How Arkham Horror the card game stole my sanity
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 07. 2024
- A reminder that only our reviews are 3 and bit minutes long.
As mentioned.
Playing board games are here: / @playingboardgames
Link to the mod tutorial here. • Arkham Horror: The Car...
And see the pinned comment for how to get the TTS mod.
To support us on Patreon please head over here www.patreon.com/user?u=9257332
Our website is here: 3minuteboardgames.com/
And, if you just want to buy us a coffee for a good job, pop over here ko-fi.com/B0B27OIZ
Designer,Nate French, MJ Newman
Artist,Christopher Hosch, Marcin Jakubowski, Ignacio Bazán Lazcano, Henning Ludvigsen + 3 more
Publisher,Fantasy Flight Games
boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/2...
You can also check it out here: www.boardgameatlas.com/game/4...
3 minute board games theme Music by Vic Granell
"Shiny tech, tech live" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
incompetech.filmmusic.io/
"Copyright Disclaimer: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act
1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
Sound effects from www.zapsplat.com
3 minute board games are J Carmichael and S Rodgersrsonal use tips the balance in favor of fair use." - Hry
If you want the tabletop simulator mod mentioned in the video, follow this link on discord go to the online-play channel and ask for the Forbidden Knowledge. Here's the link. I will not be handing out the mod personally, follow the instructions above or not at all. discord.gg/mythosbusters
For playing board games, the channel I mentioned. Go here. PLaying board games are here: www.youtube.com/@PlayingBoardGames
And for the tutorial on the mod, go here. czcams.com/video/dyR-uokar5I/video.html
Anyone else notice the shelf behind him gaining new boxes as he was talking about acquiring sets?
I can stay very still. So much so that it barely looks like we paused for 30 seconds each time so steph could put the game on the shelf and then we would restart the shot.
I love videos like this! Because I love people sharing their unbridled enthusiasm for a game. It really comes through in this video.
Agreed. While I love the 3MBG breakdowns, the occasional "fanboy" video is fantastic. We all have those games we obsess about and count down to the next time we can play. It's great seeing someone who plays games for a living still has that feeling.
If you want to savor the experience, play in the release order. Don’t get overwhelmed with too many card choices before you’re ready to handle that much choice. There is an important learning curve with each campaign’s player cards that would be overload if you skipped. And later campaigns do get harder, or at least more intricate. There are lovely cards in Dunwich and Carcosa that get less play in a full collection, due to the slow, but inevitable power creep.
You’re spot on about the PlayingBoardGames channel. Their AHLCG content is just fantastic. They have stuff for players of all levels of experience with the game, and their enthusiasm for the game just shines through. I defy anyone to watch one of their videos and then not really want to get the game out!
My all time favourite game, please stream all the campaigns 😊
They play perfectly in order of release as each one adds more mechanics and layers to the game.
Maybe skip dunwich if you've played it already and jump into Carcosa. It's definitely one of the best campaigns.
Man, that campaign... fuck, it's difficult to talk about it without spoilers. Let's just say it was "mesmerizing" and I loved it for that.
Streaming and me probably don't mix. Not only the time zone, but the logistics. Plus being on camera and playing is tricky for me ;) Aftermatch reports are a lot more likely
Personally I think Carcosa has the best story, Dreamlands has the best scenarios and Edge of the Earth has the best campaign mechanics. Only Dunwich had significant balance issue though.
I recommend Path to Carcosa, Innsmouth, or Edge of the Earth for a newer group or for those looking to get back into the swing of things! The story in those campaigns are incredible and their difficulties increase in different ways from each other, allowing you to really see how this game can truly unfold.
Have fun!
So fun to just hear you gushing about this amazing game. I recently picked up all the Carcosa stuff and am amped to jump in fully after playing through the base and Dunwich a number if times! I selfishly want y'all to play Carcosa first just so we can compare notes haha cheers!
Love this! It's been in my top 5 games since 2020.
I'm currently going through Carcosa and it has been VERY fun to do as a group instead of solo.
Mate just a joy to watch this vid. Love your unbridled passion!!
AHLCG was the first game my wife and i played when we got into games 18 months ago but like you, we were drswn away.
I smell a revival!!
Play whatever campaign you like I'll follow along as a very satisfied viewer.
Blessing from Aus.
I’m in the obsession phase of this game as well. I’ve played night of the zealot a few times and am about to wrap my first play of dunwich. The deck construction is amazing. When I first opened the investigator box and saw no pre-built decks I was like oh no. But I watched some tip videos and the first time I played a deck I built I was blown away by seeing how well it worked and also where it faulted. This game is an obsession
Aw man you’re convincing me to give AH another shot J! Really loved your thoughts on this-looking forward to more of these! 🎉
This has sat at the top of my favorite games of all time for so long. Since maybe the second cycle or a bit after then? The deck building also being character backstory/development at the same time as it's the usual crunchy optimization or playfulness is so undeniably brilliant. And the core system is so ridiculously flexible, this is a game that could live forever because of the depths of unique gameplay seems endless.
Carcosa is great, but so is Innsmouth!
I am jealous coz I want to go through all the campaigns again and experience the joy of discovery! Path to Carcosa has remained my favourite campaign for a reason I can't explain without spoiling the campaign. Forgotten Age is REALLY hard but soooo enjoyable, I liked the choices of Circle Undone, I love the setting and the adventures of Dream eaters, Innsmouth conspiracy was a classic before it was even out, haven't played edge of the Earth or Scarlet Keys yet but can't wait (I heard you should play edge of the earth with a full team bc ofcthe size of the maps). This game is my favourite boardgame of all time and is definitely my most played game in my collection. You're in for a treat!!
I recently decided to rank my favorite tabletop games as I approach my five years in the hobby. "Arkham Horror: The Card" game made it into my top 10 so I very much relate to the love coming from this video! Like you, I love the deck-building component and the powerful narrative element of the game. I generally don't care that much for co-ops (they often feel too much like videos games, with a lifeless A.I. randomly throwing a problem your way); the deckbuilding component mitigates that problem for me - I never feel like I have no agency. Unlike a lot of other narrative games, much of the narrative is expressed *through* the gameplay (not just through the narrative descriptions between scenarios - although those often work very well, too). Starting with "Path to Carcosa," I also feel like the designers became more ambitious with the type of narratives they wanted to tell. I would strongly recommend beginning your next campaign there! - Also, playingboardgames is a great channel!
I've played all the official campaigns at least once and they're all enjoyable. I would probably recommend Carcosa first if you have a group with players new or returning after a long absence, just don't play it solo on your first experience with it. Scarlet Keys is my favorite campaign but also very different as it isn't linear like the previous ones, which can cause some difficulty spikes meaning players must be ok performing damage control when victory is near impossible. Return to Forgotten Age is a close second for me, but the difficulty of that one makes me not recommend it until later.
I also like making weird combo focused decks. My favorites so far been
1) Preston Fairmont - Just use all your money to make others do the work for you.
2) Calvin Wright - Run around bloodied and near-insane, covered in bulletproof vests and protective trinkets.
3) Joe Diamond - Destroy your enemies to find the clues you need.
Man, I can completely relate to almost everything you said here.
I played Night of the Zealot, and I loved it. Played the Forgotten age, and I loved it... but man it was hard to get a hold of a complete campaign for a price that didn't really hurt. The supply situation was somewhat better here in Australia, but as you said whenever one of the random packs isn't available it feels like a waste to buy the campaign. Because of all that I ended up quitting for a while, playing one or two standalone scenarios but nothing else. When they announced the new business model I was hugely excited and got back into the game, but I got back into the game so hard that I ended up buying everything before the model was even implemented.
I've also struggled to keep organising Arkham games at home, but I'm lucky enough to live near a games store that runs regular Arkham lcg nights, so it hasn't kept me from playing.
On campaign picks, I played them roughly in release order and found the gradual evolution of the scenario design to be very very interesting, early campaigns are full of simple but thematically and mechanically satisfying design choices, where later campaign introduce more complicated but highly rewarding mechanics. I personally think experiencing them out of order would nullify that a bit. Otherwise, whatever theme gets everyone more interested is the best choice.
Saying hello from Wellington NZ as well! Really enjoy your 3 minute videos for board games I'm considering. Keep it up! 👏
Kia ora e hoa. You know i'm in wellington too right? Sunny Tawa of all places even
Love the enthusiasm. I think you can’t go wrong with playing the campaigns sequentially. If you’ve already played Dunwich, I’d start with Carcosa
Man I wished I could see you deckbuild with Netrunner (Null Signal Games). Seeing the revised campaign boxes fill your shelf for completionist goals was funny
I reached out the them to send me a review copy of their latest set. But i havent played proper netrunner in about 5 years now
@@3MBG like... just now? sick. Start at System Gateway as a proper introduction/re-introduction. Everything's cleaned up and the designs are refined from what I can tell
Carcosa seems to be the most well regarded from what I've seen in discussions. We've only just started playing though and have just finished the core and Dunwich. I've got Carcosa and Edge of the Earth, and one of our group has Scarlet Keys (which is supposed to be difficult) and will probably pick up Forgotten Age based on the theme. I'll check out those links thanks!
love the concept and not all that surprised that you are a Johny :D! We tried Arkham Horror the card game some time back, and unfortunately didn't latch onto it... something about the monsters being predictable in their movement pattern (unlike e.g. KDM with hit reactions) made the game feel a bit dead to us. Not sure if this changes later on though? Anyway, love the these deep dives and will be great to hear anecdotes on other great gaming moments
Great video thank you, I am new to this game and have bought everything too. Love it again thank you
Long ago AH2e was my favourite and sat stubbornly. Eventually I gave AHLCG a shot, and learning how well the designers used the source material, I couldn't help but fall in love with it. The staying power really is with the deck building. I have most cards in my head and love building decks. I had to make a second arkhamdb account, because I hit Max count, and even my second account has 150+ decks. I just love making Johnny type decks, and making interesting combinations. I feel I've built enough to a point that I can test the deck at the building level as a separate process before playing it in arkham proper. There's a fun analysis process that can be gained, and it comes from experience of going through many types of decks and improvement in deckbuilding. It's great to find your own niche in what you like.
Btw Ah2e is still my 2nd favourite game of all time, if that gives me any credibility, and I've watched all your videos on that subject.
As for campaign suggestions, I can't recommend the next in line Carcosa enough, namely due to level of complexity they introduce. If you've really enjoyed it as you seem, you'll end up playing it all. I'm always happy to chat with your blind experiences to a campaign, loved that feeling.
I think from comments you are leaning towards Minh, but Patrice is such a weird character, I imagine to would enjoy her too.
I’m right there with you, J! I have everything for this game even though I’ve barely scratched the surface. I’ve played through NotZ, Dunwich, and Carcosa, and am currently running three campaigns - EotE with my 4P gamer group, the Forgotten Age 2P with another AH fanatic, and just started NotZ with my 11yo daughter. I’d definitely go for Carcosa next if I were you, unless the other two players are brand new. Carcosa mechanically isn’t any harder than Dunwich, but the story is top notch, with zero “flawed” scenarios in my opinion. The other ones all have at least one meh scenario, where Carcosa just smashes it each and every outing.
Just started playing through The Dunwich Legacy for the first time. Currently have everything but TCU, TIC, TDE, and the Return Tod (which is a bummer because they seem to have some good investigator cards). Loving it so far!
I think I'd recommend going in order.. from Path to Carcosa. Ruturn to Dunwich first if you really really want to play that one again!
Carcosa was my all time fav and what made me fall in love with it. I vote that one
J: I just got my core set two weeks ago and after the first game ordered the revised core set & the new Dunwich campaign/investigator sets. Both Eldritch and Mansions of Madness are favorites so I believe I will enjoy the LCG. I previously tried the LotR LCG and it didn’t click with me, but Arkham’s structure seems improved. Thanks for posting another video about some older games.
I never played MtG but I like combos and engines so i really enjoy playing as Finn Edwards. He gets a free evade action each turn and Scarlet Keys released a lot of great cards for him. Definitely worth checking out
I was just playing Skids O'Toole through hemlock vale as and evade and fight deck, so quite similar to Finn
Player order (Carcosa) or total opposite (newest:Hemlock Vale). Agree about Playing Board Games channel. Enjoyed this video and would love an update or regular updates!
I've done updates for Carcosa, Scarlet Keys and Innsmouth
Go through the campaigns in release order.
I suggest playing Rogues for big combos or William Yorrick.
I’d love to see reviews of each campaign box after you’ve played through each one. Thanks for putting out a great video, so glad you love AHLCG!
My friend and I are playing them in order and we recently finished Forgotten Age. So far, my favorite is Parh to Carcossa. So mesmerizing... 🥴
Forgotten age felt brutally hard. Which made sense given the context (jungle and temples). Very deadly. So, when you do play that one... well... you have been warned.
Well, this is timely. I just found the base + ?? all in a box moving from old stuff. I bought it to defuse some frustrating dynamics that would arise when we'd play competitive games with a couple of our friends, but now maybe I'll tackle it solo...
I would say that Path to Carcosa is my favorite of the campaigns for sure. That made me love Hastur, and he's my very favorite of the Cthulhu Mythos characters.
So I'd recommend that one for sure.
Someone in the group should play Preston Fairmont from Circle Undone, "Screw skillchecks, I have money".
I know it’ll be a long time coming, but I’d love to one day hear your review on each campaign and stand-alone scenario.
Yeah, it would have to be once my little person is at school/kindy. Just due to time.
Also I play a Duke deck (from Barkham) with Ashcan as the Ally sometimes. Other favorites are Norman, Tony, Dexter and Darrell
My buddies and I have played every campaign multiple times (besides scarlet keys) and I’d highly recommend going in this order.
1. Carcosa
2. Circle Undone
3. Innsmouth
4. Forgotten Age (for a nice challenge)
5. Anything else
As a Johnny, play Survivor in every role! I think you’ll have an amazing time!
Have fun friend!
I’ll also say that the people I’ve met in the community around this game are some of the best people, period.
I've easily played this game 3-5x more than any other game in my collection, including having played Dunwich 1x, Carcosa 2x, Forgotten 2x, Circle Undone 3-4x, Dream-Eaters 1x, Innsmouth 3x, Scarlet Keys 2x, plus all the side session stuff. Amazing, phenomenal game
Thats me this last year, I have 4 session in person with people a week on average. One of them is always Arkham horror
Certainly my very favorite tabletop game, for years.
Do them all in release order sprinkling side quests in. Oooooo I feel so excited for you and your group! DO THEM ALL TOGETHER FRIENDS FOREVER
I love this comment. Now i have the "saturday morning watchmen" theme music stuck in my head though
Johnny's of the world unite! Some of my favourite MTG tournaments were the ones where I brought rogue decks to very serious tournaments. Arkham is an incredible LCG and Core -> Dunwich legacy -> Path to Carcosa is such a fantastic arc.
So yeah, I vote Path to Carcosa! It is such a well timed campaign if you've done Core and Dunwich a bunch. I loooooved how they played with the entire format and expectations and it remains one of my favourite arkham experiences. Wasn't as much a fan of the Forgotten age if you want a veto vote as well.
Agree - I own Dunwich, Carcosa, and the standalone investigators. And all I've done is play Night of the Zealot and Dunwich - solo. I too watch Playing board games. I too was eager to get a campaign to table (though that didn't go so well at 4 players, as there was a bit too much downtime, and the luck on the 2nd scenario was one of those "worst possible" and not in a fun way).... So I think I'll continue solo'ing, and want to buy more every time I log in to an online store... but feel the need to stop and wait until I've at least played Carcosa and "caught up". And there you go, I answered your Ramble with my own Ramble. And you should play... Carcosa I think! It's next up, the story is supposed to be great, and it's one of the most highly rated (including rates from Playing board games). Even though I haven't played it, there you go. That's my recommendation!
As a lot of people have said in order (skipping Dunwich ) But for me I think a great way is Carcosa, Forgotten Age, Innsmouth and then Edge of the EArth. After that any you like by theme
Dream Eaters was very fun with the two timelines and Path to Carcosa I really liked playing with the investigators Lola Hayes and Akachi Onyele
I'm in the exact same position as you right now! Played NotZ a couple times and finished the Dunwich Legacy, currently 2 scenarios into Carcosa, would recommend Carcosa for your next delve!
Lol, same position indeed. We did the first 2 scenarios of carcosa last night
arkham LCG is also a favorite of mine although I haven't played since the scarlet keys. For me it is mostly making the decks that stops me as this really determines if you are going to have a good time or getting your ass kicked like you're a toddles fighting a wrestling champion.
On what to play. Dunwhich, as you know, is a very standard campaign and a good introduction. However considering you played it several times innsmouth is also a good option for a more standard like campaign. It is also a very good campaign.
Carcosa is a classic, cannot go wrong with that.
Edge of the earth is also great, and they really played with the fact that the campaign was delivered in one.
Scarlet keys has a fun idea that doesn't work that well. It is more a choose your own adventure story which can lead to a lot of reading and going in circles. Still, has fun scenario's.
the twilight lodge and dreamers are ranking wise more on the bottom for me, but they are still a good time. But considering you have a month I advice carcosa and edge of the earth. Because damn those were fun.
And for a stand alone, murder at the excelsior hotel. And for a silly stand alone, barkham horror.
If you’re ever in Chicago, my 9 year old Arkham LCG obsessed daughter and I would love to play with ya.
Awww, bless. That's the dream (My girl is only 2, so still a ways off)
Path or Inns. Bless tokens are a ton of fun!
Playing a blessed Calvin deck right now. 1000x yes to this comment
Bro, I LOOOOVE this game! If you need a fourth player for this, I am dead keen.
You're making me reconsider this game! Problem is I want LOTR lcg as well. Not to mention I've already gone down the MC path already 🤦🏻♂️ Great video!
MC never hooked me. I sometimes feel like the only person in the world who cares not for Marvel (or DC for that matter)
@@3MBG I don't care much for marvel either. At the time, it was the new LCG and AH was getting difficult to track down and LOTR was near impossible. Lol I could try selling to fund the next one
My recommendation of the next campaign would be Path to Carcosa. Excellent campaign based off the novel The King in Yellow. It's a mechanically simple campaign so it's fairly new player friendly without being mechanically boring either, and the story is ominous and mind bending, leaving the players questioning what is real and is not within the narrative. It's considered to be one of the best campaigns in the series and for good reason!
Path to Carcosa for sure! Also Playing Board Games is a great channel!
I hear there's a new production of The King in Yellow at the playhouse, if you haven't seen it, you really must. Audiences have just been going crazy for the performance!
My group is nuts about AH:LCG and also Marvel Champions (for the pick-up, one-shotability), They're both in my top 10 of all time
Playing Board Games YT channel is the best AH resource. If Lovecraftian theme is important, Carcosa and Innismouth.
Yep, PBG are excellent. This is quite old, we did Carcosa, then Scarlet keys as it was the one campaign my other 2 players hadn't done, then on to Innsmouth. I've done recap videos for Carcosa and scarlet keys
Awesome, am just getting started in this game, having first checked it out in the TTS mod, and have pretty much gone on a binge ordering a bunch of the content in the revised customer friendly format. Have finished the Zealot campaign and onwards to Dunwich next.
Will check out your campaign recap videos once I am done with the initial campaign playthroughs. Do keep making your recap videos for other campaigns, if you're still playing the game, as your 3 minute video and your other longer video on how this game 'stole your sanity' completely sold me on this game!! @@3MBG
I would recommend start with Carcosa to get acquainted with multiplayer, the. Edge of the earth
nice shoutout to the playingboardgames squad!!!!
Great video. It’s an incredible game. I loved Edge of the Earth, but I still think Carcosa is the peak of this game. Every scenario is great. No low points.
Path to carcosa is a good one!
I second the Android: Netrunner comment. That game was so creative and the flexibility in deckbuilding was so fun. I know NISEI is technically keeping the game going but I just haven't had the motivation to get back into it.
As soon as regular tournament stuff stopped happening here, i stopped playing. Online was never my thing.
@@3MBG Exactly, We had a weekly group at a comic shop here, but when L5R came out many tried that, and then both games died
Carcosa is a great starting point for Arkham. Have fun!
Ooh. I’m compelled as a history teacher to vote for the Scarlet Keys! Loved this video!!
Fun Fact: I am also a qualified history teacher, although i went a different career path after teachers college.
Arkham the card game is like my main squeeze. I love it to pieces! and I would suggest Dunwich because its still a great entry!
Had played dunwich 4 times already, we kicked off carcosa last week
12 days?!
I have just been hooked by this game! 🤯 if only I'd seen this, maybe I could've saved my wallet.. but no.. now I'm part of the Arkham club 😅
Carcosa is still the best. Forgotten Age is very hard (the return to cards are highly recommended) but interesting. Scarlet Keys is good but introduces some new complex rules to keep track of. Edge of the Earth will take the biggest table you have, it is huge.
The table i did a large chunk of this video in front of is 180cm by 120cm, it fits most things. It also has a lid so so you can play on top and get the whole size of it. Fits 6 player Star Trek Ascendancy and Twilight Imperium at 6
I’d also suggest Carcosa. All the campaigns have their good and bad points, but Carcosa is probably the most consistent in quality. The plot is more based on Chambers than Lovecraft, as you might expect, so not my favourite storyline…but if you’re looking for a mix of story and gameplay, its probably the best campaign.
(My favourite half-campaign is Dreameaters/dreamlands side…but not one I’d recommend to do first)
I'm a massive Arkham LCG fan, played every campaign at least 3 times each and I have to say, as for which one you play next, Path to Carcosa is the absolute best. Amazing use of the basic mechanics without too much new stuff to overwhelm players. My opinions on the campaigns though:
Dunwich: Good but doesn't hold up terribly well against later campaigns. They were finding their stride with this one
Path to Carcosa: Generally considered the best campaign to date
Forgotten Age: The hardest and most brutal by far
The Circle Undone: Good but not quite as well executed as PtC
Dream Eaters: Annoying to manage multiple decks across the 2 campaigns but a very good campaign
Edge of the Earth: Personally one of my favourites but I agree it is let down a little by a slightly lackluster second half. Lots of reading though which means playing with a group is annoying
Scarlet Keys: LOTS OF READING. As in, more time spent reading than actually playing the game. Playing without the Arkham Cards app makes this campaign a nightmare of book keeping. The scenarios are solid enough and the key cards are fun but yeah, lots and lots of reading.
Yeah, ive heard keys is a bit of work, so we are putting that one down the order for sure
Edge of the Earth was really good, best campaign imo. Havent played scarlet keys though
I used to "hate" the idea of this "Eldritch Horror " with cards, and new expansions coming out every now and then... for some reason i ended up buying it and are now so obsessed with it, getting new premium tokens, all exps, storage solutions, this is awesome and bad!
Go Path to Carcosa, best expansion IMO and the one that goes after Dunwich (release date) !!
Ha, i literally just posted a new video on our playthough of carcosa.
I’d suggest playing through the campaigns in release order! (So Path to Carcosa next)
Love the game, but don’t have the energy to play often. Ive only ever finished dunwich and carcosa. But i own all the reboxed stuff, a bunch of standalones and the return to’s except zealot (which i got rid of years ago when i got rid of my original collection. Oops). I tried playing with some friends and oddly found i’d rather just play solo one or two handed. I’m not sure why. I enjoy figuring out the puzzle myself, I suppose!
Solo, especially 2-handed is a really good time anyway.
AHLCG is the best.
One Johnny to another here's the characters from each expansion that I think you would find intriguing:
Ashcan Pete
Sefina Rousseau
Calvin Wright
Rita Young
Patrica Hathaway
Trish Scarborough
Lily Chen
Darrell Simmons
So I guess what I mean is this Johnny loves Red and Green :) 😂😂
3MBG what games do you think need a new edition or a re-release?
I did a video on that not too long ago. 10 games i want brought back from the dead. That's for re-releases at least
Carcosa! It is awesome
Carcosa is brilliant!
go for Edge of the Earth!
Path to Carcosa is such an amazing experience. Played it 1.5 times because I got caught in *spoilers*. Dunwich was nice too, but not as exciting. Forgotten Age was too punishing. More than half way through, one of my investigators died, and I didn't want to continue with a fresh, weak investigator. So that one turned me off from playing.
What makes you come back to Night of the Zealot so many times? You try different investigators, different decks and the emergent storytelling always presents itself in a fresh way?
More that its just a testing ground for decks, a reasonably short but safeish space to see if deck construction ideas ive had work
Interesting, thank you for replying! I like Lita Chantler and Lost's Rousseau vibes she brings to our table
I agree playing all of them in order is a good way to do it. Maybe because Path to Carcosa is my favorite, and Scarlet Keys is dead last in my rankings haha. I think SK HAS to be the last regardless, because it is by far the most overly complicated. You need at least a few campaigns under your belt before tackling that. Shout out to Forgotten Age as my pick as the best story (and biggest "grower") and Dream-Eaters as the most atmospheric.
I’d suggest starting with Dunwich as its the basic game without extra/special rules. If your comfortable w/ extra rules then please do Edge of the Earth.
As mentioned, ive played Dunwich about 4 times ;)
@@3MBG Doh!
How much replayability do you find in a campaign? Is it still interesting after 3-4 plays?
I've played Dunwich through about 6 times now. The first play is different for sure because there is the shock and surprise factor. And you never really get that sort of experience the 2nd time through. But here's the thing, AH-LCG is trope based story telling, the stories are fun but they aren't murder mysteries where once you go through them the surprise is ruined. They hold together the scenarios, and the core of the game is really making a character and trying them against a series of different challenging scenarios in a row.
It does become more of a board game and less of an RPG on replays. Because you are focusing more on the challenges you know are coming up and building your decks to deal with them. But considering I'm 1/4 in terms of winning finales on my blind playthrough, this gives me something to shoot for on the replay.
I've not played since the pandemic since I played with a friend's cards & I don't like it much solo (2 handed would be OK but its a bit of a chore, especially not owning any cards :) ).
However I'm playing again tomorrow if I can overcome my AP at the ridiculous number of cards there are out now. Yay!
I think the campaigns for LotR and MC are garbage but AH soars and has legitimate branching paths and failing forwards.
My only issue is that it's hard to test decks and you can commit to a campaign with a ropey pile.
Yeah, i've been playing mission 2 from Night of the Zealot with 9XP to test decks. Not necessarily all the way through, just to see how it rolls.
Cant recommend The Scarlet Keys highly enough. From unique scenarios to the ability to drop-in standalone scenarios by design (use Fortune & Folly for sure), it’s a terrific thematic experience.
Currently playing through Edge of the Earth, and it’s been pretty great thus far.
J, you have to play The Path to Carcosa, omg, seriously, just do it, it is soooooo good
This was a fantastic video. A brilliant take from someone that isn't deep into the game yet content wise but has the enphusiasm for the game.
It is my second favourite game behind Spirit Island. The reason I love AH: LCG so much is because it is the game I think about most when not gaming. I may be watching some TV passively thinking about what decks to create, what investigators to pair together. I'm sure deckbuilding for the game on ArkhamDB has tens of hours put into it.
Great shout out to Playing board games as well who are my go to for content on the game. Team Covenant got me into the game during the pandemic as one of them learned the game live stream.
I'd recommend playing the campaigns in chronological order. It doesnt really matter but I liked playing that way and it often means you slowly ramp up into more rules being added. the latter campaigns often adding extra little rules here and there.
Recommended investigator for you: Stella Clark. A survivor. The games first trans character. A completely different playstyle of failing skill tests but gaining benefits nonetheless. If you have all the player cards there are loads of failure survivor cards that reach new heights in Stella.
I watched some of Eric playing Stella on PBG, very strong. It's looking like i'm gonna be the clue monkey in our trio, and i'm leaning towards Minh as a result.
@@3MBG I really like playing as Minh. Plenty of skills cards in her deck is normally how I go. Scavenging plus Ice picks can be really good in her as well. Hope the campaigning goes well. Would love to hear how it goes if you decided you wanted more content a brief talk through of each scenario and how it went and overall thoughts if the campaign would do very well in the Arkham community I think
Thinking Flashlight 3 and old key rings, and seeing how much i can mess about with lowering shroud. That seems a little different than the traditional magnifying glass ;)
@@3MBG I love that style of gameplay. Used both Darrell and Stella. Old key ring 3, gumption, flashlight 3, winging it and shed a light are super powerful. As is quick learner which plays perfectly in Stella.
Just be warned using that tactic in Minh. She cant access keyring 3 which gets you clue compression. Can't use quick learner for lower shroud. Flashlight 3 is amazing as it isnt an action so you can use it with the action on keyring for -4 shroud. But Minh's weakness is a hand item. So if you have an old keyring and a flashlight her weakness forces you to discard one. So Minh is particularly bad at using both hand slots. Which reduces the flexibilty of flashlight 3 comboing the old keyring.
Arcane enlightenment could give you that 3rd hand slot if you were worried about her weakness.
But I am sure she still works that way. Just some thoughts on being careful of that weakness hurting you. Its the brilliant thing about the game that we can make these wild deck ideas.
Good stuff as always! I vote y'all play Dunwich Legacy, so that I can compare my runs to an experienced player! But I'll watch either way.
Carcosa is a masterpiece! Have fun!
This is a bit tangential and I don't mean to make you repeat yourself but you'd mentioned somewhere tha Elder Sign didn't have a resource that Arkham Horror had that increased decision possibilities. Sort of like an alternative currency. Which vid was that / what was the currency? Also does the card game have a similar flexibility? Or is it a different sort of experience that way?
It was about Eldritch horror, not Elder sign. And it was my recent "10 rules that make good games great". It was about how in AH2, clues are a resources that can be spent. Whereas in Eldritch horror, they are too valuable to spend for that. And for me, that turned the game from a risk managment game to one where you roll dice and have little control over the outcome.
@@3MBG Oh! Yeah I see now. Funnily enough I was originally going to write Eldritch Horror but changed it to Elder Sign because I thought I'd mixed up the game names :) Thanks!
Cthulhu f’taghen. Ia Ia!
It stole my 💲💲💲
Arkham horror circle undone
Nice Video and i really like your enthusiasm BUT ... how can you use rubber bands on your cards.
I don't use rubber bands on my cards. Those are hair ties and they are very padded and quite loose.
Carcosa!! It's the best
Dunwich its a bit easier to start learning, carcosa is thematically great, forgotten age is kind of hard and brutal, i would start with dunwich or edge then carcosa and after that go for whatever
As mentioned, I've played Dunwich about 4 times ;)
I really love PlayingBoardGames but I don't enjoy watching them play Arkham. Team Covennat do a great job of narrating what the cards do and why they take their actions and what the options are, whereas PBG just take their moves and it can be tricky to follow. I've enjoyed watching them play A LOT of other games though!
I'm like you: love the game, but have only played starter box campaign and Dunwich, then got away from the game but want to come back. Having said that, I'm likely to buy only one more campaign. I've read a couple places that recommend Path to Carcosa as the next best campaign. So I'd like you to do that one so I can hear your opinion of it. 🙂
I suspect this might be the final result. Its next in time line, and also very popular
Path to Carcosa.