The brothers Karamazov, Part Two | DRAMA | FULL MOVIE
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 09. 2023
- Based on the novel by F.M. Dostoevsky. The tragic story of the Karamazov family takes place in the Russian province at the end of the 19th century. The relationship between the father and three brothers who are completely different from each other is complex and contradictory. One of the brothers is accused of murdering father, which he did not commit. The brothers are unable to help him, and only a loving girl follows him to hard labor.
After the death of director Ivan Pyriev , work on the film was completed by actors M. Ulyanov and K. Lavrov.
IMDb rating: 7.7
Year of production: 1968
Director: Ivan Pyrev, Kirill Lavrov, Mikhail Ulyanov
Screenwriter: Ivan Pyryev
Composer: Isaac Schwartz
Cinematographer: Sergei Vronsky
Art director: Volkov Stalen
Starring: Andrey Abrikosov, Andrey Myagkov, Nikulin Valentin, Yevgeny Teterin, Sergey Kalinin, Kirill Lavrov, Mikhail Ulyanov, Ivan Lapikov, Osenev Vladimir, Danilova Alexandra, Georgiou Georgiu, Pavlenko Pavel, Khvylia Alexander, Filippov Victor, Stanislav Chekan, Tamara Nosova , Korkoshko Svetlana, Urusova Evdokia (Edda), Pertsovsky Mark, Pyreva Lionella, Yukhtin Gennady, Kolpakov Viktor, Podgorny Nikita, Prudkin Mark, Korneva Lyubov, Bubnov Nikolai, Prokopovich Nikolai, Chuvaeva Olga, Vlasov Ivan, Volshaninova Rada, Dianova Zhanna, Matov Vasily, Varvara Popova, Yury Rodionov, Pavel Strelin, Mykola Parfenov, Alexey Stroev - Krátké a kreslené filmy
I red the book 60 years, love Russian Literature, I am I can see now this adaptation very complex history about God, family and life. Thank you for showing
Although I love this adaptation, I feel a little sad that some of the side stories aren’t there; the Grand Inquisitor, Captain Snegirov and his son, Ilyusha, Kolya Krasotkin and the boys and their friendship with Alyosha … this book has so much to offer … maybe I am being too greedy, but I wanted it all!
I know! I would need to be 6 hours though. Imagine how good it would have been!
@@emilys9524 Oh, at least six hours. Probably more. That’s why I don’t think a film would work for a book this size (the 1958 one starring Yul Brynner and William Shatner was hugely disappointing) but a good mini series of maybe six one and a half hour episodes (just an opinion, nothing more) would be about right for an English language version (speaking of which, ITV in the UK made one in 1964 but it doesn’t seem to have survived. I think it was wiped.)
There’s a lot going on, what with all the side stories (though they do help to break things up a bit and stoke up the tension.) Here are some of them:
Ivan’s tale to Alyosha about the dogs, the general and the boy.
Ivan’s tale to Alyosha about the young girl who died outside in the cold after she was mistreated by her parents.
The Grand Inquisitor (obviously.)
Ivan’s duel with the devil.
Captain Snegirov and Ilyusha, further augmented by Kolya Krasotkin and the young boys as their friendship develops with Alyosha and the compassion he draws from them towards their dying friend.
Father Zosima’s memoirs.
Katerina Ivanovna, the embezzlement story and Mitya.
Grushenka, the miser, the Polish officer and all her escapades.
Fyodor Karamazov’s backstory.
Father Zosima and the mediation in Mitya and his father’s inheritance dispute.
The heated scene between the Orthodox clergy after Father Zosima’s death when corruption set into the body early.
I know that everything can’t be covered but there is a lot to cover with a huge cast of characters.
My mom worked as housekeeper for a writer when I was a boy. He had grand library. Doskyosky's crime and punishment was the first of his novels I read. I have been a fan of good Russian literature since. Read brothers Karamazov some time later, fantastic to see the movie 🎉
Hadnt read Crime... Karamasov shocked me though. Greatbook.
God bless this channel. Thank you so much for uploading this otherwise forgotten classics especially in the west.
Nice name.🐄😂
Perfect adaptation of one of my favorite novels
It’s not perfect but I haven’t seen a better dramatic version.
So great to see this adaptation available on CZcams.
Masterpiece. 💫✨️
Thanks for uploading this! For those seeing it, please also read the novel itself. This filmatisation, although excellent in many ways, miss some crucial elements, such as the Grand Inquisitor, Merkel and and Zosima being a counterpoint to Ivan's nihilism, Guschenka's opening via the tale of the onion, Mitya climbing over the fence and hitting Grigory (imprortant later). and more. So my advise is to use them together.
What a shame Zosimas’ dialogue and the Grand Inquisitor (masterpiece!) are missing. Those are deep reflections of the authors’s heart and mind!
Yes I am reading the book and watching film and interesting to see what is left out. It seems to me the spiritual element is glossed over. I am just reading the bit where Alyosha has his vision after Zosima dies and that does not feature at all. Nevertheless great to watch the film and to have access to Russian cinema.
@@artiefountThe grand inquisitor would probably require building its own sets, hiring its own actors and wasting a lot fo money to adapt it right, otherwise it would just be Ivan telling a story to the camera. You do it right, or you don't do it at all. They chose the later.
I agree. I’m a little disappointed that Captain Snegiryov and Ilyusha, along with Kolya Krasotkin and the boys friendship with Alyosha haven’t been included. And as you rightly mentioned, the Grand Inquisitor and Father Zosima’s point about even just one sin having disastrous consequences for many people.
When Ivan finally grasps that, it’s then that he realises how he had helped nullify Smerdyakov’s conscience and helped him to commit murder by neutralising the consequences in his mind with his ‘everything is permissible’ nihilistic philosophy. It’s at that point, I believe, that guilt overwhelms Ivan and causes him to have a nervous breakdown.
@@oleggorky906 There is a filmatisation from 2009 that does this better I think. Available on DVD but also on CZcams.
Ovo mi je najdraza knjiga ikad, Dostojevskog je veoma tesko svesti u okvire filma...obozavam Mitju Karamazova
❤❤thank you for making it possible to see this masterpiece 🙏 ❤
I love this film. Characters are all superb. Musics and voices are amazing. This novel is excellently transferred into active world
Brilliant story and film making.
The cast is wonderful!! Thank you!
Great casting wonderful performance. Karamsoves!
Sergei Vronsky's Cinematographic efforts really shine outside. I wish they had managed to incorporate exteriors or real locations into the films more. Not so much a fan of the very stage-y interior house scenes (amazingly dramatic writing from the source material notwithstanding). But every time they do go outside it is such a treat!
Hello Mosfilm , it’s very great initiative that you are showing to the world from Russian original film archive. It is time I think we can see many great film and experiment done early like from Eisentein , lev Khuleshov etc . Also it would be good idea if there is any film critic from Moscow who can explain those time period and analyze a bit …
Good idea!!
Interesting adaptation. Impressive music as well. Thanks for the upload.
Yes. We need to remember, and even venerate the great Russian film classics by Eisenstein, Khuleshov, Bondarchuk which I've seen in the theatre -- remember seeing movies in the theatre ? -- with a live responsive audience. Everything else is just a simulacrum. A film critic from Moscow? I caught a rare showing of Eisenstein's Alexander Nevsky some years ago @ the Pacific Film Archive in Berkeley presented by a fantastic young Russian who was working for the state film archive but don't alas recall his name.
He told amusing stories about Prokofiev's working relationship with Eisenstein.
Grazie! Ho appena finito di rileggere il libro ed ecco che compare questo film!
Quanti anni hai?
@@user-iu4cf9lr2u Più di 50, purtroppo...
Perché?
@@pebs429È interessante sapere a che ora le ragazze leggono questo tipo di letteratura) e così via in generale. Grazie.
@@user-iu4cf9lr2u Sarà la terza volta che lo rileggo nella vita... E confido che lo leggano anche quelli più giovani di me. O almeno spero, vista l'ignoranza generale ormai.
Ciao
@@pebs429Ciao, no, per qualche motivo non volevo leggere questo libro, quindi l'ho visto e ho deciso di dargli un'occhiata. Sicuramente non lo leggo tre volte (per qualche motivo non esiste una cosa del genere) ma per i giovani probabilmente tutto dipende dalla loro educazione.
표도르 아저씨 연기 너무 잘하고 귀여우세요
This is marvelous. Thank you for uploading it.
Mosfilms! Russian films are the best !! Thanks for making them free to enjoy!!!
I wish the film would have included Ivan’s Grand Inquisitor
A very significant omission, isn’t it.
Agreed, in saying that, having just finished part 1, I’m simultaneously impressed at how they’ve pulled it off.
And since it was sent as the USSR’s submition for best foreign film at the Oscars, it might have been a cut scene to avoid criticism from the Roman Catholic west… just a guess
Isso é bom demais!
thank you!!
Spasibo
I am sorry for we couldnt see Liza in this movie. I ve wondered about her and Alyoshka's relationship.
exactly. And the boy who bit Alyosha's finger... that part is also missing
2:28 (where we left off in part 1)
3:00 a song on the guitar played by Pavel Fyodorovich
6:15 Ivan Fyodorovich Karamazov, brother of Alexei and Dimitri Karamozov
10:42 Perfect idiot! Terrible scoundrel!
11:23 Waking a drunk man
does anyone know what song Pavel plays with his guitar?
Kudos. This is fantastic. Such great attention paid to historical detail here: I am astonished at how they captured the poor dentistry of 19th century Russia.
Part 2 🎦
Great Inquisitor missing earlier on.
It's a pity Allyusha's actor looks abit too old! Although he looks a lot younger on his scene with Grushenka. Also Grushenka is hhhnnnggg!!!!!
I agree! And Alyosha's acting here is my least favorite. Ivan looks too old but by the end of the movie, his actor gave such a performance that I liked him anyway. Alyosha is just giving deer in the headlights in every scene here. Combined with the omission of his side plots with Lise and the boys, and the absence of his interbal monologue, his represtation in this version is lacking.
what is the name of the singer and of the song, the slow song with the guitar at 1:05:00
The singer is Rada Volshaninova, just found out
None else can have portrayed that part of a Pharisee's pursued atleast a disciple tried force return Leader's back to their Jewish folds but failed miserably takes New life...
28:56
I don't get the positive reviews. I think this film is dreadful. The acting reminds me of the histrionics in silent movies. If you didn't read the book, the script would make no sense at all. And having read the book makes the movie even worse.!So much left out, not just incidents, but the philosophical discussion. The Brother Karamozov is as much a book of philosophy as a family drama.
Don't watch if you're Americans or English. It will be beyond your Atheistic understanding.
it is so funny, how bad the Russian movie, they dont how to do it
why is the acting so terrible? it's like a silent film.....
I think it is quite good
They all overact in Russian movies
It suits the novel, Dostojevski is a little melodramatic
The acting is superb. You’re not used to expressive theatrical acting. It’s old school. Plus Dmitriy is a quirky character. Wild, but a pure soul.
Отличная игра.
Ciekawy byl ten nasz polski oficerek.😢
Агриппину должна играть была другая актриса, а не Лионела Пырьева ,не верю, как говорил Станиславский.
Жену свою протаскивал.. А зря..
Грушенька по книге нежнее и красивее. А в эту ..так безумно влюбиться.. трудно даже представить..