The Impact Of BukhariGate | Distinction Between Hadith & Sunnah | Mufti Abu Layth
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 04. 2023
- Clip taken from the weekly Wednesday night livestream, Meaning with MALM #39 | Dispelling The Satanic Verses
Watch the full episode here: czcams.com/users/liveQNeDSprV...
Instagram: / muftiabulayth
Patreon: / malm
Bukhari gate made me realise the Quran perhaps isn't full of the clear lies in sectarian religion (and I've since seen the Quran is a book of logic). I agree that hadiths are good historical narratives but we shouldn't put it above the Quran . Unfortunately many Muslims do this without realizing.... thank you for welcoming many and helping to open their eyes Mufti saab
❤
So much of “islamic” practice comes from Hadiths with less than questionable narration chains-Even the Hadiths regarded as Sahih were mostly verified by questionable means, ones that any scholar outside Islam would not hold as reliable.
I look at Hadiths as interesting historical artifacts, but not to be trusted-God authored the Quran, to say that God’s pen 🖊️ and his writing hand are not enough-Seems a slur against our maker.
We must trust that God has given us all we need to know, without delving into flawed men, even ones called companions.
I loved your bukhari gate series. you should go through the fabricated hadiths and also books like faza'il amaal and the fabrications
Eid Mubarak Mufti sahab your beacon of light to many of us. May you and your family be blessed abundantly in this world and hereafter. May Almighty enlighten the hearts of those you follow you. May Allah always keep you happy
Salat 🧎🏻 is a perfect example of Sunnah that wasn’t documented.
Yes we are so glad, والله it is without a doubt the most important topic for us today, and only you could have done it, what you Mufti spoke in another episode about the 2nd coming, when you mention about not being in a group minhaj you can see things much more clearly, I have bounced around so many different groups since I became Muslims many years ago, I just wish you had a greater platform, I love you for Allah Mufti Abu Layth
I thank you a lot of bringing up the tradition of Ahlul Madinah. People are too reliant on Hadith for rulings without looking at the actual practices that has been done by the Sahabi and Tabi'in as they were mainly Ahlul Madinah themselves.
God I miss the old you mufti .. you were my knight in shining armour
I love you with all my heart and Eid Mubarak
I am proud of you for doing bukhari gate
Eid Mubarak my wonderful Mufti!
Im a maliki now do to the Aml Ahlul Madeena concept.
I used to have doubts about the deen bordering onto kufr.
That was because of some hadiths that didnt make sense to me.
But once I understood the Aml Ahlul Madeena I realised how sunnah should be understood.
In fact it beautified the sunnah for me personally.
Alhamdulillah been Maliki for a good couple of years now and even in the future if i change, my doubts are now gone and I full heartedly pray and i full heartedly believe and love the sunnah.
Alhamdulillah.
What hadith did not make sense
Alhamdulillah
@@redx11x like in Bukhari where is mentioned that Rasulullah صلى الله عليه وسلم
Tried to commit suicide more than once by jumping off of a mountain top or that he was stricken by magic or that he became forgetful of the Quran or that he couldn't remember which wife he had slept with, after being promised in the Quran to be protected by Allah from the people
@@richardanthony3267 ill answer your first as this is well known. because you have so little knowledge you end up having doubts precisely because of your lack of knowledge.
It isan ESTABLISHED FACT, that what you have stated as being "hadith" is not part of the hadith and Iman Bukhari made this clear. Ibn Hajjar even explains this. The hadith in Bukhari is split into two intentionally, one part that deals with the actual hadith, three second is an addition by the reporter or one of the reporters.
Why did you not look at what the commentators have said about why there is a split in the commentary by Bukhari?
@@redx11x obviously, but I think the brother is talking about the position Bukhari holds in the realm of the Umma today, it's actually a book that the Muslims will defend to the point of where they're basically saying that the prophet can be mistaken or commit acts that go against the fundamentals of what the Quran teaches, but Bukhari cannot be wrong, nobody is saying that the book itself doesn't contain hadith that are sahih, The problem is that amongst the general عوام المسلمين it retains a position that gets defended against the better of the teachings of Islam in its entirety, it will be hard for you to find a normal Muslim who can differentiate between الثارالصحابه و قول الرسول، I'm not against Hadith، and I do comprehend the difference between the saying of companions and the saying of the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم، unfortunately, the layman Muslim isn't as educated as you seem to be in regards to accessing the books of the شرح of the hadith, I understand but many do not, I think the main point that should be made is that bukhari should be subjected to the same critique of the اسناد as all the other hadith books,
Mufti sahab please make a session on how to approach hadees?? Should we belive 100percent in hadees or ignore completely or be doubtfull about hadees...
It is true what the Mufti has said but always remember do not leave the principles and doctrine of ahle sunnah Al jama'a.
You should continue to make those videos
You open my eyes on Hadits after 20 years of practising
I refer to hadith as analogous to "raw data" in statistics. From this raw data, a narrative has to be alembicated and extrapolated. The narrative thus extrapolated is "the sunnah." Those qualified to do said extrapolating are the madhahib.
Eid mubarak great mufti saab as shayk madinah al malicki hazrat d.a. madinah!
Love you mufti sir😀
How can you distinguish between Sunnah and Biddah
Both are transferred through our parents with "Twatar"
We look upto Imam Malik and his teachers
@ Mufti Abu Lath. With what you have said in terms of Hadith that can be wrong. Why is it that a review of Hadith not be done to remove those that do not match the Quran?
Imam Abu Hanifa gave the example of Taraweeh as a Sunnah not mentioned in the Hadith?
What do you think about "Sahifa of Ibn Munabbih"? Is it authentic?
I waiting for Seerah gate. Not all seerah are realizable...
Salam Mufti! Hope you're doing good.
Mufti sahab can you have a discussion over Quran with Hasan Allahyari?
He makes a point that Tawatur of Quran breaks at era of Usman. Before that, people differed over it. What do you say?
I think no body can defeat to hasan allah yari because he is specialist of saha e sitta books.
Can the Bukharigate full video link be posted?
Hey it's on this channel. You can search for it by typing mufti abu layth bukhari gate and you'll get the videos
Whens the new lives?
Dr jakir nayek said we should believe Bukhari like quran . Can you make it clear please?
did he really say that??
@@noamaneslaitane as far as I understand yes
@@mohammadhaque9168 if he said that, he has committed shirk
@@mohammadhaque9168 zakir naik believes in many bad hadiths .
This guy isn’t really a mufti is he? May Allah guide us all
he is.
May Allah guide you to Sheikh everything haram except Al Saud .. assim Al hakkem and everyone bans me dr zaaakir naik ..hahahahahaa
Abu na-laiq.😅