Sanders Sides Theory | What Does The Orange Side Represent?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 13. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 732

  • @PickYourPoison
    @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +271

    Guys what happened.

    • @cloudybookcase9189
      @cloudybookcase9189 Před 3 lety +140

      Logan got orange eyes in the latest video on SanderSides. You predicted most of it. Nice

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +124

      I saw it. I just. What happened.

    • @TincanTophat9907
      @TincanTophat9907 Před 3 lety +63

      I’m convinced you’re psychics.

    • @aesthete3887
      @aesthete3887 Před 3 lety +80

      DUUUUUUDDEEEE DID YOU SEE HOW HIS ANGER REFLECTED ON THOMAS TOO?! AND HOW REMUS WAS HAPPY TO SEE THE RAGE?? THIS IS SO EXCITING

    • @anawithbirbs6644
      @anawithbirbs6644 Před 3 lety +36

      we're all here after that last video,, i'm losing it-

  • @michaelwainscott2947
    @michaelwainscott2947 Před 4 lety +1380

    Rage being Logic's opposite makes sense
    Logic: Think before action
    Rage: Act on impulse rather than rational thought

    • @michaelwainscott2947
      @michaelwainscott2947 Před 4 lety +22

      @Audrey Lieu Nalugon Indeed

    • @yourforeign_corvid
      @yourforeign_corvid Před 3 lety +58

      or maybe chaos, where there's no logic at all y'know

    • @michaelwainscott2947
      @michaelwainscott2947 Před 3 lety +25

      @@yourforeign_corvid OH MY! That's good!

    • @tinagrech257
      @tinagrech257 Před 3 lety +10

      I had a headcanon that Remy could be his dark side, because when you're tired you can't think very logically but thats also a good idea

    • @sishere7768
      @sishere7768 Před 3 lety +9

      @@tinagrech257 I'm pretty sure Thomas said once that Remy isn't an official side-

  • @Randum_yt
    @Randum_yt Před 4 lety +367

    If the next side isn’t rage. then I’m gonna rage

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +71

      we’re gonna extra rage because we made three videos about it

    • @pathakdipti
      @pathakdipti Před 3 lety +7

      Orange is sleep (Remy) right?

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +40

      @@pathakdipti no, Thomas has said before that Remy does not exist in the Sanders Sides canon. I suppose he could change his mind, but as of right now orange is not remy or emile

    • @stevex1716
      @stevex1716 Před 3 lety

      🙄

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +4

      @@stevex1716 oh? tea?

  • @melodysoundy7627
    @melodysoundy7627 Před 4 lety +445

    Idea what if Logan and Rage are twins like Roman and Remus.
    That's why Roman acting weird in the Christmas episode.
    And why Logan is so hot-headed.
    Twin telepathy

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +69

      It's not an impossibility but sadly that is something we won't know until the reveal

    • @melodysoundy7627
      @melodysoundy7627 Před 4 lety +43

      @@PickYourPoison Your right it would be cool to have a twin squad though.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +43

      I would love twin squad for sure

    • @melodysoundy7627
      @melodysoundy7627 Před 4 lety +19

      @@PickYourPoison Yep

    • @jamescarmody5653
      @jamescarmody5653 Před 3 lety +5

      Deciet is Misinformation wich would be Logans opposite while there is no opposite to Morality.

  • @m.i.g1131
    @m.i.g1131 Před 4 lety +631

    This actually makes a lot of sense-
    *Why can’t my school essays be this well put together?*

    • @mandu08
      @mandu08 Před 2 lety +4

      My school essays would be this good if it was stuff I cared about like this T-T

  • @dragons_for_life376
    @dragons_for_life376 Před 4 lety +274

    I....am at a loss for words right now......

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 4 lety +5

      Same🤣

    • @jenniferdomann3720
      @jenniferdomann3720 Před 3 lety +2

      how long did this take you!!??!??!!?!??!?!??!?!??!!!

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +3

      @Galaxyfnaf And Dino we honestly have no clue how long it took us, but we estimate about 3 days for research, 7-8 hours for script writing, and a little under a week for editing.

    • @thewhiterabbitsystem3670
      @thewhiterabbitsystem3670 Před 3 lety +2

      Me too omg

  • @MrInfodump
    @MrInfodump Před 4 lety +455

    Remember us when your famous XD

  • @thegayghost872
    @thegayghost872 Před 3 lety +41

    And now we have Logan yelling with glowing orange eyes... Rage confirmed

    • @acanna7602
      @acanna7602 Před rokem

      what video and timestamp??

    • @amanda_denney_creates
      @amanda_denney_creates Před 10 měsíci

      @@acanna7602 Working THROUGH Intrusive Thoughts (czcams.com/video/3yn3lhYyYgU/video.html), timestamp 22:05! Those eyes appear again during the end card of that video and again during the anime intro when the Dark Sides are shown on a black background.

    • @not-so-happypappypatton
      @not-so-happypappypatton Před měsícem

      @@acanna7602Working THROUGH Intrusive Thoughts, 22:06

  • @micah8439
    @micah8439 Před 3 lety +35

    I love the idea of wrath/anger being Logan's counterpart, for the shear fact that when you're angry you do irrational things thinking what you're doing is rational.

  • @sapphire26
    @sapphire26 Před 3 lety +446

    I have some more evidence
    (I'm new to Sanders's Sides so if this has been talked to death sorry, I just noticed something and want to point it out.)
    So I was listening to Incomplete again and as Thomas and Logans duet started I realized Thomas's part may be foreshadowing/evidence to this theory. The lyrics go,
    "This just serves as a testament to the fact that *you have a temperament*
    Which is fine *you just haven't accepted it*
    If you let them finish they'll get to the-"
    Those lines (especially "you have a temperament" and "you just haven't accepted it") make a lot more sense if we assume this is Thomas foreshadowing Rage as Logan's "dark side". I'm currently very tired so I'm not gonna say anything else about it (sorry lol) but idk here's something else to think about.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +89

      Yeah, we've definitely discussed this before. It's especially suspicious considering that it is drowned out by Logan's part, however it absolutely has not been talked to death. That's something that I've noticed gets overlooked A TON so that's a very good catch for being new to the fandom. I didn't catch that until probably my third or fourth watch I'm really glad you brought this up because I don't think we have ever mentioned it in our videos. Would it be okay if I pinned your comment so other people can see your point?

    • @sapphire26
      @sapphire26 Před 3 lety +29

      @@PickYourPoison oh yeah that's fine with me! These videos are really well made and I didn't even notice most of this stuff. It's definitely making me think about this series more critically and that's been pretty fun

    • @kingofchaos5672
      @kingofchaos5672 Před 3 lety +20

      @@PickYourPoison notice how in all the episodes where a dark side is first introduced the opposite always gets pushed away morality a.k.a. Patton isn’t there Remus hits Roman on the head I wonder how wrath is going to somehow get rid of Logan

    • @RedactedForest
      @RedactedForest Před 3 lety +13

      I like to put quotes around “dark sides” and “light sides” since it’s just a matter of how Thomas views that side as Remus said in his song “good and bad all made up nonsense” !

    • @jeonghunoh208
      @jeonghunoh208 Před 3 lety +16

      @@kingofchaos5672 Ooh, one popular theory I’ve seen is that Rage will speak through Logan, and honestly I think that’s a cool way to do it. But it wouldn’t really be getting rid of him, maybe he would blind Logan causing him to retreat for the episode?

  • @moonlightriver1607
    @moonlightriver1607 Před 4 lety +151

    One of the ideas that I had was that rather than the dark sides being opposites of the light sides, they are the flipped side of the same coin. Remus and Roman both deal with creativity, but they are different types. Patton and Janus are both dealing with morality and are both dealing with protective Thomas from emotions ( Patton buries his sadness and Janus hides them with lies ). Virgil is the other side of Logan, who is always working on planning and keeping Thomas going, and Viral is a sort of vigilance and deals with caution ( he is also very grounded but always very stressed, which comes from over planning ) Orange, in my eyes, would be the other side of Thomas himself
    This was before this video,

    • @jamescarmody5653
      @jamescarmody5653 Před 3 lety +8

      this makes more sense on why Deciet would be Pattons opposite but given what they represent doesnt make sense however orange being Immorality or Hate would be new

  • @AshNRoses4409
    @AshNRoses4409 Před 4 lety +262

    Good theory! I didn't think Sanders Sides would have so much to do with Divine Comedy
    BTW loved the ending

  • @the_last_comment
    @the_last_comment Před 3 lety +6

    So. After the newest episode, I came back here. Congrats, you were right!

  • @Abbey0912
    @Abbey0912 Před 3 lety +7

    YT recommended me this after I just finished watching new Sanders Sides episode, this has to mean something.👁👁

  • @adoor668
    @adoor668 Před 3 lety +50

    Maybe Rage will be able to control the other sides.
    Rage makes up false logic,
    Rage bends your morals,
    And I can’t think of one for Roman so I dunno

    • @rachealrobinett6957
      @rachealrobinett6957 Před 3 lety +7

      When I'm in a rage I get a darker creativity so, maybe when Rage controls Roman just creates things that even Remus would be angered by? Idunno

    • @fal4thought
      @fal4thought Před 2 lety +1

      Roman is creativity but also Thomas’ sense of pride, rage for need to do his best, or needing to be listened to

  • @SilverGallowglass
    @SilverGallowglass Před 4 lety +56

    I thought Apathy because of the part of SvS Redux where Patton claimed apathy to be "worse" than selfishness. Going off the idea that the "bad traits" are escalating.
    This theory is very nice though, sound logic and I think you could be right.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +6

      that’s also a possibility. Didn’t even catch that one.

  • @aleiagoxd1986
    @aleiagoxd1986 Před 4 lety +118

    I see the orange side as like Virgil dark/light side which i call "breaker" for some reason, and i see him as "Confidence" Bc confidence is sometimes bad and sometimes nice,Confidence by being thinking your better and confidence by standing up for someone or your self
    And the name is think it will be also "us" or possibility "il" if Virgilous is not Virgil full name, Ppl say Virgilous is Virgil full name, But my opinion is only Virgil, so my opinion the light side's name will end as "il", But the question is what name ends with "il" and will it be still part of the like Roman Revelution or somethimg like that

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +32

      Virgil is likely the neural side that Thomas has confirmed, however you’re correct about confidence having good/bad aspects. Roman is already confidence/Thomas’ ego as has been said in more than one episode, but all of the light sides have some part of them that is bad and all the dark sides have some part about them that is good. For example, Janus is also self-preservation. Thomas confirmed in a livestream that Virgilius IS NOT Virgil’s full name, so you’re right about that, however Virgil is probably the neutral side, so it’s name will probably end in -US for that reason.

    • @jamescarmody5653
      @jamescarmody5653 Před 3 lety +2

      Confidence is probaly Remus since he hides nothing.

    • @gamingwithandrea449
      @gamingwithandrea449 Před 3 lety +5

      @@jamescarmody5653 that's true he has no filter

  • @rizugalaxy9046
    @rizugalaxy9046 Před 3 lety +13

    I think your theory has been confirmed in the latest Sander sides. I don't want to spoil anything so I recommend going to watch it.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +2

      We’ve already watched it and started a theory on it. We’ll be posting the reaction within a couple days and the theory really shortly after :)

    • @rizugalaxy9046
      @rizugalaxy9046 Před 3 lety +1

      @@PickYourPoison Okay and can't wait to see it.

  • @bbc5044
    @bbc5044 Před 4 lety +160

    well Virgils counterpart could be "sleep" which is seen in thomas's vines

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +64

      i suppose, but he has confirmed that there will be seven sides and that one of them is neutral. I suppose the neutral side could be logan but only virgil has been both dark and light.

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 4 lety +28

      @@PickYourPoison yea, I think it's Virgil because he's been on light and dark sides. But Logan could be as well now that I think ab it!

    • @roisinbarry3506
      @roisinbarry3506 Před 4 lety +27

      I'm pretty sure that Thomas confirmed that sleep would not be a part of Sanders Sides!

    • @lizz_xx5071
      @lizz_xx5071 Před 3 lety +13

      @@roisinbarry3506 Honestly, i think Virgil just hates sleeping, he does drink coffee ;-;

    • @nais-roserenier1848
      @nais-roserenier1848 Před 3 lety +6

      An Undertale fan, I see

  • @BestBoy8969
    @BestBoy8969 Před 3 lety +19

    In other words:
    Watch out thomas, A storm's coming.

  • @clefang7568
    @clefang7568 Před 3 lety +39

    “If the orange side was ignorance he would quite literally be an idiot” 😂

  • @kassidykaufman8990
    @kassidykaufman8990 Před 3 lety +13

    I think that Logan's opposite side would be the scariest because so far Logan has been able to handle deceit and Remus so I would like to see how he would handle his opposite side

  • @aleiagoxd1986
    @aleiagoxd1986 Před 4 lety +60

    Also i see Deceit as Logan's dark vers.
    Bc Logan is logic, and as i learn from school, Logic means the truths, While deceit as thw lies
    I see virgil as patton dark vers bc Patton is all positive and Virgil as negative but there's a posibility the orange side can be Patton's dark vers, Or maybe there will be another side maybe "pink" "endigo" or something else as to be patton's dark vers(And yes ik the thumbnail only have 7 side box selection thing)
    While Virgil dark/opposite vers is the orange side

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +17

      Our theory is that the sides have a double opposition, or two sides that oppose them. To use your example, Deceit mostly opposes moral truth, or Patton, however it can also oppose logical truth, or Logan. It doesn’t really effect creativity, or Roman. Virgil is neutral, so he opposes EVERY side in some way, both dark and light. Thomas is pink and Logan is indigo already, so it’s definitely only orange remaining, and it probably opposes MAINLY Logan, but also Roman. This means it has little affect on Patton, as anger doesn’t change one’s moral stance in most cases.

    • @jakoblent4694
      @jakoblent4694 Před 3 lety +4

      Thats not always true
      Logic isnt always truth logic is seeing things at face value and accepting that its like that because it makes logical sense

    • @jamescarmody5653
      @jamescarmody5653 Před 3 lety +1

      Deciet would most likely be Logans opposite while patton being virgils opposite doesnt make much sense so the orange would be something like HATRED or RAGE.

    • @jakoblent4694
      @jakoblent4694 Před 3 lety +1

      @@jamescarmody5653Lies and Decieving is not the opposite of logical thinking decievness is the opposite of morality
      and anxiety is not the opposite of morality anxiety doesnt have a opposite either your anxicous or your not thats it
      so logics opposite has to be not seeing things at face value or rather not thinking straight ahead

    • @lamarwaheed1271
      @lamarwaheed1271 Před 3 lety +1

      Wait, u learn from school?

  • @GreenFanBoy
    @GreenFanBoy Před 3 lety +21

    Honestly, I really hope that Logan and Rage are the same person in the same body, I think I'd be neat and much harder to reason with since they wouldn't have logic on their side

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +8

      I’ve seen a bunch of theories on that and honestly would love to see it. That would make the episodes much more dramatic. Logan has been completely integral in every issue before so I’d be interested to see what they’d do without him.

  • @aquaticangel3380
    @aquaticangel3380 Před 4 lety +16

    I’ll be honest, at first I wasn’t sold on the whole rage thing, but now I really think you’re right. It makes a lot of sense, and unless everyone is overlooking something huge, I cannot think of any other answer.

  • @royizzy9684
    @royizzy9684 Před 4 lety +20

    You really portray facts well while also being able to deliver it in a speedy way. I am truly impressed, you have a real gift.

  • @zacksmith5550
    @zacksmith5550 Před 3 lety +4

    I'd say he's either Thomas's frustration because logan got orange eyes when he got angry and I dont don't remember any of the sides representing feelings like anger

  • @wightrabbit
    @wightrabbit Před 4 lety +92

    Not gonna lie, I am TERRIFIED TO MEET THE ORANGE SIDE!!!

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 4 lety +13

      I'm exited😂😂

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 3 lety +10

      @i- um yea what if something happens to Thomas's relationship and that introduces the orange side😳 (in a good or bad way idk)!!!

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 3 lety +5

      @i- um yea i edited the comment if u wanna look lol

    • @jamescarmody5653
      @jamescarmody5653 Před 3 lety +3

      @@stranguhh2878 that makes sense since the same kinda happend with Remus and Deciet so ..... how bad is this one since they are getting worst and worst so this cannot be good

    • @stranguhh2878
      @stranguhh2878 Před 3 lety +4

      @@jamescarmody5653 Well Remus was only a small nuisance which wasn't awful but idk. But Im still scareddd

  • @alonelygoldfish2966
    @alonelygoldfish2966 Před 3 lety +15

    The orange side is Joan’s hat.

  • @ad-ss5uz
    @ad-ss5uz Před 4 lety +51

    This is amazing!
    I am very impressed by both your research and your convincing argument. I was also impressed by how you both showed your evidence on why the other theories could be disproven.
    It was a very enjoyable and entertaining video, thanks!

  • @emilysanchez4584
    @emilysanchez4584 Před 4 lety +16

    Yeah I agree that the orange side does have to do with sloth considering they keep mentioning procrastination. Also, on tumble I saw that the orange side could be representation of a rebellious student that's "cool" but deeply insecure.

  • @ghostturtle5516
    @ghostturtle5516 Před 4 lety +47

    Does that mean Virgil’s opposite is trust? Are we going to have a trust side? Since trust is opposite of anxiety
    Edit: everyone thinks that orange is jealousy

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +21

      no, virgil probably won’t have an opposite. Thomas confirmed there will be seven sides and one will stay neutral. Jealously is almost anger than someone has something you don’t, so that still factors in

  • @aszrieldreemurr5907
    @aszrieldreemurr5907 Před 4 lety +30

    OK I LOVE THIS?? THANK U FOR THIS THEORY AAA

  • @adragon8045
    @adragon8045 Před 3 lety +2

    Coming here after “Working Through Intrusive Thoughts” is pretty eye opening and just, Congrats. I think you’re probably right on

  • @tycho9645
    @tycho9645 Před 4 lety +43

    Based off of your point about how rage has not been said in the series, do you think that Virgil's "other" side's name was paranoia? I remember that sticking out to me in the newest video and I think it can stick with the over vigilance that anxiety can cause?
    Great video!! I'm excited to see if he really is rage! You guys make really great points!

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +22

      absolutely, it’s been almost said several times without ever actually being said. Roman said para- and then stopped himself and made up a word instead. Thank you!!

    • @lamarwaheed1271
      @lamarwaheed1271 Před 3 lety +5

      @@PickYourPoison IKR!! Like also how logan was like: "Ur just being para- (with everyone looking at him) expressing an unhealthy amount of concern, thank u for being on guard..." maybe it triggers virgil into thinking the others still see him as a dark side?

    • @eelio8469
      @eelio8469 Před 2 lety +2

      @@PickYourPoison "pARa-paranavigilance. paranavigilance. look at me, making up new words. I'm basically shakespeare."

  • @scytheassassin2201
    @scytheassassin2201 Před 3 lety +3

    Ok this is amazing. I got recommended this after watching working through intrusive thoughts and you seem spot on

  • @cjck1344
    @cjck1344 Před 4 lety +24

    i’d comment a whole essay on all the reasons why i think logan is the orange side but like
    i’m t i r e d

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +4

      when you’re less tired go for it

    • @cjck1344
      @cjck1344 Před 4 lety +4

      @@PickYourPoison bruh i’m GONNA I GOTTA DO IT

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +2

      YEAH DO IT

    • @cjck1344
      @cjck1344 Před 4 lety +14

      OKAY OKAY
      👏
      This is copy pasted from reddit posts I made
      Ok ok, just hear me out.
      This was mostly copied and pasted from texts between me and my other fander friend
      -------
      the first 2-parter and room we saw was all about Virgil’s character arc. The second was Patton’s. The next one will be Roman’s, and the 4th will be Logan’s.
      When people were talking about the 4th “orange” dark side, I didn’t think he actually existed. 3 lights and 3 darks made sense. So when it was revealed that he exists I was kind of pissed because I felt like it threw off the balance.
      But then I thought about it…If you haven’t heard of the whole “blue crayon” theory, basically there was a promotional poster portraying the sides as colored crayons: red, light blue, dark blue, and purple. Now, I’ve never seen this poster myself and I’m going to look it up, but allegedly in this poster the dark blue crayon was broken. This has led to theories that Logan is going to snap.
      Then, I saw an animatic where an animator was basically portraying their theory that Logan IS the orange side, and I agree.
      Logan’s going to snap during his character arc, and it’s going to turn him into a dark side. After all, orange is the opposite of blue…
      “But like what would the opposite of logan be?”
      Common theory is ignorance.
      This actually still makes sense if Logan is the orange side, because his motive would most likely be to be the only one in charge. Ignorance stems from people having their own logic and not listening to anyone else, let alone their own morals, vigilance, etc
      blah blah blah…
      Notice how Logan starts off(in the first episode) all cheery, and as the series progresses, he gets more and more…well, Logan.
      I wonder why that happened 🤔
      I think it’s just leading up to o r a n g e b o i
      It’s kind of sad, actually. At first he’s portrayed as a friendly teacher dude(Thomas even calls him teacher dude in Logic vs. Morality I’m pretty sure) who just wants Thomas to learn and enjoy it. But as Thomas’ mental health worsens, so does Logan’s. He starts to lose his emotions and denies he ever had them in the first place, maybe to convince Thomas and the others that he’s not scared or miserable about everything going on in Thomas’ life.
      “I’m sorry but imma laugh if this doesn’t happen-”
      IMMA LAUGH HYSTERICALLY OUT OF ANGER AND THEN CRY IF THIS DOESNT HAPPEN
      -------
      Basically, Logan’s gonna break/be pushed over the edge somehow, and it’s gonna cause him to try and take over Thomas’ mind because he doesn’t want anyone’s getting in his way. And as anxiety became vigilance, logic will become ignorance.
      No but fr imma be so mad if this doesn’t happen and it prolly won’t-
      AND T H E N i was listening to Logan’s playlist and…
      “Erase Me”
      (i realized after making this post that the animatic i saw was of erase me so liiiiike)
      This song heavily implies that Logan is angry and resentful at the others(my first assumption being specifically Thomas, idk why) for ignoring him. It sounds almost chaotic. The singer sounds almost like they’re screaming. I see this song as the thoughts Logan has about the way the others treat him, that he keeps locked in his head. I can see this as him finally snapping…very soon(at least as soon as next season, as we’re still in Roman’s arc.). Also, some of the songs on this playlist sound like they belong in Remus’ playlist. Remus is the only Dark Side left. Is this a sign that Logan will join him? P e r h a p s…

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +8

      okay, yes, that is a lot of good points. The problem is that the flaws that all of the other sides have coincide with a dark side. Patton has no empathy, and Roman is egoism/confidence. It would make plenty of sense if Logan opposed rage without technically being rage. There of course is a seventh side, because Thomas has confirmed that there will be three dark, three light, and a neutral. Now despite Janus being ‘accepted’, the pretenses under which he was excepted throws off the balance of the sides, and therefore the balance of thomas. He was accepted under false pretenses where patton was almost forced to give up and accept him. He is not a light side, just as virgil is not a light side. Light sides aren’t who Thomas trusts, they’re who lead him on the path of being a good person. Virgil doesn’t affect this path at all, because one’s anxiety doesn’t 100% factor in to whether they are inherently good or bad. That’s why he has to be the neutral side. Janus is still a dark side because despite his acceptance, he still wants thomas to focus on self preservation by any means necessary, even if he has to hurt others to do so. Of course Logan is angry, but that doesn’t necessarily make him the new side.

  • @Brand_Fish
    @Brand_Fish Před 3 lety +2

    I love how everyone is coming back now that the new Sanders Asides has given us more information on the Orange Side

  • @cheeseytacotime9380
    @cheeseytacotime9380 Před 4 lety +15

    Yes I’ve been saying this and I’m glad someone else does aswell, I also loved how you compared it to Divine comedy.

  • @victoriapiontek2498
    @victoriapiontek2498 Před 3 lety +2

    Me, after watching "Working THROUGH Intrusive Thoughts": ...This one aged really well, ngl

  • @sleeplesskid
    @sleeplesskid Před 3 lety +7

    Me who just thought the Sanders sides was just for him to vent

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +6

      most of the situations are actually made up, believe it or not. It probably started as a way to vent until Joan stepped in and helped with the plot line to make it a series though

  • @TheShadeVoid
    @TheShadeVoid Před 3 lety +4

    now i wanna know what symbol rage would have on his outfit

  • @krow1533
    @krow1533 Před 4 lety +11

    My really really really out there theory: virgil is the fight or flight response while his counterpart is the rest and digest response( parasympathetic and sympathetic system of the human nervous system) i know it's dumb

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +4

      that’s not dumb at all actually. If he did have a counterpart, sloth would be sensible.

    • @krow1533
      @krow1533 Před 4 lety +3

      @@PickYourPoison and that would make aggressiveness/rage logan's counterpart part

  • @priinglescafe
    @priinglescafe Před 3 lety +2

    new info!!! Sanders Asides came out with a new episode, and when Logan got angry at Remus, his eyes turned orange. Your theory is solid :)

  • @spacekid2608
    @spacekid2608 Před 3 lety +1

    this makes even more sense now after the new sanders asides !! when logan yelled at remus to 'stop ignoring him' his eyes turned orange

  • @giraffejuiceb2545
    @giraffejuiceb2545 Před 3 lety +2

    1) This was so well written and the fact that you two did research to support your points is super cool. I don’t have the energy and time to do that, even if I want to.
    2) The ending was super funny. (Because my sense of humor is dead)

  • @theinterstate718
    @theinterstate718 Před 3 lety +2

    this was so well put together omg English teachers everywhere would be proud

  • @anonymouslymj1064
    @anonymouslymj1064 Před 3 lety +8

    It would be hilarious if after all of this speculating, the unknown side turned out to be hot pink.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +2

      noooooo

    • @anonymouslymj1064
      @anonymouslymj1064 Před 3 lety

      @@PickYourPoison Yeah that would ruin a lot of people’s efforts
      Including yours...
      But to be fair, when speculating about that hooded figure in POF, no one said "It's a homeless Leslie Odom Jr., you guys"

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +1

      @@anonymouslymj1064 if its not orange I might cry UNLESS its just joan. Then i'll be okay with it lmao

    • @anonymouslymj1064
      @anonymouslymj1064 Před 3 lety

      @@PickYourPoison Joan is always an exception

    • @starrynight1165
      @starrynight1165 Před 3 lety

      @@PickYourPoison my favorite side of Thomas's personality is Joan /j

  • @BrainsArt
    @BrainsArt Před 3 lety +6

    Seeing other fans talk about how Orange could be Rage had me a touch dubious but your theory of it being like the combination of wrath and sloth as soon in the Divine Comedy fits in SO well with the Sanders Sides narrative, repression has been a recurring theme and repressed anger could 100% be a thing to be brought up, especially with the animosity stirring up between some of the Sides right now.
    Consider me very much on board with this theory.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety

      We’re so glad u enjoyed! We just feel like Thomas would much more likely chose a multilayered representation

  • @kermitthefrog996
    @kermitthefrog996 Před 4 lety +27

    I personally don’t think the “each side having an opposite” is true because it is literally canon that Roman and Remus used to be the same side and they were split apart because of Thomas putting good creativity and bad creativity on different standards so they could not be made as opposites and there is no way Roman and Remus can be neutral because they literally represent good and bad also Janus joined the light side in the most recent episode so what does that technically make him neutral and on a sidenote isn’t it just Janus power to control people?

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +5

      we have a video coming out in about a week that is going to further explain what we mean by that, but i do see your point.

    • @kermitthefrog996
      @kermitthefrog996 Před 4 lety +5

      • PickYourPoison • oh ok! Thanks for being kind about it!

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +2

      well yeah, theories aren’t perfect, but we have been getting a lot of comments asking us to clarify that so we’re going to. Of course it doesn’t mean we’re right but it’ll be out there. Thanks for your input!

    • @kermitthefrog996
      @kermitthefrog996 Před 4 lety +1

      Oh I also forgot to say in the first episode the word anxiety was used so it isn’t that much of a far stretch to think that it is just deceits power to do that so I don’t think we should rule out other things like for example insanity I am pretty positive that word has been used before

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +2

      youre right, but if our theories are correct, we can assume that at that point Virgil was paranoia, and not anxiety

  • @Kozy_Corner
    @Kozy_Corner Před 4 lety +7

    I.... LOVE THIS VIDEO! You both did SUCH good work with your research! Honestly im really impressed.

  • @vanmitchell846
    @vanmitchell846 Před 4 lety +5

    I think he represents False Bargaining.

  • @ammy1461
    @ammy1461 Před 3 lety +2

    In the lates sides video about thomas dealing with intrusive thoughts you can see logans eyes turn orange when he get angry at remus and you can see that thomas home is very messy wich relates back to thomas realizing his sin just like you said

  • @TheAbyssro
    @TheAbyssro Před 3 lety +3

    Considering the Sander side that came out on the 7/31 im going to say you were spot on. I'm thinking that either Logan may have a split personality where he is "physically" both a Light & Dark side but can only mentally be one at a time. Actually using the example of the Wrathful and the Sullen, i would say Logan maybe the Sullen side and "drowns" himself in logic and facts. When ignored he becomes Wrathful and attacks others without actually thinking.

  • @purpleshutin
    @purpleshutin Před 3 lety +2

    The newest episode proves this even more. Logan's eyes turned orange when he snapped at Remus.

  • @Jo-yc3lq
    @Jo-yc3lq Před 3 lety +2

    All I can say is that they put so much effort into the Sander Sides

  • @Violet_Siren
    @Violet_Siren Před 3 lety +3

    OMG I believe this might actually be correct, at the time of this comment a new sanders asides video has come out "Working THROUGH Intrusive Thoughts" *SPOILER ALERT* and in it we see Logan trying to help Thomas work through his intrusive thoughts caused by Remus and at 22:06* as Remus ignores Logan in a blind fit of rage Logan shouts out Remus to stop ignoring him and as he does his eyes turn ORANGE more proof that the orange side is Rage!!!

  • @djtimo
    @djtimo Před 2 lety +1

    The end of the Sanders Aside "Working Through Intrusive Thoughts" only proves this theory further. You may have nailed it y'all

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před rokem

      If you're interested, we have actually made a video on Working Through Intrusive Thoughts where we compare it to this video!!! Thanks for the support!!!

  • @chimchimcheerio
    @chimchimcheerio Před 3 lety +1

    This is literally the best explained thing I’ve ever heard, it actually makes so much SENSE

  • @dramapenguin500
    @dramapenguin500 Před 4 lety +5

    This is a good theory. I was thinking it was something like anger

  • @miles_quartz
    @miles_quartz Před 3 lety +3

    WOW IM HERE AFTER WATCHING THE LATEST SANDERS ASIDES VIDEO AND THIS THEORY IS JUST ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT??
    I THINK YOU GETS ARE RIGHT ON THE MONEY MY MIND IS BLOWN???I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS IS FROM OVER A YEAR AGO
    the little "43770" hello in orange was such a small piece of evidence that i would've never picked up on...that's so cool omgg
    im not super deep into this fandom but woah this was a great theory it's crazy how right you were/are going to be
    AND AAAAAAAAAA I CANT WAIT FOR A NEW SANDERS SIDES VIDEOOOO

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +1

      THANKS IM IN ABSOLUTE SHOCK LMAO WATCH US BE WRONG BUT LIKE AHHHH???

  • @katierowan8464
    @katierowan8464 Před 3 lety +4

    what if orange represented curiosity because rage is more of an emotion and curiosity sounds like the opposite of logan. like they say, "curiosity killed the cat" wich might be why this side is unknown.

    • @starrynight1165
      @starrynight1165 Před 3 lety

      Logan has been described as curious himself though. But then again, roman and remus are both creativity so maybe the orange side could be the "dark" side of curiousity

  • @BixLovesMiley
    @BixLovesMiley Před 3 lety +1

    you know, there are theories that are just, out there, and than there is this. it makes so much sense, it is so well researched, and the newest video fits perfectly into the pattern you discovered with Logan's rage at being ignored!

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety

      This is such a sweet comment! Thank you for watching!!!

  • @forget_me_not2009
    @forget_me_not2009 Před 3 lety +4

    Well this video age like a fine wine with the new sanders sides vid

  • @dejavuskelecat9582
    @dejavuskelecat9582 Před 3 lety +4

    I love this theory and it's really put out! and it sorta fuels my own theory on the orange side with a lot of your evidence, it's strange but still! Great theory

  • @lillianwilliams6901
    @lillianwilliams6901 Před 3 lety +11

    13:39 I’m sorry I just love that face Remus makes 🤣😂

    • @novel4742
      @novel4742 Před 3 lety +1

      Omg yes it's amazing- he's like 'evil/suggestive smirk'

  • @dying-bubba6302
    @dying-bubba6302 Před 3 lety +3

    This makes sense! Oh my gosh, it's perfect. Thank you for making this video!

  • @malachite796
    @malachite796 Před 3 lety +4

    Comes back quietly after latest episode

  • @RaurXDberry
    @RaurXDberry Před 3 lety +2

    Thomas: *insert "Working through intrusive thoughts episode here*
    Us: yessss

  • @thewhiterabbitsystem3670
    @thewhiterabbitsystem3670 Před 3 lety +2

    Thank you so so so much for the captions, I'm so grateful honestly

  • @andriannasparkywolf9302
    @andriannasparkywolf9302 Před 3 lety +2

    I HIGHLY agree! I noticed some of that from the SvS video and it always makes me so happy when other people talk about it!!! The blinding rage was sooo cool though, and the connection with Dante’s Inferno!

  • @claireschelling3406
    @claireschelling3406 Před 3 lety +1

    This is like the most pieced together well thought out fun theories I’ve ever seen.

  • @lolli_popples
    @lolli_popples Před 2 lety +3

    Next on top ten theory videos that aged well.

  • @wingedkatgirl
    @wingedkatgirl Před 3 lety +2

    I’m just imagining the creator screaming “YES! I KNEW IT!” When Logan’s eyes turned orange in Thomas’ latest video

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +2

      We actually have a video of our reaction up on the channel! I promise you there was a lot of screaming lmao

    • @wingedkatgirl
      @wingedkatgirl Před 3 lety +1

      @@PickYourPoison Nice, I might go watch that

  • @jeonghunoh208
    @jeonghunoh208 Před 3 lety +3

    Gonna combat a point brought against this theory, yeah, Patton is not only positive emotions, he also represents more negative emotions, like sorrow. BUT, from what I’ve seen, he doesn’t cover anger. Patton may get frustrated, but he doesn’t usually burst out in anger. Honestly, I don’t remember him bursting out at all, he shows mildly strong anger, but never a full fit of rage. The other sides also only react in anger because of something else. They don’t represent anger themselves. Therefore, this theory still stands.

  • @samanthae.1002
    @samanthae.1002 Před 3 lety +4

    PREDICTION ON POINT SO FAR

  • @pokemontrainer1956
    @pokemontrainer1956 Před 3 lety +2

    I was at the point where the quote “Because i was one of them” was and i tried saying it along then when virgil said “because i was one of them” i died of laughter. I have officially lost my sanity

  • @NekoLavender1987
    @NekoLavender1987 Před 3 lety +2

    This was one of my many theories about what orange could be, good job!!

  • @bethanybratton6630
    @bethanybratton6630 Před 3 lety +2

    You know, this makes a lot of sense, I really hope Thomas sees this.
    Keep up the good work guys!

  • @makenzieburns9889
    @makenzieburns9889 Před 3 lety +3

    What if Orange is Impulsive? Logic is the opposite of Impulsive, so that would make sense. Logan got fed up with Janus in the last video and ‘impulsively’ lashed out. I could be wrong, idk

  • @shockfoxy921
    @shockfoxy921 Před 3 lety +2

    My first guess was spit which I thought of around the time the original selfishness vs selflessness came out because of the "who did you think was impersonating you" like since when angered its possible to justify anything with enough arguing.

  • @lil-Prick
    @lil-Prick Před 2 lety +3

    every time I see amazing theories like this it makes me wonder if (in this case Thomas) has seen it and is just thinking "oh shit they figured it out" other than that i like to think that we'll be introduced to rage after a long hiatus or smthn just to emphasise sloth and it could be something like Logan being angry that Thomas is extremely behind schedule to the point that his rage appears because of Logan. Ooo itd be even bigger of a plot twist if a different side ended up "releasing" rage and th story arch turning into rages surprise of it not being logan!

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 2 lety +1

      If Thomas has seen our videos we are in the worst timeline. Also I definitely would like to see some more emphasis on the sloth side of rage!

  • @toocoldforyouhere8353
    @toocoldforyouhere8353 Před 4 lety +6

    Imagine if Oranges name is Dante. I would like it.
    Or maybe Aquiles, cause guess what is the first sentence in the Iliad. Rage

    • @Arnikaaa
      @Arnikaaa Před měsícem

      Aquiles would also fit the pattern of Remus and Janus ‘s names ending with ‘us’

  • @galacticcoconut2872
    @galacticcoconut2872 Před 3 lety +3

    This is great! Your legit making sense of the tangled web of the canon! Logan's opposite doing rage or blinding rage makes complete sense with Logan's constant outbursts, his feeling of wanting and needing to be heard turns into him bottling up his feelings of rage then the bottle exploding and ending with Logan hurting the sides feeling.
    (I'm pretty much just saying what you said :^)
    I want to come back to Virgil though, yes the color purple doesn't have a complementary pair but there is a certain shade that matches Virgil, gray for paranoia. I remember then scene in (can't think of the episode) where Logan is about to tell Virgil to stop being paranoid. But before he does he stops himself and him and Virgil share a weird look with each other. Along with that gray isn't even part of the color wheel so this would technically go against the rainbow theory. I could very well be missing something important though.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +1

      No one really knows, but our theory is that when Virgil considered himself a dark side, he was paranoia, thus why it would be a sensitive subject for him since he doesn't want to be dark. Since he was introduced in black and didn't become purple until later, it's possible that black/gray were his dark side colors.

  • @randomdrawerwriter1094
    @randomdrawerwriter1094 Před 4 lety +6

    I see the orange side as a very powerful side a feeling that can muffle all the others which I think anger would be a good option since it can make you see things different

  • @lunaschaoticcorner5188
    @lunaschaoticcorner5188 Před 3 lety +4

    Am I the only one who thinks Remus is Logan's opposite rather than Roman's, and Virgil is Roman's?
    Remus literally defies logic (he even says so himself), while Roman does mention in accepting anxiety that the only thing standing in the way of his hopes and dreams is fear.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 3 lety +1

      We actually just posted a video a couple of weeks ago that dives into the sides and their opposites that you should check out!

    • @lunaschaoticcorner5188
      @lunaschaoticcorner5188 Před 3 lety +2

      @@PickYourPoison that's awesome, I will!

  • @marli01
    @marli01 Před 3 lety +2

    The new Sander Asides proves your theory imo ✌🏻

  • @fireangel6571
    @fireangel6571 Před 3 lety +4

    OHH MY GOSH!!!!
    I got this recommended to me after I watched the newest episode and I thought "wow that's really fast for someone to make a theory"- but this was from a year ago 😭✌
    This is CRAZY because it completely makes sense- and the next Sanders Sides episode is the season final so I'm excited and scared to see what'll happen 😭
    Amazing job with this video too!!!

  • @electricrainbowskull
    @electricrainbowskull Před 3 lety +2

    With the new video that came out, Rage definitely feels like a possibility
    especially when you think about how Thomas actually presents himself, a happy positive person
    Anger would be a big disruption to him as a person, and when Logan said stop ignoring me it was while Thomas was looking at the messages and he was getting more and more irritated the longer they went unansweredred

  • @loaffofbred
    @loaffofbred Před 4 lety +4

    I was thinking of the same thing! Maybe its my undying love for Logan, i dont know, but nonetheless this video is amazing and your points are explained beautifully.

  • @tajalexandrafadri8999
    @tajalexandrafadri8999 Před 3 lety +3

    logan's eyes turned orange in the new episode!!

  • @alexrodriguezelle9260
    @alexrodriguezelle9260 Před 4 lety +6

    I really love your video! Very well done. New subscriber!

  • @sv9157
    @sv9157 Před 3 lety +2

    Logan *was* once described as short tempered

  • @rubygail349
    @rubygail349 Před 3 lety +2

    This was so good! How do you not have more subscribers. I never thought of Rage as the orange side before but this makes total sense. And the research was amazing!
    Definetly a sub from me!

  • @closet_gaming3983
    @closet_gaming3983 Před 4 lety +6

    I believe that the orange side is the opposite of Roman even though Roman and Remus are "good and bad creativity" Remus has no reason or rhyme which is the complete opposite of Logan who is logical. Rage also works completely against creativity due to the fact that the angrier you get the more you lose your grove. As a person who has anger issues and is an actor and artis it's a huge road block because when you do something wrong the angrier you become the more you mess up. I agree with the theory the orange side is range he is just the foil of someone else.

    • @closet_gaming3983
      @closet_gaming3983 Před 4 lety +2

      Also as we see in Thomas's video on originality the more angry or frustrated Roman became the more obvious the "copying" became meaning his anger was working against him.

    • @PickYourPoison
      @PickYourPoison  Před 4 lety +1

      you’re right about all of that. we can’t say for sure which one rage foils, so we picked Logan, however we think each of the dark sides foils two light sides to a degree. Janus foils both Patton and Logan, Remus foils both Roman and Patton, and Rage would foil both Logan and Roman

    • @closet_gaming3983
      @closet_gaming3983 Před 4 lety +2

      @@PickYourPoison Actually I noticed that the dark sides foiled 2 light sides it's really cool that you noticed as well.

  • @chipfry1550
    @chipfry1550 Před 3 lety +3

    It is so gonna be Rage, in the newest video Logan’s eyes turned orange when he raged!

  • @lalas181
    @lalas181 Před 3 lety +2

    Yeah this makes a crap-ton of sense. I bet a lot of viewers including myself could benefit from episodes on coping with rage as well, _especially_ since there's so much to be angry about in the world that needs actual planning to fix. Good video!

  • @Biowoman.
    @Biowoman. Před 3 lety +1

    This is what I've been thinking! Thomas has also been getting increasingly angrier throughout the series. The other sides have been too.

  • @theon.1549
    @theon.1549 Před 3 lety +2

    I’ve kind of always assumed the orange one would be the leader for some reason with Janus as the vengeful henchman, using his self preservation side to fight to stay in ‘power’. Remus literally dresses as a sort of jester prince mix, so I kind of assume the costume for orange will be simple, but still powerful looking.
    I also think instead of hiding as a side (Janus), or taking out an already risen side (Remus) he will instead block someone from popping up or drag the other sides down to his realm so that he’s at his most powerful. I also sort of think that the orange side will be drawn from the beliefs Thomas grew up on. As logic is inner decision and ideas, the orange one would be outside influenced or peer pressure. Possibly even gaslighting or something.

  • @applescotchpie3003
    @applescotchpie3003 Před 3 lety +2

    Coming back to this after the newest Sanders Asides...
    "Stop, IGNORING ME"