Websites Design Critique: Student Work

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 49

  • @woutjuh13
    @woutjuh13 Před 5 lety +11

    If you want to check the mobile version using the inspect element way you often have to reload the page for it to take effect. It will probably look better after that

    • @wathah323
      @wathah323 Před 5 lety +3

      Ya, The guys at google should fix that. I mean it has been an issue for years

    • @AngryKnees
      @AngryKnees Před 4 lety +1

      @@wathah323 It's intentional. There are common use cases where you wouldn't want it to reload.

  • @scottcitron
    @scottcitron Před 5 lety +12

    Great analysis, Ran. You hit the nail on the head with each example. Well done and looking forward to more of these. Thanks.

  • @vincenthuisman8083
    @vincenthuisman8083 Před 4 lety +11

    17:44 CRO guy here. Are you familiar with the "Illusion of completeness"? You don't want to make the image to match the screen size. Too much white space can also create this illusion.

    • @fortcratefortcrate5684
      @fortcratefortcrate5684 Před 4 lety +4

      In one of his other videos he addresses this issue by using mouse icon to indicate you can scroll

    • @andresllinas8594
      @andresllinas8594 Před 4 lety

      I feel it would be better if he left that whitespace there but without text, so that you know there's more content

  • @muzili4725
    @muzili4725 Před 4 lety +2

    this is extremely helpful as i can see how a professional designer analyzed the way he thought, which helps me thinking in the similar way when i start my design.

  • @nks99999
    @nks99999 Před 5 lety +6

    Great vid. Need to do a lot more of these 👌
    - Can you please highlight the mouse pointer because sometimes it does get difficult to see (on mobile) what area you’re referring to

  • @suspendedhatch
    @suspendedhatch Před rokem

    The immediate problem in all of them is that websites are available internationally, but with an in-person service or even something that can be done over the phone, there are logistical and tax reasons to do business with someone local to you. Even the site that says “San Clemente”. Is that in Spain, the carribean, Florida, Central California, Southern California, Uruguay, Mexico? So first and foremost, on the landing page you need to orient the person to at minimum a city and state.

  • @astridmanzo
    @astridmanzo Před 3 lety +1

    Excellent review. I would add that the pier one doesn't look good with dark overlays. If I'm going to that place I want to get the sunny, perfect day with beautiful colors vibes when I visit this website.

  • @goroh83
    @goroh83 Před 5 lety +8

    In 17:45 u suggest hero section being 100vh. It's 2019, and we're used to scrolling, but still, revealing some of the content that's under hero and cutting it off can be, if designed well, a good approach that will trigger the user to scroll and explore more. Shouldn't be difficult to find some examples.

  • @canarymultimedia
    @canarymultimedia Před rokem

    This was very educational, thanks!

  • @dustinoverbeck
    @dustinoverbeck Před 5 lety +1

    It seems that many of the issues that Ran pointed out are because each web developer used an existing theme to create the site.
    Using an existing theme and trying to fit your vision inside of that theme might be too limiting.

  • @JaideepMultani
    @JaideepMultani Před rokem

    I use framer and I am very confused how the hacienda websiote did the scroll aniamtion where the background was still but the rest of the website was moving.

  • @fabriciomira2
    @fabriciomira2 Před 5 lety +1

    Great video! In your opinion, what is the best side for the hamburger menu? I believe that on the right side makes it easy for those who are right-handed, but many sites use on the left ...

  • @pilipdasamattanawin1058
    @pilipdasamattanawin1058 Před 5 lety +1

    do you think keeping all letters small is a problem? I'm kind of not very into capital letters but I understand that it's English language. When it comes to sentences, I ofc use capital letters and punctuation but when it comes to heading and sub-heading, if I keep it consistent, do you think it's still a problem?

  • @HashmiCodes
    @HashmiCodes Před 5 lety +2

    Really informative video. Thanks for creating such an amazing content.

  • @joe-un1ky
    @joe-un1ky Před 5 lety +1

    Definitely need more of these

  • @fluttersheesh8884
    @fluttersheesh8884 Před 3 lety

    I love this format

  • @NehemieKOFFI
    @NehemieKOFFI Před 5 lety +1

    Valuable critics. Thank Ran

  • @woistdasniveau8290
    @woistdasniveau8290 Před 3 lety

    How is the tool you used to find out the font spelled? I can't find it in the Chrome Store.

  • @illeone5433
    @illeone5433 Před 3 lety

    Is user feedback also very important?

  • @Raul9115
    @Raul9115 Před 5 lety

    Hi Ran, what is that slack channel that you talk about in the beginning of the video? its only for your students? and how can I submit my designs?

  • @Badasschick999
    @Badasschick999 Před 4 lety

    This was extremely useful! Thank you :)

  • @tbrew222
    @tbrew222 Před 5 lety +1

    I mean... I don't think the nav has to ALWAYS be at the top

    • @kiandraplummer2095
      @kiandraplummer2095 Před 5 lety

      Agreed, maybe if it was bit more obvious. Perhaps it may help if the font was larger?? It may even be a better option for mobile, This is a good article abt it - www.smashingmagazine.com/2019/08/bottom-navigation-pattern-mobile-web-pages/

  • @jessablack7220
    @jessablack7220 Před 4 lety +2

    I love the tattoo website! I think the days are behind us where the nav needs to be at the top, let's do something different for once.

  • @mjharris8214
    @mjharris8214 Před 5 lety

    What kind of glasses are those?

  • @BlueSky-mq9wi
    @BlueSky-mq9wi Před 4 lety

    Hi, what is the name of the extension you used to inspect the font and image. You mentioned CSS pip or something like that; at timestamp 18:12. Thanks

    • @PsycoGamingDK
      @PsycoGamingDK Před 4 lety

      Could not find his extension, but found another one, which tells you css properties over the things you hover - CSSViewer

    • @BlueSky-mq9wi
      @BlueSky-mq9wi Před 4 lety

      @@PsycoGamingDK Thank you..

    • @invisibl1452
      @invisibl1452 Před 4 lety

      CSSPeeper

  • @aronkvh
    @aronkvh Před 4 lety

    when I open the site there is no need for for a work with us button, bc i want to learn about you and i won't work with you right away before even looking at your site

  • @loge9981
    @loge9981 Před 4 lety

    Why do you not make full screen?😂

  • @wathah323
    @wathah323 Před 5 lety +1

    These are examples of what happens when a web designer has no skills in design/graphics. This is why there is millions of templates with poor UI and UX. Either of those can make a visitor not want to stick around. Also please discuss above the fold on some of these examples. On mobile in chrome you always want to hit f5 a few times, it is finicky. Best to view on a real mobile phone.

    • @KillerKyuubi
      @KillerKyuubi Před 5 lety

      Above the fold is kinda bullshit. If you're building responsive websites, the "fold" varies per device. You cannot predict and future proof that.

    • @wathah323
      @wathah323 Před 5 lety

      @@KillerKyuubi Agreed but there is a portion of the top which is valuable real-state. The size of the monitor and resolution dictates the fold line which like you said can vary.

    • @KillerKyuubi
      @KillerKyuubi Před 5 lety +1

      @@wathah323 it's a designer term that really has no meaning to developers.

    • @CharlBrazle
      @CharlBrazle Před 4 lety

      @@KillerKyuubi Does not agree at all. Working with CRO it's definitely something to pay attention to!

  • @necromaster3154
    @necromaster3154 Před 4 lety +3

    Speaking of Critique your ending design 23:00 looks horrible

  • @judisjeevan4908
    @judisjeevan4908 Před 4 lety

    vittukala pillecha..pilleralle..