Clarification: During the video I mentioned that A'isha and Talha, after the martyrdom of Uthman, were "seeking his blood." To "seek his blood" is an Arabic idiom for "avenge him." I should have made this clear in the video.
If Ali r.z was the rigthly guided 4th Caliph then why did Hz Ayesha and Talha , Zubair went against Ali r.z Also Mention why Zubair abandoned the Army? as he left army after having a conversation with Ali r.z
@@SA-rz7fw well, your question proposes a perspective to the reader that either 1) Imam a.s wasnt a rightly guided caliph or 2) Hazrat Ayesha, talha, zubair (ra) were hypocrites For imam Ali to be a rightly guided caliph, he doesnt need validation from anybody. its decided on what the majority believes, as even in the time of abu bakr r.a, saad ibn ubadah and ali a.s didnt give allegiance to him. but that doesnt invalidate his caliphate. Also talhah and zubair did pay their allegiance to Ali a.s, even the mother of believers suggested alot of tabeein to give allegiance to Ali a.s after the martyrdom of utham ibn affam r.a. Now the second point, were they hypocrites, the clear answer to that is no and this answer is given by imam ali a.s, he was asked about them, and he said neither they are kuffar nor munafiqeen. Even imam ali a.s praised Zubair and talha during jamal, they only came to avenge the group that has killed uthman and that group happened to be hidden among the people who payed allegiance to ali a.s and this doesnt mean ali a.s was saving them, it was just the caliphate became really weak after uthama's death and he didnt want islamic system to go downfall after reaching such a status. but that group later came out as khawarij probably who imam ali a.s himself fought. at the end, talha and zubair were martyred we have alot of references where repentance of mother of believers is recorded. May Allah be pleased with them All.
May Allah have mercy on Uthman, the 3rd Rashidun caliph. He was the 3rd greatest man after all the Prophets. Without him, the Quran would not have been preserved. May Allah be pleased with him and have mercy on his soul.
If I'm not wrong this video's were recorded when Farid was with Sunnah Defence, thanks for this history class ya akhi. Eid Mubarak to all muslim brothers and sisters.
@@handler654 I'm pretty sure Farid used to make more longer lecture style videos. But in his previous uploads, you'll see him more with other genre of videos, primarily reaction/responses/refutations.
May Allaah ﷻ bless Uthman (رضي اللّٰه عنه) and may He reunite us with Rasoolullaah ﷺ and his companions (may Allaah be pleased with them all) in Al-Firdous Al-a'laa.
Very interesting . I'm not Muslim but interested in early Arab history. Your videos are very interesting, only problem for non-muslim amateur historians like me are the terms you use regularly, fitnah, Hijrah, hadith etc but I'm getting used to them. Maybe one day you could do a video aimed at explaining to non-Muslims the terms used in Arabic Islamic history, their origin, meaning etc. It would be interesting.
As an Arab amateur historian interested in both Arab and European history, I would be more than happy to help with that. If you’re interested just let me know how to contact you.
Wallahi this is what I was hoping of hearing. I need to know what happened and why because these are all people that were promised paradise so it definitely has an impact on me.
Thank you Fareed. You won't believe it, but I was just watching one of your Part 1 uthman video on some other channel that was posted 1 year ago.it's a pleasant surprise. Thanks for the video
R .A . should be mentioned please show the companions R.A the respect that they are deserving of Allah SWT was pleased with them and so was the beloved prophet pbuh also Respect them brother
What is or are the salutations for Zakaria, Yahya, Yeshua Hamashiach, Gabriel, and Mikaal pbuthem? Is Yeshua Hamashiach dead? Is Gabriel dead? Arabs have become faasiqoon
This is VERY INTERESTING. I dont remember any armies attacking madina, and I remember reading books about this in a VERY shiii book. I've heard about QaQa in that book. There was also in another book that Marwan the cousin of Uthman (RA) was influencing him. Oooh, I remember the stories about the nepotism in that book as well as the mistreatment of prominent Sahaba. I kind of always thought that relatives out into power were lazy and no good. I remember the drinking hadeeth. There is this thing that the Kufans were ALWAYS dissatisfied with their rulers.
Subhannallah a few days back i was just going through farids channel to see if he had a video clarifing these matters as i could not find anything reliable on the internet. I guess Allah works in mysterious ways
Eid Mubarak everyone. subhanAllah was thinking why isnt this on farids channel. Great lecture. What about Karbala inshAllah will you post it on ur channel as well
3:24 hatim fatwa 4:10 main sources, 5:09 best source 8:13 best contemporary source 9:20 Jar’a 12:20 supposed letter by Uthman, his assassination 16:10 3 things Aisha was angered with Uthman - 18:02 the relatives put into power 26:00 issues at Kufa 29:54 people exiled by Uthman 31:52 pro-Uthman sahaba
@@ashleyjason5608 There are no such things called shia sources since there is no narrations to their sources. The Shia origins are secretive cultists whose sources can not be authenticated and what they consider sources is nothing but lies to support their cultist believes.
@@lamdal30 typical ignorant wahabi Talha was the one who incited people to kill Uthman "Shii have no narrations to sources" lmao Your Bukhari and Muslim have literally narrated hadith from a person who was cursed by Prophet pbuh himself and that guy was nobody but Muawiyah bin Abi Sufyan
A query regarding Hadeeth of Ammar b Yassir. Prophet mentioned a community which invites you to jahannum will kill Ammar b yasir is that pointing towards opponents in siffin?
Brother if you understand Urdu, Shaykh Abu Yahya Noorpuri has answered this long ago. If you want a bit of english infused urdu then De Hafiz Muhammad Zubair, he has a 72 part video on these issues
@@waliullah2391 dont know it was pretty satisfying for me. In another Riwayah it mentions that Ali RadiAllahu Anhu's group is أقرب to the Truth. Ie. Closer. This type of word neccesitates that the other group is also close to the truth, but Ali RadiAllahuAnhu's is more closer.
شيخ فريد وفقكم الله لكل خير.. أحبك في الله وهذا سبب الكتابة لك.. أولا: الخوض فيما شجر بين الصحابة مزلة قدم حتى وإن كان الاعتماد على الروايات الصحيحة فقط على منهج المحدثين لان الكلام عن ما شجر بينهم يجعل السامع يميل لأحد الطرفين المتنازعين ويتحامل على الآخر وهذا خطر على عقيدة المسلم. ثانيا: حاتم العوني رجل منحرف عن السنة وجدير أن يُحذر منه ويجتنب طرحه تماما، حيث أصبح مؤخرا أقرب للتصوف والتشيع من السنة، وهو إن كان ليس شيعيا متصوفا فهو أشعري مناوئ لدعوة الشيخ محمدبن عبدالوهاب ومتحامل عليها بل وحاقد والله المستعان.. 💐 وفقكم الله
13:25 أخي فريد وفقك الله وجزاك كل خير .. بس في ملاحظة بسيطة ولست أهلا للعلم ولا التصحيح ربما، لكن صادف عندما بحثت عن القاتل "المرجح" الذي ذكرته حضرتك أنني وجدت: "سودان بن حمران" - المرادي -، وآخر هو "كنانة بن بشر بن عتاب التجيبي".. هل هو كذلك؟ ربما حصل لبس، أو سهوا ربط الاسمان سوية في الفيديو؟ Jazak Allah Khair, Ustadh Farid!
Akhi I don't know if you read this but can you elaborate on amir Ibn hamiq. Was he a sahabi during the bay'ah of ridhwan and was he involved in the martyrdom of our master Uthman?
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM. Or exiling Sahaba.... Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
I promise you شيخ فريد if you did a video on condemning Israel for what they did to القدس والمسلمين في فلسطين المحتلة I will watch your video from start to end much love from البحرين.
What does مجلس mean were the guard of saeed bin al aas was beaten up along with hes son by Kooffuns for wishing that saeed ibn al aas owned their land so he could be generous?
I was expecting some background and authentic information on the letter to the governor of Egypt that the rebels caught and came back to Madinah accusing Usman RA of sending that letter with his stamp of authority on it from the ring that Khalifa used to wear in those times?? What is the closest truth about it?? Anyone
Didn't Mohammed Bin Abu Bakr Repented and ran away after grabbing Uthman by the beard and After Uthman told him to leave a beard that your father honored. So he ran before the death of Uthaman am I right? And didn't Aisha actually took some action and made them go easy on him even if it was temporary and wasn't she the one supplying him with water. I could be wrong can someone correct me.
It troubles me SO MUCH that I’m hearing that Aisha ra was seeking the blood of Uthman ra. I never ever knew that and I’m still doubting I don’t know what. I’m confused . After doing my little search, I refuse to accept that Aisha ever helped/preached for/called out to kill Uthman. There is no good source that tell us this and it’s great injustice to say such a thing about both Aisha the mother of the believers and Uthman ra
I think this should be more in depth and organised with presentation. This history is vital for people to understand even now the ummah are misled by being given false information. People get emotional and lead to further chaos not only from Islamic point of view but in general we make asumptions about someone based on rumors and our actions can lead to khurooj and a fitna for coming generations
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM. Or exiling Sahaba.... Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
There is no true or false information. History from the middle ages has ben written and re written so many times based on the agendas of who was narrating, hard to say who was right and who was wrong. You just have to accept that there was political turmoil, and everyone wanted that rich arab money. Death of Uthman and later state troubles were all because of that.
The exile of those people from kufa, did that happen some times before the final seize, meaning that's what led to the seize? Or was it much earlier, which led them to spread propaganda against Uthman Ra. ?
This is a wonderful exposition. Thanks for putting in the research and sharing this. A question: A'isha's argument about nepotism may not necessarily be that Uthman's appointments were not just people but rather he passed up on more component and esteemed companions. Do you think maybe that is where she is coming from? Again, thanks so much for this wonderful work and grateful if you can put together more historical analysis like this.
To farid did malik al ashtar have a role in killing as we know many rebels they simply wanted uthman radiallahuanhu to step down but not kill him and were not involved on that
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM. Or exiling Sahaba.... Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
he put marwan in power and people got mad because Muhammad (A.S) kicked him out of the land and Osman called him back and put him as the leader. The leader of kufa he appointed used to drink while praying and in the qauran it says he is a liar. He also put someone in power for egypt that used to harm muslims and Egyptians even came to complain bout it and he did nothing .
Uthman was a great man who would rather die than call an army to crush even rebel even though he could easily do that. He is also the only man ever existed whom Rasulullah ﷺ chosed to marry not just 1 of his daughter, but 2 daughters. If hes a good man for Rasulullah ﷺ then hes a good man for me.
Clarification: During the video I mentioned that A'isha and Talha, after the martyrdom of Uthman, were "seeking his blood." To "seek his blood" is an Arabic idiom for "avenge him." I should have made this clear in the video.
If Ali r.z was the rigthly guided 4th Caliph then why did Hz Ayesha and Talha , Zubair went against Ali r.z
Also Mention why Zubair abandoned the Army? as he left army after having a conversation with Ali r.z
@@SA-rz7fw Watch the second video in the series
Sheikh Farid please recommend some good Islamic history books English.
@@SA-rz7fw
well, your question proposes a perspective to the reader that either
1) Imam a.s wasnt a rightly guided caliph or
2) Hazrat Ayesha, talha, zubair (ra) were hypocrites
For imam Ali to be a rightly guided caliph, he doesnt need validation from anybody. its decided on what the majority believes, as even in the time of abu bakr r.a, saad ibn ubadah and ali a.s didnt give allegiance to him. but that doesnt invalidate his caliphate. Also talhah and zubair did pay their allegiance to Ali a.s, even the mother of believers suggested alot of tabeein to give allegiance to Ali a.s after the martyrdom of utham ibn affam r.a.
Now the second point, were they hypocrites, the clear answer to that is no and this answer is given by imam ali a.s, he was asked about them, and he said neither they are kuffar nor munafiqeen. Even imam ali a.s praised Zubair and talha during jamal,
they only came to avenge the group that has killed uthman and that group happened to be hidden among the people who payed allegiance to ali a.s and this doesnt mean ali a.s was saving them, it was just the caliphate became really weak after uthama's death and he didnt want islamic system to go downfall after reaching such a status. but that group later came out as khawarij probably who imam ali a.s himself fought.
at the end, talha and zubair were martyred
we have alot of references where repentance of mother of believers is recorded.
May Allah be pleased with them All.
@@SA-rz7fw he took the caliphate by force
May Allah have mercy on Uthman, the 3rd Rashidun caliph. He was the 3rd greatest man after all the Prophets. Without him, the Quran would not have been preserved. May Allah be pleased with him and have mercy on his soul.
Ameen
Ameen
ameen
Ameen
u
If I'm not wrong this video's were recorded when Farid was with Sunnah Defence, thanks for this history class ya akhi.
Eid Mubarak to all muslim brothers and sisters.
Ah, the vintage _Ustadh Farid_ . Now he's just 'CZcamsr Farid'.
what do you mean?
@@handler654 I'm pretty sure Farid used to make more longer lecture style videos. But in his previous uploads, you'll see him more with other genre of videos, primarily reaction/responses/refutations.
Lol
May Allaah ﷻ bless Uthman (رضي اللّٰه عنه) and may He reunite us with Rasoolullaah ﷺ and his companions (may Allaah be pleased with them all) in Al-Firdous Al-a'laa.
Ameen Peace be upon Uthman Al Ghani
Beautiful, in the part explaining the merits of Uthmaan it’s important to mention his love for the book of Allah as well.
Wonderful analysis akhi. Jumping onto the video on battle of the Camel right away!
Such good timing for this, BarakAllahu fik.
Eid Mubarak
Eid mubarak
Jazakalluhkhairan for all these videos
Eid Mubarak ustadh farid❤️. These two videos are the best عيدية I've ever got. Jazakaallah khairan.
Thank you for this beautifully explained lecture. May Allah reward you. ❤❤
Yes. Many thanks for this. I hope we are going to have more.
Very much needed video Ya akhi.
Mash’allah!!! Excellently presented
Akhi, can you please do videos like this on what happened to Ali رضي الله عنه?
@@ituuali4744 Don’t bring emotions into this, there’s authentic Hadiths to back up what’s he saying unlike you, all you got is myths and fabrications.
@@ituuali4744 lol you shouldn't have taken the cocaine you took before putting this comment
How is this about weak narrations??? The guy is literally asking about the life of Hazrat Ali RA
@@s.m.hozaifahossain5504 can you tell me what he wrote?
Very interesting . I'm not Muslim but interested in early Arab history. Your videos are very interesting, only problem for non-muslim amateur historians like me are the terms you use regularly, fitnah, Hijrah, hadith etc but I'm getting used to them. Maybe one day you could do a video aimed at explaining to non-Muslims the terms used in Arabic Islamic history, their origin, meaning etc. It would be interesting.
As an Arab amateur historian interested in both Arab and European history, I would be more than happy to help with that. If you’re interested just let me know how to contact you.
Hey man hope your doing well. My brother come to the truth and come to Islam. The Oneness of Allah
Thank you Farid. Can you please do a lecture on Siffeen also in light of sahih narrations.
MashaAllah.. If I had brother like you, I would bother you everyday to teach me more :D
جزاكم الله خيرا
_The best authentic source of these issues have been discussed by Ashraf Ghareeb channel_
Wallahi this is what I was hoping of hearing. I need to know what happened and why because these are all people that were promised paradise so it definitely has an impact on me.
MashaAllah... Love you bro.💖💖
Eid Mubarak Ustadh Farid! 🤲🏾💖
Halal homer on farids channel were one big family all of us Muslims
@@istabrakjameel for sure👏🏾
Do you knows his Instagram?
@@razmakhadem2802 I don’t think he has Instagram.
Eid mubarak bro!
بارك الله فيك
Thank you Fareed. You won't believe it, but I was just watching one of your Part 1 uthman video on some other channel that was posted 1 year ago.it's a pleasant surprise. Thanks for the video
It was previously posted on hijab's channel but yeah this vid is not new
R .A . should be mentioned please show the companions R.A the respect that they are deserving of
Allah SWT was pleased with them and so was the beloved prophet pbuh also
Respect them brother
What is or are the salutations for Zakaria, Yahya, Yeshua Hamashiach, Gabriel, and Mikaal pbuthem?
Is Yeshua Hamashiach dead?
Is Gabriel dead?
Arabs have become faasiqoon
Thanks bro!
I just realized that you are doing this lecture on eid, as the day I'm writing this is 5th of shawwal
عيد مبارك يا اخي تقبل الله منكم 💗
ya farid , it would be prefered if the questions are repeated before getting answered , jazakallah khair
This is VERY INTERESTING. I dont remember any armies attacking madina, and I remember reading books about this in a VERY shiii book. I've heard about QaQa in that book. There was also in another book that Marwan the cousin of Uthman (RA) was influencing him. Oooh, I remember the stories about the nepotism in that book as well as the mistreatment of prominent Sahaba. I kind of always thought that relatives out into power were lazy and no good. I remember the drinking hadeeth. There is this thing that the Kufans were ALWAYS dissatisfied with their rulers.
It's crazy how mohamed ibn abi bakr son and grandson were top scholars of madinah
Mohammed wasn't a scholar.
@@FaridResponds I know I said his son and his grandson
Qasim ibn Mohamed
And abdurrahman ibn Qasim who maalik narrates from
Anyone else think about shaykh uthamn ibn farooq after reading the title?
Subhannallah a few days back i was just going through farids channel to see if he had a video clarifing these matters as i could not find anything reliable on the internet. I guess Allah works in mysterious ways
Eid Mubarak everyone. subhanAllah was thinking why isnt this on farids channel. Great lecture. What about Karbala inshAllah will you post it on ur channel as well
@@ituuali4744 why didnt the shias debate with him when he came to the uk then. Taqiyyah on.
حفظك الله ورعاك
Eid mubarak ikhwan
Eid Mubarak.
May Allah bless you
Khair Mubarak
Eid Mubarak
هل حديث الرسول عليه الصلاة والسلام عن عثمان رضي الله عنه انه عند مماته راح يفتح باب الفتن او شيء من هالقبيل ؟
May Allah forgive Othman . Eid Mubarak .May Allah gives us happiness nd forgiveness ❤
Ameen
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Is there a part two to this? Cant seem to find
Scroll down on his page
Assalam o Alikum ! Brother Fareed, when would you do a Lecture on The Battle of Siffin ? & Eid Mubarak. 😀😊
@ftm mtf Hmm..And you, Crucified mentality Person😆😂
His did a lecture on Battle of Karbala, you should watch that
@@commandogamerz6544 I have and I have already read the authentic version years before his lecture.
3:24 hatim fatwa
4:10 main sources, 5:09 best source
8:13 best contemporary source
9:20 Jar’a
12:20 supposed letter by Uthman, his assassination
16:10 3 things Aisha was angered with Uthman
- 18:02 the relatives put into power
26:00 issues at Kufa
29:54 people exiled by Uthman
31:52 pro-Uthman sahaba
اخي لو سمحت ممكن ترد. انا سمعت تسجيل للشيخ الالباني ينفي اشتراك محمد بن ابي بكر في مقتل عثمان. حتى ابن عبد البر انكر هذا. ممكن التوضيح؟
We need more of these insha allah. Keep them coming. ❤️🥰
Accusing Mohammad bin abi Bakr of killing Othman complicates the issue and raises the question of why would Ali appoint him governor of Egypt.
Exactly this whole" fitna " doesn't.make sense. Maybe we should read shia sources maybe it.will.make.sense
@@ashleyjason5608
There are no such things called shia sources since there is no narrations to their sources. The Shia origins are secretive cultists whose sources can not be authenticated and what they consider sources is nothing but lies to support their cultist believes.
@@lamdal30 typical ignorant wahabi
Talha was the one who incited people to kill Uthman
"Shii have no narrations to sources" lmao
Your Bukhari and Muslim have literally narrated hadith from a person who was cursed by Prophet pbuh himself and that guy was nobody but Muawiyah bin Abi Sufyan
@@ashleyjason5608 nope, reading sources from shia whose imam said lying taqiyya is 9/10 of religion is not a good idea
@@gilabola4642 my man you're very good man
Farid is going through history as a historian. Remember people when its comes to sahabah we also have there characters praised in the Quran.
Can someone wrote for me what is the name of the best source that Farid said?
Tarikh Madina by Umar
I did not find part 2 did I missed it or I miss understand 😅
Can I get the full name of the contemporary book written about maktal uthman please?
A query regarding Hadeeth of Ammar b Yassir. Prophet mentioned a community which invites you to jahannum will kill Ammar b yasir is that pointing towards opponents in siffin?
Yes important question brother farid please notice it...!
Yes. Because Ammar bin Yasir was martyred in siffeen.
Brother if you understand Urdu, Shaykh Abu Yahya Noorpuri has answered this long ago. If you want a bit of english infused urdu then De Hafiz Muhammad Zubair, he has a 72 part video on these issues
@@ahmads5889 yes I listen both of them but its not that satisfied
@@waliullah2391 dont know it was pretty satisfying for me. In another Riwayah it mentions that Ali RadiAllahu Anhu's group is أقرب to the Truth. Ie. Closer. This type of word neccesitates that the other group is also close to the truth, but Ali RadiAllahuAnhu's is more closer.
حفظ الله الأخ الفاضل فريد البحريني
شيخ فريد وفقكم الله لكل خير..
أحبك في الله وهذا سبب الكتابة لك..
أولا: الخوض فيما شجر بين الصحابة مزلة قدم حتى وإن كان الاعتماد على الروايات الصحيحة فقط على منهج المحدثين لان الكلام عن ما شجر بينهم يجعل السامع يميل لأحد الطرفين المتنازعين ويتحامل على الآخر وهذا خطر على عقيدة المسلم.
ثانيا: حاتم العوني رجل منحرف عن السنة وجدير أن يُحذر منه ويجتنب طرحه تماما، حيث أصبح مؤخرا أقرب للتصوف والتشيع من السنة، وهو إن كان ليس شيعيا متصوفا فهو أشعري مناوئ لدعوة الشيخ محمدبن عبدالوهاب ومتحامل عليها بل وحاقد والله المستعان..
💐
وفقكم الله
Allah reward you for making that clear ,
Ameen
Alhamdulillah those two videos are back again
I think increace the size of the reservation is a better translation than fortification (الحمى)
A FRESHHH VIDEO ALHAMDULILAH
Do you have any lecture on siffin ? Please let me know
Can anyone send me the.. Pdf of the best book .. Which he talked abt...
13:25
أخي فريد وفقك الله وجزاك كل خير .. بس في ملاحظة بسيطة ولست أهلا للعلم ولا التصحيح ربما، لكن صادف عندما بحثت عن القاتل "المرجح" الذي ذكرته حضرتك أنني وجدت:
"سودان بن حمران" - المرادي -، وآخر هو "كنانة بن بشر بن عتاب التجيبي".. هل هو كذلك؟ ربما حصل لبس، أو سهوا ربط الاسمان سوية في الفيديو؟
Jazak Allah Khair, Ustadh Farid!
Ameen.
Where is the video of you and Hassan Shemrani about Karbala
Mohammed Ibn Abu Bakr ❤️
Can someone clarify the name of the author Farid mentions at 8:19
I think it is Fitnat maqtal Uthman ibn Affan by Muhammad ibn Abd Allah Ghabban
For those of you who couldn't understand what he said like me
6:32 i wont say that, actually قعقاع بن عمرو is a well-known sahabi that has multiple تراجمs but some say he was a تابعي wallahu aalam
Assalamualaikum bro eid mubarak how do I get in touch with you. I want to invite you on my podcast you have very good material
Akhi I don't know if you read this but can you elaborate on amir Ibn hamiq. Was he a sahabi during the bay'ah of ridhwan and was he involved in the martyrdom of our master Uthman?
I can't recall an authentic narration that says that.
❤❤❤❤
8:18 can someone please tell me what he's saying here. I don't understand his accent 😭😭😭
what's the role of amr bin alhamaq and other ashab ?
(34:43) can someone explain what he means about aisha seeking uthmans blood is repentance or response ?
Good point. Can you explain Sheikh Faarid? Or someone else?
That she felt bad that she opposed him?
I think ...
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM.
Or exiling Sahaba....
Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
@@saajiddaya2152 That she was seeking justice for his martyrdom
Brother Farid, when you mention sheikh muqbil who do you mean?
I promise you شيخ فريد if you did a video on condemning Israel for what they did to القدس والمسلمين في فلسطين المحتلة I will watch your video from start to end much love from البحرين.
I saw it and I watched the video it was nicely done.
Can you please the pdf where i can read it.
Wait, I just realized that you didn't mention Hussein (RA) when you were talking the people defending Uthman (RA). What about him.
Its politics
@@karamasaleh2126 that would be true if he didnt talk about shii sources. Why the difference between Hasan (RA) and Hussein (RA)?
Where is part 2?
خلاصة الكلام اسباب مقتل عثمان تنحصر في:
الغيرة
رد اعتبار لأشراف الكوفة الذين نفوا عنها
المشكلة أن كثيرًا من المحدثين يضعّفون الرجال فقط لمذهبهم وغالبًا يضعفون الشيعي وإن كان ثبتًا في حديثه
Where can I read Tarikh E Madina in English?
And the other contemporary source about the Shahadat of Uthman (as)?
So am I understanding this correctly, aisha and talha first wanted to kill uthman and when he was dead wanted to avenge him?
Sa3'Selim
أنَّ النَّبيَّ صَلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّمَ صَعِدَ أُحُدًا، وأَبُو بَكْرٍ، وعُمَرُ، وعُثْمَانُ، فَرَجَفَ بهِمْ، فَقَالَ: اثْبُتْ أُحُدُ؛ فإنَّما عَلَيْكَ نَبِيٌّ، وصِدِّيقٌ، وشَهِيدَانِ.
الراوي : أنس بن مالك | المحدث : البخاري | المصدر : صحيح البخاري
الصفحة أو الرقم: 3675 | خلاصة حكم المحدث : [صحيح]
What does مجلس mean were the guard of saeed bin al aas was beaten up along with hes son by Kooffuns for wishing that saeed ibn al aas owned their land so he could be generous?
I was expecting some background and authentic information on the letter to the governor of Egypt that the rebels caught and came back to Madinah accusing Usman RA of sending that letter with his stamp of authority on it from the ring that Khalifa used to wear in those times?? What is the closest truth about it?? Anyone
The fake letter stuff with fake stamp that part is correct. Some man of fitna forged the letter in the name of Usman r.a.
@@osamamanan2723 It was written by Marwan. Well that's what the history of Tabari says anyway. Not sure if it's actually true or not.
Didn't Mohammed Bin Abu Bakr Repented and ran away after grabbing Uthman by the beard and After Uthman told him to leave a beard that your father honored.
So he ran before the death of Uthaman am I right?
And didn't Aisha actually took some action and made them go easy on him even if it was temporary and wasn't she the one supplying him with water. I could be wrong can someone correct me.
It troubles me SO MUCH that I’m hearing that Aisha ra was seeking the blood of Uthman ra. I never ever knew that and I’m still doubting I don’t know what. I’m confused
.
After doing my little search, I refuse to accept that Aisha ever helped/preached for/called out to kill Uthman. There is no good source that tell us this and it’s great injustice to say such a thing about both Aisha the mother of the believers and Uthman ra
By seeking the blood of Uthman, I mean seeking justice for his blood.
@@FaridResponds
Oh I’m so glad! I was confused to why you’d say that
It is the Arabic expression. Seeking someone's blood means seeking justice for them. I should have been more careful.
@@FaridResponds
Arabic is my first language but hearing that in English was different
What was book name written by Dr Ghabban?
Maqtal Uthman
@@FaridResponds jazakallahu khayran, is there a pdf or bookstore I can get it from?
👍
I think this should be more in depth and organised with presentation. This history is vital for people to understand even now the ummah are misled by being given false information. People get emotional and lead to further chaos not only from Islamic point of view but in general we make asumptions about someone based on rumors and our actions can lead to khurooj and a fitna for coming generations
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM.
Or exiling Sahaba....
Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
There is no true or false information. History from the middle ages has ben written and re written so many times based on the agendas of who was narrating, hard to say who was right and who was wrong. You just have to accept that there was political turmoil, and everyone wanted that rich arab money. Death of Uthman and later state troubles were all because of that.
I had watch this on Muhammad hijab channel
Wait seriously? Was it the same thing or different
History belongs to the victor
The exile of those people from kufa, did that happen some times before the final seize, meaning that's what led to the seize? Or was it much earlier, which led them to spread propaganda against Uthman Ra. ?
This is a wonderful exposition. Thanks for putting in the research and sharing this. A question: A'isha's argument about nepotism may not necessarily be that Uthman's appointments were not just people but rather he passed up on more component and esteemed companions. Do you think maybe that is where she is coming from? Again, thanks so much for this wonderful work and grateful if you can put together more historical analysis like this.
To farid did malik al ashtar have a role in killing as we know many rebels they simply wanted uthman radiallahuanhu to step down but not kill him and were not involved on that
Ali's army consisted of Al Ansar and Muhajiroun in the revolt against Uthman
Source?
@@amirmohammed395 ibn Athir's book and Suyuti's book on history of Khalifa
Woah this is long
BROTHER THERE IS A PROBLEM AND HUGE PROBLEM IF WE ACCEPT THERE WAS ANY SAHABI INVOLVED IN MURDER OF UTHMAN R.A. BECAUSE THERE IS SAYING FROM MUHAMMAS ﷺ HIMSELF ABOUT WHO WILL KILL UTHMAN R.A. AND THE PROPHET (PBUH) DECLARED QATILEEN UTHMAN MUNAFIQEEN.
عَنِ النُّعْمَانِ بْنِ بَشِیْرٍ عَنْ عَائِشَۃَ، قَالَتْ: أَرْسَلَ رَسُوْلُ اللّٰہِ صَلَّی اللّٰہُ عَلَیْہٖ وَسَلَّمَ إِلٰی عُثْمَانَ بْنِ عَفَّانَ، فَأَقْبَلَ عَلَیْہِ رَسُوْلُ اللّٰہِ صَلَّی اللّٰہُ عَلَیْہِ وَسَلَّمَ، فَلَمَّا رَأَیْنَا رَسُوْلَ اللّٰہِ صَلَّی اللّٰہُ عَلَیْہٖ وَسَلَّمَ أَقْبَلت إِحْدَانَا عَلَی الْأُخْرٰی، فَکَانَ مِنْ آخِرِ کَلَامٍ کَلَّمَہُ أَنْ ضَرَبَ مَنْکِبَہُ، وَقَالَ: ((یَا عُثْمَانُ! اِنَّ اللّٰہَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ عَسٰی أَنْ یُلْبِسَکَ قَمِیْصًا، فَإِنْ أَرَادَکَ الْمُنَافِقُوْنَ عَلٰی خَلْعِہٖفَلَاتَخْلَعْہٗحَتّٰی تَلْقَانِیْ،یَا عُثْمَانُ! إِنَّ اللّٰہَ عَسٰی أَنْ یُلْبِسَکَ قَمِیْصًا فَإِنْ أَرَادَکَ الْمُنَافِقُوْنَ عَلٰی خَلْعِہٖفَلَاتَخْلَعْہُحَتّٰی تَلْقَانِیْ ثَلَاثًا۔)) فَقُلْتُ لَہَا: یَا أُمَّ الْمُؤُمِنِیْنَ! فَأَیْنَ کَانَ ہَذٰا عَنْکِ؟ قَالَتْ: نَسِیْتُہُ وَاللّٰہِ! فَمَا ذَکَرْتُہُ، قَالَ: فَأَخْبَرْتُہُ مُعَاوِیَۃَ بْنَ أَبِیْ سُفْیَانَ فَلَمْ یَرْضَ بِالَّذِیْ أَخْبَرْتُہُ حَتّٰی کَتَبَ إِلٰی أُمِّ الْمُؤْمِنِیْنَ أَنْ اکْتُبِیْ إِلَیَّ بِہِ، فَکَتَبَتْ إِلَیْہِ بِہٖکِتَابًا۔ (مسنداحمد: ۲۵۰۷۳)
Good question and Waleed bin uqba a guy he knew was drunk in morning salat makes 4 rak3at . And says to everyone shall I continue? AND THEN ADDING INSULT TO INJURY NOT REMOVING HIM FROM HIS GOVERNANCE OR AT THE VERY LEAST PUNISHING HIM.
Or exiling Sahaba....
Putting many leaders of bani ummaya that were very bad let's just call it how it is. You sugar coat it like oh he sinned he was drunk this isn't light. There is way more you didn't discuss . Guys if you want answers to good questions . Like serious good questions you have had about our history and these gray areas your muftis dont like answering....please watch the last Ammar nakshawanis video series starting from when the prophet died and the "calamity of Thursday" please watch with out bias and try to not envoke your emotions about some people you have on a pedestal just a historical analysis!!!
@@ashleyjason5608 not good idea to listen to shia whose imam said 9/10 of religion is lying
Why didn't Ali(rali) punish muhammad ibni abibakr?
What do you mean with "very pro sunni to sunni something wrong" I see you say that in more video's "to sunni" what do you mean by that?
Meaning pro sunni make it seem that situation is clearer or cleaner in some topics
he put marwan in power and people got mad because Muhammad (A.S) kicked him out of the land and Osman called him back and put him as the leader. The leader of kufa he appointed used to drink while praying and in the qauran it says he is a liar. He also put someone in power for egypt that used to harm muslims and Egyptians even came to complain bout it and he did nothing .
Uthman was a great man who would rather die than call an army to crush even rebel even though he could easily do that. He is also the only man ever existed whom Rasulullah ﷺ chosed to marry not just 1 of his daughter, but 2 daughters. If hes a good man for Rasulullah ﷺ then hes a good man for me.
the angle he is sitting at.. lol where is sheikh murrah to respond ?