The Spread of Democracy (1900-2021)
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 08. 2022
- This video shows the map timelapse of democracy from 1900 to 2021. The variable denotes the best estimate of the extent to which political leaders are elected under comprehensive suffrage in free and fair elections, and freedoms of association and expression are guaranteed.
Twitter: / wawamustats
Facebook: wawamustats
Source:
v-dem.net
Subscribe here: czcams.com/users/wawamustats?s...
I’m sure whoever made these metrics is completely unbiased and are gonna use them to take their resources I mean give them freedom
You mean exploitation in disguise of “freedom “?
welcome to check the north korea democracy index then
Actually, it's clearly biased AGAINST America.
@@wenxuyao5934 and Israel?
@@user-nv5ix3ib5bthen what is Gaza
Shout out to NZ for staying the same colour for over a century
Pretty easy when most of the electorate are sheep....
More like old democratic land than new zealand
And NK
NZ made a major leap to become a true democracy when it achieved proportional representation.
And Saudi Arabia
0-0.2: Hard Autocracy
0.2-0.4: Moderate Autocracy
0.4-0.6: Hybrid Regime
0.6-0.8: Flawed Democracy
0.8-1: Full Democracy
My country is moderate autocracy😥
You think the US is Fully Democratic? Don't know why they're in blue.
Yes monarchy is full democracy
Argentina full democracy yey
@@jirachi-wishmaker9242 The Nordic countries are PARLIAMENTARY monarchies, the same with the United Kingdom, it is what differentiates them from being a medieval democracy, simply the kings have no power or control over their country for a century. Ironically they are the best democracies in the world.
Imagine USA spreading democracy 💀💀💀
ur acoustic
@@eu_bebo_oleodon’t say that, it’s offensive to autistics
Are you going to argue if it worked in Germany after WW2?
Fun fact: 1996 in Canada, Indigenous Canadians have no democracy
Democracy? Is it true democracy? Is every vote people cast really self-conscious or manipulated?
Hits blunt 🥴 Democracy is when no one’s influenced by anything
Who define democracy? Is procedural democracy counts democracy?
Looks like the criteria is "THE democracy", not democratic.
Whoever gives the USA enough oik
I’m from the USA. According to Democracy Index, we are no longer a full democracy. Same thing with an increasing number of Western European countries like Portugal, France, and Italy
Because it’s not allowed to talk about 2020 election fraud on CZcams
Which is a good thing btw
The index is retarded. It considers low turnout an inherently bad thing and high turnout as inherently good, despite the fact that encouraging people to vote only pushes out low information voters.
Notice how the U.S went down in 2016
@@Sceptonic Proves my point about a politically biased index. The system did not change in 2016 or 2017 in the slightest. It did, however get less democratic in 2020 under COVID.
In Japan, democracy began to permeate the country around the beginning of the 20th century. So it is strange that there has been no change.
There was a convention that the emperor always approved the decisions of the Diet. After World War I, universal suffrage was held and the majority party assumed executive power.
In the 30s all parties were dissolved, the parliament ceased to function, and the country became a military dictatorship.
I think they labeled it as such because even though these were liberal reforms and Japan had all the hallmarks of a democracy it did not have the most stable checks and balances system. Japan in the later 20’s and 30’s was mauled by political assassinations on leading political figures and such acts were allowed to continue even into 1936 when, while the army started an invasion in China, a pacifist faction was elected into power only to be removed by Tojo’s military takeover. The military also effectively ruled the empires foreign policy and also its overseas possessions with totalitarian methods which further weakened their score.
Ah yes, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Afghanistan and Africa surely enjoying the democracy to the fullest.
监狱里的服刑人员翻墙出来吠？还用上英文了，现在这么卷了吗？当我们都看不懂是么？我说你们也是不容易，在监狱里还要当人肉电池发帖减刑
如果让我选择，我宁愿选择生活在现在的伊拉克和利比亚，因为现在可以批评政府，有示威游行的自由，也可以上网。而在以前的萨达姆和卡扎菲时期，批评政府和示威游行就会被关进监狱，如此简单的道理
You didnt specify where in africa
That’s BS there was no democracy only western puppets
@@michaelwu8712 Try criticizing the LGBT in the United States. You'll be dead meat.
I really appreciate your work but this index is cheap propaganda. Countries with colonial political systems where many inhabitants did not have citizenship cannot lead the lists of democracy. Even countries featured on this map, like Canada and Australia, had segregationist laws. The census vote in countries like the United Kingdom and the Netherlands continued to exist until well into the 20th century, but on this map it seems as if they were already full democracies at that time. NATO propaganda has done terrible damage to history.
I agree, except with the last sentence. Did 'NATO propaganda' really affect the people who estimated these scores?
What is the census vote in the UK and Netherlands, I’ve never heard of it.
"NaTo pRoPaGaNdA" Everybody who says this shit is a fatherless child, thanks for proving my theory
Yeah exactly, as an indian i can openly say this is completely biased data about my country
@@TheRealQuark-vi6yg I support NATO at same time they’re the one that allowed Ukraine Russia war to happen in first place.
As a Costa Rican I'm very happy for my country 😊
Hell yeah!
County? you mean country?
Congratulation!
India is definitely better than 10 years ago... This video is bs
Worse*
@@zippyparakeet1074cry,
@@zippyparakeet1074
Better *
In almost everything like literacy, having more toilet, less corruption , cheap internet, higher wages .
Of course it's not like the developed World but still better than 10 years back
So Monarchy (with chosen House of Lords)
Two Party system
Is democratic.
But, multi party system because it's in Asia is a hybrid regime. Got it.
@@vatsal7640 (with chosen house of lord & monarchy as head of state it is neither a democracy nor a republic)
@@vatsal7640 yes it has been stable because monarchy works for them. There is no need to change. But stop claiming yourselves as a "full democracy".
@@vatsal7640 definitely not a monarch & lord system
A lot of Parties ≠ democracy
@@German_Patriot1 LOL
kim jong un is that you
Democracy is Political show
Better democrasy than autocrasy
Change my mind
@@MHG796 It depends. Better for what? For the lives of the common people or for the strenght of the country? Because in Germany they literally voted for autocracy between WW1 and WW2 in order to become a military world power.
The democracy is just as good as the decisions of the voters while the autocracy is just as good as the decisions of the leaders whose sole job is to make (good) decisions.
The best argument against democracy is a 5 minutes talk with the average voter. Look at USA to see how smart the average voter is. You'll notice they vote the democrat party because they want to support LGBTQ and the illegal immigrants, NOT because they care about the economy or the influence of USA.
Democracy vs autocracy isn't as simple as which is the better option. In democracy you need all people to be smart and care about their country and themselves. In autocracy you need leaders to be smart and care about their country and their people.
I never aimed to make you think autocracy is better than democracy because I cannot convince myself of that, but only that democracy is not better than autocracy.
@@Hardcore_Remixer Democracy is better than autocrasy because in democracy you have balance between powers, btw i like how you act like you thought about that quote : "best argument for democracy is 5m talk with average voter" that's Churchill's quote, in which country you prefer to live in Democratic country or autoritarian one? most democratic countries are the best ones to live, Look at switzerland look at norway look at sweden look at denmark look at canada look at usa, democracy is far better than autocrasy in almost every aspect, nobody goes to live in Dubai, or saudi arabia, they go to work to earn money, not to live there in democracy matters what you think about your lider, you can express it, in autocracy what matters is what does your lider thinks about you, that could be between being in prison or falling from window, you like autocracy? you can live in dictatorial country. end of discusion and i'll give you another quote of churchill, because you clearly like to steal his quotes and tell them like is your's by leaving them in grey area : Democracy is not the perfect system, but it's best what we got"
@@MHG796 I didn't think about that quote. I just don't remember who thought about it first.
As for in which country I prefer to live inI prefer the one in which my cuktural background already alligns best without needing change and in which I can live a decent live. As a Romanian programmer, I like living in Romania. Russia doesn't look like a bad option either. Not nearly as bad as most of the Western countries. This comparison is for me, not for everyone.
As for democracy being the best, it seems to be self destructive in Western Europe because of the many always left no matter what voters and the left wing parties not tackling illegal immigration. There are also the dumb Just Stop Oil protesters especially in UK so all the more reason I wouldn't go there.
Denmark, Sweeden, Finland and Norway seem to take the children of legal immigrant Christian couples on the argument of "avoiding their indoctrination". Seems like you can't think whatever you want if you want to have a familly there, right? Or in Canada where you risk having your bank account frozen if you speak too loud against Trudeau's policies. Where is that freedom you were talking about? Only conditioned depending on beliefs? Yeah, I've seen that in China as well. Do not speak against the regime and you'll be fine. As for USA, I see they have a lot of illegal immigrants raiding stores. I don't see this in China, North Korea or any actual dictatorial country. Or the shootings in USA? Yeah, I'd rather stay far from those as well. Maybe you don't mind the risk, but I do. Different cultural background means different opinions.
Both democracy and autocracy would be great if only both the common people and the leaders would care for both the common people and the country. Too bad that's not the case.
I agree Switzerland is closer to perfect democracy due to allowing citizens to directly contest the law, but because of the average opinion there I wouldn't want to move there. I can't imagine what it's like to be forbidden to have more than 19°C in your home because your country supports a war.
Democracies are just as good as their people are smart and autocracies are just as good as their leaders are smart. I do not agree will all that Churchill said, but only with what can be tested.
I say that we can agree to disagree.
@@Hardcore_RemixerYou really are a very smart person and you say facts and the right things. It’s just that in modern society, “democracy” has already become a cult, where all countries that have sovereignty and the right to their own opinion are accused of dictatorship and autocracy.
Whose definition of democracy? And is there only one methodology of democracy? Who patented it? Is there a patent?
Do you have right to vote?
@@jacktam7673 The Russians have right to vote, are they calling Russia a democracy? The Iraqi have right to vote, and a few thousand political parties, is that a democracy? I can go to the tribes in central Africa and tell them "hey, now you all have right to vote, congrats!" Would that be a democracy?
@@jacktam7673 yea but some of the countries are obviously corrupt with the elections making it so it seems like everyone loves the guy in charges. So you mind as will just not vote.
@@zhaviator well for Russia every vote is a scam cause of well, the dick sucking of Putin system that they have, North Korea was obvious, cause the only one on the fucking ballot is Kimmy 😂 and China I can agree with mostly as well, though capitalism is different than democracy
..
..
..
The patent owner is British monarch(BBC, Sky) & Murican 2 party(CNN, FOX) system.
I'd prefer to see the national boundaries to follow the time instead of marking the electoral democracy index for the "countries" according to contemporary national boundaries on the map. This could cause a lot of confusion and misguided impressions for those who did not have a good idea how the countries around the whole world evolved in the past hundred years or so.
Nice video, every video from you is so interessting. Keep up the good work😊
So what are the basis of these data? Are the real people were surveyed base on population or by the observation of certain group with their biases? We can't just rely on certain reports such as mainstream media and private survey firms.
As someone living in Belarus I can vouch for validity of this information on my side as a belarussuian citizen for over 18 years. Boarding countries looks really correct too, can say that
After seeing this ranking, I can totally say that this video is totally bias. India is a multi party system, and people have right to protest against the government, just now we have seen Farmers Protest and farmers made our government to withdraw the farm law and agnipath protest where people made government to do some changes in the law and government had also responded to people's agitation but still we are being ranked so low. Before that india was very democractic when there was left wing government but now india becomes undemocratic when there is right wing government. Wow good. 👌. U have just placed india at that level like 1975-77 when Emergency was being declared by left wing government and no right wing government was there at that time and no other political parties were there. At that time, india was not a multi party system.
@@swastikayanghosh160 stop spamming
@@oo--7714 I love spamming
@@oo--7714 he's speaking the facts tho...
*Democracy ≠ power of moneybags*
The United States has had the same for of Government this whole time and yet the colors kept changing.
According to US, if you're my puppet you're a democracy 🤡
Source: based on left-wing journalists opinion
I don't think so... they colored the Soviet Union and all the satellite states dark red...and obviously China and other comunists country too..
USA's 2 party system is just one step ahead of chinese 1 party system which makes USA best of democracies. But, India's multi-party system is less democratic compared to USA because it has greater electorial democracy than any other country. Hypocrisy of west especially USA is unmatchable.
中國人不比印度人低等
完全適合民主化
Exactly, We have more than a 100 political parties but still ranked so low.
Moreover this video is also biased against right wing govt be it India under modi or USA under Trump. Democracy falls!
Also, the USA is normally within defective democracy, lower than Taiwan, France ect... while social democracies rule unmatched
It is not about west, western government have some understanding about India but their media and think tanks are very very bias against India.
Yeah USA should be alot lower after 2020 election now that we jail political opponents and suppress political speech
A lot of South America, Southeast Asia, and even India fell in the index score the past decade. World is definitely changing
India is as it always was. Democratic yet autocratic. It always depend on how you want to see it. It could be anarchy sometimes.
As far as electoral democracy goes. Sadly, India is not democracy because India should be one. It is democracy because it makes India stable and no other system can work for India. The debate of democracy is something which India have no luxury of.
Don't trust western data too much. Atleast majority of time, it is related to domestic politics of India. And thus, if Western nation doesn't agree with the view of that political party in the country. This thing is represented in these types of index. Thus, decrease in these types of Index.
@@lostlegend9015 After seeing this ranking, I can say that this video is totally bias. India is a multi party system, and people have right to protest against the government, just now we have seen Farmers Protest and farmers made our government to withdraw the farm law and agnipath protest where people made government to do some changes in the law and government has also responded to people's agitation but still we are being ranked so low. Before that india was very democractic when there was left wing government but now india becomes undemocratic when there is right wing government. Wow good. 👌. He have just placed india at that level like 1975-77 when Emergency was being declared by left wing government and no right wing government was there at that time and no other political parties were there. At that time, india was not a multi party system.
Because Europe was inspiring back then, now that it's in little dark age, all these countries went back on their own
Democracies are failing because it makes room for attacks from other countries
@@leyoshivenere350 I'm sure that it's a global trend not exactly dependent on Europe.
*_Source:_* *_Western Media_* 🥴😂
What? Is a Russian source going to do any better? If a Russian edited this video they would have the west as all dark red and Russia as dark blue., and China and North Korea with just the happy emoji or something
@@galaxyred7 Look at USA becoming more democratic when Obama got elected and less democratic when Trump got elected. No change was made to their system and yet the democracy index changed because USA had a different average perception of the globalism. The democracy index is at its turn decided by a bunch of people from an international identity. A global entity.
@@galaxyred7 A Russian wouldn't do that. That's what a lying scoundrel who stuck to power would do, and they have no nationality
Tient un troll debile
1:07 how are central asia, ukraine, belarus and the baltics diffrent colors? They were both in the same governemnt at the time.
very interesting
As a Hungarian, I'm not disappointed despite corruption and moderate censorship
Your country achieved a somewhat healthy balance between a good economy and good morals. You don't follow the orders of Brussels and for that you earned my respect as a Bulgarian.
There is nothing wrong with censoring soros
@@danielhalachev4714 Hungary is definitely following the orders of Brussels :) He just a freedom fighter only on the level of words.
Чёрных и женщин притесняли в США, а демократии не было в России. Смотрите не перепутайте!
we were doing so well and then in the last few years it started falling...
Having a democratic facade isn't democracy, democracy literally means rule of the people. Where does that happen? If we need a Greek fancy term for capitalism, that's plutocracy, rule of wealth.
My thoughts exactly... The west nowadays are more a plutocracy/oligarchy than a democracy... The big corporations, mainstream media and government are in cahoots behind closed doors
Всему западному обществу желаю вкусить ту демократию, которая была у нас в России в 90е
Демократия != хорошая жизнь) Это просто принадлежность к определенной стае
@@ivan_mustafaev с каких пор наличие денег стало точным/главным показателем хорошей жизни?
Это явно не общая картина
@@ivan_mustafaev деньги это важно, но это далеко не самое главная вещь для жизни.
Зачем сравнивать почти самую богатую страну (в которой помимо денег еще много чего есть) и одну из самых бедных (в которой мало что есть)?
Если же сравнить Россию (в которой у населения не так много денег) и Японию, к примеру, то я лучше бы жил в России (не потому что привык, а из-за возможностей, которые тут есть).
У Японцев вроде деньги есть, но они не вылезают с рабочего места. При этом еще на семью времени мало, а долг страны растет.
И это при том что в России так себе жизнь.
@@ivan_mustafaev лень расписывать, но из первого что приходит в голову:
- очень хреновый климат для работоспособности (желателен умеренный или субтропический)
- исторически нестабильный регион
- кто владеет местораждениями? (я сам не знаю, но подозреваю, что это какие-то европейские или американские компании. или китайские сейчас мб еще подключаются)
@@ivan_mustafaev ну вот вы сами и пишите про "исключения". Но такое есть во многих странах.
Важно смотреть на несколько факторов при оценке качества жизни и перспективности страны. Вы же почему-то зациклены лишь на деньгах (и возможно продолжительности жизни? Предполагаю еще такой ответ)
Costa Rica the only fully democratic country in America 🎉🇨🇷
What is the website called?
In Egypt we've experienced democracy only in 2012 and it was ended by the military coup in 2013
Same for Russia. We had democracy from 1991 to 1993 (till Yeltsin military coup). Technically we had democracy till 2000, but it was anarchy in reality. 90s were such a scary time...
If we don’t have democracy in our workplaces (IE co-ops and strong unions), we don’t really live in a democracy.
Spotted the commie, companies arent countries buddy, communism or socialism or syndicalism never worked and never will, if every worker could vote, they would vote the highest pay for the lowest amount of work, leading to massive inefficiency, thats the reason a cooperative never works, in fact if u want to, u can found a cooperative in any western country, the reason they arent visible is cuz they never succeed due to the aforementioned inefficiencies not because they are illegal
I never supported democracy, specially workplace democracy.
and if you did you'd have "bosses" becoming quasi monarchs as they'd form cliques within the workplace body thus ensuring their election. In a democracy, if you control who counts the votes you control the body.
@@TheRealQuark-vi6ygalright i guess?
@@mrhaci7747 Curtis Yarvin/Mencious Moldbug has already created a political theory that could replace democracy in a far future, and win against the liberal status-quo, the name of this ideology is Dark Enlightenment, or Neoreactionaryism. Search for it, and read some of his books alongs with others from Nick Land, you will finally discover what's wrong with the democratic system and become a redpilled reactionary like me.
Теперь можно сделать графики стран двойных стандартов?
Of course not. Africa and rest of the world needs more of the Glorious USA's Democracy
@@onuryldz4592 ну да, ну да. Иран, Ливия, Югославия, Афганистан и другие уже наслаждаются демократией в полной мере. Нужно больше демократии богу демократии! И плевать на миллионы жизней....
@@idolvlad Because in mind of an obese American(who can't even pinpoint countries in a map);
US, France and Western Countries: Glorious fighter of Democracy, Secularism , Freedom , Liberalism and Human Rights
Russia, Turkey: Opressors, Autocracy , Oligarchy , Fascism , Kleptocracy , Dictatorship and Violation of Human rights
Yet their whole fortune comes from leeching off legacy of Middle Eastern and African sources like a parasites.
@@idolvlad И что? преступления американского империализма никак не оправдывают преступлений российского империализма.
Россия тоже начала войну в Грузии, Чечне и Украине. Также интересы российского империализма есть и в Африке. Из Африки вывозятся алмазы, золото и другие ресурсы с помощью российских наёмников из ЧВК Вагнер.
Нам нужно выступить за поражение всех имперских правительств, нам нужно бороться за настоящую демократию, ведь пока собственность(ресурсы и средства производства) принадлежит 1% людей, пока 99% не могут управлять экономикой через демократические механизмы, тоталитаризм и постоянные войны будут нашей реальностью.
@@Alex-nf6ws В Грузии войну начала Грузия так-то.
2 августа - начало обстрелов в Южной Осетии - под обстрелом находятся грузинские села Лиахвского ущелья. 6 человек погибло, 7 ранены. Осетинской стороной начата эвакуация женщин и детей из Цхинвали, также власти республики призывают добровольцев из республик Северного Кавказа. Цхинвали фактически превращен в военный лагерь.
7 августа - утром грузинская армия сосредотачивается вокруг Цхинвала. Вечером начат массированный обстрел осетинских деревень и постов миротворческих сил. Находящемуся в г. Гори представителю России Попову отказывают во встрече с грузинской стороной. К вечеру обстрел осетинских сёл усиливается.
7 августа - начало штурма Грузией города Цхинвали в Южной Осетии.
8 августа (по другим данным - 7 августа) - ввод подразделений российской 58-й армии на территорию Южной Осетии.
В Чечне был захват власти бандитами, с захватом Верховного Совета ЧИАССР, телецентр и Дома радио. Более 40 депутатов было избито, а председателя грозненского городского совета Виталия Куценко убили, выбросив из окна. В 1992-1993 на территории Чечни было совершено свыше 600 умышленных убийств. За период 1993 года на Грозненском отделении Северо-Кавказской железной дороги подверглись вооружённому нападению 559 поездов с полным или частичным разграблением около 4 тысяч вагонов и контейнеров на сумму 11,5 миллиардов рублей. За 8 месяцев 1994 года было совершено 120 вооружённых нападений, в результате которых разграблено 1156 вагонов и 527 контейнеров. Убытки составили более 11 миллиардов рублей. В 1992-1994 году в результате вооружённых нападений погибло 26 железнодорожников. Сложившаяся ситуация вынудила правительство России принять решение о прекращении движения по территории Чечни с октября 1994 года.
Особым промыслом являлось изготовление фальшивых авизо, по которым было получено более 4 триллионов рублей. В республике процветал захват заложников и работорговля - по данным «Росинформцентра», всего с 1992 года было похищено и незаконно удерживалось в Чечне 1790 человек.
Так что это была операция по избавлению от бандитов. И, кстати, в 2003 в Чечне проводился референдум, который показал, что большинству чеченского народа важнее быть в составе России, а не в отдельной стране, похожей на Сомали.
И на Украине тоже войну начала НЕ Россия. Её объявил Турчинов в 2014. А Россия в неё вмешалась только в 2022, опять же, по приглашению от стороны конфликта, от независимых республик ДНР и ЛНР, после заключения союза с ними.
Россия войны не начинает, Россия их заканчивает.
Given that rights are easily taken away if there isnt a way to defend them any country on this map without the means of the people to protect these rights should be lowered on the list. My guess is this isnt taken into account in the estimates.
It's a bit confusing, because the map didn't show border changes.
Asia in 1964: We are red!
India: Think again.
Why are you giving countries with distorted misreprentation the same rank as those with proportional representation?
Brazilian democracy is at serious danger
2016: 0.8-0.9
2021: 0.6-0.7
And this does not include 2022 which here in brazil there were many democracy movements.
Propaganda
The democracy index is politically based. Looke at USA droping slightly in 2016 without any change in their system. It's just because Trump got elected then.
It's all for the show. If lean even slightly agajnst globalism then you are less democratic.
Fortunately Brazil likely came back to a blue color since last year 😊
Democracy: Left-wing
Dictatorship: Right-wing
@@DoisMitosEmBuscaDeAventuras So the Soviet Union was demo ratic? Nice one!
Or maybe Biden's administration in USA? I heard that political persecution is pretty authoritarian and yet his administration is all over Trump almost like Russia's secret services were over Navalnyi. Or has Biden been right wing all along? 😂
I'm from India and 40 years old but I enjoying full democracy in my country... doesn't meaning this type of graf..
After seeing this ranking, I can totally say that this video is totally bias. India is a multi party system, and people have right to protest against the government, just now we have seen Farmers Protest and farmers made our government to withdraw the farm law and agnipath protest where people made government to do some changes in the law and government has also responded to people's agitation but still we are being ranked so low. Long ago, india was democractic when there was a left wing government ruling but now india became an undemocratic country since the right wing government came to reign. Wow logic. 👌. He placed india at that level even during 1975-77 when Emergency was being declared by our left wing government in the country and no right wing government or any other political parties were there at that time. At that time, india was not a multi party system.
@@swastikayanghosh160 yes you are right..
Try visiting other countries like Germany Japan and USA. You'll realise India is not much democratic than them.
@@tgburn6984 I already travelled more than 14 countries.. and I know very well usa democracy about dark people
I google democracy index and:
Rank Country Score Classification
36. USA 0.811 Deficient democracy
85. India 0.564 Hybrid regime
Yes USA is not the best country but it is much better than India. The democracy you enjoying might not be for everyone in your country.
After 1940 things changed and after 1945 it did again
Ukraine is more democratic than Turkey and some other yellow nations. They have elections and 6 presidents in 30 years. It also is parliamentary-presidential republic. In 1917-1918 it was republic so no complete red. Constitution of Pylyp Orlyk a constitutional document written by the Hetman of Ukraine, Pylyp Orlyk,[1] the Cossack elders and the Cossacks of the Zaporozhian Army on the 5 April 1710.
That was not a "constitution" in modern sense of the word however.
In 1900, Australia and New Zealand had already been one of the highest in the world.
Ну не знаю про Скандинавию. Там преследуют противников ЛГБТ, а это не очень демократично
Surely British was so democracy so elegant so beautiful just like a wow
I know right?
В общем, чем лояльнее к США, тем светлее
Ага, тоже заметил)
The fact that not every country is a democracy disgusts me.
Yeah, Autocrat-punks fuck off
Also, the fact that all those blue countries killed and looted Indians, Africans, Australian Aborginals, Americans, etc disgusts me as well.
СССР при Сталине в 1952 более демократично, чем СССР в 1964?
Смешно. 😅
Понятно, кто все эти рейтинги составляет.
I thought mauritania will be even more red because of its flag referendum in 2017 but ok whatever works in mauritania works in mauritania
For The Economist, France have been a "flawed democracy" almost every year since 2010 which means it shouldn't be blue. Currently Brazil is closer to France than Canada. There are other countries that are blue here and that are flawed democraties.
Below, I give just one good reason why my country is currently a "flawed democracy" (there is much more to say about it, and there are probably things we don't know).
This year, the president has cheated to be reelected. How? Just like in most democraties, there is a debate before elections. Our president said he wouldn't attend the debate usually organized before the first round, and then, the TV channel that was supposed to organize it, cancelled it, and replaced it with monologues so he could participate without having to justify his nonsensical program and past actions. What should have happened, in a real democracy, is the TV channel doesn't care about this clown and keeps organizing a real debate with the candidates who want to attend it. At the second round, he attended the debate probably because his opponent was a nationalist that isn't too dangerous for him in a debate.
Don’t even bother typing all this. You make good points and I agree with you, but this map is garbage. It’s so wrong that it’s take too long to correct the creator.
I assume you're from Brazil.
@@nomenomeha30anosatras33 você é brasileiro? Pelo nome do usuário eu suponho que sim!
This is level of electoral democracy according to v-dem data. The Economist Intelligence Unit uses a broader definition on democracy, while this is strictly limited to the electoral process itself
Where is the source?
liberal democracy is a method of control, there can be only one democracy hegemony (Anglos, where politicians are front man of oligs. Trump an outsider hence the shit show), other democracies are varying degree of weaker form, because for example: CZcams algorithm feeds your info, an Anglo platform.
You sound like Hitler if his boogeyman were the English
propaganda
FBI raids political rival of incumbent president and still usa is democratic 😂😂.
If you mean Trump, bro he makes crimes as civilian. Important is that investigations are independent from government
@@German_Patriot1 Investigations are independant from the gouvernment. The FBI stopped the investigations over the coke that was found in the White House during Biden's term. Political bias at its finest.
How is Australia light blue in 1925. Women didn't get the right to vote until 1978.
Почём демократия, дядя Сэм?
"democracy" just fine word.
New zealand just chilling
Как Россия может быть авторитарнее в 1967 году, чем другие союзные республики.?
How do you define democracy?
Take the red pill
Free rights independent from cultural background or ethnic group. Free elections, equal chance for every party and no political influence in justice and investigations.
@@German_Patriot1 So what if I vote for my cultural background? What if the majority does so? Does the will of the people make a democracy flawed? If not, then the free rights indeoendant from cultural background and such can fly out the door.
Free elections, yes. Equal chance, not really. People have a cultural background and it will influence our decisions ragarding the vote. This can give a marxist progresivist party little to no chance to get a majority a country where any religion is taken seriously. Same for the chances of a party which roots its ideas in any religion in a country where atheism bias is more popular. Even life doesn't give equal chance to different people.
To me it is simple: full democracy as it was initially meant to be means the will of the people is law regardless of what external sources say (this includes UN and all the international entities, not only other countries). Whether it has one party or more is a different topic. It's really funny that different people add different stuff to make the definition biased for their political views.
Why is Philippines is red in 1965 to 1986
because of dictatorship i think like Marcos i guess
Just FALSE. Try make a video about eastern hypocrises and imperialism around the world!
It is incredible how Brasil can not develop a healthy democracy....
1991~2017
(Respondendo em português mesmo): a tendência é piorar à partir de 2023, com um sujeito que deveria estar atrás das grades e no qual seu principal advogado janta com um ministro do STF, reconhecidamente parcial e que vive praticando ativismo judicial (Barroso).
Só tirar a reeleição que melhora mais...
Brazil Being a "healthy democracy" form 91-17 is definively a JOKE. (só pra constar eu sou Brasileiro e vivi esses anos)
funny how Brazil developed better at the time of the monarchy in which the king had the power and during the dictatorships of the republic, for example the dictator Getúlio Vargas, considered the best president of Brazil.
Wish it was up to 2022 because the US has changed alot these last 2 years and is considered a flawed democracy (0.6-0.8) and is continuing to fall
Shoutout to North Korea for staying dark red this whole time!
Im very supprise that my country, Vietnam, have the same color as Thailand even though my country is communist
don't take it so serious. Everyone define democracy differently, get to vote doesnt mean get to be represented.
The USA, ahah. Yeah.
the united states is not a democracy but a constitutional republic that uses democratic procedures to elect certain officials
What the democracy means to ordinary people? is it just the votes in hands?
China is a slavery state. You don't feel it until you reach that.
Not only that it also includes freedom of speech, equality given to all the religion, language.., Less hatred speech against particular set of people in a country, no same leader for more than 1 term, freedom to know what is happening in government, speak against government, peace with most countries..! and a lot more, yeah democrazy is more colourful than we think
According to this video, democracy always falls under a Right Wing Government. Please don't reflect your personal political views on this video.
Yes, As Lenin said Freedom in capitalist society always remains about the same as it was in the ancient Greek republics: freedom for the slaveowners. Owing to the conditions of capitalist exploitation, the modern wage slaves are so crushed by want and poverty that “they cannot be bothered with democracy,” “cannot be bothered with politics”; in the ordinary, peaceful course of events, the majority of the population is debarred from participation in public and political life. “ - Vladimir Lenin, Russian politician, anti-war activist, one of the leaders of the October Revolution.
What's even wrong with being against democracy?
Wow, my country Morocco is 0.2!
Nice! We improved from that 0.0!
Ну вы поняли короче. Демократия с точки зрения запада, это когда средства производства принадлежат барыгам. А всё остальное вроде народнуластия и прав граждан это несущественные мелочи.
Most of this video, especially the early part, makes very little sense.
До создания СССР, территории нынешних Финляндии, Польши, Украины и других стран, входящих ранее в РИ, являлись частью Российской Империи. Так какого чёрта в них демократии больше, чем в России?! С нулевой секунды понял, что видео - бред
Finland and Poland was autonomous within the Russian empire, and after 1905 the Finnish parliament was like any other in Western Europe, it just didn't have executive power. I agree Ukraine makes no sense
Потому что они развивали демократию у себя все эти годы, а не скатывались в диктатуру из-за обиды на весь мир.
1:44~1:54 the most democratic world and Democracy are not forever..
Yellow possible is real Democracy than blue
How the world changed in more of 100 years going through different events and social struggles, although there is still a long way to go to achieve the common welfare.
We lost all the welfare people now lives like rats in cages this is the worst society we ever had in history
What is the common welfare? Communism?
Inequality always has been and always will be, that is the essence of biological life.
@@benjamingrant3441 Nah
@@duckmercy11yeah. Work or starve.
@@steviechubbs5238 Nah
This is somewhat biased.
Reading this comment section just make me think: What the fuck?
Same
CIS countries in 1901 - The history we deserves.
US army located in blue.
Демократия - это когда 51% людей решает за остальные 49%
而專制則是0.000001%的人為另外的99.999999%的人做決定
то есть демократия - это автократия в малой степени @@user-vu9ex9sx5u
你们民众也是被媒体和既得利益集团洗脑的啊，你真以为自己决定事情？@@user-vu9ex9sx5u
This couldn't be less relavant for the rest of the world but my country went from blue to cyan in 2017 for literally no reason. As far as I know, nothing special happened here at that time...
Democracy gives power to the people (demos: people, kratos: power). Elections don’t do that.
Lol. Suggest making a video of economic development by country from 1900-2021. You will surprisely see how the "least democrat" country - China has deveoped from a poor country to the second biggest economic power during this period. So, my question is: deveopment is the result of democracy, or democracy is the result of development? or, maybe we may rephrase the question as follow: if ask a poor man to choose between democracy and development, which will hechoose? At least for me, I am tiried of the fancy words such as freedom, democracy, I like the real development that changes my living quality to a better level.
Personal question: do YOU feel like your vote matters, do YOU feel safe and protected in your country? If so, you can count it as democratic. If you're okay with living as tool, than fine with me. I don't
You are living like a tool in your country, or you are just a disposable product which is used and thrown.🤡
@@Oosjhteuikmm living as tool? You mean working for housing and health care? labor in capitlistic society? So passive aggressive... you obviously don't know how Chinese system work. Most of time when a country experiencing growith slowing down or stagnation, the people started to be more aware and sensitive to politic, China just didn't experience the slow down for a while untill recently
@@Oosjhteuikmm Of course I fee safe and protected. If you like, you may check the change of average life expectancy in China during the same period. Now Chinese people have lived much older than before. This is a vivid evidence that Chinese people are safer and more protected than before. How can average people live so long, if they are not safe and well protected?
Yea if you live in the merge cities but let me remind you not every one lives in the mega cities of China in fact most people don’t. just go out of your bubble and walk out of the cities and you will find a whole different world in planet China and let me tell you is not pretty
USA from 2008-2016: dark blue
USA in 2016: light blue
don't let your personal opinions affect the video.
Democracy index is a thing. For USA it dropped in 2016 because those who decide it are biased for globalism and the republican party doesn't allign well enough with globalism as they intend it to be.
Getulio's Vargas Brazil is more authoritarian than Stalin's Soviet Union during the 30s LOL
well this is nonsense. ill move along, come with me and dont pay attention to it
"Every country has the government it deserves" Joseph de Maistre
Wrong on absolutely so many levels
Yes, voting right is one of the human rights!
Half right half wrong
Western countries have no right to depose of leaders they dont like
But if they are doing a terrible job(who the westerners usually like) they deserve to be disposed
Jeez you're so smart, might delete this already, no?
@@amritprajapati6075 some countries got dealt extremely bad hands by their colonial overlords. Europe ruined Africa
India 😳💀
"I love the democracy"
Botswana is more free than Poland?
No more blue, blue is dead, red will never die, red is one of best glorious color. ♥️
"All hail the red imperium, purge all xeno scums"
蜘蛛别叫了，该测核酸了，小心等下大白打你屁股
Blue is best color
@@yyygamer8559 HERETIC!!! Red is best color. Exterminatus will destroy you... ♥️♥️♥️💅
The democracy index is politically biased for globalism. USA's democracy index grew in 2008 when Obama got elected and dropped in 2016 when Trump got elected despite no change was made to the system.
It's just a political bias for globalism.
"А судьи кто?"
Нет судей. Там есть определенные критерии, типо насколько много всяких проблем и фальсификаций с выборами, насколько хорошее свобода слова, свобода митингов и т.д.
@@haseryvonyahasi судьи всегда есть. Даже в самой справедливой системе
@@benjamingrant3441 Что там судить-то? Статистика-то и так открытая и общеизвестная, просто сложить и суммировать, и получишь определенные цифры. Тут же не о каких-то абстрактных и нематериальных вещах говорится, чтобы прям уж "судить".
@@haseryvonyahasi почитайте книгу "Как лгать при помощи статистики" Дарелл Хафф. Чтобы понять как можно составить и исказить любую статистику себе на пользу
0:57 Last human zoo is closed in Europe.
US pre 1960s was too high cuz of segregation other than that
Good video