BYD Seal - A Superior Electric Car with some serious Flaws: FULL TEST AND REVIEW
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 06. 2024
- Compare the BYD Seal with other cars from the #ElectroExam:
www.todoselectricos.com/elect...
00:00 - The Electro Exam
The video begins with an introduction to the #ElectroExam, a segment that reviews and evaluates electric vehicles. The host, an electric car expert, explains that this episode will focus on the BYD Seal, a mid-size electric sedan from the Chinese manufacturer BYD.
00:43 - BYD Seal Specifications
The video presents the specifications of the BYD Seal, including its size, battery, range, and power. The host highlights the car's 82.5 kWh LFP battery, which provides a range of 495 km according to the WLTP cycle. The electric motor's power output of 530 horsepower is also mentioned.
02:03 - Design and Exterior of the BYD Seal
The video discusses the design and exterior of the BYD Seal. The host praises the car's sleek and sporty design, which includes slim headlights, fluid lines, and a modern look. It is also mentioned that the 400-liter trunk is not the largest in its category but is sufficient for most users.
05:50 - Range and Efficiency Test of the BYD Seal
The host conducts a highway range test at 120 km/h. The BYD Seal travels 334 km before running out of battery. The average consumption is 24.7 kWh/100 km. The host notes that the actual range is less than what the manufacturer claims, but the car's efficiency is good.
09:56 - Charging the BYD Seal
The host tests charging at a 360 kW fast charger. The BYD Seal takes 27 minutes to charge 49.4 kWh, which allows for an additional 200 km of travel. The host mentions that the charging speed is fast, which is a significant advantage for the car.
12:44 - Interior and Quality of the BYD Seal
The video examines the interior and quality of the BYD Seal. The host praises the spacious and comfortable interior, which includes high-quality materials, ventilated and heated seats, a glass roof, and a central touchscreen. The high-quality sound system is also highlighted.
15:45 - Performance and Driving of the BYD Seal
The host reviews the performance and driving of the BYD Seal. The car accelerates from 0 to 100 km/h in 4.08 seconds, which is very quick. The host notes that the car's handling is good, but the regenerative braking could be stronger.
21:42 - Technology of the BYD Seal
The video reviews the technology of the BYD Seal. The car includes a large central touchscreen, a high-quality sound system, a driver assistance system, and a voice recognition system. The host notes that the car's technology is modern and user-friendly.
27:10 - Driving Assistants
The host discusses the driving assistants of the BYD Seal. The car includes a level 2 driver assistance system, which can maintain the lane, control cruise speed, and automatically brake in case of an emergency. The host notes that the system works well, but would prefer a more audible alert when it deactivates.
28:56 - Final Score
The BYD Seal receives a final score of 75 out of 100. The host notes that the car is a good option for those looking for an electric vehicle with an attractive design, comfortable interior, decent range, and fast charging speed.
33:50 - Conclusion
The video concludes with a recap of the BYD Seal's features. The host notes that the car is an excellent option for those looking for a modern, technological, and high-performing electric vehicle. - Auta a dopravní prostředky
If you hammer a petrol car along at 120km/h you won’t get anywhere near the claimed range (consumption) either!
As a Model 3 owner I have some comments having extensively test driven both the Premium (single motor 82kWh) and Performance (dual motor 82kWh) Seal versions.
The Seal is a “Grand Tourer” (Gran Turismo you called it). The BYD engineers have set the acceleration response and regenerative braking for comfort and smoothness. And to drive like a conventional automatic transmission instead of one pedal driving, which they believe is more efficient. The initial part of the brake pedal movement is still regenerative. One pedal driving in a Model 3 can be very uncomfortable for passengers if the driver is unskilled (or uncaring).
Tesla has sacrificed material to save weight and the Model 3 feels noticeably flimsier than the Seal, both inside and out. Effectively the Seal is carrying the equivalent of 3 extra adults around. But the Seal feels more “premium” than the very spartan Tesla.
I agree the Seal would benefit from having a warning chime when the Auto-steer disconnects and have the speed sign warning being visual rather than aural. These are both features of the current Tesla software standard and would be easy to implement in the Seal by way of an update.
Android Auto and Apple CarPlay are both wireless in the Seal in my country (NZ). The fact the Seal has a driver’s display, HUD and indicator stalk is a plus in my book. That you compared it to the BMW, Hyundai and Polestar instead of just slavishly comparing to only the Tesla Model 3 is to your credit because I believe the Seal is more competition to those other cars.
My test drives produced consumption of 142Wh/km for the single motor and 148Wh/km for the dual motor Seal over my standard 60km route (Tesla Model 3 is 130Wh/km over same route). It is mixed driving, so for the Performance model you drove I am likely to achieve 500+ km.
Of note also is BYD have just announced the “Blade 2” battery with 180Wh/kg instead of 140Wh/kg for the current Blade Battery. So that would mean a range of 700km if they stick with the same weight battery, as well as retaining the advantages of the LFP chemistry.
Best Review I have seen. Well done. I love my BYD too. In Australia I got the Premium version (middle) for 56,000 AUD (34,000 EUR). Incredible price 62K AUD on road, 6K AUD government rebate. VERY Happy.
Thanks David
So, did I miss something? What are the "some serious Flaws"? Or is it just a click baiting title? 3 points short of the highest score, and again what are the "serious Flaws"?
Software route planning is non existing. It won't route through chargers or even tell me what battery % I can expect upon arrival
Accelerator response is poor for a sporty version
Serious flaws and absolutely not clickbaiting
@@TotallyElectric I see, those are "major Flaws'. Well, I wouldn't have clicked on the video if it weren't for the"major Flaws'". So yeah, it's a click bait and you know it.
@@TotallyElectricjust use a better route planer problem solved
A better route planner helps but he is no substitute for systems that integrate real battery percentage and dynamically calculate the range. Systems from Volvo Ford BMW and Tesla do this better
They are absolutely major flaws if you want to use this car for road tripping
I have BYD Seal Excellence. Fabulous car and i love it! 🙂 Thank U for good video.
Me too.
Thanks for checking it out
What is maximum range you get in excellence model ?
It looks and feels really great. Would be nice if they improved on the UI though. For example that beeping when you go beyond speed limit. 5 clicks to go through menus to disable it and you have to do it every time... On a Tesla it's 1 click.
Why dont you use the shortcut to turn off the sign recognition to remove the beeps? Just slide finger from top to bottom. Takes like 3 seconds that way..
You can adjust your own shortcuts also.
This was not enabled in this software version and has only been added later
Fantastic review
Thanks
Excellent review! So much depth!
Thanks Charles
Good review. I recently bought the BYD Seal AWD and I am very happy so far. It's a great car, far superior to my previous ICE car. I am getting a much better range when driving ECO and not exceeding 100km/h on the highway. Mixing in with urban traffic I can get to a 500 km range for a full charge. Android Auto works fine without the cable.
Excellent review thanks
Thanks for the review, it's very interesting. I looked on your website and you haven't tested the Highland Model 3 Long Range...... It's a question that splits many motoring journalists but would you buy the Seal or the Model 3? There are things I like about both.
I will be testing the long range Model 3 in a few short weeks and give a full comparison by then
Nice review. Note that the small delay in gas pedal input is a feature not a bug, at least in China people prefer this as it otherwise makes passengers sick ... so it's a comfort issue.
But sure, there should be a setting for that ideally, perhaps also adding one pedal driving .. both could be easily OTAd.
And with the delay in acceleration it does not make passengers sick? Don't know about that, because after the delay the acceleration still kicks really hard if you press the pedal a good amount
@@IceW4ve The idea is to minimize jerk under normal driving so the computer smooth the acceleration changes.
This happens "naturally" with ICE cars because there is more inertia in the drive train unless you're talking about tuned performance cars that try to minimize that.
It's also why some people don't like strong regen and one pedal driving because every minute change in foot pressure causes acceleration or deceleration.
I tried that mode for a while but I settled to weakest regen instead and the drive is a lot smoother.
But as I said, it should be trivial to have a slider in the car system where you could tune this as you wanted.
I hear the Xiaomi has very good fine tuning of many parameters, not sure if they have one for input smoothing.
When I first drove the "new" Corsa back in 2003 it had a similar problem which was caused by the drive-by-wire system having delays, and I think this is a similar issue in this car. A driver can adjust to the responsiveness of the system, and drive comfortably, but having a delay is just downright annoying and potentially dangerous if you need to take evasive action to get out of trouble. BYD please fix this!
Great review! We'll done 👍
Thanks
I test drove the RWD here in Chennai, where BYD now has as assembly plant the atto3 and ev6 r assembled here and the seal is a CBU at this stage… the car is planted and has good paper … it puts a lot of sports cars to shame… check my review here
Latest update the speed warning will not reset after car turn off. If using sport mode, the kwh will be higher even if you babied the padel. For good efficiency better to use normal or eco.
We drove the Premium model, which is the middle model in the line up in Australia. It was very good, however I thought the Polestar 2 single motor long range was a better drive. It came down to price and the BYD is hard to beat beat at its price point. When it came to a novated the lease the BYD does not offer any discount, where the Polestar offered very generous deals. The Polestar will get my business. I am not a fan of fixed pricing.
Great review - very detailed. I've always wondered why car reviewers don't review night driving as the headlights are an extremely important part of the car, and you completely overlook that aspect. I hear there is an autonomous high beam assistant like on the BMW. I wonder how well it works.
That's true. I found the headlights in the BYD Seal decent but not up to the level you get in a mercedes, BMW or even Polestar with their adaptive matrix LED lights.
Love from India.
Saludos al canal .Por favor ingenieros de BYD activen al seal conducción a un solo pedal y los kw de media cada 100 km que es más preciso que cada 50km.
La inmensa mayoria de usuarios se lo agradeceremos
one pedal driving is hard on the leg.
Bonjour.
Je roule en BYD SEAL identique à celle de l'essai et ma consommation moyenne sue 3000 km en France avec route et autoroutes est de 16.4 kw au 100 km. je fais surtout des parcours de 250 à 450 km .Je ne recherche pas pendant ces parcours ce qui est très économique puisque je recharge à la maison. Je suis vraiment très satisfait de ce véhicule.
You encourage 100% Chinese!
In Canada we have factories of automobile manufacturers GM, Hyundai, Toyota, Honda, I will encourage my workers here.
before Chinese workers.
I encourage 100% electric.
We dont need geopolitical opinions in any car reviews, please stop that and take it somewhere else...
@@allanudsen8525 It is not in any way a political question to encourage local workers.
If everyone buys Chinese without worrying about the economy, there is a problem you will face one day.
@@foxgood Where was your phone manufactured. The majority, iPhone and Android are from.... China. As the germans said "maybe America should make better cars"
@@foxgoodI appreciate your feeling brother for indigenous workers
but these days
Adoption to electric vehicles
Is most important thing
American cars facing quality issues
Because your govt don't put them in
Pure competition
I checked in showroom. The Doors closed with a solid clunk like a German car. Can owners comment on this aspect?
Great bloody car
Your accent is intriguing. Can you tell me your nationality, and where grew up.
I’m hearing Dutch with time in USA maybe. Or possibly Spain with school time internationally ?
Very good flowing English is second language.
Close. I am Danish but live in Spain.
I've got the Seal Premium and consistently get 500km+ range at high speed
No one gets 500km at 120 kph travelling speed.
The range is 530 WLTP, which is typically 20 to 30% above real world highway speeds in the best of conditions.
I have yet to try an EV with real world 500km range at highway speed. Maybe the Model S long range, but even the model S Plaid was less than that.
I should add that this is the Seal Premium, which has a WLTP of 570km.
@@huntchris I have the Seal Performance (AWD) and i get 450km at 100km/h. Have not tested at 117km/h but 330km would be very close based on calculation.
My seal premium regularly has a range of 550 - 610klm .... no clue why your claimed range is a little over 300k's
Driving at 120 km/h or on a regular combined driving cycle?
As the car only has 530 km off official WLTP range, it is hard to believe that you would get more than that. A typical highway range will be 25 to 35% below official WLTP
Of !
@@TotallyElectric In Australia the WLTP is 570km for the Seal Premium
Not an extra point for the karaoke on board? Bummer!
Should have done that!
I'm getting 17.7kwh/100km on my performance. Wonder why your efficiency is so bad.
Driving at 120 km/h consistently?
What will you get maximum range at performance model ?
@@TotallyElectricbro I needed this video
Because people run at 120kmph these days 👍🏻
Most EVs or ICE with see a dramatic increase in energy used when jumping from 110 km/hr to 120 km/hr. EVs , regardless of make, always seem to get hammered on this in reviews, whereas not as much attention is given to PHEV or ICE. Before I got a BYD Seal Performance, I had a 530e. Figures quoted about 4.5 to 5 l/100km. Rarely, if ever, saw below 7l/100km, with a mix of urban and motorway driving.
czcams.com/video/4N_0qB13Kkc/video.html Range in Australia around 450kms and efficiency of 14.4kWh per 100kms
Just take into account that I do tests at constant speed of 120 km/h which is different from the driving shown in the video.
3.35...rear left ???
Yeah sorry. Other "left"
This is how easily I turn off speed alerts in my Dolphin. The process is the same with the Seal. czcams.com/video/JiXh-9Pa4WM/video.htmlsi=b1Fl3RcaEPigxpqs
Thanks for the tip
key looks like mini coffin
Click baiting title! There isnt serious flaws!
Not being able to give me a proper range is absolutely a serios flaw. So is turning off lane keep assist without warning as soon. As it hits 122kmph.
Minor issues. Who’s driving at 122km per hour daily???
@@MrRobertjusher umm.. many people? And in Germany many are driving over 180 km per hour, and that is like the max speed the Seal will even go xD
@@IceW4ve you want to drive at 180kph on lane keep assist?? Death wish
Tesla Seal?
Very comparable!
@TotallyElectric Hardly. Maybe some shape similarity but that's where it stops! Seal actually has a high quality, comfortable and stylish interior. Tesla is like a waiting room at suspect doctors surgery..😊
Crap car, better to stay away from it. Not to mention the amount of depreciation...rather extreme.
What all the so-called experts in the West seem to not understand, is that the Chinese never develop anything, except a long time ago maybe the gunpowder and the spaghetti, but they are experts on making cheap copies.
Pure luck that Tesla got everything they wanted, and more, when building GF3? Of course not, the Chinese immediately bought Teslas as soon as production had started, and analyzed them into the smallest detail, and then their production could start.
But what they still haven't been able to copy is the software. That's why they always are close, but never there. E.g. one-pedal driving, it takes more than just running the motor backward. Yes, you get regen, but never the instant breaking that a Tesla has. And the touchscreen response? Same thing.
Yes, I think that eventually they will figure it out, but then Tesla has moved forward, and the Chinese, like every other copycat, will still be far behind. And then there's FSD and OTA...
I fully agree that they have a lot to learn on software and have highlighted several things in this video that could be done a lot better. However, do not disregard them, believing that they never innovate They are catching up quickly
@@TotallyElectric
Oh yes, They are definitely good at catching up, I myself am on my third China-made smartphone and I've loved them all. But, as I said, this time they try to catch up with a moving target.
EDIT: I forgot, I just found your channel, and i just love it. It is so different from most other, similar channels. Absolut a like and a subscription from me.
Braking. Breaking means damage.
I think if you visited China you'd be surprised just how advanced and innovative they are in a lot of areas. China now issues more patents than the US.
Really not sure what you points are... "Pure luck that Tesla got everything they wanted"? Maybe we have a different interpretation of what "pure luck" means. Too bad for the rest o the world who can't even copy things right. Look at the Germans, the Japanese and Detroit, let alone the rest of the car making nations. Where the heck are their viable EV's? The only one that manages to have decent software is Tesla, even that is a painful growing process, and that is the nature of software. Who else has automotive software? And by software, which layer are you referring to? Are you referring to ADAS or the basic management or UI?
Once you have someone in front of you, you are forever playing catch up. So again, what's your point?
可以多关注中国市场上发售的byd，因为他们不久之后也会出现在海外市场，可以提前了解下