"Matching Asians with Their Names & Heritage"

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 09. 2019
  • This is a short segment from an introductory class on race and culture that is taught by Dr. Sam Richards at Penn State University. Today's video comes from the ninth class on September 24, 2019: • Soc 119 - Class #9: Bo...
    Feel free to participate in the chat space and interact with students in the classroom by using the #soc119 hashtag on Twitter. But please be kind. Remember, this is a classroom.
    If we show a video in class, we'll post the link here:
    We live stream every class, during the fall semester the live stream is Tuesdays and Thursdays @ 4:35-5:50pm EST. During the spring semester we stream on Tuesdays and Thursdays @ 3:05-4:20pm EST. Need help finding your local time with our stream? Go to www.timeanddate.com/worldcloc... and enter "State College, PA" and then your local major city.
    We also live stream a podcast every Friday @ 12pm EST! That time stays the same each semester and includes when school is not happening.
    PODCAST: You Can’t Say That
    Anchor: anchor.fm/you-cant-say-that
    Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/4lvJSFF...
    iTunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
    Google: www.google.com/podcasts?feed=...
    SOCIAL MEDIA:
    Class website: www.soc119.org
    Facebook: / soc119
    Twitter: / soc119
    Snapchat: SOC_119
    Instagram: / soc_119
    Video Tags (Ignore): Sociology, Soc119, Soc 119, Soc, Penn State, PSU, Penn State University, Sam Richards, Sam, Richards, Dr Sam Richards, Dr. Sam Richards, Race, Ethnic, Relations, Race and Ethnic Relations, Live Stream, Livestream, Live on CZcams, Asia, Asians, Asians from all over the world, Diversity in Asia, Diversity, Noticing Differences, Differences between asians, different features of Asians, heritage, pronouncing names, saying names, introducing people, saying asian names, India, China, Vietnam, Korea, Japan

Komentáře • 25

  • @Hsh-fg1in
    @Hsh-fg1in Před 4 lety +22

    There are many Chinese who immigrated to Vietnam, where their Chinese last name was rendered in Vietnamese spelling. All Chinese last names have a Vietnamese equivalent. For example Wong (Chinese) is Hoang in Vietnamese. Chan (Chinese) is Tran in Vietnamese. Almost all Chinese immigrants to Vietnam were either Teochew or Cantonese, which are both different types of Chinese people. This is in contrast to the Chinese guy on stage who is Mandarin for example. The different languages of China are not mutually intelligible so it makes no sense to ask the Mandarin guy on stage if he recognizes the last name of the Chinese (either Cantonese or Teochew) Vietnamese guy. They may both be Chinese but they are different types of Chinese who speak different languages. Thieu is the Vietnamese rendition of the Chinese last name Siu. So if you asked a Vietnamese person they would say its pronounced Thieu but if you asked a Chinese Vietnamese person they would say its originally Siu. On top of this there is politics involved because in China for example it is illegal to use non-Mandarin Chinese in the classroom. For example it is illegal to teach in Cantonese. Or in Vietnam there is hostility towards the Chinese (Cantonese and Teochew) communities who settled there but are seen as outsiders. So to ask the Mandarin guy on stage about the Chinese Vietnamese last name of the other guy can lead to a whole other loaded discussion as you can see. And it can be a touchy subject

    • @nikitang6661
      @nikitang6661 Před 3 lety +1

      in the past Koreans and Vietnamese did not have surnames so they borrowed them from China

    • @vcnolechetcong7742
      @vcnolechetcong7742 Před 3 lety +3

      @@nikitang6661 That's the Sinocentric propaganda. Vietnamese had last names. BUT. When the chinese invaded Văn Lang, they attempted to wiped out the Viet culture by assigning chinese last names to Viets. This was to make it easier for the chinese to collect taxes and to Sinicize Vietnamese aka commit cultural genocide. Throughout 1000 years of occupation, the chinese did collect taxes, but they could not totally Sinicize the Viets as they did with the Min-Yue.

    • @jw1731
      @jw1731 Před 6 dny

      100% correct. The surname 绍 is pronounced as Siu in Cantonese but as Shao in Mandarin, sounding way different. There was no way an average mandarin speaker could confirm which name in Chinese Thieu is the equivalent of.

  • @afriendyouwontremember4529
    @afriendyouwontremember4529 Před 4 lety +10

    80% win rate on guessing nationality based on face

  • @gsheverything_2716
    @gsheverything_2716 Před 4 lety +11

    This class is dope man

  • @lady_raineidv9297
    @lady_raineidv9297 Před 3 lety +11

    2:13 it's literally ka-ra-wa-la, it's 4 (four) syllables. sometimes it amuses me how americans has such a hard time pronouncing something so simple

    • @ssult4648
      @ssult4648 Před 3 lety

      Bilkol sai

    • @jw1731
      @jw1731 Před 6 dny

      I think even 20 years ago this behavior was parodied in the Average Asian skits on MadTV:
      “Hi I know your name is impossible to say, so I’m not even gonna try!”
      “Well it’s actually pretty to say. It’s Hideki, just say hee…”
      *covers up ears* “Ahh don’t tell me! I don’t wanna know! Lalalala…”

  • @jwlee7559
    @jwlee7559 Před 3 lety +5

    Just because there are a lot of Lees and parks doesn’t mean they are the same. Koreans seem to have the same last names but they are actually different. I’m a lee but I’m Hansan-Lee. Another person with the last name Lee could be Jeonju-Lee, Hwasan-Lee and etc. so when we see another Lee, we ask which Lee and we exchange our full family names. We stopped using our official family name because it represented class and it led to discrimination. Even now I can tell what class they are from according to their family names. Bottom line, we are not all the same.

    • @kilipaki87oritahiti
      @kilipaki87oritahiti Před 3 lety

      Yup also only royalty had last names in ancient Korea, like the Joseon period.Why many has the same last names like (L)ee, Park, Choi etc. but without being related as they only took last names that where popular especially Lee as that was considered a king’s last name no? Chaeseungeo if I’m mistaken.

  • @Thanatar13
    @Thanatar13 Před 3 lety +2

    There's a lot of shared or related names, tbh. My family name (anglicized Soh) can also be written "Su" or "So" and can be found in Chinese, Korean, Japanese families. My mom's family name "Ng" is the same origin as say- the Vietnamese "Ngyuen."
    One time someone asked if I was Japanese after reading my last name. Facially- heck, I've been mistaken as First Nations a few times, also as Japanese and Korean more often.
    Not a scholar or anything, just have a nerdy obsession with learning these kinds of things. It's interesting how they tripped up with the name that had a very Tai-Kradai sound to it (think Thailand/Laos/Myanmar/Cambodia). I wonder how they would have dealt with Malay names or even a Arabicized first name.

    • @vcnolechetcong7742
      @vcnolechetcong7742 Před 3 lety

      Ng in Cantonese is translated to Vietnamese as Ngô and *not* Nguyễn.
      Nguyễn is totally different from Nguyên . There is no Chinese with the last name Nguyễn , except 1 character in a fairy tale. Nguyên is translated to Chinese as Yuan like in the Yuan dynasty.

    • @jw1731
      @jw1731 Před 6 dny

      @@vcnolechetcong7742Nguyen in Chinese is Ruan 阮 not Yuan 元
      en.m.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nguyen&diffonly=true

  • @lady_raineidv9297
    @lady_raineidv9297 Před 3 lety +4

    "I think this is tricking me" sis the name is literally *Vivian,* how can you think that's a last name? It's not tricking you, you're just trying to be cute.

  • @rachelchu
    @rachelchu Před 3 lety +1

    yuki is kinda dressed like tadashi from big hero 6....

  • @Askariscide
    @Askariscide Před 3 lety

    Take mine for instance. My english name is Francis, then my tagalog name is Badong. Try pronouncing my last name: Macatangay. Americans would pronounce my name "Bdäng Mcutang-Gey" 😂

  • @keithmoh1
    @keithmoh1 Před 2 lety

    So they turned the age old "where are you REALLY from?" into an entire class?

  • @dbuc4671
    @dbuc4671 Před 2 lety +1

    bruh as someone who is obsessed with geography/cultures this is painful to watch

  • @speedythings7396
    @speedythings7396 Před 10 měsíci

    Indian guy mogs everyone

  • @user-ss7gn7kl6d
    @user-ss7gn7kl6d Před 3 lety

    Yellow shirts boy

  • @kamauwikeepa7308
    @kamauwikeepa7308 Před rokem

    What's the object of this discussion? I don't see any first nation people. You might like to ask yourself, where you're from.

  • @ashwinpawar5325
    @ashwinpawar5325 Před 2 měsíci

    That kid is way too tall for an indian guy