Therefore, OBEYING the Messenger is OBEYING Allah! Literally, you can say:
Obey Allah = Obey Messenger
Obey Messenger = Obey Allah
{Verse 4:80}
Unfortunately, the shiekhs and mullahs have decieved the masses to believe that obeying Allah is Quran, and obeying the Messenger to follow hadiths & sunnah.
There really isn't any point of having a discussion since you still believe what the shiekhs taught you bro. It's a shame but everyone is responsible for themselves. I pray that Allah opens up your chest to make you 'see' the truth!
Take care brother