I still can't believe it... It is impossible... My drum and lyrics guru is dead😥😥😥I cry and I'm in mourning😪😪😪Condolence for the family, friends and all fans of Rush😓😓😓R.I.P Neil... My Brother🧡🧡🧡
Same here. I haven't tried playing them yet after hearing about Neil. I know I won't make it to far in before losing it. These guys are why I even pick up a bass. Music and the possibilities of what it could be changed when I heard them for the first time.
@Eric I didn't get to see them live. I had the chance in 2012 and I messed up. They played in Indianapolis. I was living just south of there. I know Alex and Ged will do something together. It'll be awesome but bitter sweet without Neil. Just have to patiently wait. I wonder what other collaborations they will do in the future.
@EricI'm 57 and my favorite band since 1974 and thank God got to see them over 40 times... Neil God bless you and now your playing for everyone in Heaven..R.I. P. and thank you for your great performances...😟
Alex always said he played a certain way and used open chords to give the illusion that there’s more than one guitar playing because of how important a full sound is in a 3 piece band. Very brilliant and an absolute freakish player.
Must MUST MUST agree! He has NEVER gotten his due among the best! But after 43 years of them being my favorite band, I think I realize that they didn't care about their individual standing. They just wanted to be the TIGHTEST and BEST they could be! Off of each other. God bless them!!
There's Neil ........................................................................................................................................................................................... then there's #2,3,4 etc
Neil never crossed "the line" of his drum kit and left that space for Geddy and Alex to do their thing. You can tell these guys were good friends in addition to band mates...
When asked in an interview, Alex said Natural Science was a favorite Rush song to play but was also extremely demanding and difficult to play consistently.
Why do people keep saying this? Hes in a hugely successful rock band where there’s no other guitarist so obviously hes an important part. Many famous guitarists have praised him many times. Hes in a shit ton of guitar magazines and websites. He has guitar and amp sponsores. Idk where this idea that he’s underrated comes from.
Someone i would say is legit underrated is omar rodriguez lopes from mars volta, who alex and neil were a fan of. He rarely gets talked about. Absolutely incredible guitarist.
This is a perfect Rush song. Alex's guitar is at a frenetic pace, the drums are insane, you got time signature changes, and Geddy's voice and bass holding it all together. With most of your biggest pop bands, it's not that they WON'T do this......they CAN'T do this....not on their best day.
Indeed,look at what's going on now..the truth is a horrible hateful thing,according to those who presume to do our thinking for us(MSM)..as people who speak the truth are also horrible hateful people,to be demonised and thrown out of their jobs and homes...We are now in a war,my friend.
This is the ultimate Rush song. Lyrics, Guitar, Bass, and Vocals. This is also possibly the best live performance of this song I have seen and I've seen them 14 times. Perhaps its because they are in their homeland. I LOVE THESE GUYS!! I'm 55, and they were the soundtrack of my life. Lets get it together ppl and LOVE one another. They surely loved us!!
I love how Neil plays the entire first section in traditional grip, seemingly just becuase he can. Rest in peace, one of the greatest to ever pick up a pair of sticks
90's = Neil at his peak. He had perfected his art while still being young or healthy enough to put a ridiculous amount of power behind his drumming. It baffles me how a kit could survive an entire tour with Peart or Bonham behind it. Two of the hardest hitters in drumming.
I’ve seen a video where he put the bass pedal through the drum skin. That should be impossible. They are designed very carefully and I can assure you that an incredible amount of years and research went into drums we know today. I met the man credited for developing them at my daughter’s music school in Boston. It is the oldest music school in America. How I would have loved to see the look on that man’s face the moment Neil’s pedal went through that bass drum.
I had the pleasure of seeing this in person once. When I had listened to the album, I assumed this was a studio piece meaning they don't perform live. At the beginning of the song I thought, Oh can't believe they are attempting this! Boy was I wrong. They flew through the song as if they could be holding a phone conversation while playing their parts. They were that good and prepared. It. Was. Awesome!!
I saw this at the Spirit of Airwaves recording, the bootleg concert recording front row February 13th in St. Louis. Sat 15 away from Geddy and it was SO epic. The set list was their best ever and all 3 were as good as they could ever be. Those 4 front row tickets cost me 35 dollars with a 50 cent handling charge per ticket. I got those tickets by being the first caller to reach Dial-Tix when lines opened at 10am. This would not have happened if not for my mom letting me skip school to do so. By far my best concert ever
I was at this very show with my girlfriend (now wife) - it was her first exposure to Rush (my first time live). Was totally blown away at the sound these 3 guys made! This was a show beyond anything we had seen prior, and serves as near tops of anything since! Seeing 2112 in entirety that night was something special, so was this song...The entire setlist, mixed with the atmosphere of the night (warm summer breeze coming off of Lake Ontario, the laser lights as the sun went down, the clouds of pot smoke, and these hometown boys) made for an experience like no other!!
Lucky you! The more I see of this show, the more I hope that someday they'll release a DVD of the entire show. Although it's hard to be definitive on a band who were such unrelenting perfectionists, I don't think they ever looked or sounded better. Not sure why it is coming out in bits and pieces. I believe the first half hour or so was a bonus on the R40 boxset, and then a couple more songs were on the bonus bonus R40 disc. Don't get me started on the R40 box, which I never bought, because it was asking a lot of those of us who already owned the other DVD's, to buy them again for the sake of a single bonus disc. And then I can only imagine the feelings of those fans who forked out for the R40, only to find out that there was a bonus bonus disc, which they didn't get unless they ordered it from the Backstage club. But then, I might get started......... oops too late.
Ryan Haydock a wee too laid back compared to the Permanent Waves/MP era though! I've heard the legendary St Louis 80 Superstars of Rock show/bootleg and back then Natural Science had an F'ing mind of its own😯😯😯 they could barely control & contain the damn thing💗😎💗
@@johnIZaUWL that's when I was front row in front of Geddy, the first third night. I was one of the first 25 people to get tickets to the Dec 13th show I believe it was but they sold out so quick they booked another then another, just so happened Kiel was available for 3 nights and they sold em all out. Geddy was yelling at us in the front rows, you guys are the originals, you'll get our best. Talk about full filling a promise or statement. That and Aftk weremy best concerts ever. Every song a monster
Life and Death is a mystery. Just over a month after this concert Neil’s daughter will be killed in a car accident and his wife would be gone within a year. And now he is gone. Thanks for all the great stories that inspired the music Neil. RIP
"wheels within wheels... a spiral array... a pattern so grand and complex..." p.s. was the first tour they performed it live?? If I Recall Correctly ... they didn't used to perform it live just after "Permanent Waves" 'cuz it was a bit too complicated...
@@SpotWorksLNC Indeed. He was a brilliant man, however tragedy no doubt made him a much deeper (wiser/compassionate) man because of it. Those two don't often go together.
This must be the ultimate prog metal song. Not sure Rush have ever bettered this, but then who has? The stunning power of it, the contrasts, the seamless shifting between weird time signatures, and of course the portentous, rather alienated lyric, all add up to something greater than the sum of its parts.
Simply amazing, I’m so glad I discovered this amazing group of guys. The fact that 3 people can get this amount of sound is incredible. I don’t think I’ll ever discover a band that top this.
Chris, I also must have my "daily" RUSH !!! I saw 22 live shows over the years, starting with the Vapor Trails tour and would have preffered 122. I discovered Rush a bit late though... :-(
I'm the same way. Gotta have my daily dose of RUSH. Since Neil's passing, I've been through their catalog multiple times. IMO, they're the best band ever! All 3 guys, amazing musicians! RIP Neil....
I don’t know when exactly they excised the verse (and added extra “wheels within wheels”) but this arrangement was standard for years before and evermore after.
@@paulsikes3515 This tour (TFE) was the first time they changed the arrangement, it was the first tour Natural Science was played since 1981. I don’t mind it but part of me really misses the “art as expression” verse with the guitar solo.
This is one of my favorite Rush songs. I remember hearing that Rush was going to play a song on the T4E tour that they had never played live. When my friend and I were on our way to the show, I told him if they played Natural Science it would make my life! When the song started, I almost didn't even recognize it because it shocked me to hear it live. What a great night that was and what a great show.
They also played it on Snakes & Arrows tour in 2007/2008. (Was) Always pumped to see it live. Awesome to see it and Jacob's Ladder on R40. It was definitely a high point of my life.
All you need to do is listen to RUSH often, Loud, and with a friend. Share Rush with everyone when possible. Rest In Peace Professor. Stay strong Alex, Geddy. Love ya all. Peace
This song, live and original, gives me chills every time I hear the opening verse with the full band. "Wheels within Wheels in a spiral array, a pattern so grand and complex. Time after time, we lose sight of our way, our causes can't see their effects..."
Alex Lifeson ONLY SEEMS to be Under rated, BECAUSE HE IS PLAYING ALONG SIDE THE WORLDS BEST DRUMMER AND PROBABLY THE BEST ROCK BASSIST EVER !!! PS He is pretty good despite very bad arthritis problems in hands !!!!! Give it up for the best all around ROCK GUITARIST of all time !!!
Eddie Van Halen said when asked "What does it feel like to be the top Guitarist?" He replied, " I do not know, ask Alex Liefeson!!!" True story as reported by Rolling Stone Mag
FUCK YES! MY GUITAR HERO, and the reason i can play ANYTHING at all today.... Along with Elliot Easton and a pile of other killer players ... criminally underrated.
Perhaps their greatest live performance. Certainly my favorite. No one comes close and never will. Thank you Rush for all the great songs. They have meant so much to so many.
First time I ever heard Rush was around 1977/8 the album "A Farewell to Kings" and Closer to the Heart was a 12 inch single released here in the UK(still have it), anyway I am now 62 yrs old and that was me totally hooked 43 years ago. Just pure unbelievable musicianship from these 3 Canadians. The Professor Neil Peart will be very sorely missed by the great family of Rush fans but we will never forget what this man meant to us all. Thank you for the incredible lyrics Sir.
The most epic band, playing their most epic song. A band like Rush only comes along once in a Millennium...... Thank You Universe for aligning all the stars at the perfect time for these 3 Masters to meet
40 days before Neil's life was turned upside down. Sad he's gone now. I cherish every concert of theirs I've been to, and wish there would have been more. Best group of guys, best musicians and artists in rock and roll.
Preach, bruther! I came to this song a bit late, I'm not shy to admit. Full appreciation did not bloom until I heard it live. I believe that must have been Snakes & Arrows leg 2 in 2008.
All I can say is , "THANK YOU, Alex, Geddy, Neil for ALL the music and memories!! Was lucky enough to see them with friends and then my kids at least 5 times and was stoked to know this song was included in one of those concerts!! What a CLASS act!! Happiness in your quieter days ahead and thank you guys again!!!
Took my wife to this show. It was her first “live” RUSH. Blew her away! Molson Amphitheater in Toronto, same place I took her to for Supertramp and Floyd.
I sat next to Lerxst's family - the kid next to me had a college recommendation from Alex's father he said - was amazing - his Mom and Dad were like 4 seats from me - lol
Sorry but you are wrong...Neils daughter was killed on my frikn birthday of all days..6-20...so Neil was dealing with that tragic loss for a week and a half..unfortunately
In over 50 concerts I've seen, my very favorite moment of them all was this song, 1981, the fog machine was full blast with the magenta and green colored lights, and Alex Lifeson playing the 2nd guitar solo with his head cocked slightly to one side surrounded by the curling fog all lit up by spotlights, in his red dinner jacket, playing his blonde ES-345. That does it for me.
nEIL pEART the greatest drummer, lyricist, and creative artist in our times. Ya know I can really sympathize with Neil when he told the band he just didn't have the energy to do it anymore because he was battling cancer and being a drummer takes alot more physical energy than the rest of the band needed on an almost daily basis. RIP PROFFESSOR
This song is from Rush's very best album. Every song is good. Its such a perfect combination of strong guitar riffs, excellent songs, perfectly produced. Its that perfect combination of early Rush meets "pop" Rush.
Picking a best album from Rush is like picking a favorite food...:)...Permanent Waves is brilliant, true... but, Caress of Steel, 2112, Hemispheres, Farewell to kings ( my favorite), Moving Pictures or Signals are no less great...:)
My favorite Rush album is 2112FarewellToKingsHemispheresPermanentWavesMovingPicturesSignalsGraceUnderPressureCounterpartsSnakesAndArrowsClockworkAngels. My 2nd favorite Rush album is RushFlyByNightCaressOfSteelPowerWindowsHoldYourFirePrestoRollTheBonesTestForEchoVaporTrails
I was at this show; an unbelievable night watching and hearing Rush live like this is one of the greatest concert experiences of my life! Long live Rush
Neil had a summer home not too far from Le Studio in the Larentian mountains in southern Quebec. He named a small rock island (1 of four that were on the lake) he had bought in the after years as a memento for his love of that mystical place he so loved. He named it "science island". He took his second daughter Olivia to that island to teach her about nature and natural science. RIP Neil you were an educator and professor to world.
Can I give that 100 thumbs up?! I had the pleasure of seeing them play this song when they came to Nashville on this tour which was sometime in the Summer of 1997. Of course this was also the tour where they played the whole first side of 2112! Not just the overture and the Temples of Syrinx but the whole enchilada!! Thank you Rush!!!
Saw them 3 times in the Northeast on this tour. Nailed this song each show. If that doesn't scream the extent of their talent, you either don't know what it takes to play it or you are deaf.
Rest in Peace, Neil Peart. Greatest drummer to ever play, in the greatest band of all time. Also, the greatest (most intelligent, thought-provoking) songwriter in the world. For anyone who doesn’t know, he wrote almost all of Rush’s lyrics. He was the heart of the band. May he rest easily, hopefully with his wife and daughter. I love you, Neil Peart!
It's tough seeing Neil playing with his arm strapped up. A sign of much worse things to come. It didn't affect his playing here, though, because he refused to let it, but man, he must have been in agony after a full gig. Much love and respect, boys. ♥♥(♥).
Rest easy Neil. Lifelong hero to myself, my dad, countless others. Absolutely devastated, can't imagine keeping brain cancer a secret battle for years but that just shows how private and humble he was. His music and words are immortal, thank you for everything.
Several years ago I saw Rush in concert, and they played Natural Science. I was absolutely stunned! Never had I ever witnessed such musicianship! They hit every note, every beat with such accuracy and authority, and at the end I had tears running down my face! I'm sure I wasn't the only one either! I had just witnessed the greatest band ever!
i had the exact same experience at the R30 tour with Xanadu.... in 25 yrs of shows id NEVEr heard them play Xanadu live Mind fucking BLOWN. it was just so goddamn perfect I cried like a little girl lol. I feel real pain when i think of how i missed the R40 tour.......;-(
That was a great concert. It was the 3rd (and last) time that I saw these fine lads in Toronto. However, I am grateful for having saw the R40 show in Chicago.
So privileged to have seen Rush live on the Time Machine Tour. Such gifted musicians and writers and so much humour. They looked so relaxed on stage blissfully unaware of the starstruck teenager grin on my 43 year old face.
Saw them play this live on the TFE tour and was like a little kid. They also played the full 2112 epoch including ’Dream’ for the first time live on this tour. The tempo on this performance is smokin’! 🫡🥇✊
I still can't believe it... It is impossible... My drum and lyrics guru is dead😥😥😥I cry and I'm in mourning😪😪😪Condolence for the family, friends and all fans of Rush😓😓😓R.I.P Neil... My Brother🧡🧡🧡
Snowdog, I feel you brother, I looked up to him like a big brother, rest in peace neil
Same here. I haven't tried playing them yet after hearing about Neil. I know I won't make it to far in before losing it. These guys are why I even pick up a bass. Music and the possibilities of what it could be changed when I heard them for the first time.
Legend NEVER die Even if I m really sad about this :(
@Eric I didn't get to see them live. I had the chance in 2012 and I messed up. They played in Indianapolis. I was living just south of there. I know Alex and Ged will do something together. It'll be awesome but bitter sweet without Neil. Just have to patiently wait. I wonder what other collaborations they will do in the future.
@EricI'm 57 and my favorite band since 1974 and thank God got to see them over 40 times... Neil God bless you and now your playing for everyone in Heaven..R.I. P. and thank you for your great performances...😟
A lot of people don't realize how difficult this song is on guitar...Alex Lifeson is one of the best guitarists of all time
He's the core of Rush to my ears
Alex always said he played a certain way and used open chords to give the illusion that there’s more than one guitar playing because of how important a full sound is in a 3 piece band. Very brilliant and an absolute freakish player.
I agree. He is also the most underrated guitarist of all time, bar none.
Must MUST MUST agree! He has NEVER gotten his due among the best! But after 43 years of them being my favorite band, I think I realize that they didn't care about their individual standing. They just wanted to be the TIGHTEST and BEST they could be! Off of each other. God bless them!!
I agree
...and God said: "I will put the 3 greatest musicians together and I will call them Rush"
God really is a good judge of musical talent. RUSH is pound for pound, the most talented band ever. Skill levels for those 3 were off the charts!!
OMG!!!!! Deluded people.
@@alanstrom2221 OMG! It's their opinion and their taste. With a nice twist of humor there
One of their top 10. Always gives me goosebumps!!!!!
And all the world will cheer
Alex Lifeson just may be the most underrated guitarist ever.
Snake Plissken not maybe, definitely!!!
Snake Plissken He certainly isn't the best guitarist ever, but he is certainly underrated.
+JabbaDuhHut there is no best guitarist
MrCold012 At no point in his reply did he say that there was "a best guitarist". Try reading the post again.
LudwigSC93 Jabba said: "He certainly isn't the best guitarist ever." implying there is a category of best guitarist.
RIP NEIL PEART
The greatest drummer of all time. Thank you for everything.
missing a lot
Bonham was but Neil is great too
There's Neil ........................................................................................................................................................................................... then there's #2,3,4 etc
@@gigigregory3043 Neil can do what Bonham did, but Bonham could never do what Neil did
@@25newrush Totally agree.
Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson goofing off a bit mid song and Neil is in complete intense concentration playing. God I love this band.
their goofing off is one of the added pleasures the band gives us
Neil never crossed "the line" of his drum kit and left that space for Geddy and Alex to do their thing. You can tell these guys were good friends in addition to band mates...
Alex doesn't get enough respect. In this performance he occasionally sounds like multiple guitarists.
When asked in an interview, Alex said Natural Science was a favorite Rush song to play but was also extremely demanding and difficult to play consistently.
Alex is so brilliant.
Because he's a guitar god.
Why do people keep saying this? Hes in a hugely successful rock band where there’s no other guitarist so obviously hes an important part. Many famous guitarists have praised him many times. Hes in a shit ton of guitar magazines and websites. He has guitar and amp sponsores. Idk where this idea that he’s underrated comes from.
Someone i would say is legit underrated is omar rodriguez lopes from mars volta, who alex and neil were a fan of. He rarely gets talked about. Absolutely incredible guitarist.
This is a perfect Rush song. Alex's guitar is at a frenetic pace, the drums are insane, you got time signature changes, and Geddy's voice and bass holding it all together. With most of your biggest pop bands, it's not that they WON'T do this......they CAN'T do this....not on their best day.
Rush never needed "auto-tune" as Geddy was always spot on....
Ya and this is live! Wow just Fukien wow! Love this band
this why it's in my top 3 favorite Rush songs of all time..... Camera Eye, Natural Science, The Weapon
God rush fans are insufferable
The song is imperfect and incomplete. If you think this is great you are a poser. His best solo ever is cut. Too fast I guess
"The most endangered species, the honest man," indeeed. rest in peace Neil ....
Indeed,look at what's going on now..the truth is a horrible hateful thing,according to those who presume to do our thinking for us(MSM)..as people who speak the truth are also horrible hateful people,to be demonised and thrown out of their jobs and homes...We are now in a war,my friend.
The three of them, THE THREE OF THEM, were so synced in this song.
Absolutely perfect. Just sublime.
I love them so much 💞
They are so synced in all there songs.
@@rsdeharp2112 where? (seewhatididthere?) LoL
This is the ultimate Rush song. Lyrics, Guitar, Bass, and Vocals. This is also possibly the best live performance of this song I have seen and I've seen them 14 times. Perhaps its because they are in their homeland. I LOVE THESE GUYS!! I'm 55, and they were the soundtrack of my life. Lets get it together ppl and LOVE one another. They surely loved us!!
you're right! this may be the best Natural Science ever!!! from beginning to end its perfect. love the up tempo.... Alex just kills on this song!
@@LesPaul3399 Agreed! The Snakes & Arrows live version was TOO slow.
Not just "possibly"
59 , couldn't agree more
The most endangered species the honest man!!! Blew the speakers in my 83 vw rabbit
A f*cking masterpiece by one of the greatest bands ever!
Correction, the greatest of great ❤️
natural science and the camera eye are two songs the fans wanted for so long and then Rush came through with killer live versions.
You think this is killer? The song has been edited and is imperfect and incomplete. You don’t know it well obviously
This is a great track and Permanent Waves was an excellent album.
Suddenly you were gone..all the lives you left your mark upon...I remember.
Eehjkm Bruns After Image!! Outstanding brother great words!! 😢
Yes, dude. Exactly the tribute.
It's obvious Rush is the best rock and roll band ever
I love how Neil plays the entire first section in traditional grip, seemingly just becuase he can. Rest in peace, one of the greatest to ever pick up a pair of sticks
90's = Neil at his peak. He had perfected his art while still being young or healthy enough to put a ridiculous amount of power behind his drumming. It baffles me how a kit could survive an entire tour with Peart or Bonham behind it. Two of the hardest hitters in drumming.
I’ve seen a video where he put the bass pedal through the drum skin. That should be impossible. They are designed very carefully and I can assure you that an incredible amount of years and research went into drums we know today. I met the man credited for developing them at my daughter’s music school in Boston. It is the oldest music school in America. How I would have loved to see the look on that man’s face the moment Neil’s pedal went through that bass drum.
I'm so happy we have so many great recordings of shows like this. RIP Neil
Agreed. It was the right time and place for this band to exist.
ME TOO!!!
I had the pleasure of seeing this in person once. When I had listened to the album, I assumed this was a studio piece meaning they don't perform live. At the beginning of the song I thought, Oh can't believe they are attempting this! Boy was I wrong. They flew through the song as if they could be holding a phone conversation while playing their parts. They were that good and prepared. It. Was. Awesome!!
Sweet!!!
You are a lucky guy!
You are so lucky!
They didn't attempt it. They did it.
I saw this at the Spirit of Airwaves recording, the bootleg concert recording front row February 13th in St. Louis. Sat 15 away from Geddy and it was SO epic. The set list was their best ever and all 3 were as good as they could ever be. Those 4 front row tickets cost me 35 dollars with a 50 cent handling charge per ticket. I got those tickets by being the first caller to reach Dial-Tix when lines opened at 10am. This would not have happened if not for my mom letting me skip school to do so. By far my best concert ever
I'm so proud of them, in what they have achieved throughout their careers. There will never be another band that can compare...
Neil with carpal tunnel right arm, Geddy with a perfect tone, and Alex with leather pants. Priceless!
I was at this very show with my girlfriend (now wife) - it was her first exposure to Rush (my first time live). Was totally blown away at the sound these 3 guys made! This was a show beyond anything we had seen prior, and serves as near tops of anything since! Seeing 2112 in entirety that night was something special, so was this song...The entire setlist, mixed with the atmosphere of the night (warm summer breeze coming off of Lake Ontario, the laser lights as the sun went down, the clouds of pot smoke, and these hometown boys) made for an experience like no other!!
Lucky you! The more I see of this show, the more I hope that someday they'll release a DVD of the entire show. Although it's hard to be definitive on a band who were such unrelenting perfectionists, I don't think they ever looked or sounded better. Not sure why it is coming out in bits and pieces. I believe the first half hour or so was a bonus on the R40 boxset, and then a couple more songs were on the bonus bonus R40 disc. Don't get me started on the R40 box, which I never bought, because it was asking a lot of those of us who already owned the other DVD's, to buy them again for the sake of a single bonus disc. And then I can only imagine the feelings of those fans who forked out for the R40, only to find out that there was a bonus bonus disc, which they didn't get unless they ordered it from the Backstage club. But then, I might get started......... oops too late.
It's so amazing to read how well you've described your night at the show. Brilliant!
I was there at the OP marina with my pals that night- it was awesome. We tied up his boat along the boardwalk wall could hear it perfectly.
This performance was just flat out on point. Speed, accuracy, energy, amazing.
Ryan Haydock a wee too laid back compared to the Permanent Waves/MP era though! I've heard the legendary St Louis 80 Superstars of Rock show/bootleg and back then Natural Science had an F'ing mind of its own😯😯😯 they could barely control & contain the damn thing💗😎💗
I could only imagine, I've never seen rush live, and tbh if I had to choose just one song to see live, this would be it.
They were 17 years older at this point, so cut them a little slack.
@@johnIZaUWL that's when I was front row in front of Geddy, the first third night. I was one of the first 25 people to get tickets to the Dec 13th show I believe it was but they sold out so quick they booked another then another, just so happened Kiel was available for 3 nights and they sold em all out. Geddy was yelling at us in the front rows, you guys are the originals, you'll get our best. Talk about full filling a promise or statement. That and Aftk weremy best concerts ever. Every song a monster
@@johnIZaUWL True, have recordings of that time, Neil was just literally trying to play as fast as he could 👍
Life and Death is a mystery. Just over a month after this concert Neil’s daughter will be killed in a car accident and his wife would be gone within a year. And now he is gone. Thanks for all the great stories that inspired the music Neil. RIP
"wheels within wheels... a spiral array...
a pattern so grand and complex..."
p.s. was the first tour they performed it live?? If I Recall Correctly ... they didn't used to perform it live just after "Permanent Waves" 'cuz it was a bit too complicated...
I was thinking the same thing, but then realized I think it was early August of '97.
@@Oneironaut9 Ya, you're right. I edited my comment... was just over a month after this. Still, surreal and sad!
@@SpotWorksLNC Indeed. He was a brilliant man, however tragedy no doubt made him a much deeper (wiser/compassionate) man because of it. Those two don't often go together.
@@nyokoSalome Complicated never stopped them before.
Man Alex plays arpeggios like no one else.
This must be the ultimate prog metal song. Not sure Rush have ever bettered this, but then who has? The stunning power of it, the contrasts, the seamless shifting between weird time signatures, and of course the portentous, rather alienated lyric, all add up to something greater than the sum of its parts.
These structures were ahead of the time. 1980.
Chuck Lang they were at thier best well after this song was written as well
This is the song that got me playing the guitar, 30 years ago.
These guys are going places...😎👍
Great summary. Don't think I've watched them play this one before. Cool to see.
Simply amazing, I’m so glad I discovered this amazing group of guys.
The fact that 3 people can get this amount of sound is incredible. I don’t think I’ll ever discover a band that top this.
No you won't
Not a day of my life goes bye that I don't listen to these guy's. They are just so tight with everything they play. RUSH is life.
All of my passwords are Rush lyrics. Shit, should I have said that online? Hahahaha
Chris, I also must have my "daily" RUSH !!! I saw 22 live shows over the years, starting with the Vapor Trails tour and would have preffered 122. I discovered Rush a bit late though... :-(
No doubt, have to have my daily dose. The greatest and most perfect band. There is Rush, and then somewhere down below everybody else.
Move in next door to me! ;-)
I'm the same way. Gotta have my daily dose of RUSH. Since Neil's passing, I've been through their catalog multiple times. IMO, they're the best band ever! All 3 guys, amazing musicians!
RIP Neil....
Art as expression
Not as market campaigns
Will still capture our
Imaginations
Did Geddy skip this verse? I don't think it's there!
I don’t know when exactly they excised the verse (and added extra “wheels within wheels”) but this arrangement was standard for years before and evermore after.
Given the same, state of integrity, it will surely serve us well!
@@paulsikes3515 This tour (TFE) was the first time they changed the arrangement, it was the first tour Natural Science was played since 1981. I don’t mind it but part of me really misses the “art as expression” verse with the guitar solo.
This is one of my favorite Rush songs. I remember hearing that Rush was going to play a song on the T4E tour that they had never played live. When my friend and I were on our way to the show, I told him if they played Natural Science it would make my life! When the song started, I almost didn't even recognize it because it shocked me to hear it live. What a great night that was and what a great show.
drummer3125 well they have played natural science live. Permanent waves and moving pictures tour.
Had the same feeling when they played Losing It
drummer3125 I think Ged said this R40 also... hmm...
They also played it on Snakes & Arrows tour in 2007/2008. (Was) Always pumped to see it live. Awesome to see it and Jacob's Ladder on R40. It was definitely a high point of my life.
@@plannermann Oh right. That was the song they'd never played live. It was a great moment, but I think the song is weakened by sentiment.
All you need to do is listen to RUSH often, Loud, and with a friend.
Share Rush with everyone when possible.
Rest In Peace Professor.
Stay strong Alex, Geddy.
Love ya all.
Peace
Right on!!!🦄
This song, live and original, gives me chills every time I hear the opening verse with the full band. "Wheels within Wheels in a spiral array, a pattern so grand and complex. Time after time, we lose sight of our way, our causes can't see their effects..."
Its "wheels within wheels", just to let you know.
RSmith2112 Oh, okay. Thanks
RSmith2112 I always hear "river & wheels". All three interpretations make sense, & to me, that makes a good lyric.
chris schiefen Wheels within wheels
I always hear chips and cheese and a spiral souffle.
Alex Lifeson ONLY SEEMS to be Under rated, BECAUSE HE IS PLAYING ALONG SIDE THE WORLDS BEST DRUMMER AND PROBABLY THE BEST ROCK BASSIST EVER !!! PS He is pretty good despite very bad arthritis problems in hands !!!!! Give it up for the best all around ROCK GUITARIST of all time !!!
Neil Peart Plus
YEAH , indeed , peace mate
good photography , *xs 10 +
Eddie Van Halen said when asked "What does it feel like to be the top Guitarist?" He replied, " I do not know, ask Alex Liefeson!!!" True story as reported by Rolling Stone Mag
FUCK YES!
MY GUITAR HERO, and the reason i can play ANYTHING at all today....
Along with Elliot Easton and a pile of other killer players ... criminally underrated.
pretty good??
If you are a RUSH enthusiast, this is a GREAT song!
If you are less than a real music lover, you have NO idea why WE love them SO!
If time travel becomes possible, first thing I'll do is go to every Rush show ever (five for the second time). Love you guys!
Perhaps their greatest live performance. Certainly my favorite. No one comes close and never will. Thank you Rush for all the great songs. They have meant so much to so many.
First time I ever heard Rush was around 1977/8 the album "A Farewell to Kings" and Closer to the Heart was a 12 inch single released here in the UK(still have it), anyway I am now 62 yrs old and that was me totally hooked 43 years ago. Just pure unbelievable musicianship from these 3 Canadians. The Professor Neil Peart will be very sorely missed by the great family of Rush fans but we will never forget what this man meant to us all. Thank you for the incredible lyrics Sir.
Another killer song by the worlds best band ever!
The most epic band, playing their most epic song. A band like Rush only comes along once in a Millennium...... Thank You Universe for aligning all the stars at the perfect time for these 3 Masters to meet
Absolutely insane to play this song at this tempo!
I miss Neil so much like everyone. I’m thankful I was alive during the time of Rush✌🏻❤️. Much love to all fans.✌🏻❤️
40 days before Neil's life was turned upside down. Sad he's gone now. I cherish every concert of theirs I've been to, and wish there would have been more. Best group of guys, best musicians and artists in rock and roll.
I have seen Rush live in concert 11 times over the years, best 3 man band to walk the face of the earth!!!!!
Lifeson’s intro ,he has such an ear for dynamics.
This song is so awesome.
Gotta love Geddy's mastery of finger-style bass playing!
Silence! The gods are playing.
SPEAK IT MAN!!!
Preach, bruther! I came to this song a bit late, I'm not shy to admit. Full appreciation did not bloom until I heard it live. I believe that must have been Snakes & Arrows leg 2 in 2008.
Still have chills.
The Holy Trinity
They are Immortal for a limited time ; gods ,,, no ; but MASTERS of music!
All I can say is , "THANK YOU, Alex, Geddy, Neil for ALL the music and memories!! Was lucky enough to see them with friends and then my kids at least 5 times and was stoked to know this song was included in one of those concerts!! What a CLASS act!!
Happiness in your quieter days ahead and thank you guys again!!!
I always thought of this as a quiet song. I don't know why. These guys absolutely rock like no other band ever
Love this Song so amazing and was recorded at LE STUDIO Morin-Heights
they were at their live peak on the T4E tour. they didn't mess a single moment of any song up the whole time.
Probably the most musically and lyrically accomplished song in the arsenal
Amazing, thank Rush for all you've done!
This band no matter what stage of life has always been my favorite.
Took my wife to this show. It was her first “live” RUSH. Blew her away!
Molson Amphitheater in Toronto, same place I took her to for Supertramp and Floyd.
I sat next to Lerxst's family - the kid next to me had a college recommendation from Alex's father he said - was amazing - his Mom and Dad were like 4 seats from me - lol
Bat Man No doubt. Probably go to lots of “local” shows. He is from Richmond Hill I was told.
it's hard to watch this, knowing what Neil had just a few weeks ahead of him.
I'm heartbroken watching this.😟
Sorry but you are wrong...Neils daughter was killed on my frikn birthday of all days..6-20...so Neil was dealing with that tragic loss for a week and a half..unfortunately
gdub454 I don't think so. they were done with the tour. what does it matter anyway. still a nightmare
Ronald Tartaglia
Ya know what?..I think I made a mistake..think it was Neils wife that passed on 6-20 I forget the year..
Ronald Tartaglia what you on about?
Ronald Tartaglia really?
In over 50 concerts I've seen, my very favorite moment of them all was this song, 1981, the fog machine was full blast with the magenta and green colored lights, and Alex Lifeson playing the 2nd guitar solo with his head cocked slightly to one side surrounded by the curling fog all lit up by spotlights, in his red dinner jacket, playing his blonde ES-345. That does it for me.
I saw this live on the Permanent Waves tour. It still gives me chills.
You see the drummer? That’s the man right there. That’s the man. Neil Peart, Rest In Peace buddy. Relax man. 🤘🏼🤘🏼🤜🏼🤜🏼 incredible drummer he was
This song is PERFECT
Each time I listen to this song I feel like in a trance state of mind, I imagine I will live again in a far future time and space.
Hopefully in some form or fashion in 2112 with these guys
@@samdorsey2112 Lol, absolutely :)
There is nothing better than working on a crew and knowing that everyone will do outstanding work.
Geddy playing that Godly super busy bassline and also singing…as everyone knows, what incredible gifts he’s harnessed. Long live RUSH
Bassline.
@@HardPen-jj5nl lol. Thank you. Auto correct
The music, the lyrics, the meaning, the whole damn package! This song will forever be BADASS!!
One of the best songs of all time. One of the best bands of all time. RIP Neil.
Seeing Rush live brings it all together.
Gosh they had so much fun playing together up on that stage!
nEIL pEART the greatest drummer, lyricist, and creative artist in our times. Ya know I can really sympathize with Neil when he told the band he just didn't have the energy to do it anymore because he was battling cancer and being a drummer takes alot more physical energy than the rest of the band needed on an almost daily basis. RIP PROFFESSOR
This was my gateway song, and I never turned back
This song is from Rush's very best album.
Every song is good.
Its such a perfect combination of strong guitar riffs, excellent songs, perfectly produced.
Its that perfect combination of early Rush meets "pop" Rush.
Picking a best album from Rush is like picking a favorite food...:)...Permanent Waves is brilliant, true... but, Caress of Steel, 2112, Hemispheres, Farewell to kings ( my favorite), Moving Pictures or Signals are no less great...:)
Foxtrot 5 you've heard of 2112 almost assuredly
A buddy of mine bribed the DJ at my wedding to ensure Entre Nous was the very first song played. I could not have been happier.
My favorite Rush album is 2112FarewellToKingsHemispheresPermanentWavesMovingPicturesSignalsGraceUnderPressureCounterpartsSnakesAndArrowsClockworkAngels.
My 2nd favorite Rush album is RushFlyByNightCaressOfSteelPowerWindowsHoldYourFirePrestoRollTheBonesTestForEchoVaporTrails
This song has 'origins of prog metal' written all over it. It's so cool! On a bit of a nostalgia trip at the moment. Miss seeing Alex with a PRS.
Talk about a "pattern so grand and complex." Try laying that bass line down and singing at the same time.
Singing in high octave like geddy did make it even hard 😅
I've been learning this bass line and it's all I can do. He is so naturally talented and he also works so hard at his craft. What an inspiration.
plays bass with his hands, sings all the songs, plays synth pedals with his feet, and moves the mic stand with his nose
One of THE greatest bass players in rock history...Gary Lee Winerib.
@Shallex Whatever.
Close enough.
TOP of their game right here. R.I.P. Professor, you will be sorely,sorely, missed.😥
I was at this show; an unbelievable night watching and hearing Rush live like this is one of the greatest concert experiences of my life! Long live Rush
Neil had a summer home not too far from Le Studio in the Larentian mountains in southern Quebec. He named a small rock island (1 of four that were on the lake) he had bought in the after years as a memento for his love of that mystical place he so loved. He named it "science island". He took his second daughter Olivia to that island to teach her about nature and natural science. RIP Neil you were an educator and professor to world.
Neil, Alex,Getty...
Gentlemen ...
Your music will stand for all time!
1997 was a magical year in which Steven Wilson and Geddy Lee had the same look
No definition of tighter is available. These three are at the top of perfection.
Definitely, one of my all time favorite songs. Then again, all their songs are ALL magnificent.
Can I give that 100 thumbs up?! I had the pleasure of seeing them play this song when they came to Nashville on this tour which was sometime in the Summer of 1997. Of course this was also the tour where they played the whole first side of 2112! Not just the overture and the Temples of Syrinx but the whole enchilada!! Thank you Rush!!!
Saw them 3 times in the Northeast on this tour. Nailed this song each show. If that doesn't scream the extent of their talent, you either don't know what it takes to play it or you are deaf.
Rest in Peace, Neil Peart. Greatest drummer to ever play, in the greatest band of all time. Also, the greatest (most intelligent, thought-provoking) songwriter in the world. For anyone who doesn’t know, he wrote almost all of Rush’s lyrics. He was the heart of the band. May he rest easily, hopefully with his wife and daughter. I love you, Neil Peart!
This song makes me feel good today.
Three great musicians. I am glad I got to see them a few times.
1000 % Agreed.....
Me too!!!!
RIP Neil Peart🙏
RUSH = LEGENDS OF PROGRESSIVE ROCK!!!!
ill never understand, how Geddy remembers all those obscure lyrics, i love this song,,
It's tough seeing Neil playing with his arm strapped up. A sign of much worse things to come. It didn't affect his playing here, though, because he refused to let it, but man, he must have been in agony after a full gig.
Much love and respect, boys. ♥♥(♥).
Rest easy Neil. Lifelong hero to myself, my dad, countless others. Absolutely devastated, can't imagine keeping brain cancer a secret battle for years but that just shows how private and humble he was. His music and words are immortal, thank you for everything.
✊
Feel privileged to have seen them 5 times
17 years after they recorded the song, played it back with the freshness of the original and then some. Smokin!
I was at this concert .. great to see this song performed live
Music like this just can't be done anymore. It has faded from our world like major or an ancient art. 2112 was more more prophetic than we expected.
Epic. Best live version of this song i've heard.
I used to air drum this in high school. I was amazing! Lol
High school, I'm 48 and it's still everyday, lol
Several years ago I saw Rush in concert, and they played Natural Science. I was absolutely stunned! Never had I ever witnessed such musicianship! They hit every note, every beat with such accuracy and authority, and at the end I had tears running down my face! I'm sure I wasn't the only one either! I had just witnessed the greatest band ever!
i had the exact same experience at the R30 tour with Xanadu.... in 25 yrs of shows id NEVEr heard them play Xanadu live
Mind fucking BLOWN. it was just so goddamn perfect I cried like a little girl lol.
I feel real pain when i think of how i missed the R40 tour.......;-(
That was a great concert. It was the 3rd (and last) time that I saw these fine lads in Toronto. However, I am grateful for having saw the R40 show in Chicago.
So privileged to have seen Rush live on the Time Machine Tour. Such gifted musicians and writers and so much humour. They looked so relaxed on stage blissfully unaware of the starstruck teenager grin on my 43 year old face.
Saw them play this live on the TFE tour and was like a little kid. They also played the full 2112 epoch including ’Dream’ for the first time live on this tour. The tempo on this performance is smokin’! 🫡🥇✊
One of the best Rush songs. Great live version.
Neil still had the goatee and was not old yet! Still he IS the master even NOW!
Nice warm summer night down by the lake, cool breeze and some Rush. Great times was a great concert.
Biggest blessing I ever had was my 40th at Red Rocks. Such an amazing trio of humans, RIP Neil.