"Opposition Clueless on Hindutva Since 2014" I Modi, Rahul & The Future of India's Muslims | Barkha
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 27. 07. 2024
- The Supreme Court today delivered a critical judgment on the rights of Muslim Women to Alimony ending decades of political debate around what has come to be known as the Shah Bano case. The Judges made it clear that a Muslim woman, just like any woman from any religion, can apply for maintenance under Section 125 of the CrPc. The court rejected an appeal by a Muslim man from Telangana who did not want to pay his divorced wife monthly alimony. Amid this big verdict, which will invariably open the doors for a new debate on a Uniform Civil Code, we speak to Hilal Ahmed, political researcher and scholar who has just published an important new book - A Brief History of the Present, Muslims in New India
#Muslims #Supreme Court #modi
Become A Mojo Story Member Nowđ / @mojostory
Welcome to Mojo Story, where storytelling meets truth-telling in its purest form. Led by renowned journalist Barkha Dutt, we're dedicated to bringing you narratives that transcend time and format.
From succinct 60-word snippets to immersive videos spanning up to 60 minutes, we explore the spectrum of human experiences and current events through a lens that prioritizes authenticity and integrity. In a world divided by polarization, we stand firm as a beacon of non-partisanship, refusing to be swayed by agendas or affiliations.
Here, you'll find content that goes beyond the noise, beyond the rhetoric, and beyond the confines of bias. We're neither 'Chamcha' nor 'Morcha'-we're advocates for the truth, champions of #PeopleFirst storytelling.
Join us on this journey as we navigate the complexities of our world with curiosity, compassion, and an unwavering commitment to the facts. Subscribe now and become part of a community that values truth above all else. Welcome to a space where every story matters, and where the voices of the unheard are amplified.
Subscribe to us for more updates:
Follow us on Twitter: / themojostory
Like us on Facebook: / themojostory
Instagram: / mojostory.in
Disclaimer: The views of guests who appear on Mojo Story, as well as the views of interviewees or speeches by public figures or those in the news, are their personal opinions. At no point do they reflect the views of the organization.
Why can't you understand that india is a hindu majority country we have learnt from your past mistakes
5:19 Pakistan isn't a country it's a mindset
Modi/BJP has not got even 100 Muslim votes all India put together.
BJP was singled out
This headline is suitably titled. The problem is we cant be whites ,europeans even if we speak in the best of english(a language hardly 800-900 years old).Please watch the latest series 'Under the bridge'.
Neither can we be central asians ,arabs ,chinese .
What are we then ..Lets accept our soil,our languages,our clothing,culture. We can be atheists but the culture is vedic or sanatan
We are zimmi hindu . White Christianism nearly Annihilated native population of colony.now they are give token money to native population. But in India minority Muslim toture majority Sanatani for long time and divided this land . Coconut đ„„ like Burkha thing we are white Christianism. Pathetic
Appeasement vote bank politics must stop, country is already divided based on religion for 75 years.
Yes but the other narrative is also appeasement.. for the elite .. it's the war between appeasements bruh
@@rahulsen002 "the other narrative" ..is about giving dignity back..to the civilizational foundation of India that is Bharat
@@stallionspirit1576 we always had the dignity.. nothing to give back .. we have the patriotism and humanity in our heart .. education helps you appreciate it .. without it one won't find the diamond engraved in our heart.. permanently.. nobody can snatch it from us .. hope you will discover it someday .. and be above the identity crisis.. education is healing man ..
@@rahulsen002 we had so much dignity..we let pappus say in court..that ram is a myth..your colonially brainwashed education is quite clear..no wonder...west bengal is turning into west bangladesh..lol
@@rahulsen002 we had so much dignity..we let pap''''pus say in court..that ram is a myth..yo'''ur colo''''nially brainwa'''''shed edu''''cation is quite clear..no wonder...west bengal is turning into west bangladesh..lol
Human rights apply to Muslim women too. Meher is not given to Muslim women in Kerala. The men get dowry from the Muslim men
When muslims take all the benefits given by BJP but never vote for them, what is it called? Who is being communal in mindset? Congress and rest of so called secular parties overtly seek muslims votes and yet they are called secular! what type of argument is this?
There are people who are obsessed with different things in life like money , lust , fame .violence etc But barkha is obsessed with Muslims
Very confusing for me.. I couldn't conclude wat exactly is he saying.
Reservation in private sector is a problematic proposal as private sector cannot be forced to do social reform. Some private players may start voluntarily in their organization but a law which mandates such thing id gonna lead to flight of capiral
21:30 Barkha dutt speaks for the elites. It's not sufficient that the elites in the army have pluralism. Do the masses have pluralism ? Does Kashmiri Muslims have plurality in them ? Does Pakistan which is an agglomeration of indian muslims + access to power have plurality ? Does Owaisi have plurality ? If so why did he oppose the women's reservation bill ? And why won't muslim women in his constituency punish him for that ?
Why did Muslim women come out to protest against CAA but not against Sha Banu or against Owaisi for opposing the women's reservation bill ?
Entire Indian subcontinent enjoyed religious harmony - and shared a common heritage.
Let us get the things straight: the present judgement of the Apex court is not new: way back in 2001, the Supreme Court delivered similar judgement enabling Muslim divorced women to either to get maintenance under125 of the CrPC or, Muslims women's Act1986 according to her option. It is complementary right of divorced Muslim women. Either she can opt for 1986 Act or Section 125 of the CrPC. If she opts for maintenance under section 125 of CrPC,she can't remarry and if she had son above the age of 18, she can't opt for maintenance under Section 125 CrPC. If she opts for remedy under 1986 Act, she can get Mehar,and lumpsum amount. It is for the divorced Muslim women to take a call which makes economic sense as well as her financial needs.
However, Section 126 of the CrPC stipulates if she opts for maintenance in one of the Acts ,she can't avail remedy under the other . The Supreme Court has reiterated the earlier position of the same court laid down in 2001judgment.
Let us not politice the issue: it is the economics and financial needs of the divorced Muslim women.
The Punch line of Rahul Speach was when he said BJP/ RSS do not represent the Hindu religion. He fell short of saying that BJP & RSS represent a Polythistic Brahmin religion and not a Hindu religion. Each caste is a more significant Polytheistic religion in its own right, while the Hindu religion is not even a Polytheistic religion. The Hindutva of RSS is actually a Brahminvadi Polytheistic religion, which they like to call the Hindu religion. The Hindu religion came into existence during British rule. They encouraged it by clubbing all non-Abrahmic religions under the umbrella of the Hindu religion. They did it primarily for their administrative ease and not to support religion. That is why we do not find any King in History who called himself a Hindu King. Even Lord Ram was not known as a Hindu King. Nor do we find any reference to Hindu religion in any holy book of Sanatana Dharma. Be it Vedas, Upanishads, Bhagwat Gita or Ramayana. We do not see any temples from the pre-British era, known as Hindu temples. During British rule, the Brahmins started putting a Barat of Idols in all our temples to pocket the revenue and started calling it the Hindu temple. Hence, we had no followers of the Hindu religion between the Vedic times and the British era. We still vote for our caste / Polythistic religion. The founders of the nation were wise people in giving us a secular constitution and not a Hindu / Brahminvadi constitution, which the Brahmins of RSS want to create now.
Please ask Hilal - what type of Islam does he follow and as Hindutva - and Hinduism / can he classify Islam - also in the same
way , he will never do that . Any Muslim can insult Hindus and Hindu Religion but never Islam or Qaran -
đđ I am ok with reservations in Public sector but who in right mind ask for fully private organisation to follow reservationsâŠ..This will kill startup culture and small business (and only help corporates because no new startup emerges to challenge big corporatesâŠ.like Jio did to Idea and Reliance to many textile giants)âŠ.because all startupâs will be busy in following new License Qouta RajâŠCompanies are here to make profits and grow not do Public service and justice that is govt workâŠThis policy another way to escape politicians who canât answer why after 75 years they have not changed society and given good education and healthcare to backward castes
Bharat has always been PLURALUST- birthplace and safe haven of many religions! Foreign invaders changed that!
this fellow is crazy, reservations in private sector. even ambani will run away and this will become somalia!
It seems like that secularism is the main problem in India.
The moment you give reservation to Muslim and Christian dalits, entire SC&ST will be converted and India will become a Hindu minority country. Present reservation policy is keeping many converted SC&ST as Hindu, at least on record.
Reservation in private sector will kill enterprises for ever as merits will be over looked. Give reservations and financial assistance only in education. Thus we can provide opportunity and a level playing field to every section of society to uplift themselves. Jobs in any sector must on merit. This only will improve our productivity and help our nation scale the heights.
Shame! we are still discussing this in 2024.. please stop this nonsense
If Shias want to be safe, they should make deal with Hindus and start supporting bjp,
Muslims need to look within rather than blame everyone except themselves (which this man Halal is also doing). Voting like a hive, rather as thinking individuals, will never better their lot. Modi has done much more than any other PM to improve the condition of all poorâŠbut, Muslims would rather do Vote JihadâŠ
Totally, their fault.
Why canât India deal with Muslims the way China đšđł deals with Uighurs?
Becoz India believes...in..slow and steady wins the race
@@stallionspirit1576 what race? Do you mean the âHindu rate of growthâ ??
RAGA copy= Red book!
If I am an Intellectual ....My Job is to blindly oppose and spread hate against BJP
Why should affirmative action be seen through a religious lens. It should be based on upliftment of all downtrodden citizens. Itâs true that thereâs no point of talking about fastest growing economy when thereâs a mass of poor people living below acceptable levels.
dat mass of poor peopel..was kept poor...by decades of nehru/congress socialism...
Hilal Ahmed is brilliant. Again, thanks to Barkha for bringing his voice and thoughts to my living room.
brilliant??...how exactly?