The Complete History of the Earth: Silurian Period

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 06. 2024
  • 0:00 Intro
    1:54 The Silurian Globe
    3:06 The First Forests
    4:43 The Rise of Fish
    8:17 Sea Scorpions
    11:10 The New Frontier
    #seascorpion #eurypterid #historyoftheearth #eon #epoch #geology #paleoanalysis
    After all the devistation that took place at the end of the Ordovician, life on earth was going to take some time to recover to get back to its previous glory. Luckily a few different groups held on and what followed would be 25 million years of steady warm temperatures that allowed them to thrive. As a result we see many different milestones in the story of life get achieved including the diversification of fish, the rise of new sea scorpion super predators and eventually the very first terrestrial ecosystem! Things are finally starting to get interesting!
    Check out My Linktree to join me on social media!:
    linktr.ee/PaleoAnalysis
    Most of my music has been provided by MehoDrums. If you enjoy any of the tunes in my background or into, check out some of his other stuff and contact him if you want to have him compose some stuff for you!
    linktr.ee/MehoDrums?fbclid=Iw...
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

Komentáře • 481

  • @TheKlaun9
    @TheKlaun9 Před rokem +1250

    I envy the people that find your channel in like 2025 and can just binge this series back to back.

    • @metalismedicine5499
      @metalismedicine5499 Před rokem +38

      Agreed

    • @Markfps
      @Markfps Před rokem +15

      He's been out and unable to do lots of videos, have a little patience my dude

    • @TheKlaun9
      @TheKlaun9 Před rokem +72

      @@Markfps no worries, not complaining, I'm happy for the free content :). I just envy some folks

    • @stormisuedonym4599
      @stormisuedonym4599 Před rokem +39

      @@TheKlaun9 Yeah, but on the other hand - they'll be in 2025, and if the recent trajectory of history continues...

    • @OldieBugger
      @OldieBugger Před rokem +15

      Yeah, I envy them too. Especially the 2025 me, who'll be able to binge this series when it's completed.
      But, it's just a few years ahead so no worries!

  • @ThePaleozoicGuy
    @ThePaleozoicGuy Před rokem +37

    I think what should be worth mentioning is that, by the end of the Silurian, only five of the nine generally accepted orders of Trilobite survived. By the end of the next period, only one will remain, Proetida. Really shows how well adapted they were considering we live closer to the extinction of Trilobites than they did to their own evolution.

  • @TheMaldawg101
    @TheMaldawg101 Před rokem +178

    Good to see another complete history of earth vid. This series introduced me to your channel and I can't overstate how interesting I find all these videos. Thanks for making this stuff for us.

  • @DerkMiester
    @DerkMiester Před rokem +154

    This series is truly awesome, dinosaurs are so saturated in our consciousness that I'm loving the conversation about the other eras of history. Can't wait for the next one!

    • @sirdetmist3204
      @sirdetmist3204 Před rokem

      Some dinosaurs are but there are other animals from that era that arent.

    • @ronschlorff7089
      @ronschlorff7089 Před rokem +4

      Yup, instead of the endless remakes of Jurassic Park movies, there could be some interesting ones made of other geologic eras!

  • @dudeinfinity
    @dudeinfinity Před rokem +131

    I've always been interested in paleontology, but I rarely looked into anything that wasn't dinosaurs. This series has taught me so much already, and has gotten me way more interested in paleontology outside of the Mesozoic era. I really love the work you're doing and I can't wait for more videos from this channel.

    • @bighomiestevethemetalhead8131
      @bighomiestevethemetalhead8131 Před rokem +11

      You summed up why I enjoy this channel soo much, I only wish he would post more frequently!

    • @mehodrums
      @mehodrums Před rokem +6

      @@bighomiestevethemetalhead8131 there should be a little more structured routine here soon. He’s still getting all settled in from the big move but is really geared up for bringing more content to everyone 😁😁 regardless of the consistency, I’m so happy to see these

    • @ThePurpleKrow
      @ThePurpleKrow Před rokem +4

      @@bighomiestevethemetalhead8131 he should be getting back on track of posting weekly videos soon! We recently moved to another state & you never know how much crap you have until you pack, move & try to unpack 😅

    • @bighomiestevethemetalhead8131
      @bighomiestevethemetalhead8131 Před rokem +2

      @@ThePurpleKrow for real, I've had to move a couple of times and it's crazy because you don't realize how much stuff you have lol. I just watched the Season 2 Preview video yesterday so now I understand, thanks for the info! 🙏🤜🤛

    • @ThePurpleKrow
      @ThePurpleKrow Před rokem +3

      @@bighomiestevethemetalhead8131 and we have quite a large collection of fossils & other fragile things so that's been extra fun, lol 😅

  • @anthonys3892
    @anthonys3892 Před rokem +2

    Yes! My favorite niche CZcams channel uploaded!

  • @Riley_The_Snailsquid
    @Riley_The_Snailsquid Před rokem +3

    YESSS YOU ARE BAKK!!!

  • @jonbate5513
    @jonbate5513 Před rokem +43

    Magic commentary. Mixes brilliantly the two essential ingredients of learning i.e. being Informative and entertaining. I look forward to each episode.

  • @MidnightsEdge
    @MidnightsEdge Před rokem +53

    Amazing video and series, thank you!

    • @CanaleAV
      @CanaleAV Před rokem +1

      Glad to know that this channel isn't a Frankensteinian abomination :)

    • @MidnightsEdge
      @MidnightsEdge Před rokem +1

      @@CanaleAV lol

    • @apexnext
      @apexnext Před rokem

      Time will tell? 😁

  • @jacobgoodstone7572
    @jacobgoodstone7572 Před 9 měsíci +1

    I just have to say I love this series. I feel like videos about the history of the Paleozoic start with the cambrian explosion, skip straight ahead to the first jawed fish, and then skip ahead again to the great dying. It’s awesome to have a series detailing the complete history of the paleozoic, and talking about all of these forgotten periods that were so crucial in life’s history.

  • @vault_dwelIer
    @vault_dwelIer Před rokem +39

    Keep these up. Just discovered your videos tonight and I had to watch the other videos to catch up to this one. Coincidentally, I found it within hours of upload.
    Your style is unique and very enjoyable. I very much look forward to going through all of the eras on this channel. I especially appreciate it when the more obscure eras are given love.

  • @hsdinoman2267
    @hsdinoman2267 Před rokem +3

    oh how i have missed this series

  • @williamwalker3826
    @williamwalker3826 Před rokem +1

    The King has returned.

  • @omarkarn
    @omarkarn Před rokem +46

    such a good series i wish it wouldnt end

    • @PaleoAnalysis
      @PaleoAnalysis  Před rokem +39

      That's why I find it so shocking that everyone likes it so much, we all know how it ends! 😂

    • @johannageisel5390
      @johannageisel5390 Před rokem +7

      @@PaleoAnalysis "And now we're in the time of the 6th mass extinction."

    • @rickkwitkoski1976
      @rickkwitkoski1976 Před rokem +1

      @@PaleoAnalysis 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @rickkwitkoski1976
      @rickkwitkoski1976 Před rokem

      @@PaleoAnalysis Just waiting for the Permian. That's the most interesting imo.

    • @scambammer6102
      @scambammer6102 Před rokem

      @@PaleoAnalysis no spoilers!

  • @silverbemyname
    @silverbemyname Před rokem +3

    Man I've been waiting for another of these videos for a while.

  • @msalas0101
    @msalas0101 Před rokem +3

    This series is great. Just found it and can’t wait until my 10 year is back. I’m going to rewatch them all with him.

  • @backwoodscowboy8992
    @backwoodscowboy8992 Před rokem +10

    Haven't started watching yet, but I appreciate the video none the less.
    Have been waiting for you to post for awhile! + I have introduced many of my family and friends into this channel.

  • @christinebartram6182
    @christinebartram6182 Před rokem +6

    I accidentally stumbled on your channel last night and I am blown away by the content on earth's history! Please please please make more videos, it's so interesting and I love how you deliver the content.

  • @orzelgryf
    @orzelgryf Před rokem +10

    The only problem with this series is that I cannot simply bingewatch all episodes until current times :D
    Yet.

  • @franciscahazlet4021
    @franciscahazlet4021 Před rokem +17

    This was a very interesting and entertaining video. It was great. I never new there were tree size mushrooms on earth. Looking forward to the next one. Thanks

    • @kevinpeters6709
      @kevinpeters6709 Před rokem +5

      And this is why the Paleozoic needs more coverage. We had a literal Mushroom Kingdom so to speak

    • @ronschlorff7089
      @ronschlorff7089 Před rokem

      yes, makes you think that on other worlds there will be eras similar to the ones on Earth; and there may be some big mushrooms there too, a delicious and potentially deadly food source for future explorers on alien worlds!! Que the next "B" sci fi movie: "Planet of the Toxic 'Shrooms"!! LOL ;D

  • @Mytwistedvoices
    @Mytwistedvoices Před rokem +6

    Keeps my childhood fascination of primitive species alive!

  • @veggieboyultimate
    @veggieboyultimate Před rokem +3

    YEAH! Bring on the history of Earth!!!

  • @TheShinyFeraligatr
    @TheShinyFeraligatr Před rokem +16

    Good old Jaekelopterus, one of the first truly terrifying sea creatures there was.

    • @kyokyodisaster4842
      @kyokyodisaster4842 Před rokem +6

      Nothing says, wtf nature, like a arthropod scorpion thing the size of a goddang alligator!

    • @svennoren9047
      @svennoren9047 Před rokem

      I wonder who came up with the name. Jaekel or jäkel is a swedish word for devil. (We have plenty of those. Most Swedish swearing is at the Devil, his home and family).

    • @jaredthehawk3870
      @jaredthehawk3870 Před rokem +1

      @@svennoren9047 named after the person who first described it, one Otto Jaekel.

  • @TheDesisgarf
    @TheDesisgarf Před rokem

    You have single handedly made me a paleontology nerd, I’ve spent the whole day binge watching your videos at work. Shut up and take your likes and subscription

  • @meg2831
    @meg2831 Před rokem +20

    I'm glad you are back. You make learning about the history of the earth fun. I never thought I even cared to learn about this stuff but you have me really interested. 😁

  • @harrietharlow9929
    @harrietharlow9929 Před rokem +2

    Evolution is one of my big interests, and you make it easy for even non-professionals to understand. love that Tim-Tim is evolving, too.

  • @nakenmil
    @nakenmil Před rokem +6

    I just binged all your former episodes yesterday! What a great surprise! :D

  • @billkallas1762
    @billkallas1762 Před rokem +5

    The Devonian is one of my favorite Periods, except for the end of it, when Oxygen levels dropped enough to make it tough to walk around, for any length of time.
    I must go back there, some day.

    • @ronschlorff7089
      @ronschlorff7089 Před rokem

      Mars, will be easier, it will be low O2 as well, for a little while (compared to these past time scales) any way! ;D LOL

  • @colemanmoore9871
    @colemanmoore9871 Před rokem +48

    What is the story with the giant mushrooms? Plants compete for height to get sunlight, but since fungi are not photosynthetic, what were they reaching for? What was the evolutionary advantage to becoming enormously tall?
    Also, what were they using for food? Were they breaking down rock, or using the cyanobacteria and early plants?

    • @scvcebc
      @scvcebc Před rokem +55

      They reproduce with spores, so being tall allowed them to release their spores higher into the wind for wider dispersal. Unlike modern mushrooms which release spores once from a cap that then dies back, the Silurian giant fungi stalk kept growing taller year after year. The stalks had scars from the older spore sacs, the newest ones were at the top. Their hyphae fed on the decaying plants which grew low around them. Without animals to eat the plants, they just rotted in place, providing food for the fungi.

    • @svennoren9047
      @svennoren9047 Před rokem +10

      PBS Eons has made a video going into this, it's called "When giant fungi ruled" IIRC.

    • @vikingskuld
      @vikingskuld Před rokem +1

      There I no purpose or need for a giant mushroom. None its ability to spread spores doesn't depend on such great height. It just doesn't need to and it's counter productive as that REAQUIRES MUCH MUCH MORE work and resources. There is absolutely no gain to get or maintain that kind of height. Noone ever considered the difference in oxygen the much higher air pressure and the possibility of a denser cloud layer. There are reasons why a fragile fly could get big enough to have a 12 in plus wing span.

    • @grahamfisher5436
      @grahamfisher5436 Před rokem +1

      this is a very interesting debate 🤗

    • @pnutbuderjj
      @pnutbuderjj Před rokem

      @@scvcebc THANKYOU i learned

  • @nobedience
    @nobedience Před rokem +1

    I could watch something like this for hours.

  • @jagtech490
    @jagtech490 Před rokem +3

    Great to see this goated series back

  • @jabootiimcfrootii1636
    @jabootiimcfrootii1636 Před rokem +5

    This has become my new favorite yt series, keep it up!

  • @bensantos3882
    @bensantos3882 Před rokem +2

    Coolest and down to earth paleontology channel. He may not be the smallest or oldest that hadn't broken the million subscribers mark but if he keeps up he will.

  • @TheSnoopoff
    @TheSnoopoff Před rokem +9

    Welcome back, can't wait to watch more of your amazing videos! Binge watched everything already months ago 🤣

  • @yovaha
    @yovaha Před rokem +17

    Amazing! Really excited for the next periods, and the evolution of the plants too!

  • @sksk-bd7yv
    @sksk-bd7yv Před 11 měsíci

    I watch this serie over and over again. It always makes me happy.

  • @allanbriggs6349
    @allanbriggs6349 Před rokem +10

    Please don't make us wait long for the next one! Your channel is amazing. Love your work!

  • @caseyleichter2309
    @caseyleichter2309 Před rokem +3

    Welcome back! And thanks again for these deep dives into less well-known periods of Earth' history.

  • @kuitaranheatmorus9932
    @kuitaranheatmorus9932 Před rokem +2

    I love this channel and this video was just so epic and I wish yall had a good day

  • @gwennahedden8485
    @gwennahedden8485 Před rokem +7

    Yeah a new installment of your history of the earth series. Love your videos. Educational and entertaining.

  • @kalebk9595
    @kalebk9595 Před rokem +3

    Awesome to see another video in this series!
    Here's my comment for the algorithm.

  • @gtbkts
    @gtbkts Před rokem +8

    Thanks for the awesome content!!!

  • @karayanna8119
    @karayanna8119 Před rokem +1

    I wish I had more friends to show this to. It's so good.

  • @Iamthelolrus
    @Iamthelolrus Před rokem +13

    These are some if my favorite videos, thank you for the time you take and effort you put into them.

  • @DragonFae16
    @DragonFae16 Před rokem +5

    I'm so glad there's another of these videos! This series is so much fun and no one else is doing anything like it!

  • @melissak118
    @melissak118 Před rokem +4

    So excited another video is out!! This is my first time really diving into the topic of the Earth's history and development, and I'm finding it so fascinating. I can't wait for the next one!!

  • @HVAC_Sean
    @HVAC_Sean Před rokem +5

    Can't wait for the next episode! Hyped for more placoderms and chondrichthyes.

  • @eggdog1051
    @eggdog1051 Před rokem +1

    I absolutely love this channel! It has made me find again my long-lost love for paleontology and history from when I was a child. Also insane respect for that tierzoo shoutout. Keep up the good work and thanks a lot for this amazing content!

  • @oliviawilder7540
    @oliviawilder7540 Před rokem +1

    So glad the new paleo analysis dropped 🙏💥🏜

  • @metalreaper493reaper2
    @metalreaper493reaper2 Před rokem +7

    Loving these history of earth videos

  • @arthureaton8
    @arthureaton8 Před rokem

    I absolutely love the little helper critters you use, upgrading them every episode in 1980s computer game fashion. Top Marks!!!

  • @swearenginlawanda
    @swearenginlawanda Před rokem +3

    I would love to see this series all combined on one video.

  • @joshuajohnson7848
    @joshuajohnson7848 Před rokem +3

    I missed the videos man. This one was great. Thanks so much and glad you’re back to making content again

  • @ATier87
    @ATier87 Před rokem +7

    Subbed yesterday coz of these period videos and damn, a new video already! Wish i could double sub. Can't wait for your following vids good sir!

  • @DirkVaughan
    @DirkVaughan Před rokem +5

    I really appreciate this series, thank you so much.

  • @shabazzmcclain5049
    @shabazzmcclain5049 Před rokem +2

    Welcome back! I've been hooked on your deep dives into the Paleozoic.

  • @WoopersDad
    @WoopersDad Před rokem +2

    Waited so long and finally its here !

  • @1Fracino
    @1Fracino Před rokem +2

    Hurrah! You're back! I've been waiting as fast as I can :)

  • @Xerxes2005
    @Xerxes2005 Před rokem +3

    A little disappointed that you did not talk about the Stromatoporoids, the sponges that were the main reef builders of that period.

  • @theomnissiah-9120
    @theomnissiah-9120 Před rokem +1

    Wow 40 seconds ago
    This is legitimately the earliest I’ve ever been

  • @Scott-wf9kp
    @Scott-wf9kp Před rokem +5

    So nice to see an update from you! Hope you're doing well. I love the way you talk about Earth's history; I can really hear the passion and appreciation in your words. You have a way of making every era of Earth feel special in its own way. It makes me want to keep learning more. Thanks for another fantastic video!

  • @senorsuave
    @senorsuave Před rokem +1

    We definitely blew way beyond your sub goal, congrats on your success. I hope you've made your offerings to the algorithm gods

  • @navigatorofnone
    @navigatorofnone Před rokem +2

    as always, your videos are always amusing. highly educational and amusing. 👍👍👍😎😎😎

  • @reidtaylor7269
    @reidtaylor7269 Před rokem +4

    Keep it up!
    Very entertaining summaries with the right mix of biology, geology and climatology.
    Admirable scholarship and presentation as well.

  • @dorkiedoodles2297
    @dorkiedoodles2297 Před rokem +1

    Can't tell you how excited i was to see this video pop up!

  • @kelseylogas1580
    @kelseylogas1580 Před rokem +2

    Hello! I completely stumbled on your channel because I was hungry for more paleontology videos. I absolutely love your content and I think you are doing an amazing thing here. The information is excellent, the animations and art are wonderful and imagination-sparking, and you have an excellent delivery style. I am so thrilled I found you; I have learned so much about weird animals after the Permian extinction an d the early days of life on this planet, something that isn't discussed too frequently because everyone rushes to the Cretaceous. Please do keep it up; I am enjoying this series in particular, though all of your videos have been great!

  • @jrr7031
    @jrr7031 Před rokem

    Ive been addicted to these and the comic relief is well placed and timed.

  • @mjtravers1507
    @mjtravers1507 Před rokem

    I sat here and binge watched the series. Wow! Outstanding content. Bring on the Devonian, that's my favorite.

  • @tuzruhu
    @tuzruhu Před rokem +1

    Your channel is so good!!! I really am glad that i found it

  • @johncartwright4041
    @johncartwright4041 Před rokem +1

    Your videos demonstrate a deep personal knowledge of the subject and extensive research. I always enjoy your videos. From Brisbane Australia.

  • @bigboss4993
    @bigboss4993 Před rokem +7

    We need a time machine so someone can go back in time and get fossilized to troll future humans

    • @ronschlorff7089
      @ronschlorff7089 Před rokem +1

      or an AI robot, that would really "cause a stir"!! ;D LOL

  • @TheGBZard
    @TheGBZard Před rokem +3

    Nice to see new content from you, keep up the great work

  • @mrmaison4924
    @mrmaison4924 Před rokem +3

    Love this series! Welcome back!

  • @poskeegget8043
    @poskeegget8043 Před rokem

    It is always fun when you drop another video. I always claim that pet videos are the reason youtube can exist, but videos like this, is why it should exist.

  • @EvilCat-EnergyCatalyst
    @EvilCat-EnergyCatalyst Před rokem +1

    11:52 that's a beautiful desert.

  • @michaelbrophy3023
    @michaelbrophy3023 Před rokem

    I absolutely love you channel. I’ve watched every video of the series. Some I’ve watched a few times. It’s amazing how much I learned in such a short time. Paleontology has always interested me, but had a hard time sorting out the different eras. Especially with the Paleozoic eon, so much to learn. Your series is very entertaining, and helped me puzzle it together in my mind. Thank you, and well done. I can’t wait for you next video.

  • @suckmyd1ck420
    @suckmyd1ck420 Před rokem

    The algorithm brought me here too early. I need more of this series. Even though I knew most of this already your presentation is phenomenal.

  • @lessonslearned2569
    @lessonslearned2569 Před rokem +1

    Finally. Glad to see you back again!

  • @wendywhite4537
    @wendywhite4537 Před rokem +2

    It’s good to hear from you again. Great video. I’m looking forward to more.

  • @coconutcore
    @coconutcore Před rokem +4

    This series should be called “The Greatest Story Ever Told”. I’m sorry, Jesus, but this is just too literally great to match.

  • @wesphillips7806
    @wesphillips7806 Před 3 měsíci

    I'm loving this series. I have a perennial desire to research the Earth's history and it ends up looking like 50 wiki tabs open across my screen. This show has consolidated it, somewhat. Thank you!

  • @LilliamSlasher
    @LilliamSlasher Před rokem +1

    can't wait for next episode!!

  • @tuxuhds6955
    @tuxuhds6955 Před rokem +1

    Another vid, you've just made my week!

  • @dustindavis3537
    @dustindavis3537 Před rokem

    Woo! Welcome back, and love the vid!

  • @Viatoreptil
    @Viatoreptil Před rokem +4

    I am thoroughly enjoying your "complete history of the Earth" series. I'm looking forward to the deep dive (no pun intended, maybe) into the Carboniferous and Permian marine ecosystems. Paleo-Edu channels have a lot covered regarding the terrestrial ecologies. Still, these are the two periods where I'm not very familiar with the dominant marine taxa in detail. So the Devonian is all about Dunkleosteus and the Placoderm co. But then you don't hear about a successful group until the Triassic with the Ichthyosaur radiation. Who were the top dogs of the Carboniferous and Permian oceans?
    Thank you for your content.

  • @malcolmhardwick4258
    @malcolmhardwick4258 Před rokem +2

    This is great well written and with a dose of humour ! Love this series really top notch stuff !

  • @theomacphail7687
    @theomacphail7687 Před rokem

    Awesome series, as a layperson it's engaging to see these things put into a continuous chronological context rather than presented in a vacuum as they typically are. Subscribed!

  • @duhsbo
    @duhsbo Před rokem

    REALLY looking for the next vídeo. Great work man, really well made and acessible

  • @coltoncarey7042
    @coltoncarey7042 Před rokem

    New to this channel, I am LOVING your manner of analysis and explanation. and the cute little skits are leaving me in stitches. Keep up the good work

  • @luckyotter623
    @luckyotter623 Před 9 měsíci

    I love this series. I just discovered your channel last night, and I got to say I'm hooked! Fwiw, I've always found the earlier periods of the earth's history (before the dinosaurs) the most fascinating. While the Silurian period isn't my favorite (that would be a tossup between the Carboniferous and the Permian) it does seem the most alien. Imagine if fungi had become the dominant kingdom rather than plants and animals!

  • @nekohuntress99
    @nekohuntress99 Před rokem

    looking forward to next videos, this series is so good! keep it up man

  • @Karnage420698238
    @Karnage420698238 Před rokem

    all i can say is thanks for making learning fun cant wait for the next one of these the whole series so far has been and is a blast to watch (tim tim is awesome lol)

  • @erichodge567
    @erichodge567 Před rokem

    Ok, I gotta binge watch this channel. It's telling me things I've never heard before.

  • @lucinho8958
    @lucinho8958 Před rokem

    Loved the video as always, excited to see more!!!!!!

  • @LDK447
    @LDK447 Před rokem

    Awesome organization and presentation in your videos! This series is really enjoyable and is just a great idea in general. Keep it up! This channel is definitely gonna grow big.

  • @Doktor_Morlord
    @Doktor_Morlord Před rokem +1

    i would focus on this series. this is good stuff.
    Found ya just a week ago.
    please do more of this stuff.

  • @jesseaverdijk9060
    @jesseaverdijk9060 Před rokem

    how often do you upload these video's? I'm really starting to enjoy them and cant wait for the next one. keep it up

  • @joshuasalem5022
    @joshuasalem5022 Před rokem +1

    Your channel is awesome and is going to get A LOT bigger soon

  • @alexielaxel1451
    @alexielaxel1451 Před rokem

    I just started binge watching your channel, love your content

  • @ieatgauffres4432
    @ieatgauffres4432 Před rokem

    honestly this is a strong contender for best channel on youtube, I love the narrating, the pace and everything is so comprehensible!