Magic 5 Pro vs S23 Ultra - Speed, Battery & Thermal Tests
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 06. 2024
- Battery consumption, speed & thermal management are the main factors to identify which smartphone has the best chipset in 2023.
In this video I will compare the Snapdragon 8Gen2 in the Honor Magic 5 Pro vs Snapdragon 8Gen2 For Galaxy in the S23 Ultra to see which one has better performance & thermal management.
The test includes 4 heavy tasks that each flagship will run simultaneously for 30 minutes to see which one will survive and takes the win.
#magic5pro #s23ultra #honor #samsung #speedtest #batterytest #thermal #snapdragon8gen2
*Chapters*
0:00 - Intro
1:21 - Setting The Rules
1:56 - Test Preparation
2:14 - Ready, Steady, Go
5:27 - Final Conclusion
For Donations:
paypal.me/indepthtechreviews
Related Videos Playlist:
• Speed Test
Follow me on:
Facebook: / in-depth-tech-reviews-...
Twitter: / idtechreviews
Instagram: / indepthtechreviews
Amazon Affiliate Links:
Amazon US: amzn.to/3AOk4MB
Amazon UK: amzn.to/36uXJFM
Amazon UAE: amzn.to/3k9LLcv
Amazon Canada: amzn.to/3kg0aUy
Amazon Germany: amzn.to/3hZ4zbT - Věda a technologie
You need to run these tests on more phones, we can't rely on benchmarks only, good work
Planning for this
Yes I completely agree, this is what real life test means. My iPhone gets so hot during the day that many times is unusable but no one is pointing this during their reviews. It is a very powerful device no denying that but is lacking a cooling system and that is a major flaw in my opinion
Magic 5 pro battery is 5100ah and s23 u is 5000mah. That's a difference.
Yes this is the real life benchmark if you ask me 💪
@@mariuscristian2831 true, my friend's iphone gets too hot until he has to stop playing PUBG but another android phone can still go.. but no reviewer says this maybe because they are afraid Apple will no longer sponsor a review unit to them or money
This is literally the best channel when it comes to tech. You really deserve way more views, very scientific tests that mimic the real world usage.
We need them on more phones.
it.s arbic man
why he don't speak arbic in video
A similar test between iPad Pro and any top Android tablet would be interesting to watch 😎👏.
You have a unique way to test the performance of these devices.
Ipad pro vs tab s8 ultra
@@levipb1403s9
This is the perfect test for battery and chipset, other content creators just run some benchmarks and blurt out some stats and call it a day. This is how should be done thank you!
The temperature has to be measure on the screen as well. Also to know if the the heat is held inside just compare battery temperature, that way we'll know the heat dissipation capabilities of both. Otherwise glad to see someone doing that kind of tests!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts
Thank you for these tests .
I have not seen anyone doing this test yet Except you .
Thank you again and could you do this test using galaxy s23plus if you please
Make more videos like these with flagship mediatek processor also , great comparison BTW
Am grateful to how u deep dive to bring out all details
I appreciate all the effort put into this test. I didn't find better channel about in depth smartphones reviews.
That’s why we call him in-depth.
Keep the good job going..benchmark apps have been compromised.
U are how only hope
You should check the temperature by app because you see inside temperature
( game options ) for Samsung
Wow finally a "Real" Performance review. You got my subs
A really nice comparison. Thanks. Both are great phones and I can see that I didn't go wrong with the Honor Magic5 Pro.
Incredible test, good job 🎉
Subscribed!! Haven't seen actual phone reviews ever...
Could u consider looking into fold phones? This channel helped me immensely grabbing something budget for a gift
Thanks for the amazing comment, am currently reviewing the Honor Magic Vs a very food foldable
in the other test between 14PM and s23u and pixel, the s23 dimmed its display at 11 minutes. could it be due to the update?
Perfect job tnxx bro
great video. Thank you
You should have put a fps counter, maybe that will help more
very nice present. hard work. good information. thx for sharing
Could you run this test on poco f5?
Finally a real test excellent video
Does anyone know if there is any signal issues with magic pro in the US
Make more workload series man.. I really enjoyed. ❤
Can you please do the test on the new sony Xperia 1 v
Why is this the only video about the Magic 5 Pro!!
I needed a camera comparison so bad so I can recommend the phone safely🤦♂
1st Comment
Always Liked your Videos
🙏 From India
Thank you for making the most professional content. I enjoy watching your videos.
Brother what about the shared display quality 😢 the one on other side sees something else than what am see on my phone
Can you also do OnePlus 11 please
Excellent job brother
Very good working keep going
Magic 5 pro looks magnificent. The Samsung looks just like a phone😏
habibi! shokran!
Please s23 vs s23 plus test.
THANKS FOR THIS TEST WHILE I WAS FEELING BAD FOR IPHONE 7 WHEN IT STARTS LAGGING WHILE PLAYING ASHPLAT9 FOR AN HOUR
@In Depth Tech Reviews
I'm curious why S23 ultra performed worse than when it was competing with 14Pro max. It didn't dim the display like it did in this one. Have you figured out any reason for that? is s23 ultra gradually losing it's charm?
The workload he initiated in this round was way more tasking than the one one he used in the Ultra vs pro max/pixel video
لو انا هشتري واحد منهم ومحتار ما بينهم اختار مين في مصر
مين الانسب وشكراً
If the back of the phone is hotter ? Does it not mean that the s23U actually managed to decipate the heat better from the SoC to the chassis ?
Great Video btw ❤️
Or magic doesn't not get heatup at the first place it could be like this also l.al😂
@@prafullrahangdale666 not possible,heat dissipation is at fault in honor
That is a good question and we need more data for that, i.e. CPU and GPU temps which may be difficult. Difficult to be definitive. I would say that do not worry that the S23U was slightly hotter on the outside as Samsung are very good at thermal controls.
@@andyH_England i agree
Honor had much bigger heat sink. Vc cooling system i guess. Samsung’s is just it’s optimization. Both good in it’s way. But it’ll be better if both tech of cooling get merged
What is the max resolution of magic 5 pro. Can it go QHD?
2848x1312 460ppi
Why no full resolution? 😮
Isn't the ultra running in 2k resolution???
Curious to know the resolution of majic 5 pro ??
Both are on FHD+ as shown at the beginning
فنان ياباشا الى الامام تستاهل لايك
I like this kind of video.. test other phone too
Free magic 5 pro thanks 😍😍😍
Watching from Jamaica and love your channel and test you perform. S23 ultra is still amazing. Keep up the great and unbiased work.
Tough opponent🤯
Waiting for the S23U and iPhone 15 pro max comparison
Please do compare S23 6.1" with Redmagic 8 pro (Inbuilt cooling Fan)
the red magic 8 pro will eat the samsung for breakfast, lunch and dinner
@@CZcams-Censorship-Police ok
Next with rog 7 ultimate please
مقارنة عظمه 😍❤️🩹
الحين منو الافضل في البطارية مافهمت المقطع
@@mowaly64
الأتنين اعجوا نفس النسبة بس احسن بطارية حاليا هو الs23ultra و هو مش اسوء سرعة شحن موجوده ومش افضل بس هونر احسن بس عموما لسه الs23ultra مميز عن باقي الجولات يعني.
@@AhmedIbrahim_ يعني منو الي يصمد بالشحن بالساعات هونر ولا الترا 23
@@mowaly64
الاتنين حلوين بس الs23ultra شوية احسن بالنسبه للبطارية و كا جهاز فا هو افضل.
من افضل جوال حاليا حسب معرفتك هواوي ميت 50 برو او هواوي بي 60 برو او هونر ماجك 5 برو او ايفون 14 برو ماكس او جلكسي اس 23 الترا محتار بينهم كثير اتمنى تفيدني
I think why the phone lowers the screen brightness because there is no activity on the screen, I'm sure if the game is actually played lowering the brightness won't happen unless the battery is low!!
Why is the screen gray on the s23 ultra 🙄
Usa para la prueba el genshin impact qué es más exigente qué el asphalt 9
Yes, this test makes more sense. The last test was a new 2023 phone versus last years and was setup to make the S23U look good. Tests should always be fair and the S23U has the latest 2023 specs that make a massive difference, and these include:
1/ X70 modem, more efficient.
2/ Latest Samsung display with 16% less power draw.
3/ Latest LPDDR5X RAM which is faster and more efficient.
4/ Faster UFS 4.0 storage.
5/ A 2023 chip. Both the Tensor 2 and A16 are based on 2021 architecture.
6/ Newer phones always have better hardware and software.
Waiting for this test when 2023 iPhone and Pixel arrive.
Sthu clown 🤡
Devices in the last didn't have up to a year gap, did they ?🤔🤔 Don't really remember, but it was the latest iphone model so there was no other option
@@hibernate8517 it is just that new components arrive in the earliest released phones each year so any comparison with a previous year is unfair. This is even more apparent this year as there were many upgrades to RAM, storage, displays, modem, etc that were generational, so iPhone is getting all these new components in iPhone 15Pros and we can scientifically without favour or prejudice test for how well each phone works in unusual tests like this.
@@andyH_England That's true, that's true. Also keep in mind the S22 was released very early in 2022, compared to the iphone and the pixel released in September and October respectively. Meaning less time for optimisation. But you're right overall.
I wouldn't call it a setup to make S23 look good, it was the latest Samsung phone, so it would make more sense to review it at the time, from a CZcams perspective.
try xiaomi 13 ultra also
this is what I call comparison
WHY are all CZcamsrs making measurements of the temperature externally? - it doesn't show anything about the phones capabilities. A phone that's hot outside instead of inside would be preferred to the opposite way around. So it's pointless when the internal temperature isn't measured. A warm external temperature of a phone could be because it's actually pretty good and effective at getting rid of the internal heat.
Magic 5 pro ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
same same
How do you have 12 GB of RAM in the Galaxy on the 256 GB model? On their website it shows 8 GB of RAM for the 256 GB model then 12 GB only for the 512 GB and 1 TB models.
the middle east version has 12GB of ram on all models ...
@@7MO- Ah I see, thanks.
I thought the S23 Ultra came with 12Gb of RAM on the 512Gb model, I have the 8/256 version
In UAE it's 12GB for all models
@@IDTR Thanks
Are you sure your S23 Ultra has 12GB RAM? In some countries, the 256GB version only has 8GB of RAM.
In the UAE it comes with 12GB for all models
@@IDTR sadly in Europe the base is 8GB of RAM. Thanks
This ties in with my thoughts that the S23U performance is a clear factor of using new TSMC nodes rather than Samsung Fabs or Samsung doing anything special. So, any improvement with the S23U can be replicated across any SD8G2 device. Ergo, performance and efficiency is no longer a variable in the choice of an Android flagship phone and anyone claiming Samsung is better are probably brand loyal. Both did really well and no clear winner.
So basically every android flagship is better than 14 pro max in these tests..continue coping😂
@@pratikdarawadepratik5084 maybe? But only for the 0.1% that will use a phone like this. And they will be stressing their phone killing it faster than normal users.
the snapdragon on galaxy is clocked ever so slightly higher on both GPU and CPU prime cores. that and that they used TSMC foundry also helped.
@@josiahsoko32 The overclocking is a marketing spiel to sell to their ardent fans. I have seen benchmarks, and it makes little difference as other OEMs also overclock but don't make a big fuss about it. It is 100% down to TSMC, so Qualcomm has signed with TSMC for the SD8G3 and SD8G4. If Samsung Fabs were any good because they are cheaper, then Qualcomm would use them.
Well the Honor is great except on CZcams. It lags on CZcams. I returned mine due to this. Unfortunate
Honor magic 5 pro vs s23+???
S23+ is better.
Honor magic 5 pro have serious throttling issues , after 30minutes of gaming it decrease performance like crazy, anly 42% stability in 3D mark stres test . I returned it to the store and buyed s23 Ultra.
Magic 6 pro?
Please, do PUBG test instead of Asphalt.
Thermal ... Since they both use the same chipset they both generate the same amount of heat ... How they dissipate the heat can be different and measuring a different temperature outside is meaningless because the heat somehow must go out of the phone. Significantly is how they perform in a long gaming session, that's the deal breaker.
Testing like this is an actual real 'Performance Test' i think, Benchmarks are just numbers & iPhone gets it the most lol, but in wildlife extreme Samsung beats the iPhone everytime since that's pretty reliable 😀
I think iPhone uses optimisation to do that since they the only phones with IOS.
@@domilesespartan3287 iOS is a very light skinned software, that's why it works really well with their system (people like the smoothness, animations etc) the Nvme storage if android used it, bro! It would be f* slow.
@Jalal O'dean i don't really know much about it, i just think IOS Cheats sometimes.
@@J-oDean458 it is not surprising that iOS is smooth and fluid because it's been written in a much lighter language. But it's truly miracle that laggy and sluggish Android that originally write with trash language is now able to keep up with IOS interm of smooth and fluidity.
@@nononononame8904 exactly i agree that android's really heavy OS, & find IOS to be much lighter
honor good
لجهتك مصري ١٠٠%
😅 ماهو عشان مصري مش معبرنا كتبتله كومنت عايز اعرف لون الخط الاسود ف مكان الشبكه والبطاريه اعمله ازاي بدل اللون الأبيض التقليدي مردش مسحت الكومنت مع اني كتبته بال English والله 🤣...
بس هو بصراحه محترم ومجتهد ومميز ف المحتوي عن العك المصري اللي بنشوفه وعاما دي قناه موجهه لل universal...
بس في اختبار نفسي اشوفوه لل pubg lite مش العاديه بين الجهازين دول.. لان المطور بتاع pubg lite مخلي الجرافيك علي hd لغايه سناب دراجون 855 ودي كارثه لأني لما جبت من اول نوت ٢٠ الترا وs20 و s21 الترا وال 22 الترا كمان اللعبه بتقطع وضعيفه جدا ف الجرافيك والحركه وشكل اللعبه وحش جدا
لكن لما جبت ال٢٣ الترا من السعوديه ٥١٢ جيجا الألوان الحصريه والمعالج قايلين gen 2 مخصص لسامسونج انبهرت من الاداء.. لقيت الجرافيك برده مش hd لان المطور موقفه عند snapdragon 855 .. لكن لقيت المعالج المخصص لسامسونج مخلي الجرافيك والصوره ف ال23 الترا كأنها hd وحركه واداء جميل وناعم بطريقه تحفه. ختي لعبه Gangstar 4 بجد تغييرر محترم ف توليف المعالج لسامسونج بس للأسف في سخونه لكن بتهدي لوحدها وبسرعه مع الوقت...
please stop using record scratching sound effect, its bad
Beating iPhone badly was fun!
Android vs Android no fun!
Next we need ROG phone!
😄
Yep, ROG vs other Android phones with same chipset would be interesting.
@@myolgiden
Yeah 😀
first
Where are all the apple sheeps screaming *"iphones have the fastest processor in a smartphone"* or *"Apple kills android phones in performance"* where are they at?. 😂 Come out from your caves and see the light which is the Galaxy S23 series
You can't test same S23 Ultra any time with any new Smartphone, it's gonna be hard all the time
VS iPhone 14 Pro Max
VS Google Pixel 7 Pro
VS Honor
VS ...
We already know Galaxy S23 Ultra gonna be the Champ
Of course, the temperature will be lower because the Honor screen is lower than that of Samsung You are supposed to measure the temperature before the screen brightness decreases
The honour magic 5 pro is the best looking phone out right now.
s23 ultra dont have 12/256 gb version :)
your accent like the Egyptian people
S23 ultra VS rog
الانجليزية .مصر
now keep in mind that the 512gb magic 5 pro is 300 bucks cheaper than the 256gb s23 ultra and on top of that; has a way more capable camera system with bigger sensors, faster aperture etc.
samsung once again scammed its dumbo consumers, but they keep on hyping xD
Another proof that Samsung is fkn overrated. Honor all the way ♥️
I would advise everyone to stay clear of this phone. I purchased one brand new 4 weeks ago and it broke in the first 3 weeks after being in my pocket during a short rain storm. Honor are refusing to replace my device under warranty as it has traces of water inside the device. It is supposed to be IP68 waterproof rating but clearly isn't.
absolute waste of almost £1,000 - go and buy a phone from a reputable organisation that doesn't cut corners in their manufacturing process.
Now I'm 4pro next will be 5 pro I can't buy this expensive Samsung and without a charger😂😂😢😂
The magic 5 pro if the 512 storage and 16 gigs of ram would beat the s23 u. Same specs id take the s23u.
The s23 being hotter means the cooling system is doing a better job at dispersing heat, meaning the internals have less heat and the phone will last longer, also the giant camera bump is probably covering some of the hot parts that are exposed on the s23 (to anyone saying "samsung fanboy" to that i say yes XD)
good work bro are you Egyptian?
I think why the phone lowers the screen brightness because there is no activity on the screen, I'm sure if the game is actually played lowering the brightness won't happen unless the battery is low!!