‘Make Spain great again’: does Melilla really need a Trump-style wall? | Divided Cities
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 11. 2019
- Everyone in Melilla has some connection to the city’s most visible and controversial feature: a huge barbed-wire fence, which separates this Spanish port city from the rest of north Africa.
Subscribe to The Guardian on CZcams ► bit.ly/subscribegdn
Asylum seekers like Aboubacar wait for months in hidden forest camps to scale the fence, populist politicians like Jesús want to strengthen it, and both the Moroccan and Melillan economy depend on the 30,000 Moroccans like Youssra who cross through it every day to work. Will Melilla embrace its fate as a city embedded in Africa - or will it succumb to populist Trump-style demands to build a wall?
Divided Cities is a five-part documentary series exploring five cities split by major global divisions. Subscribe here for the next episode ► is.gd/subscribeguardian
Support the Guardian ► support.theguardian.com/contr...
Today in Focus podcast ► www.theguardian.com/news/seri...
Sign up for the Guardian documentaries newsletter ► www.theguardian.com/info/2016...
The Guardian ► www.theguardian.com
The Guardian CZcams network:
Guardian News ► is.gd/guardianwires
Guardian Football ► is.gd/guardianfootball
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/GDNsport
Guardian Culture ► is.gd/guardianculture
#Melilla #DividedCities #Spain #Morocco #AsylumSeekers #Immigration
I feel bad for the guy from Côte d'Ivoire but he is an economic migrant, NOT a refugee. Same thing for Moroccans, there's no war or genocide etc going on
I have to agree
This wall has been in place for years now, nothing new.
Its a set of fences. Huge fences but obviously it doesn't hold people back.
HAHAHA, more like a fence!
Morocco has their very own nice wall in Western Sahara with landmines and heavy machine guns...
Who said it was new? I actually learned alot..
As a spanish and proinmigration person I recognize one special problem in Spain: unemployment. Its really hard to justify massive inmigrants coming and working illegally (the mayority of the times its not their fault, I know) while there are more than 3 million people unemployed in Spain. This is one of the top arguments of Vox. In my opinion if we lower that number nobody will be Against inmigration.
Historically, Spain has been a nation where its citizens have had to leave Spain in order to find work. Only in the past 20 so years with there economy being built up has this not happened. But after the 2008 downturn many left. A number of Spaniards ended up in the Americas.
@@ab9840 they go to the americas because of the civil war, not because the economic problems
sopa domacaco many Spaniards left to Argentina, Mexico and Uruguay to find work after the 2008 downturn.
@@eliseomartinez7911 Don't be ridiculous. Their situation is even worse than Spain.
@@plusultra6199 It's true though.
So long as there is such drastic economic disparity across the globe (as well as environmental) there will be migration.
@White Brad Bad Your statement expresses perfectly the low levels of your IQ. What evidence do you have to back up your claim or wait let me guess, anecdotal evidence? If your statement was true in your little dichotomous world, then explain why the Chinese have immigrated to every country on earth yet have a higher average nodal IQ than whites, also keep in mind there are hundreds of millions of Chinese that have never left China let alone immigrate to another country. Why? Financial disparity just like every country on earth have different levels of financial disparity. The greater levels of financial disparity the greater levels of difference in socio-economic power. Your poor attempt at compartmentalising a complex issue shows the surface level of prejudice you carry and I must say it's appalling to the extend that people like you should be reprimanded and neutered so no more inbred children are born.
@White Brad Bad what about Europeans who throughout history, have immigrated to other continents such as north america, south america, Australia, and some parts of Asia and Africa?
@White Brad Bad Yea there must be a huge disparity between wherever you go and all over the world
It's their country's fault. Why other sovereign countries should comply to such pressure
@ragnar ulrichson Economic immigrants migrate to escape poverty. They migrate to get a better life. T9 get money for their family so they can get a proper eduction in some cases. Nothing wrong with that. I do believe that are too much coming but nothing wrong with a moderation
I live in a German village and we have about 200 black African migrants living in containers along our street in what used to be the children's playground. We all welcomed the migrants when they came at first in 2015 and as a language trainer I went there to offer my services for free. Nobody there was interested in learning German and most spoke English. Many had arrived through the Spanish enclaves with the aim of getting to Germany. Non came from a war zone and many believed that once they had crossed the fence into the Spanish enclaves that they were in mainland Europe. Their geography is appalling and their journey all the way from their home-country is controlled by people traffikers. All have left family behind, wives, children parents, and our camp in the village is 100% young men - just sitting around, doing nothing. 2022 is their 7th year here!
Merkel's big mistake. I think she meant well but didn't really think through the consequences and now both Germans and the immigrants are suffering.
I hope there will be a day that no one needs to leave their own country and culture
That is so unrealistic and will never come true.
When the Lord returns, there will be no more disparity. The kingdom will be eternal as Eastern Orthodox have explained since 33 AD
Africans were content in their native places and didnt care abt leaving their places until the Europeans left their own countries.
Yes this means people need to leave Africa and african resources alone and do for their own so African don't have to keep suffering to cross borders of those who have invaded Africa and living in Africa rent and tax free
Whatever your thoughts of economical migration, colonization does leave a lasting effect on the once colonized. Aboubacar is speaking in French, and the name Aboubakar is from Arabic.
Well said
As if European countries were never colonized or invaded
te suena La Reconquista?, 711-1492, fueron 780 anyos nada menos, con ese "argumento" los arabes y norteafricanos musulmanes nos "deben" mas que nodotros a ellos.
arabs colonized north africa
@@Luca-nu2zg not as recently or on the same scale.
If I was an impoverished African, would I try getting into Europe for a better life? Of course, all of us would. Should Europe let in all impoverished Africans looking for a better life? No, of course not that would be disastrous for Europe.
kashattack Europe wouldn’t have this problem if they did destabilize and plunder most of the planet to begin with.
Funnily enough some European leaders still back many African dictators right now
@@randomuser1105 what exactly did Europe plunder?
I wouldnt ruin a country like theyre doing
Great job TG. Thank'u👏👏👏
Americans really think they own walls at this stage
The Spanish nationalist is literally saying "Make Spain Great Again". You think he came up with that in a vacuum??
Guardian is a UK publication
@@RyVDL Stole it from trumps mouth 🤣😭
Spain was last great in 1492! 😂
Definitely, would donate to help Youssra become a teacher.
She must be able to do so in Morocco, as Spain has to solve the problems of its own people first
@@supernivemdealbabor who said that shes planning to do that in Spain ? ^)
@theonly man probably because she's cute.
@theonly man man this is a biiig problem we are homosapiens humans we can be black white yellow.... Our languages are different we all have one nationality which is planet earth so please let's all think as a human and help humans not just because they share ur land or ur nationality we all the same.
you real desperate boi
Got to get to the root causes of the problem . There must be a way to stabilise the country’s there desperately fleeing from . It does not solve problems by allowing people
To poor in over the border.
Why should it be their problem? Spain has its own problems./
@@profile1172 Problems which are normally caused by countries often end up with the country not fixing or paying for the problem.
@@profile1172 also fixing the Problem there might be cheaper in the long term than funding the Border defence or caring for the migrants.
You cannot even spell the plural of 'country' correctly?!
@@MrSvenovitch , nor use the correct version of "pour" instead of "poor".
As you saw in the film, the work is difficult, but everyone is happy because they have found a source of livelihood
You are a beautiful berber woman
just saying
Thank you so much for your words
Are you still a Porter, Youssra?
No, it close because of COVID but I get married with a wonderful man in Uk
@@youssratirari1319 are you gonna move to uk?
"We want Spain to be what it once was." Wellllll...what it "once was" is a colonizer, which is how you came to be sitting in a Spanish city in Africa and complaining about how Moroccan it is 🙄
the colonisation only occured after the africans were kicked out of spain.
Also Spain didn't colonize a lot of Africa, they just colonized the Americas, for colonization of Africa blame France and the UK
Ceuta and Melilla are part of Spain before Marocco existed, they were part of Visigoth Spain" in the VIII century...
@Giggitee O'Yeah you forget they have the largest ammounts of Posphate which is hell a lot useful for crop preservation.If Morocco decided to cut the supplement it means that the world would have a casualty of ~ 70% - 75% of Phosphate quantity
@Giggitee O'Yeah Yeaaah if you see what happens in th WHOLE world you will understand why i mentioned it. Some countries don't have the advantage to extract phosphorus from useless sewage waters and set up a mass scale operation although it would be better for not exhausting earth rescourses, still the majority isn't like USA, Japan, Sweden, Jordany, Kuwait etc.
People have a right to safe homes and secure borders. People may IMMIGRATE from one country to the next, but NOT to MIGRATE. It would be like one neighbor trespassing and forcibly moving into another neighbor's home because he simply didnt like the house he grew up in. Now THAT is insane.
Thats what israel is lol
It's not a matter of frivolous dislike but survival
@@AKumar528 the blindness of privilege makes cruelty effortless. "simple dislike" apparently means your country was bombed to rubble, privatized, deindustrialized...
Morocco has their very own nice wall in Western Sahara with landmines and heavy machine guns...
They're literally fighting a war over there, it was a strategic decision to bar off Western Sahara guerillas from the parts of Western Sahara they control. Also, they control most of Western Sahara so your point is really dumb. You're comparing migrants to an opposing army which is very disingenuous.
That's what Spain gets for maintaining Ceuta and Melilla on the African mainland.
What's wrong with that? A lot of countries has territories faw away from its mainland
@@alvaroortiz1126 Nothing wrong with that at all just don't cry when this happens.
@@MrMasterLoulou we don't cry for it, we take action when it necessary
@@jbagger331 yeah it did
@@jbagger331 you fuckin uncultured swin we are a 1200 yo kingdom you guys were wisi goth slaves before the rise of al andalouse, and how ur culture is soo influenced by ours, imagine being this dumb and believing that you guys have the right to be here you took advantage of our weak days to control some of our territory, wich we will take back eventually.
COME TO SPAIN LEGALLY! These ppl aren't asylum seekers seeking refuge from war and genocide, and if they want to live, contribute to, and work in the EU, they should learn Spanish and apply for a visa rightfully.
It will never be granted. My cousin lives in Cuba, speaks Spanish, has an engineering degree, has professional work experience, etc. Spain has denied his multiple applications to live and work there legally. If it's that hard for someone who is well educated, from an ex-Spanish colony, who speaks the language, and has a similar culture imagine how impossible it will be for someone from sub-Saharan Africa.
@@dand5829 The terrible, slow process is basically an incentive for people to do it in the illegal way, not just in Spain, but my country Italy as well, and pretty much all of Europe.
It’s a never ending cycle, the only way to fix the problem is by giving a helping hand to poorer countries and make it a better place rather than spending it all on a wall that people still manage to get over.
@Lord Shrenny why because of there colonial past that killed thousand of lives in africa. Or just give it to Morocco as they handle it better than Spain does.
Bersyukurlah di Indonesia damai, jarang konflik, banyak yang masih cinta sama negaranya, bisa beribadah dan bekerja dengan tenang.
Lihatlah negara lain banyak konflik, ekonomi hancur, beribadah dan bekerja bahkan keluar rumah aja ga tenang selalu was-was, akhirnya banyak yg jadi imigran.
Jadi tolonglah jangan ribut2 lagi..
Walaupun nyari kerja agak susah kata orang, tapi banyak peluang usaha di negara kita, bisa dagang cilok, cilor, telor gulung, somay, bakso, mi ayam, dropshiper, reseller, jastip, tukang COD, gojek, grab, supir angkot, kuli bangunan, knek, kuli panggul, petani, peternak, nelayan, sosis bakar, nasgor, mi aceh, bubur manado, coto makasar, nasi padang, pempek, papeda, kue lontar, kerak telor, rujak cingur, gorengan, ayam penyet, warkop, asongan, jus buah, susu nasional, es kepal, es kelapa, es tebu, es cendol dawet, cimol, rujak bbek, tahu gejrot, martabak, kripik, mendoan, pecel, karedok, ngajedog.. tambahin lagi kalo kurang..
Bener, sumpah gw bersyukur banget.
Hidup di Indonesia memang gak bisa dibilang enak banget, tapi hidup di Indonesia jauh lebih enak daripada banyak negara yang sedang berkonflik ataupun krisis.
Tapi, kalo dipikir2, jumlah pengangguran yang semakin meningkat (apalagi karena pandemi 2020-21) juga bikin kita jadi seperti Spanyol (Spanyol jumlah penganggurannya 6 juta, nyaris setengah jumlah penduduk), padahal jumlah penduduk kita jauh lebih banyak dari Spanyol. Ini yang bikin kita lumayan "related" sama Spanyol dalam hal anti-imigran (khususnya imigran Tiongkok :p)
Tkw dan TKI indonesia banyak diluar negri tandanya kita belum beranjak...
In 1982, King Juan Carlos had plans to give Melilla back to Morocco. It was unfortunately the cold reaction he received from the Moroccan side, being at the time deeply involved in the Western Sahara conflict, that caused this plan to fail. Now we have a right-wing Vox nationalist call Melilla, the most Spanish of all Spain's cities. The irony!
@@lelouchdibritannia4508 cry more
@@lelouchdibritannia4508 Keep dreaming
que pesados sois los marroquies con Ceuta y Melilla. Arreglad vuestro país y dejad de pensar en invadirnos
Strange every time I hear people speaking Spanish I think of spanish paella and get hungry...
I thought about paella as the politician said make spain great again
Pealle isnt Spanish it is Moorish.
@@morocco_020fc7 😂😂😂😂😂😂🙆
@@morocco_020fc7 how comes that? Lol im valenciana, and real paella is the valencian ome
@@cdl6892 It is created in Valencia true but it was created after the moorish brought rice spices ect. And the word paella come from Arabic "pachia" and it means the left overs as farmers made the dish from there leftovers.
The Moroccan is beautiful!
*looks in cup holder*
there could be someone in there.
The young girl should start giving tours and explain to people what is happening and what can be done to help.
No
This might have nothing to do with the story but Youssra is so gorgeous C: oh, my heart
Spain
> Owns city in Africa
> Gets annoyed there's Africans in it
Logic?
@@jbagger331 What point are you trying to make here?
J Bagger HOW is it nonsensical? It’s a city in AFRICA owned by Spain somehow, and then the man complains about how many Africans there are. Spain shouldn’t own Ceuta or Melilla in the first place
J Bagger Yeah most of what you said is nonsense. If they have any complaints they should go back to their continent.
@@jbagger331 "the fact city is in Africa is irrelevant to the fact that there's Africans in it"
Are you trying to be stupid here?
Jonas Helling isn’t owned by Spain “somehow”. It’s been Spanish territory for over 500 years. There have also been multiple treaties granting Spain sovereignty over it. Not to mention it’s quite stupid of you to think “Africans” from Sub Saharan countries should be able to go there just because it’s Africa. At least if you made te Moroccan claim it would of made more sense.
Why do they change the filter? I wanna see the how the camps really look
There's no camps
Youssra ♥️♥️♥️ Something drew me close to her
The title of the video has nothing to do with the video itself
it can be improved a lot. water cannon towers. Electrify the fence. Stun mines and a second line with machine gun towers
Hahahaha..
If you ever get to the gates of Heaven(doubtful) remember before you enter you will have to answer for this sentiment.
Y drones patrullando la valla las 24h del día, soltando gases paralizantes a cualquiera que ose colarse dentro
its happen in all developed country that why we must appreciate what we have because not all of us is struggle for just crossing a border for a better .....
The old alt-right guy said he doesn't want Melilla "Moroccanizing", even though it's in north-africa and Maghrebi people have been living in it since the prehistoric age. I can get that you're denying sub Saharan people because they're literally strangers to that region. But to deny people in there own historic and ancestral land?...
This guy is a fool. Denying reality, like a little kid. His method will never solve any problem.
The typcial imperialism
Asylum doesn't mean you get to go wherever you want because you are poor, it means you are under severe threat of death or oppression (gays in Saudi Arabia, opposition leaders in russia etc) due to present circumstances. These people are economic migrants, and have no right to go anywhere
Yes, the mothers, sisters, wives and daughters of these men have a right to asylum as they suffer female genital mutilation BECAUSE of these men. But they are not there. These men are no political dissidents who are fleeing concentration camps. The sad thing what will happen because of these men abusing the concept of asylum is that the asylum law will be changed to the detriment of the ones who really need it.
thaliasghost what why are you calling all immigrant men abusers for no reason???
@@djivrannl Reading comprehension is a skill. You should practice it. These men come from a very specific group of countries, countries in which female genital mutilation is a widespread cultural practice. In Somalia, 98% of women have suffered female genital mutilation. No little girl grabs a rusty kitchen knife cutting off her vulva and clitoris.That is done because of and for these men you see in this video. We also know that these men statistically do not flee war, they are not only economic migrants but they are the ones who are the best off. They are the strongest ones. While the weakest ones and the ones who actually can ask for asylum (see: female genital mutilation) are not there. So yes, these men actually are oppressors of women in their misogynist societies.
thaliasghost but Somalia is in east Africa these immigrants are west African
@@hwfq34fajw9foiffawdiufhuaiwfhw fair argument but could atleast be accurate
Africa hasn't been spoilt. There are HUGE amounts of resources in Africa and a LOT of potentials that are going down the toilet because of the ineptitude of the governments, corruption and dictatorships that are destroying the continent and people's lives.
Why don't we switch places to take it literally bring your beloved government and let switch places
@@houssam19941 brother these people will never care enough about us to understand the history and the struggle. they will always just say we are corrupt, primitive, lazy, and uncivilized so that they can sit comfortably and with a clean conscience in their colonialist bloodwealth.
Phony colonial borders and centuries of theft wil play havoc. Spain is built off of African resources and African blood. Itt owes Africa.
Look, yes, the struggle is real but the criticisms of African leadership since independence are also very valid.
I'm aware of the interference by Cold War powers in *some* African states, by Chinese and Russian interests now and the criticisms of the French monetary policy's effects.
However, not everything can be blamed on that. It has been FAR too common for corruption to run rampant, FAR too easy and too common for petty dictators to seize power and to incite one cultural group against another - or to play favorites.
I encourage you to look at the examples of nations who escaped colonialism and are now doing well or moderately well. Vietnam is rising. So is India, in fits and starts. Singapore was a colony and dirt poor.
Its 2020 and people are still living like this.
Paris fall without the war. I don't want it to happen to Spain
For some reason one of ladies look like oparh
0:40 Track ID?
Why they do not claim to King Marruecos instead to Spain?
The problems is not with stopping migrants get in, it's making these poorer, dysfunctional countries more habitable. But that is very idealistic.
Moroccan king is the richest man in Africa...
So?
the irony of Spanish colonial people don't want African immigrants to live in African lands!!!
Those lands have belonged to Spain for five centuries. They are as Spanish as any other part of our territory.
@@albertolaboria5866 no.
@@albertolaboria5866 Hola Alberto, disculpa. Cuánto tiempo tiene que estar una tierra conquistada antes de que pase a considerarse que ya no pertenece a sus habitantes originales? Al menos desde el punto de vista de un facha subhumano como tú, digo
@@sacta Tú mismo te retratas como un intolerante, no me extraña que hayas votado a Pablo Iglesias. Ajo y agua talibán.
@Adrian Bradey African and Spanish have never been mutually exclusive. That land has never belonged to Morocco.
Easy alternatives to MSGA: 1. Trademark talking with a lisp then sue the heck out of everyone with a real lisp. 2. Rebrand Bullfighting by selling it to Disney 3. “Discover” new territories to plunder.
South of spain has no lisp and thats half the population.South americans have southern spanish accent.Pathetic little haters like you need to inform yourselves first.Lisp lisp lisp stfu
65+ year old guy in Melilla - of all places - saying he's "always been right wing". You know *exactly* what that means. Wonder if he knows the full history of his beloved caudillo when it comes to Moroccans in Spain....
You have to admire the fortitude of the migrants, especially the sub-Saharan ones; one really has to laugh at the right-wing tropes about laziness and living on the dole: my guess is most of the people saying stuff like this could never find the personal wherewhithal to make it to Europe.
Great , why don't these migrants apply their skills and try their luck in their own land . Then no one will have any problem .
I laugh at left wingers who are still delusional about reality
SIR Lord Henry mortimer I don’t agree with the OP, I think most humans who are desperate enough will do anything to survive or make a better life for themselves regardless of where they’re from, however I think individuals within the right who say “why not stay home and build up your country” are delusional, particularly when such right wingers are usually neo or classical liberals who are supposed to acknowledge and embrace individualism and reject the idea that you have to hold your own ambitions back for the state; sounds awfully collectivist to me lol.
@@qv8281 we are desperate to protect our culture and our centuries old traditions and our way of life . If we deal the external borders of Europe , seal the Bulgarian Turkish border , patrol the black sea , there's no way they can get into Europe .
It's funny how the leftist espouse and champion gay rights , women's rights while letting in military grade men (18-35) into our countries who's views compatible with madievel ages. Freedom of religion.........they follow a religion where apostasy is punishable by death .
Europe is not a charity home centre where everyone and anyone can come in and do whatever one wishes to do.
I am a traditionalist and a social conservative , I follow the works of Micheal oekshoft , Kirk Russel , Newman , Edmund Burke ......not frauds like neoconservatives
I think you as citizens of Europe should protest you government to stop the interference of African countries,dismental any progress in African countries, and when most of Europen citizens don't understand this that their country (NATO) are the source of these mass immigration to Europe, they will never solve this problem
@@swahilkid3128 spain has barely touched africa. We just occuppy 30 square kilometers there and sweeden didnt touched africa or Irak neither. Morocco is losing thousands of young people it would be a disaster for morocco economy and for europe
We need the wall! Viva España!
Build that Wall!
Get out of Africa first Melila is in Africa. You can put it up in Spain but not in Africa.
@@lydcheke3959 all of Africa can't fit in Melilla and Ceuta.
Viva!
Viva la estupidez humana
Yes.yes it does.
Ceuta and Melilla have 150 thousand inhabitants but they have resources
Moroccans and many others from that region should start building up their own countries in stead of repeatedly trying to reach countries where we have things in order. Here is an idea.....start working.
Morrocco is doing fine... ita the sub saharans that flee from there homes through morrocco.
The morroccans qctually also defend this wall with massive incentice from the EU.
Dumb dumb
No it's not morocco. Moroccans are cool with the Spaniards. its the Sub saharan migrants from Mauritania and Nigeria that are causing the problems.
@@za.monolit they can stay in morocco
Ignorant comment
@@vchalls No they cant, and if they can then they also can stay in spain.
Every country have the right to protect themselves. You cann't solve all the problems, that the world has, especially in Africa.
Yes it does!!
Spain was colonised by North Africa for over 7 Centuries, people should be aware of the history.
Yeah 300k people colonised 6 million people 😂
@@tearet741 The Moorish Empire colonized "Al Andalusia" for over 7 centuries, look it up.
A minute to appreciate the sheer stupidity in the phrase "And now we see it deteriorating and 'moroccanising' at a dizzying speed"
Well
It's in freaking mainland Africa
A goddamn enclave in Morocco
What the hell did he expect?
It’s part of Spain
@@MCJ62 nah its a part of morocco enclaved by spain with moroccan amazigh names, moroccan history "Nekkor emirate" that existed way before the unification of the kingdoms that existed in iberia that formed the current day spain
@@zakariadarif spain should destroy morocco and liberate the western sahara
@@zakariadarif spain exist since the fall of roman empire but was destroyed by arabs
@@sopadomacaco8470 espagna was a roman district it has nothin to do with the modern spain lol
genial. gracias
that old dude said "this part has always been spain" wait que? lol. he might want to look what continent he's on haha
How do people afford Givenchy on €10 per day?
As a Mallilense, I think it should, if you all would live here with fear
Bine Narcis
The translated text is not accurate***!!
You should add more context with time stamps
@@jbagger331 What's the top three worst examples of the Guardian lying you can think of?
Was it me or were the translations of the Vox politician, Aboy, rather generous in his favor?
@@curziomalaparte3008 quite
Why don't teh EU make Meilia and Ceuta "outside the EU and overseas territories of Spain ", I promise very few immigrants then whoul bother going there?
Personally I think one shoudl seek asylum and work permit from home, no point in going to teh EU first at grat risk and cost to find out if you can come or not. Thsoe who do so obviously will not easily leave as tehy spent time, money and risk getting there.
How do you tell people who have settled in a place for more than 1500 years to leave their identity and become an African shelter? Why don't they solve the colonial problems with their colonies? because Spain can send buses to every town in Europe with extra drums
I'm not sure it is possible to take away EU citizenship rights from the residents of Ceuta and Mellila long after they were granted. Perhaps if it could pass a referendum.
They do need a wall.
I am guessing this comment section has less of my fellow Americans here...otherwise it could have been straight out vitriol and drivel. These comments are grounded on thought and overarching perspectives...something we childish Americans need desperately.
Agent Smidt 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Anyone entering illegally should be sent back imediately, no questions asked.
To think that Ghadaffi was providing the answer and being the example for all of Africa only to get executed by American and European dictators.
It's seems like the Europeans don't want there to be another answer. They must stay on top.
08:55 the hair equivalent of a breakdance battle. Love it
Spain should just give up those two little satellites to Morocco. Not worth the headache.
lmao
Da parte de tu pais a Estados Unidos o China.
Is imposible since the Melillans and Ceutians doesnt want to leave their homes or become moroccans coz we wants to be spanish
If ceuta and melilla become 90% arab and African then yeah let that garbage go
@@gabrielmolina2551 You can hop back in to Spain my friend, it's just 15km away.
"Does Melilla really need a Trump-style wall?" Yes. Yes it does.
You have now received the answer...
The African tectonic plate goes all the way to Switzerland. Technically they are all living in Africa.
The Guardian - please, provide me with a contact for Youssra. I'd like to send her some money and provide help for her and her family.
Thank you!
I’m American, but I’m with Vox and the Spanish nationalists!
8:32 yeah we knew your situation but also understand the situation to the country where you like to live it
Of course they don’t like to have a lot of jobless guys in their country also how about the food
What about the opportunity for native and local resident there
And also if all migrants goes to Europe then where we will live it would be super crowded
Its got a much more hectic wall already ahah
We need a bigger and electro-shocking wall.
Yes keep europe safe.
The atmosphere is similar to the US Mexico border , but the African version is not Mexican and latin america
*YES*
There's no need to ‘Make Spain great again’! In my eyes Spain is the greatest Country and I'm not even Spanish!
There’s a lot of unemployment in Spain
Its strange when they talk about their huge families and lack of jobs for everyone. Why don't they start using condoms at last and learn about family and family budget planning? While most Europeans would like to have more than one or two children in the family, but still they can't afford it.
This could be the other way around if Putin launches those nukes.
Yes, yes they do.
Not surprised really to read comments here from people who are in favour of those migrants and what they do, peope who voted for brexit to stablish a frontier and stop this inmigration into the uk. Control of migration is bad only when it is about another country trying to control it, when its the uk that's another matter.
Migration has nothing to do with the EU. The UK had full control of immigration whilst in the EU (for non-EU and EU citizens). Its a talking point bc of its convenience, not bc its true.
Why dont they just leave the city , its in Afirca anyways
most people there are spanish and this city was spanish before the creation of Morroco. At least this is the excuse. Think whatever you want
@@miquelcanosasanteularia1678 Just relocate and save themselves from migrants
@@zuboy4272 the problem is not that big omg, actually Melilla is one of the richest cities of spain
@@miquelcanosasanteularia1678 The city is Moroccan and Morocco existed way before the Alaouite Dynasty, maybe it was weak when the spaniards took it but this doesn't deny the fact that most its inhabitants are from Moroccan ethnicities.
@ismail adam they literally conquered Spain over 800 years. And that was the reason because spaniards start conquering everything they can, they take revenge of africans invading Europe. None tolds this part of history... the first colonizers and slave owners were north africans and middle easterns
this fence need 380 volt and Guns
Of course Melilla needs a wall. Not because it will divide the city but to protect the city.
They only show the perspective of the other side
They showed all perspectives.
1) The Spanish right wing governor
2) The Ivorian/ Sub Saharan assylum seeker
3) The Moroccan Porter woman .
I think they did a great job at showing the different perspectives from all groups.
Ceuta and Melilla is a colonialism case that must be resolved unlike the American wall
🤦🏻♂️ unlike the American wall? 🤦🏻♂️
Do you remember what California, Arizona, new Mexico and Texas where from?
Get some history lessons please
@@ichide7 lol, all of America are colonised until today, there is no country that is truly to represent certain indigenous nations. So, taking land in America cannot be counted like you occupy land in Europe, Africa or Asia
Nice
remember Catherine.
who?
Tate? Deneuve? Zeta - Jones? Wheel? Of Aragon? Which one, dammit?!
remember Abdelkrim El Khattabi, remember Annual, remember Monte Arruit, remember Chaouen.. ;)
VIVA ESPAÑA!!!!
Build as tall a wall as you want. People will find ways to get through it. This is not an effective solution. Actuakly, it's downright wasteful.
Wow ... ever realized there was a wall straight through Europe and it was extremely effective
Yes you're right. Spain should just knock it off and stop patrolling and controlling its borders along with carte blanche access to 26 (already) open border countries. Great idea.
I think Melilla in Africa what are the Spanish doing there.
Moroccans are not the Native Americans. So Spain be careful!.
What is Britain doing with their overseas islands , the same we are doing.
Too be honest. I think middle east country can be more saved than africa country. The problem in middle east are too much foreign intervention. What i look in africa. it looks like they always civil war even without foreign intervention.
Melilla is apart of mainland Africa so what gives the right for Spain to determine who can come in and out of the city. Isn't this proof enough that colonialism still exists today?
Melilla and ceuta are not considered colonies because they belonged to Spain before Morrocco ever existed. The majority leaving there consider themselves spanish and european. Believe what you want
It's not colonialism because the cities are not a colony, they are autonomous regions of spain, and they feel part of it
@@miquelcanosasanteularia1678 Morocco existed for a long time though? So you mean before they had an official name?
@Gery A People have been living there for ages
Not colonies, they are cities in North Africa that are part of Spain.
He clearly isnt poor if he has a smart phone with wifi and sharing videos with other people.
Clara el no es pobre si tiene une "smart-phone" con wifi.
Clairement il n'est pas pauvre si il a une smart phone avec wifi et il a envoyé ded vidéos à ses amis.
More people have access to cellphones than toilets.
You don't have to be poor to be a refugee.
Eh poor is different in 2020
Hard working people and a rich guy eating and complaning about the hard working people. I have everything clear now.
Look at her... 1:25 even she cringes away and looks extremely uncomfortable, as her Moroccan brethren run past and try to brush up against her... But that's racist to point out, isn't it?
Mf lives in a Spanish colony that used to be Marroccan land and wants it to be as Spanish as Madrid... smh
Ceuta and Melilla were never Moroccan land
Pablo You’re right on a legal standpoint. I meant it on an ethnic way.
@@luisfer9361 By that logic only Madrid is Spanish, Spain has always been a multicultural country where many different peoplehave intermarried, you can't talk about a Spanish ethnicity. There has been Celts, Goths, Moors, etc, and even today there's plenty of identities within our country
Pablo I agree with you, that makes no sense. That’s what I meant on my comment. Dude uses the logic you are referring (hispanicidad (whatever that means)) to justify the Moroccans not belonging. Using that same logic, I made counter.
@@pablo8286 esos eran otros tiempos
I've lost all faith in humanity at this point
honestly i think some people are just too stupid to understand how evil they are, and that is the biggest problem.
ceec e
Who the migrants?
bob
Spain has more foreigners than Spaniards. That is sad. It’s not their own anymore. Soon people will think Spaniards are Latinos or middle eastern or Asian rather than their own distinct people
The girl at 13:47 is so stunning.
close enough