Vocal Coach reacts to Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper Shallow (From A Star Is Born/Live From The Oscars)
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 02. 2019
- 📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
☀️ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bet...
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: / bethroars
Check out my second channel (Roar!) where I take on challenges: / roarrawr
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vocal Coach reaction to Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper Shallow (From A Star Is Born/Live From The Oscars)
Original Video: • Lady Gaga, Bradley Coo...
I hope this video helps you understand your voice and what you can do to grow as a singer
Book a lesson with Beth at www.bethroars.com/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Social Media
Facebook: bethroars
Twitter: @bethroars
Insta: @bethroars
Lady Gaga just said in an interview that every bit of this was directed by Bradley. It was so beautifully done and such a special moment.
@@duncanplayle4157 They're magic together. Bigger than the sum of their parts.
Thats because he wanted it to reflect how the movie was shot. All of the concert performances are shot from the bands perspective. You never see shots of the bands performances shot from the crowd except on the cell phone video of Shallow.
@@umainebearman Ah, thank you for that information. I haven't seen it yet (😞) but now it makes sense just from the clips I've seen.
@Peter Lustigait,you mean this is FAKE NEWS? no shit.relax.the point of this all of this effort and focus groups and whatnot is to: evoke emotion,showcase talent,and make money. and it was successful in doing those things.nothing wrong with trying to get away from mass shootings,a shitty economy and wall building and just watch a MOVIE.not sure why you'd want to spoil that for people.js.
It annoys me people saying this was a bad performance. In this modern age I give a ton of credit to them singing it live with no autotune. As a musician I love the slight imperfections which gives the performance character. Hell Jimmy Paige said a song is never done and would often tinker with it live!
But it's rare for people to say that this is a bad performance. Based on how the internet reacted, people actually liked it.
I'm assuming the vocal coach in this video said it was bad?
I wouldn't know. Couldn't watch it anymore after she said she seen the movie. What is she reacting to then?
@@HalkerVeil In my opinion her reactions are mostly about the technique that's used in the specific songs and not about hearing them for the first time. So it doesn't matter if she heard it before or not.
it was really bad and pitchy
It’s one of the most popular videos on the internet. Everyone loved the performance. Did I miss something?
Bradley is from Philadelphia and Gaga is from NYC. I can always hear the New York accent when Gaga sings. She's just amazing. Bradley said he modeled his accent after Sam Elliott, who was superb playing his older brother. On a talk show prior to the Oscars, Bradley said the singing was really hard for him and he would have to get with his vocal coach in order to perform at the Oscars. Love love love all 3 of the above. mentioned actors!
This whole setup all the way from the camera view to the lightning was directed by Bradley Cooper before that night. So awesome
I agree it wasn't technically perfect, but that's what made this performance great.
Lady Gaga could easily become on of the world's top actresses if she wanted to.
Already is
Shes actually better than most, especially jennifer lawrence who i think just plays herself in movies, gaga was flwless and so natural in asib, phenomenal movie btw, its no wonder we fell in lurve with her ❤️❤️❤️🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
Not
I get chills EVERYTIME I hear it, I come from a vocal performance background but stopped years ago after joining the Army but it's songs like this I find myself just melting from the inside out and remembering just how much a song can grab you and leave you exhausted. Thank you for the review, it's my first time here and I'll be back.
Congrats to Lady Gaga for winning the Oscar for best original song - Shallow ./Beth great reaction to the video.
Thom Yorke should have at least been nominated for Suspirium from the film Suspiria. I think its a much better song and it wasn't even nominated. Sigh .
Hey! Here is my reaction to Thom: czcams.com/video/dHvJeCdrXlg/video.html
you have to understand that this is also in front of the biggest crowd around the world watching. so they both would be a little nervous and Bradley said he was. so too me they both nailed it.
I really enjoyed your critique. I like the way you point out the few small blips yet also excuse them because in the broader view of the performance they are not important and likely add to the work.
Gritty and rough masculine meets soft, strong feminine. To me it's a musical conversation between two people who have experienced a lot of adversity and they've come together. It's just beautiful. 💖💖😢
1.) Bradley Cooper is not a professional singer and he doesn't claim to be, but he went up and gave it his all. I'd like to see some of you naysayers not only have the guts to put yourself out there like that, but do anywhere near that good.
2.) Loved the honest review you gave pointing out the imperfections while conveying how perfection wasn't the point of this performance.
3.) My favorite line of all Beth videos is now "Such a beautiful song, this" Put a smile 10 miles long across my face. Had to rewind to make sure I heard it correctly. 'Rawr'
You nailed it on Bradley's part, especially the start of the song. He isn't trained, but live he has a true honest tone. Not like the film, it was nice to hear his honest tone.
I wanna see Gaga get more into rock or metal music, I think she would totally kill it!🤘🏻
czcams.com/video/IfHhwfmzTQw/video.html
I like a lot of old music and Lady Gaga's songs back in the old days were some of my favorites
Lady Gaga was in American Horror Story. She's acted before. Her acting on American Horror Story showed her diversity with acting. She is really incredible.
She was in the sopranos when she was like 17. I don't think it was even a speaking role but I suspect it was her first pro gig of any kind.
Very good critique and insights. True, perfect singing technique is not what made this song nor performance so affecting. Even the vocal misteps are part of the emotive factor.
I first listened live with the critical ear, and some things were to be considered, but the emotion, the chemistry, the directing of the camera angles, the piano being brought out, the stroll up the stairs, the way Bradley wobbled on his stool as she sang, then the way he snatched the mic stand up before joining her on the piano bench... made it so emotional for me, listening subsequent times... your review is spot on...
In order to make the sound he wanted he lowered his voice an octave. He worked with a vocal coach. Gaga is from NYC.
I watched an interview with Bradley Cooper and Sam Elliot, and Bradley had actually worked with a vocal coach to sound more like Sam. Mr. Elliot was actually honored and that's what pushed him to accept the invitation to the cast. So that little bit of accent you can hear in his voice is based on Sam Elliot's speaking voice.
Beautiful reaction from a beautiful lady covering a beautiful song😊😍😍❤❤
It's four years on so you might not see this, but your analysis/commentary here was excellent.
The way they look at each other at the end, and how the dang it together just hits hard❤
Beautiful right!
I just love you Beth, such a vocal Beast
I agree with others that said they sounded a bit pitchy. It wasn't horrible at all, I'm not saying that. But just a wee bit out of tune here and there. I'd much rather hear 'a wee bit out of tune' than have it autotuned, though.
Absolutely. This is completely natural, makes me really appreciate the chemistry (which is outrageous) even more.
Bradly sounded horrible. This was like karaoke for him
Hey, Fantastic drummer, can u sing at all? Shame on all u ppl talking abt such pros being fucking pitchy. They wanted 2 give us something raw and real. These ppl have accomplished a masterpiece
U don't know anythg abt purity, blatant honesty, or vulnerability. And , noone is fucking perfect. So qwit w/ the fuckin pitchy. Oh. As if it matters, I've been playing and singing for 50 yrs. My ear and taste r multi-faceted , and I just love pure and raw 4 a change. Fuckin fresh air in a mean, weird, and phony world. Congrats Stefani and Bradley 4 letting us in even more. This performance will live on. Shame on any of u 4 having the nerve 2 criticize.
Bradly is a little off here and there, but he s not a professional singer...
@@roxannetoth5026 I think it's okay to criticize! That's what art lovers do! Bradley, who isn't a singer, did a great job considering the stakes. But he was far from perfect. And he was singing with one of the most talented humans alive! The song is great, the performance was fantastic. But it's totally cool to have critiques! That's how all artists get better....
You can tell he's nervous as hell. All from the throat, going sharp. Big difference between singing in the shower and then in front of a couple thousand people. She had some funky pitches going on too but such a change since she's singing from the abdomen.
Loved your take.
Her analysis.rocks!
Hahahah “the connection” everyone felt. We thought Gaga and Bradley would stay together in real life 😂😂😂
Lady Gaga and her character are both from New York. Bradley actually worked with an acting coach to have an accent like Sam Elliot before Sam even accepted the role of his older brother(which was a bit of a stretch, his father would seem a bit more appropriate given their age difference)
wow Beth you have an amazing voice...
Thank you Beth
This was the happy end that we didn’t have in the film. ❤️
Thanks for sharing.
Great song another great review. X
What a classy lady beth is....also gaga and cooper...wow..
Lady Gaga should get the Get the Best Actress Award
Kinda expected a good performance from Lady Gaga due to her pretty good showing in AHS. What I didn't expect is Bradley Cooper holding his own in a singing role, in his own way, with a singer co-star
The last shot was done 15 min after her good friend passed, so authentic and raw
Bradley has a nice voice, beautiful song with my girl Gaga
KILLED IT ON THE REVIEW :)
Great reaction.
I'll admit, I have to be careful when watching Gaga and Cooper perform together. Whether it be in music, or on the screen. I can't hold it completely together. Not just because of their chemistry (which is historic), but because of what the movie's about. Grand, fleeting love, burning out as quickly as it begun. Weighs very heavy on my heart.
Bradley Cooper is from Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and he is born 1975 so he is 44 years old, he said once that he never had done any singing performance before he directed the movie...*A STAR IS BORN*
Perhaps it wasn't the "perfect" performance because this was the GRAMMYS. I know Gaga's a professional, but he's not so maybe they were both "off" slightly. I loved it.
"like the Grudge", lol. Good one
Bradley Cooper’s singing voice here reminds me of Neil Diamond.
That's what he was going for!
Agreed
Wow, that’s exactly right.
I would love to see you analyze and react to Joe Cocker "with a little help from my friends" he was such a unique singer and it would be interesting to see your reaction, being from the current generation, while knowing your stuff as far as singing mechanics.
Ghost - If You Have Ghosts Acoustic Live
I second this
❤️Damn this song reminds me of my ex when we first watched it. I joked about hanging myself like the movie and it brought tears to her eyes smh, but now the thought wouldn’t even trigger a hair line on her body....”love” even after a mutual ending. fin
I take a look into my parents garage and sometimes wonder what the rope would feel like and if it would heal me from my pain of not having my love next to me. To fill the void sometimes you have to empty the bucket for fresh water to come when it rains an eternity...
We started as strangers and we ended as strangers as if it never existed.🖤
The Dutch Goddess Floor Jansen just covered this on the show Beste Zangers. You need to check it out Beth.
For not being a singer, Bradley Cooper has nice grit to his voice and he has a very clear sound.
Ben Caplan - Down to the River, live in Bellwoods 42!
emotional 10/10. beth {rules}.
You gotta do Type O Negative. Solid bass with 4 octave range.
Please do a breakdown of "the day I tried to live" by soundgarden. Rip chris! We all miss you in so many ways :(
I always think that a married couple... where both can sing... it should be the most romantic thing to sing a song together
Great one once again Beth!
I really think you should react to pain of salvation - iter impius or hallelujah or ashes. Also nevermore - the learning or this godless endeavour. Devin Townsend project - super crush or ih ah. All live versions are on youtube. I would love to see your reaction and analysis, especially on pain of salvation.
Love this version and your comments, Beth!
P. S. ladies... Let me be your Bradley... 😘
Love, looooahooooahhhaaa… oooooooooahhhhhahhhahhh...ah ya Beth! Keep up the great work!
Previous versions of A Star is Born include James Mason and Judy Garland, and one with Kris Kristofferson and Barbra Streisand.
Bradley Cooper is from Pennsylvania. Lady Gaga is from New York. Here in America they would both be considered Northeasterns.
I love the country reactions and would like to see you react to Brooks and Dunn "Believe".
What a fantastic song. Oh man, can't wait for you to react to Floor's version.
❤️❤️❤️
Cooper is from Philadelphia, PA.
You should see her in American horror story she is amazing xxx
Technical does not guarantee that someone is going to be good, or worth listening to. Lemmy was not perfect technically, but he knew how to use his voice to tell the stories that sang. Bradley did a good job there for being an actor first, and a singer after that.
Dont stop gaga..she is a master
You should react to some rush they have a very "interesting" singer. Rush- Permanent Waves-Freewill
Other awesome singers: Jim Gillette from Nitro, Mike from Steelheart, Michael from Stryper,
Ohh Beth I just Love youu..!
The chemistry between these 2 is so fucking intense. Is this a perfect performance? No, but it would be a worse performance if it was technically perfect IMO
why at 3:00 when he was singing they was looking at each other like they was IN LOVE😭 like dis ain’t the movie nomore wrap it up😂
Can you react to Nathan Sykes? Very underrated singer! React to his rendition of who's loving you💕🙌🏼
She's playing the piano while singing. That's hard enough. Compared to people who lip sync and use autotune. This is near peak performance
Sometimes when Im watching your videos I imagine it's an episode of Bear Grylls of music reactions lol
Two requests : Gojira - Global Warming [Live at the Silver Cord Studio]
Opeth - Ghost of Perdition [Live at The Roundhouse Tapes DVD]
Thank you for doing these videos!
You need to see Pentatonix cover of this song. It haunting!
Notice the camera shots are from back of the stage. like the movie. :) A little promotion.
One year voice training as an actor.. dam good job to get up and sing in front of fellow actors and peers. :)
Another great video. Just have one thing to say. HOW HAVE YOU NOT REACTED TO A CHRIS CORNELL SONG YET?!?!?! Do a video of "Say hello to heaven". Your mind will be blown. Back me up people! Any song will do honestly, but that vocal performance is ridiculous. Back. Me. Up. People!
I am a terrible singer, no two ways about it. But I think Chris Cornell has an AMAZING singing voice. I'd love to see a reaction, too!
Been begging for say hello 2 heaven
thank you.... anything you can say about THE WORLD'S BEST? or is there copyright issues...
Your take on CREEP was amazing!!!! Please react and analyze SARAH GERONIMO ‘s version of CREEP 🙏🙏🙏👍❤️
I like your nails in this video
Subscribed...
Would recommend Shinedown: Diamond Eyes... this seems like a good time to recommend it.
I love Brent Smith's voice, but goddamn is that song bad. React to "45" or "Beyond the Sun" or "Shed Some Light".
The basic reason for that recommendation was because of the portions this gaga song borrows from it. But thank you for your comments.
Yeah, I see the similarity in the vocal melody now, though I wouldn't say it's "borrowed", per se.
Please please react to John frusiante Carvel live acoustic. I'd love you forever.... Like I already dont
📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
☀ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bethroars/power-of-the-wolf
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars
Film gives us a lens into the human spirit like nothing else can." Kimberly Steward.
"You should not dream your film. You should make it." Mr. Steven Spielberg.
Of all the music that reached farthest into heaven, it is the beating of a loving heart.
Henry Ward Beecher. "The only limit is the one you set yourself." - Felix Baumgartner
Manhattan New York City. February 2019. Twenty seven year old, Josephine Warren, an courageous and fearless arts educator, disability legal justice activist, and a future film director and film producer, reflects on her wonderful childhood growing up in Manhattan New York City and coping with mild High Functioning Aspergers Autism Syndrome and coping with her getting bullied, (through her love of theater and film screenwriting). Josephine, 27, the eldest of four children; Sandra Warren, 25, Michaela Warren, 25, and Josephine’s only and youngest brother Reed Warren, lived in Manhattan New York City her whole life. In late February 2019, Josephine Warren, expressed to her siblings and her parents, just how much she wanted to attend film directing graduate school at the University of Southern California Los Angeles, instead of serving in the US Navy Seals as a military aviation technician. Toward the middle of her life, her bullies and her parents Trisha Warren and Alex Warren; former Navy Seal graduates keep on, hiding her film school applications in their office drawers, as, they fear that Josephine, their daughter, would fail to follow in her parents footsteps of becoming a Navy Seal West Point Academy soldier; as that is what the Warren family legacy is defined as, according to Josephine Warren. Even though Josephine lived with Aspergers her entire life, Josephine would use her adversity and failures, as foundation blocks, toward her evolving into one of the most inspiring film directors in New York City and global history; At the end of her film, Josephine Warren, receives the most inspiring reward of her life, and she ends up inspiring, tens of billions of lives, through her artistic voice
and loving and gratitude giving heart and human existence alone.
At the film’s end, Vincent Everett, an doctoral graduate student of
the University of Phoenix and a Five Star US Navy Seals Admiral at
Phoenix’s “SEALS RECRUIT ACADEMY” in Arizona, falls romantically
in love with Josephine, in Baka Jerusalem Israel after reading her film
script for Superheroic and shows his soldiers unit, that the human race
can inspire, even in adversity and obstacles. Superheroic, A Mr. Jonathan
Trauner Directed Film. (I have shared my Superheroic film script to the Scarlet
Lens Film Production Company of Toronto Canada and to Mrs. Leah Rifkin; Renowned Film Director and Author of Beyond The Directors Chair; She said that my story has the power to inspire the Oscar Academy of Beverly Hills California. Even though I have Aspergers, I have completed my Superheroic film story, I am an Israeli American immigrant Jerusalem Jewish Israeli citizen, and I work for Mobileye Intel in Jerusalem for their Computer Algorithms Correction Department. I also shared my Superheroic film story with Nancy Spielberg and she was so inspired by my story, characters, and Superheroic film script message; My dream is to win an Oscar Academy Award in Los Angeles California in real life. My mission as a film director and storyteller is to inspire the world through storytelling, love, gratitude, and heart. Main Theme for my Future Oscar Academy Award Winning Film Superheroic; Never Give Up. (The Score, Unstoppable). The Score's Unstoppable identifies with my primary Superheroic film theme which is never give up. czcams.com/video/Xydf351l-gw/video.html
You should definitely react to Caitlyn Smith!
I don't really detect southern twang. It's more of a middle america bland accent I think. Could be wrong, but that's what I gather from spending my life between the areas. (On Gaga's part I mean, I see it for sure in Cooper's performance)
Lady Gaga is from New Jersey USA Bradley Cooper I believe either Texas or Arkansas USA they probably both live in California now well for a while but I'm pretty sure Bradley Cooper was raised at West maybe New Mexico
HI you're great, can you analize jesse and joy?
hi from Mexico!..Please react to "cafe tacuba"; "las flores" unplugged
This performance was FUCKING amazing!! The feelings are real.... thanks for the reaction😍❤
In my channel, I have my cover of Shallow:) I hope you like it!
Hi! I just wanted to say that your videos are pretty cool, it would be great if you do a reaction of Nude by Radiohead (live from The Basement)
Please check out Iced Earth - A Question of Heaven. I really wanna know what you think of Matt Barlow
Lady Gaga is from NYC.
Bradley Cooper is from Philadelphia just fyi
Can you please react to they might be giants and the pouges
Don't know where Bradley Cooper is from but Jackson is from Arizona. Gaga is from New York and her character is from New Jersey, not the south.
😭😭😭😭😭😭❤️