All Might FAILED Hero Society. Yes, Really | My Hero Academia Analysis
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 12. 2022
- All Might was the symbol of peace, anime Superman, the iconic hero from My Hero Academia. But there's a dark side to his influence. In this video I cover why All Might may not have been the immutably good influence some people make him out to be, and why some aspects of his reign as the number one hero might've actually been harmful.
- Zábava
It reminds me of a Batman and Superman story.
There's a kid being bullied and being beaten up, but Batman (Bruce) is just sitting there watching, waiting for the kid being bullied to finally fight back, to finally gain the courage to fight, to stand up for himself and fight for himself, something that almost happens but before the kid finally fight back Superman (Clark) arrives and scares away the bullies.
Superman asks Batman why he didn't do anything to stop the bullies, Batman then talks about how the bullied boy had finally gained courage and was about to finally change, to fight back, but Superman ruined everything by intervening in the fight, Batman then asks Superman what he is going to do the next day (tomorrow), because the next day the bullies will return and if he is not there they will beat the kid even more, they will hit even harder, and even if Superman is there tomorrow, and the day after? And the next day? And the next day?...
Superman has no answers for Batman.
At the end of the story the boy finally stands up to the bullies and beats them up, and Superman comments on how Batman taught the bullied boy how to fight, the story ends with Batman and Superman agreeing that both of their methods were wrong, and that the best it's a middle ground.
I think that's the perfect example for All Might, he just didn't think about the long term, and the day he wouldn't be there anymore.
I believe Allmight did what he had set out to do. To be a symbol, and inspire. If anything, I blame hero society from growing complacient. He, like Hawks, want to create a better world Hawks one that doesn't need them (if I remember correctly) and there is nothing wrong with this. My hero Academia has been a story mostly based on ideals, only now embracing realism (at least Deku's perspective). Could he have done more? Sure, but I wouldn't call him a failure, society wouldn't have collapsed had there been a strong structure capable of holding it after he fell. Endevor was terrible, but he was willing to catch up, why weren't other heroes? Can we blame Allmight for that? As a teacher, yes, he is bad, but as a hero, I believe each hero has a calling, and he did everything in his power to uphold what he believed in, and ultimately, his actions did inspire a new generation that looks up to him, Deku would not be the selfless, and altruistic person that wants to save everyone were it not for All Might, at least that is what I believe.
I could be wrong, this is just my opinion after all. I loved the video.
I agree with you. Sure, All Might's influence and power did lead to people to grow complacent. But to put the blame sorely on him is unfair. Everyone is ultimately responsible for their choices and actions. People growing lazy was on them, not on All Might. He didn't tell them to do any of that, they did that all on their own.
It's no surprise for me that All Might's attitude isn't perfect. Like you said, the peace was only when he was around. Then he lost powers and the society panicked. No one knew what to do. There were a lot of criminals who were no more scared of heroes and it was a disaster. The guy who causes this kind of situation when he's the only one who can do anything useful isn't very clever in his decisions. I think All Might didn't think much about some of his choices and their consequences and that is a huge problem considering how much people were admiring him and depending on him.
I really liked your video. Until now, I haven't been thinking about All Might's teaching skills but now I see he's a terrible teacher. I can't believe he let Deku hurt himself and was even encouraging him to do so
glad you liked the video! I definitely like All Might as a character but he's definitely super flawed. just the mark of a great, well-thought out figure in the MHA world!
@@monkfruitThere were quite a few great points in this video, but I think your approach on some things was far to unnuanced, and a few things flat out wrong
Most of this stems from a. You seeing All Might (AM) has highly egotistical and b. Him as the singular cause for society viewing him/heroes as the sole caretakers of responsability, when it's quite the opposite.
AM as we know him is incredibly aware of what the fall of his power would do. He constantly feels like hes done everything wrong. Which is why he disregards nighteye after his injury. Just quitting would have a similar effect as being forced to quit.
Great as he is, he alone couldn't create the society he is in. He was BORN into a world that expects heroes to be the end all be all pillars, and he was simply the best, and it became a self fulfilling prophecy.
He succeeds and is put on a pedestal so high no one thinks to help or emulate him--but THEY put him there, and then he feels obligated to perform.
Even in his immediate circle--David Shield goes batshit out of fear that AM will fade, Gran Torino only ever bludgeons him for mistakes, never gives him new thoughts or trains anyone else, Nezu only cares that OFA is passed on, he's the U A principal and never thinks to train up more all mights in spirit, Nighteye expects AM to be the perfect hero, and when AM starts to fade, he just tries to replace AM singularly, not make more.
Thus, the mindset AM lives in is reinforced to him by friends and society, society puts it back on AM as he succeeds, and round and round the circle we go. It takes more than AM alone to do this tango
AM is an imperfect person. That's a huge part of his story. But if you're going to go after him about Midorya hurting himself with OFA, you'd best have Aizawa, Nezu, whatever other UA staff handles 1A, Gran Torino and Inko right next to AM. All of them, AM especially tell Midorya to take it slow, and the little shit doesn't. The failing of ALL these adults is not enforcing proper punishment/restriction on Midorya when he doesn't stop, even up to expulsion/delay in becoming a Hero until he can control his power, but it is ALL of them mixed with Midoryas own stupidity and hero complex, not just AM.
The "should midorya have gotten ofa" has lots of sides and arguments, and i won't go into it here. No matter who got it, OFA was going to be a bone breaking blast in its 9th iteration, regardless
Also the manga does a better job in the s4-5 era showing AM training extensively with Midoriya, but it's the writers failing that he doesn't show them together more when it's supposed to be their story, so sone of it is real-world issues
Also not sure what the beef with him "believing" he can defeat AFO is--i don't know if he did"believe" it, but he did swear himself to trying, so of course you approach it with grit and determination
Overall you're doing what I see most people talking about all might do. In universe it's meant yo be a BAD thing that society blames All Might fir every single problem they face, when the show makes it clear that a lack of personal responsability, government corruption, turning blind eyes, discrimination, dark forces pulling strings, and sheer human nature all play their PART. All Might is just the easy scapegoat.
Yet, many in the real world likewise blame All Might alone, as it's an easy, neat little package answer as to why it all went downhill, when the ugly truth is EVERYONEs imperfections played a role, All Might too, but also you.
All mights human top he's not a failure he's just not perfect he's an example of peace and stride to get that peace. He isn't literal peace so I'm kinda cringing.
They literally told us this since episode 1..... He says those words to keep everyone happy and safe but he isn't literally at peace he's an example of it.. THAT'S THE POINT
@@monkfruitand it's not stupid. Anyone would wish such things in that universe. Stop acting like he's the only one that's there.
@@monkfruithe might carry but he's still human he has his limits so this summary is annoying
Honestly it's more of All Might overestimating his peers when really he's a really big optimists in humanity and people but as you can see by the time he arrived at that conclusion it was already too late, he becomes the new normal the status quo and the symbol of hope, not peace but hope because that's what is the meaning of his strength, the strength to hope for a better tomorrow
They are two things that i disagree in this video.
-The first one is all might choice to give the one for all to deku. He did the right thing, even if he was physically weak he had the quality of an hero.
-The second is about the "correct reaction". There is no such thing as "correct reaction", there only worst or best and scolding isn't the best in this situation because deku never knew he was going to break all his bone using the one for all for the first time.
The best would have been to try to understand and control it during the weekend (or something like this) and each time he broke his bone, recovery girl heal him.
(If she agreed of course but i think she just going to beat all might with her cane. First his knees, second his arms so he cannot escape.)
But i do agree that all might is fucking bad at teaching and deku is as idiot to make too much useless efforts.
Ps: also i don't remember all might wanting deku to be the next pillar of society.
The problem is that people are just idealizing All Might way too much. The public to an actually unhealthy extent. In season 2 it was established that true heroism is shown when going out of their way to do what they seem needs to be done. Heros are not superpowered cops,they save people. But in MHA it is forbidden to use your quirk to hurt other people (criminals) without guidance and that's just bullshit. The spin off manga vigilante is what this series actually should have been about. The hypocritical of heroism in MHA is teased on in season 2 but never really touched upon again.
yeah we are supposed to get a mini-deku arc after this war arc that covers vigilantism a little bit but it was pretty underwhelming in the manga :/
@@monkfruit it was after the paranormal liberation war that Horikoshi got tiered of his manga.
@@monkfruit it was after the paranormal liberation war that Horikoshi got tiered of his manga.
I disagree that licenses are bs.
Gentle tried to help unlicensed but ended up making the situation worse.
I do think good Samaritan laws and self defense laws should be in place, but you can't say in a society with 80 percent quirks... even if only a few are actually dangerous, shouldn't have laws and regulations.
@@metageek7878 The licenses ARE bs.
The word idol was lost on this show. An idol is someone you look up to and a person you see as a goal to try to reach. Idolising someone means feeling a sense of craving that makes you want to be like them. While all might (lol) might have been a hero he was definitely not an idol; endeavor became the idol of what a hero should be the moment a replacement for all might was needed. His past actions not excused he still strives to get better and change unlike all might who even in his effort to make some change still does it in his old fashioned way. All might was a good man but he made shitty decisions. If only he didn't try to take on everything on his shoulders and built a way to prepare the upcoming generation but that's not who he was and even he knows he's a crappy teacher xD
His existence allowed everyone around him to absolve their responsibilities to improve
I 100% agree with everything in this video but if the power was given to someone else then we wouldn't be having a show because the show isn't about him.. It's about deku rationalizing the whole premise is pointless xD
And honestly all might encouraging deku to break a few bones seemed a little exaggerated he was still worried but that should've been a clear foreshadowing at how dark this anime gets with every season
Another great one monkboss❤️
You should probably get some intro music honestly If it's possible like associate a specific sound with your channel
And if you're taking a request again
Maybe something about kirishima.
Thank yoou
Tbf idols have a very specific connotation in Japan and it's the heroes in themselves that represent it.
If Allmight did give the quirk to someone else other then Deku that user would of died due to the muti-quirks. It was luck or fate that Deku got it, so I wouldn't say he was a failure because he choose a quirkless Successor . If anything Allmight would of been more of a failure if he listened to Nighteye.
True, but at the same time All Might wouldn't have of known that. I'd assume what they mean by Deku being the worst choice is that in universe, with no knowledge of the other quirks manifesting they way they do in Deku, a quirkless nobody shouldn't have of been the pick. Let's say One for all wouldn't have of killed whoever All Might gave it to and he picked Togeta. Togeta knows from his quirk that effort equals power, so he would've trained with One for all until he he had at a good enough level to not break his body and use with permeation, that as well as working at a solid hero agency creates a powerful pillar, Nighteye probably would've taught him to be better than All Might too. It was dumb luck that All Might chose a quirkless person when One for all would've killed someone, but we're biased since we have access to that knowledge and have Deku as our main character. In universe All Might's decision could've easily been the wrong one given the knowledge he had at the time of choosing Deku. Sorry that this has been hella long but it should get my personal thought process and what I'd assume Asara's to be too :)
Then Allmight should have picked a better quirkless guy who actual put some effort in trying to be a hero instead of a kid who only put in a year worth of effort after meeting his idol
@@TheBlaze22b yh that always struck me as odd about deku, yh he had his book taking notes, but you'd think a guy that doesnt have a superpower but wants to be a hero anyways would be doing more to prepare to BE a quirkless hero and so would be pretty damn ripped before all might even showed up, like "okay i cant be superhuman but if i want to be a hero ill do everything i can to be PEAK regular human" its so weird despite KNOWINIG he cant rely on a super power to carry him deku made no effort to built up his stamina and psyical abillity before getting a superpower that required him to do so to use it
btw you understood wrong, the death to multi quirks was caused by a awakening in OFA after deku already got it, which meant it will quickly kill anyone who already has a quirk, meaning that deku might be the lost holder because quirkless people like him were already a rareity in his generation, good luck finding 1 when deku is ready to pass it on at like age 40, thats the reason, mirio could have gotten it and would have been fine because the awakening in OFA hadnt happend yet
@@xxxhalo4everxxx this is an issue with world building. In a reality where 7.7 billion people have quirks and only 20% of them dont that leaves around 1.5 billion people who are quirkless. We should be seeing alot more people who are quirkless in the story. For example the humanrise cult thing should have been a bunch if quirkless people with support item so the fight would have been controversial (a bunch of quirked up heroes putting down the quirkless minority).
Hero society in MHA will always have its flaws.. not one person can be held solely responsible in my opinion.
They really needed a Symbol of hope in the darkest time when peace is lost because peace won’t last long.
I think the reason why all might chose deku was because he visualised himself in him how he was quirkless and how he jumped in to save bakugo even though he did not have a quirk(we can argue that he was his friend). But yeah he surely could have trained him better or at least prepared a few years earlier but then again there was no significant threat after he defeated all for one. I think after defeating all for one he never would have thought he will come back someday so he took it easy i mean it's not like the villians knew about his health.
Fun Fact:
All Might used hundreds of support items and years of training to make sure bis body is compatible with the full force of One for All.
So why the frick is Izuku without a support item in his training?!
Sorry to nitpick but that’s just not true, All Might himself adapted to his quirk almost instantly being able to practically wield 100% from the get go. Also when it comes to support items he stated in a conversation with Izuku that while he tried support items once or twice they were always to bulky and he never tried them out after that.
I think All Might being ultimately wrong is actually a big point of the narrative.
Something deku does, that all might didn't is prop up his peers and analyze how useful other quirks and fighting styles are.
I believe if all Might wasn't a lone pillar, giving Deku the chance to be a hero wouldn't be a bad thing... but a successor should have been ready sooner...
That being said, giving it to someone quirkless did add a hero to society instead of buffing an existing one, which could be argued to be a long term benefit...
Well after the last chapter came up looks like you were right and even all for one acknowledged dekus greatest power is proping up his boys
A, I agree, whenever a symbol becomes a dependency, it is not good for society.
However, what I find ironic is the quirks name. One, for all.
It insinuates that the user sacrifices themself for the good of everyone else, but to save everyone they have to do it alone, and that they will die in the effort. It's not about the long term good, it's about the idea of holding the entire world on the shoulders of one individual, and sacrificing themselves, day in, day out, every day to do nothing, but try and save the world.
I really think the biggest failure isn't so much in All Might but in the hero society at large. Having a ranking system and making it known who is the most prominent and successful hero. This does nothing but breed competition and an uncooperative mindset that poisons the hero society as a whole. I mean, look at Mirko calling Edgeshot week for forming a team. Look at Endeavor mouthing off about the rescue mission to save Bakago for "cleaning up UA's mess". This entire system only creates rivalries and not alliances. Meanwhile, the villains band together and form an army that the heroes are ill-equipped to handle.
Which leads us to Stain. For all his bluster and fanaticism he's a moron. Rather than attacking the institution and the broken system of a ranking for heroes, he attacks the heroes themselves. What does that accomplish? If he somehow managed to attack and kill lets say Endeavor, then Hawks just becomes the number 2 hero. And that's not even getting into the issue of "a hero should not receive payment for their good deeds" Umm...hello? A heroes only job is to be a hero. Who would want to pursue a profession when you can't afford a roof over your head or food on your table. How inspiring would a hero be if they had to panhandle so they can buy a sandwich? And in most cases, such as with Iida, his family got rich off generational heroism.
I believe its the system that needs to be overhauled and not the individual heroes themselves, however, the individual heroes are equally guilty for buying into this system. Should heroes get paid? Absolutely, otherwise how would afford basic expenses? But is a ranking system the most efficient way to promote a successful hero society? No. I really wish the series would have spent more time analyzing this than, you know, the joint training arc. Have the students question whether the current system is the best and if it should not be reformed. But they buy into the propaganda just like the pros.
Personally, I always liked the idea of Madoria being a Batman type hero. Using his brains and gadgets and proving even without a quirk, people are valued in a society that praises heroes to an almost religious level. But that's just me.
I think you've got this back words. In that I mean we both are driving to the same place but were in different parking lots. It's not that All Might failed it's that he was too effective. He stopped crime by just existing that's not failure but it did make other heroes and worse the public complacent that's not his fault but he is the cause.
It's easy to criticize all might for the consequences of his actions in this case because hind sight is twenty twenty. As far as i'm concerned, he just a guy trying to do the right thing, but just still wasn't perfect or omniscient. Let's not forget after all, things really didn't start falling apart and he didn't lose his powers until All for One came back with a vengeance.
correction, only someone quirkless like deku can inherit one for all safely
Giving his power to eraser head would be dumb he hated that power and wouldn't want it
In the time all might grew up the world was filled with crime (if I remember correctly the crime rate was 6x what it is with all might which is pretty insane because, in the first episode, we see two villains around the same time making the average villain encounter 12 before all might's time) and villains because there was no hope so he wanted to be that hope so people can aspire to be like him and stop crime the problem is that he was soo good people stopped trying
and he wanted to become a pillar because there were none in his time
and choosing Deku is the most logical because any successor of One for All would be stronger than everyone so the thing he needed was not physical strength but mental strength and the right mindset so picking a young person who he could nurture was the right choice especially
because he thought that All for One was dead so there would not be anyone that could stop him and that when he finally ran out of One for All deku would already be a hero and Mirio and Nighteye were already strong they don't need to be stronger and giving one for all to Aizawa would be the stupidest thing he could have done because for Aizawa personality and especially because Aizawa didn't want to stand out so he would be the symbol of peace
and all Might does actually try to learn how to be a better teacher we are even shown a scene in season 4 of him reading a book on how to be a good teacher and people with talent are usually bad teachers and someone doesn't become a good teacher overnight
I disagree with the opinion at 6:25, It is revealed later on in the story that OFA users with quirks would die soon after getting the quirk. Deku is using OFA and 6-7 other quirks. Deku was one of the greatest choices out there.
I explained that on reddit ( i got minused ) the true power of ONE FOR ALL isnt the power thats only one might posseses. Ba ! Its not only the power that Deku posseses. It is the power that we all posseses. That power is empathy. Its quirk to feel person laughing, crying and pain. And if you feel the pain youre angry. Youre angry because its like all the things done to others are given to you. Thats why people all over Japan willingly fight for All might because they know it is 100% worth and he would do this for the smallest soul in those island that believes him
There are others solutions rather than with cold mind and calculation comes with our feelings. And there is nothing wrong with them. Thats what make us humans :)
I think you wat h too much anime my guy , your comment seems like it will be somewhere on fairy tail
Nice editing!
All might was saving people but not teaching them to save themselves.
Like teaching someone to fish vs giving them a fish. You can give someone a fish to eat everyday of your life but once you are gone they can't eat because they never figured out how to fish. By teaching hero society to have more well rounded heroes that actually care for the people not the fame all might would have been able to retire sooner aka teach them to fish.
Manga is ending soon and yeah it's a mess. Things just snap back and forth with society and the heroes and it doesn't sound good to leave mha at that
funny Deiku even did more for hero society than all might with gentle criminal who stopped an entire prison break by himself basically Saving a soul who then saves others.
It wasn't just his way of doing things, it's also the fact he hod a lot of things from the world and that came bacj to bite the world's ass
All Might Failed in that he rarely allowed other heroes to step up. The only person even trying to catch up to him was Endeavor. There is a reason that, after he left, crime began to rise almost immediately. Outside of Endeavor there were not really a lot of heroes that could live up to that shadow he cast.
I laugh so much when the fanbase wanted Midoriya to be like Batman
Like i can give them a question if you think Batman is an Intresting and Reliable Hero why is Gotham's Crime Rate Still at a All time High and got worse when the Dark Knight Retired?
I didn't say batman fail to be hero and he tried to put a fear of god like he said "he wanted them scarred" be invunerable but since Villians in Gotham knew he is just a Man and Man has weakness you know and her can be beat i m'ean take a look at Bane Vs Batman or Poison Ivy Vs Batman although they do lose to him
Hero worship is a form of idolatry and it is what ultimately caused the collapse of the Hero Society. Also, peace is actually a lie. After all, wars of survival and conflicts such as arguments and the struggles to live day-by-day are everywhere. And while I know that All Might cannot be everywhere, he also propagated the idea that nothing can go wrong as long as the society is relying on him, which is wrong. The point is that the Hero Society needed its own reformation, something sort of akin to the Tanzimat Reforms but looking into certain elements from the religious laws such as Islam, Sikhism and Mormonism instead and borrow those certain elements to create a new set of regulations.
1 Islam strongly prohibited all forms of idolatry, and that's including hero worship. So that means such a thing like the hero ranking system is a no-no to the Muslim countries because such system can be interpreted as the attempts of someone to become a partner or an equal with God. And in Islam, it is always said by its followers that God has no partner and it is considered to be one of the greatest sins to placed someone or something as His equal. And like Islam, Sikhism and Mormonism also strongly forbade idolatry as well. In other words, getting rid of hero worship by taking out the hero-ranking system because it generated hero worship among the public and toxic competition among the heroes.
2 In Islam, there are no races and no tribes. An Arab is not superior to a non-Arab nor a white man is superior to a black man. And when we all died, all will returned equally to God. This can be stated clearly that it doesn't matter who have quirks and who don't have quirks, all humans are equal to one another in God's sight.
3 When it comes to morals and ethics in Islam, such things like the focus of achieving fame and legacy is replaced by the concept of all humans will be called to account before God during the Day of Resurrection. So what matters here when all humans are alive should be about the good deeds they have done to humanity and the society, whether the ones who did those good deeds have quirks or not, without asking for fame, wealth or creating their own glorified legacies in return after they passed away.
4 Islam, Sikhism and Mormonism promoted people to give charities for the poor and the needy. While Sikhism and Mormonism do no made it mandatory for the followers of their faiths to give charities, Islam did by making it a religious obligation in the form of almsgiving called zakat. So in order to make sure the heroes and even the quirked people in general are not being too much attached to their wealth, making it mandatory for them to pay zakat would greatly decreased the number of people who wanted to become heroes just for wealth and fame. As for the civilians, having them donating their fixed amount of wealth to the heroes instead of paying their taxes to them.
5 In Sikh's philosophy and theology, the idea of selfless service is promoted. Selfless service is a service that is performed without any expectation of result or award for performing it. Such services can be performed to benefit other human beings or the society. So by promoting this idea of selfless service to the superhumans' society, the heroes will become more effective and deserved be called the true heroes.
6 The Sikhs who become warriors are known as Khalsa. And the duties of all Khalsa are to be honest, treat everyone as equal, meditate on God, maintain his fidelity, resist tyranny and religious persecution of oneself and others. The Five Ks and the Four Prohibitions arre yet to be put in because they should be applied to the Khalsa only. But back to the Khalsa's duties. If the pro-heroes have the similar kind of the code of conduct to the Khalsa's duties, then the false heroes like Endeavor and Bakugo will be no more.
7 In Sikhism, the places or worship/gurdwara, are more than just the places or worship for that each gurdwara has their own community kitchens, akak langar. And the community kitchens in the Sikh places of worship are opened 24/7 to the peoples of all faiths, backgrounds, genders, caste and races to receive free vegetarian foods without any kind of discrimination. This will dissolved the issues related to the persecutions against the quirkless people and the quirked people with forms as animals.
8 After Prophet Muhammad died, the Muslim community of Arabia was completely not prepared for this. However, the Prophet's father-in-law, Abu Bakr, stood up in the mosque and said this to those who gathered in the mosque with him:
"If anyone worships Muhammad, let them know that Muhammad is dead. If anyone worships God, let them know that God is alive and cannot die."
This sentence alone soothe the souls of all Muslims to leave from the profound shock that struck them with the death of their Prophet. But what matters more is this. It's clearly stated that Muhammad himself is just a man. A man who can bleed, get sicked and died. The same can be say to All Might as well. Because at the end of the day, All Might is just a man. However, the society treated him as some sort of benevolent godlike being like you said. And this will make them never be able to prepare themselves when All Might is gone. Even more, they don't even have someone like Abu Bakr to calm them down at all with such a speech that can remind them of the reality at all.
9 In Islam, children are not properties of their fathers and they all must have rights to be fed, clothed, protected, educated and should not be forced by their birth parents or their stepparents. This will definitely improve the conditions of Shoto and his siblings for sure if this law is adopted and applied to the Hero Society.
10 In Islam, parents are to be obeyed and respected by their children and that the women who are mothers have the rights to receive the best treatments than accorded to any other persons, in addition the mothers have the rights of custodies of the children in general circumstances, at least until she remarries. Parents have the rights to be looked after by their children, and to receive physical or financial help as necessary, especially in their old age but also parents must not force their children/child as it is according to the sharia, aka the Islamic law. So by using these rights of parents from Islam, Rei's chance to win the custodies of all of Natsuo and Shoto from Endeavor will be a lot higher.
11 Adoption does not existed in Islam because it will created the confusion within the adopted children's heads about their lineages. So instead, all orphans have to be treated as fellow brothers and sisters of the faith and being sponsored with the system called kafala without becoming part of the families if the adults wish to sponsor them. And while the sponsored children will have no rights to bear the names of the fathers, no rights to inheritance, cannot see the female children of his sponsors without them wearing hijab and cannot called the sponsors as moms and dads. The sponsored children have the rights to marry into the families of their sponsors and have rights for the living expenses if they volunteered for to have them. Kafala means sponsorship in Arabic. This idea as a whole might be able prevent someone like Overhaul to have Eri in his possession because if he wanted to have her with him, he will be forced to treat Eri as a sponsored child instead of an adopted one.
So... anyone have anything to say about this? Just no flames, please.
I love the fact that you used religion in comparing with this
@@user-pt4th4pq5z Thank you! And what do you think about it?
@@user-pt4th4pq5z Thank you! And what do you think about it?
In a way i agree with some of the points in this video but not completely. It's true that he could've done better by thinking more long-term for when he wouldn't be there anymore and in some of the ways he trained mioriya.
I acknowledge that All Might isn’t perfect but I also don’t think it’s right to say he failed hero society. For the people who are like All Might could have picked a better successor than Deku you are correct Deku was not ideal and shouldn’t have been picked but also he is quite literally the only possible successor he currently has access to with current knowledge. If he chose anyone else they’d die with it a couple years likely so even while it wasn’t a perfect choice it could have been worse in hindsight. Secondly yes he is a bad teacher but you know whose also a bad teacher? Literally everyone at UA apparently because somehow no one literally no one sat Izuku down to help him gain basic mastery until like two months or something like that into UA and it’s fairly clear no one was ever planning to do anything about it either since Izuku gained control in like 1 week the second he had a decent teacher. Also Aizawa’s entire treatment of his class and especially Bakugou and Izuku’s relationship is a mess like yo Bakugou nearly killed Izuku in week 1 and all he has to say is “stop being childish” like seriously. Finally All Might made a mistake by setting up hero society on his back yes but he was also born in a time where things were basically going to hell and single handedly dragged hero society from it so he may have failed it but he damn well saved it first and got it to the point of stabilizing to be able to survive his fall. If not for the fact that AFO was around hero society would have recovered and been fine without him. So yeah he failed but I think you might be exaggerating a bit much.
Saying All Might giving One For All to Midoriya was a poor choice is absolutely stupid.
All Might chose Midoriya because Midoriya was quirkless which was a wise move.
One For All rapidly reduces it's users lifespan if they already have a quirk, so if Mirio or Shota were given OFA, they would eventually die due to them already possessing quirks of their own (Yes I looked this up)
And Izuku had the goal of saving people with a smile on his face, a smile that would say to those he saves that everything will be fine now, which may be a very difficult goal to achieve, but it's an admirable goal.
Honestly... I HIGHLY disagree with "All Might made a mistake with giving Midoriya OFA"
(And complaining to me saying that I'm wrong will just prove to me that you are full on ignorant)
Thank god I’m not the only one who thinks about him that way
If you watched Clamp's Magic Knights, you know that any system that relies on a pillar is a flawed system.
6:50 I agree, imo he should have given the quirk to someone like Mirio, Tamaki, or Hawks. Someone young who is powerful and has potential to be (or is) a top 10 pro. Deku was a TERRIBLE choice.
(Spoilers)
I am aware that anyone with a quirk that receives ofa dies after a decade or so but All Might himself didn’t know that at the time so that doesn’t matter here
Good
I mostly agree with you, but "ofa + quirk = bad" aside, I'd still say Izuku was the best choice. If he spoke to Nana about her quirk at all, he'd already know OfA would cause changes to their quirk. He'd also know that someone seen with All Might suddenly gaining power while he lost it (something Bakugo calls him out on later during the JTA), would be super sus. A relative unknown with no power with no quirk and an "ideal" "heroic" spirit and an appreciation for power and powerlessness was the right call instead of someone widely known (Mirio was nude on international television once due to his quirk) that already has Power (ironically, from being groomed to receive OfA, super cringe reality when you think about it).
The problem was not getting Inko and Torino involved earlier. Those two gave All Might and Izuku the reality checks they needed to realize their way was unacceptable, but by then, it was too late, with the habits formed and the damage done. You could make the argument that maybe Gran's character was an after-thought, but that doesn't make his existence in the narative any less of a condemnation of Toshinori's poor judgement.
What makes Deku a perfect choice but a poor successor is that they never worked on teaching Deku to not believe he was Deku, and that was likely intended in the writing. A tragedy from the start but a planned one.
Edit: TLDR: Izuku was a good choice, but Deku was not. You teach what you know, and All Might only really knew how to try to fix everything himself.
All Might is a pillar who stopped crime just with his existence? Kind of like Kira, how people won't commit crime out of fear of being deleted. Only Kira kills criminals quickly with a heart attack, not a Detroit Smash to the head that would cause permanent brain damage.
I agree with you not because I watch the video, but I always had this opinion
I disagree with you on All Might choosing Deku. If you read the further chapter OFA can no longer be inherited by a quirk user because it will slowly kill them due to it's massive power.
Think of it like computer getting overloaded with additional software.
Though I do agree with you that Izuku was not right successor. Izuku could have been worthy to inherit he either if All Might chose him few years earlier and trained before inheriting the quirk or Izuku underwent physical training before he met All Might.
I mean isnt a flawed character good😂
Honestly, basically gets it all might biggest problem wasn’t that he wasn’t strong or anything it’s because he wasn’t acknowledging the consequences of his choices. Like, for instance, how he train izuku it was really shown them. Most of his teachers were really bad at teaching. People who had no talent, and unfortunately stent to him, because most of the previous wielders of one for all were talented, except for the first and everything. And the problem is he’s them that to his own student. My God he screwed izuku so hard unintentionally. It’s like this. He was a great hero but he wasn’t a good person. Because if he was a great person, he could’ve really helped people more that didn’t need him.
Its said in the show endeavor is a better teacher than all might lol
All Might is the goat
This would be true but it wasn’t only allmight. There was other hero’s that are also pillars. He even inspired tons of people to be hero’s. Allmight is human. He’s not infallible or godly. Your argument is good but you just overlooked his deeds and all those he inspired. Allmight is the only true hero I admire because he’s not like Superman or the other hacks. He’s human. He makes mistakes. He’s not all knowing or all powerful. He’s like us he has his short coming and he can learn and grow just like us.
I I'm b they type of guy who will listen to crazy sagestions? But what do you mean all might didn't make the world stronger, he inspired a hole genoration of heros to become heroes. And don't you dare say deku would be a bad hero just because he is quirkless. Almight knew it is more important to find someone who Wouldn't abuse one for all, and someone who was determined. Deku works hard every day, to learn how to confront one for all. Plus, almight stopped the first rise of all for one, amd kept the society as safe as it possibly could be.
How much of the anime and manga have you watched? You are pointing out some true ideas, but you are missing out on a lot of other essential ones. And it's all in the plot. All Might is himself saying he is a failure, he himself regrets his way of being and many of his decisions. He is built as a kind hearted but overemotional and unreasonable hero, that runs to save everyone before thinking about the better long term plan. And it makes sense, because without that there's no plot. He is guided by emotions and is full of remorse for the consequences after that, and that's always there, that's the whole philosophy of this anime. Maybe you just make this so unilateral to get comments, and here's one, but in this video you missed All Might s Essence in this anime
It's not all mights fault the other hero's are weak that's on them
You are not crazy and stupid. I can see where you are coming from. All might was a failure but thats part of what makes his character unique. Flaws... Let's not forget every One For All user before All might was also a failure.
You’re wrong though. By your logic, being a good parent is selfish. A good parent’s role is to make their children feel safe, so they can flourish. It’s the child’s responsibility to do the same for the next generation.
And no, they go over it: Mirio was supposed to be the next bearer of One For All, but we discover that the quirk is so strong now that it could’ve been fatal on anyone who already has a quirk.
I enjoyed the video, you’re just incorrect about daddy All Might.