Stephen A. AGREES with Steph Curry! THE BEST PG EVER! 🔥 | First Take YouTube Exclusive
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 05. 2024
- On First Take, Stephen A Smith agrees with Steph Curry about his status as the NBA’s best PG ever. Plus, Stephen A. Discusses notable matchups in the 2023-24 NBA schedule, headlined by Celtics vs. Lakers on Christmas Day.
Tune into all the latest CZcams Exclusives from First Take across our ESPN CZcams channels.
✔️ Subscribe to ESPN+ espnplus.com/youtube
✔️ Get the ESPN App: www.espn.com/espn/apps/espn
✔️ Subscribe to ESPN on CZcams: es.pn/SUBSCRIBEtoCZcams
✔️ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on CZcams: bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoNBAonESPN
✔️ Watch ESPN on CZcams TV: es.pn/CZcamsTV - Sport
For those that didn’t catch the whole conversation Steph basically said if you ask him to pick between himself and anyone he’s always gonna choose himself, but he knows Magic’s resume is top tier and he’s still got work to do
Always lobe that he points that out.
Exactly. It's also ridiculous, everything points to Magic Johnson...the only argument people make is Steph's "impact on the game" with the 3s which mean there's no argument. Magic did not grow up with a 3 point line, I'm not giving Steph or Harden or even LeBron any extra credit cause the math got figured out during their era.
@@supavolit’s not even about the match it’s fact that dude hitting from any where
@igotjokes4ya340 Magic has a higher career FG% than Steph. 52% to 48%. He just never shot 3s cause no one really did back then. Magic a 85% FT shooter so he had touch.
@@supavolwhat if Steph came into the league with the mvp on his team💯
Steph’s most recent championship run was masterclass
Not really
@@chriswright8074why not?
For real best defense in the league w defensive player of the year at his position + celtics were targeting only him the whole series + legendary away game 4 performance
@@therealwelfin it doesn't matter , Celtics made it to the finals in 2022
@@chriswright8074 Yes it was Celtics were unstoppable they beat MVP Greek Freak and the best teams then Steph put the Warriors on his back and got the title proving one thing he can win without KD but KD can't win without him🤷facts are facts. Plus your just A hater so
Not to mention, Steph has shown that he’s very much capable of being a “traditional” point guard at a high level. However, for the system he’s in (which he is the system) the way we often see him play is what has gotten them 4 chips.
With only 1 finals mvp & Wiggins should've got that one lol.....
@@yuryberrios7003 you probably also believe that Andre Iguadala deserved the finals fvp when he got it. lol
@@yuryberrios7003Which games in that finals was Wiggins more impactful than Curry?
@@yuryberrios7003he should have 3 fmvps to be honest 2015 he deserved 2018 he deserved and 2022 he finally got
Magic led the Lakers to a championship in his rookie year and winning game 6 without Kareem to seal the title
He had a Superteam… never had a mediocre team. Magic is among the greatest, but come on… a little bit of honesty goes far…
Won FMVP has a Rookie
Worthy and scott wasn't there magic's rookie year and Steph played on a super team too after they choked. And he wasn't even the best player on his own superteam... Let's be honest
@@MauMauBinghiI hate to break it to you bro but neither was magic. Kareem was by far the best player their first finals. David stern gave magic that finals mvp not the voters.
@@MauMauBinghiin 2015 it wasn’t a superteam sorry. People like you revise history so that even the 2022 team is a superteam. 😂
Magic orchestrates the floor by passing the ball right where it needs to be. Steph orchestrates the floor by moving without the ball and killing defenses with it, making the opposing team think about him constantly on potentially being open, and also thinking that his teammates might get open, as well, because of the gravity he's creating. Both the same idea in terms of creating plays, but just with different trademark styles.
Everything you said was just art.
when steph answered sent a chill down my back fr , he is the real deal
Magic Johnson is not only the greatest point guard. But hes the greatest player of all time. He could play every position on the court. He won on every level...
God, that was such a genuine answer because you could see it in his face. He really didn’t wanna go against Magic but he knew what the truth was and this is coming from a guy who will probably watching Magic when he was younger so you know it’s an authentic answer.
it's called ESPN talking heads doing anything to grab headlines and get clicks.
@@AnHebrewChildik they’re running a business but it is still possible for said talking heads to be honest. Stephen was hired for his opinions. They’ll make him talk about a certain topic, but I don’t think they force him to take a given position on said topic.
This is a really hard one for me. Based on the definition of a prototypical point guard's duties (floor general, primary ball handler, getting others involved, initiating the offense, etc...), I think Magic Johnson is the greatest "traditional" PG. Regarding Curry, like Stephen A said, his movement without the basketball is unbelievable, and he is a dangerous catch and shoot player. Reggie Miller was similar, but he was a SG not a PG. Steph Curry doesn't fit the definition of a traditional PG. He isn't the primary ball handler on the team and to me he is too offense-oriented to be a true PG. He plays more like a SG. But since basketball has evolved so much over the years, I think we can say Steph is the greatest "modern" PG. So now putting the two players head to head, what do you prefer? Traditional or modern?
Magic by far is the greatest PG the NBA has ever seen. Stephen A is an idiot
Good points , I prefer the traditional point guard like Magic, Nash , Stockton , Cp3. Curry is more of a scorer than passer which is why it makes the debate.
What do you mean he is and the primary hall handler ? I think he is I agree with everything you said but that one part
Position were made for novices…what matters is the effect the player has on his team ….before kerr ..steph played the traditional point guard role …then turned to an absolute beast and so did the team cause they unlocked what his best asset can do for the whole team…tony allen was a shooting guard but he is known for his defense nobody feared him on offense …curry challenged the old school half court pace and turns out that style cant hang with the new era pace …curry getting penalized when he has won 4 chips for playing off ball is crazy 😂😂😂
@@yayarea5109That makes him a SG, not a Point Guard
Can’t spell “Stephen A.” without “Steph”
😂😂
Cringe
😂😂😂😂
My mom came out as trans
@@TransKidsMafia 🫤🫤🫢😂
Sounds like he's describing a shooting guard instead of a point guard
so in your perspective, Luka is also a point guard,,,,
@@thannypadlanlukas most definitely a pointguard
@@theoo149 and so is draymond, jokic, lbj
notice nothing Stephen A said had anything to do with being a actual PG just his shooting
All these "PG" "SG" "SF" "PF" "C", are just NBAs versions of Weight and Height Classes These "positions" don't mean anything in the NBA.
Being a “true PG” isn’t the question. It’s about who’s the best player at the point guard position. Just because Jokic shoots threes and sets up a lot of his team’s plays doesn’t mean he’s not a center.
@@obi3924 False parallel. SMH
He said multiple things… you might just have selective hearing. He brought up Leadership, Impact, off ball floor generalship essentially, Playmaking, and making his teammates better.
@@Da_Summersoldierhe doesn’t do any of those better except off ball 😂 when magic was a rookie Kareem got hurt & everybody was sad. This dude walked in the locker room and said “never fear magic is here”.. a rookie 😂 Steph don’t got that type of leadership
What Stephen did in that 4th chip run solidified it imo the offensive juggernaut he was averaging 30 through out the whole playoffs i think second in ppg in the year was Jayson averaging almost 28 throughout the playoffs but eventually fell due to lack of experience and fatigue but what curry did in the playoffs that year was unmatched
So.. in a sense.. he’s a 2 who just so happens to play the PG due to his size
@@BourneKnightis jokic a pg or a center?
@@Handlehosyler Jokic actually plays like a center which includes posting up, blocking shots, and rebounding. Green is the architect/ best passer on warriors offense.
@igotsixringsniggaWell, his attributes are quite the opposite as those of a true PG. CP3, Magic, Stockton are true PGs whereas Curry is the lowest in the assists & steals categories as a PG. So much for being a GOAT at the position.
@@BourneKnight Ngl man if you think green is a better passer than curry you dont know ball. Gotta remind myself to stop posting comments on social media lol
Impact? Steph revolutionized 3 point shooting. Magic Johnson literally saved the nba. Idk about this one.
Hmmm we could argue that more than Magic, Jordan saved the NBA. Steph changed how the game is played. Then again these comparisons make no sense given how dramatically different their impact is on the PG position.
bro stfu u dummy talking about saved😂😂 steph better
Magic did that alone?
@@LETSROCKTA no, no no no. The nba was literally going out of business until bird and magic saved it. Jordan took it to another level but Magic and Bird are directly responsible for it even existing. Nba wasn’t even live on tv until bird and magic.
@@LETSROCKTAmagic and bird saved the nba! They wasn’t even playing live games on tv until
Those 2 came
Steph got it. And by Steph having it there's no disrespect to Magic, but this man has changed the game on offense & defense for the foreseeable future and he has all the hardware to back it up. 🐐
Magic brought the flare of passing. Michael changed the game for scoring guards. AI gave everyone the street crossover. Ray Allen and Reggie Miller brought in the lights out shooting mentality. Put it together you have Steph's influences. The NBA changing the rules against hard defense to allow high scoring games is why Steph is so dominant in this era. No hard fouling anymore. Sooo its Magic, because his game was transcendent beyond rule changes and eras.
This is really hard. But Steph will always create space for all other players on his team. If you made an all time team and picked Steph at your PG then Jordan, Lebron, Kobe or whoever you choose as your wing players will have so much space and isolation opportunities more then if Magic was the PG.
Yeah it's unfair to compair eras because players overall will just improve. But that being said nobody is picking Magic over Steph as their pg on an all time team. So that basically answers the question, and the gap is only going to grow wider over time
The NBA changing the rules against hard defense to allow high scoring games is why Steph is so dominant in this era. No hard fouling anymore. Sooo, its Magic, because his game was transcendent beyond rule changes and eras.
Steph has been my favorite player since 2013. I even jumped on the “Steph is the best PG ever” bandwagon. But the truth is MAGIC did so much with such a short career. Go look up his heroic performance in the finals as a rookie. I gotta give the nod to magic. Now if Steph gets 5 rings it’s a wrap.
How? What does he do that makes the team better when on the FL besides shooting 3's😂😂😂😂that's it. He doesn't make anyone better, he just can shoot 3s and really good at it, but that's it
Gotta remember stephs doing this at 6’ 2 maybe 6’ 3…, that’s unheard of… a player that size leading a championship only other one I can think off was Isaiah Thomas imagine if Isaiah had 4 rings at that size
@@edwinwashington6288this how I know u a casual,Steph DOESNT just shoot threes,HES a great playmaker,he can finish around the rim,he can play on and off the ball,HES a good midrange shooter,HES also a average defender,he can basically do everything on the court,and his film shows that,so cut the cap bruh
@@edwinwashington6288casual
@@edwinwashington6288Imagine truly believing this is a true claim when the man been the only one on his team who's consistently generating 20+ on/off court plus/minus impact swing seasons after seasons. Like that stats in the finals vs Boston was mindboggling. The team had 80-some offensive rating when Curry sat on the bench,, and the mark jumped to close to 120 when Curry was on the floor. Magic don't generate such an impact to his team,, ever! And Curry constantly had such an impact on his team and a casual like you somehow don't call him a PG just bcos somebody else playing point forward role got more apg (not by a wide margin anyway) than him. Caasual 😂😂
Magic still the best PG of all time but Steph is right there on his heels.
Steph is not a PG.
@@melvinhhcp3615thinking of basketball positions in their traditional roles in 2023 is unbelievably outdated and invalid
@@melvinhhcp3615 Thank You 💯
no0 he isn't steph isn't and hasn't passed Big O
@@DoubaComps The history of the game far supersedes 2023 norms sir.
It’s a tough one. I got magic still at 1. BUT Steph is definitely in the conversation. If Steph gets one there still a conversation but Steph edges. If he finds some way to get 2 more the conversation is dead. The thing that hurt magic was he wasn’t in the league long enough. Steph’s game translates when he gets older. He might be the only player with 4K 3s made and the efficiency he does is crazy. So Steph is in the conversation.
Almost all the final the warriors won, step was not the best player in the team.
@@vayduong68062015 i know they gave it to Iggy, but Steph was better. 2018, I actually believe that Steph and KD were in the same level, so it comes down to personal preference, and 2022 which obviously is Steph
@@valber7472 2022 he is good but Wiggins was the man in that series
Actually impressed with the thoughtful discussions this question is bringing
Magic made the game popular His leadership was amazing I mean he made an impact as a rookie winning Finals MVP
Important thing to note is his 3p efficiency with how many shots he takes because that’s what is insane
Steph is the most lethal offensive player in men’s United States pro sports history. That’s my opinion
Mannnnn. Steph is my favorite player ever but that’s a bold claim. Offensively Steph is a top 3 player ever. Saying he’s outright the greatest is… I’m not certain how I feel about it. I want it to be true bc he’s my favorite, but I’m not sure I agree.
@@specialknees6798 I’m taking Steph curry’s offense over anyone, and I’m sleeping well with that take too
I really liked the point Gil made about Magic being a point-forward or something to that effect; the man started at centre when he was required to. Bron is a similar player. The way the game is being played today and the direction it's headed in, PG's are gonna have to have a little bit of everything in their bag. Guys like Dame and Trae are also helping redefine the role.
Steph manages to affect opposition defenses in ways that achieve the same results as more tradition ball-in-hand guys like CP3 do; open up the floor, collapse the lane, ruin matchups, control the tempo of the game, get his guys wide open shots and ultimately get these W's.
It's a more nuanced argument than that, but the point I'm getting at is that a great PG has to do and be more than just a floor general. Steph has just evolved faster than I think a lot of folks were prepared for, and right now, he's the apex predator at his position.
All that being said, it's a lot of combo guards coming up who are creating their own niches, finding different ways to be effective on and off the ball. Nikola, Giannis and Joel are doing the same thing at the other end of the size scale. It's gonna be a time when the position listed next a players name is meaningless, and as a fan of the game, I'm here for all of it.
I still have Steph at 2, in my personal opinion, although Steph is a way better shooter, Magic had the ability to lead an NBA team, his skills on the basketball court were phenomenal and what awards he was able to earn while in the NBA solidified him IN MY OPINION as the best PG. It is clear Magic Johnson is the best due to a combination of his leadership, basketball skills, awards, and his ability to make all of his teammates better players.
Me too magic is still number 1 bt if Steph get more ring I put him number 1
Only thing I will say is Steph has always been the leader of his team. It’s tough for me too.
@@michellesmith684Same with me then. 2 more rings to make it no more a debate tho
@@liamcephus9687 not until Kerr was signed.
Yea Steph need one more ring to solidify it
Seems like the 3-1 2016 finals have disappeared . Couldn’t imagine if Lebron, Kobe, MJ blew a 3-1 lead in the finals we would never stop hearing it
Bron got 6 Finals losses. He's not even in the conversation.
You talking like Adam Silver wasn't involved.
Are we forgetting that Lebron got swept in the finals?
Lebron got swept multiple times and Completely Disappear in 2011 finals while having the best roster in the NBA I don’t wanna hear nothing Lebum also has the record for the Most turnovers in NBA history
@@R2Holloway13so did Kobe with prime Shaq what's your point ?
They should have had a panel for this question
Magic gone see you soon for this take Stephen A. 😎💯
Magic had a bigger impact on the game . He along with Larry helped get it from tape delay to what it is now . Magic has 5 rings yes he had Kareem but steph had kd for 2 and also a stacked team .
Lolol. Magic team wasn't stacked
“Bigger impact on the game” this is insane
Curry is literally better than him he can do everything magic does on offense besides dunk and the only reason magic defense is better is because he's taller dude not even a PG fr
@@piplonf8591 Magic was a PG. Knock it off.
Majority of teams that won the chip were stacked
If durant doesnt go to golden state were not having this conversation
It's not even a conversation. Curry changed the game. His impact on the game is next to MJ.
@@badalshakya3635 analytics changed the game not steph
@@badalshakya3635Magic SAVED the game
@badalshakya3635 without Magic Johnson, there wouldn't be a game to change. Magic saved the game
@@sean24833 sure kid. Curry is the reason teams take so many 3’s idiot. Not analyzing freaking bozo.
1:17 - whenever Steven A says this it has me weakkkkk
Asffff 😂😂😂😂
Larry Bird had six seasons shooting 3Pointers well over 40% each season. If it wasn't for his terrible back injury, foot spurs etc. and him sticking around too long playing too hurt, his stats would be even better. During his unparalleled 3 year in a row MVP run where the Celts won 2 NBA finals including beating Lakers, Bird was in the 42% range for 3s every year.
I LOVE watching Steph Curry play, but Magic Johnson is the greatest point guard ever. Even Michael Jordan, the greatest PLAYER ever, calls Magic Johnson the greatest POINT GUARD ever.
Won a chip as a rookie, played all 5 positions during that 1st chip when Kareem Abdul Jabbar got hurt, made REAL no-look passes, moved like a locomotive at 6'9" with that size as a point guard, and put together 5 chips dominating the league with Kareem. Magic was SPECIAL.
the thing is you cant compare current player with older gen as the definition of position changes.
Oh man I can’t wait to hear this one 😭
No one cooks up that sauce from the trey line like The Chefff 🔥
if he gets one more, i agree. for now, it's still Magic, although it is very close
If he gets one more he would still have inferior accolades compared to Magic. But it would be a more interesting conversation. Magic was NICE, bro.
@@SojiRo23 no doubt
@@SojiRo23why because five championships in an older worse era is more valuable than five championships in todays game? Magic only should have four cuz they fixed it for them one year against the pistons. Go back and watch the foul called on lambeir or edwards(can’t remember) against Kareem in the last seconds. Tell me if that is anything close to a foul and remember that that wasn’t a foul, pistons win the chip again. And then add the one curry got fixed against when they fixed it for the cavs. Curry actually got 5 and Magic got 4
I don't think it's as close as people think but hey that's just my opinion. I like to ask people a simple question, if you are building an all time team starting 5, are you picking Magic over Steph for the point guard? And I think there's an obvious choice unless you are biased and that's no disrespect to Magic. That being said, some people argue Bill Russell is the greatest bc of his accolades etc so talking about accolades and career that's an argument, so maybe they rate Bill Russell higher than Shaq based on that but it doesnt mean he's better than Shaq. This also gets into the MVP conversation, does it mean the best player in the world or the best player that season? I just think Steph is overall a better player
@@Qdawwg your right. Go watch some bill Russell highlights. He is basically a short Deandre Jordan with a worse shot. Bill russell wouldn’t even play division 1 college basketball if he was magically transported into todays game
Magic had big impact from day 1. The Lakers went from missing the playoffs to championships
The Lakers made the playoffs the year before drafting magic and Kareem was the mvp of that season.
@@jaydot4956 Exactly. The Lakers were far from bottom feeders when Earvin got there. What Bird did in turning around that Celtics squad in his rookie year, was honestly far more impressive. Magic was sensational, but he basically turned an already pretty good Laker team with a still established #1 guy, into a bonafide title contender.
Both are the best pg of all time. It just depends if you want to play big or small according to the opposition because both are pure excellence and hard to say one or the other.
What if you could still hand check and chuck players when they come off screens and come into the paint would he still be able to just play free flow basketball its blows my mind that nobody seems to bring up the rule changes and how much of a inpact that has had on shooting
STEPHEN A. has and always will be obsessed with Offensive players. I'm sorry but I cant put Steph over Magic when the only thing Steph does better than Magic is shoot. Magic was a better Point Guard which they play, a better defender, a better rebounder and was just as Winning as Steph. He came in as a Rookie and filled in for Kareem in the Finals, had immediate impact and etc. Steph needed years to be a factor and needed help to develop. Steph isnt even the best set up Man on his team
Facts
Steph has better gravity, more movement, far more handles. Curry has added alot more wins for his team when he is in the floor. And Steph still has years to play anyways
@@dinni.7073 So if Curry surpassed Magic and most people got Magic over Kobe, then is Curry over Kobe?
Magic ain't guard nobody!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 0 none zip nada not once not one not ever
Magic was also the size of a PF at the PG position
Someone please tell me what makes Steph a point guard when he doesn’t even bring the ball up the court.
he absolutely does bring the ball up the court? draymond does occasionally as well but the ball is in stephs hands at the beginning of the possession 90% of the time
Bringing the ball up the court makes you a PG? Lol alright.
@@diez5778bringing up the ball and facilitating the offense does. Draymond & Wiggins do that more then Curry
Y’all be saying anything. Not even going to argue.
Lol old heads swear they know ball. Ridiculous take. Do you even watch the games or even watched at least 10 magic Johnson games lol
Id like to see curry and magic in the same room, with these types of questions and see who gives who more recognition for each other's talents on the court and let the chips fall where they may
Stockton is just so looked over when it comes to point guards. Even though he holds not 1 but 2 all time records. No he doesn't have a chip, but as far as individual stats i think he should be in the discussion
Pure insanity! Magic is undisputedly the best
For me, Steph has an advantage over Magic when it comes to building your best starting five. Not the best 5 at each position, but starting 5 that would fit their games well with each other. Steph's range is such a cheat code, his game can compliment the best of the best. like MJ would better with Steph than Magic, Lebron would be better with Steph than Magic, etc.
Magic would
Make great players better
@@abdeenabdul7803Steph straight up created an all star/hof career for Draymond Green.
Exactly, if you are building an all time team there is nobody who is picking Magic over Steph without being extremely biased. It's Steph every time and honestly an easy choice. And so that should answer the question right there, and that's no disrespect to Magic I just hate when people pretend it's closer than it is, or say "oh if he gets one more chip then maybe he passes magic" like no sorry but he already passed him
Having Steph on ur team gives him u an advantage that other teams can’t have and can’t stop. He’s nasty
0:35 this was an epic Stephen A pause
It’s crazy just the clip of the interview made news before the interview even released.
When it comes to PG, I think of CP3, Jason Kidd, magic, and nash. When I think shooting guards I think MJ, Kobe, wade, and yes curry. Draymond is the point guard of the Warriors.
Exactly Curry is a shooting guard, that handles the ball due to his size. If he doesn't score his impact on the game is minimal, whereas Chris Paul or Rondo can dominate a game without putting up huge numbers. He's the greatest small shooter we've seen for sure, but he's in a class of his own. I wouldn't say he's a better facilitator than Chris Paul, and Chris could score almost as well. If I was a GM I'm taking Chris Paul on every team except the Warriors. These conversations are just talking points for lazy news days, but Curry is just a unique shooter and that is how he should be remembered. This BEST argument is getting old, because these folks switch their answers any way the wind is blowing.
Absolutely 💯
@Paul.Burrell You do realize Steph can facilitate?
@@cfhar080591 Any body CAN facilitate, but can he facilitate like Chris Paul or Rondo. They are saying he's the best POINT GUARD, and that is what the position requires. Chris Paul can DOMINATE a game with 11 points, Steph cannot. He is just another body without his scoring, no different than Lillard or Iverson, or many of the other smaller shooting guards. That is just a fact. It's no slight on him, but his strength is shooting, Chris Paul is a better point guard because he has no weaknesses and is a st team defender. So no Steph isn't the best point guard ever, he's not even better than Chris Paul.
curry averages 7 assists per game over the last 10 seasons
While Steph isn’t a traditional pass first point guard he excels at being one of 2 greatest off ball movement players ever. Coupled with arguably the best ever gravity with teams consistently paying attention to him which in tow gives others easy buckets off double teams. If unassisted assists were a tracked stat Steph would be the nbas leader in this department.
Who’s the other guy? I thought consensus was that Curry was the greatest offball mover ever by far
I thought the thumbnail of this video said Stephen a agrees with Stephen a. LOL 😂
Hard one, it's like picking passing vs. shooting
Steph is just like Magic: a non traditional PG that changed the game. An anomaly.
Magic was a SF parading as a PG. He walked so the likes of LeBron could fly. Sure, he ran all the base stereotypical responsibilities of a PG at a high level, but he also heavily benefitted by being the ONLY 6'9 PG in league history. And being drafted by the team with the GOAT of his era. But it doesn't diminish his accolades and accomplishments. He broke the mold.
Steph has a similar impact. He runs the team based on the pure principles of a PG but his approach is one of a kind. He is the extension of the coach on the floor, and makes plays for his teammates to thrive. However, he goes against the stereotypical ideals of being a playmaker. Hes not the guy that pounds the ball most of the clock and is looking to make the immediate pass for a score. He doesn't prioritize getting assists to validate being a playmaker because hes truly unselfish. He's fine with creating opportunities for the NEXT pass to be wide open. He promotes ball movement from the ENTIRE team with his gravity. Thats why the warriors have been one of the leaders in team assists throughout their dynasty. But lets not get it twisted: when you are unequivocally the GREATEST SHOOTER EVER, with the ability to shoot off the catch, off the dribble, and from unprecedented range, you have an impact unlike anyone else in nba history. Sure, he played with KD, but KD came to HIM. (I dont see people diminishing Wade for playing with LeBron, so keep that same energy.) And aside from igoudala, the rest of his core has been homegrown, with a revolving door of talent surrounding them. Yet he still led them to relevance and prominence.
Magic is bigger, won more, easily the best passer ever, and helped save and shape the league going forward. But he's also offensively limited, not a great shooter, subpar defensively for a guy with his physical tools, and left some game on the table due to his "extracurricular activities"
Steph is easily the more offensively gifted talent, an underrated passer and playmaker, honestly about the same defensively as magic without the physical tools to supplement (I'd argue today he's a better defender since he's put on muscle) but he was also a late bloomer with his ankle woes.
Ultimately, Steph is more relatable than Magic, and i think that makes him slightly more impactful. It took almost 2 decades before the next "Magic" could grace the floor (Lebron). But in the past 8 years Steph not only broke the mold on whats acceptable in the league today, but directly influenced the type of talent prevalent in the league and around the world. Look at Trae young, Damian lillard, jordan poole, Luka, etc. And look at different leagues from all age groups. The deluded idea that you think you can shoot like Steph has (for better or worse) changed players approach to the game.
It's a toss up on who the GOAT PG is, but there's only 2 candidates. And depending on your preference, you're not wrong.
But don't diminish the other on faulty principles. They are BOTH non traditional and BOTH anomalies.
I'm personally team Steph. But its close. How about you?
Curry literally flew across country to beg Kd to join his team. You Curry fans always lie about the situation and say Kd went to them but it was the exact opposite. Curry will always look weak for that.
@@tahireedThat's a lie but keep being the media's puppet dawg lmao
@@savonsanders3955 Do you live under a rock? Curry himself said they flew to the Hamptons to ask him to join the team. What do you think happened? Hahahahaha 🤣
@@tahireedno actually Draymond made the call to KD. Magic never had to beg though because he had a top 3 player of all time with all of his championships. How many top 3 teammates did curry have? That’s what I thought lmao try again
@@jjcoolboyify Try again? Hahaha
Curry blew a 3-1 lead and then listened to the real leader of the team, Dray, and they begged Kd to join. You just proved Curry cant even lead himself. Can't blame Dray. He knew Curry couldn't get it done against LeBron and Kyrie so he got Kd to join. Cowards.
I have seen Steph without Draymond and it didnt go so well. Dray is the PG on this team
That is statistically not true, look up how he played last year when draymond was out.
@@connorheidebrecht1440he played bad!!! They sucked
@@blackjesus2082😂
Absolutely right,he is just choke volume shooter nothing more,absurd to put him with those names even near come to playmaking
Lol yall just mad any of ur team's pg isnt in this convo
Finally! someone has finally said it!
It's Magic. To me he's the best ever. I will say the fact that Stockton is hardly ever mentioned in this debate is kinda ridiculous. His steals and assist numbers are untouchable.
It really depends on how we are defining “point guard” because that definition has changed. Point guards were not called on to score like they do now. So if your using the new definitions then yes steph is the best but if you are using old definitions it’s magic
They are basically saying who is the best player to play the pg position not necessarily who was the better point guard if that makes sense.
@@jaydot4956 ahhhh fair
Steph would have done better in Magic's era than Magic would have done in Steph's era and that kind of answers the question for me tbh
@@Qdawwg totally disagree. The physicality and hand checking would’ve affected him a great deal. He wouldn’t average nearly as much. Magic would’ve averaged a triple double in this era
@@ringbellz1062 you need to be able to shoot and space it doesn’t matter how good of a floor general you are. Look at Ben Simmons, and I know that’s an unfair comparison but people would just let magic shoot threes wide open idk if it would translate…
Tired of the whole “you see kids wanting to shoot 3s “ so curry has impact. Yes, he does to an extent . One could argue that he also destroyed the league cause not everyone is curry beyond the arc.
Yeah, and we're all tired of this same argument that has been mentioned many times that he destroyed it too.
@@MervinMasajo people said the same thing about mj, saying his 1v1 style of play destroyed the game.
Big facts put respect on his name
I got Magic #1 and I don't think it's debatable but I'm happy Steph answered the way he did. He didn't come out and say he is the best all time pg he just answered a question and every player should either answer that way or state they are at least trying to be the best
Steph is NOT a PG. He's a 2-guard.
Yeah because draymond is a point guard
Steph is a PG. Just because he doesn't play like a traditional one, doesn't mean he's not one
Exactly. People keep saying I’m hating but when I think of PG he’s not even a true point. Magic, Stockton, Kidd, Isiah, nash are true floor generals. Steph is an undersize 2 that is listed at PG like A.I
By y’all logic of the person running the offense wouldn’t that make Lebron the best PG of all time?🤔
@@vintagemonte Agreed
I would love to see Steph try to stop Magic 🎩🪈💯
What about magic trying to keep up with steph though
Magic would get cooked by Steph
@@vantejackson8358 Lil boy, you probably werent even born when Magic played 🤱 Steph only cooks small PGs 🤦♂️😭 Yo pampers need to be changed 💯
Magic can't stop Steph when he pulling up from 30+
@@GumbyDaGreatWith all due respect my friend, Curry cooks the best defenders in THE NBA. How long haven’t you watched an NBA game? Sincerely. Because your comment can’t be serious. Have a nice day.
Magic is universally loved and respected. The resume is there. Curry is right there in the conversation. Im a Warrior fan and Steph is everything here. Im not ready to put Steph over Magic yet but he’s right there. But Curry has impacted the game as much as anyone ever.
Zeke is in the convo. Less offensive help with more defense than both of them.
Steph curry finally getting the respect he deserves
But, he didn't do anything to deserve it.
They really need to stop over-glorifying offensive players with no defensive team selections . I’m sorry but you can’t be the best at a position with no defensive team selections or DPOY🤷🏽♂️. All the other greats at their positions have those things
Thankyou, well said.
Magic was never known for his defense bro what are you talking about?
@@obi3924lmfao exactly he could play 1-5 but doesn’t mean he was great
Thank you!!!
@@obi3924 This applies to Magic as well.
2nd to Magic dude was Finals MVP in his Rookie season and he was force to retire at a prime age of 32
Gotta go with Magic here. He did it all in less seasons as well, having to leave the game in his prime due to HIV (Not gonna count the 32 games he came back for years later, in which he still played at a high level)
Steph is a shooting guard by style of play.. This is the era of position less basketball. He's an undersized shooting guard.., like AI and Kyrie. Magic's passing ability is just as unique as Steph's shooting ability.
He can play traditional tho.. but why limit his game to that?
Bruh at the end of the day he’s still a PG. Steph can avg 11 apg if he wanted to but draymond doing most of the passing.
This is just Stephen a being a Stephen curry fanboy like usual no objectivity at all he’s not magic Johnson smh 🤦🏾♂️
Career Résumé…Total Achievements: (Titles, MVPs, Finals MVPs, 1st All-NBA, 1st All-DEF)
1) Jordan = 36
2) LeBron = 30
3) Kareem = 29
4) Kobe = 28
4) Duncan = 28
6) Magic = 20
…
To put things into perspective, Stephen Curry only has 11…he’s not even close to the great ones.
…
NBA Titles:
Magic = 5
Curry = 4
…
MVPs:
Magic = 3
Curry = 2
…
Finals MVP:
Magic = 3
Curry = 1
…
All-NBA 1st Team:
Magic = 9
Curry = 4
…
NBA Assist Titles:
Magic = 4
Curry = 0
…
Career triple doubles
Magic = 138
Curry = 10
…
Curry is not a true point guard. You have to be a facilitator of the team in order to be a point guard. He is more of a shooting guard. Even Curry himself admitted in an interview that Draymond Green is more of a point guard than him. LeBron James and Draymond Green are better facilitators than Stephen Curry. Magic will always be the greatest point guard of all time. Case closed.
Gils Arena show always must see TV!!!
Agree, Steph Curry is the greatest PG of all time, he changed the game and his impact is out of this world
Steph is rightfully placed as the greatest shooter of all time and his impact on transforming the game is just as great as well. That doesn't make him the best "point guard" ever, though.
Greatest shooting guard arguably, greatest point guard still magic
I feel like there are some pretty big name shooting guards you seem to be forgetting… Curry is the best player at the 1 spot. Whether he fulfills the role of a traditional pg is irrelevant, because he adds greater value to the team with his scoring and off ball abilities. If Steph acted like an old school pg, he’d just be Chris Paul with the greatest jump shot of all time. Steph is far more than that.
When he bounces the ball, it's like a pass to himself. Well said sir.
So if Curry surpassed Magic and most people got Magic over Kobe, then is Curry over Kobe?
This whole question is cap. Neither Magic or Curry play legit defense. They're only offensive players. Kobe was an time great offensive player & an argument can be made that he was a Top 10-20 defensive player in league history. 9x All NBA Defense 1st Team, 12x overall. That's Top 3 ever next to Duncan & Garnett. We could probably add Wilt, Russell, Hakeem, GP, Stockton, JKidd, Ben Wallace, Ron Artest, Tony Allen, Bruce Bowen, Dennis Rodman, Sidney Moncrief, Mark Eaton, Karl Malone, David Robinson, Pippen, and Drexler, but Kobe is still right there with them.
Nobody got Magic over Kobe unless you a super Magic fan or a super Kobe hater
@@melvinhhcp3615 I don’t agree with it, I’m just questioning people’s motives when they come to these all time ranking. A lot of these list be on selective polticin stuff and when people make these all time list they don’t keep that same energy for everybody else.
So many fan are so insistent on putting Curry over Magic but when it comes to Kobe being in that convo people don’t want to go in that rabbit hole. Kobe always get the short end of the stick when it comes to these all time ranking but they change their criteria of how they make the list when you give them the evidence otherwise.
I bet you if I told Stephen A Smith about the Kobe aspect, he will have Magic over Curry. I say this because last time I seen Stephen A Smith top 10 list, he had Magic over Kobe
@@Grievous_ A lot of people got Magic over Kobe, even Stephen A had Magic over Kobe with the last top 10 he made & shared on ESPN
@@anthonycelestin3559 Stephen A doesn't make sense.
Stephen A Smith talking about the impact Curry has made when Magic and Larry saved the league.
I think losing to the Cavs after being up 3-1 should be a factor in this topic.
@@DeeRG Steph has never been the best player in the finals.
Whoa we are in a new era! They actually acknowledging us here on the Tube okay okay "they're learning"
Anybody with logic knows what’s going to happen when there is a 6’9” guard going against a 6’2” guard.
Magic is better but height is not a valid argument.
@@michaelthreepeat magic is better because of its height. It would be a different story if both of them were the same height.
Humility is completely lost on this generation. It used to be looked down upon to talk about yourself like that
Facts 💯.
the f u talking bout, the moment young players are humble you criticize and call them soft and no having no drive
@@EduFabolousPeople admire humility not arrogance... although in America im starting to wonder.
@@EduFabolous nah, that makes no sense
@@GrandmasterZen at least they used to. Jordan, Kobe, Magic, Bird… none of them have EVER claimed to be “the greatest”. They always gave reverence to the guys before them. That’s respect. It’s lost in this generation
Career 3pts % over .42 and he doesn't take easy 3 in the corner with nobody around him (S/O PJ Tucker I love you champ😊❤)
Man is double, triple 😂😂 and he doesn't care, cash most of the time
Love him
He and Magic are the best PGs that have ever played the game. No need to fight iver 1 and 2, both are absolutely amazing on their own.
The game today is so different than on magic's era that you might say they are different sports.
**We live in a positionless world** but he's not a point guard, lmao
I think magic still got it by a slim margin
Slim? Ridiculous
Hes far better pg than curry i still dobt have curry over cp he just shoots better than all these guys on a team that compliments shooting 3s
I feel like Stephen A is the reason “Marksmanship” is a word in today’s vocabulary! 🤔
I can sort of agree with Stephen A Smith said Steph Curry and Magic were tied for impact. For him to say it's definitively is kind of a stretch. It can be a pick em depending on what your team needs. Magic was a ruthless competitor, can't say the same for Steph Curry. Steph Curry's value to his team is so great, that I don't think GS wins without him, but the same can be said with Magic.
He’s not even a pure pg
Magic wasn’t either, 6’9 is not no dam pg
@@ninety8grovebaby701 height has nothing to do with being a point guard
He is bro stop what you doing
@@Freddy-kw5hqthank you
@@ninety8grovebaby701magic was pure bro lol
Plz Magics impact as a 6'9 point guard changed the game. 10 finals 5 rings. Greatest passer ever.
ESPN u wrong for not clipping just at least the convo 😭😂🤌🏾
To me Curry is the best Pg ....we all have our favorites or who we think is the best at what position .....Steph is the best PG of all time in my opinion
Dam Right!! ✌️🙂
Magic Johnson's converse is under the armour of Steph curry Steph without question
Curry's performance in the finals against Boston put him above Magic to me. Steph is on my all time starting 5. Curry, Jordan, Duncan, LeBron, Olajuwon.
Guys, here we are forgetting something. Something that the statistics do not count but all of us who have seen Curry play know it:
1-Curry stretches and deforms any defense until it breaks without even having to touch the ball.
2-Its enough for him to run through the screens and panic seizes all the opposing players and the attention he attracts makes them make mistakes in rotations that lead to easy basket for their temmates.
3-If thats not a way to give assists, then what is?
4-We have to invent an indicator that calculate this impact because like Curru this is unprecedent.
5-We can't say that about any other player in history. Not even from you MJ.
6-Even so, i still believe that Magic is the best pure point guard ever
With point guards you have to split the category in my mind. Pure pass first guys and then scorers. Would be smarter to not look at position at all though. Just talk about him being the greatest shooter of any position and one of the greatest scorers. Given their system he should be compared against historic SGs and some wings.
Magic Johnson has been my Goat of all times for many reasons, including the fact that he played the game with so much love and passion, also for winning 5 championships, including his first championship as a rookie and to win that final game of the series without Kareem, and he only played like what 12 seasons? Magic also still has the most triple double in NBA history and did it as I mentioned before 12 seasons. I’m saying all of this to say that Curry is the only player I have been able to compare to Magic as far as not only the way he plays the game with that same love and passion but so far has 4 championships, and of course he is the best shooter in the history of the NBA, I don’t believe he is done winning championships and think that he will surpass my beloved Magic but again I don’t minded at all, Curry is well deserving of being in my mind the Goat!!!
I think the impact of how Steph Curry changed the game compared to the impact that Magic had keeping the nba popular is really similar. Because if Magic and Bird don’t appear…who knows if the league is like it is today. As mainstream. So both dudes don’t have the same kind of impact, it’s different. But both very important
How quick ppl change they ideas