Seb Takes On The Unrepeatable 9a's | Seb Bouin's Vintage Rock Tour Ep.4

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 02. 2021
  • Fred Rouhling's Iconic Trio of 9a's at Les Eaux Claires is the site for the 4th episode of Seb Bouin's Vintage Rock Tour....and the challenge of repeating the unrepeatable awaits...
    Psyched? Check out the Winter SALE at the EpicTv SHop: bit.ly/379MzXP
    In the 4th episode of The Vintage Rock Tour, Seb takes on the classic crag of Les Eaux Claires, On the west coast of France. Famous for its trio of Fred Rouhling 9a's, Akira, Hugh and De L' Autre Côté du Ciel...Seb's mission to repeat all 3 is a tricky one, and he must use all his experience and focus to work our a solution for each route
    Catch up with the latest episodes of the Vintage Rock Tour: bit.ly/3aVCgHE
    Check us out on instagram:
    @epictvclimbing: bit.ly/2iovWz1​
    @sebouin: bit.ly/31nX1qs​
    Seb Takes On The Unrepeatable 9a's | Seb Bouin's Vintage Rock Tour Ep.4
  • Sport

Komentáře • 172

  • @GavynPendleton
    @GavynPendleton Před 3 lety +146

    I really enjoyed this!! But don’t be afraid to make them longer. I’d have loved to see more footage of each climb.

  • @bloctribe
    @bloctribe Před 3 lety +74

    That's better now. Release as much footage as possible. It's totally worth it. Hats off to Seb for honoring Fred. Much respect to both. "De L' Autre Côté du Ciel" is probably the most aesthetic route on earth, the moon and Mars as well...

  • @johannessporer
    @johannessporer Před 3 lety +144

    I think you can't blame Fred too much for claimbing 9b for Akira because the required style was so ahead of it's time. Todays pro climbers like Seb are so good at climbing steep stuff, but back then it was not that common. When you look at old routes it is often the case that vertical, super technical routes are graded extremly hard for todays standards and steep routes are almost soft in some cases.

    • @8Hidan8
      @8Hidan8 Před 3 lety +6

      yeah but he shouldn't have skipped the 9a+ grade, that was a big mistake and doing so he lost all his credibility

    • @tunaficiency
      @tunaficiency Před 3 lety

      Fred said the route has changed so it is now 9a hold breakage I think ( I’ve climbed a very little at les eaux claire it’s nails

    • @matthewgallagher4913
      @matthewgallagher4913 Před 3 lety +26

      @@8Hidan8 He didn't lose any credibility at all. What he did was brilliant and there is nothing more to say really.

    • @8Hidan8
      @8Hidan8 Před 3 lety +2

      @@matthewgallagher4913 that's history of climbing ,you can't deny it. He lost all his credibility and there is nothing more to say really.

    • @lucast89
      @lucast89 Před 3 lety +10

      @@8Hidan8 That's a great way to end any argument.

  • @AstEternal
    @AstEternal Před 3 lety +13

    Honestly I think we should all be grateful to Seb for his contributions to climbing. Repeating some routes that have been unrepeated forever. Really gives some life into those routes and excitement into the community

  • @M0dElite
    @M0dElite Před 3 lety +14

    Think of Fred Roughling what you will, but those lines are beautiful! Great job by Seb for the repeats!

  • @Spungeur
    @Spungeur Před 3 lety +11

    Le meilleur falaisiste français dans sa petite clio vintage

  • @lafalck
    @lafalck Před 3 lety +31

    Seb Bouin + Chris Sharma = Lucien Martinez... I can't be the only one seeing this, right? 😅

  • @cotranzbb3535
    @cotranzbb3535 Před 3 lety +33

    Super vidéo ! Dommage de ne pas avoir vu Fred en parler, ça aurait été ouf

    • @vincentbelmas9787
      @vincentbelmas9787 Před 2 lety

      C'est clair, quel dommage, s'aurait été top d'avoir un peu sa vision des choses et son récit, mais je pense que Rhouling a été un peu échaudé des média grimpesques en général, donc bon s'exprimer sur un film où un grimpeur décote sa voie ça a pas du lui dire grand chose.

  • @Hikups
    @Hikups Před 3 lety +11

    06:40 Very confusing to see Seb spotting Seb :)

  • @1981stonemonkey
    @1981stonemonkey Před 2 lety +3

    Finally someone who has an unbiased opinion about these routes, and just having a go at them for curiosity´s sake.
    I always felt Fred´s creations deserved wayyy more recognition than they did back in the day.
    Maybe they will, now. Well done, Seb.
    Did you contact Fred, at all, by any chance? Would have been even better to have witnessed a dialogue between you two.

  • @robertohiroshi1789
    @robertohiroshi1789 Před 3 lety +3

    11:07 la souplesse et la dynamique du mouvement c’est impressionnant. De la danse sur roche, superbe ascension!

  • @donkyuhbuhts540
    @donkyuhbuhts540 Před 2 lety +1

    That was some of the craziest roof climbing I've ever seen.

  • @theboulderboys1572
    @theboulderboys1572 Před 3 lety +4

    Honestly such a beautiful video 😍 the scenery and just the absolute amazing climbing. I could watch an hour of this

  • @twpayne
    @twpayne Před 3 lety +2

    Absolutely brilliant video, and a fantastic tribute to Rouhling. Respect and thanks!

  • @jeromelecat6859
    @jeromelecat6859 Před 3 lety

    Great contribution and Lightning to our climbing history! Well done and thanks to you Seb and Lucien!

  • @Airsofter3009
    @Airsofter3009 Před 3 lety

    Merci Seb et Lucien pour ces belles histoires et ces magnifiques images. Chapeau, messieurs !

  • @wondertof
    @wondertof Před 3 lety +8

    Bel hommage à Fred, et superbes images, merci Seb

  • @rodolphe5624
    @rodolphe5624 Před 3 lety

    Merci de nous offrir ça c'est juste un régale de voir du super contenu comme ça

  • @apostatepaul
    @apostatepaul Před 3 lety +1

    What an awesome collection of some amazing routes! Brilliant 👌👌👌

  • @frantzlanoue58
    @frantzlanoue58 Před rokem

    Et en plus, la musique est très bonne les gars. Merci!

  • @brendanacord2557
    @brendanacord2557 Před 3 lety

    Great production, editing and of course there is the super cool factor of seeing Seb climbing just oozing style on these futuristic routes :)

  • @alixvolte
    @alixvolte Před 3 lety +4

    Merci Seb de remettre sur le devant de la scene des falaises et des voies qui ont marque l'histoire et le developpement de l'escalade en France. Les images sont superbes ! Et bravo pour ces realisations !

  • @Buckfast2003
    @Buckfast2003 Před 3 lety +3

    Small correction, Akira is not on the same climbing site in the Eaux-Claires valley, which has many climbing routes. But on a world scale, it's relatively close (21 km / 13 miles).
    Petite correction, Akira n'est pas sur le même site d'Escalade (de la vallée) des Eaux-Claires, qui comporte de nombreuses voies d'escalade. Mais à l'echelle du monde, c'est relativement proche (21 km / 13 miles).

  • @AntoineAlluyn
    @AntoineAlluyn Před 2 lety

    Seb t'es une machine de guerre ! Bravo pour ces répétitions historiques !

  • @vincentgarruchet2093
    @vincentgarruchet2093 Před 3 lety

    Super inspirant, merci Seb !

  • @niamor17
    @niamor17 Před 3 lety +1

    trop bien! merci

  • @lyghty
    @lyghty Před 3 lety

    so many cool holds! great footage and music choice aslwell! cheers from Brasil

  • @baschu101
    @baschu101 Před 2 lety

    I love the final scene… no sponsored VW T6 - mini car packed to the roof… same goes for Sebs old bike on some videos…

  • @CollinGill7
    @CollinGill7 Před 7 měsíci

    the middlle crux of that chipped roof route was insane

  • @kriszteblade
    @kriszteblade Před 3 lety

    Great video. Loved it.

  • @justinjakimiak1998
    @justinjakimiak1998 Před 3 lety +12

    Finding myself strangely comfortable with manufactured routes

    • @terraflow__bryanburdo4547
      @terraflow__bryanburdo4547 Před 2 lety

      Chipping can be artistic in the right situation. The Dark Art.

    • @racerschin
      @racerschin Před rokem

      ​@@terraflow__bryanburdo4547 Why not bolting some holds, like in a gym. And if route is repeated without them, remove them. Chipping is so egoistic and permanent.

  • @dariorotaclimb
    @dariorotaclimb Před 2 lety

    Awesome brilliant video!! Tnx

  • @GalleryBones
    @GalleryBones Před 3 lety

    Seb is such an awesome guy

  • @ericfrisard2060
    @ericfrisard2060 Před 3 lety +1

    Vidéo très sympa ! Et super complément au dossier du Grimper de ce mois-ci !

  • @morrisspliffberg4276
    @morrisspliffberg4276 Před 3 lety

    Magnifique

  • @2009ASGJPJ
    @2009ASGJPJ Před 3 lety +1

    The classic Renault Clio scene in the end...!! :)

    • @leoingson
      @leoingson Před 3 lety

      Is it actually Seb's car?

  • @Matreynaud
    @Matreynaud Před 3 lety +6

    Toujours aussi bon! Merci! Et continuez à nous régaler. Dommage que Fred n'ait pas été présent. D'un autre coté, je comprends qu'il soit passé à autre chose.

  • @ochoymedio78
    @ochoymedio78 Před 3 lety +1

    AMAZING VIDEO! Thanx so much for showing us such an inspiring and beautiful place. Love how you pay respect to Fred, though I would have liked to hear the man himself. Sure you tried to get in touch with him, it's a pity that he isn't on the video. Btw, you could make a 30 min video of this 3 routes and I wouldn't mind... translation: PLEASE do an extended video!!! hahahah

  • @audiocratie
    @audiocratie Před 3 lety +1

    c'est bien ce que tu fais seb :) c'est très très bien ;) à bientôt

  • @helmik666
    @helmik666 Před 3 lety +2

    was Fred not willing to comment? it would be amazing to hear also some memories from him

  • @BlocBusters
    @BlocBusters Před 3 lety

    very enjoyable video ;)

  • @pabletedona
    @pabletedona Před 3 lety +1

    "Calité" Increíbles vías!

  • @jeremieuchard383
    @jeremieuchard383 Před 3 lety +1

    Je suis toujours agréablement étonné de voir l'approche historique que Seb Bouin a. Continue comme ça tu nous régales!

  • @Hopesfallout
    @Hopesfallout Před 2 lety

    Not sure what to think about the chipping in the last example ;D but damn these are easily some of the most interesting high-level routes I have seen in a while!

  • @LFSJack
    @LFSJack Před 3 lety +14

    no move harder then 7a?! i kinda doubt it ^^ 8:06

    • @mikegruber1771
      @mikegruber1771 Před 3 lety +1

      thought exactly the same, 7a boulder with mono in a cave. I doubt it :D

    • @tutecalmesoui
      @tutecalmesoui Před 3 lety

      7a boulder = 8a

    • @the0neskater
      @the0neskater Před 3 lety

      Yeah I lost my shit when that was said and then proceeded to do multiple nasty crimps, pinches and massive dynamic moves, and then a mono campus to top it off, all in a full roof hahahaha...

    • @terraflow__bryanburdo4547
      @terraflow__bryanburdo4547 Před 2 lety +1

      @@tutecalmesoui No...7A =7c at most. Looks more like 8A =V11+=8c=14b which matches better with overall 9A

    • @tutecalmesoui
      @tutecalmesoui Před 2 lety

      @@terraflow__bryanburdo4547 the hardest boulder is 8c+ and the hardest route is 9c

  • @MrEldorado15
    @MrEldorado15 Před 3 lety

    Wow !!!

  • @terraflow__bryanburdo4547

    Such sick routes..it would be interesting to see Fred interviewed.

    • @The0casanova0
      @The0casanova0 Před 2 lety +1

      Your dream came true, an interview was released on another french climbing channel

    • @terraflow__bryanburdo4547
      @terraflow__bryanburdo4547 Před 2 lety

      @@The0casanova0 I watched, and it was great! I had to laugh how soon it popped up! I have put up almost 1000 routes myself (no 9a's lol) and only two chipped holds, but I respect Fred's work, looks like some real beautiful and futuristic stuff, too bad the bad vibes turned him off.

  • @permaphil3973
    @permaphil3973 Před rokem

    Sick

  • @cillijed4291
    @cillijed4291 Před 3 lety

    ÀMAZING

  • @jeremiemaxit
    @jeremiemaxit Před 3 lety

    Merci pour ce nouvel épisode autour des voies mythiques de l'histoire de l'escalade en France.
    J'habite en haute-savoie et pas loin d'une voie libérée par Rouhling "Mandallaz Drive" en 9A à Allonzier la Caille pour ceux qui habitent dans le coin. Si jamais Seb passe dans le coin ?

  • @ThomasRevest
    @ThomasRevest Před 3 lety

    Bravo ! au top :) Ca fait plaisir de voir répéter ces voies historiques

  • @Fred-oz3tw
    @Fred-oz3tw Před 2 lety

    wow

  • @synkaan2167
    @synkaan2167 Před 3 lety

    Très bonne vidéo et merci à Seb pour ce tour historique =)

  • @haywardab
    @haywardab Před 3 lety

    Is that the last episode of the vintage rock tour? Hope not! Great series

  • @yohannelbaz3690
    @yohannelbaz3690 Před 3 lety

    trop bien la dernier falaise

  • @nicolasjeannet1063
    @nicolasjeannet1063 Před 3 lety

    Très lourd

  • @maximeferre6903
    @maximeferre6903 Před 3 lety +8

    Dommage de ne pas voir l'intégralité des ascensions sans coupures ! Et de ne pas voir Lucien grimper. Sinon beau reportage, belles images, bonnes musiques, voies magnifiques ! ça pourrait être plus long ;)

  • @flooo5071
    @flooo5071 Před 3 lety +4

    Finalement pas de pas de bloc en 8B au début d'Akira ? Il me semble que F. Rouhling mentionnait ça, d'ailleurs dommage qu'il n'ait pas été interviewé !

    • @runbikehell
      @runbikehell Před 3 lety +1

      Il s'est expliqué à ce sujet suite aux répétitions !

    • @The0casanova0
      @The0casanova0 Před 2 lety

      Il y a une interview qui vient de sortir sur une autre chaîne d'escalade française

  • @nathankenny7454
    @nathankenny7454 Před 3 lety

    Absolutely amazing. Great story telly. Less cuts and edits of the climbing please.

  • @cats831
    @cats831 Před 3 lety +1

    someone please explain how the mid-route tie in worked? A pre loaded locker!?

    • @matteobabic4963
      @matteobabic4963 Před 2 lety

      Pre tied figure 8 to locking carabiner is my guess. It’s very safe just shouldn’t use it a lot cause your knot will never come undone, and puts wear on certain spots on the rope only. If you are worried use two biners for redundancy.

  • @anotherfloatingmind8842

    anyone know the name of the song that begins around 11:55? thanks

  • @rixdalerheptads1505
    @rixdalerheptads1505 Před 3 lety +7

    EpicTV: posts a video in french as the original language
    The entirety of France: This comment section is now our property

  • @laurentdaramy
    @laurentdaramy Před 3 lety

    Pour bien saisir l'esprit castoche de l'époque de cette trilogie, on peut lire le billet 'histoire de taille' de mars 2011 sur le blog 'Vertical Concept' d'Axel Franco. En plus c'est drôle (contrairement aux commentaires qui n'autorisent pas les liens)

  • @liam7342
    @liam7342 Před 3 lety

    How did he tie in with the mid roof? I was expecting to see a tie in knot on a carabinier?

    • @aspuzling
      @aspuzling Před 3 lety +1

      That's what he has done. If you look closely, you can see there is a carabiner between the knot and the harness.

  • @EKdlwoasred
    @EKdlwoasred Před 3 lety

    Comme si comme sa

  • @escaladaseguraamimanera3621

    decir que es impresionante es decir poco. pero el grado es un factor determinante en la escalada, unos lo tienen y otros no.

  • @jerzykoakowski8018
    @jerzykoakowski8018 Před 2 lety

    What is the song at the De L Ature Cote....route?

  • @oldi6btm6t9d4
    @oldi6btm6t9d4 Před 3 lety +24

    Though these routes are really cool, I hope everyone understands that chipping is not expectable any more.

    • @krakenattackin7617
      @krakenattackin7617 Před 3 lety +6

      I really don't see why anyone cares if a literally blank piece of rock at a crag that wasn't some destination gets chipped. It hurts no one and nothing.

    • @krakenattackin7617
      @krakenattackin7617 Před 3 lety +7

      @@ohhhspanky We already bolt everything we can, I don't see how adding a couple lines at a cliff that is already established as a climbing cliff is an issue.

    • @andrewscott5059
      @andrewscott5059 Před 3 lety +38

      @@krakenattackin7617 The current ethics almost everywhere in the world is to not chip, and the reason is as such: just because it's too flat and featureless for you doesn't mean it can't be climbed by somebody stronger, or the next generation of climbers when they're 2-3 grades stronger than anybody is today. If we decide it's okay to chip, routes that could have been climbed without it will be destroyed before their time, and finding routes pushing the limits will become impossible.
      Chipping isn't something we should see as okay for the sport, even if you don't think it's a problem environmentally. With the advent of modern plastic holds, there's little reason to make your own problems from the rock. If you want to create so badly, do it in a less destructive fashion.
      Bolts are as minimal as it gets for protection, and most people don't notice them or know they exist if they're not climbers. Especially in areas with climbable rock, it's not ethical to chip new routes (or old ones for that matter). The ethics of climbing are to minimize impact, not to have no impact. Chipping is unnecessary, whereas bolts often are the only way to safely climb an area.

    • @FragenAnsLeben
      @FragenAnsLeben Před 3 lety +2

      @@krakenattackin7617 if you can't climb it, you can't climb it.

    • @braydonsmedley5652
      @braydonsmedley5652 Před 3 lety +2

      @@andrewscott5059 I had the same question as to why it wasn't acceptable. I figured the ethical problems with chipping fell in the same category as people who believe you shouldn't climb anything that you cant protect with trad gear. Your explanation makes a lot of sense though and has helped me understand why chipping is a harmful practice. Thank you.

  • @Psychid5
    @Psychid5 Před 3 lety +1

    Akira not harder than 7a boulder? How do I find that hard to believe..

  • @twpayne
    @twpayne Před rokem

    Still the best climbing video ever made

  • @souslesbombes
    @souslesbombes Před 3 lety

    4:45 😳😳😳

  • @israelCaver
    @israelCaver Před 3 lety

    What is the name for the music on 5-th minute (czcams.com/video/DuMxIC6qdp8/video.html) ? Thanks!

  • @000razo000
    @000razo000 Před 3 lety

    Did he almost die at 3:42?

  • @luape6593
    @luape6593 Před 3 lety

    2:59 if its a yellow shirt i always think its megos

  • @dvdsct
    @dvdsct Před 3 lety +1

    3:42 belay!!!!

  • @laurentdavou
    @laurentdavou Před 3 lety

    Bon, je vais juste reprendre les mot de la dame: "Très très bien ce que vous faites, c'est Bien!"
    Merci.

  • @paulmartin3355
    @paulmartin3355 Před 3 lety

    Super vidéo ! Je n'ai pas compris si Akira a finalement été confirmée en tant que 9b ?

  • @satanaz
    @satanaz Před 3 lety +1

    Omelette du fromage?

  • @quezquez3084
    @quezquez3084 Před 3 lety +4

    First, as an european, let me tell you that I love this series. Chipping holds has to be a really bad practice. Even in the 80's they should have known that chipping holds would have a long last impact on the rock and environment. I mean, millions of years! In the 21st century that practice should be seen as totally unacceptable.

  • @imxd9698
    @imxd9698 Před 3 lety +1

    chipping holds is ok as long as it's super cool now?

    • @krakenattackin7617
      @krakenattackin7617 Před 3 lety

      Who cares? The rock was literally blank, this wasn't a popular destination crag at the time it was chipped.

    • @imxd9698
      @imxd9698 Před 3 lety +1

      @@krakenattackin7617 yeah let's let this one slip and next thing it's chipping holds at a popular crag, but kind of out the way from the main area you know? chipping is totally fine if it's away from popular areas.

    • @nicwilliams9709
      @nicwilliams9709 Před 3 lety +2

      Manufacturing routes (ie chipping, glueing, etc) was a common and totally acceptable ethic at the time this area was developed. It's obviously no longer acceptable. This wasn't stated explicitly in the film, but I think most viewers are probably aware of this. No one saw this clip and got inspired to go chip some new holds at their local crag...

    • @imxd9698
      @imxd9698 Před 3 lety

      @@nicwilliams9709 for all you know.

    • @racerschin
      @racerschin Před rokem

      ​@@krakenattackin7617 bolt some holds like in a gym. reversable.

  • @petedangerous9616
    @petedangerous9616 Před 3 lety

    7A? Lol

  • @rippendale
    @rippendale Před 3 lety

    why did you leave out all the controversy surrounding these routes and why doesn't Fred himself appear in the video? Feels like a mixture of a missed opportunity to touch on some of the more nonsensical 'rules' and hardliners within the sport who basically bullied Fred out of a career back then (feel free to Google), and also a 'wall of positive' noise trying to plaster over the actual history with a nicer, smoother narrative. I don't think that does justice to the routes and to Fred's story. Or was this all discussed in an earlier episode that I've missed maybe?

  • @leoingson
    @leoingson Před 3 lety

    I love what Seb is doing! But please don't cut away so much (speeding up long shake offs is ok), it just ruins any climbing video. Quite often clipping is the most interesting part.

  • @paolomarcotulli2388
    @paolomarcotulli2388 Před 3 lety

    Action direct 1991

    • @kikolification
      @kikolification Před 3 lety +3

      C’est le tour des falaises de France

    • @moonti6820
      @moonti6820 Před 3 lety +1

      Yea everybody knows that, thanks. With this tour, Seb is doing the historic routes of France, so he's obviously talking about the first FRENCH 9a.

  • @papadeltavictor664
    @papadeltavictor664 Před 3 lety

    Concernant le côté « vintage » de la démarche : Ca fait quelques décennies que je ne suis plus dans le circuit mais je constate tout de même un gros changement depuis les années 80: à l’époque on ne mousquetonnait pas les clous avant de passer mais on se trimbalait toutes les dégaines sur le baudard… Je veux bien que le niveau des grimpeurs a évolué en 30-40 ans mais je serais curieux de voir quelqu’un se balader au-delà de 8B/8C avec un trentaine de mousquetons. D’ailleurs, une des premières voie que j’ai vu mousquetonnée à l’avance, c’était Azincourt (pour la rose et le vampire, j’ai un doute).

  • @Dynafet
    @Dynafet Před rokem

    I dont understand how anybody can live with connecting eyebrowes...

  • @DrRaving
    @DrRaving Před 3 měsíci

    Lucien Martinez est un cosplay de Seb Bouin ? On dirait un copier coller mdr

  • @peakinbuffalo8296
    @peakinbuffalo8296 Před 3 lety +4

    07:15
    "and even though it's not harder than a 7a boulder"
    Being a 7b+ climber and 7a boulderer, in what world is that horrendously strenuous route supposed to be a 7a lmao?

    • @syneko7464
      @syneko7464 Před 3 lety

      The translation is misleading. Seb said that each move would not be above 7A.

    • @moonti6820
      @moonti6820 Před 3 lety

      If you were to take each move separately, no one would be above Font 7A

    • @kriszteblade
      @kriszteblade Před 3 lety +1

      Maybe those seem like 7A boulders when you have 8C strength ;)

    • @MS-fg8qo
      @MS-fg8qo Před 3 lety

      Or 9b/+ strength...
      Yeah, a ton of 7a moves add up to a hell lot more than a 7a-boulder. Easy to understand. Admittedly, the transition on the roof mono looks really hard...

  • @gregturner2668
    @gregturner2668 Před 3 lety +1

    You know he could have made all the false claims in the world but by chipping the rock he committed the gravest sin of all.

    • @listrahtes
      @listrahtes Před rokem

      I wouldnt say gravest sin but people who say it wasnt a problem back then are wrong. In the excess Rouhling did it, it was quite the exception even as other top climbers as Menestrel did it on a lower level sometimes. Fred is a very creative person and he basically sculpted his own routes by working the rock. I dont think we should judge him for that. He created beautiful lines but I am glad this did not turn out to be trend . Otherwise a lot of rock walls and even big walls would imo be completely changed from their natural beauty.

    • @racerschin
      @racerschin Před rokem

      ​@@listrahtes how about bolting a couple of holds and not chipping the rock. why permanently altering a route. egoism, that is why.

  • @user-hh1tu5nt2d
    @user-hh1tu5nt2d Před 3 lety

    The stingy garlic intraperitonally suit because thomas postauricularly handle to a internal game. careful, unused plaster

  • @masterpropper2485
    @masterpropper2485 Před 3 lety +3

    The proper spelling is 9as, not 9a's.
    Just trying to make the world a better place.

    • @Onmywayto8a
      @Onmywayto8a Před 3 lety +1

      Actually, I think you are wrong:
      www.grammarly.com/blog/apostrophe/
      The plural of "a" is "a's".
      Thanks for trying to make the world a better place and thus obliging me to look this rule up.

    • @masterpropper2485
      @masterpropper2485 Před 3 lety

      @@Onmywayto8a Sorry, I'm still right. The title doesn't say "a's" it says "9a's".
      There's no danger of misreading it as "as" because of the "9" in front of it which makes clear that we're talking about the plural of "9a".
      Apostrophes for plurals are always wrong with the one exception: when there is danger of misreading, which is not the case with 9as.
      You also don't write "the 1980's" to take a grammarly example.

    • @Onmywayto8a
      @Onmywayto8a Před 3 lety

      @@masterpropper2485 "the 1980s" is not a good example since it is not ending with a lowercase letter. If we are talking about bouldering grades, then yes, it should be "I sent three 8As yesterday".
      Apostrophes for plurals are always wrong with the one exception: when there is danger of misreading, which is not the case with 9as.
      > This is not true since the same rule applies for all lowercase letters. Example: "Notice all the w's in the sentence". There is not risk to misinterpret since there is no "ws" word in English.
      we're talking about the plural of "9a"
      > 9a is an acceptable word in the English language therefore the plural morpheme (mark) will be carried by the last compound.
      I am a linguist and during my studies, I have been told something that was very liberating (I used to be more conservative language-wise): there are two "right", what the linguists/specialists think and the common usage. If the vast majority of people use a rule a certain way, it can be considered as "right". This said, in both cases "9a's" is correct. Google "9a's" and "9as" and you will get your answer.
      when there is danger of misreading, which is not the case with 9as.
      > That is not true; if you present "9as" to a non-climber, they will read it as such.

    • @masterpropper2485
      @masterpropper2485 Před 3 lety

      @@Onmywayto8a I'm a linguist as well (nobody else would care). And I'm definitely not giving in to this, sorry.
      It doesn't matter if you know what 9a means or not, the correct plural is 9as and not 9a's.
      The rule of "common usage making wrongs to rights" (which mostly apllies to the English language) is something I absolutely try to refuse to accept, especially in our modern times of social media and messenger services where people (thanks to auto correct) write the craziest stuff...

    • @Onmywayto8a
      @Onmywayto8a Před 3 lety

      @@masterpropper2485 I'm a linguist as well (nobody else would care)
      > I was almost sure you were :-)
      And I'm definitely not giving in to this, sorry.
      > You do not have to "give in". I gave you my arguments but you do not have to accept their validity.
      especially in our modern times of social media
      > I was referring to less deviant usage of the language. Just because many people write "there" instead of "their" does not mean they are right.

  • @ScottandJodi
    @ScottandJodi Před 3 lety

    Great vid, but, sorry, the chipping of the holds by Rouhling on that last big roof is BS. Not EVERY piece of rock needs to be climbed.

    • @wesleychen4408
      @wesleychen4408 Před 2 lety +1

      I don’t think anyone disagrees with you, not even Fred himself (read the famous climbing world article about him).

  • @johndawkins7823
    @johndawkins7823 Před 3 lety +1

    Seb's words, "By chipping the holds he made some insane boulders." To chip a route is completely bad style. Who cares what grade it is? Look further afield and leave those un-chipped crags for someone who might be able to climb them one day, without chipping them, and if they are unclimbable, so what. Saying that things are bolted anyway and you can see the bolts is nonsense and a false equivalence. Bolts are for protection, utterly different to hacking hand and foot holds in the rock. No respect here.

    • @raulsuarez5421
      @raulsuarez5421 Před 3 lety

      do you understand this was done in the 80's/90's and no one does it anymore? ..now, what? save the bees???

    • @braydonsmedley5652
      @braydonsmedley5652 Před 3 lety +1

      Yeah but we are judging the ethical decisions of someone in a totally different time period against the ethics of our time period. When Fred was climbing, manufacturing climbs was fairly common practice at the top of the grading scale. With the growth of climbing we have seen some things go by the wayside and be declared unethical, manufacturing climbs being one of them. I think that it is a great thing that we are growing as a community but why hate on people who were making the best decisions they knew how to make with the ethical standards and knowledge of their day. It doesnt make it right to chip holds and we certainly shouldn't be doing it now but we should extend some mercy to those who did these things simply based off the time period they lived in. They hadn't been taught better.

  • @jok5931
    @jok5931 Před 2 lety

    Arretez d'enlever les moves de clip... c'est ridicule