Physicist Breaks Down The Science Of 10 Iconic Marvel Scenes | How Real Is It? | Insider
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 05. 2019
- To celebrate the release of “Avengers: Endgame,” we had physicist (and lifelong comic book fan) Jim Kakalios take a closer look at the physics of the Marvel universe. Here he reacts to 10 memorable scenes from Marvel movies and rates them based on their accuracy. Find out what exactly quantum mechanics, time dilation, Einstein’s theory of special relativity, and spider silk tell us about the superheroes of the Marvel franchise.
Which weapon would you rather have in a fight: Thor’s Mjolnir hammer or Captain America’s shield? Hint: The answer has to do with the conservation of energy - and the sonoluminescence of vibranium. Dr. Kakalios breaks down the physics behind this and many other Marvel phenomena, including Shuri’s holographic car in “Black Panther;” Peter Parker’s spider-webbing train save in “Spider-Man 2;” the multiverse theory of “Doctor Strange;” the role of Pym particles and the Higgs boson in “Ant-Man;” artificial gravity in “Guardians of the Galaxy;” and Tony Stark’s cybernetic helmet and gold-titanium exoskeleton in “Iron Man.” He sheds light on why Carol Danvers doesn’t age from “Captain Marvel” to “Avengers: Endgame;” why the Space Stone is so powerful when yielded by Thanos in “Avengers: Infinity War;” and what’s with all the talk of quantum entanglement, quantum tunneling, and “quantum mumbo-jumbo” in “Ant-Man and the Wasp.”
Kakalios is the author of three books - “The Physics of Superheroes,” “The Physics of Everyday Things,” and “The Amazing Story of Quantum Mechanics.” He was a science consultant for Sony’s 2012 film “The Amazing Spider-Man.” Before that, he won an Emmy for his work as a science consultant for the Warner Bros. superhero film “Watchmen.” A physics professor at the University of Minnesota, Kakalios teaches a popular class that uses comic books to illustrate the principles of physics.
For more, visit:
www.amazon.com/Physics-Everyd...
www.amazon.com/Physics-Superh...
WATCH MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
Crocodile Wrangler Rates 12 Crocodile And Alligator Attacks In Movies And TV | How Real Is It?
• Crocodile Wrangler Rat...
Afghan War Veteran Rates 9 Afghanistan War Battles In Movies
• Afghan War Veteran Rat...
Military Experts Rate 70 Military Battles In Movies And TV
• Military Experts Rate ...
------------------------------------------------------
#Marvel #Science #INSIDER
INSIDER is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.
Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com | How Real Is It?
INSIDER on Facebook: insder.co/2NyYczE
INSIDER on Instagram: insder.co/2xN5qFB
INSIDER on Twitter: insder.co/2xyN5wE
INSIDER on Snapchat: insder.co/2KJLtVo
INSIDER on Amazon Prime: insder.co/PrimeVideo
INSIDER on Dailymotion: insder.co/2vmKnZv
Physicist Breaks Down The Science Of 10 Iconic Marvel Scenes - Zábava
Doesn’t use complicated words, loves comics & movies, a university professor
This is rare
YEAH
yea hes not toxic like other dudes
By far the coolest professor iv’e ever seen. 🔥
this isint rare this is a 1,000,000 in 7,000,000,000 droprate
@@masao2922 no its 1 in 7.5 trillon
I’m glad the professor wasnt just saying “this just a movie” LIKE he’s an actual fan and has seen the movies!! Big ups to this prof!
Ralph Dizon He’s been using superheroes in his lectures for decades and wrote books about them and comic book authors have consulted him. He’s a true fan.
He clearly show a book he made about superheroes from the start
He has a fantastic four tie on
hes been a comic book fan since he was a kid(back in the 60s), he says this in his book.
@@MildMisanthropeMaybeMassive Can you tell me about his creations, please? I would love to add his books to my collections.
Scott Lang, "Do you just put the word 'quantum' infront of everything?"
Real life scientist, "Yes. Yes, we do."
That was genuinely what I waited for Fishburn or Douglas to say. I was sad they didn't.
Who was the real life scientist? I certainly didn’t hear that here.
@@profile2047 well idk the professor her?
I can almost see Fishburnes' eyebrows slightly raised as if a bit surprised by the question, as he nods his head and says "yes", then turning to Douglas, who's also nodding(with a shrug and no eye contact).
Definitely a missed opportunity....on a quantum level.
I'll be honest, I would happily watch videos of him reacting to movies. You can tell that he loves movies (especially Marvel movies), he's a great teacher and I can tell he would have a blast explaining it all.
Imagine failing a physics class and then seeing your professor giving an 8 out of 10 to a superhero movie for realism
scientifically realistic
is that bad or something?😂
Well he's more grading the realistic sciences that they reference rather than what is capable now.
No he is talking about scientific realism not humanistic like the time of Renaissance
Imagine being so salty your professor failed you accidentally prove he made the right call.
Drax: *Stands so still that he becomes invisible to the naked eye*
Professor: 'This is completely physically plausible.'
Rating: 10/10
Thats me in high school LOL
drax is op 😂😂😂🤣
It's funny tho because he has such a hard time seeing stationnary things, colors and other stuff like that so it makes sense that he wouldnt be able to see himself if he were to be perfectly immobile.
But nobody can explain his contender JOHN CENA
Well. If her was perfectly stationary the brain would be less able to see him. Not invisbility. Just being less noticable.
He’s so clearly invested in the comics and the movies but is also a brilliant physicist and has a great sense of humour
Love it
I actually read his book years ago. I used it to get one of my co-workers into physics who didn't happen to be much of a reader and even he said he was super intrigued.
What you're seeing in this clip is the same way he's explaining everything in his book. He just goes into more detail. But the general gist is the same - he's using heroes and their powers as reference points and then explains concepts of physics this way. I'd recommend it wholeheartedly; if you liked this clip, go and check out his book. 🙂
name?
@@nuskyahmad6375 I believe it's "The Physics of Superheroes" or something along those lines. But look for the author, you should easily find it.
fish
He's more than just a physicist, he clearly is a Marvel fan also. Shout out to this guy.
"just a physicist"...
You don't get that often
Something about him in the thumbnail pleasantly reminds me of a case manager who helped me through community college
True virgin.
Same. I love this guy
I love the fact that he knows what he's talking about and understands the movies
TheReal Doge yeah I thought he was going to be talking about how unrealistic and stupid the movies are but he actually likes them 😂
@@yorktown2541 im sure those comics were a part of his choice to become a scientist
I hate the doge memes with the fires of a thousand suns
We love a physicist who loves marvel
TheReal Doge tbf he did write a book on it
0:33 First Clip: Guardian of Galaxy 3/10
2:11 Second Clip: Avengers 8/10
3:25 Third Clip: Iron Man 9/10
6:11 Fourth Clip: Ant-Man 4/10
7:40 Fifth Clip: "Spiderman 2" 8/10
8:55 Sixth Clip: Dr Strange 3/10
10:37 Seventh Clip: The Avengers 7/10
12:15 Eight Clip: Ant man & the wasp 2/10
13:47 Ninth Clip: Black Panther 5/10
15:45 Tenth Clip: Avengers Endgame 9/10
Thank you😁😁
Love this guy's charisma, you can tell he's passionate about the topics he's discussing. Would like to see a part 2.
*elevator breaks and is quickly falling to the ground*
Me: *wAnNa SeE a MaGiC tRiCk*
Better than doing nothing before you die
Actually so funny dude
I’m dead 😂😂
Actually there's a braking mechanism in every elevator, and ever since its invention no one had ever died of falling elevator,so you could now perform the trick with no fear :)))
Ebit Lagger shut up nerd 🤓🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
Everyone here can respect this man for that Fantastic Four tie that he wore. He was really looking forward to this.
He's been waiting this moment for his whole life lol
boys, we found him
You again
I can tell he’s kinda nerding out
A comment from Just Some Guy without a Mustache without more than 1k likes??? Reality can be often disappointing.
One thing I think he got wrong is the part in Black Panther at 14:34. He mentions Shuri using a hard light hologram to control the car, but that's not what it is. The solid parts Shuri is interacting with come from a pool of sand like vibranium that can take the form of solid objects, and a hologram of the car itself forms around the physical components. I think they actually do refer to it as a vibranium sand table or something similar at some point in the movie.
Wrong time
Yeah, all the hard points are actual physical objects.
It’s essentially a driving simulator rig, but with a hologram that I don’t think is purely there to give the driver a quick idea of where the vehicle’s corners would extend in the real-world environment.
Dude is super forgiving with his ratings as compared to other experts they brought in. Kinda interesting that it's the science/mathematics people that are more open & optimistic of the fantastic elements in film.
physics will be so much more interesting if our professors gave examples like these.......
Just correct
When any science can be linked to our phisical world that science become interesting. It doesn't matter if it's Literature or Social Studies. But it needs to be interesting if don't nobody will remember it.
My professor always uses Star Wars
Thats because majority of all our chools are old school :/
@@danieltodorovic3879 its a bummer
The fact that Spider-Man 2's train scene is somewhat accurate makes me feel so happy
I'm amazed that he didn't mention that spiderman would've been torn apart by the force
@@FlaminChicken231 I think he just wanted to tell us how awesomely strong spider web is
@@wellshit9489 yeah thats true
@@FlaminChicken231 I guess you are forgetting the part where he has spiders tensile strength which let's him fight big villans so easily and throw a punch so hard
In reality he just would have pulled a bunch of bricks out of the buildings and the train would have lost almost no velocity. That's always the problem with superheroes. Hulk can grab two continents and smash them together? Why not just two handfulls of rock or dirt. Superman (DC) can stop crashing planes/rockets/etc by grabbing them without just punching a hole in them?
Damn, I always deduced that Carol Denvers was just a very well preserved 50 year old, consequence of her powers maybe, but this time dilation explanation makes perfect sense.
I can tell that whoever did the editing for this video had a lot of fun haha.
The smile on his face when he's explaining all of it is just precious.
"The world could always use more heroes"
- time traveler lesbian sonic
Um, of course he is. More people than ever are now showing an interest in physics!
Renato Cunha, every. anime. ever.
3k likes and 3 comments, but im gonna break it.
@@aevajjae sad, innit?
You could tell he likes physics, but LOVES marvel
Totally. We love Marvel and superheroes
Fr
Win Bolton He loves both
you can already tell by his tie
@@Sciencationelle except me lol
You seldom see this combination in a person but it definitely makes sense. To analyze superheroes movies as how they relate to realistic science I think would end up a pyrrhic victory but I feel he directed his focus to the wins even when they proved totally fictional giving rooms for lots of "COULD" and "IMPROBABILITY".
Overall, I like his enthusiasms and truthfulness, the glow in his eyes are something to take away. And how he analyses concept that you wouldn't even pay attention to like Loki's attempt on Thanos's life linking it back to the use of the tessaract in the first avenger is superb. It tells me, Man knows his onions.
I would be much delighted if they can manage to find a magician to breakdown Dr Strange's movie
“He’s shooting out of his wrists which is not where a real spider would shoot it out of”
The most underrated line
*Tom Holland proceeds to poop out web fluid*
@@j_rod3131 *Andrew Garfield proceeds to vomit web fluid*
@@iaminevitable3495 i missed the part where that’s my problem
@@BullyGarfield. venom :i missed the part where its my problems
Ah I love how innocent the first two replies are
Imagine being in a life death situation in an elevator and going like “pick a card, any card!”
Pretty sure it’s just death if you have time for one of those haha
Jonathan Burns depends on how far you’re falling... about 5-8 floors is the limit on luck for surviving though...
Just jump when the elevator about to land😂
*Picks the death tarot*
@@johnuzoka6229 No, you'll hit the ground as hard as you were falling..
It's best to lie down on your back with your hands covering the back of your head, spread your legs apart and pray for deliverance..
This professor is GREAT. Smart, informative, and with a sense of humor!! I've always been interested in physics and quantum mechanics, but my math skills SUCK. If I had a teacher that could have made it this interesting I might have become an engineer!!! GREAT guest!!!
i love how he is very well versed in both physics and Marvel, and could also explain how real the clips from the movies are
Imagine you falling in an elevator getting ready for a tragic death and the guy next to you just says:
Hey look at this pipe
That’s the type of outlook on life that I need😂
i would be this guy
That’s exactly what I was thinking when he said that
‘hey VSauce, Micheal here, look at this pipe’
Ceci n’est pas une pipe.
This professor:
- a veteran physicist
- could explain everything complex into simple words
- a marvel fan
- also, a comic book writer
you forgot the "he has a cool Fantastic Four tie" part...
You missed
-chad
AND A MINECRAF PLAYER (probably because he mentioned mumbo jumbo)
well at least knows minecraft
@@bhomikjain6040 where did he mention the simple redstone guy
Sounds a little bit like Sheldon 🤔
I love _how many references this guy is dropping._ I grinned like an idiot at 11:10 - "when Captain America throws his mighty shield."
i like the way he explains it, like it’s less of big words he tries to put it in the simplest form
I love how this physicist talks with 100% accuracy on both physics theories and MCU lore. He does a better job of getting these details right than most CZcams “critics.”
He needs to dumb it down for the audience (at least the physics )
Márcio Amaral Uh not really. He could easily do it without knowing so much about Marvel. He’s just a huge, adorable Marvel fan
@@AlexM-mj3sq
Well, as long as he's huge.
That's why they pay him the big bucks lol
@@AlexM-mj3sq "Not really" ?
I'm an engineering major and trust me, he really dumbed it down to make it easier for the audience.
Take any serious physics book and try to understand the phenomena he explained from it and you'll see why I wrote that.
This guy can kill Thanos with his Quantum knowledge.
*dies*
@Marcel Reiner 😂😂
Yep
I've been studying quantum mechanics as a hobbie since 2014 when I was 14 years old. it ALWAYS bothers me that I try to explain the physics behind some movies and my friends go "but the talking racoon is fine??" and I'm like CMON FORGET THE RACOON
Loved this man forgetting the racoon and focusing on the gravity on and off
Thank you
I'm gonna buy that book btw
To me it seemed that he found a talking racoon more plausible that artificial gravity. Which kind of says alot.
The talking raccoon is a cyborg, so ofcourse it's fine. Now onto the more pressing questions! Why is Gamora?
I wish that all teachers/professors could be like this gentleman. How much easier would be to learn under tutelage of a person like this! Especially for students struggling with a particular subject.
I liked how this guy didn't use too complicated words so us idiots could understand lol
His shield in the comics is an alloy of vibranium and proto-adamantium, not steel.... WHY HAS NO ONE COMMENTED ON THIS???
Facts LOL
@@nahor88 he used steel cause we don't know what proto-adamantium steel is
LMAOOOO you just made my day HAHAHA
@@nahor88 in some comics it's steel, while in others it's adamantium
I like how he is not a random guy but he actually likes the movies 😂
how is he "not a random guy". He certainly is to you and me, no?
He means he is not any old physicist but one that rlly likes marvel
He had to enjoy these movies, or else he wouldn’t let himself watch them.
Actually likes movies? As in its unusual to like movies?
@@Kakyyoin he also knows a lot about the comics ...so yeah he is not random
It's a weird feeling when a physics professor tells you that sure, cybernetic helmet, no problem.
Beyond that; this video is adorable.
You can tell he's both a physics and a Marvel fan: he doesn't try to find "hey, that'll never work stuff", but to find a way to explain how something might work.
Which is exactly how invention works: looking at an impossible idea and going, "well, for that to be _possible_ , you would need ..."
"I dont know if I can do this but someone shuri can"! I see what you did there, well done! I really like this guy. He has that tipical aura of cultivated/well educated people, a big Marvel nerd and obviously a great teacher. Looking forward for more fun stuff.
He's not just a physicist..
He's a *TRUE MARVEL FAN*
The way he speaks and explains is from the inside of his heart...
Aswin i mean come on just look at his tie
@@proximitive3872 oh. I didn't notice. Thanks for sharing mate
Yeah, I have his book on science of superheroes. Beyond physics he spends a lot of time talking about the comics history. Really nice!
You're not even close to wrong. It's a little weird to explain, but there are plenty of little moments and details that he references or brings up that most experts who don't really love Marvel, or just sorta watch the odd one when it comes out, wouldn't pick up on, or forget, or whatever. It's something that irks me, as a super-attentive moviegoer, when I watch some of these 'experts break down' videos. This guy? Not even once. Every time I thought to myself, 'ugh, of course he's not gonna bring up that', he freaking next thing he said was addressing it.
He had a big smile on his face the whole time.
*little did they know, drax was in every scene, standing very still*
😂
Try explaining THAT teacher
It is well known that the speed of light, constant in all reference frames, is the absolute maximum speed. Less well known is the speed of Drax, also constant in all reference frames, the absolute minimum speed.
Y E E T
@@Lashb1ade took you long enough
I was under the impression that Shuri was using something more along the lines of a volumetric display rather than a hologram.
00:05 seconds in- Already love him.
this man should break down the physics behind bollywood movies
😂
🤣🤣🤣 Yes
Do you wanna give a heart attack to this really sweet man???
It is already broken my great bollywood movie creators.🤣🤣...they are far ahead
😭😂😂😂🤣🤣
This professor needs a CZcams channel to keep teaching us physics through marvel movies 🤩👌
Definitely. This was really fun.
I'd subscribe for sure!
He has one im not sure what its called
there is a simillar thing with a channel called flim theory he doesnt use just physics though he uses other branches of science
@@orchidvity4748 yeah, FilmTheory is awesome :)
I think I recall reading his book or a variation of it. What always stood out to me from the book I read was the note that speedsters like Flash and Quicksilver would need to be nearly indestructible or wrap themselves in some sort of force field when moving or the dust particulates in the air would hit with enough force when they ran to rip them apart.
I love his attitude! Presents the science is a funny and engaging way and still have the fun attitude to comment and accept the movie 'magic'. Love this clip!
He's my professor from my freshman physics course! You can bet he went out of his way to use superhero examples whenever he could in both lectures and exams.
Lucky you
r/thathappened
@@reptilefan1115 god shut up
@@reptilefan1115 true
Erik Husby well you can tell him he was off with the iron man one, a few years back a researcher (woman) made a gold titanium variant, that was I believe 200,000 psi .
Artificial Gravity = questionable
Talking Raccoon = believable
I love this guy
XD
Well the “genetic and cybernetics enhancements” that made him could be possible giving enough research
genetic engineering is farther along that gravity physics
Genetically engineered catgirls are real.
@@apolloniuspergus9295 Elon Musk is trully Tony Stark of our worldline but with catgirls instead of AI controlled suits.
Well, if you think about it, there is an infinite number of planets in the universe. A raccoon like intelligent alien could have evolved somewhere. So, at this very moment, in a distant planet or even galaxy, there is a talking raccoon.
Of the Insider rating film scenes, this is definitely a favorite of mine. I taught physics to gifted students, so it's a subject close to my heart, and brain. It helps that this gentleman happens to be brilliant, with a wonderful, warm sense of humor. I've got to add his book about the physics of superhero movies to my reading list!
Big thumbs up!!!!
This is awesome! Finally an explanation about the physics in super hero movies/comics that is fun to watch and actually makes us learn a lot about physics itself!!
Is nobody going to talk about his Fantastic Four tie? Just gotta love this guy. Physics professor and Superhero movie fan.
Oh I was about to. That tie is...fantastic.
Yeah, you have to love him... until he goes through an equation derivation on one slide in 10 seconds. Then I'd say he's not as great haha.
What if he became a Physics professor just so he can prove and back up every question there is to every superhero character... 🙌🏼💯
Fr dude, I love this guy.
sirtanon1 sheldon cooper
still dont know why is gamora
a guy of randomness 😹
Lol
Aariz A.X.I p
P
Oo
Ppop
Because Gamora
*An intelligent person knows how to breakdown complicated things to be understandable to everyone no matter their level.*
I like how he's giving out references instead of just explaining the physics part and moving on
I wish I had a professor like this lol
i love how this guy is actually a marvel (or at least a comic) fan. respect ma man!
Aren't all the nerds? Try big bang theory for reference !!
@@azar6835 I really wish I had knowledge on anything as much as this guy bruh !!I would've proudly joined the nerd's club. Sadly I don't have. But yeah I know a thing or two about comic books for sure.
Prateek Majhee I hate the big bang theory. So corny.
@@pnut3844able your choice !! Your opinion !! None of my deal !! Peace out.
@@prateekmajhee5706 Someone humble for once FINALLY
"but he's the master of the mystic arts, so i'll give him a break"...3/10
he really is a physics professor
Bruh
You cant rate a magic movie high for how scienifically accurate it is
@@reptilesceptile1035 He's not rating the magic stuff, he's rating its consequences, which are ultimately bound by physics.
@@Sriram-ek5el yeah, but the means are magic.
@@reptilesceptile1035 Yes, but it is being used in reality and reality is bound by the laws of physics. And these laws imply that there are consequences. One can still question the magic as in what kind of direct and indirect effects it has on reality.
For example, using Avada Kedavra spell in Harry Potter universe kills someone. You need not question how it does that (magic), but you can ask exactly what part of the body it effects to kill the person. Like, does it stop the neurological function, the heart, or something else?
There can be a lot of questions to be asked like this despite the nature of magic, but I hope that conveys my point.
The fact that he's a Marvel fan makes this so entertaining to watch. How he's smiling while he's explaining everything and I mean the Fantastic Four tie.
Best university professor ever. I'm definitely going to be checking out his book.
I loved the video so much, thank you for the content !
Professor: He's the master of the mystic arts, so I'll give him a break.
Also Professor: **3/10**
Yeah, he definitely teaches at a college.
lolllll
otherwise he would have given 0 or 1 points :P
You had better give him a break or he might pull some mystic prank on you. Like having the elevator car you're in break out of the shaft and start zooming around through downtown traffic without your control upon it.
@SennaFan Wow. Who hurt you, baby boy?
And judging by your grammar you didn't make it through middle school, so I'm not sure you should be the one talking.
@SennaFan Because you don't have the foresight to proofread, yet you have the nerve to randomly loose your premature "mommy didn't love me enough" anger on total strangers who were having a pleasant conversation about a joke?
Because you actually tried to insinuate you're more intelligent than someone else you've never met and couldn't spell your words right or form a complete sentence?
As if your attitude means we should bow down to your delusions. Ha.
Sorry dude, but I didn't change anything. Nobody won here. You came into this thread a loser already, as evident by your hostility. Your insults were baseless because neither you nor I have the potential nor need to prove them, so there's no need to give them any merit.
Bye.
Since noone else is gonna mention it I will:
His tie is awsome!
Ikr
its fantastic
His tie is too glorious for our eyes
@@sinsaydarylg.9165 i see what you did there
@@celtic5505 ey you saw it
I love how much of a need he is and it makes me genuinely happy
I’ve always been fascinated with anything related to space and time travel. Thank you for sharing the reality of it Professor!
"Your friendly neighborhood phisyc professor" and " face front, true believers" almost made me tear a bit.
Yea he is the best professor ever,wish he had more subs too
Just needed an "Excellsior!" in there.
"Friendly neighborhood physics professor" lol I love him! He's really a fan
Shout out to our real Spidey homie TOBEY MACGUIRE
Use shaders in Minecraft!!!!!😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😃😃😃😃😃😃
He is being honest thts all not a fan though
Any physicist could have been shown scenes and then be asked to discuss them from a scientific standpoint. However, I think we all agree this guy genuinely knows his Marvel movies and characters. It was great to watch such a well rounded guy give this lecture.
I would love it to have him as my physics teacher/professor.... simple explanations, very pleseant personality and voice and on top of that: an obvious marvel and/or dc fan :D
This dude will have an heart attack if he was to break down science scenes in Bollywood movies
🤣
Damn right😂
Omg bro 🤣🤣🤣
*a heart attack
an aneurism
*Talking Raccoon*
Scientist:That's totally normal
he probably gets email from one
His voice would sound a little wonky because of his jaw shape, but other than that, totally realistic.
"Eh, not my field. The medical students can complain about him."
I mean, he IS a physicist, so he doesn't care about medical shit.
Awohali Uhyoha talking raccoon > god of lightning
All the experts these breakdown videos have chosen are great, but this guy is FANTASTIC!
Well explained and super edit😍😍
What I expected: "The MCU is wrong because X, Y, Z."
What I got: "It's not too far off really."
well, most examples except for the one of Dr. Strange were not too fancy or far from science...
@@Leotique far from logic tho
@Looney Mar It's one of those universes where there's a bunch of science that doesn't exist in real life, but for the science that does, it works analogously to real life.
@@tomfoolery4490 I was speaking of plot twists and characters, not science
@@looneymar9153 we're here for the science part, not the logic & characters, tho, so your comment is irrelevent.
He looked so proud after his 'Shuri' pun 😭😩
lol
What was the pun?
@@lynxb8300 "Someone Shuri-ly will"
He was trying so hard not to laugh.
He “Shuri-ly” did
This was an awesome presentation! I like it even more than my old book "The Physics of Star Trek"!
Amazing video and this was so interesting to watch and enjoy today :]
Me: "That's unrealistic."
Jim Kakalios: "That could happen."
Me: "That could happen. Only a moron would think otherwise."
Me
Well, the glass of water standing on a table could spontaneously start boiling.
That is possible. Physics allows that. Though probability of that event is so small, it is considered impossible.
Pretty much same thing goes about pseudoscience they put into comic books. Something with a similar name is possible. But absolutely not what is shown in the cartoon.
So despite "that could happen", no, it is not realistic.
Iron Man got 9/10?
_Quick, let's make Iron Man real just in case robots revolted againts us_
Zuzu *brings cheeseburgers* LETS GET IT!!!!!!!
It would be a dream to see Robert Downey Jr. In his mark 50 suit in real life ♥♥♥
Look up Hacksmiths, he made a complete Iron Man helmet
Yeah, have you seen there are actual guys building his suit and helmet. His movement when he first created the iron man suit and was trying to pilot it are also very accurate in that regard.
you should look up Richard Browning who built a jet suit.
love this, him being a big fan makes this so much better.
Would love to hear him talk about the possibilities/impossibilities of time travel
I never had so much fun listening to someone talk about physics
Your profile picture matches your comment.
you've had bad physics teachers then😶
Physics is fun if you understand it. U cant blame anything for the lack of knowledge u have for it
@@rollxrsmash3591 any subject can be fun if the teacher makes it fun.
And you can blame the lack of knowledge for boredom.
Thats cause all he did was talk about it, if he started bringing in the math, equations, and assumptions that physicists often require, it would probably be several lectures long
So according to him, the MCU is more realistic than I imagined it to be. This is kind of a first.
yeah he must be a real fan because he was really generous, like in ant man, the fact that it shrinks without altering the mass or that he ahrinks below an atom's sizedeserves a 1, and the 3 nuclear power plants are no better than a 3, being realistic, only spiderman and the last one go avobe 5
but hey, im biased because ive never seen any of these movies, the plot may be fantastic, but not the physics
Alejandro Zarzuelo i mean it is from comics tho and the original source material is really unrealistic but they try to add explainations for the movies so i do appreciate them doing that
He only analyzed a few things. He gave most of them low scores. And overall, he was extremely generous.
Lol , no its not
@@Azknowledgethirsty how'd u come here?
I... would never have guessed the Spiderman train-stopping scene was plausible.
Spiders are freaking badass.
@9.56 when he mentions the parallel universes possibility for Dr Strange - he was way ahead of the curve. Not only in Marvel films but clearly in fashion as well. What a legend. Wonder what he makes of modern day MCU
So he’s basically a comic nerd, a very smart one lol
7:46 and I love this bit xD
best part lol
The Big Bang Theory but real.
@Demarcus Liggernips what do you mean humorless bazinga is the funniest ever 😬😬😬
i love his facial expressions when he starts talking about iron man
Can't blame him, Iron Man 1 slaps so hard.
I love iron man 1 3000
It matches with mine when I talk about any iron man movie
My #1 most absolute favorite video ever. As a comic nerd, this was the best
Thank you for this vid! I love your book!
Mad respect for you putting my boy Tobey Maguire saving the train.
He sure has grown
How much would the fans squee if there was a live action spider-verse film and Tobey's Spiderman shows up.
I love how much this man loves comics. It hurts my heart when experts sneer at fiction or are overly cynical (we get it, we know it's fantasy too). But the fact he's a renowned physicist and a huge nerdy fan is Grade A in my book!
Yup, he's pure awesomeness personified! I wouldn't bunk so many physics classes in college if he was my professor, that's for sure! I'm pretty sure he makes physics lectures pretty entertaining...
I’ve actually taken his class many many years ago! He’s a delight!
I wouldn't consider marvel movies nerdy as they are very mainstream.
@@TheAgentOfDeath He mentioned he read comics as a kid though. That was considered nerdy then and probably is now.
@@TheAgentOfDeath Marvel is mainstream NOW, when this guy was reading comics, it was still, "shove into lockers" material. Also they're still nerdy, it's just that being a nerd is mainstream now. Regular people finally figuring out something is cool doesn't make it less nerdy.
This has been one of the most charismatic clips so far! The Professor is a chad.
Thanks for all the in-depth ℹ️nfomation mate! 👏🏾👍🏾 I’ll take Ghost powers but wish they would’ve cleaned up the explanation of her powers
I really appreciate an expert who doesn’t immediately say it’s impossible, as so many analyzing comic book movies do; instead we finally have someone looking for how it could be possible, so thank you for that.
Dude just about had a minor epiphany when second guessing how Shuri could theoretically create a hardlight hologram using vibranium soundwaves.
Science is not really about proving what is correct but figuring out what isn't.
@@xXEienKageXx wym?
@@rodvincent yea exactly. like we dont know what is possible but we know what isn't.
yeh and is full of mistakes
"He would need a long extension cord from the suit"
Tony, get in the Eva
funny.. that's the first thing that stood out for me when I watched Evangelion. Mech suits that actually have to drag cables behind them that destroy stuff in their wake!
Dammit I was thinking the same thing 😂😂
Your dad loves you GET IN THE ROBOT!!!!
i so wanted to see this comment!
Evangelion classic
I love this guy's expressions when he's talking about iron man
22 seconds in, I'm like I love this dude, his tie, and his energy!!
marvel seeing this: Write that down write that down
Haha Marvel go boop
Underrated comment😂
Lol. Accurate.
@@AJ-xd7me i love charles the french
Yeah XDZS
Is he really a comic book nerd as well? He has to be the best professor ever.
Actually, most scientists are massive nerds.
@@sophiejones7727 And that's good.
@@voldy3565 yes it is :) mostly.
Maybe only for the science? To study how the comics use physics😂
Judging by how he said he oftenly see that 'spiderman-grunting-stopping-the-train-face' in class, his students probably don't agree.
Wish i had this Professor in my college.. Great job ❤️
Great job Doc! Appreciate your passion and profession!