Avatar The Last Airbender: CABBAGE THEORY (Alex Bale)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 3K

  • @AlexBaleFilms
    @AlexBaleFilms  Před měsícem +782

    You can watch a brand new SpongeBob mini theory right now on Patreon for $5: www.patreon.com/alexbale (the theory will eventually be public in the big final spongebob bonus compilation. I'm still working on that video, it's just taking awhile.)

    • @danielsurvivor1372
      @danielsurvivor1372 Před měsícem +19

      The fact you're gonna make a Theory about Avatar The Last Airbender is a surprise for sure, but a good one. We will watch your career with great interest 🗿

    • @carlosdiaz-mo2ol
      @carlosdiaz-mo2ol Před měsícem +1

      Ol

    • @JoeMQZ
      @JoeMQZ Před měsícem +6

      Hey Alex, my theory is that the cabbage vendor has an infinite supply of cabbages. 🤯

    • @FootBallxFootBall69
      @FootBallxFootBall69 Před měsícem +5

      Bro i am super hyped to watch because i know its gonna be good

    • @ivnrvl
      @ivnrvl Před měsícem

      "Mini theory" and its 9 mins long

  • @starfiresreign
    @starfiresreign Před měsícem +6507

    This feels like a rant sokka would come up with at 3am. The cabbage merchant lookin real sus now tho

    • @countyfacts6920
      @countyfacts6920 Před měsícem +249

      Bringing down Ba Sing Se is a stretch, but he definitely brought down Omashu. There's actually no other explanation. And he literally hates all earth kingdom places: "This place is even worse than Omashu" mmhmm.

    • @scaper8
      @scaper8 Před měsícem +120

      Cabbage merchant has been _real_ quiet since this dropped.

    • @skits2240
      @skits2240 Před měsícem +32

      He would honestly

    • @seid3366
      @seid3366 Před měsícem +47

      Suki and Gaang: you know, it *is* strange how much we see him in almost *every* location we've been to

    • @Hic_Sunt_Leones-o7v
      @Hic_Sunt_Leones-o7v Před měsícem +44

      Definitely a cactus juice rant if I ever heard one lol.

  • @overanalyzingavatar
    @overanalyzingavatar Před měsícem +7445

    This is the first I'm hearing of any cabbages in Avatar, very interesting.

    • @dronix6624
      @dronix6624 Před měsícem +422

      yeah, out of all of the overanalyzing videoes I've watched, not one mentioned these "cabages"

    • @musicrocks0138
      @musicrocks0138 Před měsícem +51

      I’ve never watched avatar lol

    • @danielr.
      @danielr. Před měsícem +33

      Makes total sense though

    • @jamesbuscarini
      @jamesbuscarini Před měsícem +240

      There is no cabbage in Ba Sing Se

    • @Toester
      @Toester Před měsícem +64

      Yeah i have no idea what this guys talking about, who is this "cabbage merchant"?

  • @Danero1919
    @Danero1919 Před měsícem +165

    This has all the energy of someone who has found the truth and doesn’t want to believe it themselves, but not sharing the truth is tearing them up inside. Absolutely incredible theory.

  • @atlasbechard757
    @atlasbechard757 Před měsícem +2315

    I love that, according to this, this man is so petty he's willing to throw an entire _kingdom_ under the bus because they don't respect his talent, his cabbages, like he does.
    It's almost admirable the amount of guts he has

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool Před měsícem +2097

    Cabbage bending is the strongest avatar style.
    Fire the sun that helps photosynthesis. Water to drink. Earth to grow in and air to spread the seeds. Truly the avatar state or vegetables

    • @RedMonkey-ev1qc
      @RedMonkey-ev1qc Před měsícem +27

      But we will get to That part later.

    • @Ccrey_
      @Ccrey_ Před měsícem +24

      Water also helps grow and also the nutrients in the ground and fresh air…. He’s the avatar

    • @dowesschule
      @dowesschule Před měsícem +13

      Air for the carbon that it's made of

    • @fryguy9704
      @fryguy9704 Před měsícem +4

      Robot chicken moment

    • @cradiculous
      @cradiculous Před měsícem +13

      Only the Cabbatar can master all four

  • @RuefullyUrs
    @RuefullyUrs Před měsícem +265

    This theory goes down a dozen rabbit holes, only to emerge into something shockingly plausible.
    I'm in awe.

    • @JoséMendoza-d8j
      @JoséMendoza-d8j Před 18 dny +2

      Earth Bending to make those rabbit holes, air to spread out the dirt and hold it in place as Fire and Water do the rest

  • @santawithaflamethrower2758
    @santawithaflamethrower2758 Před měsícem +2013

    I know he's shown as and called a Cabbage Merchant, but think about it. Have we ever seen him sell his cabbages? He always has a full cart and never sells any of them.

    • @vincentfadoju8531
      @vincentfadoju8531 Před měsícem +75

      This.

    • @davidhong1934
      @davidhong1934 Před měsícem +172

      His cabbage carts do tend to explode violently before we can see him sell anything

    • @santawithaflamethrower2758
      @santawithaflamethrower2758 Před měsícem +109

      @@davidhong1934 Fair, but even in the afternoon when he should be getting a lot of business, he still has a completely full cart. But it is funny to imagine for every on screen time we see his cabages destroyed there are 100 others off screen and that's why he always has a fresh cart.

    • @DingleDuck
      @DingleDuck Před měsícem +22

      maybe thats just because no one likes him or his cabbages 💀

    • @santawithaflamethrower2758
      @santawithaflamethrower2758 Před měsícem +34

      @@DingleDuck Yeah no that also could be the case. I mean would you buy a cabbage after seeing a guy rub his face all over it?

  • @TheAangGang
    @TheAangGang Před měsícem +1367

    The cabbage merchants goes all the way back in Kyoshi’s era. “An overdressed merchant from Omashu haggled with a fire nation procurement officer over cabbage futures…”

    • @Keram-io8hv
      @Keram-io8hv Před měsícem +119

      So his symbiosis with cabbages made him immortal?

    • @toxincloud1629
      @toxincloud1629 Před měsícem +115

      @@Keram-io8hv probably a generational practice. Or u are right, Kyoshi was a disciple of Lao Ge the immortal and lived for 200+ years herself, and lao ge was a earth bender so we can only wonder

    • @joe4459
      @joe4459 Před měsícem +39

      Or cabbages in the show extend life.😮 Think about it everyone in the avatar show and past books lived 100+ years. Then after the company switched to technology everyone is aging horribly and dying young (relative to the avatar universe).

    • @KyleGK01
      @KyleGK01 Před měsícem +3

      Where is the source?

    • @joe4459
      @joe4459 Před měsícem +6

      @@KyleGK01 probably the books in rise of kyoshi or dawn of Chen

  • @lyndseystrait1513
    @lyndseystrait1513 Před měsícem +178

    LOL why is this theory so coherent though?! I was expecting the play insight but actually seeing a confirmed cabbage slug in the Ba Sing Se security scene is crazy! Also, if Toph can uniquely bend metal & the swamp people can spy on people through plants, then the cabbage merchant could definitely have cabbage bending! I really liked how Alex referenced both the original Avatar series & the Legend of Kora series. Fun theory!

  • @kaitalit9135
    @kaitalit9135 Před měsícem +494

    Bro I was so sceptical but after finishing it i was shocked. HE IS A SPY

    • @Friezahim
      @Friezahim Před 24 dny +6

      HEAVY IS SPY. HEAVY tf2

    • @Imperials3nate
      @Imperials3nate Před 3 dny

      ​@@Friezahim "That cabbage Merchant is a spy!"

    • @Friezahim
      @Friezahim Před 3 dny

      @@Imperials3nate that cabbage merchant is spy

  • @CT-mf7ll
    @CT-mf7ll Před měsícem +1020

    I think if you want to make this theory a little stronger, you can also say that the cabbage merchant is from the swamp and is a water bender. The reason he knows about the tree in the swamp is because that’s where he’s from. He’s able to bend his cabbages because he’s a water bender who’s bending the water inside the cabbages, just like how Hue bends the water inside vines in the swamp. The cabbage merchant even has a similar skin complexion to people from the swamp and a very similar hair color to Hue in particular.

    • @LeoLau-ip9bv
      @LeoLau-ip9bv Před měsícem +18

      huh

    • @Pimp_Frieza
      @Pimp_Frieza Před měsícem

      Valid

    • @bebepastiche9105
      @bebepastiche9105 Před měsícem +76

      Omg ur right Huu and Canbage guy have very similar color palates

    • @deodlow141
      @deodlow141 Před měsícem +57

      their is also the fact that those episodes in the swamp are mostly centered around pollution and starvation.

    • @Beberle675
      @Beberle675 Před měsícem +33

      He kinda looks like a water bender too ngl

  • @eleemaeli1830
    @eleemaeli1830 Před měsícem +89

    i'm only at 0:20 well cabbage bending is not impossible in the canon of the show, plant bending is a thing, a sub-bending of water that the swamp tribe did learn

    • @namelessdude207
      @namelessdude207 Před 28 dny +5

      It could also be a form of Spirit-Human Binding/Fusion (Cabbage Spirit -> makes more sense and is easier to make canon) like the Avatar

    • @eleemaeli1830
      @eleemaeli1830 Před 28 dny +3

      @@namelessdude207 oh god a cabbage spirit i want to see it badly

    • @eleemaeli1830
      @eleemaeli1830 Před 28 dny

      if i think about it Fructus can work as something close to it

  • @ShrekOgrestone
    @ShrekOgrestone Před měsícem +624

    No matter how much of a stretch the theory initially seems Alex somehow manages to find seemingly explicit clues to support it. Great theory as always!

    • @CruzingAroundTheBlock
      @CruzingAroundTheBlock Před měsícem +7

      Nice pfp! 😂

    • @ShrekOgrestone
      @ShrekOgrestone Před měsícem +2

      @@CruzingAroundTheBlock Thanks!

    • @beobabygirl9048
      @beobabygirl9048 Před měsícem +3

      ikr lol every time 😂

    • @lamiadominus997
      @lamiadominus997 Před měsícem +9

      This is so real. I almost dismissed the video entirely and passed by it until I saw it was made by Alex, so I decided to give it a shot. As always with him, I'm convinced. 👏

    • @teleportingpotatoe
      @teleportingpotatoe Před měsícem +2

      mike is life. mike is love. @ShrekOgrestone

  • @jessesgirl7299
    @jessesgirl7299 Před měsícem +305

    This is the type of unhinged theories I miss from Game Theory and team. No hate to MatPat he has a special place in my heart but this type of content is why I got into theories in the first place. Mario is a psychopath, peach is dead and now Cabbage Man is a firenation spy! I love it, keep it up man!!

    • @Januaryof28
      @Januaryof28 Před měsícem +11

      Ness is sans was my favorite

    • @Azurethewolf168
      @Azurethewolf168 Před měsícem +3

      Yeah I feel like as he’s gotten older, his theories are more toned down and family friendly now

    • @rickydiscord7671
      @rickydiscord7671 Před 16 dny

      I wish you people would stop acting like mat is the only person on youtube making crazy theories. there more people out there you know.

    • @KateCat420
      @KateCat420 Před 3 dny +1

      ​@rickydiscord7671 True, but a lot of people grew up watching MattPatt and he's who they think of when they think of theorists. It's not that serious, you don't need to defend anyone.

    • @rickydiscord7671
      @rickydiscord7671 Před 2 dny +1

      @@KateCat420 ANYONE can make a theory. you don't have to go and think about one person for that. is just a nitpick that most people keep thinking mat's the only one. also is "defend" the word you really using? because that's not what I'm doing. that's what YOU are doing.

  • @multiply98
    @multiply98 Před měsícem +41

    The whole show takes place in less than a year. Aang is 111 years old the whole show. I whole heartedly agree that cabbage man is a spy, but he would've been a spy the whole time. There's no 'years of abuse' to make him mad, and Zuko was getting intel from the very beginning. Cabbage man is likely from one of the fire nation colonies and is loyal to the fire nation, but he knows the earth kingdom well, so he's been spying since before Aang showed up.

    • @CatDragon292
      @CatDragon292 Před 19 dny +1

      Well, there could have been years before the show started. And so he’s been helping the Fire nation before this.

  • @SprayInk-Kreatïv-Nouveau
    @SprayInk-Kreatïv-Nouveau Před měsícem +495

    This whole theory is just as if the "My Leg" guy from spongebob were a spy for Plankton to help him conquer the world just because spongebob keeps breaking his leg.

    • @LordZemosa
      @LordZemosa Před měsícem +33

      I want to see this now

    • @KingdomMayFivePadua
      @KingdomMayFivePadua Před měsícem +24

      sorry to burst your bubble but Fred rechid (my leg guy) gets his leg broken to be treated by a nurse he has a crush on

    • @mikadotakimura
      @mikadotakimura Před měsícem +1

      Bro’s cooking 🔥🔥🔥

    • @ArtemisAYO
      @ArtemisAYO Před měsícem +4

      ​@@KingdomMayFivePaduawhy not both? 😈

    • @KingdomMayFivePadua
      @KingdomMayFivePadua Před měsícem +2

      @@ArtemisAYO contradictions

  • @bowserbreaker2515
    @bowserbreaker2515 Před měsícem +455

    This is crazy, but believable. Here's another piece of evidence: In the episode "Imprisoned", Haru saves an old man with Earthbending, but he immediately rats him out to the Fire Nation. It shows that Earth Kingdom folk don't automatically have loyalty. While I don't think that guy was a spy, it does show that anyone can turn on the Earth Kingdom.

  • @tk0buba831
    @tk0buba831 Před 25 dny +10

    Okay, but the cabbage slug actually blew my flipping mind

  • @DKTH77
    @DKTH77 Před měsícem +500

    I feel like if Sokka had this wrote down after a sleepless night, dropped the paper, Alex found it and put it into a video

  • @beanieb0b
    @beanieb0b Před měsícem +945

    I mean this in the best way possible, but the title and thumbnail remind me EXACTLY of the Theorizer

    • @nugget6723
      @nugget6723 Před měsícem +41

      I swear I thought I was the only one thinking that lol

    • @KikiQueen497
      @KikiQueen497 Před měsícem +12

      Same

    • @user-fn8xi1jg4
      @user-fn8xi1jg4 Před měsícem +20

      I know when I saw the teaser I thought it was his

    • @Moonstriker2514
      @Moonstriker2514 Před měsícem +33

      When he said "the new logo is a cabbage" that felt like a big twist of a mort theory video

    • @keanu3782
      @keanu3782 Před měsícem +4

      At that moment i heard the word "Cabbage-bender", i immediately thought on Robot Chicken

  • @-0.0-_0-0_
    @-0.0-_0-0_ Před 28 dny +5

    If this theory is true, props to the creators of Avatar, because that would be such a crazy thing to do like in the background just for nobody to end up noticing, except for one dude on the internet

  • @user-jw7nk2ur8t
    @user-jw7nk2ur8t Před měsícem +547

    I always felt bad for this poor old man. He just wanted to make a living off of his cabbages.

  • @user-tu2nf6fo2e
    @user-tu2nf6fo2e Před měsícem +297

    I have binged Avatar every summer break for over 10 years continuously (still going). No matter how crazy this theory is, it all somehow makes sense. Sokka in Legend of Kora says that he isn’t surprised that people could bloodbend in the day because he knows how benders are always pushing the boundaries to impossible extents, the same logic applies here.

    • @user-ul1xq2db4f
      @user-ul1xq2db4f Před 28 dny +17

      Cabbages are mostly water, would it be an offshoot of waterbending?

    • @user-tu2nf6fo2e
      @user-tu2nf6fo2e Před 27 dny +7

      Probably, if you can bend the water in vines to move them, I’d imagine you could sense things too. If you can bend vines, you could bend cabbages.

    • @Mark-fo6hz
      @Mark-fo6hz Před 22 dny +2

      if u are a gamer or like animes/mangas/novel, then it would really make sense for plant blending..
      a character or creature controlling plants just make so much sense

  • @beetroot4798
    @beetroot4798 Před měsícem +74

    This isn't just convincing, it's *REALLY* convincing.
    The Cabbage Merchant should be the Firelord. That's just some insane dedication.
    CABBAGE Lord.

    • @AchyParts
      @AchyParts Před měsícem +6

      The only being on par with the Melon Lord

  • @jennybrown7834
    @jennybrown7834 Před měsícem +279

    As theoretically weird as cabbage bending sounds its not the weirdest thing in the avatar universe in the old nick magazine they had a comic where the animators made fan ocs canon for one comic for a contest one of them was a cookie dough bender and one of the others was a shadowbender

    • @cradiculous
      @cradiculous Před měsícem +42

      Shadowbending sounds like the most generic angst fanfic someone could come up with. Cookie dough bending though... You have my attention.

    • @jennybrown7834
      @jennybrown7834 Před měsícem +10

      ​@cradiculous the other ocs were a old guy who could talk to animals a kid who could earthbend and had a rock dragon pet last one was a teen girl who could surf with waterbending and had customized weapons

    • @jennybrown7834
      @jennybrown7834 Před měsícem +9

      ​@@cradiculousand those are just the finalists the honorable mentions where a plant bender with a 6 legged koala a water bender who could surf who was gifted with sea creatures a archer with unusual talents and someone who could tie there shoes with waterbending

    • @iamgoingtogoof
      @iamgoingtogoof Před měsícem +11

      ​@@jennybrown7834 Behold! My one true skill! *Ties shoelaces with waterbending*

    • @gaminglegend
      @gaminglegend Před měsícem +2

      @@cradiculous Already exists in Naruto lmao

  • @matthewayala988
    @matthewayala988 Před měsícem +264

    nickelodeon: let's make a man who sells cabbages that get destroyed as a funny gag.
    alex bale: HES A FIRE NATION SPY WHO CAN CABBAGE BEND TRYING TO DESTROY THE EARTH KINGDOM.

  • @atlafan7364
    @atlafan7364 Před 23 dny +8

    Close enough, welcome back MatPat

  • @user-jv1ou4wv1n
    @user-jv1ou4wv1n Před měsícem +508

    Water benders can bend plants so he is a water bender

    • @zakronthesheep
      @zakronthesheep Před měsícem +77

      well, not necessarily. toph is an earthbender and she was able to see through plants, which suggests that particular ability isn't connected to any element.

    • @acrab6527
      @acrab6527 Před měsícem +86

      In the fortune teller episode Aaang says, "clouds are made of water and air so we can both bend them" and they do. so plants are water and earth.

    • @jimjohnsung4574
      @jimjohnsung4574 Před měsícem +10

      He just needs to mention Air benders in his manifesto and we've got ourselves the eco terrorist Avatar (working for the Fire Nation, using his water bending to sabotage the Earth kingdom, motivated by Air nomad scripture)

    • @pigeonflame9885
      @pigeonflame9885 Před měsícem +5

      He could have gotten cabbage bending from the lionturtles themselves

    • @scaper8
      @scaper8 Před měsícem +3

      ​@acrab6527 And fire from the sun for photosynthesis and maybe even air for pollination and seed dispersal.

  • @vivijansen7240
    @vivijansen7240 Před měsícem +136

    i am somehow always surprised by alex's ability to convince me of of the most ridiculous sounding statements

  • @JiggaBoo_Johnson69
    @JiggaBoo_Johnson69 Před měsícem +36

    Cabbage bending can actually be canon believe it or not; in the official short story avatar comics there was a story called "New Recruits", in it Aang and the gang try to recruit new members to help take down the fire nation, Old man Yahshi then brings 4 different benders with unique abilities. There was one bender who could manipulate shadows and there was another who was able to bend cookies, yes actually. Technically since this is an official comic that is canon to the show it is basically confirmed that aside from the 4 elements it is also possible to bend other things as well, so if a literal child can bend chocolate chip cookies then it's pretty safe to say that the merchant cabbage bending isn't so far fetched at all, I'm surprised Alex didn't use this piece of evidence to back up the cabbage bending claim, it would've really help to solidify parts of this theory low-key

    • @sidelamp
      @sidelamp Před 17 dny +2

      That comic is not canon. The characters featured in the comic were created by fans as part of a Nick Magazine contest. The winners would get their character featured in a comic for the magazine. Later on the comic would be collected into a book titled "The Lost Adventures" in which it was placed in a section named "Bonus Stories" and not grouped with other canon comics, making it decidedly non-canon.

    • @JiggaBoo_Johnson69
      @JiggaBoo_Johnson69 Před 16 dny

      @@sidelamp damn guess I over looked it, would've been an interesting focal point for the theory tho ngl

  • @Balrog-tf3bg
    @Balrog-tf3bg Před měsícem +111

    This… is actually one of the most compelling avatar theories I’ve seen recently. Good job!

  • @danielz6177
    @danielz6177 Před měsícem +107

    It’s crazy because I love Avatar to absolute death but I never noticed how many times cabbages appear in the background until Alex pointed them out

  • @Zigdog
    @Zigdog Před měsícem +24

    20:35 he is the leader of the red lotus.

  • @solonec.4285
    @solonec.4285 Před měsícem +147

    You know, actually the Cabbage Man wasn't from the Earth Kingdom, he was originally a waterbender from the Southern Water Tribe. In fact, he was one of the waterbenders that were captured by the Fire Nation before with Hama though he was only a small child when he was taken. Unlike Hama and being such a young age, he went the opposite direction as Hama. Instead of taking the path of revenge, he took the path of Stockholm syndrome and joined the Fire Nation. He was sent to live as the child of a Fire Nation vegetable merchant. He took a particular interest in cabbages because they sort of looked like they had faces. The other children like Chan (who grew up to be Admiral Chan's father) and Runan (who grew up to Hide's grandfather) teased him and called him "Cabbage Boy" so he had no friends and was very lonely. After school, he would talk and play with the cabbages and they became his only friends. He was still young so he never got to really develop his waterbending skills and because of the Fire Nation indoctrination, he eventually forgot he came from the Southern Water Tribe or that could waterbend, so later, he was surprised that his best friend Caibbage spoke back to him. Cabbage Boy didn't realize but he had just invented a subset of plant bending: cabbage bending. Unfortunately, his best friend Caibbage was starting to wilt and wither and he was desperate to find a way to save Caibbage. That night during the full moon, Cabbage Boy could hear Caibbage was close to dying so in a desperate attempt, he picked Caibbage up and ran toward the local apothecary. On the way, he bumped into someone and he and Caibbage fell. Cabbage Boy got up and to his surprise, his friend Caibbage was healthy again and all that was left of the stranger was his clothes and dust. Caibbage explained that somehow Cabbage Boy was able to transfer that stranger's youth to Caibbage. While Hama learned to pull the youth out of plants like those fire lilies, causing them to desiccate and die, Cabbage Man learned the opposite: using plants (specifically cabbage) to pull the youth out of people. Eventually, he was able to take it a step further and transfer that youth the cabbage stole and transfer it to himself. That's why he doesn't look so old. As an adult, Cabbage Man wanted to join the army but was rejected because he refused to be separated from his cabbage. Cabbage Man move to the Fire Nation colonies and set up shop there but his stock kept getting ambushed or destroyed by groups of Earth Kingdom rebels, particularly this one group called "the Liberty League" led by Plane and Feelerflea. Cabbage Man was driven mad from all the carnage of cabbage casualties and decided to take revenge on the Earth Kingdom. He used Caibbage to drain the life out of some random Earth Nation cabbage merchant and took his clothes. Caibbage taught Cabbage Man about the infamous cabbage slug and how they could use it to cripple the Earth Nation's agricultural production and economy. Unbeknownst to both the Fire Nation and Earth Kingdom, Cabbage Man played a significant role in helping to secure critical gains for the Fire Nation despite their poor leadership under figures like Officer Zhao and that Warden guy voiced by George Takei. Eventually, Cabbage Man found his way to one of the biggest Earth Nation standouts, Omashu...
    Anyway, from my understanding, the cabbage merchant was intended to be a one-time character but later changed to be a running gag. The only reason he appears again in Book 2 and mentioned in Book 3 and shows up in the live action was because the running gag was popular among fans.

    • @NotInting
      @NotInting Před měsícem +11

      Still counts

    • @1ndiebird
      @1ndiebird Před měsícem +4

      Oh my god man

    • @TOAOV
      @TOAOV Před měsícem +4

      Where did you get that info?

    • @pkkiller_apathy4568
      @pkkiller_apathy4568 Před měsícem

      A cabbage

    • @TOAOV
      @TOAOV Před měsícem

      @@pkkiller_apathy4568 Idk, fr now, is he legit or just talking bs rn?

  • @ultimategamerdoomdoom7414
    @ultimategamerdoomdoom7414 Před měsícem +120

    Also at Omashu there was a disguise that Soka (I think) had to use and it was a squid or an octopus and they just said that he was sick and they shrugged it off like it was a normal occurance maybe there had been an outbreak of whatever the slugs or rotten cabbages had and that weakened the forces of omashu this is prolly a stretch but idk

    • @AlexBaleFilms
      @AlexBaleFilms  Před měsícem +52

      Yeah I noticed that too! Wasn’t enough to make the video, but it’s interesting for sure.

  • @ladyamy1262
    @ladyamy1262 Před měsícem +5

    I was skeptical at first but the more I saw the more convinced I become

  • @alexdoloress2180
    @alexdoloress2180 Před měsícem +99

    I love the fact that this theory is right but also that it could be more than a simple agent :
    - this is not cabbage bending because the merchant power must be linked to the spirit world (such as with the swamp or this Guru who wanted to train Aang). The spirit world is the only option with Avatar powers to spy on everyone with cabbages miles away from the bender ( even strong techniques like blood bending can't be used in a long range or period of time, only a strong spiritual connection is required like in Jojo with activation stands)
    - Regarding all the episodes when the Avatar journey meet the cabbage merchant, he couldn't be a Fire Nation intel before "the Earth Book" so I think that Zuko had just use every intel from the army or even other spies in "the Water Book" to track down Aang (you just have to look for a flying bison) . To proove this, it would be logic for the Fire Nation, after this century of war effort, to create an impressive intelligence web across the world to find the Avatar/ exterminate other benders . On the other hand, they already have the ressources to create such a web, as seen in the show with all the mercenaries or elites soldier detachments (the Explosion Man other the Rhino-lizard riders)
    - In the Avatar universe, the White Lotus loves to approach every people who are gifted with unique abilities, such as Sokka with his soul of enginner. Saying that the cabbage merchant is a member of the Red Lotus could be explained by the fact that he was already in the White Lotus at the end of The Last Airbender (because if he was a member since the beginning he would have entered Omashu or Basing Se with great ease) . Remember, any talented people can join the White Lotus, even Iroh from the Fire Nation .
    -There is a disturbing link between the merchant power and cabbage slugs, because at first we would not understand why he had slugs that eat his source of power that is to spy everyone . However, we could also say that these different spy weapons are designed to his modus operandi : these slugs are not here to destroy Earth Nation's food reserves because they are just cabbage slugs, but it's an excellent way to hide the evidences of his actions . Basing Se and Omashu are guarded by Earth Nation soldiers or even Dai Li agents who could discover the truth, so take some slugs and they won't see that the cabbages they bought at the market have face marks like Katara's cabbage ! By the way the merchant could have an impressive power range + no reasons to be worried because this cabbage is in a friendly territory : Fire Nation archipelago 🥸 !
    At this point, there is just one missing element : I'm not convinced that the cabbage merchant is anarchist in Legend of Korra : how to be part of the Red Lotus, those terrorists opposed to the Avatar and benders in general, while you are some kind of privileged man with a spiritual power and a famous tech company with capitalist tricks such as programmed obsolescence of your products ?
    With all these evidences, I come to this dramatic conclusion :
    The lore about the cabbage merchant tells us a tale about the birth of a MASTERMIND .
    The cabbage merchant is a man gifted with a strong connection with his production . The problem is, he's born in a world ravaged by war where everyone could be a spy for the Fire Nation . Plus, any farmers will tell you the same thing : in a world like Avatar where you have rice or other cereals, cabbages aren't the first choice for in terms of productivity to feed everyone.
    But you know how you make way more money than selling cabbages ? Selling well accurate intels, thanks to this spy ability . Just need to hide some slugs to wipe the evidences .
    At the end of the war, there is a way better business with this power : stealing business plans and technologies from big brains like Sokka or any genius in this industrial era . Creating an influent company and be praised as one of the greatest personalities from the Earth Kingdom !
    Just one last problem : getting rid of the Avatar. Not only this person had already put the merchant in several compromissions by destroying his material, not only Aang and Korra are a bridge between the material and spirit world and can discover the secret cabbage connection, but the Avatar is first of all the one responsible for the murder of the merchant precious children 😢 Those poor cabbages need to be avenged !
    Destiny is sometimes pretty sweet... after he had infiltrated Basing Se, the merchant heard about Iroh and the White Lotus coup against the Fire Nation occupation. Using this precious information, he betrayed fire benders, knowing that one day, he would create a more influent faction to kill the Avatar.
    In the Legend of Korra, people have political debates around the utility of the Avatar. The Red Lotus is born, financed with Cabbage Corporation funds and tools of espionnage . On the one hand, the merchant lives on decades of tech fortune . On the other hand he helps any ennemies of the Avatar in the shadows .
    This was the tragedy of a man, only counting on his incredible power to live a peaceful life with his cabbages . Last time I saw such a character, it was Kira Yoshikage

    • @Serge2256
      @Serge2256 Před měsícem +23

      …bro is so sleep deprived he wrote an entire collage essay

    • @chip2499
      @chip2499 Před měsícem +2

      ok the dedication is insane, you are insane, but i applaud you

  • @Alchemis
    @Alchemis Před měsícem +49

    the fact that this gag character and similar type gag characters of other shows have enough evidence for huge conspiricy theorys like this that the origonal writers may have never intended is nuts!

  • @CrustySock1939
    @CrustySock1939 Před 18 dny +5

    Tbh bubble buddy from SpongeBob was a menace to society

  • @Vex-ey6mu
    @Vex-ey6mu Před měsícem +302

    I will never look at cabbages the same way again.

    • @benjaminbaer9712
      @benjaminbaer9712 Před měsícem +16

      Cabbages will never look at you the same way again either.

    • @MrBrineplays_
      @MrBrineplays_ Před měsícem +4

      ​@@benjaminbaer9712They'll be watching more often now

  • @VerbenaRP
    @VerbenaRP Před měsícem +172

    This man was on his revenge arc after omashu

  • @Iveno-Von-Aethervein
    @Iveno-Von-Aethervein Před měsícem +9

    You neglected to mention the southern water tribe's vine bending, where they bend the water in the vines to make them move. That's one more piece of evidence.

  • @RogerH_CxP
    @RogerH_CxP Před měsícem +196

    13:52
    Fun Fact: Aang had the vision about Toph in the Swamp, the same Swamp Toph now lives in.
    Another bonus fun fact: In the episode "The Avatar and the Firelord" Toph says "Do you really think Friendships can transcend lifetimes?". Years later, Toph befriended Korra.

    • @KairuHakubi
      @KairuHakubi Před 25 dny

      how did 180 people thumbs-up this comment. I mean no offense but this is just two very obvious things that we all saw.

    • @RogerH_CxP
      @RogerH_CxP Před 25 dny +1

      @@KairuHakubi not really, though. Not many people know this. Trust me, I've been on many forums and servers over the years to know this.
      But of course, over the years, it obviously became more well-known to people. Still, a lot of people didn't put two and two together. And since it's still a fun fact, I'm sharing it.

  • @ivanbluecool
    @ivanbluecool Před měsícem +1142

    MY CABBAGES

  • @vanyavanilla7108
    @vanyavanilla7108 Před měsícem +78

    Alex is cooking some real cabbage soup in this theory.

  • @Tiamat-sz5qi
    @Tiamat-sz5qi Před měsícem +48

    I just woke up randomly and see Avatar the last Airbender cabbage theory, I though NEAT... I see Alex Bale on the thing and... I watched the whole thing.

  • @Maxfromohio2155
    @Maxfromohio2155 Před 29 dny +3

    I’m convinced that Alex works for the studios that makes these animated shows because how else does he find all this stuff

  • @TheTrueKingofDRAGONS100
    @TheTrueKingofDRAGONS100 Před měsícem +58

    Mat Pat is gone but Alex Bale is back

    • @pepper-974
      @pepper-974 Před měsícem +1

      The man who can Feel In Role So That we wont starve for theories
      We need to thank him

    • @TheTrueKingofDRAGONS100
      @TheTrueKingofDRAGONS100 Před měsícem +2

      @@pepper-974 yes

    • @pepper-974
      @pepper-974 Před měsícem +1

      @@TheTrueKingofDRAGONS100Hehe you fail to se

    • @wuttington6307
      @wuttington6307 Před 3 dny +1

      But when the world needed matpat most he vanished

  • @princeofalbany
    @princeofalbany Před měsícem +77

    Just to tell you, the guy we see in Legend of Korra is actually Cai (Cabbage Merchant)'s son, Lau. Cai himself is probably dead by that time considering he already looks aged in ATLA and LOK is 70 years later.
    On another note, there is a subset of water bending called plant bending, which is exactly what it says on the tin. If Cai was a waterbender, he could have learned plantbending and used that to tap into the cabbage's somehow.

    • @seanchernov7178
      @seanchernov7178 Před měsícem +2

      There are THOSE in Avatar who with Unique capabilities had attained long life spans and sometimes even immortality such as Kyoshi, Bomi with earth technics (they specifically aren't immortals). Yet the most interesting example is Guru Patick who is at least 150 probably thorough Chi or even energy banding. It is possible that the Cabbage man being the supreme red cabbage had attained immortality through his energy connection to cabbages. And as such continues to work in the Shadow among or against other immortals within the spirit/idea realm or the physical one.

  • @LZRvision
    @LZRvision Před 26 dny +4

    This has got to be the best Avatar Theory I've ever, ever seen.

  • @spencernaugle
    @spencernaugle Před měsícem +70

    Just started the video, but I hope he goes over how the Cabbage merchant breaks the laws of physics as they exist in the Avatar universe.
    During the 100 Years War, The fastest form of travel that existed on Earth was a flying sky bison. But somehow the Cabbage merchant travels between locations faster than Appa flying in a straight line.

    • @darkninjafirefox
      @darkninjafirefox Před měsícem +11

      He rolls on the cabbages

    • @goob12309
      @goob12309 Před měsícem

      ​@@darkninjafirefox yeah like in the intro

    • @Maholix
      @Maholix Před měsícem +2

      Technically speaking, Aang is shown to be easy to distract and prone to taking side stops. I believe at one point a fire nation general thinks he's tactically evading them, but it shows he was actually just being a spaz. He almost never takes a direct route to anything.
      So it's entirely plausible that the merchant is beating him to locations that are well traveled through trade routes.

  • @dabatman5187
    @dabatman5187 Před měsícem +20

    The Cabbage Merchant being an Anarchist leader is not what I expected when I saw the thumbnail

  • @akosmolnar4592
    @akosmolnar4592 Před měsícem +3

    This just changed my whole childhood

  • @WittedMystic
    @WittedMystic Před měsícem +112

    The fact that he’s not at a million subscribers is insane. Some of the best content on the platform!!!

  • @ysca08
    @ysca08 Před měsícem +105

    ALEX IS BACK!!

  • @someone2436
    @someone2436 Před měsícem +4

    When team avatar tried to get the citizens of omashu out of the city; a guard said "I'm pretty sure I've heard of that disease before." Proof the cabbages worked.

  • @Scordeloop
    @Scordeloop Před měsícem +43

    I absolutely love how you use your horror film knowledge to make an immensely atmospheric video with great music choices, each one building up more suspense. Awesome video!

  • @Scotch7574
    @Scotch7574 Před měsícem +215

    This is definitely Alex's 'Sans is Ness' theory.

    • @HannibalTorrance
      @HannibalTorrance Před měsícem +50

      Still makes way more sense

    • @SpaceSkelet0nn
      @SpaceSkelet0nn Před měsícem +13

      i liked the sans is ness theory 😭

    • @louis7059
      @louis7059 Před měsícem +25

      I find it funny how matpat got flamed for that theory because they were just 'easter eggs' but then those same people would use easter eggs for their fnaf theories​@SpaceSkelet0nn

    • @TweedleDeem
      @TweedleDeem Před měsícem +3

      Naw

    • @blockedjuser1272
      @blockedjuser1272 Před měsícem

      And the theorizers mort thiery.

  • @viktordominguez
    @viktordominguez Před měsícem +4

    😂 the ending with the Red Lotus logo sent me. Great video! Love all the work you put into this. Definitely my favorite theory of the show now

  • @ivnrvl
    @ivnrvl Před měsícem +50

    So that last bit about the mouse, that could be proof of Iroh using MOUSE BENDING but he just isnt advanced enough to understand what the mouse is saying quickly enough and thats why he was caught.

    • @musicrocks0138
      @musicrocks0138 Před měsícem +2

      Mouse bending you mean like mouse traps

    • @dr.archaeopteryx5512
      @dr.archaeopteryx5512 Před měsícem +9

      Mouse bending would actually definitely be possible via bloodblending. So uh, that's uh, fun.

    • @donkylefernandez4680
      @donkylefernandez4680 Před měsícem +1

      Not necessarily, we've seen animals respond to human language beyond petty commands. Hell Momo and Appa are a PART of the group. Instead, people themselves who are more connected to the Earth like Iroh, Aang, and Cabbage Man have an innate ability to "speak" to animals, but because of Iroh's guilt and current responsibilities, he wasn't able to properly connect himself at that moment. There's also the bounty hunter lady that had a connection with her "hound" but that seemed more like a order-response relationship

  • @cosmeticincantations7997
    @cosmeticincantations7997 Před měsícem +36

    This really is a crack theory, but I'd believe it. The amount of times this person had to witness total cabbage carnage already had me thinking "Damn, how'd you not become some sort of enemy?" but turns out he was? Yeah, sounds about right.

    • @cosmeticincantations7997
      @cosmeticincantations7997 Před měsícem +1

      Also another thing, there's no direct proof of if he's a bender at all, so he could be a waterbender bending cabbageeeessssss......

  • @flaviamartinez3292
    @flaviamartinez3292 Před 28 dny +2

    I like theories like this. Theories were the creators didn't attend to do this but then instead theorists like you get so much evidence and proof just to prove it and I love it. So thank you for another incredible theory.

  • @InsertNam3
    @InsertNam3 Před měsícem +27

    I can’t unsee this….Thank you for your work

  • @windowstechsupport3562
    @windowstechsupport3562 Před měsícem +37

    Next theory: MOMO IS A TIME TRAVELER

    • @auditect950
      @auditect950 Před měsícem +4

      That would explain why he's the only flying lemur in the show.

    • @emmanuelyahaya-nh9fq
      @emmanuelyahaya-nh9fq Před měsícem

      @@auditect950 Please watch Legend of Korra there are more and they can fly

  • @josephmaller592
    @josephmaller592 Před měsícem +8

    The red cabbage 😂 20:07

  • @LollyPopLollyPop256
    @LollyPopLollyPop256 Před měsícem +21

    Why do i always get unnerved when I watch Alex Bale. It's not supposed to be scary lmao

    • @maryamzanana2630
      @maryamzanana2630 Před měsícem +5

      I think it's the choice of music he uses and the timing of it and how he draws the suspense out.

    • @jah-melle
      @jah-melle Před měsícem

      Same

  • @havalax413
    @havalax413 Před měsícem +13

    I love that this video is 22 minutes long like an actual episode, and has white book screens, and an intro, ect. Well done, Alex Bale! Great editing!

  • @calistodorren
    @calistodorren Před 3 dny +2

    You're actually not that far off Alex, "Cabbage bending" is actually plausible, Guru Pathik used energy-bending to show Appa how to find Aang in Ba Sing Se even though there's no record of him being an element bender, nor was he anywhere near the swamp...

  • @lenski8306
    @lenski8306 Před měsícem +12

    To be fair, i wouldn't go into cabbage bending because the swamp thing works because everything is connected like with roots and earth and all.
    However, if we go with the idea that the cabbage merchant is basically putting worms everywhere with its cabbages, maybe the cabbage merchant is connected to some worm spirit. Think of it like a tyrannid hive mind or something like this.
    And seing how some parasitic insects parasits can spread and take possession of insects or animals like sheeps or cows it could be a very huge threat to the Avatar world.
    And red lotus being spiritual and all, it could work, a worm spirit giving them info.
    Maybe a previous avatar basically went against a worm spirit and in revenge said worm spirit could try to go full last of us.
    In this, the spirit merchant would mostly be a tool ensuring for himself and his family a future at the top of society.

  • @CrispyCris02
    @CrispyCris02 Před měsícem +97

    If he's doing Avatar, I need to see a theory about if Suyin really is Sokka and Toph's daughter

    • @antoniacosta6221
      @antoniacosta6221 Před měsícem +1

      Come again?

    • @mr.waffles8739
      @mr.waffles8739 Před měsícem

      There's a theory in the community that Suyin is the daughter of Sokka and Toph that a lot of people made their head cannon (myself included lol)​@@antoniacosta6221

    • @Z3rd1x
      @Z3rd1x Před měsícem

      how… what??? No… Sokka wouldnt do that… would he????

    • @debater452
      @debater452 Před měsícem +2

      She isn't she is probably the daughter of a guy from the comics who's name I don't remember

    • @ImperatorNocturne
      @ImperatorNocturne Před měsícem

      @@debater452 Lin and Suyin had different dads, it would stand to reason that Lin the older and more responsible is the daughter of the mechanic guy in the comics
      Imo it would make sense for the more free spirited Suyin to have a more free spirited dad, not saying it´s Sokka though.

  • @tobyegwakhide7517
    @tobyegwakhide7517 Před měsícem +2

    Thanks a lot for all the work you put into this video, I really found it hilarious and surprisingly very convincing.
    I've got to say after watching this video, I can never look at the cabbage man thesame way again and will always be suspicious of him any time I watch or rewatch Avatar.

  • @nameistanya
    @nameistanya Před měsícem +33

    i see, a new muse has arrived, and is craving cabbages. i see through you, Alex.

  • @Olat67
    @Olat67 Před měsícem +9

    I love how years later, i found a theory that's actually good and somewhat hilarious 😂

  • @fairytales5938
    @fairytales5938 Před měsícem +3

    I love it when you make something like a plot twist in your theories just like in 17:30
    I love that man :D

  • @_itskira_9241
    @_itskira_9241 Před měsícem +13

    20:08 HE CANT KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH IT

  • @skyrogue1977
    @skyrogue1977 Před měsícem +19

    If he was getting paid for his info, that probably how he started Cabbage Corp in the future.

    • @Mrryn
      @Mrryn Před měsícem

      And it actually goes roundabout when Hiroshi Sato frames the merchant and Cabbage Corp for supplying tech to the Equalists: if the merchant was secretly a cabbage bender, Sato unknowingly assisted with the arrest of one of the benders he despised.
      And we know "unknowingly" because, if he or the Equalists knew about the merchant, they would have taken him themselves. It's just funny how things work out.

  • @PestilentAllosaurus
    @PestilentAllosaurus Před 24 dny +1

    You've convinced me. Cabbage spy is now my favorite character.

  • @Ms.Divine2024
    @Ms.Divine2024 Před měsícem +42

    Yas I can't wait. 4 hours left yall.

  • @Sideshowbilly
    @Sideshowbilly Před měsícem +14

    My girl friend was very confused with what I was watching when she jjst kept hearing the word “cabbage” said so many times in the span of 6 minutes 🤣

  • @MASRIDER777
    @MASRIDER777 Před měsícem +22

    “There’s a red spy in the base!”

  • @Barakon
    @Barakon Před měsícem +10

    I bet he became a spy because the only 1 who liked his cabbages was the fire lord or even the royal family in general.

  • @davidbagels
    @davidbagels Před 22 dny +1

    You can’t just start with
    “I think he is the main villain in avatar, oh yeah, and he can cabbage bend. But we’ll get to that later.”

  • @karlyuchka7004
    @karlyuchka7004 Před měsícem +11

    Alex got tired of being the SpongeBob guy, he's gonna become the Avatar guy now

  • @masscreationbroadcasts
    @masscreationbroadcasts Před měsícem +3

    9:05 This is the point I went "ok...ok, let him cook".

  • @windowstechsupport3562
    @windowstechsupport3562 Před měsícem +8

    What if he can communicate with the slugs? It would explain allot, like he could hide one in Kataras cabbage, its kinda like a spy drone for him, they get intel and give that to the merchant

  • @DanielJ_Mart
    @DanielJ_Mart Před měsícem +19

    I know this sounds crazy! But….. I think Alex might be onto something.

  • @pattyy2818
    @pattyy2818 Před 16 dny +1

    i went into this thinking im just gonna watch some silly avatar theory. i came out of it 100% believing it. I cannot believe he is STILL DOING THIS

  • @OhNoBohNo
    @OhNoBohNo Před měsícem +11

    agricultural warfare was actually not high on my list of guessing how the Cabbage Man would help the Fire Nation, but maybe it should've been
    This would be a good warm-up to a Spongebob theory proving the 'My Leg' guy is trying to take over Bikini Bottom

  • @SbevenGaming
    @SbevenGaming Před měsícem +15

    Say the line, cabbage guy.
    MY CABBAGES!!
    (Cheering)

  • @CruzingAroundTheBlock
    @CruzingAroundTheBlock Před 22 dny +1

    You can tell Alex had a blast recording this!

  • @HeraclesN-fp1bw
    @HeraclesN-fp1bw Před měsícem +14

    Cabbage Merchant is voiced by James Sie who also voices Jackie, Shendu, & Chow (Jackie Chan Adventures), Monkey, Viper’s dad, WuKong, & others (Kung Fu Panda series), Wind Dragon & General Kwan (Justice League), Kwan (Danny Phantom), Atom & Dyna-Mite (Batman the Brave & the Bold), Confucius (Time Squad), You Lee & others (Jimmy Neutron), Shoji (The Secret Saturdays), Louie (What’s New Scooby Doo), Penba (Chill Out, Scooby Doo!), & many more

  • @ambassadorofbadtaste
    @ambassadorofbadtaste Před 28 dny +3

    My love for cabbages throughout the video: 📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉📉

  • @BiG_Brain13
    @BiG_Brain13 Před měsícem +7

    I just love how he always almost loses his mind completely at the end 😂

  • @rikuran7042
    @rikuran7042 Před 28 dny +1

    Dude. You should do a part time job as car salesman.
    At the start I never thought I would actually believe this theory but it just holds (at least for the most part).

  • @TheDeamonscream
    @TheDeamonscream Před měsícem +8

    I’m grabbing my popcorn for this one! Alex only drops banger vids \m/

  • @misteranonymous1886
    @misteranonymous1886 Před měsícem +24

    "Laghima once wrote, Instinct is a lie, told by a fearful body hoping to be wrong. It means, that when you base your expectations only on what you see, you blind yourself, to the possibility, of a new reality"
    -Zaheer

  • @ladyjinyxx
    @ladyjinyxx Před měsícem +1

    My take:
    Cabbage man destroyed their crops to make a monopoly of his own cabbages. That's why he stayed in the Earth Kingdom. And selling them ships was a marketing ploy for more sales and endorsement. All of the earth kingdom went under from the slugs right? He destroyed their infrastructure and then implemented his own and got praised as a hero when HE was the one who messed it all up. He ruined his competitors. This whole show is about cabbages. He alone can manage the slugs on his crops because he can sense them all! So his fields don't get damaged!
    Also the Red Lotus is one of each element user, the cabbage guy is an energy bender. He is the 5th element.

  • @user-dw3pb3oj9g
    @user-dw3pb3oj9g Před měsícem +69

    MY CABBAGES AHH MOMENT

  • @itffo1240
    @itffo1240 Před měsícem +4

    Well, I have a whole show to look at and all he sees the cabbages. That’s how you know this man is determined to find the craziest things. It’s amazing how we could put the puzzle pieces together in a show where things go by fast good job, bro.