Arthur said this because Archie (Thomas Downes son) was coming off as hostile and rightfully angry at Arthur for killing his father. I believe Arthur's intentions behind this threat was to intimidate Archie into standing down rather than picking a fight with Arthur as it would only result in Archie's death and Miss Downes losing two family members. Besides if this isn't true Arthur would be throwing an insult at a young man recently made fatherless for no reason, which isn't in his character, even for low honor.
@@boxey8147I don’t know if Arthur technically killed him supposedly he beat him badly and Downes died a few days later which may or may not have been caused by the beating
"We can't always fight nature. We can't fight change, can't fight gravity neither. We can't fight nothing. You can't give up neither, you can't fight your own nature. Our time has passed, John."
@@DeadX2 he had tuberculosis and if u finished in low honor micah killed him with a (Gun) and when arthur reached the revolver dutch stepped on his hand So if dutch wasnt there micah would have been dead already
"We dont have any problem with you sir nor you with us...But if you want to start one, there's gonna be a lot of folks dead in this room before its done" - Dutch Van Der Linde 1899
In a deleted audio when arthurs beating up the odriscoll in the barn he would say, "you wanna tell me what you boys are doing up here before i smash your skull?" He was supposed to be more cold-hearted because in the original script he was supposed to have a baby thst froze to death in the mountains
"I'll kill you again in hell my friend".
- Arthur Morgan, Low honor ☠️.
What's the high honour equivalent?
Bro when Arthur sees Micah in hell
@@charlieambriado”I have brought you a pretty flower feller”
I think he says this after killing a few civis outside of towns regardless of you honor .
I got something like this but I can’t remember if it was the same or not but I was max honor
“But you said you knew Spanish”
“Senior, Por favor”
“Damn, that’s pretty good!”
Aqui
“I could see it in her eyes, the way she looked at me”
Mans that ain’t no line
@@dylanowens1787it’s a joke lol
@@callous2k486 yeah I know
Last one is wild
bro is based af💀
Adolf Hitler senior
"🙋♂️🇩🇪"
🇩🇪
That shit was uncalled for 😭
"you eat babies" is a classic
-John Marston
A certified hood classic
No I do
“I eat BERRIES”
@@Blank-n1t Ofc u eat everything with that caseoh pfp
"Ill keep her in black on your behalf" is Unbelievably dark and twisted
Fr lmao
Arthur said this because Archie (Thomas Downes son) was coming off as hostile and rightfully angry at Arthur for killing his father. I believe Arthur's intentions behind this threat was to intimidate Archie into standing down rather than picking a fight with Arthur as it would only result in Archie's death and Miss Downes losing two family members. Besides if this isn't true Arthur would be throwing an insult at a young man recently made fatherless for no reason, which isn't in his character, even for low honor.
@@boxey8147he never should've borrowed the money
You're a good man Arthur Morgan
@@boxey8147I don’t know if Arthur technically killed him supposedly he beat him badly and Downes died a few days later which may or may not have been caused by the beating
"You sir are a fish!"
I think the most obvious best quote is “revenge is a luxury we can’t afford”
”This land is no such thing as civilized, its man so in love with greed he has forgotten himself and found only appetites.”
"We can't always fight nature. We can't fight change, can't fight gravity neither. We can't fight nothing. You can't give up neither, you can't fight your own nature. Our time has passed, John."
You sir are a fish
aww its a toy boat!
No lol
I didn't realise I was talking to a "lady"
“Does this trolley goes to Tahiti?”
Don’t forget the quarter
@@muffinman-zd4gdshut up arthur
Nice profile pic
@@chasogamo A man of culture, I see.
Tahitians I guess
The emotion in John’s “F*cking” gave me goosebumps
Pause 😭
okay now take the context out of this comment and see the magic
Rob Wiethoff is an absolute golden human being. From his acting to his character as a person. Such an amazing actor
“OH , it’s a toy boat!” Is one of the best
The best one is " I have lumbago john"
Herbert moon failed art school.
He ain't racist he hates everyone and is possible the ancestor of Eric Cartman
Last one is straight up racism 💀
No really ?
Let him cook
Nah it's da truth 🗣️
👨🏻✈️🇩🇪
Mmm nope
"You sir, are a fish" - Arthur Morgan 1899
"who live in tahiti"
"Tahitians i guess"
The last one hits the hardest
its relatable
It doesn’t for me tho me and my friends use it everyday
Wtf is wrong with y’all???
@@SquigglesMcJiggleswhooosh
Last one specially hits Europe in 1942 I think
« How’s this train you stole from us »
« Which one »
- Dutch Van der Linde 🥶
"Bertram like sherry" is a good one
Last one is just racism 💀
I thought it would be like John screaming at him after😭😭😭
No, everyone has an opinion.
@@TheSmileGlaze 💀
@@I-quit609 "I don't like natives, now that you ment-"
*raspy whisper*
No
"Can't even beat a dying man"-Arthur morgan
Except Arthur was getting destroyed lo
@@DeadX2 he had tuberculosis and if u finished in low honor micah killed him with a (Gun) and when arthur reached the revolver dutch stepped on his hand
So if dutch wasnt there micah would have been dead already
last guy is me fr
Bro what 💀💀💀
"Dont forget the quarter"
"When I'm gone they'll just find another monster. They have to... because they have justify their wages."
🥶🥶
“Revenge… is a fools game.” -Arthur
_"Is it your street ?"_ was so damn funny to me. 💀
Arthur has the best cold lines
“Vengeance is a fool’s game” -Arthur Morgan
"Just you, is it?"
"Yeah. Just me."
“YoU eAt BaBiEs!!”-John Marston
‘You sir are a fish’ 🥶🥶
Cringe
"Some of us, sooner than others"
-Agent Milton
“Tell the Devil Red Harlow Sent You”
-Red Harlow/Uncle
Red is not Uncle
It was never about the money”.
- red Harlow
John’s is the best one 🥶
“Don’t forget to tell the devil, *Red Harlow* sent you.”
“You sir are a fish 🐟 🤠”- Arthur Morgan 1899 (probably)
I’ll keep her in black on your behalf literally sent chills down my spine
"We dont have any problem with you sir nor you with us...But if you want to start one, there's gonna be a lot of folks dead in this room before its done"
- Dutch Van Der Linde 1899
Red Harlow: open the damn door women
"you venerate savagery and you will DIE savagely"
The last guy is just an average Instragram commenter
"Your The First Man To Have Half His Brains Eaten by A Wolf And End Up More Intelligent!"
“You sir”…
… “A r e A F I S H!”
"We die alone, but we live amongst men" John Marston's most underrated yet badass quote
"When Something happend dont look back"
This quote is Uderrated
“I’m your old friend amnesia”
First one is always gonna be coldest 🥶🥶
“You eat babies”
-John 1911
"On your behalf" - 😀
I relate to the last one
Nice, also Bigfoot didn’t eat babies, I did 😋
CASEOH?!?!??!??!?!!?!?!?!?!
casoh
You probably banned the babies…
caseoh
@@danim8414 where can a guy like me get some hot sauce around here?
the last one is the coldest quote in human history
"it's dangerous for a man to lose his brains... Especially on such a nice floor"
-arthur
I was waiting for" I had a god damn plan! Arther
"Don't forget to tell the devil, Red Harlow sent you. " -Red Harlow
In a deleted audio when arthurs beating up the odriscoll in the barn he would say, "you wanna tell me what you boys are doing up here before i smash your skull?" He was supposed to be more cold-hearted because in the original script he was supposed to have a baby thst froze to death in the mountains
Herbert moon is undoubtedly the goat
Herbert moon to cold with it 🥶🥶🥶🥶🥶😈😈🔥🔥🔥
Herbert moon would have solo'd the entire van der linde gang and its time people realised it
@@IrishGuyForfeitEnforcer yea them zombie really nerfed him, We gotta see Herbert vs Bertrum in a short
"I have lumbago john! Very sick"🥶
"People don't forget. Nothing gets forgiven."
“You sir are a fish”
-Arthur Morgan
“I guess we have to die sometime”
“Power is like a drink you have to have more”
I can’t remember if that’s all he said but
“YOURE DYING BLACK LUNG!!!”
“yeah and you’re dead…inside you’re dead.”
Herbert Moon is always so damn relatable
that last one was just uncalled for LMAO😭😭
Mr Milton, this is America; You can always CUT a deal!
thelast one is so relatable
Revenge is a luxury we cannot afford.
Last one Is so sigma
Micah: You can fight but you can't think
Arthur: You can do neither
😂😂
Beta Arthur voice lines🥶
Herbert Moon is just something different bro
Bro the armadillo general store merchant doesn't like anybody, that's why john just sits there as he screams and gets teared up in undead nightmare😂😂😂
"Just you now is it?
"Yeah just me" i think it goes like that
“But you said you knew Spanish…?”
“ITS JOHN MARSTON MICAH”
“I got lumbago, John.”
“LenNY”
Rip van winkle
Don’t forget the quarter
Does this trolley go to Tahiti
Tahitians I guess
You eat babies
You sir are a fish
And ifc revenge is a luxury Ee can’t afford
“you couldn’t even shoot a fart out of your own a$$”
Last one is so real
"You sir are a fish" 🥶🥶🥶
Nah this is the best one
"damn you"
"TENNIS BOAT"
Bro the last one💀💀
Fun fact: shortly after this discussion Herbert Moon changed his name to Alois for whatever reason.
last one is mad relatable
The last one is the coldest one 🥶
The last quote is relatable
Last quote was the realest shit
The last one’s pretty fire
The first one is the most wild in my opinion
"Ahhh I broke the goddamn wheel"
Arthur Morgan
Last one is literally me omgyat
"Damnit!! I broke the god damn wheel!"
The first one sounds funny if you boost up the audio whenever john talks
"That loan you took... it's payday"
“Mi nombre es John marston”
First and last lines go HARD
Were the hell is our time has passed John
"We're more ghosts than people"
“What’s your name?”
“Rip Van Winkle”
The last one was a real one 🗿
That’s all there is livin and dyin!
Micah Bell II 🥶