Charmed Reboot (2018) Vs Original Charmed - Which Version is Better?
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 06. 2024
- Charmed Reboot (2018) Vs Original - Which is Better? I just got done watching the pilot for the Charmed Reboot, because I was wonderings... which is better? In this video, we're comparing and contrasting the two series to see if the concept was worthy of a reboot or if this is a waste of time. Let's discuss!
Check out TubeBuddy for the best Titles, Tags, and Keywords! www.tubebuddy.com/EloyTB
Follow The Turnout on Twitter: bit.ly/2XkssTJ
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @theturnout
Never miss our Entertainment Review, News, and Discussions!
Subscribe NOW!!! bit.ly/2IwK8nd
Visit USAAudiences.com for Movie and Special Event Invites - Zábava
WATCH NEXT: Charmed Reboot 2018 Powers Got a Major Upgrade vs the Original Charmed czcams.com/video/QZDW6UZqlDE/video.html
Okay Phoebe was the one that didn't have no powers seeing into the future it's nothing compared to Peru Piper and Paige they have power Paige and Prue can move objects with their mind Piper could freeze time and blow up things but Phoebe didn't have power
And writing spells is not a power!! now if they gave her a power that she was an empathy then I will say the 4 of them are very powerful. But the new charmed is better than the original. you don't see the new Charmed Ones fighting with each other you see them work with each other and there's no favor sister on the show The sister who is adopted does not feel left out she's not an outcast. Piper made paige feel like she wasn't part of the family and piper never wanted Paige in the beginning because Paige Matthews was replacing Prue Halliwell and if you ask me if paige was mixed with black the show would have been a little bit more better
2:51 dude Prue had a fulltime job, Piper was the motherly house wife who simultaneously had a night club, Phoebe was a columnist, Paige later was a cop to help people more while being a whitelighter at the same time. They were more than a "stereotype"
Exactly
Preach!
They were self involved white women who didn’t much concern themselves with social justice. They were also very arrogant and acted like they were invincible and were definitely over cocky.
@@Psych_Major_Blonde but that was part of the shows plot😅 them being too cocky brought them into trouble over and over again
@@Psych_Major_Blonde its hard to fight demons and protect the world from evil while still signing petitions for social equality, atleast in the 42 minutes week you see anyway. Whats their race got to do with it? "Self involved" would have done on its own really.
The original charmed
I cant get into the new charmed i find the old charmed the characters seem more real and better humour, the new charmed trys to be funny, i cant personly see how the new charmed is better the old charmed is just wayyyy better to me anyway i like eveything about the original its just done better more with smarter writing like they popped to the past for 5 minutes in the new version hardly though anything off it the old version it was a whole episode and not rushed, finding out about whitelighters and elders over time instead straight away oh im harry in your whitelighter, writting is more clever when its not all explained in one episode all over time learning about the world so to me old charmed wins by miles!
The old charmed group had jobs too, they weren't just defined by their age.
Prue worked as someone who curates art pieces and old historical pieces
Piper was a chef turned bar owner
Phoebe was a column writer turn personality
Paige was a social worker turned teacher
_ When you said that the sisters on the reboot are better than the original (despite the actresses’ horrible acting) just because of their race and not their chemistry as siblings, you already lost your argument.
_ It took half of season 4 for Paige to be fully recognized as a new and permanent member of the Halliwell family and yet in the reboot, they got along in just 1 episode. If that’s not the definition of “forced”, I don’t know what is.
Oh you’re one of those people 😂 it’s cool to disagree, cause it’s just an opinion. I appreciate you checking out my video anyway. Cheers!
I’m not disagreeing. Just stating the fact that you really have no idea what good or bad acting is.
As someone who has been analyzing acting in films for 15 years, I can assure you that the acting in the original series is much better. Their dynamic and bond as sisters (from those clash over petty issues to ones who have each other’s backs) felt authentic whilst the “chemistry” in the reboot gave me cringe.
Hehehe not hearing any facts though. 😂 sounds like opinion, even if it’s an educated opinion.
Also Macy still wasn’t 100% integrated into the sisterhood until close to the end of Season 2. They were able to operate and work together but their connectedness varies a lot. I feel also that it’s harder to accept a new sister after the death of one, whereas there was no mourning to get over. The mom doesn’t count, and is rather something that was used to push them together. Only through Mel And Maggie could Macy learn more about the mom she never knew. There’s a lot of differences in the setup that lead to outcomes that differ from the original series.
Also, “just because of their race” was definitely not anything I said, but I do like the representation on the show and it makes it appeal a bit more to me personally.
@@TheTurnout doesn't one of the sisters in the reboot discuss toxic masculinity and cutting up men's dicks in the first 10 minutes of episode 1?
I don't think Paige takes up the same space as Prudence. Paige was half Whitelighter and half witch, which added more to the story.
I'd agree with that
Have to disagree with you there. I can't take the new show seriously as it just takes the old plot arcs from the original, slaps them in the new series without a thought and butchers them.
Niko was meant to be the Andy character from the original not Darryl is the partner of Andy.
thanks for the clarification :)
The Turnout your welcome yes Andy was dating Prue the older sister, that’s how the cop and witch situation but since they made Mel lesbian they had to do a switch of the character
I tried giving this show a chance but only got into S1 Ep2. If they called this "The United Nations of Witches" then maybe it would have gained merit on its own. But taking on the mantle of the original Charmed was a suicide mission. Shannen, Holly, and Alyssa are not just your ordinary Janes put together in a series. They have substantial acting credentials under their belt even before they came together for the 1998 Charmed tv series. This is why I'm not surprised that S1 Charmed is way far ahead compared to S1 Charmed Reboot when it comes to connecting with the viewers because S1 of the original is all about emotions rather than all about powers.
Just my two cents. Respect.
Well, I get that the reboot may be better in a way. It's modern, the CG is better, and it has the OG as a reference of mistakes to avoid. And yes, the OG was silly, had a lot of plot holes, the storylines were a bit wonky sometimes... But for me, the original Charmed will always be the best. In the OG (let's talk about seasons 1 to 4 and forget the rest lol), I really had the feeling that I was watching sisters. The dynamic that you say is stereotypical actually makes sense in the OG and is explained.
Also, the concept of being Charmed is different. In the OG, I actually get the feeling that being Charmed is something almost sacred and special. I also liked that they tried to stay close to IRL Wicca in the practice of witchfraft. I really feel that the Halliwell family line streches very far in history, making the Charmed Ones very powerful and legendary witches. It's like, it makes you wanna say "wow." The new show dumped that and made it "Let's cast spells in latin because that's more mysterious" ! And I lost that sense of "sacredness" with the new show. They don't feel as magical, they almost feel fake. It's hard to describe.
But most importantly, I feel like the original Charmed had a soul. It felt and still feels like home. That's why they still live in their family manor in there late 20s. That's home! I wasn't watching it for the witchcraft, I was watching it for the dynamic between the sisters. In that sense, I think the new Charmed lacks that, and is too focused on witchcraft with CG explosions every five minutes. It's okay if people like that though. I think the reboot is okay. We needed a more diverse cast and the new takes on Charmed are a bowl of fresh air. But the OG will always be the best in the hearts of those who grew up with it !
I think both have a soul. The new one is a reinterpretation of the old, taking the concept into a new direction. Nothing wrong with that. I'll continue to watch both, and won't bother with trying to bash one to justify the other. Cheers!
Exactly, how can a true charmed fan says shi**y stuff about the original series S1-4. this guy is crazy to criticise the original serie!
Fan is short for fanatic, which I’m not. I love a lot of shows but that doesn’t remove my ability to identify the faults in said media. Blind allegiance does nobody any good, IMO. Cheers!
@@TheTurnout I started watching Charmed as a 4 year old. I am now 24, almost 25, and my fanatic love for Charmed simply evolved with the times and what is currently relevant. I am an activist like Mel, and so I see the values of this turn in CW Charmed. OG Charmed did this in bread crumbs, but CW Charmed simply took it further and there is something to be learned from each episode that relates to the current generation. I saw myself in Phoebe in Paige for years, and now I am just comfortable in watching a show where I can’t see myself in the characters because of my whiteness, but being bisexual and pagan, I understand the closet/broom closet conversations. And it’s nice that they have representation that doesn’t have to look like me 🙂. Although one thing I really like in the CW Charmed 🆚 OG Charmed is that no one has made blonde 👱🏻♀️ jokes in this one.
2:59 - Honestly this isn't a fair description of the sisters. In the first episode, Prue has a successful career working at Buckland's auction house. Piper works at Quake (I can't remember if she is a chef yet or a manager). Phoebe is returning to SF after a failed stint in NYC, and she quickly becomes a student. Later Prue works a photographer/photo journalist, Piper buys and operates P3, and Phoebe is a majorly successful columnist after she got her degree in psychology
3:40 - Leo was a combat doctor in WW2, so he is also from the 40s. Honestly I think this is a huge reason to dislike the reboot, they take the same characters and just give them new names, slightly new backgrounds, and new personalities and call it "new." Why make the male whitelighter from the same era as Leo but give him a horrible, stuffy personality with a grating British accent (which I honestly thought was fake until I looked on IMDb just now)?
4:16 - Yes the original cast was attractive, but am I blind? Because the new cast is also very attractive. Also, Leo's backstory was very fleshed out. He also has entire episodes dedicated to his past, and his life apart from the charmed ones. ALSO If Harry was with their mom at some point, they are just stealing more from Sam's character, who was with Patty.
5:08 - Technically the original's original "cop friend" was Andy, who did have a relationship with Prue until he died. Darryl was his partner and only became the "cop friend" after Andy died.
6:15 - In the original show they did deal a lot with the loss of their mother, entire episodes were dedicated to the fact that they never got over their mother's death, and that they still grieve her. If I'm correct I think there is an episode dedicated to each sister's grief over their mom - Prue in the one with the water monster, Piper when she gets married, and Phoebe in the 70s episode. Not to mention, in the first episode they are still dealing with the fall out of Gram's death, it is just more subtle.
I love the old Charmed. I also grew up watching it. I find the story lines were a bit better the first season of the show did seem dry but it did get better. On the 4th season when Page is introduced it takes almost half the season for them to be close like a family and for her to move in to the house. The new one introduced the sister first time to the family and it takes till the end of the first episode for her to move in and be sisters. The spells and magic seemed true to the Wicca and pagan ways in the original. I am willing to try to watch the second season hoping it gets better. I do wish they kept the whitelighter effect the same maybe gave more of a updated effect with the orbs. I do miss the opening credits but as of now in 2019 on CW which ops out of opening credits and goes for a simple intro.
It’s definitely different but I thought it was a solid first season of a show. I have a lot of favorite shows that had “not so great, but important” first seasons after all lol
The new charmed should be in Disney..on par with thats so raven...
It really depends on how you go about it. The original is better if you consider the first 4 seasons because that is the era where the show was at its best. The sister's chemistry, the witchcraft, the family aspect. All of which is completely absent in the later seasons of Charmed. Tbh in Seasons 5-8 the show took a major nosedive where the sisters (namely Piper and Phoebe) became really selfish and hateful characters. The witchcraft began to take a complete backseat, even the characters didn't really seem to care about anything after a while.
Not to mention the amount of continuity errors in the later seasons, especially Seasons 6 and 8. I'd say factoring in Seasons 1-4 original is better because the reboot's biggest flaw is its lack of flow, bad pacing (it serious feels like multiple seasons have gone by with how many things are thrown around and resolved with little to no follow up) and characters not even being fledged out or identified. There's barely been focus on the sister's relationship and they hardly use the BoS. Not to mention the OG sisters weren't overpowered in their first season.
In Seasons 1-4 to the show's credit it did bother building up the relationship between Piper, Phoebe and Prue for Seasons 1 & 2, to where by the ending of season 2 you bought them as sisters completely. Even Paige gets her time during the first 13 episodes of season 4 with them introducing her. The girls also used their book a lot and seasons 3 and 4 in particular started to add more witchcraft and potions into the mix. It basically is more structured which the reboot lacks.
Yes Charmed was always a campy/silly show that you didn't really have to take a lot of elements seriously. However where I think the first 4 seasons were enjoyable in that regard is that the campiness was relatively fun and enjoyable, there were good episodes sprinkled in here and there.
For characters I'd say the OG sisters win if again factoring in their earlier counterparts. Piper, Phoebe and Prue were all likable in the first 2 seasons (3 for Prue and Piper). Phoebe's character went downhill from season 3-8 and never recovered. Whereas Piper became annoying later seasons as well. But going by their Prue, Piper and Phoebe dynamic, then yeah I would agree with them being better. I'd say the reboot sisters are more likable than the OG sisters in later seasons for sure.
However I feel Macy really carries the trio in a similar way to where Paige carried the second set of sisters in the OG. Because when it came to later seasons of OG Paige was the only one left doing anything and Macy is the one in the reboot with a consistent focus/arc. Either way I agree with each set of sisters winning.
Yeah, I think season 5 was where i stopped watching the original and o loved the original show. But also, I went back and watch some of it before doing this video and it really doesn’t hold up well. The writing is terrible and it’s even campier than I remember lol. I did love Paige though, her power was awesome. And yeah, I like Macy and how she drives the show now, but I also feel like the writing is much better and all the characters have stakes which is great.
Context Code a whole collage SA
I'm watching a new show but their acting game killing me
Hehehe. Watching both shows, the acting in on par across the board. I think Harry does an amazing job though. lol
@@TheTurnout I meant three main actresses. Rupert Evans is the charisma of the new show! In the original show I did not like just Rose's acting. Her plasticity was so artificial
Yeah, we tend to cloud up quality in nostalgia a lot of the time which is why I went back and watched a bunch of the original before make this comparison. And really, all the sisters from both shows do a good job with the tone and approach of the show. It’s supposed to be a bit melodramatic and over the top and I think they pull that off.
@@TheTurnout macy and harry acting is on point and maggie but mel she dosent fit it
@@ianbo1501 Everyone in the original series had good acting exceopt Rose McGowan. In the new one the acting was horrendous.
Prue & Paige did NOT occupy the same space. One was the original, eldest sister, w/ telekinesis. The other was the youngest, a half sister, & a half white lighter. & the original sisters DID have defining traits beside the tropes you implied. Prue was an auction house curator & art history specialist, she was fluent in foreign languages as well. Piper was a chef & business woman, Paige was a social worker & Phoebe became an advice columnist. Did you actually watch the original show?
Okay the show is basically using the Charmed name to attract fans. They should’ve just made a new show. They should’ve made three friends who discovered they have magic and come from three coven lines. That would’ve been better than a show that doesn’t follow the same elements of the original show. First the sisters all have a strong bond with each other. I really didn’t get that from the trailer and the few CZcams videos I’ve seen of the show. Second the sisters have distinct characteristics that are not in the reboot. Macy doesn’t seem confident, strong, and stubborn. She isn’t struggling with following her dreams or doing what she wants instead of thinking of her sisters first. Mel isn’t timid, insecure, and the bridge between her sisters. She isn’t the mother hen of her sisters. She isn’t struggling to find confidence in herself. Maggie doesn’t dance to the beat if her own drum. She doesn’t rebel to seek attention. I really feel like they should’ve just made their own show or at least have more elements of the show.
If I were to have made it, I would’ve made them kill off the oldest sister in the beginning. Then have them find out that the oldest sister had magic and so did they. The death would’ve been used as a sacrifice and the magic from that unbound the sister’s magic. Later they find out that the magic also unbound the magic of an unknown half sister. Mel would start to become less timid as she starts to see life is too short, Maggie would start to try to think first before she acted and Macy would try to find her way through a new family. Like that could’ve had a better start to the show than their mother dying and a random British guy telling them they’re witches.
I mean, how long has it been since you watched the pilot for the original Charmed. It’s essentially them finding the book of shadows and Phoebe having to convince the other sisters they are witches and even though they are freezing time and throwing things around the room with their minds, they’re like “no, there’s no such thing as witches”. I prefer the traumatic events and their white lighter showing up to explain things personally. But that’s just me. Cheers!
The Turnout yeah actually after watching this video I went to see the pilot of both and the original wasn’t as good as I remembered it and the new one isn’t as bad as I thought it would be. I still stand on my idea that they should’ve made their own show from how different the new Charmed is from the original, but when I saw it without thinking of how different it is from the old show it was actually sort of good. Though I do think they need to work on their pacing, but that’s my issue with a lot of CW shows. Like slowly introducing Harry as their whiter lighter throughout the first few episodes. But that’s just me.
I definitely agree with the core of them rushing through some major plot pieces though. I think it’s setting them up to go in an entirely different direction in season 2 and I hope I’m right! Cheers!
Definitely agree with you on the part that they should've just made their own show. The main thing imo that makes the original better is that they stuck with the theme of the show being abt 3 sisters who happen to be witches. And along with that, they had the writers research the actual Wiccan religion and culture and would incorporate their findings into the show, which is not what the reboot does. The reboot is just all over the place and I really tried to watch it and get into it but I couldn't. And it's even more difficult to grasp when they disassociated the show from the original characters. This is why fans of the original wanted a spinoff show based around Chris and Wyatt.
@@TheTurnout Actually, the sisters in the OG were using their powers without realizing they were doing so after Phoebe read the incantation which makes it believable to me. They had no concept about nor any memories of witchcraft. Their emotions triggered their powers, Prue with her sleazy boss, Piper's anxiousness with her job interview etc. (ie. She froze the chef at the restaurant by accident and then tried to get in touch with Phoebe by pay phone). Phoebe needed to convince them because they didn't believe in any of it nor that what happened was due to some magical destiny. They were thinking "logically" which is what most "normal" people tend to do until their own reality sets in. I found the reboot more UNrealistic regarding their introduction as witches (ie. being tied up by their whiteligher Harry LOL) and barely knowing Macy yet an instantaneous sister bond is formed by the end of the first episode? Nope. That didn't even happen with Paige and the original even highlighted how the first 3 sisters had family struggles, drifted apart after the death of their Grams, with Prue & Phoebe even sharing a sibling rift. We saw how gaining their powers & becoming the Charmed Ones brought them closer together. I found all these circumstances more realistic & the build up more impactful in my opinion.
Everything new and shinny is not always better. The new come from the original. Original had rules to their magic that kept them connect to the human side .
The original! It had a better storyline, spells that made sense, no sexual deviancy, and more believable interpersonal characters!
Ah... yeah, the new one isn’t for you.
While I completely disagree with your opinion that the new show is better at all, the new show isn't as terrible as I expected.
The dynamic between the Sisters aswell as their characters however are roughly the same, as far as fleshed out characters and not "just their age". You're really not using the same standards for both and Phoebe also had that same power FYI only that they removed it because it was a too powerfull plot device. Them having the Hispanic Background means nothing if you cast 2 african american and one hispanic Woman who could pass as being african american, furthermore how does their race further any plot about Witchcraft?
To be fair what I preferred about the new show was the way they setup them getting their powers. That they showed the mother, that the Sisters seemed young enough to still live in that house and that their Whiteligther actually gave them an introduction.
But apart from that it's really not better in any aspect, I bet that they'll also have one of the Sisters date the Whitelighter and so on. The Difference here is that Charmed was a 90's show like 90210 mixed with Witchcraft/Monster of the Week, while the new Charmed is more of an Desperate Housewives instead.
The new Charmed is better than I had feared but it's most certainly not better or even as good as the original. But who knows maybe they'll become better, the main reason why the original Charmed went down the drain was because of budget cuts that among other things forced them to stick to humanoid enemies and minimize production costs
Glad you gave it a shot either way! So many others aren’t doing that and are missing out!!
Niko is not Daryl's counterpart. She is Trudeau's counterpart. A cop and one of the sisters' romantic interest
ah... I feel you. I always enjoyed Darryl more. lol
@@TheTurnout I like Darryl. But I always thought he was very underdeveloped as a character.
Maggie’s still has a power Phoebe had. Phoebe was an empath as well in like seasons 6-7 but took it away cause she was too over powered lol.
When they visited the future in Season 2 or 3 Pheobe was being burned at the the stake for using her Empath power to turn someones hatred onto themselves, killing them with the raw power.
Phoebe lost her powers in season 6 because she misused them and relied too much on them. So she agreed with the tribunal to have her powers stripped and she would earn them back
@@camrnjurena that was season 2 Morality Bites. The Book of Shadows basically was teaching them a lesson. Phoebe didn't develop her Empath powers until season 6. She got her levitation powers on the first episode of season 3. But her main power was premonition.
isislaz yeah I know in the story that’s what happened but the creators of the show said they got rid of it because they thought phoebe was getting too much power.
@@honperryhill1687 not that. They said they had to lessen the effects due to budget
Plus the old charmed used rhymes as spells like its a damn nursey rhyme, and the reboot uses latin language as spells which makes it better and don't let me start on how cool the story line is and makes much more sense.
Original all the way!
Actually no Phoebe is also an empath along with having premonitions and she can levitate. And i disagree about the character analysis over all
I saw the first episode and after their white lighter tied them to chairs, I never watched it after that.
That’s a weird reaction but okay
@@TheTurnout Through out the years, networks sought to bring back a series. The Bionic Woman, Kolchak the Nightstalker, and the current version of Magnum P.I., Each series used the characters but failed in character development and plot.
The premise of a new Charmed worked well with the sisters. Their white lighter's introduction for me missed the mark
According to IMDB, season 3 begins January 2021.
effects, and storyline .. yeah .. i guess ..but character wise .. i like the original... the reboot is so trying hard to make it politically correct... plus since as noted by some to be better, why did they have to ride on the “charmed” bandwagon ... they could have done a different take .. for us to really note that they are better... at the end of the day.. the original stood the test of time ... and up to now ... we still watch it and even the new generation dig 😀
How is the reboot trying to be politically correct? By having diverse characters? In what world is that a bad thing? Also, you can’t say the charmed reboot is riding the original’s bandwagon. They had some interesting callbacks and the powers were essentially the same, but all and all this is a different show almost entirely. The problem here is that if they made it any more different people would have said “then why even call it charmed” and if it were closer to the original, they’d say “why even have a reboot of it’s exactly the same”. There are big differences between the two shows and it’s okay to have a preference. I like both personally, though the original doesn’t really hold up to me. Especially not with the new version doing a way better job with the material. Cheers!
Harry was involved with Macy at the end just like Piper and Leo also Parker was half human and half demon he fell Inlove with Maggie in the original Cole was also half human half demon and he fell Inlove with Phoebe
Waaaait Macy and Harry?? Ewwww
Ok but....did you even like the original show??? 😆
Yup! Watched it for many, many seasons. :)
Original Charmed is better until later on after season 4 then it went down hill. I can't get into the new charmed. I don't know what what it is about the new charmed I just can't connect with the all the characters. Too much going on.
A lot of ppl are highly against the reboot and trust me I'm a HUGE Charmed fan from day one of the original series and never did I think I would actually like the reboot. Takes a while to get used to it with the first few episodes. But it picks up half way through the season and has a decent story plot despite the CGI and props not being too par and the slight changes in abilities and character arcs. I mean season one of the original series was a little questionable too but being as it was made in the 90s we give it abit of leeway. I can honestly say I actually enjoyed it and wouldn't oppose to a new season. I think u just have to give it a chance
Completely agreed, though I was hooked by episode 4 myself :)
In season 6 Phoebe becomes an Empath. Just thought I'd mention that, since you said it was a new thing. The younger sister, in both original & reboot, has the power of empathy.
Edit: Btw, I hold the original close to my heart. The reboot is starting to grow on me, but I still hold the original in a slightly higher place.
Oh yeah, that’s cool that Phoebe grows into the ability but they have different starting abilities. :)
@@TheTurnout I'm actually curious if they'll do the same thing in the reboot. Macy also astral projects, Mel blows things up, Maggie levitates &/or has premonitions, stuff like that.
I think I could be cool. Their powers already escalated from the beginning of the season to the end, so the sky’s the limit
Phoebe was actually the middle sister when she got the power of empathy. Paige was the youngest. Prue died so that made Phoebe the middle sister
@@isislaz Yeah, but originally she was the younger sister.
the problem with the new series is instead of coming up with an authentic plot (let alone title) they literally made a carbon copy of it and included cliche modernized acting / cringey dialogue. they should’ve made it its own series cause nobody would’ve tuned in if it wasn’t for the original.
But not really
The Cgi Demons are horried!
It could be better, but it is infinitely better than the Original tho. (Not that I blame the Original for this).
@@smexyseme yeah the original had graphics from the 90s tho
I don't think I agree with the whole personality difference. I think personality wise in both versions are the same. The oldest is more serious, the middle is idealistic and the young one is immature. The big differences are their professions... I guess scientist is more impressive than auction house director, activist is more progressive than chef.
Fair point
Cool review!
I actually agree with many of your points, but you only have seen few episodes.. there r more to see before you can reach your conclusion.. I already finished the 1st season of CW Charmed
I love the old Charmed, and I dig the new one
But there r things that you have yet to see, and here is my opinion to point out some of your points :
1. The supporting actor for whitelighter (Harry) is more fleshed out than old Leo I agree, but the actor and character who replaced half-demon lover Cole/Belthazor is a paper-thin character as human, his name is Parker and he is basically a basic "reformed bad boy" right from the start which makes him far less interesting, and he lacks personality on his own, he is just a lover boy who changed his loyalty for a girl he barely know in a blink for the sake of romantic plot
Although his demon CGI form is very cool and awesome!
His character is very similar to another character in another witch TV show Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Nicholas Scratch.. which happens to be similar to every "reformed bad boy trope"
2. Niko supposedly replaced Andy, who is Prue's love interest, not Daryl
But the actress who play Niko fails to convince me that she is in love with Mel I can't root for them despite watching for the whole season, because the characters lack chemistry with each other
Jada is far more interesting
3. Mel is very unlikable, unlike Piper.. partly due to forced "woke" and feminism, and also because the showrunner decide to make the feminist main character is a basic men-hater lesbian.. you don't need to hate men or be a lesbian to be a feminist, and the fact that Mel's character is written as having no attraction to male species due to her sexuality and she is basically a misandrist kinda took away the feminist strength featured in the the original show
4. This show's casts is diverse, and I love how the show deal with ethnicity issue with Maggie and Macy.. plus point for the show
But bear in mind pretty much every other show during OG Charmed's era had mostly white characters or popular TV show with mostly black characters.. time has changed now but we can't blame OG Charmed for featuring mostly white protagonists it was the (rather upsetting) trend at that era
5. The format of TV show also has changed today.. as people tend to binge-watch we prefer straight to the point storyline.. but the "villain of the day" story is the basic TV format at that era of OG charmed too.. I think OG Charmed works best at that time where the characters and their sisterhood fleshed out during this episodes.. the "filler episodes" actually bring the audience closer to the characters.. this is similarly how I feel about OG Sailormoon in the 90's vs Sailormoon Crystal new adaptation.. the new Sailormoon series has better execution, but the relationship and the personality of each characters are not fully optimized due to lack of character-focused episode, like in this new Charmed
6. This sounds really shallow but the OG Charmed are far prettier overall, but I get today we prefer more representation from every kind of person that reflects the real population.. though I wonder why they didn't make one of the sister in the new show plus-sized too
I kinda upset with Mel's casting tho, she looks way too old to be the middle sister.. I googled her and found out the actress Melonie Diaz is like 7 years older that her "older sister" Macy.. they should at least appropriately cast according to age
I know that Alyssa Milano is one year older than Holly Marie Combs.. but she did pass playing Phoebe the youngest sister based on her looks and her believable acting.. overall all the older Charmed main casts are appropriately cast which I really love
But I think Mel, Niko and Parker are miscast in this new show
7. Also the "Elders" in this new show is basically straight up humans.. they lack mysteries and basically quite powerless and useless.. what the heck
the Elders is one of the main weakness of this new Charmed plot
Yeah they changed a lot of stuff but I argue that they needed to. If it was too similar, people would be mad about that. lol.
On the subject of attractiveness, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The original cast were hired because they were young and beautiful and were put in skimpy clothes a lot of the time. The new cast is gorgeous though, imo, especially Macy. OMG!!! 🥰 so all of that is really just a matter of perspective and opinion. 😂
@@TheTurnout I agree with u.. Macy is gorgeous!!! but my fav is Maggie
I juz dislike Mel
Tbh, Macy (and Galvin) are the only good things about the reboot
Yeah, I really dig Macy!
Did old charmed ones are way better they actually feel like real ppl...
Do they thought? They seemed liked caricatures imo. As so most tv characters on shows like this.
@@TheTurnout yes they seem like real people. The reboot ladies do to but they definitely do not feel like sisters. More like roommates.
That "bad gsi" you said was a good one back then for a series.
Agreed. It doesn’t hold up though and the new series has better effects. As I said in the video though, I don’t hold it against the old series too much because that’s just what they had at the time. Cheers!
@@TheTurnout I actually liked most of the effects in the og😅 the cgi of the reboot is mostly silly in my opinion and I don't like that
New charmed is rushed and the acting is flat. The are rushing the story line which makes it hard to connect. The original was put together nicely
I think both are pretty darn good. Does one have to be bad for you to prefer the other?
The Turnout never said that. I really enjoyed how sophisticated the original charmed story line was. The other is okay but compared to the original it doesn’t compare. It had big shoes to fill anyways. But are good. Just the original is better
You're correct.
2018 : Charmed Reboot
2021 : Fate the winx saga
2023 : ???
🤔
Original has always been amazing. But the reboot still give the original great vibes that stayed with us from the original.
you are so wrong, and the most thing that interest me is that you say you are a screenwriter, and you are saying that this ripoff ,that is not original and is saying the original cast where too beautiful the problem is maybe if they just make a new show and not capitalized on a well loved show just to take it apart, maybe i would like it on its merits, maybe they could have inherit the charmed legacie from the originals, being long distant cousins or something, but this saying their are better that the show that run for 8 seasons, and that as fan personally would like to see a show that continue their kids stories instead of these.
Agreed
I really really wanted to love it because the original was my fave show growing up, but something just hasn't clicked for me. I guess the new one is technically better, the og was very cheesy, full of inconsistencies, and yeah due to its time the graphics aren't great. However, the characters were engaging and as ridiculous as the show could be at times it was always entertaining. I have watched the first two seasons of the new one but I just couldn't stomach it anymore. I think actresses are very talented but I just am not invested in their characters at all. I don't think it's a bad show, I just find it very dull. Each episode I'm just waiting for it to end. With the OG when the episodes finished I just wanted more. I don't know if it's worth giving S3 a go maybe I will because like I say I feel like I want to love it. Maybe things get better in S3, but unfortunately the first 2 seasons did nothing for me at all.
The turnout sucks
I liked your comparison! Might have to checkout the new Charmed!
I think it's a good choice for a show to watch. I'm about 11 episodes in now and it keeps getting better.
Maggie does have vision of the future now 🙂
Yup! This is an older video 😂
After watching the first season of the reboot and actively watching the second season of the reboot now the “OG Charmed” is the better of the series.
Season 1-4 of the OG Charmed were the best seasons of the series for me. The dynamic between Prue Piper & Phoebe and even Paige’s introduction, the writing, the character development (except Phoebe who fell victim to the relationship trope of needing a man to be interesting in Season 3 and beyond) the magic, the family history, the world building was all done realistically, gradually, and we felt like we were growing with the sisters in their lives, dreams, aspirations, and not just watching a show to pass the time. It felt more grounded/believable in that aspect and the magic/demon of the week was just the icing on the cake.
The first season of this reboot was poorly rushed, too much was going on, the girls barely relied on the Book of Shadows and everything was handed/explained to them, they advanced with their abilities way too quickly (especially Maggie), their “sisterly bond” was not and still not believable, we still do not know anything about these girls or their family’s history with magic, the writing could be better and literally Holly Marie Comb’s acting in “Hell Hath No Fury” in Season 4x13 is more emotion than I’ve seen from these new girls in these two and half seasons of this reboot thus far lol
I will give credit to the reboot for dabbling with the ideologies of expanding on the “gray area” of the moral compass. The OG Charmed just focused on the good and evil but sometimes it’s not always that clear.
I’m not gonna harp on the CGI or effects. The OG Charmed was practical and used what they got and this reboot I’m impartial with the use of it but it’s apparent this reboot is drawing inspiration from various other sources of magic (Harry’s teleporting is Harry Potter ish, the first demon the Reboot Charmed zones vanquished looked like the Night King from GoT etc.).
When the Reboot Charmed Ones get better with their sisterly dynamic/chemistry, the writing/direction of the show finds some kind of ground to build up from and properly world build, we learn more about their pasts which is passed off as just useless background knowledge and not as important which is boring, and we organically watch these girls grow in a well rounded way THEN I can see it being a better Charmed.
Checking off boxes (Having POC leads, an LGBT representation, Feminist, Millennial terminology, social issues etc.) to have in a show doesn’t automatically mean the show will be spectacular.
Why would you make a comparison if you haven't finished watching?!
I immediately stopped watching when you said you've watched five or six episodes of the reboot.... then I went back to give you another chance.
The results are in: You clearly don't know quality.
The reasons I like the reboot more remain through the remainder of the first season. I’ve finished it since and nothing’s changed in my mind. It’s cool if you disagree, though, its just personal taste. Cheers!
@@TheTurnout You clearly aren't a true fan of the original and are very ill equipped to compare. If you actually watched the original, you'd know what made Charmed Charmed. You'd also be able to recognize what this show is missing compared. It wasn't perfect but it had its unique strengths. Most of your points, if not all, are character points, which, as a newbie reviewer, is a very weak base. The reboot, even as a stand alone show, is very weak in comparison; from leaning on the original show to set the scene all the way to the dreadful acting and hundreds of choppy rushed storylines. Not to mention, what appears to be the lowest vfx budget from the CW.
No one needs to be a “true fan” of something to talk about it, that’s point #1. #2 is that yes, I am very interested in character. What you see as a weak base, I see as the entirety of the show. Without good characters, then the show is nothing and I like the new charmed ones and their stories and their execution much better. Does that mean I didn’t like the original? No! And I’m not saying YOU have to stop liking he original either. I’m here to state my opinion not dictate what others like. You keep having fun with the original, despite its flaws, and I’ll like the new one, despite its flaws. Neither of us is wrong in this conversation is what I’m getting at. We just like what we like. Cheers!
@@TheTurnout Quality is based on a number of standards and if you're looking to give quality reviews, let alone comparisons, there's a lot to work on.
Sure. Well, have fun disagreeing with people in the Internet! Cheers!
The original charmed is way better, they’ve turned this reboot into something darker especially with the backstory of the white lighters having their whole history erased and why even call them white lighters because the orbing is messed up in the reboot 🤣🤣 original charmed wins every time.
It’s not a reboot if it’s not the origin story but a continuation from new charmed ones perspectives ....they are just the charmed ones of this generation. I like both versions though
I feel like you should have watched the full 22 episodes before you made a video comparing the two versions. It would have been a more even and fair assessment. You really can't get a good grasp of the new series untill you've made a real dent into the season. The new season is fun to watch but it suffers hugely from poor story telling. Also, the way the new show handles social minorities is dubious at best and I don't think we should be so accepting just because they threw us a bone by castiing non white leads. We deserve better than tokenism, so lets enjoy the show cos its fun but I can't praise them for much else.
What I’ll say is that my final summation in this video doesn’t change after having watched all the through the first season and fully caught up on the second. Cheers!
are you serious???????????????? "what version is better"? obviously the 90s version is better theres no competition here thanks.
I obviously disagree lol 😂
@@TheTurnout and you also obviously need to go to bed or school. Only little kids who didnt grow up in the 90s like you dont like the old school charmed. Lol lol Next
Hahaha! How old do you think I am? I’ll take that as a compliment.
I haven't really watched the old charmed but I definitely like the new one so far because it has a good story, characters and CGI.
Although it has all of these things, I do believe that it had some bumps like how everyone is hooking up with each other and the people that are actually friends with them are either irrelevant to the story or the villains. The only friend to them that isn't like that at all is Harry.
I also don't really like how serious it is. Yes it adds up to the drama which I love but it's nice to add in some humor to lighten up the audience's mood in the story.
The old one is good too, but I do prefer the reboot
The only reason why I choose the reboot is because that’s the one I have watched
they're both great! it's hard to watch the new one and then go back for me though.
I can't get into this, feels more like supergirl series than charmed
Bro u missed out on some of the things that the original charmed ones were about
Prue had a full time gig at the auction house that she was amazing at, Piper started as a restaurant maneger then she ran a successful night club P3 Phoebe started out sorta aimless but eventually she went to college got a degree and became an advis columnist. You should watch the original again.
I find it hard to believe you’ve watched the old show honestly
I watched it and a ton of other Aaron spelling shows lol. I was huge into Melrose place.
2:48 you can already tell he only likes the new version because he doesn’t want hate let’s just be honest
That’s a new take, since my liking the new version has gotten me more hate then anything 😂
I love the new one
You and me both!
I like the new one still
They shold remake ghost whisperer too...lol i love d old charmed .i wana see d new charmed first.
Defintiely check out the new one. It’s great! In every got into the ghost whisperer myself though lol
I love/prefer the original charmed, I had to stop comparing the two shows in order to enjoy the reboot. The reboot is a good show as it’s own entity.
I still watch this show. I still enjoy the older shows. Awesome review.
The old one will be in syndication forever. It was great but I think the new one continues the legacy in a really cool way
@@TheTurnout I agree just love the old ones. Actually just watched yesterday that about all I can do right now lol.
Im sticking with the old one
It better in my opinion
That’s one route to take, to stick with the thing you know best and are more comfortable with. There’s nothing wrong with checking out and appreciating new things too though.
@@TheTurnout i already saw it
To me it wasnt that good
I think Niko was based off of Andy not Daryll
I don't agree with you at all. The original was much better than the reboot which is why it lasted twice as long.
But Which Witch is Which?
😂
I dont like the reboot. I watched the first few episodes and I couldnt watch anymore. It feels too quick and too forced. The fact that the sisters are of different races, I think, should not be a factor for how the series is better. As long as the actresses can bring their character to life and make you feel for them, that is what should count. This show did not make me like any of the sisters. Their emotions dont feel real in the show. The twist with their whitelighter was an interesting change that has potential, but I do not like how he was introduced. In my opinion, he was trusted too early. And this whole science thing is cool with the witch craft, but again it feels too forced and too stupid. They beat an enemy with baking soda. In the original series it was not that easy. It wouldnt just take one substance to kill an enemy. Now if they had made a chemical using more than one thing like potion making, then it would make more sense. There are a lot of missed opportunities they could have done. They could have made the series more modern without taking out traditional witch craft lore. The original will always be better in my opinion when compared to this reboot. The original has its own cons as a show, but is overall a show that many generations can enjoy for years to come.
bustkateers4 I agree Like they already mentioning The source of all evil 🤦🏾♀️🖐🏾
Both have their good points
Agreed entirely
Love both series
Being hispanic is a plus? that's racist BS, as a hispanic myself I can tell that could have any ancestry and it should have been the same, not inferior nor superior.
It’s called representation. Wanting to see ourselves reflected in our media isn’t racism, it’s just human nature. But sure, whatever you need to tell yourself to feel superior
In the original, the actresses actually act like sisters. In the new, it feels forced, idc what race they are, as long as the acting is believable.
I loved the og charmed but as a black, dark skinned, witch, gay male I LOVE the reboot. It's good to see someone that looks like me or someone in my family as a main character. Plus I'm loving their character development!
Exactly Blair! You get it! 💜
And like you said it is a reboot of the original
So the new show is better because the character's aren't white... *eye roll*
Also, I'm loving the ratio you're getting.
Thanks for the comment!
@@TheTurnout You're welcome
You noticed that too.
Heyyy hun part 2 please
gotta figure out what could be included in a part 2 :)
In the original charmed Shannen Ds character Pru she dated the cop Andy, Daryls partner. They had a romance in hs then hooked up in the latter of season 1 I think but demons kill him of course
How do you said you are a big fan of the original movie back in the day and I am a big fan now but you do not hit the part where they had different Scripts
When are they going to bring back Alf?
I’d watch it
Phoebe was able to read minds latter on in season 2 or 3
The new charmed
this guy never watched i mean really watched the original
You do know the building off the original?
I will always love the original Charmed. I have all 8 seasons on dvd. I'm busy watching them again. I watched a few episodes of the new Charmed but I stopped watching because they are not the same as the original sisters.
Did you want them to be the same sisters? I was honestly pretty excited to see where else they could take the story with different character. We already know how the Halliwells did stuff, right?
@@TheTurnout I would have loved to see a sequel rather than a reboot. The series ended with all 3 sisters having children. They could have gone with that story. Especially Piper's sons Wyatt and Chris. The sisters could have made one or two appearances just to show that it's still the same show but I would have put the main focus on the next generation. I love your reviews. I just subscribed to your channel.
welcome to the channel! it is very much appreciated! And yeah, a continuation I think would have been less appealing to me personally, since I stopped watching the original Charmed about 6 seasons in. It just got too ridiculous and repetitive to me. That said, it was a great show and I feel the reboot has done a lot of good in bringing the feeling of the original show when it started back to the world (you know, if you ignore all the OG fan hate). 😂
@@TheTurnout I will probably try watching the reboot again in the future but for now I'm watching the original again. I'm busy with season 2 so I still have a lot to watch. I'm just a huge fan of the original actresses because I have been a fan of them before Charmed. Shannon Dougherty aka Prue from Beverly Hills 90210, Holly Marie Combs aka Piper from picket fences and Alyssa Milano aka Phoebe from who's the boss.
harry gets with macy
The new series doesn't have that umph like the original. They strayed from the theme of 3 sisters who happen to be witches. Plus its just wrong for the new to have no affiliation with the original characters and it doesn't look like the writers actually did research on the Wiccan culture like the original writers did.
isislaz well it is a reboot/remake. Not a continuation. So of course they wouldn’t bring back the original sisters. If it was a continuation it’ll be different. And the reboot sisters are latina/Afro Latina. Wicca is a white European folk magic and religion. So it makes sense for the reboot sister to do more Santeria, voodoo, brujeria and other African, Caribbean and Latin magic.
@@tvlover1492 and that's why this reboot was bs.
isislaz ehh I thought it was cool. I just wished they divided into Latin and Caribbean folk magic more.
@@tvlover1492 I tried to like it but it swayed too much away from the original and its theme of it being abt 3 sisters who happen to be witches. The reboot just looks forced. They didn't even give those girls time to grow into their powers. And it doesn't even seem like the writers explored the actual Wiccan/Wicca religion like the original writers did. Not once in the few episodes I watched did they imply the rule abt using magic for personal gain. The sisterhood wasn't forced in the original and they gave its audience time to get familiar with the sisters and their stories which then started to include fighting evil demons and warlocks. This new shit they did ain't it.
isislaz Yea I will admit that although I like the reboot I don’t feel the sisterly connection as much as I did with the originals. You kind of feel it with Mel and Maggie and eventually with Macy and Maggie but Mel and Macy have no emotional connection at all which throws the whole dynamic out the window lol. And they actually did talk about personal gain in the Halloween episode. And I think the reason why they didn’t add the 24 hour window in this reboot was because they were trying to stray away from the Wiccan aspect and explore other magically mythos from different cultures. I was actually surprised and glad they added some Yoruba and Santeria in it although it wasn’t much. I also didn’t like the new power boost they got every five minutes lol. That was rushed too.
I love the reboot and the original.. but the reboot really catches my attention
Me too!
I don't like that Macy and harry are hooking up
I didn’t at first but it’s growing on me 😂
This is clearly a paid review,I literally can’t believe I’m hearing someone say the reboot sisters had better chemistry,mans defo didn’t fucking watch the original cause he’s talking shit start to finish,the acting is awful and one dimensional in the reboot,their plots are not innovative or fresh at all,the CGI fine whatever that’s like the only okay thing,the characters are all super wooden and just immediately get along?. Absolutely no depth to anything,Holly Marie Combs was right,this was made to get profit off the show she,Alyssa,shannen and rose all worked so hard to build. They already get easy views because they used the Charmed name and now get to fuck up the legacy it left behind.
So just to clarify, you don’t like the reboot? 😂
This isn't even a decent reboot...there is no chemistry, writing is dry, acting is dry, to me the reboot is a flop...and dude...by your video, I can tell you didn't really pay attention to the original series that you think you do....try re-watching the original with your ego put on a shelf . Lol..reboot sucks.
Thanks for your opinion, even if it’s wrong. 😂 cheers!
@@TheTurnout Yes it is my opinion, but then by the start of season 3 of original Charmed, the tv show was having a profound effect on tv viewers. The original Charmed had created a culture, a trend that still lives on today. People still binge watch the series. Aaron Spelling did the research on Wiccans, Lores, Mythology, and legends. Characters were or evolved into 3D personas. The "reboot" is really a revamp, that is as dry and 2 dimensional as the paper the script is written on. The show can't even garner a decent share of the 21 and under female viewer market, which it seems the show is trying to reach out to....The only reason this show is still around is because it shares the title of the original Charmed series. That is the only reason YOU even started watching it.
Anyone who decently watched the Original Charmed series knows Prue had telekinesis, with the ability to also mind blast a person into the next room. She also developed astral projection. Piper could freeze time and evolved into being able to blow people/objects up. Phoebe had Premonition, evolved into being able to levitate and also empathic abilities. Paige due to some inherited white lighter, could orb, orb objects, heal, and limited ability in changing appearances. Again, your vid only demonstrates you didn't really watch the original series, probably talked during the show more than watching and comprehending. Cheers.
And I’m sure it has nothing to do with OG charmed fans who won’t give it a chance, huh?
@@TheTurnout I did give it a chance. Hello? Hello? LoL....I watched it because it was "Charmed", hoping it would be close to the original...it failed me LoL, I didn't fail it....smh
Hard to believe, but sure you did 😂
Part way into reboot season two and I have to say they started with the same idea but they are taking things in new ways
Which I love!
In my opinion, you can obviously tell that the reactions of the characters are fake the acting is terrible. There is CGI explosions and editing everywhere every 5 seconds. the storyline in the reboot is jam packed into one episode rather than a few seasons like the OG; in other words it's a rushed storyline and the way they handled everything was unrealistic.
The whitelighter is so untrustworthy
Harry’s a good dude who comes off as untrustworthy at the beginning because that’s the story they were trying to tell. They get over that pretty quickly though and he becomes a huge part of the team.
Lol I agree I'm in season 4 of original charmed .. im over the pheobe and Cole relationship problem that keeps coming back
yeah... that NEVER goes away. lol
Huh, I enjoyed this show too. I had trouble getting into the original series though. I should have hit all my buttons, but I just couldn't get into this. The reboot? Yup, fun and interesting!
Also the reboot is a little more believable in terms of motivation. I hated the original for making the sisters doubt their powers even though it was obvious! I enjoyed Macy going “oh, well, that actually makes sense now” lol
Charmed is my favorite both are good but the reboot is a whole lot better than the original 👍🙅
@@TheTurnout It was always a struggle for the sisters in the original series because they needed to sacrifice a number of things to embrace their new roles as the Charmed Ones. From the reviews and short videos I've seen with the reboot, it seems the motivation part has gone way over the top. Two sisters who grew up together embrace a new half-sister without hesitation and turn to a life of magic then goes on to become an upgraded version of students in Hogwarts. Then they turn into Dragon Ball Z witches with their power level increasing in a short period of time, and then goes on to become Xena warrior witches before the first season ends. I guess that speaks a lot for being believable.
@@andregempesao6723 let them know how you feel 🙆♂️🙆♂️🙌
@@noizusagi6901 Hahaha. My loneliness is gone now. Thanks.
How does Maggie have the same (Black) father as Macy . . .but she doesnt have a drop of black in her. . .in fact. . .she might very well be the whitest one in the bunch. How does that work?
First, genetics is imperfect. Second, look up the actress and have fun. More than meets the eye
@@TheTurnout She's completely Hispanic. . .if she was half black she would look it as black genes are most dominant. Genetics may be imperfect but they didnt at all think this through. Anybody can be black now? I just thought it was a silly move. Diversity is great and all but at least be realistic. Her support group for African Americans scene was so cringey. Dexter Vaughn was deep dark chocolate . . .theres no way in hell it makes sense that he is her father.
But like... also do any amount of research and you'll find that what you are saying is wrong. What you're saying doesn't affect my enjoyment of the show, but it's obviously affecting yours. Checking your sources may make you like it more, but if not, maybe it's not a show for you. And that's cool! You can't like everything. Cheers!
@@TheTurnout what exactly is wrong
Rusty Shields I’ll give you an example very close to home. I’m am a very very black man, but my great-great-grandfather was a blue-eyed white man from Finland (and probably the only white ancestor in my entire bloodline, with the rest being black only). But, that drop of white blood in my bloodline caused all of us (his descendants) to be carriers of European genes, some expressing them while some don’t. I was born with dark skin, deep brown eyes, kinky hair (your typical black man), but my wife is a white Irish lady with blue eyes and guess what, our child is as white skinned, blue-eyed blond girl. The blue eyes gene is a recessive gene, meaning for it to be expressed in an individual, they must have inherited it from both parents and not just one. I passed on my blue-eyed gene (inherited from my Finnish ancestor, through my father) to my daughter, and she inherited the other half from my wife.
What I’m trying to say here is that my daughter is a blue-eyed, wavy blond White girl, with my black blood in her veins. But she is my child, my biological child. Genes work in mysterious ways and that would have been the case with Maggie and her black father.
I honestly love both versions like I cant even explain how hard it is for me to chose. I really want to go with the original but at the same time I stoped watching it when the prue actress left anyways so idk.
After prime left it got better for a while (cause I loved Paige) but then started declining in quality near the end sadly. So far with the reboot, season 1 was strong and season 2 was uneven. If season 3 can bring it back around then we’ll be on the right track
I feel the same way abt the reboot. Season 1 was great season two was kinda weird and I'm hoping season three is better too
You missed out Paige. I loved Prue and I almost stopped watching when she died, glad I didn't Paige was amazing
@@TheTurnout season 1 and strong? Yes the characters are really cool, I love Mel veing gay, Macey veing a scientist and Maggie whatever Maggie is but season 1 was not strong😅 it was rushed af and bad plot writing
Listen it different the oh was good back then and the reboot is good now
The original is still better.
It will always be better.