Video není dostupné.
Omlouváme se.
Is Monsanto’s Roundup Pesticide Glyphosate Safe?
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 11. 2014
- Higher levels of pesticides on GMO soy is a concern since Monsanto’s Roundup has been shown to be to have adverse effects on human placental tissue.
New subscribers to our e-newsletter always receive a free gift. Get yours here: nutritionfacts...
What is glyphosate? Please see the “prequel” to this video, Are GMOs Safe? The Case of Roundup Ready Soy (nutritionfacts..... Before that I covered GMO corn: Are GMOs Safe? The Case of Bt Corn (nutritionfacts.....
It’s the dose that makes the poison, though. Do we have evidence that the levels of Roundup chemicals not only found on crops but also in our bodies after eating those crops actually have adverse effects? That’s the subject of the final installment of this video series, GMO Soy and Breast Cancer. (nutritionfacts....)
Commercial interests can have a corrupting effect on the science of nutrition and hold sway over institutions that are supposed to operate in the public interest. See for example:
• Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Conflicts of Interest (nutritionfacts....)
• Seeing Red No. 3: Coloring to Dye For (nutritionfacts....)
• The McGovern Report (nutritionfacts....)
• Dietary Guidelines: Advisory Committee Conflicts of Interest (nutritionfacts....)
• Food Industry “Funding Effect” (nutritionfacts....)
Have a question for Dr. Greger about this video? Leave it in the comment section at nutritionfacts.... and he'll try to answer it!
Image Credit: Eric Constantineau via Flickr.
NutritionFacts...
• Subscribe: nutritionfacts...
• Donate: nutritionfacts...
• Podcast : nutritionfacts...
• Facebook: NutritionFacts.org
• Twitter: nutrition_facts
• Instagram: nutrition_facts_org
• Books: nutritionfacts...
• Shop: drgreger.org
Did you watch this weeks’ most popular video on how Monsanto’s Roundup pesticide was found to be among the most toxic?
Watch below or click the link to watch on NutritionFacts.org: nutritionfacts.org/video/is-monsantos-roundup-pesticide-glyphosate-safe
Mark Seydel yep
The moment you quoted Seralini you lost all credibility.
You're also cherry picking studies. That's just bad science.
No
Great informative video as usual. Might want to change the title as Roundup is a herbicide used to kill weeds that would otherwise compete with the crop, as opposed to a pesticide used to control insect attack :-)
Would like to know how to stop them. The knowledge in itself is mostly depressing, knowing they don't have to label any of it. Love your vids. Thanks.
Bless you for making behavior due to economic interests sound factual as opposed to imagined. Thanks for the warning.
Thank you for the honest information.
Thanks Dr Greger, for your thorough investigating reporting on this. It's good to see all of these research papers side by side, and what they are actually revealing. Love your work!
Want your toxicity study results to be vague with regard to effects on humans? Use rats! Good ol' rats, yes, they throw the results off just far enough as to render any extrapolation to effects on humans ambiguous. Thanks for posting this, Doc.
Thanks sooo much!
After watching a video about trends in gluten intolerance from @PlantChompers my family replaced conventionally grown grains and beans with organic. After just days, years of digestive illness were completely gone or hardly noticeable. I hope you do a follow up on this for those with IBS and other chronic conditions.
VERY enlightening.... Now ... What do we do with this information?
Now you research more! You will find that glyphosate is harmful. It's even been proven by one of their own research! All pesticides are harmful and the combinations we dont even know what are the effect on humans. Buy organic non GMO real food. Not the trash sold by this company with military history.
buy and eat organic!
Well fuck. My dad is exposed to a lot of shit as a farmer. Between this, diesel exhaust, and who know what, I'm concerned. His side of the family has a serious history of cancer too. There is so much that makes me think oh shit about his health. I mean, I grew up on the same farm, but I wasn't the one using this.
Best video since it actually shows "round up" as more than one ingredient. Since "round up" is more than just glyphosate. Glyphosate alone is hard to prove harm and easier to defend for Monsanto. It is the combination in "round up" that causes harm.
The chemical is : Gly - PHO - sate (it is not gly - phos - phate)
Otherwise, thank you for the informative video.
You are an intelligent idiot.
Kind of a catch 22. Monsanto (1\3 of Evil, Inc. w Halliburton & BP) because if they DID do human research, who would be dumb enough to take part if they know anything about Monsanto (who that is, still breathing?)? I'm trying to thing but I'm drawing a blank about what it is and when it was that Monsanto ever produced ANYTHING that wasn't at least controversial or at worst harmful to anything that breathes
this is so complicated :
Without proper labeling I am worried that I am consuming roundup pesticide. Please get your senator to mandate GMO labeling of food products.
+Thomas Coy Don't live your life in false fear. You're allowing false information to make you paranoid.
M C Anderson False information or false advertising?
I taste poison when i ingest most american wheat products and thusly have cut it out of my diet. If you do the same it will take months for your taste buds to no longer be used to the pestacide taste and you will be able to recognize it. No matter what the chemical is, whether it be RoundUp, or something involved in the GMO crops, you will feel healthier off of american wheat within 4 weeks maximum. I have had 40 friends cut wheat out of their diet (most eventually went back, weak willed) and 39 of them felt varying degrees more healthy than when they were eating wheat. This is no easy task though, wheat is snuck into everything. It's called modified food starch, modified wheat starch, and it can even be in "natural flavorings".
They spray round up on wheat crops to kill/dry them out for easier harvesting, since they upped the 'acceptable amounts' of round up in the diet.
They spray round up from planes onto crops. They increase their use of it because weeds have become resistant. Monsanto is evil and they have a huge control over our government.
Corn, soy, and wheat is in damn near every processed food product.
@@ryanglenn7878 Absolute nonsense. No way anyone can taste one part per billion.
Surely washing fruits and vegetables thouroughly before eating prevents most of what you've said.
So if its fine if all the animals die.. just not humans..? Oh jesus..
Watch the end of the video.
There is no case for any poisons to be sprayed anyway. It kills the soil.
If we allow the soil food web to reestablish then the yeilds will increase.
What he is referring to is POEA (polyethoxylated tallow amine) there are 2 studies involving POEA and human cells. The first one found that it is safe, and the second one (the one he mentions) found that it had acute toxicity in very high doses. Those doses are NOT found on GMO foods.
Isaac Gordon u got the studies?
Isaac Gordon Yeah OK!? Then you eat the garbage! We’ll stick to organic!
what resources are there out there for consumers to discover what brands of food are GMO/Non GMO?
depending on your country and legislations. monsanto lobby is pushing to make ppl not know what they eat of course.
Brilliant!
In my country (Chile) buying organic and non-GMO foods are still a luxury and expensive and even hard to find.
Thanx! I'm gonna look into it! :)
Grow your own food!
Thank you Dr. G
Gregor well knows that he speaks bullshit.
The plantbased diet is extremely high in glyphosate.
Horseshit.
Not if you avoid conventionnal wheat.
This is really depressing and shocking info to me. again feeling betrayed by the food industry. what can we do? If i refuse to eat GMO foods i may well starve to death....i cant be asking every restaurant, every family hosted event "is this non gmo?" how do we pressure the grocery chains to ban this food?
mickeyaaaa "i cant be asking every restaurant, every family hosted event "is this non gmo?"" Ok then keep eating horrible poison.
You MUST ask every restaurant and every family hosted event, or you will never know and they will never know.
You MUST read and research the ingredients list before putting something into your body.
You are trying to abdicate responsibility to someone else, this won't work and you'll keep getting poisoned.
informationwarfare
Nope, not gonna be THAT guy....despised by anyone preparing food who has to put up with such questions...those are the people who get a nice wad of spit in their food. I just wont eat out whenever possible - boycott restaurants until they get the message. I don't mind checking labels at the grocery store (if we have labelling laws here in Canada i don't know yet....) to avoid gmo foods.
Nia LaLa "but you don't want to be THAT guy you want to be cancer guy." That's right isn't it! Seriously mickeyaaaa make the right choice, we need brave pioneers in this toxic world who are willing to be the first to stand up and tell the truth.
Do you want to die knowing there are things you wanted to say or do, but did not out of fear of what others think?
informationwarfare
I speak with my wallet - just avoid all restaurants.
Rick Couture
I don't eat out at all except there is one organic cafe near me that has some good stuff.
Roundup is a herbicide not a pesticide.
Just saying.
Ok Dr. but what shouldn't i eat to stay free from this kind of pesticides? Wich vegetables are sprayed with Roundup?
+Octavision Vigo Just because there's a picture of a guy with a stethoscope, it doesn't necessarily mean he's a doctor.
+M C Anderson Sure, but that's what any human would think, it is called semiotics, beside he is a real doctor, check it out, he's name is Michael Greger
+M C Anderson He has a team of scientist reading though every single paper published in nutritional science. He reads trough every single magazine in nutrition that released in english. His book " how not to die" has 150 pages of references to studies. The book is only 400 pages long. His organization is also non-profit. He knows what he is talking about.
Anybody can read published papers, magazines, and anybody can publish a book. It doesn't prove anything.
KungfuHeathen research proves itself
why would miners send canaries in a mine before allowing a human to enter??? Think about that.
Great video
Cutting through the jargon, YES, roundup is not safe for human consumption, and Monsanto's interests are only profit based.
Note, Roundup is NOT a pesticide; it is an herbicide.
Roundup and all herbicides are pesticides. "Pesticide" is the word for all materials which control or mitigate any pest, whether it be a weed, insect, fungus, bacteria, rodent, bird, whatever. Believe it or not, those sanitizer-soaked towelettes that come in a convenient pop-up container are listed as a pesticide.
Virtually all materials have certain levels of consumption at which they are dangerous, or at which there is no observable adverse effect, called the NOAEL. If you wish to discuss toxicology, you should learn some of the basic concepts, including the first one: "The dose makes the poison." Glyphosate levels in food are several orders of magnitude lower than anything toxicologists have found to be harmful.
Your assertion is inherently flawed. While Roundup may act upon insect in a destructive manner, it does in fact have more damaging aspects to it as an herbicide on plants. It was made as an herbicide and the maker's claims are that of an herbicide.
Perhaps you should learn to read toxicology reports on the adverse health effect and the implications of modern diseases in almost all animals life from Roundup herbicide, and pesticides.
1. sustainablepulse.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/Glyphosate_II_Samsel-Seneff.pdf
2. www.enveurope.com/content/pdf/2190-4715-24-24.pdf
3. www.glifocidio.org/docs/impactos%20ambientales/ia18.pdf
I have many other studies that are contrary to your absurd assertion that Roundup is not harmful.
Steven Peters, if you can show me an independent study that shows some kind of evidence of harm, I will happily concede. However, the links you have posted do not meet that criterion. The Samsel/Seneff study was debunked long ago, as was the Benbrook. The third link is not even a study; it's more a compilation of all the various pseudoscience surrounding the topic.
If evidence from known anti-GMO/Roundup people is good enough for you, that's fine. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. But someone will need to find some solid evidence before I can abandon this point of view.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10854122
Reinhold Fuhrmann The EPA, Washington State Dept. of Health, and from numerous accredited reseachers is pseudoscience?
Clearly you haven't read any of the peer review journals' papers that I cited; had you, your opinion on the subject would be much different than what it is currently.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24434723
Steven Peters, you said, "Clearly you haven't read any of the peer review journals' papers..." Not true. I have read them, just with a critical eye for pseudoscience. For example, the study in your most recent link shows that the glyphosate formulations cause harm to human cells ***in a petri dish***. I can do the same thing with ordinary table salt. Is table salt bad for you? In excessive amounts, of course it is. Again, the dose makes the poison.
If the study was so good, why was it published in a journal with such a low impact factor? These are just a few of the things I evaluate when reading studies. It's also the reason that there is broad scientific consensus about the relative safety of this product.
It's unlikely you can find anything that will change my mind, just as it's unlikely I can find anything to change yours. We simply have different standards for the evidence to support each position.
Who would have thought that?
What?
That they lie to you.
😯
I'm generally a massive fan of Michael Greger, but as a left wing environmentalist I refuse to vote "Green" because of their ignorant approach to this topic. At the end of the day it's all about "Agent Orange". I suggest people genuinely interested in learning about this topic check out Myles Power's videos.
Right on.
"compared to" or "compared with"?
Gregor knows that in vitro cell line studies mean nothing with respect to humans.
Glyphosate is safe.
Bel video!
Is it just me or does monsanto seem kind of shady?
Is this sarcasm? Hope so!
no there is no danger in ba sing se
Hope this video stays alive...
I hope it's updated in the light of continuing research showing glyphosate is not harmful to consume.
Seralni studies cant but relied. Most likely GE food dosen't effect us, but the inert ingredients in RoundUp seems to not be good for aquatic animals.
I'm from GE, just skeptical of any possible HTCs
Burn Monsanto...
futurevideo10
Monsatan
RSchronicle
They can grow using permaculture techniques which use the laws of nature to our advantage without needless genetic modification. "Vitamin A", aka beta-carotene is incredibly easy to obtain from vegetables, golden rice is unnecessary.
Your guilt trip failed.
RSchronicle
"If it was so easy than why is it responsible for saving so many lives"
Because of lack of education, beta-carotene is very easy to get.
"explain to me exactly how you can use the laws of nature to grow crops in a drought?"
Permaculture. CZcams search "greening the desert permares" there is a 5:22 long video, gives a brief overview, then go into more to see more info.
Anti-GMO organizations should profit, I don't care if they profit they are not pushing poison.
Animals are experimented on all the time, and you want to make the case that GMOs should not be tested on animals because that would be cruel? Yet we should feed it to people? Insane.
"is not an answer to how something you consider a poison saved the lives of thousands of children."
Yes it is, it really is. Beta carotene is so easy to obtain, that golden rice is totally unnecessary, you and those pushing this GMO garbage are just trying to guilt everyone with the cliche "think of the children"
"it's easy there is nothing there that dictates how ensure that crops survive a 6 month drought."
I guess you didn't look hard enough, swales capture water and soak it into the landscape, these swales sustain food producing, water harvesting, soil building forests and landscapes.
""Animals are experimented on all the time" is the worst defense like how the hell does your brain work. GMO's don't need to be tested on animals at all but Anti-GMO campaigners keep paying and pushing for studies in which animals are given GMO foods in which guess what the animals don't die but the stress of being in an experiment isn't worth it because guess what, GMOs aren't toxic."
You fucking scum, stop trying to guilt people into not looking into or researching GMO! Fuck!
You actually have the audacity to say that testing GMOs is pseudoscience? You are crazy.
RSchronicle
RSchronicle
Golden rice is inefficient because most plant foods contain beta carotene.
Actually research permaculture and realize it is a far better system.
Just ditch soy. It's not worth putting into your body. You don't need tofu or those nasty frozen veggies burgers. There are so many better whole food options.
corn is just as bad btw. so go organic with that too
This study already proved GMO and glyphosate a.k.a. Roundup dangers;
*Republished study: long-term toxicity of a Roundup herbicide and a Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize* - Gilles-Eric Séralini
Round-Up is an _herbicide,_ not a pesticide!
Herbicides are a kind of pesticide you nitwit.
"pesticide" sounds scarier - personally I prefer "weedkiller"
Pesticide covers all crop pest chemicals. Raticides and fungicides and insecticides are particulars.
boom 💣