2nd coming of Jesus (a.s)?
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 12. 2022
- In this video I will be discussing the topic of the alleged return of prophet Jesus (a.s). Does the Qur'an really say this? And I will also talk about The Mahdi and The Dajjal. Let us reason and reflect.
Right, bismillah... just listened to Abu Layth a week ago, totally convinced, and entertained in the process, and just listened to Anwar Shaik Jesus part 2, but now i need the careful analysis from Br Negeto.
Salaam akhi,
Even though I don't agree with some things Abu Layth says but I totally love the guy and for his amazing videos. And I totally agree with him on his stance regarding the so-called returning of Jesus (a.s).
I'm pretty convinced that the Qur'an is clear that no one (jesus or mehdi) is coming to 'save' the Muslims. Our saviours (The Messengers) did come to the world preaching the Verses of Allah but mankind chooses to turn their backs.
May Allah keep us on the Straight Path.
Thank you.
very nice explanation, I hope people see this video.
Thank you AI.
I love that Br Joseph from Quran Centric as well. I just used his 3 minute video dispelling Child Marriage in the Quran nonsense being spewed by Daniel Haqiqatjou, Salafi, ISIS & co. It prevents intelligent people like Howard George Stirrup suspect the Quran.
Hope you are well brother. I suspected you were Turkish. I wonder what you think about our Istanbul video 😆.
On a more imoortant note, have you noticed a concerning statement Br Joseph made on his last CZcams Community Post?
Yes, i love brother Joseph as well and hope that he comes back with full force to destroy the falsehood from these traditions.
Yes, I'm Turkish and haven't watched your Istanbul video in full yet but I surely look forward to watching it in full insha'Allah.
Indeed, I did read brother Joseph's last community announcement on his Channel and that he had some doubts about the authenticity of the Qur'an. Trust me, we all have some doubts which appear in our hearts from time to time but Allah is the source of guidance. May Allah strenghthen his heart and our hearts and keep us holding firmly onto the Rope of Allah!
It's unfortunate & also very shocking for me to find out that he goes by "quran2christ" now, meaning he's a christian now. I learned about the truth of the Quran exactly a year ago. I've always been skeptical of the hadiths since that time, and it took me a month to realize that the hadiths were garbage and invented to divert from the truth within the Quran. It wasn't until Joseph made that community post 9 months ago that I learned about his channel. So I missed A LOT of his content that used to be available, but of the few videos I have seen, he did a phenomenal job analyzing the arabic in the Quran. This is why his conversion is so shocking to me, he was on the right track from what I could see, yet somehow someway he started doubting, and eventually became christian. I truly hope he doesn't delete his old videos again. He has made a new channel quran2christ, and turned comments off on his qurancentric channel.
@@zurahollowoh my God! I am absolutely speechless!!! He became Christian?? By Allah, whomsoever Allah guides, there is NONE to misguide him. And whomsoever He leaves to go astray, there is NONE to guide him.
I can only pray that Allah guides him back to the Qur'an. I'm so shocked Wallaahi 😢
@@zurahollowpeople who move from one religion to the other are confused people and really do need a god to believe in. He'll be eventually back to Islam, nobody sane would worship Jesus when he's been used to worshipping allah alone. I assume this Joseph guy was not a born Muslim.
@@enlightenlife2840inshaAllah he comes back to the truth! This just goes to show that it is Allah ALONE who guides!
One of the most prominant Judeo-Christian (false) belief is prophecy of messianic/savior figure at end times.
While it was clear in the quran that messengers duty is just to convey Gods messages. And the core of that messages is to worship Allah, to make Him our one and only savior.
Happy Waiting.
35:18 false mahdi concept... case closed
Allah bless you brother. Your channel is uniquely beneficial and requires several revisits due to the rich content
Thank you my brother and may Allah bless you to. My videos are not the final conclusions but simply a stepping stone to understanding this magnificient Scripture. May Allah increase us in knowledge, understanding, and wisdom.
Very true brother. I agree with you. 👍👍
Thank you brother Asif and it's perfectly fine if people differ with me. As long as they bring their proof from the Qur'an. But I think it's abundantly clear what Qur'an says regarding this topic 😊
@@negeto2460 Thank you brother and appreciate your efforts and patience. I would like to ask you one question. How was his actual death and where is his body burried ?
@@asifgokakgokak799Allah knows best akhi. All we know is that Jesus died and it's crystal clear from the Qur'an.
@@negeto2460 brother. Thanks for your reply.
Assalamu alaykum bro and may Allah reward you for your efforts. Very nice presentation. Quran 3:46 He will speak to the people '' fil mahdi'' from the root mīm hā dāl (م ه د), mahdun means cradle and ٱلْمَهْدِيّ Al-mahdiyyu from the root hā dāl yā (ه د ي) means ''the rightly guided'', from the same root is اهْدِنَا ''ihdinaa'' which means ''Guide us''. May Allah give us understanding.
Wa alaykum salam brother Ahmad. Good to see you made another great video yourself. May Allah reward you to!
@@negeto2460 Amen bro.
Remind the human being about the Day of Judgment(Yaum Al Qiyamah) to do good deeds.
(14/44) (14/41-48H)
It was the forecast of the Hour last day of this World that being convey among the people in my country Malaysia. Allah know the exact time of his creation of the Universe. Wallahu a'laam.
نفخ في الصور The photo had been ?blow by the Israfil at the covid19
Raised 👉to Himself👈 - 'rafa'ahu Allahu ilaihi'
I loved your video on the Salat. A very nice collection of all of the Ayats on it and leaving it to the viewer to discern what it is. I was wondering if there is a site I can get the slides for that presentation for my own study.
I only share the below alternative perspective to provide information in the hopes that it may help in some way. I have subscribed and like your presentation style.
Regarding this video, I do think that the question of Isa (A.S)'s destiny is not fully clear and Allah knows best. Another scholar, Sheikh Imran Hussain, has a video on the return of Jesus (A.S) from the Quran alone (5 proofs I think it is). It is titled The Quran and the return of the Messiah and is a good alternative point of view on this subject.
He proposes that we must first define what is death in the Quran and concludes, and Allah knows best, that death is when Allah takes the soul, (like when we sleep), and keeps it until the Day of Judgement. Apart from sleeping, there is another verse of the Quran where a man passes by a dead town and wonders how it would be restored and Allah caused him to die and be brought back in a hundred years or so and the town is alive again. The man thinks that he has only been away for a day or part of a day. Similarly, when the People of the Cave fall asleep and wake up 300 or so years later, they also think it has been just a day or part of a day. It can also be possible, and Allah knows best, that if Isa (A.S) is somewhere up in the heavens and alive, very little time is passing by for him.
This means that human beings can "appear" to be dead but they are not actually dead. To die, means that Allah took your soul and kept it, however, Allah says when explaining the crucifixion that he (Jesus) surely did not die. After this he says that he raised him onto Himself. According to the Sheikh, in a separate video, the sequence of these events and verses is important and explains what happened:
1. The Jews tried to Crucify Isa and boasted about it when it was over.
2. Allah rejects this and clarifies.
3. They did not Crucify him nor did they kill him.
4. Allah took his soul.
5. After what "appeared" as a Crucifixion was done, they took him down
Salaam brother Haris,
Thank you for your comments and may Allah bless you. I respect your thoughts and do not in anyway force my opinions or my positions regarding certain topics onto anyone. With regards to the so-called return of Jesus, I asked myself these fundamental questions:
If Jesus (a.s) is to return back to earth, then the question is:"FOR WHAT REASON??"
Ask yourself:
1 - Did Jesus (a.s) fail his mission?
2 - Did he fail to preach the Injeel to his people?
3 - Did he not call his people to Allah?
4 - Did he not cure the leper, the blind, and bring the dead back to life by the permission of Allah?
5 - Did he not be dutiful and kind to his mother?
6 - Was he not the promised Messiah (Al-Masih) to his people?
7 - Was he not a Sign (aayatan) to his people?
8 - Was he not the Word of Allah (bikalimatin)?
The list goes on...
I fail to see why there is a need to bring Jesus (a.s) back when prophet Muhammad (a.s) is the seal (completion) of prophethood and he brought the Qur'an which is descibed as:
- A detailed explanation for ALL THINGS (watafseela kulli shay-in). {12:111}
- a clarification for ALL THINGS (tibyanan likulli shay-in). {16:89}
Didn't the Qur'an EXPLAIN and CLARIFY the truth and reality regarding Jesus (a.s)?? Or did Allah miss some information in the Qur'an and has to resend Jesus back to inform the Jews and Christians the truth about himself???
If Muhammad (a.s) is the final prophet, then how is it possible that prophet Jesus will return??
If Jesus is going come back to join with the so-called Mehdi, then what exactly does the Qur'an say about Mehdi since it is an explanation for ALL THINGS?
If Jesus is going to kill the so-called Dajjal, then what does the Qur'an say about this since it is a clarification for ALL THINGS???
Brother, there are so much more questions that can be asked about this topic and it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever that Allah would send Jesus back when prophet Muhammad delivered the final revelation which is a Mercy, Guidance, Criterion, and explanation for all things.
Take care akhi
@@negeto2460 Thanks you for your response.
When you said: "...it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever that Allah would send Jesus back when prophet Muhammad delivered the final revelation which is a Mercy, Guidance, Criterion, and explanation for all things". Brother, I would kindly suggest that you may want to add "and Allah knows best" since absolute truth is with Allah and we are just trying to find answers to questions.
You asked some very good questions. We all look for guidance from Allah in the Quran to many questions that we ask. I asked a different set of questions due to my different perspective of the world today vs yours, and we all have different perspectives.
If I limited your questions to those just pertaining to subjects mentioned in the Quran (so excluding prophecies about Dajjal and Mehdi and wars, etc) and also those on whether Jesus (A.S) fulfilled his mission (because there have been many Prophets named and many had their people punished while a few escaped so it's hard to measure or state what can be considered a "mission accomplished")..... then I guess your main question is how can Allah send Jesus (A.S) back when Prophet Muhammad (S.A) was the "Khatam / (or Khatim in another recitation)" of the Nabi.
I find it interesting, that this verse about Muhammad (S.A.W) is mentioned in a context about how he felt something hidden about a woman who was with someone else and so Allah made a way to have the Prophet marry this women just as it was done for Prophets in the past and also so that there is no confusion about the children. These are the preceding verses and I just presented a summary of some attempts at the English translations. The verse in question then states that Muhammad (S.A.W) is not the father of any of your men (perhaps suggesting that the people should not compare him to any of there fathers or think he is like any of there fathers - perhaps in behavior or due to this episode or event) but rather he is a Prophet of Allah and "Khatim/Khatam un Nabi" which you said and many say means "seal".
A seal is, among other things, a mark that identifies someone as something. For example, a countries king can seal a letter with their physical seal to prove that it is authentic. If we take this meaning then it would suggest that this was another re-assurance to the people from Allah that Muhammad (S.A.W) is a true Prophet of Allah because he also has some sort of seal which authenticates it and so the event that just transpired regarding the woman has been delt with just like it has been delt with all of the other Prophets of Allah in the past (as the preceding context mentions).
Another meaning for being a "seal" also comes from sealing a letter but from the act. Sealing a letter indicates that you are done with the message and so have put it in an envelop and now the last act is to seal it and send it off. If we take this meaning, then it is possible that he is the last Prophet of Allah to come down with an updated revelation and now there is nothing new to add to the Religion of Ibrahim (A.S). In this sense, if Jesus (A.S) were to come back, then he would not be adding or updating the religion of Ibrahim (A.S) but instead be a sign. One last sign to his people, Banu Israel, to accept the truth or continue in their belief that the messiah is yet to come and he, Isa (A.S) was an imposter.
The above are two alternative explanations and your own interpretation also makes sense, i.e. Maybe Muhammad (S.A.W) was the last Prophet in all sense and Isa (A.S) is not to return. In the end, and in the grand scheme of things, as long as it does not happen before our very eyes, I do not believe that belief in it or against his return is something that can condemn someone to the hellfire as most(correction: some) verses pertaining to him must be interpreted (or are verses that are ambiguous (correction: allegorical) as the Quran explains of the different kinds of verses in it).
Allah knows the truth!
btw, any chance I can get my hands on those Salat slides, the effort you took to compile all of those verses is very useful as a good summary and as you mentioned a checklist of checking if the Salat is going good or not.
JazakAllah Khair,
Brother Haris
@@frostpitt Salaam again brother Haris,
First of all, ofcouse Allah knows best because guidance comes only from Him!
Secondly, what we need to know about Jesus (a.s) has been FULLY EXPLAINED and CLARIFIED in the Qur'an - which leaves no room for doubt.
Thirdly, towards the end of your comments you said:
"... most verses pertaining to him must be interpreted (or are verses that are ambiguous as the Quran explains of the different kinds of verses in it)."
This idea that the Qur'an has 'ambiguous' verses is another misunderstanding my brother and I briefly explain this in my video called "What is the Quran". I show my viewers what are the 'Muhkamaat' and the 'Mutashaabihat' verses and how they are used throughout the Qur'an.
And finally, I would love to share any one of my powerpoint slides with you bro. Please email me and I will reply InshaAllah:
nejdet_m@hotmail.com
Peace
Peace and blessings upon you brother, you please tell me what arabic dictionary you use?
May Allah bless you as well brother. I mainly use Lanes dictionary which can be found online.
so what was sign of hour mean again?
@@muhammadnuralhafiz a SIGN (ayaat) can mean either a 'miracle' or an actual 'sign' or 'indication' of the Day of resurrection.
Same as my points n my next video
13:10 Br. Anwar Shaik has provided a compelling case that he (as) was killed but at the same time not in the way we think. Jesus Part 2 midway.
I'll have to watch that one to insha'Allah.
Jesus aka Isa ibn Maryam was definitely death. His birth was not miraculous. Definitely he had a father.
Salam aleikum brother i think there are verses where Allah told us that everything is created in pair so how could jesus ben created different it goes against Quran it self meybe we should reflect more just my thoughts
Yes, you have a good point brother. We must look at the entirety of the Qur'an and reflect.
My next video is on the Anointed Jesus son of Mary
Buctures of tafsil
2nd coming of Trump (s.o.b)?
2nd coming of Jesus, Israk Mikraj, Imam Mahdi... all these stories are not Quranic but crap stories from Christianity and Persian..
Spot on!
Here again you rely on translations and transliteration. Both are leading to wrong conclusions. A transliteration of the Qur'an is * not * the Quran.
To give you a simple example from your video. The transliteration of both المهدي and المهد are identical when المهد is followed by a كسرة which confuses you. This an ABC level in Arabic, and a limitation in this form transliteration.
As for mentioning the second coming of Jesus (A.S), if Allah ﷻ didn't mention it explicitly in the Qur'an, that by itself doesn't make it true or false, but it makes it impossible for * you * to believe in it because you, for whatever reason, made the decision to limit your information to the translations of the Qur'an.
Peace.
Salaam Kinan,
I never said translations / transliterations are Qur'an - obviously it's in Arabic! But since the Majority of the world are non-arabs (myself included), then how do we understand and follow the Qur'an without translations?? Does Allah expect everyone to master arabic in order to obtain guidance and salvation??
Wouldn't we need translations (greek to english) to understand the New Testament? Knowing arabic is not a condition to obtain Allah's guidance my friend. It's good to know, but not mandatory!
There is not a shred of evidence in the Qur'an that Jesus (a.s) will return! People only ASSUME this because of the rubbish they heard in the hadiths.
Ask yourself this: If the Qur'an is a DETAILED EXPLANATION (watafseela), a CLARIFICATION (tibyaanan) for ALL THINGS (kulli shay-in), and a CLEAR BOOK (kitaabin mubeen), then why does Jesus need to come back?? To do what?? Didn't Allah already explain and clarify the story of Jesus? Isn't the Qur'an sufficient to provide us the details??
Peace
@@negeto2460 Salam brother,
Yes, you never said translations and transliteration are Qur'an, because no one will believe it, including yourself. But you actually did rely on translations and transliteration to build your arguments as if they were the Qur'an. I can not claim to know what Allah ﷻ expects, but I know you don't need to master Arabic to "obtain guidance and salvation". You do need Arabic, in fact Qur'anic Arabic, to understand its words and to argue about their meaning. Otherwise you'll make mistakes like confusing المهد and المهدي.
While not relevant to us, glad you mentioned the New Testament. Jesus (A.S.) spoke Hebew and Aramaic, so when you read his words in English, you are reading a translation of at least another translation. King James version of the bible uses "thou shalt not kill" instead of the more correct translation "you shall not murder" in the Hebrew language of the Old Testament. Son of God is a Hebrew term used to refer to a pious person. As you can see, relying on translations causes major confusion and misunderstanding.
As I said before, if the Qur'an is silent about the second coming of Jesus (A. S.), it doesn't mean it's not going to happen.
"""Ask yourself this: If the Qur'an is a DETAILED EXPLANATION (watafseela), a CLARIFICATION (tibyaanan) for ALL THINGS (kulli shay-in), and a CLEAR BOOK (kitaabin mubeen), then why does Jesus need to come back?? To do what?? Didn't Allah already explain and clarify the story of Jesus? Isn't the Qur'an sufficient to provide us the details??"""
The Qur'an is not the only book Allah ﷻ had revealed. You're assuming the second coming of Jesus to be unnecessary, maybe true for you and Muslims in general. But what about Christians (and Jews)? Would his return affect them and their beliefs? Obviously it should. That's one. The term messiah المسيح an indication that he is supposed to become a king, to rule. When did Jesus (A.S.) rule?
As for the "Qur'an is a DETAILED EXPLANATION (watafseela), a CLARIFICATION (tibyaanan) for ALL THINGS (kulli shay-in), and a CLEAR BOOK (kitaabin mubeen)" I guess you're taking this text outside its intended meaning. Where do you see quantum physics in the Qur'an. Which part teaches me C++? I hope you get my point.
@@kinanlaham744 Salaam Kinan,
You said: "where do you see quantum physics in the Quran. Which part teaches me C++? I hope you get my point?"
This is such a lame argument bro! Obviously, these things have NOTHING to do with 'guidance' and 'salvation'. The Quran is a detailed explanation and clarification for the Deen of Allah! It tells us EVERYTHING we need to lead a good life in this world and the next!
Let's get back to the topic of Jesus (a.s). If he is to return back to earth, then the question is: "FOR WHAT REASON??"
Ask yourself:
1 - Did Jesus (a.s) fail his mission?
2 - Did he fail to preach the Injeel to his people?
3 - Did he not call his people to Allah?
4 - Did he not cure the leper, the blind, and bring the dead back to life by the permission of Allah?
5 - Did he not be dutiful and kind to his mother?
6 - Was he not the promised Messiah (Al-Masih) to his people?
7 - Was he not a Sign (aayatan) to his people?
8 - Was he not the Word of Allah (bikalimatin)?
The list goes on...
I fail to see why there is a need to bring Jesus (a.s) back when prophet Muhammad (a.s) was the seal (completion) of prophethood and he brought the Qur'an which explains / clarifies ALL THINGS!
Didn't the Qur'an EXPLAIN and CLARIFY the truth and reality regarding Jesus (a.s)?? Or did Allah miss some information and has to resend Jesus back to inform the Jews and Christians the truth about himself???
If Jesus is going come back to join with the so-called Mehdi, then what exactly does the Qur'an say about Mehdi since it is an explanation for ALL THINGS?
If Jesus is going to kill the so-called Dajjal, then what does the Qur'an say about this since it is a clarification for ALL THINGS???
I suppose the Creator & All-knowing missed some important information and left it in the hands of hadith scholars (ibn hajar, nawawi, bayhaqi, ibn Salah, etc) to fill in the gaps??
You get my point?
@@negeto2460 Salam brother,
"""6 - Was he not the promised Messiah (Al-Masih) to his people?"""
What was the promise?
What do you understand from the two words المسيح and كهلا, and how old was Jesus when he was raised?
Peace.
@@kinanlaham744 The 'promise' was the Messiah which the Jews were anticipating from Allah. The Hebrew term 'Mamshiah' is the equivalant of the arabic word 'al-masih' and the Qur'an states that Jesus (a.s) was the Messiah!
And what age was Jesus when he was raised? What does that have to do with anything akhi?? Let me guess.. bukhari has the answer?? 😅