Library Chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq As the Sacrifice: A Case Study of Tafsīr and Scholarly Influence
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 09. 2024
- Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Intro Soundtrack:
By Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi
Outro Soundtrack:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official CZcams Channel
135
I am a Christian and I always appreciate your sincerity about your sources. When I listen to you, I listen with open mind to understand your materials. God bless you.
1. Why did the first Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Isaac Ishaq?
The start of the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 repeats Quran chapter 19 where after prayer God gives Isaac Ishaq meaning Quran chapter 37 is the story of the son of Sarah.
The Torah Taurat names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and the Quran tells the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:40 and confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:41 and says in Quran 4:136 “... whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah)” and in Quran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true." meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat to show that humans do not have the power to change the written word of Allah (in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:3) which the Jews have been commanded to follow forever in the Torah Taurat by observing the Sabbath Day in all their generations in a covenant agreement made with Allah forever in the Torah Taurat which is confirmed in the Quran as proof Allah is real and as proof the Quran is truthful.
.
2. Why did later Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Ishmael Ismail?
Later Muslims said that Ishmael Ismail was the only son for 13 years and therefore the Jews changed the Torah Taurat.
However when you read the Torah Taurat you will find that Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq were both living in the same house before the sacrifice and it was after Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar are sent into the desert that the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim is Isaac Ishaq and this is why Allah says “Take your only son Isaac Ishaq and sacrifice him” meaning the faith in Quran 4:136 which the first Muslims had in the Torah Taurat was the correct faith meaning later Muslims did not read the Torah Taurat and believed what other people told them when they claimed the sacrifice was before the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Isaac Ishaq is given to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time is by the angel of Allah with the birth of Isaac Ishaq and the second time is after the angel of Allah stops the sacrifice and gives Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time.
The name good news is always the name of Isaac Ishaq in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Ishmael Ismail is not mentioned anywhere in Quran chapter 37 or in Torah Taurat Genesis 22 which is the story of the sacrifice.
.
In the Quran Allah only blesses Abraham Ibrahim and Isaac Ishaq in the story of the sacrifice.
Allah has left no blessing or mention of Ishmael Ismail in the story of the sacrifice because he is not in this story.
.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat however Satan Shaitan tests Muslims to show who believes the word of Allah was changed in the Torah Taurat in the same way Satan Shaitan tests Christians to show who believes Prophet Jesus Isa is Allah.
.
3. The story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 starts in Quran chapter 19.
The story of Prophet Isaac Ishaq who is called the “Good News” son is the story of the son of Sarah and Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
In Quran 19:46 - 19:49 Abraham Ibrahim lived with his father and prays and when he went away Allah gave him Isaac Ishaq in Quran 19:49 meaning this is the story of the son of Sarah.
.
The story in Quran 19:46 - 19:49 which is the story of Isaac Ishaq the son of Sarah is the same story in the beginning of the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:98 - Quran 37:101.
1. Quran 37:98 is Quran 19:46 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is living with his father.
2. Quran 37:99 is Quran 19:47 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
3. Quran 37:100 is Quran 19:48 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
4. Quran 37:101 (We gave him the good news) is Quran 19:49 (“We gave him Isaac Ishaq”).
.
The angel of Allah gave the Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq twice.
The first time the angel of Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is as the Good News in Quran 37:101 which is the same as when Prophet Isaac Ishaq is given the first time in Quran 19:49.
This Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq is to be sacrificed in the next verse Quran 37:102.
.
The second time Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is after Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq a second time to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112
.
The story of the sacrifice only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq both separately and together as the father and son.
Allah has left no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat as proof no one can change the words of Allah as promised in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:30
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 “... and whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah).”
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
Respected Shaikh,
You don't need to worry about 1 hour time limit.
Those of us who can willingly sit through listening for one hour... can easily sit through much more.
Feel free to take as much time as needed.
Agreed
Fully agree with...
I agree.
I actually prefer these Library chats to be longer
Same here alhamduillah. I drive a lot and I love listening to podcasts and lectures. CZcams tends to save timestamps of videos and picks up where you left off. So keep on keeping on Sheikh.
“When you don’t know different positions, whatever you are taught becomes the orthodox position.”
agree on it. that is why it is important to have the equal understanding of the both perspectives. it makes us able to think any perspective from curated ways
Very true statement.
Assalamu Alaikum and happy Ramadan,
1. Why did the first Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Isaac Ishaq?
The Torah Taurat names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and the Quran tells the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:40 and confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:41 and says in Quran 4:136 “... whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah)” and in Quran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true." meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat to show that humans do not have the power to change the written word of Allah (in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:3) which the Jews have been commanded to follow forever in the Torah Taurat by observing the Sabbath Day in all their generations in a covenant agreement made with Allah forever in the Torah Taurat which is confirmed in the Quran as proof Allah is real and as proof the Quran is truthful.
.
2. Why did later Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Ishmael Ismail?
Later Muslims said that Ishmael Ismail was the only son for 13 years and therefore the Jews changed the Torah Taurat.
However when you read the Torah Taurat you will find that Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq were both living in the same house before the sacrifice and it was after Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar are sent into the desert that the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim is Isaac Ishaq and this is why Allah says “Take your only son Isaac Ishaq and sacrifice him” meaning the faith in Quran 4:136 which the first Muslims had in the Torah Taurat was the correct faith meaning later Muslims did not read the Torah Taurat and believed what other people told them when they claimed the sacrifice was before the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Isaac Ishaq is given to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time is by the angel of Allah with the birth of Isaac Ishaq and the second time is after the angel of Allah stops the sacrifice and gives Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time.
The name good news is always the name of Isaac Ishaq in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Ishmael Ismail is not mentioned anywhere in Quran chapter 37 or in Torah Taurat Genesis 22 which is the story of the sacrifice.
.
In the Quran Allah only blesses Abraham Ibrahim and Isaac Ishaq in the story of the sacrifice.
Allah has left no blessing or mention of Ishmael Ismail in the story of the sacrifice because he is not in this story.
.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat however Satan Shaitan tests Muslims to show who believes the word of Allah was changed in the Torah Taurat in the same way Satan Shaitan tests Christians to show who believes Prophet Jesus Isa is Allah.
.
3. The story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 starts in Quran chapter 19.
The story of Prophet Isaac Ishaq who is called the “Good News” son is the story of the son of Sarah and Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
In Quran 19:46 - 19:49 Abraham Ibrahim lived with his father and prays and when he went away Allah gave him Isaac Ishaq in Quran 19:49 meaning this is the story of the son of Sarah.
.
The story in Quran 19:46 - 19:49 which is the story of Isaac Ishaq the son of Sarah is the same story in the beginning of the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:98 - Quran 37:101.
1. Quran 37:98 is Quran 19:46 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is living with his father.
2. Quran 37:99 is Quran 19:47 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
3. Quran 37:100 is Quran 19:48 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
4. Quran 37:101 (We gave him the good news) is Quran 19:49 (“We gave him Isaac Ishaq”).
.
The angel of Allah gave the Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq twice.
The first time the angel of Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is as the Good News in Quran 37:101 which is the same as when Prophet Isaac Ishaq is given the first time in Quran 19:49.
This Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq is to be sacrificed in the next verse Quran 37:102.
.
The second time Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is after Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq a second time to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112
.
The story of the sacrifice only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq both separately and together as the father and son.
Allah has left no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat as proof no one can change the words of Allah as promised in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:30
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 “... and whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah).”
When I was a child in church they taught me Isaac was the sacrifice son and I don't recall learning about Ishmael at all. In those times I lived under the impression that Abraham only had Isaac as an offspring. How fascinated I was to learn the stories of Hajar and Ishmael. My love of these people and their significance is not troubled by this debate. The focus is on Abraham and his submissiveness. God was their witness and God knows best. Peace and Love to anyone reading this
Genesis 16.
Sarai, Abram’s wife, was not able to have children. She owned an Egyptian slave named Hagar. 2 So Sarai said to Abram, “The Lord has kept me from having children. Why don’t you sleep with my slave? Maybe I can build a family through her.” Abram agreed with Sarai.
3 After Abram had lived in Canaan for ten years, Abram’s wife Sarai took her Egyptian slave Hagar and gave her to her husband Abram to be his wife. 4 He slept with Hagar, and she became pregnant. When Hagar realized that she was pregnant, she began to be disrespectful to Sarai, her owner.
5 So Sarai complained to Abram, “I’m being treated unfairly! And it’s your fault! I know that I gave my slave to you, but now that she’s pregnant, she’s being disrespectful to me. May the Lord decide who is right-you or me.”
6 Abram answered Sarai, “Here, she’s your slave. Do what you like with her.” Then Sarai mistreated Hagar so much that she ran away.
7 The Messenger of the Lord found her by a spring in the desert, the spring on the way to Shur. 8 He said, “Hagar, Sarai’s slave, where have you come from, and where are you going?”
She answered, “I’m running away from my owner Sarai.” 9 The Messenger of the Lord said to her, “Go back to your owner, and place yourself under her authority.” 10 The Messenger of the Lord also said to her, “I will give you many descendants. No one will be able to count them because there will be so many.” 11 Then the Messenger of the Lord said to her,
“You are pregnant,
and you will give birth to a son.
You will name him Ishmael [God Hears],
because the Lord has heard your cry of distress.
12 He will be as free and wild as an untamed donkey.
He will fight with everyone, and everyone will fight with him.
He will have conflicts with all his relatives.”
13 Hagar named the Lord, who had been speaking to her, “You Are the God Who Watches Over Me.” She said, “This is the place where I watched ⌞the one⌟ who watches over me.” 14 This is why the well is named Beer Lahai Roi [Well of the Living One Who Watches Over Me]. It is still there between Kadesh and Bered.
15 Hagar gave birth to Abram’s son. Abram named him Ishmael. 16 Abram was 86 years old when Hagar gave birth to Ishmael.
It is important to know this story because the Muslims claim Ishmael to be their ancestor and hence claim to be a prophet foretold in the Bible which is BS.
@@NaCl_Salt Muslims don't claim Ishmael to be a prophet foretold in the Bible. They believe in his prophethood based on the Quran. And Muslims consider Abraham to be the ancestor as per the Quran, while genetically of course Muhammad is from the offspring of Ishmael.
@@NaCl_Salt God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
@@NaCl_Salt What is the Gospel Injil?
Jesus did not write anything because everything Jesus taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
.
The four Gospels are four reports about Jesus meaning Jesus never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
.
The Quran tells the Christians to observe the Gospel and judge by the Gospel (not by the other books in the New Testament because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel).
.
Jesus in the Gospel says the Tanakh will exist forever and will never change (and this is the reason that Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in the Tanakh Jewish scripture) meaning anything in the Gospel which contradict the Tanakh did not come from God or from Jesus.
For example when Paul in his letter says the Torah is old and will soon disappear this is opposite to what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel where the Torah is forever and will not change and must be followed forever by the Jewish people in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
.
Every prophet after Moses including Prophet Jesus and Prophet Muhammad reminded the Jewish people to observe the Torah forever as the Torah has commanded them and as the Gospel and Quran reminds them..
.
Sometimes the Gospel contradicts the Tanakh however some publishers of the Gospels have added foot notes explaining problem verses in the past therefore Christians in the present or in future can add foot notes to show verses that cannot be true such as the claim that Jesus descended from David because it contradicts the Tanakh (where a person can only inherit a tribe like David biologically through the father and not by adoption and not through the mother and not by choice) which Jesus said will never change and must be followed forever in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
In the Quran Prophet Jesus did not claim he inherited the House of David because it is impossible for anyone without a biological father to inherit a tribe in Judaism.
.
A. Gospel Problem: How was the New Testament contrived? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds
czcams.com/video/mJK6gY2IZUI/video.html
.
B. How did these four Gospels make it into the New Testament? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
The first person to assign the names Mark, Matthew, Luke and John to each of the earliest unnamed Gospel manuscripts was Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyon, in Gaul, today in France in 180 CE.
Gospel of Matthew 9:9 shows it was not written by Matthew because Matthew is mentioned in the third person and not in the first person.
czcams.com/video/HabMqyhx3YY/video.html
.
C. Does Judaism Regard Muslims as B’nai Noah (Righteous Gentiles)? Rabbi Tovia Singer.
Muslims correctly worship God means Muslims are righteous gentiles.
Do Jews believe Jesus was a prophet.
The Virgin birth in Islam is not a problem in Judaism.
The Virgin birth in Christianity is a problem in Judaism because some Christian Bibles wrongly translate the Jewish scripture in Isaiah 7:14 from "the young woman" to "a virgin."
Not all Christians are the same in 2011 the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops removed “virgin” in Isaiah 7:14 and put “young woman” in the New American Bible (Revised Edition).
czcams.com/video/eUL-HCI5Ri8/video.html
.
D. Why do Muslims believe that Jesus is the Messiah? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
czcams.com/video/RU-gFC_1B5U/video.html
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
You have no idea shaykh how many people love to listen to you. I love to listen and learn from you just because of this maturity and academic approach to the ilm. Yes I went thru that "I know everything phase " years ago but I learned that being patient with learning and being humble is key to gaining knowledge. I pray that Allah strengthens you in your deen and let us benefit from you. السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
These library chats are my favorites of your videos. Nobody else is doing these kinds of lectures. You changed the name from YQ Gems to Library Chats, but these lectures truly are gems. And I like the hour glass in the background. May Allah bless you and give you the ability to continue doing these lectures.
WOW...i am not a learned person of Islam but listening to you have given me a real understanding of this topic and may ALLAH continue to bless and guide you as you continue to help make us understand our religion...
I love how he introduced Ibn Tayyimiyah like its a wrestling match.. 💪💪
41:57
He sure did😂. Loved that too
lool! Ibaaaaaaaaaaan Taymiyyah!!!
🤣🤣 good one
I'm a Christian and I admire your honesty.God bless you Sheik.Respect to you
Do not be deceived. YQ is not an honest person. He has tried to be, but soon realised the truth to his ummah is like daylight to a vampire. The truth is a source of mental distress to muslims. Remember the Holes in the Narrative controversy?
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Your library chats, in the comfort of your own home, are some of the best work that you do. 👍🏿
MashaAllah! Keep it coming Ya Sheikh. You are awakening minds with these academic lectures.
The absence of this balance approach of seeing others perspective is one of the factor of the intolerance out there.
JazakAllah khayr.
My dear beloved brother, we want more of these library chats if time permits. Speak your mind, word of my brother is like a golden nugget for me. May be sometimes consider doing a commentary of your favourite classic islamic book with us. May allah unite us in jannah.
Salaam my brother I love the stories you tell and the lesson you bring with them they are so heart felted and your gift of delivering of any Islamic lectures contain knoeledge, Windom,, that you use QURAN and hadith and community's stories to bring your lesson in our time. Your speech is articulated as well. May Allah bless your endeavored.
here you have more czcams.com/video/ejrywsyri-o/video.html
Awesome. Sheikh, you always come up with topics which are truely intriguing. Please never ever stop publishing these kind of videos. Expecting a detailed series on early islamic theological developments.
Great Topic for the video today sheikh was wanting this for such a long time may allah bless you!
Make a series on islamic theology
Please. INSHA allah
May Allah help us
Ameen
Agree.. i'm completely clueless about all the name of firqohs & what are those that you said here syekh..
I also want an series
It was once explained to me that when a person has a very conservative, almost single minded position on Islamic issues that it's actually NOT a sign that they are learned or a scholar. The fact is, if an individual has studied under qualified people, they will have come across multiple valid positions because scholars will interpret ayats, hadiths and seerah differently. There have always been differences and for those who don't accept it, usually it's because they have never been exposed to a number of qualified opinions.
Jazakallaahu khair bro
Yeah, I like that. I like choice and I will always choose what pleases me.
@@takarabdi you're kidding right?that isn't Islamic that is a liberal view.
The more i listen to shaikh yasir...the more i am impressed
Sir, I am and my family is your great fan . May Allah help you to serve the Muslim Ummah.
Great way of introducing critical thinking for the masses
Critical thinking.....? according to the Torah (Genesis 22) it was Isaac who "....travelled up the hill carrying a bundle of wood in order to be sacrificed by his father....." This typology repeats itself clearly in all four Gospels 2000 years later referring to Jesus Christ the Eternal Son of the most high God carrying his cross to Calvary hill to be crucified. Its as clear as a bell. Those who have eyes to see let them see, those who have ears to hear let them hear.
it just depends on how you are thinking !
@@psalm5187 the Quran confirms the previous scriptures.
If the previous scriptures were changed - how would you know?
There seems to be a strong motivation of the jews to want to change the sacrificial child - as the child of a maid servant who is not the forefather of the jewish people.
Yasir qadhis goal was not to discuss the view anyway, it was a way of introducing muslim audience to different way of thinking (especially with opinions which at first glance seem isolated/strange). Ishaq being the sacrifcial son is the dominant opinion early on in islamic history.
So it would be interesting to see why the shift after ibn taymiyyah
@@Adrian-yf1zg how do you know the previous scripture was changed ? Please can you show evidence? I can say anything I can say Mohammed is a paedophile. To justify this claim I would need evidence. Please show the changes in the scripture Islam has been crying about. Hebrew greek Latin or English.
@@psalm5187 what is wrong with christians on youtube? Are you unable to comprehend basic Statements. This is not a debate about the scripture you follow.
Read the above comments and try understand them before commenting.
Listened to this on Eid al-Adha 2022. So eye opening. May Allah reward and preserve sh. Yasir.
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
Subhan Allah! Barakallahu lak!
I think this shows us all a lesson!
I never knew about this... Jazak allahul kheiran about the beneficial knowledge you are sharing! It is humbling and shows me that I really am not in the position to defend a position. I have often debated with Christians about this topic and I was so sure... Subhan Allah... May Allah teach us all his knowledge...
I wish I could attend your seminar but we have 10.000 km between us... I am so thankful that you share your knowledge via CZcams so we all can benefit from it.
Allâh said (interpretation of the meaning): “But We gave her glad tidings of Ishaaq, and after him, of Ya’qoob.” (Hood 11:71) meaning that a child called Ya’qoob would be born during their (Sara and Ishaaq’s) lifetimes, and he would have many descendents… and it does not sound right for Ibraaheem to be commanded to sacrifice him when he was little, because Allaah had promised that he would have many descendents.
That was interesting -- academic presentation
I never heard about this before. Thank you for the insightful knowledge.
i wish indonesian people would watch your lectures and gain a bit of passion in becoming a little bit mature in our religion. it's been humbling experience for myself. But of course language is the main barrier. if somehow i could help to translate this..
I was waiting any video from Khaykh Dr Yasir Qadhi. May Allah bless u and increase your knowledge. Amen
Where are the young guys who know nothing and only refutes learned academics I hope they can see analysis of yasir qadhi from individual research if you young bankrupt refuters think you are indeed knowledgeable.
May Allah bless Shaikh yasir qadhi and give him the health to continue his work
The reason that almost no scholar says that it was Ishaq nowadays is because the later scholars, particularly ibn Taymiyyah, ibnul Qayyim and others, refuted that claim in such detail, and brought so many evidences, that it made it practically impossible to believe anything other than Ismaeel being intended
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Salam alaykom sheik, love your work, I can’t wait for the next episode
I keep watching this video and again thank you for your truthfulness. Please don't stop. People will fight truth but truth will prevail.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
this is amazing. i had no idea there was such a controversy within islam. and along comes YQ, broadening our horizons without warning.
There are many controversies in Islam, If most muslim apologists and IMAM's would be honest apostacy in Islam wouldn't be so bad.
@@truthinchristapologetics3542 i think we're talking about different kinds of controversies.
@@BSKX17 No, when people come to a faith and base their faith on what they’re told, no matter what it is, and then find out they were lied to it shakes their faith.
@@truthinchristapologetics3542 i have no idea what you're talking about. your name doesn't suggest you're an atheist.
@@BSKX17 I’m not an atheist. What I am talking about is Muslims have been told their entire lives that the Quran has never been changed, when we know otherwise, how Muhammad was a perfect example of a human to aspire to but when we read Al-Bukhari we find that it really isn’t the truth.
When I witness to people for Christianity I want them to accept Christ using the truth. Yes we know we have a handful of verses that have been added, out of over 23,000 verses it comes out to be less than 1/5th of a percent, less than 30. But we know what they are and were honest about it. Imagine if someone came to Christianity because I told them our bible was perfect, then they found that out.
It’s time for Islam to be honest, warts and all, the longer it waits the larger the fallout will be.
Dr Yasir Qadhi is a threat to Islamic University of Medinah... This guy is destroying the cult which limits thinking.
I like him. May ALLAH increase him in knowledge and wisdom.
What a brilliant speaker he is 👌🏽
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
@@samvoron1727 man you. Really want ishaq a.s to be sacrificed, man
@@drfaisalsaeed2331 . Allah revealed Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 meaning Allah knew that later Muslims would dispute which son was to be sacrificed.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat to show that no one changed the word of Allah because this is the proof Allah is real.
The meaning of “your only son” in Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2 is confirmed and explained in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48
By explaining Torah Genesis 22:2 below the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat is correct as proof the Quran is truthful and as proof no one can change the written word of Allah because that is the proof that Allah is real.
.
1. Quran chapter 38 is the chapter after the story of the sacrifice.
Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 is Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2.
In Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 Allah is blessing Abraham and Isaac with the vision dream and Ishmael is in the next verse without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream.
.
2. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Allah did not give the blessing of the remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice to Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
.
3. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice.
.
4. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
.
5. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice meaning Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
.
6. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not with his father at the time of the sacrifice because many years earlier Prophet Abraham Ibrahim was tested by sending Hagar and Prophet Ishmael Ismail away into the desert meaning Prophet Isaac Ishaq was “the only son” living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim at the time of the sacrifice.
.
7. The remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 38.
After the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah gave the blessing of the remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the next chapter Quran chapter 38.
.
Quran 38:45 Verse 38:45 And mention Our (Allah’s) servant Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel (who were), men with strength (of faith in Allah) and vision (to understand the meaning of dreams).
Note 1. Prophet Isaac Ishaq is blessed with his father.
Note 2. Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq are blessed with the vision dream.
.
Quran 38:46 Verse 38:46 We (Allah) chose them (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel) for an exclusive (quality which is their) remembrance of the home (in the hereafter which is the final destination after death).
.
Quran 38:47 Verse 38:47 And indeed they (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim, Prophet Isaac Ishaq and Prophet Jacob Yaqub Israel) to Us (Allah) from the chosen ones are the best (of humans).
.
Quran 38:48 Verse 38:48 And mention Prophet Ishmael Ismail and Prophet Elisha Al-Yasha and Prophet Ezekiel Zulkifl Dhul-Kifl. And all are from the best (of humans).
Note 1. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father compared to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 38:45 - 38:47.
Note 2. Prophet Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream compared to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 38:45 - 38:47.
.
8. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 is explained in Quran 12:6.
Quran 12:6 Koran 12:6 “And so your Lord (Allah) shall choose you (Joseph Yusuf) and shall teach you the interpretation of stories (dreams) and shall perfect His (Allah’s) favour on you (Joseph Yusuf) and on the family of Jacob Yaqub as He (Allah) perfected it on your fathers before you, (who were) Abraham Ibrahim and Isaac Ishaq. Your Lord (Allah) knows all things and is wise.”
.
9. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 is Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2.
Quran 38:45 - 38:47 blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq together with the vision dream and in the next verse Quran 38:48 Prophet Ishmael Ismail is blessed without his father and without the vision dream.
.
Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 and Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2 explain that the only son living with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream was Isaac Ishaq meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat.
.
Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq together with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and then Allah in the next verse blesses Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the vision dream in Quran 38:48 showing that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream (by not blessing him with the vision dream like Isaac Ishaq is blessed with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47) and also showing that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream (by not blessing him with his father like Isaac Ishaq is blessed with his father in Quran 38:45 - 38:47).
.
The story of the sacrifice in the Quran is proof that no one can change the written word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because the proof that Allah is real and the Quran is the truth is that no one can change the written word of Allah.
.
Torah Genesis 22:2 And He (Allah) said: “Take your son, your only son (who still lives with you, reminding him that Allah had earlier taken Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar away from him into Allah’s care in the desert in Genesis chapter 21 meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living with Abraham Ibrahim in Genesis chapter 22 when Allah is testing Abraham Ibrahim a second time to show if Abraham Ibrahim will give Allah his second son who is the only son still living with him after Abraham Ibrahim gave Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert in Genesis chapter 21), whom you love (Allah makes the test very hard by demanding his second son and reminding him that this is his only remaining son and reminding him that he already gave Allah one son in Genesis chapter 21 and reminding him of his love for these sons), even (namely, that is) Isaac Ishaq and go to the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt-offering on one of the mountains which I (Allah) will tell you. (Will Abraham Ibrahim give Allah the only son who is living with him after he already gave Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert in Genesis chapter 21. Will Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?).
@@drfaisalsaeed2331 . Allah revealed Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 meaning Allah knew that later Muslims would dispute which son was to be sacrificed.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat to show that no one changed the word of Allah because this is the proof Allah is real.
The meaning of “your only son” in Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2 is confirmed and explained in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48
By explaining Torah Genesis 22:2 below the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat is correct as proof the Quran is truthful and as proof no one can change the written word of Allah because that is the proof that Allah is real.
@@drfaisalsaeed2331 1. Quran chapter 38 is the chapter after the story of the sacrifice.
Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 38:48 is Torah Taurat Genesis 22:2.
In Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 Allah is blessing Abraham and Isaac with the vision dream and Ishmael is in the next verse without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream.
.
2. Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and 38:48 shows that Allah did not give the blessing of the remembrance of the famous vision dream of the sacrifice to Prophet Ishmael Ismail.
Great lecture. I hope you can discuss similar topics
Library chats is one of the best series so far MashaAllah, want it to be longer since this is soo interesting. JazakaAllah khair Shaykh
OMG! I remember when sheikh al-maghamsi came with this opinion; he was highly criticized. Till now, if you go to his channel its one of the only videos where the downvotes are higher than the thumbs up. Admittedly - I thought he pulled that opinion out of nowhere. I had no idea that it was so widely held in the past.
Does his channel have english subs?
Masha'Allah, i don't know why but i was so curious so much interested in this knowing this story, but now I'm even more confused, really grateful for bringing up this topic💚
LOL)
I think this is one of the best Library Chats. I didn't even know that this discussion existed in early Muslims. And the conclusion in the last ten minutes is thought-provoking. YQ keeping the pressure up on Salafis 😅
Assalamoalikum
It is really good to know the names of so many people of knowledge who in their own capacity and sincerity tried to serve Islam.
May Allah grant them highest of Jannah and forgive any mistakes in their work.
May Allah guide us All and forgive our sins makes us steadfast and sincere in our religion, and save us from sins and fitnah and grant us repentance and make us return to At Tawab every time we sin..
May Allah protect us and grant us best of both worlds.. Ameen
Dear YQ we like to know more and more about those people of knowledge and their work of gist of work. It help us to be respectful of scholars and allow us to live with difference of opinion where my way or the high way has becoming the standard practice of adherent of different sects and madhabs.
I believe the reasons the early Muslims believe it was Issac is because the Bible said is was , without proving at the same time the Bible saying Issac wasn’t because no math done was regarding the statement “ your one and only son” Which was Ishmael for 13 years.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Really like and enjoy these sessions. Please continue
I love this lecture. We follow blindly what was the order of the day. We should open our minds and ask questions.
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
In Islam, opening your mind and asking questions can cost you your life. Telling the truth about the holes in the standard narrative of Quran preservation almost cost YQ his career and his reputation. He had to back track and fall back into falsehood in order to save his skin. Yes, Islam requires you to follow blindly.
@@olivetree7756 What is the Gospel Injil?
Jesus did not write anything because everything Jesus taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
.
The four Gospels are four reports about Jesus meaning Jesus never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later.
.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil (not by the other books in the New Testament because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel) meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Torah Taurat came from Jesus and whatever contradicts the Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone (for example Mark, Matthew, Luke and John) who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
Jesus in the Gospel says the Tanakh will exist forever and will never change (and this is the reason that Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in the Tanakh Jewish scripture) meaning anything in the Gospel which contradict the Tanakh did not come from Allah or from Jesus.
For example when Paul in his letter says the Torah is old and will soon disappear this is opposite to what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel where the Torah is forever and will not change and must be followed forever by the Jewish people in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
.
Every prophet after Moses including Prophet Jesus and Prophet Muhammad reminded the Jewish people to observe the Torah forever as the Torah has commanded them and as the Gospel and Quran reminds them..
.
Sometimes the Gospel contradicts the Tanakh however some publishers of the Gospels have added foot notes explaining problem verses in the past therefore Christians in the present or in future can add foot notes to show verses that cannot be true such as the claim that Jesus descended from David because it contradicts the Tanakh (where a person can only inherit a tribe like David biologically through the father and not by adoption and not through the mother and not by choice) which Jesus said will never change and must be followed forever in Gospel of Matthew 5:17 - 5:20 and Gospel of Matthew 23:1 - 23:3.
In the Quran Prophet Jesus did not claim he inherited the House of David because it is impossible for anyone without a biological father to inherit a tribe in Judaism.
.
A. Gospel Problem: How was the New Testament contrived? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds
czcams.com/video/mJK6gY2IZUI/video.html
.
B. How did these four Gospels make it into the New Testament? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
The first person to assign the names Mark, Matthew, Luke and John to each of the earliest unnamed Gospel manuscripts was Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyon, in Gaul, today in France in 180 CE.
Gospel of Matthew 9:9 shows it was not written by Matthew because Matthew is mentioned in the third person and not in the first person.
czcams.com/video/HabMqyhx3YY/video.html
.
C. Does Judaism Regard Muslims as B’nai Noah (Righteous Gentiles)? Rabbi Tovia Singer.
Muslims correctly worship Allah means Muslims are righteous gentiles.
Do Jews believe Jesus was a prophet.
The Virgin birth in Islam is not a problem in Judaism.
The Virgin birth in Christianity is a problem in Judaism because some Christian Bibles wrongly translate the Jewish scripture in Isaiah 7:14 from "the young woman" to "a virgin."
Not all Christians are the same in 2011 the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops removed “virgin” in Isaiah 7:14 and put “young woman” in the New American Bible (Revised Edition).
czcams.com/video/eUL-HCI5Ri8/video.html
.
D. Why do Muslims believe that Jesus is the Messiah? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
czcams.com/video/RU-gFC_1B5U/video.html
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
@@olivetree7756 Books like the Book of Enoch quoted in the Christian Bible are rejected in Orthodox Judaism because in Tanakh angels always obey Allah meaning there are no fallen angels in Tanakh Jewish scripture.
.
Jesus did not write anything because everything Jesus taught by his mouth was already written in the Tanakh Jewish scripture meaning Jesus did not add or subtract from what is in Tanakh Jewish scripture as Allah commanded for the Jewish people in Torah Deuteronomy 4:2.
.
Torah Deuteronomy 4:2 You (the children of Israel) shall not add to the word which I (Allah) command you, neither shall you diminish (take away) from it, so that you may keep the commandments of the LORD your Allah which I (Allah) command you.
.
The four Gospels are four reports about Jesus meaning Jesus never wrote anything and what he said was passed by mouth until it was written many years later by four unknown people called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John.
.
The Quran tells the Christian to observe the Gospel and judge by the Gospel (not by the other books in the Christian New Testament Bible because what Paul teaches contradicts what Jesus is teaching in the Gospel) for example anything about fallen angels which come from the Book of Enoch contradict Tanakh Jewish scripture where there are no fallen angels because angels always obey Allah meaning it did not come from Jesus or Allah but is a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Torah Taurat came from Jesus and whatever contradicts the Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone (for example Mark, Matthew, Luke and John) who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
The difference between Satan in Christianity and Judaism.
Satan in Hebrew means obstruction or adversary. Starts 31 minutes 00 seconds 31:00
czcams.com/video/-DCGJvkJyus/video.html
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
@@olivetree7756 There are no names on the original earliest four Gospel Injil manuscripts meaning the names Mark, Matthew, Luke and John were all added later meaning no one knows who wrote them.
Quran 5:68 says observe the Torah Taurat and the Gospel Injil and Quran 5:47 tells Christians to judge by the Gospel Injil meaning whatever in the Gospel Injil is confirmed in the Torah Taurat came from Jesus and whatever contradicts the Torah Taurat came from the unknown writers who are traditionally called Mark, Matthew, Luke and John in a test from Allah described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone (for example Mark, Matthew, Luke and John) who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
1. In Quran 4:157 Jesus was not killed on the cross confirms the words of Jesus 3 days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 “I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allah, meaning I have not yet died)” ...
.
2. In Quran 4:158 Jesus was saved on the cross with sleep when his soul ascended to heaven in Quran 39:42 and the way Allah would save Jesus on the cross is foreshadowed before the time of the crucifixion in the Gospel Injil as follows.
.
Gospel of Mark 5:39 "... The child is not dead but sleeping",
Gospel of Matthew 9:24 "... For the maiden meaning the girl has not died but sleeps ..."
Gospel of Luke 8:52 "... She is not dead but sleeping."
Gospel of Luke 8:54 - 8:55 “…"Damsel meaning girl, wake up!" And her spirit returned, and she stood up at once, and he ordered that she be given something to eat. (This was proof that she was alive and not dead).
.
3. In Quran 5:75 and Quran 3:144 is the natural death of Jesus 2000 years ago which is mentioned three days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allah, meaning I have not yet died); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father (Allah, meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof to his people that he is human meaning do not let a miracle make you believe I am not a human like you) …”
.
4. In Quran 19:36 Jesus said “Allah is my Lord and your Lord” meaning Jesus is teaching his people that he is not Allah and this is said 3 days after the crucifixion in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus says to her (Mary Magdalene), "Do not hold on to me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father (Allah, meaning I have not yet died); but go to my brothers (my disciples), and tell them: 'I am ascending to my Father (to my creator Allah, meaning Jesus will die like every human dies as proof to his people that he is human meaning do not let a miracle make you believe I am more than a human like you) and your Father (to your creator Allah); to my Allah (to my Lord) and your Allah (to your Lord).”
.
5. Allah chose the Israelites and gave them the Torah Taurat and told them to observe the Sabbath Day in all their generations forever meaning Allah decreed Judaism and the Torah Taurat forever so that the following might be fulfilled.
.
a. The Torah Taurat shows which verses in the Gospel Injil confirm the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Jesus and which verses in the Gospel Injil contradict the Torah Taurat meaning they came from Mark, Matthew, Luke or John in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
b. In the same way Allah is testing Muslims in every generation in the story of the sacrifice in a test described in 1 Kings 13:14 - 13:24 teaching that the word of Allah will not change and do not believe anyone who claims the word of Allah has changed.
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
The sand timer in the background, first I thought it to be just decorative piece. I had to fast forward the video to confirm it's real and working 😊
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
I agree very much on ur way of thinking.. jazakallahu khayr
i stand with ibn Temiyya and his students for the fact that, the prophet showed us clearly how to perform hajj and where satan was chased away by throwing stones at him. this evidence is enough to say the sacrificial person was Ismail.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Thanks for this lecture. It's very informative and eye-opening.
MashaAllah, two episodes of Library chats (YQ gems) in a week? We are blessed, Alhamdulillah. JAK Sheikh Yasir.
Wallahi I had no idea. I thought Ismail was the monolith. You learn something new everyday.
It would be great that the history library chat is about Andalusian Spain.
Sir more power to your elbow this is to show that you are really learned and may Allah increase you in knowledge please we need more of this library chat thanks
I live in the uk. I wish there was a way to join classes in the institute that he teaches in .
I believe you can audit the classes
Barak Allahu fik, ya Shaykh. Much appreciated. Really enjoy these discussions.
As usual an eye opener. There are so many question in mind wish I could ask dr Yasir qadhi
I have no balls to watch the full vid, so who is the son of Abraham that Abraham wanted to slaughter??
@@youareastretchedasshole.3371 Ismail AS.
@The Astronomer Desperate Xtians Trying hard to propagate false informations on Islam. Shady Nasser's Positions are not correct.
Go to Articles of Yasin Dutton.
Marijn Van , Hythem Sidky , Sheikh Ammar Khatib to Know more on Qiraats.
@@ANSILKHANLR how can different qiraat change a word from fought to killed ?
@@youareastretchedasshole.3371 Put both words in the Ayah and read. U will get both are saying something. One is explanatory to other. That's the need of Qiraats.
jazakaAllahu khairan for introducing to all of us our islamic scholarly culture as always and broadend our thinking of islam in different directions and different interpretations.
Confronting the bold truth is way harder to imagine if it was the old days of CZcams the down thumbs will blow this video and we thank for the truth to be told by you Dr YQ.
Assalamualaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu MashaAllah Alhamdulillahir Rabbil Alamin SubhanAllahi walhamdulillahi wa la ilaha illallahu Allahu akbar, SubhanAllahi wabihamdihi SubhanAllahil azeem, Jazak Allahu Khairan
Barakallah feek sheikh this is very intellectually stimulating.
Attributes controversy hinted at.... Is jesus being the word of God,.... So when mu'tazili debated christians in abassid courts... The christians said speech of Allah is Eternal.... Jesus is referred as the word.... Therefore Jesus is Eternal..... So thats one of the reasons such a hard stance was taken by the Abbasid rulers and Hanbalis
Jesus has always Eternally has existed!
*In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God.* All things were made through him, and without him was not any thing made that was made.
John 1:1-3 ESV
bible.com/bible/59/jhn.1.1-3.ESV
Bible Study:
In the beginning [before all time] was the Word (Christ), and the Word was with God, and the Word was God Himself. He was [continually existing] in the beginning [co-eternally] with God. All things were made and came into existence through Him; and without Him not even one thing was made that has come into being.
John 1:1-3 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/jhn.1.1-3.AMP
How do we Know the Word Became Flesh?
*And the Word became flesh and dwelt among us,* and *we have seen his glory, glory as of the only Son from the Father, full of grace and truth.*
John 1:14 ESV
bible.com/bible/59/jhn.1.14.ESV
Bible Study:
And the Word (Christ) became flesh, and lived among us; and we [actually] saw His glory, glory as belongs to the [One and] only begotten Son of the Father, [the Son who is truly unique, the only One of His kind, who is] full of grace and truth (absolutely free of deception).
John 1:14 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/jhn.1.14.AMP
*Jesus tells us He Eternally Existed:*
Now, Father, *glorify Me together with Yourself, with the glory and majesty that I had with You before the world existed.*
John 17:5 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/jhn.17.5.AMP
Father, I desire that they also, whom You have given to Me [as Your gift to Me], may be with Me where I am, *so that they may see My glory* which You have given Me, *because You loved Me before the foundation of the world.*
John 17:24 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/jhn.17.24.AMP
When I saw Him, I fell at His feet as though dead. And He (Jesus) placed His right hand on me and said, “Do not be afraid; *I am the First and the Last* [absolute Deity, the Son of God], *and the Ever-living One* [living in and beyond all time and space]. *I died, but see, I am alive forevermore, and I have the keys of* [absolute control and victory over] *death and of Hades* (the realm of the dead).
Revelation 1:17-18 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/rev.1.17-18.AMP
“Behold, I (Jesus) am coming quickly, and My reward is with Me, to give to each one according to the merit of his deeds (earthly works, faithfulness). *I am the Alpha and the Omega, the First and the Last, the Beginning and the End [the Eternal One].* ”
Revelation 22:12-13 AMP
bible.com/bible/1588/rev.22.12-13.AMP
@@rc6289 and this is why the early scholars warned against kalam... Like the greek philosophers.
Watch Bart Erhman show how the gospel of john was the last gospel wfitten and how the early christians went astray
@@Adrian-yf1zg I have One Question for you.
Why would you Follow a Man who rejects God (YHWH) and who also Denies, your different God, Allah!
Satan will use scripture and twist it to cause Doubt, Bart also does the Same Thing to cause Doubt.
Why would you listen to a Man who rejects your god and My God?
Bart likes the "Famous and Rich Bart Erhman" more than he Loves God himself.
@@rc6289 to be frank and without trying to be offensive.... Even without bart erhman.... It's quote simple to say Jesus (peace be upon him) is not eternal, he was born and came in to existence... He was begotten.....meaning for muslims he was born
@@Adrian-yf1zg The Early Church had to deal with the First Heretic Named Arian. In 319 AD, (4th Century) Arian Position was, the Father was Eternal. And *before* the Creation of the Heaven and the Earth, Jesus was the Fathers First Creation.
So Arain believed the 1.Father is Eternal
2. The son of God was Created before the Heaven and the Earth.
Making the Word Not Eternal with the Father (Heresy teaching).
3. Then the Father Created Everything through His *Word.*
(The Word is Christ before Flesh.)
So, he maintained Jesus was the Son of God, But his first Creation.
The Problem then this means God Changed! *God does Not Change, He is the Same today, Yesterday and tomorrow.*
I can send you links of Scholars explaining who God is with the Early Church or the Disciples Creed and the Nicine Creed and look how similar they are.
Here is more on the Arainism Heresy
www.gotquestions.org/arianism.html
God is One in *Being* (YHWH), and Three in *Person* (Father, Son, and Holy Spirit).
Listen to how He explains God czcams.com/video/LoTSqXY5uhc/video.html
*The Oneness of God exist in three in Person who share the same essence or being.*
*What this means is the God (Yahweh) exists in the distinct and co-equal person of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit but they share a Fully Divine essence or being,* such as uncreatedness (always existed), Eternality, simplicity (indivisible), immutability (unchangeableness), Omniscience (all wise and knowing), Omnipotence (all Powerful), Goodness, Mercy, Holiness, will and Freedom.
*The Three Persons share the same Essence. That is, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are equally wise and Merciful and Holy; One is not more wise or merciful or holy than the other. The co-equal and distinct persons of the Father, Son (Word), and the Holy Spirit are not Three Gods because they share the Same Essence in Complete Unity.*
8 sahabas (3 of them are also mentioned in the other camp)
Over 15 of the famous taabiun
Imam Malik
Al-Azraqi
Ibn Qutayba
*Ibn Jarir at-Tabari*
Abul Mansur al-Maturidi
Abu Layth al-Samarqandi
*Al-Nahhas* (Egyptian grammarian)
Al Hakim al-Nishapuri: (mentioned the difference in opinion between muhaddiths & mufassirs)
Ath-Tha'labi
Al-Wahidi (debate about the place of sacrifice in the Ishaq AS camp)
Ibn al-Jawzi
Al-Qurtubi
Al-Jurzani
Al-Jahid
Al-Zajjaj (Grammarian of the Basrah school)
Al-Biruni
Az-Zamaxari*
Abu Hayyan
*Fakhr ad-Din ar-Razi*
Al-Suyuti
Ibn Attiyah
Al-Baydawi
*Ibn Taymiyyah*
Ibn al-Qayyim
Ibn Kathir
Barak Allahu feek. Sheikh, how I want to become your student??? Should I travel to USA from Malaysia
Me too
From India (WB)
Yes, go travel if you have the tools to enter and study in the seminary, why not ?
This poses interesting ramifications for Muslim-Christian Dialogue/Debate on the issue of which son was offered for sacrifice. As is usually the case that they're on opposing sides where in fact they can now actually agree on this issue (if the classical opinion is adopted by Muslims).
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
maashaALLAH to you..
Thank u for being honest🙏🙏🙏. At the end The Truth will set u free!!!
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
The first son is Ishmael, he is the sacraficed one, however he is not the begotten son of Ibrahim. The verses in Surah Saffat are clear, after the sacrafice Allah gave Ibrahim Isaac as a reward for being patient and accepted to do the sacrafice.
" He [Ibrahim] said, “I am going towards my Lord, and He will guide me.”
100. “My Lord, give me *one of the righteous* .”
101. So We gave him good news of a clement boy.
102. Then, when he was old enough to accompany him, he said, “O My son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you; see what you think.” He said, “O my Father, do as you are commanded; you will find me, God willing, one of the steadfast.”
103. Then, when they had submitted, and he put his forehead down.
104. We called out to him, “O Abraham!
105. You have fulfilled the vision.” Thus We reward the doers of good.
106. This was certainly an evident test.
107. And We redeemed him with a great sacrifice.
108. And We left with him for later generations.
109. Peace be upon Abraham.
110. Thus We reward the doers of good.
111. He was one of Our believing servants.
112. And We gave him good news of Isaac, a prophet, *one of the righteous* .
113. And We blessed him, and Isaac. But among their descendants are some who are righteous, and some who are clearly unjust to themselves"
Quran 37:100-113
How is Ismail AS not a begotten son of Ibraheem AS? Our Prophet SAW is a direct descendent of Ibraheem AS through Ismail AS
@@zaraghori
The prophet PBUH is direct descendent of Ishmail.
"And We gave him Isaac and Jacob in addition, and all [of them] We made righteous"
Quran 21:72
"And We gave to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob - all [of them] We guided. And Noah, We guided before; and among his descendants, David and Solomon and Job and Joseph and Moses and Aaron. Thus do We reward the doers of good."
Quran 6:84
Wathilah ibn al-Asqa’ reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, Allah chose Kinanah from the sons of Ishmael, he chose the Quraysh from Kinanah, he chose the tribe of Hashim from the Quraysh, and he chose me from the tribe of Hashim.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2276
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Muslim
@@MrAlio84 Yes I agree with all of this. I think you may not understand what begotten means. Your first comment insinuates that Ismaeel is not born from Ibrahim As
@@zaraghori
Allah in many verses said the descendant of Abraham are Isaac and Jacob. Allah never said Ishmael is the descendant of Abraham. Hagar was an Egyptian princess from the previous dynasty before they were taken as slaves, and Ishmael is her son, therfore he was the legitimate king of Egypt.
"According to the Qisas Al-Anbiya, a collection of tales about the prophets, Hājar was the daughter of the King of Maghreb, a descendant of Salih. Her father was killed by Pharaoh Dhu l-'arsh and she was captured and taken as a slave. Later, because of her royal blood, she was made mistress of the female slaves and given access to all of Pharaoh's wealth. Upon conversion to Ibrāhīm's faith, the Pharaoh gave Hājar to Sara who gave her to Ibrāhīm.
According to another tradition, Hājar was the daughter of the Egyptian king, who gave her to Ibrāhīm as a wife, thinking Sara was his sister.[22] According to Ibn Abbas, Ismā'īl's birth to Hājar caused strife between her and Sara, who was still barren. Ibrāhīm brought Hājar and their son to a land called Paran-aram or (Faran in Arabic, in latter days held to be the land surrounding Mecca).[23] The objective of this journey was to "resettle" rather than "expel" Hājar."
"Rabbinical commentators asserted that Hagar was Pharaoh's daughter. The midrash Genesis Rabbah states it was when Sarah was in Pharaoh's harem that he gave her his daughter Hagar as servant, saying: "It is better that my daughter should be a servant in the house of such a woman than mistress in another house"."
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Perfect library with perfect timer🤩🤩🤩
With all due respect Shaykh, I understand your reasoning for bringing up this issue as a lesson for critical thinking but I do have some serious objections to how you worded and portrayed it as if there was some sort of monumental revisionist shift towards Isma'il عليه السلام being the sacrificial son by later scholars whereas the truth is far less dramatic than that.
Yes, there was a difference of opinion between scholars with some really big names on the other side but it is rather disingenuous to suggest that the opinion of Ismail عليه السلام being the zabeeh was somehow a minority position. And some of the sources you cited - such as Mustadrak al Haakim and Imam Razi also are reported to have been of the position leaning towards Ismail عليه السلام.
To quote Al-Haakim:
- المستدرك على الصحيحين للحاكم - كتاب تواريخ المتقدمين من الأنبياء والمرسلينذكر إسماعيل بن إبراهيم صلوات الله عليهما - حديث: 3970حدثنا أبو بكر محمد بن عبد الله الشافعي،ثنا عبيد بن حاتم الحافظ العجلي،ثنا إسماعيل بن عبيد بن عمر بن أبي كريمة الحراني،ثنا عبد الرحيم الخطابي،ثنا عبد الله بن محمد العتبي،ثنا عبد الله بن سعيد الصنابحي، قال: حضرنا مجلسمعاوية بن أبي سفيان فتذاكر القوم إسماعيل وإسحاق بن إبراهيم فقال بعضهم: الذبيح إسماعيل، وقال بعضهم: بل إسحاق الذبيح، فقال معاوية: " سقطتم على الخبير كنا عند رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فأتاه الأعرابي، فقال: يا رسول الله، خلفت البلاد يابسة والماء يابسا هلك المال وضاع العيال، فعد علي بما أفاء الله عليك يا ابن الذبيحين، فتبسم رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم ولم ينكر عليه، فقلنا: يا أمير المؤمنين، وما الذبيحان؟ قال: إن عبد المطلب لما أمر بحفر زمزم نذر لله إن سهل الله أمرها أن ينحر بعض ولده فأخرجهم، فأسهم بينهم فخرج السهم لعبد الله فأراد ذبحه فمنعه أخواله من بني مخزوم وقالوا: ارض ربك وافد ابنك. قال: ففداه بمائة ناقة، قال: فهو الذبيح وإسماعيل الثاني
Another quote by Al-Haakim:
قال الحاكم: وقد ذكره الواقدي بأسانيده وهذا القول عن أبي هريرة، وعبد الله بن سلام وعمير بن قتادة الليثي وعثمان بن عفان وأبي بن كعب وعبد الله بن مسعود وعبد الله بن عمر وعبد الله بن عمرو والله أعلم.وقد كنت أرى مشايخ الحديث قبلنا وفي سائر المدن التي طلبنا الحديث فيه وهم لا يختلفون أن الذبيح إسماعيل وقاعدتهم فيه قول النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: " أنا ابن الذبيحين " إذ لا خلاف أنه من ولد إسماعيل وأن الذبيح الآخر أبوه الأدنى عبد الله بن عبد المطلب والآن فإني أجد مصنفي هذه الأدلة يختارون قول من قال: إنه إسحاق، فأما الرواية عن وهب بن منبه وهو باب هذه العلوم *
Here Al-Haakim clearly states from amongst the scholars of his time there was no difference of opinion that Ismail عليه السلام was the zabeeh.
Imam Razi is also quoted to have the same opinion:
وبناء على ماسبق يقول الرازي ” أَجْمَعَ النَّاسُ عَلَى أَنَّ إِسْمَاعِيلَ مُتَقَدِّمٌ فِي الْوُجُودِ عَلَى إِسْحَاقَ، فَثَبَتَ أَنَّ الْمَطْلُوبَ بهذا الدعاء وهو إِسْمَاعِيلُ، ثُمَّ إِنَّ اللَّهَ تَعَالَى ذَكَرَ عَقِيبَهُ قِصَّةَ الذَّبِيحِ فَوَجَبَ أَنْ يَكُونَ الذَّبِيحُ هُوَ إِسْمَاعِيلُ”.
Moreover:
ذهب إلى القول بأن الذبيح إسماعيل : عبد الله بن عمر وأبو هريرة ، وأبو الطفيل عامر ابن واثلة، وهو قول سعيد بن المسيب، والشعبي، والحسن البصري، ومجاهد، والربيع بن أنس، ومحمد بن كعب القرظي، والكلبي، وهي رواية عطاء بن أبي رباح، ويوسف بن ماهك عن ابن عباس .
وقال ابن عادل : " وقال الإمام أحمد : الصحيح أن الذبيح هو إسماعيل وعليه جمهور العلماء من السَّلف والخلف".
Mujahid here is yet another example you cited that is also reported to have stated that Isma'il عليه السلام was the zabeeh. Of course, other names such as Hasan Al Basri and Sha'bi. Finally, Imam Ahmed Ibn Hanbal is quoted to have said categorically: "The authentic position is that Isma'il was the sacrifice, and on this is the consensus of the Salaf and the Khalaf".
Once again, I understand you bringing this up as an academic exercise, but the assertion that the mainstream opinion on this "evolved" over time because of some kind of revisionist movement by later scholars is erroneous at best and misleading at worst.
May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge.
I fear the people with novice understanding of Islam might go in the wrong direction after listening to the lecture. The issue is why an ijma that has been built over time need to be revised? What a common person will benefit from knowing the issue in the video? The common people might take from the lecture that all the ijma are like the one mentioned in the video, while this is not the case. So if the past ijma or scholarly opinion had influence of socio-political situation, how do we make sure that the opinion of YQ or other western scholar is not influenced by it? Why "Haqq" or bravery is breaking away from other scholars? If that is the case, then the safe is still to stay with the majority of ulama. May Allah protect him and all of us and increase our knowledge.
@@Kakashi-nl9cl Brother, YQ did not say it was Ishaq (A), due to the impact of Israelites, our early authors were misled. Ibn Taymiyyah changed the notion with evidence and it is also mentioned in Tafsir Ibn Kathir. However, Even if it was Ishaq(A), it will not impact our Akeeda at all. And follow what YQ said, even though all the Giants of Islam said one thing, Ibn Taymiyyah changed the notion academically.
@@faridahmed3152 Thanks brother for your input. I don't have problem with the particular issue of Ishaq or Ismail A.S. My issue is with the principle which Dr.YQ is using this example for.
@@faridahmed3152 again, I should make clear that Dr. Yasir's assertion that Ismail عليه السلام being the zabeeh was somehow a minority position and the consensus shifted only after Ibn Taymiyyah is categorically false. I have quoted numerous early giants of Islamic scholarship before Ibn Taymiyyah who also had no doubt over Ismail عليه السلام being the zabeeh. Now I don't intend to imply that the Sheikh is deliberately misleading us - maybe he wasn't aware of this, but what he said is simply incorrect.
@@IsolatedIntellectual Assalamualiqum Brother, Yes I got your point. Thanks a lot for clarification
The main thing I learned that this man has always taught that our salvation is independent of these things rather our faith in Allah Prophet Muhammad s.a.w day of judgment and the commands Allah and Prophet will take us to jannah
Correct
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Im sure all the haters of sheik yasir are listening attentively .(scratching their heads again)
I have been following Sh Yasir Qadhi for several years and I can testify that the haters have gotten everything wrong and all their accusations are *categorically* untrue. As if they have been living in alternate universe.
These haters do give some Islamic knowledge that benefits me, but it is the *smallest fraction possible* compared to the enormous knowledge and benefits that Shaykh Yasir has been giving to us for *free* for many many years. My head will explode with so much knowledge and understanding from Sh Yasir.
I really wish these haters learn some manners and know their place. And learn to sit at the corner and be silent.
And I pray for Allah's blessings to Sh Yasir and his family. May Allah multiply the rewards of Sh Yasir. Obviously, I can't repay Sh Yasir's lecture but I ask Allah Taala to pay him in Jannah.
Jazaakallah Shaykh.Very beneficial and eye-opening.
First of all, what I could not understand is why it was alright for both opinion to co-exist for 700 years and now it is almost like a Shirk to mention that it was Ishaq? secondly, for us average Muslims why whether it was Ishaq or Ismael make any difference? in this story Allah was teaching us and showing us what a true submission to him is, and that is what matter.
For Christians it is very important so i'd suggest that muslim want to distance themselves from the Christian teaching it was Isaac since Ishmael was outside of wedlock. (Genesis 16)
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Critical Loyalty has had a similar objective for many years now. Their motto is critical thinking while staying loyal to the tradition. Excited to see the Islamic Seminary's take on this, as I love Sh YQ's lectures and classes.
As-Salaam-Alaikum. I'm no scholar but in Surat AsSaffat, 37:99-113, Allah calls out to Abraham (AS) and tells him that he has fulfilled the vision and that this was a clear trial, and thus Allah reward the doers of good, and Abrabram (AS) was a believing servant and we gave him the glad tidings of Issac (AS). So in this narrative from ayat 99-113, the story of the sacrifice comes first, and then the story of the good news of Issac (AS) comes second. Also, in the Bible, Genesis 1-24, God commanded Abraham to sacrifice his son, his only son. At no time was Issac the only son of Abraham.
Selam aleikum, that is a good point however you need to relise that the text in the Hebrew says his only begotten son. Now in Hebrew to say begotten typically implies uniqueness to this sonship and this is used throughout the bible. Now notice that ismail is birthed by hagar who is a concubine whereas ishaq came from Sarah who is his legitimate wife. Thus ishaq is his only legitimate child in terms of inheritance, additionally this is reinforced by the narrative in genesis that God proclaims ishaq to be the one carrying Abraham's seed thus reinforcing the uniqueness of ishaq and thus legitimating him being called his only begotten son. Hope what I said makes sense and Allah knows best.
@@haidersalam2406 W/S . I'm going according to the Quran. You are using the same argument that the Jews do by demeaning Hagar and Ismael (AS). The Bible clearly states that Hagar was gifted to Abraham {AS} as his wife. Gen 16:3. So Hagar was Abraham's wife and Ishmael {AS} was his first born. According to Jewish law, the rights of inheritance is favored to the first born.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Impressed by the way you introduced ibn taymiyyah, it was really a climax 👍
This is collosal revelation jazakallah kheir sheik
Yasir qadhi I appreciate your honesty.. Just like standard Islamic narratives...
Love it. Nobody ever did it at this level.
Eye - opener Mashallah
May God reward you for your great work
I love these type of videos. I find them extremely beneficial. Keep up the good work. Salam from your brother from Down Under.
Your lectures has been my company for months whenever i need to drive far. Always inspiring.
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
How can someone join the Islamic seminary
Why did you stop the series of the prophet and libery chats
This great lecture broadened my mind.
Shaykh, you should make a video about Historical conflict between traditional scholars and sufis. I came across some 'hanbali sufis' in the past which I didnt know existed at any time.
I think sheikh Abdul Qadir Gilani r.a. was a sufi leader of a tariqa and hanbali and I think a syed as well
@yasir qadhi asak, Shaikh do you have any plans on making series on Mongols. You mentioned few time in other videos you will do one when you get a chance. JZK
I like this Yasir Qadhi
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Interesting and academic! Allah truly knows best
I am not a Muslim but I found this lecture very interesting. YQ is saying far more than the words you hear. He is teaching the truth about Islam and the only way to get to the truth is by critical thinking. However accepting the truth comes at great cost so it cannot be spoken about when learned. The regurgitaters are too many.
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
Sir, Yasir, I think that the context of surah saffat reveals that the sacrifice was indeed Ismail. Verse 112 comes after the incident. I did not watch the whole video so I do not know if you mentioned this.
Well I'm sure he knows all of the evidences of both sides, although he did not mention them.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
Good news is always the word used to describes Isaac Ishaq in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, and 51 and there is no change in the meaning of good news as Isaac Ishaq in the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37.
.
Quran 37:101 Koran 37:101 (In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq. The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim) So We (Allah through His angels) gave him (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim) the good news of a forbearing (meaning patient, not complaining) son (Prophet Isaac Ishaq who is also unnamed in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and 51:28 because good news is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51).
.
Quran 37:112 Koran 37:112 (In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq. The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim) And We (Allah) gave him (Prophet Abraham Ibrahim) the good news of Isaac Ishaq (a second time after Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:102 - 37:107 and blessed Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:108 - 37:111. The good news is always the name of Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51), a prophet of the righteous (requested in Quran 37:100 and given by Allah as the good news son in Quran 37:101 and when in Quran 37:102 Prophet Isaac Ishaq is old enough to work with Prophet Abraham Ibrahim they both understand the vision in a dream that showed Prophet Isaac Ishaq will be sacrificed and is remembered in Quran 12:6 and Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and showing in the next verse in Quran 38:48 that it was not Prophet Ishmael Ismail by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of vision and so Allah decreed those revelations in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 to guide by Allah’s word those who understand what Allah is teaching. Those who understand are guided by the words of Allah. Those who do not understand are misguided by the words of humans. The righteous good news son is named Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:112 and Allah blesses both the father Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and the son Prophet Isaac Ishaq in Quran 37:113. Quran 11:69 where good news is unnamed like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 and together with Quran 11:71 where the good news is named as Prophet Isaac Ishaq like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 show that good news both when it is named or not named is the name for Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran. Quran 11:74 where good news is unnamed like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 and together with Quran 11:71 where the good news is named as Prophet Isaac Ishaq like in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 show that good news both when it is named or not named is the name for Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran. Quran 29:31 which mentions good news is related to Quran 29:27 which mentions Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the same way as in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 which mentions good news is related to Quran 37:112 which mentions Prophet Isaac Ishaq because good news is always the name of Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran).
.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
I love Prophet Ishaq & Prophet Ismail likewise. We are all followers of Ibrahim regardless .
Allaah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
Nowhere in the Quran did Allaah say anyone changed the written word of Allaah because the proof Allaah is real is that no one can change His written word except with their spoken words meaning in conversation for example in the story of the sacrifice of the son of Abraham Ibrahim no one could change the word of Allaah except in conversations when some Muslims said the son to be sacrificed was Ishaq and other Muslims said the son to be sacrificed was Ismail.
.
Notice that no Muslim changed the word of Allaah in the Quran except with their mouth in conversation and in the same way no Jew can change the word of Allaah in the Tanakh Jewish scripture except with their mouth in conversation.
.
Allaah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allaah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allaah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allaah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allaah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allaah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allaah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allaah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allaah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allaah then Allaah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allaah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allaah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allaah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allaah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allaah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allaah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allaah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allaah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allaah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allaah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allaah it would be proof that Allaah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allaah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allaah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allaah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allaah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allaah and this is when Allaah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allaah because it is Allaah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allaah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allaah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allaah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allaah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allaah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allaah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allaah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allaah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allaah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allaah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allaah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allaah-answers-2
@@samvoron1727 We are all mankind of God , please try not to compare between prophets . Allah mentioned Ismail & Ishaq as holy prophets . Main belief is that we are all followers of Ibrahim. And prophet Ibrahim was a friend of Allah .
@@samvoron1727 Surahe Kaderoon , Allah commanded us not to argue with other. People of the book. Your faith is for you & my faith is for me. May God Bless you 🙏
@@1sagstermaster Assalamu alaikum brother,
How does Allah show that Quran 37:112 reveals the name of the good news son in the sacrifice?
The verse structure and content about Prophet Noah Nuh and Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is the same in Quran chapter 37 and shows that Quran 37:82 the people in the flood is like Quran 37:112 the people in the sacrifice.
.
Quran 37:82 is about the people in the flood like Quran 37:112 is about the people in the sacrifice as shown below.
.
Quran 37:112 reveals the name of the good news son in the sacrifice like Quran 37:82 reveals the people who drowned in the flood.
.
Quran 37:75 Noah prayed before the flood. Quran 37:100 Abraham prayed before the sacrifice.
.
Quran 37:76 Allah saved Noah. Quran 37:106 Abraham passed the test.
.
Quran 37:77 and saved his off spring. Quran 37:107 and saved his son.
.
Quran 37:78 Remembrance of Noah. Quran 37:108 Remembrance of Abraham.
.
Quran 37:79 Peace is on Noah in heaven. Quran 37:109 Peace is on Abraham in heaven.
.
Quran 37:80 Peace is the reward for good doers. Quran 37:110 Peace is the reward for good doers.
.
Quran 37:81 He is one of Our believing servants. Quran 37:111 He is one of Our believing servants.
.
Quran 37:82 Reveal who drowned in the flood. Quran 37:112 Reveal the name of the good news son in the sacrifice.
.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
@@1sagstermaster The promise before Ishmael Ismail is born he will have many descendants.
Ishmael Ismail means “Allah has heard” meaning Allah has heard the call for help from his mother Hagar Hajar in Genesis 16:11 and Allah tells Hagar Hajar that she will give birth to a son called Ishmael Ismail and Allah promised Hagar Hajar will have many descendants from Ishmael Ismail in Genesis 16:10 - 16:11 meaning before the birth of both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq Allah promises they will both produce many descendants.
.
This is very interesting because it means that before the sacrifice of the son of Abraham Ibrahim Allah had promised before the birth of both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have many descendants.
.
Would Abraham Ibrahim sent Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar into the desert with little water when Allah had promised descendants from Ishmael Ismail before the birth of Ishmael Ismail in Genesis 16:10 - 16:11?
.
Would Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq when Allah had promised descendants from Isaac Ishaq before the birth of Isaac Ishaq?
.
Trusting in the promises of Allah and giving Allah both children was a great test from Allah which Abraham Ibrahim passed and which teach humans to look after each other and stop the human sacrifices which were happening in the time of Abraham Ibrahim meaning Allah showed humans that Allah does not want human sacrifice and Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Jazakallah sheikhs
I'm glad I stuck around for later part of the talk. Felt a little disheartened at first as I had never heard the other opinions before. Jazakallah khair shaykh
Assalamu Alaikum,
1. Why did the first Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Isaac Ishaq?
The Torah Taurat names Isaac Ishaq as the son to be sacrificed and the Quran tells the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:40 and confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat in Quran 2:41 and says in Quran 4:136 “... whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah)” and in Quran 3:93 “… Say (Prophet Muhammad, to the Jews of Yathrib), "Bring the Torah Taurat here and recite it (to me as evidence) if what you say is true." meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat to show that humans do not have the power to change the written word of Allah (in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:3) which the Jews have been commanded to follow forever in the Torah Taurat by observing the Sabbath Day in all their generations in a covenant agreement made with Allah forever in the Torah Taurat which is confirmed in the Quran as proof Allah is real and as proof the Quran is truthful.
.
2. Why did later Muslims believe that the son to be sacrificed was Ishmael Ismail?
Later Muslims said that Ishmael Ismail was the only son for 13 years and therefore the Jews changed the Torah Taurat.
However when you read the Torah Taurat you will find that Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq were both living in the same house before the sacrifice and it was after Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar are sent into the desert that the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim is Isaac Ishaq and this is why Allah says “Take your only son Isaac Ishaq and sacrifice him” meaning the faith in Quran 4:136 which the first Muslims had in the Torah Taurat was the correct faith meaning later Muslims did not read the Torah Taurat and believed what other people told them when they claimed the sacrifice was before the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Isaac Ishaq is given to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice. The first time is by the angel of Allah with the birth of Isaac Ishaq and the second time is after the angel of Allah stops the sacrifice and gives Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time.
The name good news is always the name of Isaac Ishaq in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
.
In both the Quran and Torah Taurat Ishmael Ismail is not mentioned anywhere in Quran chapter 37 or in Torah Taurat Genesis 22 which is the story of the sacrifice.
.
In the Quran Allah only blesses Abraham Ibrahim and Isaac Ishaq in the story of the sacrifice.
Allah has left no blessing or mention of Ishmael Ismail in the story of the sacrifice because he is not in this story.
.
The Quran confirms the Torah Taurat however Satan Shaitan tests Muslims to show who believes the word of Allah was changed in the Torah Taurat in the same way Satan Shaitan tests Christians to show who believes Prophet Jesus Isa is Allah.
.
3. The story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 starts in Quran chapter 19.
The story of Prophet Isaac Ishaq who is called the “Good News” son is the story of the son of Sarah and Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapters 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
In Quran 19:46 - 19:49 Abraham Ibrahim lived with his father and prays and when he went away Allah gave him Isaac Ishaq in Quran 19:49 meaning this is the story of the son of Sarah.
.
The story in Quran 19:46 - 19:49 which is the story of Isaac Ishaq the son of Sarah is the same story in the beginning of the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:98 - Quran 37:101.
1. Quran 37:98 is Quran 19:46 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is living with his father.
2. Quran 37:99 is Quran 19:47 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
3. Quran 37:100 is Quran 19:48 Prophet Abraham Ibrahim prays.
4. Quran 37:101 (We gave him the good news) is Quran 19:49 (“We gave him Isaac Ishaq”).
.
The angel of Allah gave the Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq twice.
The first time the angel of Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is as the Good News in Quran 37:101 which is the same as when Prophet Isaac Ishaq is given the first time in Quran 19:49.
This Good News son Prophet Isaac Ishaq is to be sacrificed in the next verse Quran 37:102.
.
The second time Allah gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq is after Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Prophet Isaac Ishaq a second time to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112
.
The story of the sacrifice only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq both separately and together as the father and son.
Allah has left no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 meaning the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat as proof no one can change the words of Allah as promised in Quran 6:34, Quran 6:115, Quran 10:64, Quran 18:27 and Quran 30:30
Quran 4:136 Koran 4:136 “... and whoever has no faith in … Allah's Books … then he has strayed far away (from Allah).”
I really like المغامسي he seems to do more critical thinking than a lot of other sheikhs. He seems to also be really into history too.
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
Great lecture and great points....Majority opinions of a time may not be the Truth..........but it may be.
If someone know...
What was the evidences of the Pro Ishaaq camp of scholars (apart from Israili riwayaat)?
I did hear the evidences of Pro Ismaili scholars...and I did hear it's refutation/answers to those evidences....
But I didn't hear any evidence of the Pro Ishaaq scholars.
Did I miss something?
@Mohamed Ismail
Yes yes... Jazakallahu Khayran katheera...
@Mohamed Ismail Surah Saaffaat Ayah 100 to 102 really does make it feel like the child was growing up with Ibrahim A.S. and it was the same child for whom Allah gave bashara..
Tabari's points are really strong
@Mohamed Ismail your points are valid. Point number 2 & 3 are have good reasoning.
@The Astronomer the pro Ismail camp's number one allegation on Pro Ishaaq camp was that they had taken it from the Israeli Riwaayaat.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
Salam Brother, but what about the hajj? We throw the stones at 3 devils, wasn't the mother of Ismael tempted about the sacrifice of her son? So that sounds like the Georgia tafseer goes in line with the hajj ritual
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
One in a million truthful muslim...thank you yasir
If YQ were truthful he would have left Islam
Allaah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
Nowhere in the Quran did Allaah say anyone changed the written word of Allaah because the proof Allaah is real is that no one can change His written word except with their spoken words meaning in conversation for example in the story of the sacrifice of the son of Abraham Ibrahim no one could change the word of Allaah except in conversations when some Muslims said the son to be sacrificed was Ishaq and other Muslims said the son to be sacrificed was Ismail.
.
Notice that no Muslim changed the word of Allaah in the Quran except with their mouth in conversation and in the same way no Jew can change the word of Allaah in the Tanakh Jewish scripture except with their mouth in conversation.
.
Allaah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allaah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allaah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allaah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allaah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allaah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allaah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allaah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allaah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allaah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allaah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allaah then Allaah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allaah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allaah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allaah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allaah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allaah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allaah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allaah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allaah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allaah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allaah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allaah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allaah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allaah it would be proof that Allaah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allaah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allaah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allaah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allaah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allaah and this is when Allaah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allaah because it is Allaah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allaah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allaah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allaah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allaah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allaah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allaah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allaah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allaah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allaah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allaah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allaah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allaah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/site/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allaah-answers-2
I had a slight hint previous to this lecture, there was even a hint of difference of opinion in this topic. However i have to admit that I did not know this debate on this matter was this rich and wide. I took it as given that Ismael was the sacrificed one. thank you again for this again. Now, time and time again i am finding how little I have known about Islam.
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2
I can feel it, when I told my friends that iguana is halal they all shouted on me like I am a Dumbo who doesn't know anything.
Si is camel , rabbit, shrimp etc etc
Mashalah the way you brought in Ibn Taymiyya 42:10 🦁
subhanallahhh Lion
God gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time God gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that God stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does God say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When God says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat God is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to God when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
God tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse God and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to God in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give God both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey God then God stops the test and fulfils His promise because God always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name God gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
God names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. God has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 God only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where God blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and God blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of God in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of God it would be proof that God did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born God promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice God promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
God told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject God by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to God and this is when God stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to God because it is God who has commanded this test of faith and it is God who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what God commanded him to do in this test.
.
God stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to God in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice God saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that God always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that God forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that God is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (God’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from God, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with God which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthekoran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/god-answers-2
Jazakallah khair
Wow good work sheikh. But to me is obvious that the first 700 yrs are right positions which include big sahabas like of Omar r.a and ibn Abbas even Othman was mention. And your position as Ismail aa dhabiha just to go with the mass is somehow bizzare. As Razi said no one for sure knows who is who. Am from today support Is-haq as dhabiha. Allah knows best
Allah gave the good news of Isaac Ishaq twice to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim.
In the story of Isaac Ishaq, Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim twice.
The first time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:101 which is the good news of the birth of Isaac Ishaq.
The second time Allah gave Isaac Ishaq to Prophet Abraham Ibrahim is in Quran 37:112 which is the good news that Allah stopped the sacrifice of Isaac Ishaq and for a second time gave Isaac Ishaq to Abraham Ibrahim.
.
Why does Allah say sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat?
When Allah says sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq in the Torah Taurat Allah is reminding Prophet Abraham Ibrahim that he already gave one son to Allah when he long ago sent Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar into the desert.
Allah tests Prophet Abraham Ibrahim a second time by saying sacrifice your only son Isaac Ishaq who still lives with you.
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim refuse Allah and say but you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who is the only son still living with him after he had already given Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert?
Will Prophet Abraham Ibrahim give Allah both his sons?
.
When Prophet Abraham Ibrahim shows he will obey Allah then Allah stops the test and fulfils His promise because Allah always fulfils His promise.
In the story of sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
Prophet Isaac Ishaq is called the good news son in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29, 37 and 51.
When the Good News son is not named four times in Quran 15:53, 15:54, 15:55 and in Quran 51:28 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:101 where the good news son is also not named because it is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq.
.
When the Good News son is named five times in Quran 11:69, 11:71, 11:74 and Quran 29:27, 29:31 it is Prophet Isaac Ishaq and this is the same in the story of the sacrifice in Quran 37:112 where the good news son is also named Prophet Isaac Ishaq because Good News is always the name Allah gives to Prophet Isaac Ishaq in the Prophet Abraham Ibrahim story in the Quran.
.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq as the good news son 9 times in Quran chapter 11, 15, 19, 29 and 51.
Allah names Prophet Isaac Ishaq four times in Quran chapter 37 twice as the good news son and twice by name.
In the story of the sacrifice in the Quran Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq. Allah has left no other blessing.
.
In the story of the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son of Prophet Abraham Ibrahim in Quran chapter 37 Allah only blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and his son Prophet Isaac Ishaq and leaves no other blessings in the story of the sacrifice and this famous vision dream is remembered in the next chapter Quran chapter 38 where Allah blesses Prophet Abraham Ibrahim and Prophet Isaac Ishaq with the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and shows in the next verse that Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not the son in the vision dream and Prophet Ishmael Ismail was not living with his father during the vision dream by blessing Prophet Ishmael Ismail without his father and without the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:48.
This is confirmed in Quran 12:6 and in Torah Genesis 22:2.
.
In two famous vision dreams in the Quran Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the sacrifice of the son in Quran chapter 38 after the story of the sacrifice in Quran chapter 37 and Allah blesses both the father and the son with the vision dream of the bowing of the Sun and the Moon and the eleven stars towards one star in Quran chapter 12 as proof the Quran confirms the Torah Taurat meaning as proof humans do not have the power to change the word of Allah in the Quran and in the Torah Taurat because if humans could change the word of Allah it would be proof that Allah did not exist.
.
Before Ishmael Ismail was born Allah promised his mother Hagar Hajar that Ishmael Ismail would have many descendants in Torah Genesis 16:8 - 16:11 meaning before the story of the sacrifice Allah promised that both Ishmael Ismail and Isaac Ishaq would have children.
.
Allah told Abraham Ibrahim in a vision dream to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq (in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6) who was the only son living with him (in Torah Genesis 22:2) meaning Ishmael Ismail was not living in Canaan today Palestine and Israel during.the vision dream (in Quran 38:48 where Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with the vision dream and Ishmael Ismail is not blessed with his father meaning the only son living with Abraham Ibrahim during the vision dream is Isaac Ishaq in the blessing of the vision dream in Quran 38:45 - 38:47 and Quran 12:6).
.
Abraham Ibrahim passed the test because he did not reject Allah by saying “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because you promised future generations for me from Isaac Ishaq” or “I will not sacrifice Isaac Ishaq because I already gave you Ishmael Ismail and his mother Hagar Hajar in the desert” instead Abraham Ibrahim showed that he would give both his sons to Allah and this is when Allah stopped the sacrifice and gave Isaac Ishaq a second time to Abraham Ibrahim in Quran 37:112.
.
The choice of a first born animal or a first born son in a sacrifice does not apply to Allah because it is Allah who has commanded this test of faith and it is Allah who can choose anyone to be the sacrifice.
Abraham Ibrahim did not have a choice about who to sacrifice but he could only obey or disobey what Allah commanded him to do in this test.
.
Allah stopped the test when Abraham Ibrahim showed that after he had given his first son Ishmael Ismail and Hagar Hajar to Allah in the desert he was willing to sacrifice Isaac Ishaq who was his only son who was still living with Abraham Ibrahim in Canaan today in Israel and Palestine during the vision dream.
.
By stopping the sacrifice Allah saved Isaac Ishaq and fulfilled the promise that Isaac Ishaq would have children as proof that Allah always fulfils His promises and to teach humans that Allah forbids human sacrifice in Quran 17:31, Quran 16:57 - 16:59, Quran 81:8 - 81:9, Leviticus 18:21, Leviticus 20:3, Deuteronomy 12:31, Deuteronomy 18:10, Deuteronomy 24:16, Hosea 6:6, Jeremiah 7:22 - 7:23, Psalm 40:7 in Tanakh Jewish Scripture or Psalm 40:6 in Christian Bibles and Micah 6:7 - 6:8.
.
The proof that Allah is real is the Quran and the Torah Taurat confirming and explaining each other because "Whoever has no faith in His (Allah’s) Books then he has strayed far away (from Allah, Quran 4:136)."
.
Most early Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Isaac Ishaq.
Most later Muslims believed the son to be sacrificed is Ishmael Ismail.
This means most early Muslims believed no one changed the Torah Taurat which confirms Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat) and most later Muslims believed the Torah Taurat was changed which contradicts Quran 2:40 (telling the Jewish people to observe their covenant with Allah which is the Torah Taurat forever) and Quran 2:41 (telling the Jewish people that the Quran confirms what is with the Jewish people in the Torah Taurat).
.
1. Which son was to be sacrificed?
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/which-son-was-to-be-sacrificed
.
2. Library chats E7: Ismā`īl vs. Isḥāq as the sacrifice: A case study of tafsīr and scholarly influence.
czcams.com/video/CANtmlGngiw/video.html
.
3. Was Abraham commanded to sacrifice Isaac or Ishmael?
www.judaism-islam.com/was-abraham-commanded-to-sacrifice-isaac-or-ishmael/
.
4. Quran chapter 37. The story of the sacrifice.
sites.google.com/view/islamandthequran/quran-chapter-37-surah-37
.
sites.google.com/view/quran-tanakh-gospel/allah-answers-2