Sam got so great development here, i wish he would do the same in the orginal. I never realised how much potential this guy had until now... I mean, I never hated him or anything, just never saw him as important enough for a plot. what if idea: What if total drama action had mix of old and new contestants? i mean like, you keep the orginal 14 that compeated but you add 8 of people who were in later seasons, i would sugest Mike, Zoey, Scott, Dakota, Dawn, Brick, Sam and Anne Maria. (Jo would be too simular to Eva to have her here, Lightning too simular to Tyler, Cameron too simular to Harold and finally B and Stacy just wouldn't be interesting enough. For people who think Dakota wouldn't join because of being too simular to Lindsay, Dakota's dad would probably pay Chris to let her in the show).
Interesting idea, also yeah All characters have potential if written well especially someone like Sam who was in the least episodes total of all the all stars cast
@@TheAlphaXXO yeah, all of them do, just not all of them have it shown so it is hard to realise how much of potential they have in reality if they are shown for only couple episodes.
What if Scott and Alejandro or Lightning and Tyler were switched in their debut? It would be interesting to see how the dynamics between Scott and Tyler would be and how Lightning and Alejandro would absolutely dominate in their respective seasons
I love this so much it’s funny Courtney finally got a win and you didn’t kill Duncan’s entire character he’s still dating Gwen and made up with Courtney ish I wish you would’ve had Alejandro mention he’s dating heather though but other then that I wish this was how it actually went
I love this what if but would it be more fitting if Al got switch to the New Newts since he is the newest member and honestly hardly a old gen being in Season 3
What if finalists weren't allowed to compete twice (besides maybe All Stars). Like if Owen and Gwen skipped Action, so two replaced them or Bowie and Priya didn't compete in Reboot S2, so only 14.
@@TheAlphaXXO I saw Pepsicat bring it up, so there is potential. I thought of rewriting Total Drama Drama Drama Drama Island so Gwen won but split the winnings with Owen. And Chris holds the million dollar briefcase contest separately. For the sake of keeping genders balanced, one replacement girl and guy. So Eva and either Tyler or Noah. The guy really comes down to preference to be honest. I suppose the stories would lean towards more Justin and Courtney stuff. But maybe a new big player. - As for reboot, Caleb would have a new plot and I suppose Julia+MK get to run their cheating operation a bit differently. Either Julia and Millie pick out the teams or for convenience, they are the same in canon, but Chris just happened to handpick them
Nice to see the TD Wonderer influence
I feel like Jo's fear would be being beaten by Lightning (again) and Brick, so they both fight her.
Spoilers;
Courtney VS Sam would be a goated final two ngl
Sam got so great development here, i wish he would do the same in the orginal. I never realised how much potential this guy had until now... I mean, I never hated him or anything, just never saw him as important enough for a plot.
what if idea: What if total drama action had mix of old and new contestants? i mean like, you keep the orginal 14 that compeated but you add 8 of people who were in later seasons, i would sugest Mike, Zoey, Scott, Dakota, Dawn, Brick, Sam and Anne Maria. (Jo would be too simular to Eva to have her here, Lightning too simular to Tyler, Cameron too simular to Harold and finally B and Stacy just wouldn't be interesting enough. For people who think Dakota wouldn't join because of being too simular to Lindsay, Dakota's dad would probably pay Chris to let her in the show).
Interesting idea, also yeah All characters have potential if written well especially someone like Sam who was in the least episodes total of all the all stars cast
@@TheAlphaXXO yeah, all of them do, just not all of them have it shown so it is hard to realise how much of potential they have in reality if they are shown for only couple episodes.
In my head Courtney is the cannon winner, shes never made a finale and deserves the win.
What if Scott and Alejandro or Lightning and Tyler were switched in their debut?
It would be interesting to see how the dynamics between Scott and Tyler would be and how Lightning and Alejandro would absolutely dominate in their respective seasons
Your All Stars would have been sick to see on screen
I like how Sam, out of all contestants, manage to make his way to the finale, all because he is deemed easy to beat in the finale
Yup basically XD
I love this so much it’s funny Courtney finally got a win and you didn’t kill Duncan’s entire character he’s still dating Gwen and made up with Courtney ish I wish you would’ve had Alejandro mention he’s dating heather though but other then that I wish this was how it actually went
What if All Stars was 26 episodes? (with an extended cast)
Can you do what if Noah played in the dodgeball challenge
I’ll add that to my list
27:25 it looks like all their pngs are looking at Gwen lol
Can u do What if Wayne And Raj were not injured (season 1 episode 7)
This is on my list but I have sooo many video ideas so it might be a while
@@TheAlphaXXO ok
i so love what if ❤
I feel like the team names could have been
The veteran vultures
The newbie narwhals
I would 100 % root for first cast lmao
Mike Mal, Mal Mike Milk
I love this what if but would it be more fitting if Al got switch to the New Newts since he is the newest member and honestly hardly a old gen being in Season 3
What if Justin and Eva were in World Tour instead of Alejandro and Sierra?
That’s an interesting idea I’d have to think about it
❤❤❤
What if Lindsay was the main villain of island? (Like originally in Camp TV) (Heather is still a villain, but secondary to Lindsay)
That’s more of a rewrite than a what if though so I don’t think so
Nice
What if finalists weren't allowed to compete twice (besides maybe All Stars). Like if Owen and Gwen skipped Action, so two replaced them
or Bowie and Priya didn't compete in Reboot S2, so only 14.
Wow that’s a great idea someone should do that
@@TheAlphaXXO I saw Pepsicat bring it up, so there is potential.
I thought of rewriting Total Drama Drama Drama Drama Island so Gwen won but split the winnings with Owen. And Chris holds the million dollar briefcase contest separately. For the sake of keeping genders balanced, one replacement girl and guy. So Eva and either Tyler or Noah. The guy really comes down to preference to be honest.
I suppose the stories would lean towards more Justin and Courtney stuff. But maybe a new big player.
-
As for reboot, Caleb would have a new plot and I suppose Julia+MK get to run their cheating operation a bit differently. Either Julia and Millie pick out the teams or for convenience, they are the same in canon, but Chris just happened to handpick them
@@sirkillalot9892 I’m friends with Pepsi and I don’t want to step on any toes there