After I left Xinjiang, I began to see the whole picture
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 02. 2021
- Thanks for watching! Opinion is mine. Just wanna share a Xinjiang in my eyes.
Born and growing up in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region, I felt a sense of unfairness between the Han people like me and the ethnic minority groups living there...
For years and even after I went to Beijing to study and work, I thought I was among the unprivileged in Xinjiang until I learnt about the Western take: The Han people are the “oppressors” and the Uygur minority group is the “sufferer”!
01:04 Why am I not a Uygur or Kazak?
02:09 What do human rights mean for people in Xinjiang?
04:09 Is learning Mandarin a form of genocide for local people?
04:51 Why couldn't some Xinjiang locals work where they live and what will "forced labor" related sanctions against Xinjiang affect their daily life?
Ps. About why the Mandarin is necessary for Chinese people to learn, I quote CZcamsr Cyrus Janssen's story here. Check here to watch the complete video. • Is the Mandarin Langua...
![How I See the US After Living Abroad for 15 Years [CULTURE SHOCK]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DO5x_tJBn7w/mqdefault.jpg)
Good to have locals who speak English so well to share your life in Xinjiang. We love you.
Right, Never ever listen, read or watch western biased media about Xinjiang. Their news and reports is so disturbing because they DO NOT TELL YOU THE TRUTH. Visit Xinjiang and other parts of China yourself and experience it with open eyes, mind and feelings about Xinjiang and China and its people.
英文講得很清楚且有條理
介紹很仔細且有根據
非常感謝！
加油！
請有空時。 多多介紹妳的家鄉情形
祝福妳！
👍👍👍👍👍👍
Well done to spread more facts in Xinjiang.
I want to cry with joy 😊 I am new to your channel. Thank you for helping the international community understand China accurately and not through baised and ignorant western lense. I am Chinese Canadian. I know Chinese people are not perfect but we are also capable of so much greatness 💕
Ms Fangfang, you did a good job of explaining to people what Xinjiang is like. Your explanation to the situation in Xinjiang is not what the Western media and politicians are saying about Xinjiang. Their aim is to destroy China and Xinjiang is just one of the area they are targeting at. Similarly in Hong Kong where they 'trained local youths" to destroy the public infrastructure under the pretence of democracy. Keep up the good work. Jiayou to you and China.
Thank you so much!
I will work harder this year, stay tuned🥰🥰
补充个事实：约翰迪尔等品牌的采棉机出口到中国，主要客户都是新疆人😂这是美国媒体不会告诉大家的“商业机密”😂😂😂
Your English is good. This helps foreigners understand more about china especially Xinjiang. Xinjiang is a vast region and need several visits as a tourist. Please do more videos on Xinjiang. Keep up the good work. Already subscribed to your chanel.
Thank you so much! The next video is in production, will upload soon! Stay tuned!! It's about cotton!
Great work in showing the world the real Xinjiang. The world need to see the truth. No country is perfect but when some countries deliberately vilify another for their own gains and discriminations, that is despicable. Well done!
such a good explanations of what human rights really is
@@denchae8384 Have you ever been to China to know there is no freedom? Are you so brainwashed that you think the West really has freedom?
Good to hear from a native from Xinjiang. Just ignore the haters and losers. 加油💪
I LOVE CHINA! I am from Hong Kong. China is the best.
i totally agree with you 1000% about language.
as an indonesian, a country with various cultures, ethnics, and local languages, the west (UK and US in particular) never know the meaning of unifier language like indonesia or china has. they're just too ignorant to think that every country in the world only have one languange like they do. a country with differ ethnicities surely need ONE national languange that can be used to unify them, as their national identity. i always knew that's what exactly happens in xinjiang. the west are just soooo self centered thinking everyone should be like them.
and i also agree about human rights pov. as a muslim woman i have similar human rights pov when the west accussing islam for oppressing women, especially about the hijab. what they think is oppressing is actually a freedom for us. we muslim women have the right to choose to cover ourselves, that's a freedom for us that no one force us to.
funny how the west only look up to themselves as the only role model for the world to follow
You know Uyghur women in China go to prison for wearing a hijab, right?
@@lutherblissett9070 nope they're not. they live just fine
@@babybibil4556 No, they really don't.
@@lutherblissett9070 china maybe prohibits hijab in some places such in schools, but hey, doesnt france also ban hijab and other religious symbols on public place too? however china dont put uyghur women in prison just because they wear the hijab. that never happen.
i dont wanna argue over something that you and i both have no knowledge about. unless you're an uyghur yourself or there's an authentic proof to it (not some edited bbc/cnn news reports) then i dont believe it. enough lies about islam or xinjiang already. i see many mosques are still standing in xinjiang some even get renovated and there are still many muslims and mosques all accross the country. if chinese governmet want to eliminate muslims, as the west medias say, would they still exist today? with that power i dont think so.
unlike the west, never in the history of china that they occupied other nations.
anyways i know what happened in iraq or palestine, so i know my enemy (if enemy is the right term) and that is not china. but thanks for your information. i hope what you told me was not you trying to create hatreds, your medias have already taken the role for you🙂
peace my friend❤️
@@lutherblissett9070 how do you know Uyghur women imprisoned because hijab? Do you live there? Have you talk to Uyghur.
Seriously, at this point, I wish I could just go every where to have first hand experience cause I know so many media report false information either deliberately or because ignorance.
Thank you for telling the world true stories about Xinjiang.
The Capital city of Xinjiang is much developed, safer, and cleaner than any cities in the US and UK.
Hahahaha yeah OK 1 dusty city in China is more development that about 1000 cities in the States and the UK. The fantasy section of your brain has gone into overdrive!
@@majpanik well yea the guy they use as a white monkey in their words is trying to claim we can all understand each dialect of English easily which is far from true, and saying americans say learning mandarin is genocide no we think forcing people to learn and conform is wrong and killing those who don't want to conform is genocide.
@@majpanik that says more about you than them .
I've been there, I don't think it's much developed than Europe. Definitely feel much safer and cleaner though. China's t1 and some t2 cities on the other hand are much more developed infrastructure wise. London is kinda stuck in the 90s/early 2000s. Shanghai was truly an eye opener.
I grew up thinking Canada and US cultures are righteous. Totally opposite US what a shame.
Canada and US，vile liar!
Thank you for helping outsiders understand the true reality in Xinjiang. I understand what you mean by people goofing around and not eager to get a job, living off parents and government subsidy. And the government has to motivate people and increase their productivity with skills training, and possibly matching them with jobs
I wish I could visit many places in China someday. China is such a great and beautiful country... Long live China.. Love from Indonesia.. 👍👍👍
China government is the closest government that works for the people thus over 90% of Chinese people approve of their government which is the highest approval rating in the world. I am proud and feel bless to be protected by such great government. 🙏🇨🇳❤️✌️
approve or jail
😂 go ask the minorities in the US where they put them if they don’t get shot but the cops first !
Thank you for sharing your own experiences as a Xinjiang native. So invaluable to hear this all firsthand. Keep telling your side of the story, Fangfang!
nice work great
Hi! Lovely to discover your channel! Great video (I subscribe to Cyrus Janssen too!) I think an increasing number of people in the UK (I live in Scotland) are seeing through the western media bias. I have family in China and am very concerned about this. Well done for speaking out! Your English is amazing and gives you a powerful communication tool as regards reaching a western audience.🙂
Thank you so much!
I went to the UK before covid, and lived in London for months. Love the country and people! Do want to go back some day in the future❤️
Interested to learn more about China. Subscribed.
Sanction on Xinjiang products and cotton will only make people in XInjiang suffer. There is no forced labour there. Help XInjiang products to help Xinjiang people.
That’s America’s only intention with their policy. To create social unrest and to sow the seeds of an uprising against the authorities and their tools to do this is this policy combined with the returning home from Syria the radicalised jihadists with military training who fought alongside ISIS. Nothing America does is designed to help the people in Xinjiang. Quite the opposite is the plan.
Regarding genocide? There are fewer than 260 full-blooded Hawaiians now existing in Hawaii, only living on a private island to prevent interaction with white and other tourist males. The vast majority of people claiming to be "Hawaiian" are mixed-race people, often mixtures of from 2-7 other races. Government programs are set aside for the "Hawaiians," but as with programs for the Native Americans living in contiguous United States, those programs are easily defeated by whites pushing the 1/32 blood quanta provision set up by the government to allow white people to further take what should be there for native peoples.
Yearly the question of Hawaiian sovereignty is brought before the American government by native peoples (mixed-race Hawaiian), only to be denied, as Hawaii has enormous strategic value in the Pacific, similar to the military value of the Philippine Islands and Guam.
Most of the Chinese, Japanese, Filipino, Portuguese, Guamanian and other Pacific-diaspora people do not speak their native languages. Not many people know that here in Hawaii, until 1996, Hawaiian people were discouraged from speaking their native language, and it was not taught in schools here until about then. Local people here speak "pidgin." In the plantation days of American colonization (land theft) here, native peoples brought from other countries to work, and the local Hawaiians, developed a method of communication called "pidgin," a form of Creole, while plantation masters (native people called "Luna") were taught a form of English called English Standard, which was just enough English for them to communicate with plantation owners, the 5 original missionary and corporate families who took Hawaii at gunpoint (1893) from the Hawaiian people while at the same time forcing Christianity upon them, also at gunpoint.
Forced labor is very common in American prisons, actually. Not just in Louisiana. That state prison, Angola, is often used as an example due to the striking historical connotations of black men picking cotton while being overseen by white men with guns. It's not quite THAT bad elsewhere, but the practice is common.
For example, our vice president Kamala Harris had quite the reputation for it back when she was a California state attorney general. Due to disastrous and unsustainable development of California plus the general American greed ruining the environment, California suffers from rather extreme drought now, which has led to terrible forest fires gripping the state. I'm sure you've heard about them.
Kamala Harris ran an interesting regime in California. Her police were wildly repressive, cracking down on minor offenses (particularly minor drug charges, but also things such as school truancy) to keep prison populations high. Her crime labs were inventing evidence, often not actually doing any tests asked of them and simply ruling in a manner to favor Kamala. Thousands of trials were thrown out over this, but it was kept out of the media when she was running for president.
How these two connect is that California can no longer afford to hire the huge army of firefighters it needs every season. Their poor fire management practices that are forced on them by wealthy landowners make it even worse. So, California simply finds reasons to arrest people so they can be used as free labor fighting forest fires. These jobs are incredibly difficult, dangerous and the prisoners are not well trained.
Kamala Harris is on camera not just admitting to this, but LAUGHING about it. She was ordered by a higher court to release thousands of prisoners due to inhumane punishments and severe overcrowding, and when asked when she would do this by a reporter, she says "Not until AFTER fire season!" and laughs.
These are the people who are attacking you. Remember that. They are monsters who enslave their own people to force armies of slaves to protect their mansions from fires their greed caused. Their day will come.
Just don't think all of us Americans are raving imperialists. We've been lied to for a long time, but I think the failure of our government on Covid as compared to China has pierced the veil for a lot of people. Slowly but surely a lot of us are waking up, especially from the undisciplined mess America calls a left wing.
Democracy allows for tens of millions of americans to be street people. No compulsion. But if they need food, they have to force themselves to find the means to fill their tummy. Again no compulsion. The alternative is to rot away.
Thank you for your amazing work! As a Chinese student studying in the US, I hope one day I can create great and honest videos like yours! ❤️❤️❤️
"I want to work until the day I can't walk". Fang comment, "He wants to live a decent life with hard work". Don't tell this to some Americans - they want everything without working! How can a nation progress if some people adopt such a philosophy: it can only regress. Regrettably, we are seeing this in real time. There are not enough working people to pay taxes , and the very very rich pay no or minimal taxes. Unless there is a change in the mindset of some American to accept lower wages to compete in the manufacturing industries, the rust belt will remain. Woke employees wants to tell owners what they can publish or produce. What? Only this can happen in USA. Study the history of past world empires and their downfall, and this point keep cropping up: it fell because of the rot from within - corruption, immorality, self-indulgence, etc.
Thanks for sharing
Ver interesting. Thanks for uploading.
4:23 I think this can be seen as a problem by the U.S because it reflects their past crimes against the native Americans because the U.S used to have native language and it was not English but due to a series of discrimination, They are almost entirely gone from the country. It should not be too hard for people from the U.S to understand that many country around the world didn't only live using one common language but against expectation, It was indeed hard for them to understand that concept.
In my country Indonesia, there are 700 local languages across the archipelago. Although we shared one common language (The Indonesian language), only some of these 700 local languages sounds close to the common languages while the others are partly understandable or not even recognizable by the people coming from the capital. For the country and its citizen to move forward, they need communication so you can say that it is very important for the citizen to learn the common language used in the country that everyone can understand.
So inspiring, can't wait to see your next report on Xinjiang
this is the fact #xinjiang #beautiful 💯👍👍
Thank you this is fully clear!
一件很有意义的事，一项很有意义的工作！加油！期待你有更多的优秀作品。
I will be watching yr channel..its incredible n informative..
Thanks for this... Hopefully many more will learn from you
Respect, beautiful Young lady
The first person who needs content like this for his research is Adrian Zanz.
except he's paid by the NED to ignore actual evidence and simply demonize China for "Americans to compete economically with China by any means necessary" (Biden's words).
Great question!
Who can really help Xingjiang move forward?
Maybe USA? Like how they helped Afghanistan for 20 years? 🤭
This is a good point.
Good video. You have good command of English words, you do have some accent that I can put a finger on it? I do understand everything you said. Thanks,
Greeting from UK.
Nice video confirming my belief. I hope Central government will put in coordinated effort to improve Xinjiang economy. Already the work in poverty alleviation has completed but a long term plan is needed. I think Xinjiang will have a booming time as neighbouring countries like Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Afghanistan and Kyrgyzstan are being developed so Xinjiang will be a connection hub to China.
Good video, congratulations
谢谢管主的视频
We need stories told by the minority Uyghurs and Kazaks on the current situation of Xinjiang.
Such a video is good. Can let western people know more about Xinjiang
The western ppl don't care. All they know just talk sh1t about china
@@Meteora_sky not all western people are brainwashed by media (unfortunately a lot though) But not all 😋
Thank you very informative 💓
This is inspiring.well done
Just subscribed.
USA UK have only 1 Goal:
IT IS IMPERATIVE
that no EurasiaN challenger emerges capable of dominating EurasiA and thus of also challenging America
-
Zbignew Spykman Wolfowitz etc.
I am really wondering why she likes that comment - pretending to be cosmopolitan and super nice and in fact she is not but agrees with nationalism and the existence of imperialism in general. So why should it be appropriate for the chinese government to "dominate" and threaten other nations, if its not for the US? This is what you literally agree with when you like that foolish comment, because you are not reflecting on the issue at all and dont ask yourself the question if is it in fact appropriate if one dominates another. But this is the question to be asked here........ Furthermore it is watering down the complexity of international politics and labels certain participants simply as kind of "evils" with a certain plan and entirely bad intentions. Not only it does appear conspiracy-like but the truth is not so simple to be put in a few lines......No wonder for me that chinese people with a nationalistic attitude, who like to see China appearing in a light of heroism ("challenging" the US) and avoid the critical approach are happy with that problematic statement. Yeah, maybe I am expecting to much from this lady with the fake accent........maybe she is just there to be cute not for thinking.....
@@ponytail2547
Wrong Answer
USA has only 1 Goal:
It is imperative that no Eurasian challenger emerges capable of dominating Eurasia and thus of also challenging America
-
Zbignew Brzezinski Spykman etc.
@@geoeconomics5629 honestly? you are just copying that statement again here? wow, this is an even more ridiculous answer than I expected
@@ponytail2547
wrong answer
@@geoeconomics5629 no
Western politics is not about right or wrong, it is about power struggle. Western medias when in the international issues, are not truth telling institutes but platform for politics.
I'm subscribed to Alex From Xinjiang too have you heard of him, greetings from Japan.
We followed each other on Twitter😅
@@FranklyFang320 Nice to hear that! his latest uploads are great. I follow a lot of Chinese CZcamsrs in Japan. I myself studying Chinese, but just a beginner. Have a nice day!.
Because you are a Han Chinese, you will not be believed by the Western MSM. However, I congratulate you for trying to set the record straight. Please see if you can do an interview with a Uyghur family on your channel, especially one with experience of both before & after China's efforts in improving the situation in Xianjiang.
No use, whatever they say the West will just say they are threatened by CCP. I can see some citizen reports by westerners but CZcams might have blocked them for the west audience.
you can search 歪果仁研究协会 ychina ，they did that before
you can search 歪果仁研究协会 ychina ，they did that before
The United States has bombed so many countries, why doesn't it save the Muslims in their countries? Is it trying to save the Muslims in China or divide China?
Actually when a Uyghur girl showed the truth she got banned and threatened by western audiences! The Anglophone media is run and censured by the US !
We will support China 🇨🇳 Love from IRAN 🇮🇷
Xinjiang will move forward with prosperity and a peaceful society for all to live in.
It doesnt matter what the West said, ignore them. One has said the haters will promote propaganda or lies, the fools will spread them and the idiots will accept them.
i love your jaw
优秀！
Why is this Age restricted Freida?
Finally, I have figured it out...Thanks so much Jerry!
👍
what is human rights? Money, competitions, drugs, weapons, adultery, sexuality, economy are things that humans are condemned to live with.
Too much rights, they go left and fell off the cliff.
Unfortunately, working hard and earning your keep is seen as blasphemous nowadays in the US. Americans have abandoned the good old values that made America prosperous in the first place. I read that China throws people goofing around into vocational institutes and make them acquire a skill and get a job if they want to be released. I thought that was brilliant.
that is better than making them homeless and involved in cocaine
The key words here throw, make and keep... The US has programs to get people off the streets and into homes and have jobs but we only imprison criminals and we don't kill the one's that can't or won't.
There are still a lot of people in China especially in the rural area that's stuck in the 1980s to be fair. Just small scale farming, trading local products etc. For the country as a whole to move forward, they'll need to do more than that. Uighur for example are still stuck in such way. Their daughters get married off to the next highest bidder and they only communicate amongst themselves.
I am curious about why some people concluded that this video must be lie, so what ist the truth? If this video is made on purpose and they’re all actors, I want to ask them, what is truth for you? Xinjiang is peaceful and people all lead a happy life, that is wrong. But some videos say that there are genocide in Xinjiang, you think that’s totally right. I just want to say, don’t judge these video are lies or the truth if you never go to Xinjiang and see what this place really are. But I did go to there, so I can also say you are liar.
Well the fact the guy she uses to help her point lies doesn't help because no 99% of American english is not the same there are many dialects people struggle to understand and there's millions that don't even speak english...
👍👍👍💪👍
... Cheers ...
When you change rapidly the economy of a region from a poor rural economy to a middle class urban industrial economy it will be followed by changes from poor rural culture into middle class urban industrial culture. For the older generation it's a cultural chock. It happened in the western countries after World War 2 when there was also a rapid move of their poor rural economies to middle class urban industrial economies. I remember well the cultural chock of the older western rural generations in the sixties. The symptoms of that cultural chock are the same in Xinjiang . Did anybody talked about cultural genocide then?
Xinjiang in China very good.
简单流利的英语。赞👍 需要用英语来反驳虚假叙述和宣传。
谢谢您！事实胜于雄辩。但语言的确需要不断提升！
谢谢您，我去过昌吉，新疆是个好地方。
It is interesting to hear that Uyghurs were allowed to have a sibling. Yet in the west, they keep talking about genocide in Xinjiang !
What about forced sterilizations by the government of Uighur women, as accounted by them? Or any Chinese person. Yes there is over population but it is so sad in my opinion, women secretly having to have unsafe abortions or giving their child to orphanages where the conditions are not good......
@@Peacelovegoodenergy I wouldn't believe everything you read in the western media. Some of the Uyghurs have been caught out lying as well.
@@Peacelovegoodenergy The women are sterilized and yet they can still bear 2-3 children, and even 5 for Ismayil? Come on.
@@quietman18 why would they lie.
@@Peacelovegoodenergy Who lie?
You are doing good job, telling the truth.
My dad is willing me be forced to work ,,,, by the government ,,,,,,
but,,, I like drinking and fighting ，，，，i like my life，，，，
Any choice should be respected. I just wonder how you make a living...
@@FranklyFang320
My life is drinking , and fight my wife,,and drinking , and sleeping,,,,it is all ,,
@@peilin4766 Wow, what a way to make a living. Where do you live?
Wow I never knew this, the Han are the real disenfranchised peoples and the Uyghurs just run the show. Let's lock these guys in some kind of vocational training center or something to rectify this injustice
Well i think it really helps to accelerate the learning process because there's nothing to do but study when in the education camp.
Many Americans Prisoners of War in Vietnam came back speaking Vietnamese.
I agree with you totally.
Hi good evening
North America has no right to say those things about xinjiang when they haven’t put the effort to assist the indigenous population. I see all these awareness posters and media exposure.
很遗憾的说，他们不想听真相。以前，我以为他们不懂少数民族有优惠对待。
+100 Social Credits
I'd give her more for reporting the truth.
Right....
So sad the government has so much control in the way people live.
@@Peacelovegoodenergy what are you saying? Why do you foreigners feel that life in China is so miserable while the Chinese feel very happy
Time for the world to know the real Xinjiang...
the politicians in the western countries really concern about the muslin in middle east !?
Only xnjian them selves and their Chinese government can help xnjian to develop more and more...
Thank you for informing the west about China. I love China! I'm from canada 🇨🇦
中国🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳💪💪💪💪💪👍👍👍👍👍
China is a great country with great people. We don't believe a word that comes from the west. They did the same propaganda thing to us. Sending a lot of love❤️ from Serbia to our friends in China! 🇷🇸🇨🇳
点进来已经想好怎么骂了，结果发现不是写日记那个方方，撤退😤
我也是😂
Unfortunately it doesn't sound convincing unless you're a Brit, Yank or some European.
So how is the genocide against the Uyghurs in Xinjiang?
China is a great great country. And you should be proud of your country no matter what the haters say.
美女可以考慮進入外交部工作嗎？
Make sure you collect your 50cts on the way out.
Iam not American or from America
Iam pro Chinese
Iam anti CCP (as any Chinese person should be)
Genocide/arbitrary detention, dissappeared or inability to criticise to improve is bad for the people
Taiwan is a country and proof Chinese people can live a life without fear of speaking or innovation
Any questions feel free to ask but please remember that
1) anyone should be free to speak there mind
And
2) the CCP is has
CZcams, Intragram, Facebook, banned Russian Media in EU countries yesterday. Check the news, and learn the word hypocrite.
Also, Taiwan is small, and people are mostly educated. Democracy only work when majority of the people are well educated. If not, democracy will only be used as a tool to control a country by big country like USA.
They use media to influence the people to choose a government that work for the US. Ukrain is in chaos and has become corrupted and failing state after they gain independence because US made their influence there. They toppled a pro Soviet goverment, and enacted a president that pro west. So that they can ge the resource from Ukraine and stop relying on Russia.
America did genocide too. Also America killed millions, not in their own country but in other country. They conduct drone strike to kill people they don’t like in other sovereign country. They topple government that does not go along with them in the name of “freedom”.
These are all facts you can learn, if you keep and open mind.
网红芳
Nah....
If you do not like Xinjiang you are free to go. The fact you are staying is the living proof you are not. Romanians have a saying: "the mouth of the liar speaks the truth".
China doing xselent so far for short periods of time They a. The best don't cry with English. Ties
Its Chinese occupied East Turkestan,
After 1884 Thr Qing Dynasty Annexed East Turkestan, That's where they give the Name Xinjiang, It literally Means New Land.
If Xinjing becomes East Turk, They will fare like Afganistan.
Frankly Fang, you can speak fairly good English. What you didn't talk about, or didn't dare to, is the fact that numerous Uyghur prominent intellectuals are jailed, most of them on charges of trumped up crimes, they are political prisoners. This is what human rights is all about.
Your knowledge came from disinformation of the main stream Western media. You should to be wiser and learn from the real Chinese.
@@samc269 Why do you think the "disinformation" is from Western media? Then why the mainland Chinese communist regime blocks Google, Twitter, CNN, CZcams, Facebook, gmail etc, etc, in mainland China while in the West the Chinese official media's propaganda is seen and heard everywhere? Why 14 billion Chinese citizens have no right whatsoever to freely absorb information from all over the world and express heir own judgements? Who is brainwashing and indoctrinating whom?
@@jasonqian Looks like you are not interested in the truth.
If you are a Chinese origin and with your actions, you will regret for the rest of life your life.
I hope you live long enough to see and feel it.
@@samc269 I am certain one day an intelligent woman like you will realize that yourself have been a slave all your life with no human rights whatsoever under that evil regime that, for over 70 years, committed countless crimes against its own people including a massacre of unarmed students right on Tiananmen Square 33 years ago witnessed by the whole world. No civilized nations can tolerate such atrocities. Wake up !
How do you know the charges are Trumped up? Do you know the details of the crime? It's easy for outsider to refute the charges. Also a violation may not be a crime in one country but is a crime in another.
So you like capitalism. Got it.
Can you talk about the forced re-education camps? How there are the children also in these educational camps because their parents are detained?
What about all if the surveillance, camps, and labor that is forced? Young children Are not legally able to decide for themselves whether they want to participate in this "reeducation" or not. Also children are separated from their families without a choice? How if this fair?
Becaise there is no forced labor there.
You want to boycott somewhere with forced labor? Look at the US: they still use forced labor in prison.
The "reducation" you claim is just regular school 😬 glad to see you are so brave you want kids to not receive schools.
If there is voicemail, I want to shout n curse you.
You have been listening to propaganda lies and spew it here. Phuiiiii
Where you are, is it so fair?
Is China the worst there is? You don't fcuking know western agenda on China. O
Phuiii
there's no answer for your question because what you say here are lies from msm...
Yea....young children not forced to go to school ? In USA ?
No wonder the streets of USA is so unsafe. Guns and drugs paddling, goofing all their lives and end up becomes homeless.
Children separated from their parents ? Are you referring to those Hispanics kids in southern USA ? So, where is the fairness ?
Dumbfart like you are so blinkered to the point of being stupid. Xinjiang is vast and sparsely populated due to harsh living environment. The natural geography dictates that. Kids need to be gathered and concentrated at educational facilities for education to be viable. So naturally they will be housed in boarding school away from their parents. Just as simple as that. You comprehend ?
Thank you for telling us what the great CCP also wants us to believe.
lol, david david david david..when does it stop?
(Thank You) - For - Letting - Us - Know - (You) - Are - (A) - (Sucker) - For - (American - Media) - & - (N.E.D) - (Propaganda) - 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 -
1:50 in and already two old tropes ticked off: that the Han are the real victims because they couldn’t have two kids and didn’t get bonus points on the gaokao (never mind that in practice universities ignore those 25 points knowing they were given for free). I pretty much stopped listening after that and the fact it’s just a Han person speaking for Uyghurs, which is like a Brit speaking for Hong Kongers.
Wow, talk about glass half empty thinking. Here's someone perplexed about why there is this cognitive dissonance between her own reality and what she sees all over Western media. How she saw the minorities were being treated in a way that resembles affirmative action, as opposed to the word "genocide" being bandied about all over the west which for the majority of people conjures up images of millions of Jews being literally exterminated. It is oft repeated with absolutely no actual evidence, all based on hearsay. But you are unable to look at the substance of her observations. You look for generalizations and "tropes", Basically saying that because of her race (Han not uyghurs) she must be discredited on what is happening in her homeland,
(Lol, much like the trope that because one is a white male, your opinion is suddenly irrelevant on issues of gender). In the same manner, you're saying she as Han Chinese, does not deserve to be heard.
Tropes are over simplifications. And basically, in this case it is racist. Putting one race as oppressed, and the other as the oppressor, because of the way a person looks, we can prejudge a person's credibility. It is here that your concern becomes all too transparent. You are concerned more about the narrative (that China is a country of evil doers, out to exploit and conquer like Colonial England.), rather than actual concern for the improvement of the lives of these minorities. She is saying that factories in Xinjiang are discouraged from hiring uyghurs lest they be banned by Western buyers. Cotton manufacture is a major employer, it's an industry that provides livelihood for the uyghurs. And it is precisely the actions of sanctions that are negatively impacting the lives the west are purporting to help.
@@lukecheuk TL; DR
Yea you have a good point. Just because they get the points... ok so what? What does that actually translate to? Show me some Uyghurs outcompeting Han in the job market if you want to convince me. 25 points is nothing if it’s not really worth anything...
Lastly, CCP is overwhelmingly Han Chinese. Uyghurs have no representation in the government so why is it so amazing that they’re not subject to a law they had no part in deciding?
Lastly, sure, if China is just going to genocide and sterilize the Uyghurs anyway why would they care about forcing the one child policy on them? It’s not worth the risk of the growing resentment.
@@educateyourself3872 you already have your opinion pretty established. I doubt anything people say will change your mind anyways. But “no representation” is a little far stretched, it’s as easy as google.
We are not even gonna talking about central level. Province wise, the main one will be Han, vice will be uyghur.
But you’ll say oh, they are not main, so they can’t do anything. Why bother watching ?
@@davisobiax606 yes, you’re right my opinion is made up, and I’m sure yours is too. My want is to point out the deficiencies in what she is saying so that anyone who may be swayed by this propaganda video has some information so as to not be tricked. The fact is that if the CCP would enforce such a one child policy on the Uyghurs it would have occurred without their representation anyway. Even more so, the Xinjiang region is a designated autonomous zone. So I am not 100% sure but I am mostly certain the CCP cannot pass such a law on an autonomous region. If this is true... then her claim is an outright lie because she makes it as if the CCP is doing something nice by exempting them from the one child policy when in reality they cannot due to the region’s autonomous status. Either scenario, through lack of representation or the CCP’s inability to legislate the policy due to autonomy of Xinjiang... either way, the fact that Uyghurs were exempted from the one child policy is no indication of proof of CCP benevolence toward the group.
I have my mind made up on this issue because I personally met a Uyghur who cannot contact family members in China and personally told me of the bad things that happened there. There is no reason for the person to lie about it.
You don't see you're looking at Xinjiang with a very colonial mindset: people have to learn the language, people have to work in cotton and tomatoes, just because Han Chinese don't see the problem. Han Chinese see their language, the work they offer as 100% good. If Uyghurs don't accept their suggestions, Han Chinese see Uyghur as ungrateful.
So all over Xinjiang, we see 'language training centers' with 3-fold barbed wires so the Uyghur don't escape all of this friendly reconversion.
questions:
why can't a foreigner rent a car in Xinjiang (no problem in the rest of China)? (I will tell you: the gas stations work with face recognition cameras. You heard that well: if you fill up your car in Xinjiang, big brother is watching you).
why are foreigners, but especially young male Ughurs kept hours at checkpoints all over Xinjiang?
Why are foreigners who visit Xinjiang for tourism interviewed in their hotels every single night about there whereabouts for the next day(s)?
Why are so many areas in Xinjiang off-limits due to control posts refusing entrance?
Why do police ask people "to shave of the beard'" (first hand knowledge!)
Why is it illegal to use drone for photography in Xinjiang, and why is it illegal to photograph any government building (not just military buildings: any building) in Xinjiang?
Why is there less police presence in cities with a big Han Chinese population, than in cities with a big Uyghur population?
As Chinese try so hard to state there aren't problems in Xinjiang, why are there so many restrictions...? I hope you have an answer, because right now, you're living in a state of denial.
If it's not blocked in China, watch how a reporter in Xinjiang saw a totally different world out there than you in your bubble: czcams.com/video/IsIR2_Vp4yY/video.html
Did you encounter all of the above incidents yourself? Have you been to Xinjiang? Or you just get the info from the Telegraph video that you shared? Bear in mind that the Telegraph is just another British propaganda machine mainly to smear China. I have been to Urumqi in 2014 and I have never encountered any of the above incidents you mentioned. Don't be another brainwashed fool of western medias!
@@marklee8512 Ofcourse you haven't encountered this: it all accelerated enormeously after the 2014 Xinjiang terrorist attacks. Wide-spread face recognition is something that only started in the last 5 years. Things are evolving very fast in Xinjiang. Check the Vice documentary: it's extremely similar to the one from the Telegraph: constant harassing, big brother everywhere,... (search "China’s Vanishing Muslims: Undercover In The Most Dystopian Place In The World"). I have been in Sichuan, Xinjiang, Henan and Beijing but all between 2000-2010, so I haven't got much 1st hand experience, except that friends of mine travelled in 2018 and they lost 1.5-2 hours DAILY at checkposts and were denied a visit to some more remote places (they were having an adventurous holiday with trekking etc.).
@@l.d.t.6327 Vice media group is just another western propaganda machine with Rupech Murdoch and 21 Century Fox as its majority shareholders. To be impartial, try to check out this video to get insight about Xinjiang from an Israeli American's point of view, who have been to Xinjiang numerous times.
czcams.com/video/CldtoYwPtMk/video.html
lies this is an evil police stat aka shit tree country like north korea
When the High Commissioner for Human Rights (HCHR) of the Office of United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), Michelle Bachelet visited Xinjiang in 2022, she was not permitted to tour any unrestricted area freely in Xinjiang. She was also not permitted to interview any Xinjiang Uighurs freely she might run into during her Xinjiang tour.
She was permitted to visit only those places in Xinjiang permitted by China. She was permitted to interview only those Uighurs in Xinjiang selected & approved by China. Moreover, this Uighur interview must be carried out in strict supervision & close monitoring by China.
China is committing humanity crimes on Uighurs in Xinjiang, and of course China won't let any people witness or gather evidence for their humanity crimes.
So, you think you can use this naive video there is no genocide & humanity crimes being committed in Xinjiang ?
Screw your mind ! Please !