Ian Hislop on God, Nigel Farage, the cautious BBC and 'Have I Got News For You'
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 11. 2014
- In his Private Eye office, Ian Hislop gives a rare sit-down interview for the latest in our Chat Life series.
He muses on the two current non-establishment movements in politics; Nigel Farage under UKIP, and Russell Brand. He also discusses his faith in God, while admitting that most of the people he works with are 'liberal atheists'.
Ian assesses how the BBC, especially in relation to Have I Got News For You, deals with controversy. He also gives a revealing insight into which newspapers he reads, and those he merely skim-reads!
See www.chatlife.tv for more, and visit our sister channel Chat Politics here: / chatpolitics
© 2014 - Chat Life. Please get in touch on CZcams or via our website, www.chatpolitics.org, for usage requests. - Zábava
I once sent a CV, cover letter and small portfolio to Private Eye in the hope of finding work there. I received a hand-written and signed reply note from Ian Hislop himself stating that he regretted to inform me that there were no opportunities available. I was amazed that he'd spared the time and had been polite enough to write back to me, and it was without a doubt the best rejection letter I've ever received (I have to admit I was somewhat starstruck too). I loved him enough as it was, but to receive that made me respect him just that little bit more. I might not see eye-to-eye with him on certain things, but that ought to be expected. I still see him as an ultimately and thoroughly decent man.
***** sour little fool go crawl back where you can from
***** im not one with a inflated ego thinking Private Eye has done an injustice to them
Yes, youtube is a great medium for venting out displaced anger.
Some good advice to you is dont take to heart too much what others say. Even private eye.
What was in the portfolio? Wouldn't object to reading some of it.
kelman727 Just some pieces I'd written mainly, some of them have been published on the London Progressive Journal which is a great site if you haven't heard of it.
One man who helps keep thousands of others on the safe side of sane.
The state of the country when a man with integrity and decency stands out as a lone figure..
Who Xi?
Ian Hislop has Compassion...A relic of old decency.
Ian Hislop's always looked like he's about 55, even when he was 30. I think he'll look about 55 when he's 90 as well.
He's what we call a geezer.
If you'd ever gotten laid you'd know a cunt's a good thing.
Maybe you would, but most people use protection
Quite a big bit of rubber actually
Don't strain yourself, noone will blame you if you can't make a decent insult
I love Ian Hislop and I agree with the commenter below he is a thoroughly decent man and the kind of person who makes me proud to be British as he has this thoroughly British politeness about him which seems genuine and sincere.
@Tim Loves Bacon - We have a special place for our close family, over and above others. We also do the same for our close friends, and so on all the way up to everyone within the country, surely?
There is nothing wrong with nationalism, it is a healthy attitude towards a common system, as long as it does not include a hatred of foreigners.
I disagree with you; it is possible to be proud of many things, and you seem to suggest it cannot sit side by side with the other sources of pride you list.
I really like Ian Hislop. There's not that many people in public life I feel I'd like to be friends with particularly, or at least wish were regulars in my local - but Mr Hislop is one of them. Always look forward to seeing him on HIGNFY on Fridays.
He takes the piss out footballers............he's a good one for that reason on its own.
i love Ian's perplexed thinking at the beginning, then responsese ''editor of private eye'' that IS Ian Hislop , the fact he had to ask is a bit hmmm....
A decent fellow, I think. You can see by his face on HIGNFY when he is unhappy when one of the 'team' makes an unfair, personal comment on someone's appearance for example. I'm surprised about his religious leaning though.
Sort of bloke you would want on your side in a pub quiz Paul gambochine and Brian Cox the other 2.
I love Private Eye, since I first began to read the serious political narrative, PE has been my go to read. I'm looking at my bookshelf and I have five years of binders of the magazine up there. I don't by any stretch of the imagination agree with Ian on everything, but on the whole I respect his honesty.
best episode of extreme hoarders ever
His assessments here of Nigel farage and Russell Brand were and are spot on. Jeremy Paxman's interviews with both men confirmed Hislop's take on them.
What I like about Ian Hislop is that he is well educated, very knowledgeable and can crack a pun on just about any subject, what a great contributor to mankind.
Ian Hislop ‘occasionally worries’ about sack from Have I Got News For You12th October 2020 0532am 27.12.23 ....................if you want to know i was searching the archives for references to hislop sacking the staff of private eye when he "took it over". all you can find, if yer me, is references to shaka hislop.... and erm............ that's about it.
I like Ian Hislpos straight-talking and satirical look on the world of politics. I enjoyed this interview thanks Chat Life.
but the clown believes in a god.....if they cut half of his brain out he would still be more intelligent than me but it's he who has the imaginary friend.... a funny old world
The slow motion interruption was a load of bullshit.
Ned McFabulous led to me immediately unsubscribing after subscribing
Ned McFabulous Yeah, it was a bit cheap and vlogger-esque.
+Ned McFabulous Thought the same. The sort of childishness that will prevent him getting further worthwhile bookings...
What!!!! Hislop's a comedian half the time gotta weave that theme in.
Nothing new there
A man of honesty and integrity, wish there were more like him
I love how he treats everyone, of any ideological persuasion with an unbiased, critical eye. The nearest we have to H.L. Mencken
I don't agree. He's a politically-correct leftie, and his paper follows that line. The fact that he's a pleasant speaker, seems to be a friendly chap and clearly has a good sense of humour and a quick wit shouldn't disguise his bias.
@@jonb6417 what makes you think Hislop is a left winger?
@@jonb6417
Have you read the Eye particularly?
I'm not sure of Hislop's politics, but he always struck me as a Conservative voter.
The nature of any political satire is that the finger will mostly be pointed at those in government, because they are the ones doing the most "work" (good and bad).
The Eye has been (and still is) savaging Corbyn and Labour, as well as Boris & the Tories, but at the end of the day, the Tories are actually doing stuff and Labour can only really talk about doing stuff, being in opposition.
LexTNeville He has a moral compass, which is enough to make anyone a “politically correct leftie” it seems.
@@jonb6417 Ha-ha! There are many who think he's a right-winger! This shows he's in the right place. He's a compassionate, well-informed, even-handed and articulate man
Long live Private Eye. Keeps me sane ... just about. Thanks Ian.
Loved that! Intelligent and honest interviewer, intelligent and honest interviewee - funny too! Thank you.
Ian Hislop on God, Nigel Farage, the cautious BBC and 'Have I Got News For You' 27.12.23 0539am i mean private eye, although being deemed considered, should be aware that just becuz hip young kiddies or those in the know dont wear their insights or parade their knowledge for all to discern on their sleeve - that they're to be deemed "slow" or that they require or demand slow news so they and the public can "get it". i do agree that news is just an industry and does merely churn out the same old news on a stick packaged and parceled almost before it happens - that damnable anticipation, y'see, which fucks with their collective mindsets should they mis-read the situation .... and the blurghhhh blarr blguh quote was about as near the mark as anyone could get. but................... what to do: create a private eye based you tube channel which allows any old soak and those imbued with enough considered ire to come along and waffle on in the style of a news channel refer to eg: GBNews or TalkTV... nice idea if you want off the cuff and honest insight but the ratings would be terrible... hint hint.
I think Hislop's Great!. I really appreciate the Private Eye. And use it as my source of information, in an ever misinformed world!. Thanks "Chat Life", decent interview!.
What Private Eye has to say is often truer than the shite, cover-ups, whitewash and bluster that government spews forth, long live 'The Eye'
private eye and hislop are both excellent
Great point on the 24 hour news cycle! Absolutely true.
It's just fodder for the masses...the Facebook & Twitter aficionados....it makes them feel "connected"..... whilst being above the common herd.
Yay. Ian Hislop is a great role model. Good man. Never die.
Thankyou for a brilliant channel,with the brilliant and very funny Ian Hislop,This is high quality interviewing. Its a pity TV seems to have almost forgotten this most entertaining art form ie just 2 people and intelligent discussion its so much better than sales talk by supposed celebrities with nothing but making money on their mind.
The sort of thing that the now very bland BBC cannot do for fear of getting less money from the government!
Great interview, as a Private Eye subscriber I find it to be possibly the best source of news out there.
Four years late, but me to.
At the moment I think the Eye might be the current pinnacle of british investigative journalism (which is a pretty bad indictment of our press at the moment, that a bi-monthly satirical magazine is doing a better job).
@@simonoleary9264 Now...2022... I agree....
The British Press is something that should have been thrown away many years ago. The Daily Mail...being a classic example.
It's obsession with celebrity "news" and that ridiculous side bar full of "skimpy bikini" "Full bosom" "Pert thighs" "daring" "lacy see through"
garbage....I thought this was 2022...where such wordage (garbage) was misogynistic?
How do they get away with it? Why are not the Women's Libbers up in arms about it all.... The paper is run on TRASH! At their very expense!
The Daily Mail. Once.... A Long Time Ago...a very long time ago was a respected Newspaper..... Now it is just a click bait shyster.
To the people that work there: You need to look in the mirror. Best career move you will ever make.
He has a piano in his work office. If ever I doubted the man, this has demonstrated once again to me he is a good human being.
I agree entirely. A touch of civilisation.
I agree with your opinion on on Mr Hislop, however having a piano is not linked to to his decency as a human. Stalin had a piano and played it regular, so did the gestapo, and other high ranking Nazis. A piano speaks of culture, not for people to be described as decent or good. Now he may have played the piano well but that makes no one decent.
This actually deserves a lot more likes. Hislop (and Private Eye) is a sort of an anti-British Institution: and most British people are also anti-British Institution... thats what makes it work.
Controlled opposition.
Check out his appearances at the Leveson inquiry. Like Galloway in the US senate he took them to pieces. A rare species_ a journalist that is truly independent and free from taint.
Galloway is a POS.
Hislop is a principled man.
Hislop is an absolute legend
Ian Hislop on God, Nigel Farage, the cautious BBC and 'Have I Got News For You' 27.12.23 0534am does this fucker exist!!? i look at him and think george fucking robey. a fucking clown!!!
Just love listening to Ian Hislop's views on things, a decent bloke.
Wow, he has a piano in his office.
As always, fantastic guys. I always enjoy your CP or CL videos :)
Great interview. Nice questions and answers. Thank you for posting.
Great interview, the interviewer did really well. I'd like to have those skills myself.
Yes...I think he did very well.... got his questions in at the correct time...yet allowing Ian to finish the reply to a previous question, naturally and without curtailment.... The way an interview should be conducted.
If only more would listen and learn from this young man. He gets full marks from me.
Seen it before. Watched it again. Still great stuff. Long live IH and PE.
You have more in common with Russell Brand than you think Ian. You both point out the faults the lies the corruption but neither have the answer or solution that is for us to make a more informed decision with the contributions from you both. Thanks
I just requested a Private Eye subscription as my xmas present. It's the only honest 'newspaper' in the UK.
What a fabulous chap. !! 👍🏼
I love the fact that he loves being sued for libel! He is a solicitor after all! And a legend.
Hislop is not a solicitor.
@@samsteve1000 The comment is still valid.
Loved the Peter Cook quote at the end.
Cook would have kicked his teeth in for promoting the likes of Clarkson and Johnson.
I love Ian Hislop! YAAAAY More Kind Revolutionaries please.(well,people that are kind and CAN be bothered...)
The older I get the more I appreciate and admire this brilliant man
Yes: let's not underestimate the value of a genuinely independent and satirical voice.
That is a beautiful office. I want an office with a piano and loads of files and books and newspapers and posters :)
It really is like a Tardis
It's all staged ,faux intellectual.
Ian is such an amazing character, I would love to invite him to dinner with us - Nottingham
You and Paul provide much needed sustainable stuff. Keep it that way.
HIGNFY - Best
what a hero. In my opinion one of if not the most intelligent human being on the planet.
Sure. Formats like Have I Got News For You massively boosted the career of both Johnson and Rees Mogg. What a rebel.
Great interview of a great man. Thanks
This man should lead this country.
No he shouldn't.
Hislop - always a man worth listening too
Thank Christ for Ian Hislop - please don’t die
ian hislp a true global treasure
Wow, really great questions that make for an interesting interview --- nice work!
The actual slo mo bit wasn't really necessary was it
It was worth a small chortle.
It wasn't incredibly funny, bit I chuckled!!
It's called a joke ....... and it most certainly is appropriate considering it's Ian Hislop. Moreover I'm sure he would agree.
Exactly what I thought. Bad taste. No wonder this channel has failed.
i thought it was funny, but maybe i have a funnier bone than most i dunno
Mr Hislop, you are desperatley incorrect in thinking Private Eye has made no difference. Since I was 17 you have; amused, educated and informed. That was 31 years ago and I have a vote. Best to you all .
How many editors have pianos in their office?
Hell, how many musicians do..?
How am I only finding this video now? Ian is a national treasure.
Private eye always has been my favourite magazine and Ian has always been one of my favourite Britons and there;s not many I can admire these days.
A piano as well as a bookcase; that is my perfect backdrop!
Great interview/er/ee!
If you have any doubts about Ian Hislop watch his confrontation with Priti Patel about Capital Punishment on Question Time. He ruthlessly exposes Patel's poverty of intelligence and logic.
cracking interview really liked your style thank you
Fascinating and funny guy. Good job by the interviewer too.
A good honest man.
"transparently, straightforwardly and honestly, and therefore effectively..." An idea that shows an unusually healthy worldview...
This video might just have the best dynamic thumbnail of all time :)
Bly me, I have exactly the same piano as Hislop, a Knight upright. It has a very nice sound, a bit heavy on the touch but that makes for great subtleties in dynamics that are not possible to produce on stage grands.
What w world it might be if such dignified, intelligent, brutally honest and fair people rant it!
I would love to work for Mr Hislop.
Ian's a good satirist and the point of satire for me is to point out hypocrisy, misleading and lies. Their weapon is truth, the more negative effect a target of satire has on society the more value satire has as a weapon. It should never concern itself with whom the satire is targeted, thus be politically unbiased. Some looking through their personal political prism would accuse a good satirist of being partisan for pointing the satire at their own parties expense, while completely ignoring a good satirists history of calling things correct no matter whom their target.
I also value the claims from a partisan satirist too if their claims have a basis in truth, as putting ones own group in order has more value than focusing only on the issues of others.
nous devrions tous être charlie !
how did a channel with 2k secure a interview with ian!?
When I think of Farage I think of stale cigarettes rather than fresh air...
Check that against a pint of beer and debates that attempt to clear the air that are available in 2021.
I liked his hit songs in the 80s.
Smalltown Boy 🤣
@@AlisonBryen his contribution to The Fine Young Cannibals version of "Suspicious Minds" is up their with Elvis' version...if not it sometimes edges it above!?!
I think the test is never whether or not the world is better after you than it was before you, but instead whether or not it would be better if you'd never been in it. Basically the same except it eliminates the influence of others and just sticks to what you've done. Same goes for a thing you did in the world. Is it richer for it, than it otherwise would've been?
I don't think that's necessarily the be-all and end-all but it's a solid place to begin. I'd certainly put an investigative journalism effort such as Private Eye in the "is better for" category.
I've just subscribed! Sick of the other press offers.
"All that satirical cabaret in Berlin in the 1930's put a stop to Hitler didn't it? Oh no - it didn't" Peter Cook. The one we really miss.
We miss Alan Coren too
This man is a legend! Whatever he says, I believe him. Totally trust him. Would love a chat with him although I don't think he'd like me lol
simjem people had the same adoration for Jimmy Saville and Roll Harris.
Davy Tornado what the hell does that even mean? it doesn't even deserve this response.
I never trust anyone a hundred percent but I'll love to talk to him but he probably not be into talking with a purpled hair guy who wears too much black eyeliner and black clothes.
I bet you're great fun at parties.
I really like Ian and The Private Eye. Wasn't so sure about the handshake at the end, however :)
Two year's ago I saw our fella here on King's road, he looked at me and laughed prays indeed cleaver FELLA 🙏🇬🇧💯👍 Bless & Cheers💪
My mask was a laugh 👍
"Vague fumes of alcohol" I died.
Rather them fumes than the ones coming from ol baldy hipslop
If everyone stopped buying the daily papers they would deliver them free because they want their opinions in your house
They do. Via the internet.
great interview and some cracking questions there, good stuff
"How slow does it have to be for everyone to get it?" Wonderful!!
bit slower jc
I don't the read the Star. You don't have to read the Star, it has pop up pictures. ;)
Ed Lewis there is an obvious mistake in your comment. However with your error in grammar i learn how not to be.
Pictures stimulate the mind far quicker. ‘A picture paints a thousand words’
Ironically private eye has sketches and cartoons. I saw a very nice pop up card that showed a Maple Tree.
Snobbery between abilities causes unmerited conflicts. Discipline a person to better their skills or accept their skills as unique to them rather than purely judge.
@@gjeacocke I thought a painter paints pictures and writers write words. As for seamstresses stitching time to save nine, I know not.
James Rowden oh, so you don’t imagine pictures or moving pictures in your head when reading descriptions in novels,stories etc?
@@gjeacocke What? That is one amazing effort of extrapolation. I crown you King of the Strawmen.
James Rowden no it wasn’t for i draw. It was not for me. Or perhaps you lack something that you wish you had
The great Irony of Ian Hislop is he criticizes UKIP claiming "they point out sources of public dissatisfaction and not offer any solutions", this statement sums up the entire career of Ian Hislop and every one in the BBC.
UKIP lost. And badly.
Deal with it.
The slow mo great and best Jeremy Clarkson impression ever !
LOL! What a first question! It's nice that Hislop is able to take the calipers off his boots whilst being interviewed
It's almost as if he's talking about real journalism and a proper journalistic approach.
If they ever cast Babyface for a Batman movie, they should definitely use Ian
I can remember Ian with hair at Spike Milligan’s Lifetime Achievement Awards, clapping like mad ❤️
Spike Milligan is one of my great heroes - his four books on his wartime experiences are the funniest you'll ever read - a brilliant man, and humble with it.
Ian is lovely I can tell he’s kind it shows on his face
Looks like my high school music department...
Ian Hislop is a great satirist,comedian and world class intellect, I would rather he had taken over hosting QI than anyone else!
You're a very good interviewer.
Quite funny to hear him reveal that the most offended letters he gets are from right-wingers. Even in the comments here, the only angry and upset comments are from right-wingers who clicked on the video and wrote an abusive comment without bothering to even watch the video. Says it all, really.
Really? Where?....I've got this far and seen nothing of your "observations" ....Care to list them, John?
Just point them out and I will re-read all those comments I have waded through without seeing any real "Right-Wing" "abusive comments."
May I suggest you change the colour-tint in your spectacles? (Ever so politely of course...would not want to cause offence or "abuse".)
Met Ian Hislop once..........fantastric way to spend half an hour.......bright, clever and funny.
very cool
Well, I enjoyed that, good man yourself Ian Hislop. I think I'd probably only have enjoyed the interview more if he'd done a quick turn on that piano at the end.
I have visions of him giving a rousing rendition of Onward Christian Soldiers or Jerusalem surrounded by the liberal atheist journalists of Private Eye.
If you really want to know who is in Power ask of whom you cannot criticise - VOLTAIRE
Nobody?
Children with Leukaemia?
my mum?
A shadowy elite of Jewish, Muslim, transgender biofems.
@@RUBBER_BULLET Off your meds again, huh?
Does the interviewer looks EXACTLY like Ian Lee or has my brain broken?
I know, right? I've watched this quite a lot and every time it starts I think it's "TV's Iain Lee" ha
:)
Xanzia Klik is it not him?
he doesn't have a bandage 'round his head so it can't be
Some years ago a girlfriend of mine said that" You can tell a man from the shoes he wears". Hislop appears to be a prime exampel of what hse was talking about!
But Ian will be aware that God doesn't judge you on what clothes your wear. Great personality and Private Eye is a great magazine!
...My grandfather ( Jack Lambley ) was a cobbler from... Northampton, ( The recognised home of Cobblers ) and he would say that you could tell a man's personality from his shoes !
Also he was unable to enlist for the second world war because he had to stay in England and repair the Forces footwear.
a very interesting interview. IH ummed and aahed a good deal but proof surely that he hadn't been previously briefed on the questions. Interviewer didn't seem to refer to his device terribly much (unless he did it when camera was on Ian) which made me think he'd done his research, refreshingly. most surprising to hear the interviewer say he was interviewing someone else in an hour. I would have thought one heavyweight a day was enough. Must check out Dennis Skinner's go.
Ian bishop is a good man of integrity and funny long live private eye
🤣🤣🤣
He doesn’t say what he really stands for ?
If anything at all
Didn't he play for Man City ?