Fleeing war in Gaza - for a new life in Egypt? | DW Documentary
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- Tens of thousands of people have fled to Egypt to escape the war in Gaza. There they seek to start a new life and put the traumas of war behind them. They hope for peace but also fear for those who are still in Gaza.
14-year-old Moataz Al-Sabaawy is one of at least 100,000 Gazans who have found refuge in Egypt since the start of the war. He has been living in Cairo with his parents and sister since May 2024. His two older brothers were both killed in Gaza in an Israeli attack on the family home. The death of his brothers and his experience of the war have traumatized him. Like all the refugees, Moataz keeps in regular contact with family and friends in Gaza. Every time he calls home, he dreads hearing about the death of another loved one.
Bassem Medhat Abu Al-Aoun owned two restaurants in Gaza, one of which was near the Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City in the north of the Strip. Both restaurants have been destroyed in the war. He managed to escape to Egypt with over 50 members of his family. Escape is not an option for most Gazans. No one can leave the territory without the permission of the Israeli and the Egyptian authorities. Often, the border is sealed off completely. Those wanting to leave need a humanitarian visa, which is issued by international embassies. But Egyptian journalists say there is an alternative route out: It involves paying Egyptian brokers to "coordinate” the departure. The fee is several thousand US dollars per person. Abu Al-Aoun has now opened a new restaurant in Cairo. But he worries about what the future holds.
Meanwhile Israa Ali from Egypt has founded an initiative together with her husband and friends that aims to help the refugees. It’s called "Olives Grandsons”. The organization has over 100 volunteers looking after traumatized children from Gaza. Art therapy, sport and singing help alleviate the children’s fears and trauma. The charity also offers lessons based on the Palestinian curriculum, as most families hope one day to be able to return to Gaza.
#documentary #dwdocumentary
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/t...
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
Hamas doesn't care about it's own people
Tell the occupiers that
@@sana4u02 Tell what ?? Occupation is other way round. Egypt is where they belong.
It's about Hamas It's about the Zionist.
Sinwar said that if even 200.000 died it was worth it, thats how Humus thinks , they dont for the people at all.
And Israel care especially when they are targeting schools hospitals refugee camps UN safe zones just look at the map of israeli booming in gaza they targeting every single inch they are using heavy bombs that's not allowed in a zone with high population density
So only people with money are allowed to flee Gaza? Why can't Egypt offer more people temporary refuge until this terrible war is over and people can return?
Many problems like terrorist getting into Eqypt which already has problems with terrorist groups, also it is expensive to provide for housing education, etc and the biggest reason is if Eqypt lets so many gazans out it might encourage israel to settle in gaza just like in the west bank
Only the poor suffer the most when there is war. Sadly!
By the way more than 50% of the gazaouites are egyptians!!!!!
@@amoahablesadly.thats the majority...or those without relatives abroad..sad reality
Israel will never let them come back. It is the real Israeli aim of this war
And yet Egypt and the surrounding North African countries should be the most natural place for those wanting to flee Gaza to relocate to.
The only natural place for palestinians is to stay in Palestine.
Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar, and Iran can really accommodate them.
@@bornonjuly7052no the pissrael Ike’s can go back to Europe and wherever else they invaded from
@@bornonjuly7052 Excatly! They keep saying our BROTHERS and SISTERS are suffering from the war yet where are those super rich BROTHERS and SISTERS ?
So Israel can occupy Gaza as well and send in some settlers?
Consider making a documentary about the farm murders in South Africa, they don't even make the news anymore.
if your talking about what I thinking your talking about I've been aware of it for 10 plus years .
It has been extensively covered for many years. We get it you don't care about Palestinians or brown people on general
They won't they only care if it is non whites being killed
@@danny_chestnut253yoo palestinians can shove it tbh
Well said brother. Infact, they've downplayed them. Just like all MSM media. They are traitors.
HAMAS IS THE CULPRIT
Zi.onists, you mispelled.
can someone tell me why so many arab countries refuse to let them come over? why are they not helping? I do have an answer let me hear yours
They collectively cause trouble wherever they go. When Jordan took in Palestinian militants, they caused a civil war in Jordan (Black September), when Lebanon took them in they caused a civil war by m*rdering Christians and attacking Israel as well. Even when Denmark took Palestinian refugees in 92' now have a criminal record.
Because they know that if they do that Palestinians would start saying that their country belongs to them and would start giving wrongly facts, that’s already happened in Lebanon and Jordan where some Palestinian groups excluded themselves from the rest because they wanted more power
@@imatyourwindow4066 perfect answer
Arab countries aren’t democracies
Why should they have to leave their homeland?
Thanks once again to DW❤
Thank you for watching!
@@DWDocumentary thank you so much for this “unbiased reporting” that failed to mention Hamas not even once !! ❤
Thank you to the German reporters : Mohamed Khalil, Menam Sami, Abdullah Mostafa, Mostafa Hanafy!! ❤
@@DWDocumentary thanks for not cutting the part of a kid drawing a Hitler at 20:12 LMFAO
Gazians are Palestinian citizens, not Egyptian citizens. Egypt does not have an obligation to take displaced people in unconditionally just because they are poor or suffering. Egypt like any other countries looks after its citizens. Egypt is not a charity.
No. Gaza belonged to Egypt after Egypt invaded Israel in 1948.
Gazans even had Egyptian nationality between 1948-1967 and were stripped of their egyptian nationality afterwards
Yes it was Egyptian land , so they should help their arab family members
They do have an obligation to take refugees
Absolutely amazing to see the children, heartbreaking but amazing. I ham happy that at least a small fraction get to be children. I hope more will
Thamk you DW
They get too many children. A family has six or more children. That is one of the reasons why they are poor and hungry and often begg for money and aids.
It is a common problem in the poor countries.
A family should not have more than two children when the parents can not feed them.
15 miles of white sand beaches and all the aid a person could want so no one has to work and yet all they wanted to do was start a war with their neighbor.
DW, Kindly include official English subtitles.
They started a war they couldn't handle. And war is like that. The same thing is happening in Sudan and Congo but all these media channels are looking the other way.
I agree with you.
@@CurrentAffairs-k8eI disagree with you when you say they started the war
@@enmn6001 may be you are right
If you continue to return these kids who alledgedly all suffer from PTSD to the cause of their so called problems, they will only get worse and not better.
Thank you for a great documentary and reporting.
As for the hasbara propaganda and talking points in the comment section, I hope your comments never get deleted, as you look at them in shame in the near future. These comments will not age well. Rest assured, history will judge you.
Thank you DW for reporting the truth of the suffering in the GAZA STRIP 😢
don't be pathetic 🤣
@michalveltrusky9633 sorry my values are different than yours
A day will come when everyone will say that they opposed the genocide all along. But some of us will remember the spineless enablers who, rather than holding power to account, kissed its feet. And that includes Deutsche Welle.
There is no genocide
It's war. Even a dog knows not to bite the hand that feeds. They slaughtered civilians and now beg for mercy?
I think many people that have much of feelings over for Arabs anymore considering how many act in Europe and considering they 1nv4de us.
People always die in war even civilians not everything is a genocide, in the other hand there’s a lot of genocides being committed in different African countries but that doesn’t matter because unfortunately they don’t have arab propaganda
It is strange that Germany committed a wrong against Jews and the Palestinians have to suffer for it. That's not affirmative action. That's double injustice. It's like someone steals a neighbor's car and then, to repay their neighbor, they steal someone else's car. How is that justified?
Cherry picking facts to create a false narrative, you probably never cared about Gaza for the 16 years before October 7th. Stay classy, no one deserves to ingest your confusion.
@@kokabr what kind of twisted message is that?
Jews are the original inhabitants of the land of Israel / Palestine.
Arabs and Muslims came into this land much much later and invaded (stole) that territory and other territories in the whole middle east
Germans have nothing to do with that story.
Don’t twist facts and history to fit your antisemitic narrative
How is jews returning to their historic land wrong. The Palistinians are Roman colonisers.
You can see that their life before October 7 was good. It all changed after the Oct 7 attack. You cannot justify that bla bla bla reasons. You can see based on their stories especially the restaurant owner, they are almost living in luxury before Oct 7.
The country i live in gives the palestine area about 120 million euro in annual aid. I wonder where that money went all those years.
Even Palestinian refugees don't take care of each other. That rich Gazan who just opened that restaurant and didn't even hire a single other Palestinian...
I don't think it is allowed for people from Gaza to work unless you are an investor. Thats why the Gazans in that restaurant only work in cleaning. They aren't allowed any other jobs.
that's because his Egyptian restaurant is already filled up with Egyptian employees.
@@Muntan_17 What does that tell you about his mentality?
@@i.k.8868 it is telling me that he respects the local's right to be employed over the foreigners. These people have suffered so much so leave them alone... stop dehumanizing them just becuz you want the world to ignore the injustice they are continually facing just because of their national identity
@@Muntan_17 What on earth are you talking about. Palestinians and Egyptians are neighbors, not foreigners.
DW quietly took down its film "Two kids a day" which documents the outrage that more than 700 Palestinian children and young people were arrested every year by the Israeli army (before October 2023). It provides evidence of emotional and physical abuse of Palestinian kids by Israel. To repeat: CHILDREN. The film was uploaded on 18th Sept 2023 and quietly removed after the 7th October.
Spoiler Alert: DW Documentary doesn't produce and own all the content they air. Sometimes they obtain the rights to independently produced films for a specific amount of time.
When the rights expire, the film is taken down. That's how it works on this channel. DW Documentary uploads and removes content on a regular basis.
But, sure - let's call licensing arrangements part of a conspiracy.
Have a safe and interesting week 🍁
@@TheStockwell Thanks so much for engaging.
I note you feel the need to deploy that easiest of trigger words "conspiracy" in your response. No need for you to invoke any conspiratorial behaviour whatsoever when there is a far simpler explanation. And it does rather go without saying that licensing rights exist and expire.
It seems you view this as an isolated case - perhaps a single bad apple in an otherwise healthy Deutsche Welle orchard?
I can only assume you are new to this channel. DW has in fact a long track record of erasing or negating the Palestinian viewpoint. Including by firing its Arab staff back in 2022 (look it up). If you remain in doubt I recommend you seek out DW's interviews with Ali Abunimah, Yara Hawari and Noura Erekat to name but three Palestinian commentators. I cannot guarantee you will still find them on DW's channel but they are available elsewhere. Do licensing rights also expire on DW's own proprietary content?
But above all, I recommend that you read DW's own code of conduct to which its employees must adhere since September 2022. You'll find it demands lenient treatment be given to the country of Israel. That clause alone ensures that any self-respecting journalist will ply their trade elsewhere. Obedient yes-men, on the other hand, will jump aboard. Hence no need for a "conspiracy" - it's a process that selects for spineless careerists.
Curious and critical adults will see that the "healthy orchard" is in fact rotting from the roots. I cannot say what it looks like when viewed through the eyes of the wholesome ingénue on the prairies, however. Greetings from Berlin.
The Palestinians mean children, kids even when these are fifteen, sixteen years old, also under eighteen years old.
The Palestinians educate the young people to stabb the Jews. That is the reason why they must go to jail.
Even in Germany, some Muslim minors must go to jail because they plan acts of terrorism in Germany.
once a nazi allways a nazi
@@robertmusil5831 Were you homeschooled? Nobody functional talks like this... And to your point, yes, you did imply that DW was basically controlled by western Israeli propaganda, so the first person responding to your comment was right to call your allegation a conspiracy. What you implied is that DW is secretly conspiring with Israel, while you have no proof at all. Take the meds next time
hopefully the kids can flourish without the brainwashing and hate from hamas
Hamas has nothing to do with people wanna leave free frm israel gang
20:12 the Palestinians are Hamas
Israa Ali and the volunteers will go straight to heaven inshallah. I can't describe how moved I am seeing what you are doing for the children of Gaza ❤❤❤.
I find this fascinating how knowing some information changes such stories. A restaurant in Al Rimal? The most wealthy neighbourhood in Gasa, mostly populated by Hamas top members. A simple un-envolved person can't have a restaurant there. Neither can it pay for evacuation high bribes that Egypt demands. Most of those who speaks to media at least have Hamas or IJ among their close relatives or are members themselves. But no one in the media will even try to show this, although it is easy to check this in their social networks. If you remember that story about boy with daun sindrome - two of his brothers are openly in Hamas/IJ.
How exactly to you know that? Back up your claims. I'm waiting. Jfyi, the restaurant owner is an American citizen.
@@user-ru1zv9ed6r what should I justify? Google it
Is very sad the story children's gaza But God is helping them is the most important🥰🙏Greetings from 🇩🇴
Yeah its sad because their own government is using them as human shields
How do someone know the contribution will reach the gaza children???
Money buys freedom and safety ! Thats sad to see those who have no money get stuck
Im confused. I thought Gaza was a prison, why do they miss and want to live in a prison? Why do they call a prison their home? The media needs to get their narrative in order
Are you a troll? Their life was in Gaza. Their families are still there. Besides, those who managed to escape were the one who had money. So they had comparatively a good life in Gaza. Gaza is considered a prison because it is heavily controlled by Israel : air, sea, water, sky, produces in and out, borders,... the development of Gaza is stiffled by Israeli controls and every two to three years, Israel used to "mow the lawn".
@@kona744 What you describe is still not a prison
@@ArtSmosh1274 I don't think you will ever understand until you know someone or you yourself have experienced it
The Palestinians get aids and money from the Western governments, when they live in Gaza.
If not, they will go to Germany and Europe to get welfare like many others from this region.
The most immigrants who go to Germany are from Syrie, Turkey, Afghanistan, Irag, Marocco, Algerie, ...
Only the Western and some Asian countries like Japan, South Corea, Taiwan can build democratic and rich countries.
Israel is rich because it is a democratic country.
Democracy and freedom of press are important. The governments get less chance to be corrupt and they must care more for their countries and their people.
People in Israel get more help from the government of Israel(shelter, Iron Dom, welfare...) than the Palestinians from Hamas.
@@ArtSmosh1274you are right, it is not prison, it is a concentration camp
Will they be supporting the muslim brotherhood in Egypt?
If so they will be jailed and no one in the media will care about this. It's not Israel to label every jailed person poor child that did nothing.
Obviously you haven't studied the politics of Gaza and how Hamas got into power.
It's OK, DW, I saw you removed my post, so I reposted it to hundreds of my Facebook friends and expanding its reach and content. Thanks! Here it is in it's entirety:
In general, I think very highly of DW Documentary and their global reporting perspective, which is more balanced than US media outlets.
However, this one got me because the feature is about a few wealthy upper middle class families that escaped Gaza in the days shortly after October 7, 2023. One of the people featured is a family man who has built a successful Turkish-styled restaurant, right outside of Shifa Hospital and he lost everything when Israel retaliated with missiles and bombs, restarting a new life and business in Cairo, but now dealing with a traumatized family . Good for him, but I wonder why he waited until hostilities literally took out his lifeblood and home before he acted on his better instincts.
Did he not notice that for 16 years that Hamas was building tunnels and rocket launchers scattered throughout his neighborhood? Did he notice that Hamas had no civil defense plan to safeguard his family? Did he think: "Business is good, I'll build another restaurant right next to a Hamas military base"? What could go wrong? Did it concern him that Hamas offered him and his children no future, other than to build Hamas tunnels and his doner kebab empire to feed the local neighborhood radical islamists? Even if he hated Hamas everyday for 17 years, why didn't it occur to him to seek his refugee status in a safer city?
You need to know what Al Rimal is. It was a wealthy neighbourhood, populated by Hamas top members. There is zero chance he had a restaurant there and had something against hamas. He should had been very close to them to have a restaurant there.
So cruel..cruel of Hamas
We need a gofundme account to get the kids stuck in the other side of the war zone out. All the kids deserve to be within the realms of safety, not just some🙏💔
Not my problem. When have arabs ever helped or cared for us in any capacity? Infact it's the opposite. My experience with them is horrible.
@JenJams1 Goodness do you work for Hamas that’s exactly what they want is more suckers pumping money into their embezzlement money laundering schemes
Where will they go ?
Why? When have they ever lifted a finger for us ever?
appreciate this video and I know the founder of the initiative ahfad alzeitun which is great to highlight- but you highlighted palestinians with extreme privilege. there are thousands of families who live below the poverty line, without mattresses, stoves, couches, and other furniture. nobody has a car here in cairo. I think you could have focused on really highlighting the realities here of how little arab nations like egypt doing to support displaced palestinians. most gazans who did not come with money are hoping for support from mutual aid.
most gazans like the palestinian restaurant owner do not live in wealthy neighborhoods with furnished apartments like this. it can be misleading.
They should care about birth control. If not, they will be poor whereever they go.
A family in this region has six or more children. The mother can not work and the family has not enough income.
A family should not have more than two children when the parents don't have money.
Why should they go from.their land?!Coz a thief stole it!
These people always get children like crazy, I agree. Goes for all of none-Europeans. No respect.
Elevating a family from poverty is a better alternative.
The Arab colony of Egypt should accept refugees from the Arab colony of Gaza/Palestine.
A modern empire like the Arab World should have the resources for this.
So countries speaking the same language is an empire. So is Canada and USA part of the same empire. Cool
And Americans are indigenous people right??
@@hemafalcon629 natives are yeah.
Coming back to their ancestral land, beautiful.
A lot of Palestinians in gaza are descendants of people who were displaced in 1948 from Israel
Their ancestral land is Palestine. 70% of Palestinians of Gaza are in fact refugees expelled from their land Inside the frontiers of 67
Palestians belong to palestine. If you look on the other side Israelis have banned DNA testing and you need a court order to obtain this I wonder why that is. 😅
good point
BTW: Arafagg was Egyptians
@@michalveltrusky9633when will the Euripides gags go back to Europe
There is a reason why Egypt does not want anything to do with Palestinians.
What is it? If u don't mind
@@narutouzumaki6533 it’s past experiences with the Palestinian people, wherever you have too many Palestinian refugees the host country suffers! Ask the Kuwaitis, Lebanese or Syrians!
A video shedding light on someone's or people's ordeal and yet you can't even be sympathetic to reason
@@narutouzumaki6533 When you're a corrupt government being paid by the US to be an accomplice to what is happening to the Palestinians in Gaza...
@@Kneetbomb These entities are not in this for humanity, they bring ideologised interests in these comment sections and lie about things.
Live in Egypt, find work, start a family, and learn to live with people of other faiths.
These people include christian palestinians too palestinians arent just muslims
Looks like they'll be fine then.
@@JeffBilkins they wont be because theyre still stateless which will hinder their ability to lead a normal life there
Palestine before 1920 was composed of the 3 religions including Islam, Christianity and Judaism. Go read history
JESUS was a Plastinian. So It begs the question who really "crusified him"?
Will you please stop making programmes about bloody Gaza!!! What next, how the pets in Gaza are being treated for mental trauma??? Is there nothing else going on anywhere else in the whole world???
You seem upset. Get off CZcams
@dwreporting
Thank you so much for this “unbiased reporting” that failed to mention Hamas not even once !! ❤
Thank you to the German reporters : Mohamed Khalil, Menam Sami, Abdullah Mostafa, Mostafa Hanafy!! ❤
To be fair this is not a news report. This is very clearly a documentary highlighting what the refugees from Gaza are going through. Your criticism would be justified if they had presented this as a piece of journalism covering the war between Israel and Palestine as a whole.
@@jonfox4022 DW is not reporting facts and not even doing basic journalism 101.
Why? They failed to mention Hamas even once… that’s quite impressive!
After all, these people are here mainly because their leaders (Hamas) declared war. It is important to put the context.
@@Xavi297 Again you seem to misunderstand the difference between a documentary and a news report.
@@jonfox4022 thanks. I know the difference. A documentary doesn’t mean you need to hide facts and context is my point.
@@jonfox4022 if you hide facts, context, historical backgrounds, then it is not a documentary, it is not a news report… it becomes a propaganda piece.
whats the meaning of this film ,,,,,feeling sorry for this family ,,,,,they got their money ,,,left everyone behind ,,,,they are doing great ,,,,,so im not feeling bad for any of them ,,,i work ,,,more hours than them,...they wanna go to canada ,,,lots of benefits there,,,good thinking,,,thode muslims know what they are doing ,,,,,,nice sad music too
All the people who screamed propaganda on the Israel documentary will be quiet now. Why are you so biased?
just blame hamus
they brought this suffering to these people
@@BugiezTvopen your two big eyes war is not starting October 7 . Israel terrorists occupied palestinians lands in blocked Gaza read the history about Palestine 75 years Israel massacres Palestinians
@@thonusIf you stand Israel terrorists give them your land
Because colonisers have no right to play the victim. Because they simply are NOT!
@BugiezTv its a war.
This is what happens in a war.
A country can only restrain up to a certain point, hamas pulled the trigger and started something which it couldn't stop.
So it was no open prison 😂 it was a luxury life before, that's why they attack Israel
Hmmm you see the lies don’t match up
Hamas is to be blamed for this.shame on hamas
@jibril2950 why do the Palestinians support them
The incoming generation will judge this Conflict. In Teams history 😂
I would suggest to the young Palestinians to seek out the teachings of the Buddha and Miyamoto Musashi. Their teachings make no promises.... and they don't give you anything that you as a human being don't already posses. It's just a suggestion.
Because they want to go to Allah @@batman-cu1ep
@@batman-cu1ep Some in fear of their lives, some hold the "all or nothing approach" (all land, including modern day Israel).
20:12 think you forgot to edit out some footage
LMFAO you can not make this up
@michalveltrusky9633 yes you can't make up that children are drawing scenes they saw while living in Gaza that include their family members getting killed by Israel... that's what art therapy is.
Please make a documentary about mexican cartels and funkytown gore
Gazans are by and large Egyptians. THis emigration seems like the normal course after losing the war they started
Genetically north African component is low amongst the Palestinians. Palestinians genome on average is 60-80% levantine. U should see the DNA of yews from Europe and America 😂
how can one donate to this important initiative?
Blame Hamas
I have so much love for the Palestinians. Unfortunately I'm in the country that is financially supporting the other team. My heart and doors are always open for the people of Gaza. I would be more than willing to bring a family into my home
You are more than welcome to have Sinwar at your place. He is super cool.
@@Xavi297he's better than Satanyahu!
@@BMboss108 an islamist vs someone who fights an islamist? Okayyyy 😅
@@BMboss108 You only say this because you hate the Jews. Nobody bats an eye when muslims kill muslims. No sympathy for Syra, Lebanon, Afghanistan, Iran, etc,... Muslims don't even help each other and have long term goals of relocating to the western world. Even in this documentary the family taking refuge in Egypt clearly says they're hoping to emigrate to Canada.
@@Xavi297 😂😂😂😂😂😂
There have been many groups of people and tribes who lived on this planet and are now gone. Is it possible its just Palestine's turn? They have a failing society an ideology that's not serving them in the 21st century and no means of survival other than what they are given. Perhaps it is their turn to fade in the history. This is not a desire or wish. It just is.
Ummmmm NO! this conflict can be stopped being ok with Genocide and indiscriminate bombing in not ok! What the hell is wrong with you?!
Don't deceive yourself, it's only their turn if the US decides so by keeping the war indirectly.
@@Terraider There is no genocide
@@Terraider There's a difference between war and genocide. Why is it that you care so much about this war between Israel and Palestine? Do you give this much attention to what's going on in Syra, Lebanon, Afghanistan, Iran, etc,.. I suspect that you, like most Palestinian supporters, are more anti jew than you are pro muslim and you let your hatred guide you.
Viele Araber in Gaza sind Ägypter.Das bedeutet, dass sie jetzt in Ägypten zu Hause sind.
I’m sorry fr both Sides but good people get caught in this 😢😢
The comments from the heartless scumbags here are perfect. Keep it up, let the world see you for what you are.
One of the main issues Egypt has with the Palestinians especially the ones in Gaza is the biggest threat to Egypt is the Muslim brotherhood which Egypt is trying to quash. Another big issue in Egypt is a ongoing insurgency in the Sinai. Gazans supported Hamas which is an offshoot for the Muslim brotherhood so importing 1-2 million Palestinians could bring in thousands of Hamas fighters who could oppose Egypt or try to take over the Sinai to wage their war against Israel. On top of that it would cost a lot of money to house and support these Palestinians and so there are way to many risks involved to just bring in 2 million Palestinians.
FFS just forbid all religion - problem solved!
Half the population of Gaza were born after hamas was elected and also how would women and children provide political ammo to the ikhwan (Muslim brotherhood)
@@adamanter5566 No idea but the Taliban were born out of Afghan youth in Pakistan who then went back into Afghanistan to wage war against the warlords. A lot of these kids are teenagers or young adults as well. These are ripe people to be mass recruited into the muslim brotherhood, ISIS or another hamas offshoot.
They wanted war so be it.
Only the wealthy can get out 😥
WTF 20:12 even the Palestinians kids are monsters !
wow you're weird. Nothing that was said there even remotely implied the demonhood of palestinian children. Projecting?
Since Gazans were given a chance to self govern in 2005 but chose war and the destruction of their neighbors.
I am sad for them but I cannot have pity for them as they “played” and lost.
They can play the victims (again) for uneducated westerners who know little and for journalists (so eager to dramatize a situation that they indirectly encourage themselves)
Truth is that Gazans voted Hamas that declared to “destroy Israel” in 2005.
Since history dates well before 2005 (1917,48,56,67 for instance), this “uneducated westerner” isn’t buying your bilge.
Try spelling genocide and get back to me.
Well said!! Gaza & "Palestinians" keep starting wars & terrorism. Let them pay the consequences.
Blablabla
In fact, you are a brainwashed to not know that Palestinians in Gaza were never been free. According to international law, Gaza is still under occupation after 2005 because putting 2 millions in a big prison, it not freedom or independancy. It is just another way of occupation
And you are just saying that Israelis the 7th October were responsible because who is supporting occupation, colonization, apartheid, blocus, ethnic cleaning and massacres of Palestinians since many years? Who voted for this Nazi government in Israel? You are just saying also that 2 million persons in Gaza are responsible for a vote committed in 2005. Do you know the number of young Palestinians in Gaza who were born after 2005?
These poor people. One of the worst things I have ever seen is Russia and Ukraine, Israel and the Gaza. The US Republicans and Democrats being destroyed by their own people 😢
17:30 "We had to drink salt water" dude? :D he doesn't know, probably never drank it lol
Are they in Egypt? I have never seen such a good looking area in Egypt during my whole trip.
Theres more beautiful cities that what you saw in this documentary...Because Egypt is 100 million population and most of the tourists area are in poor ancient Districts... middle class and upper class Egyptians live in modern cities far from ancient cairo or the nile ,,, even the government will move far from cairo to new capital which is east of the new cairo.
Supported humas and then consequences came and cry
Where exactly in the video was there an indication that they supported Hamas?
@@catalina5382vast majority of Palestinians does
Your turn is coming just wait for it.
@@appletree6741Do* and so it doesn’t matter you can’t harm people who support a certain ideology which you disagree with that’s the reasoning some people use to support oct 7th
Who killed Jesus?
Very nice documentary 👌 👍 👏 😀
Thanks for watching!
Big surprise, here: after all the snotty comments about how DW Documentary is afraid to air a documentary about Gaza, what happens when they do?
Amswer: a lot of Whataboutism asking why DW Documentary doesn't air documentaries about other troubled areas, instead.
Because: "Thank you" and "We appreciate your work" are alien concepts in these comments.
People come here not to hear other viewpoints, but to criticize, complain, and rage ABOUT other viewpoints. 🙄
True, the Oct 7th documentary is like the most innocent micro-level insight into the suffering of the civillian victims of the attack, and yet the comments on that video are overflowing with hate and rage about "the other side".. Lmao.
When hypocrite cries , no one care .
Thanks for this documention, it's master piece because I live in Israel in prosperity.
If only Oct 7 never happened
Can I help you?
Unfortunately poor people cannot escape this horror ...5.000 to 10.000 per person to flee Gaza not everyone can pay this amount of money.As usual poor people will pay the heavy price.
All of them forgot to tell thanks to Ha*mas 🤣…
Free Palestine 🙏🏻🙏🏽
I thought they supported hamas?? Oh well
Those who're affiliated or supports hmas probably didn't get pass the security check.
@@laizerwoolf are you sure
By not leaving the gaza, they are supported hamas .
they still like to teach the kids about "good" guys 20:12
Thank your goverment they started this
I have a question if we have so much going on in our country the great usa ppl suffering hunger poorness our native americans and so many more ethic ppl why do people want us to worry about whats goin on in the other side of the world i dont get it let them deal with there own stuff and we should do the same
It's a small world.
Probably because your government backs up and feeds this war with weapons and ammunition non stop.
Because we love in a globalized world. Everything is connected products and goods come from all over and need to maintain there relationships.
Exactly. Glad you are against supporting Israel with billions in protection, arms and aid.
Não tem legenda 😞
It is not fair that the Palestinians have no options but to give up their land so that Jews can have their place where they can be safe. Why do Palestinians have to pay for what Europeans did to them, especially Germany.
Many unfair places , Turkey invaded and illigal occupy northern Cyprus around 1974, no one acknowledged this as Turkey and Greeks had their houses and land stolen. No UN or Arab countries get angry about this. Tibet was invaded and illegally taken by China, its horrible but no one will lift a finger. Morocco has taken West Sahara and no help either. Putin stole Crimea in 2014 and now more land in 2022-2024. Sundan experience horrible genecide but almost no news coverage or solutions. Palestinians in Jordan and Lebanon are not threatened well , no one cares in the arab world. Kuwait kicked out almost 400.000 Palestinians after Gulf war because their leadership didn't support Kuwait, no one talks about right to return. The list goes on.
Palestine has been re-settled by jews since the 1800s. It’s their historical homeland that the Romans drove them away from
Who still support Israell after this documentary? 💔
We will, forever.
One side started the war on October 7th.
What about documentaries about Israeli wounded from Nova, Israeli kids with PTSD from Hamas killing their parents in front of their eyes, Israeli displaced from North and South, Israeli who fled the war to other countries? Why this particular video should change someone's mind? After all it shows wealthy people who were able to pay bribes to Egypt and free the war. Many aren't so lucky. Many died, much more are wounded. And the only reason for all this suffering is Hamas that started the war with clear intention to bring this suffer on their people while they will sit in tunnels in safety. Hamas ideology does not value lives of their people and quality of life. They are able to finish all this everyday - return the hostages and surrender. But then they will lose their power and wealth gained from oppressing their own people. No, they don't want this and wouldn't make anything to lower the casualties, the opposite. The more dead the more people will be on Hamas side. And I claim this because the result of being on Palestinian side is restoring Hamas, what is the opposite of Palestinians interests. So every action that allows Hamas to remain in power is being on a Hamas side, not on a Palestinians side. Israel gave them 19 years of self destruction under elected Hamas government, the moment that movement decided to bring its violence to Israel territory it wasn't their internal issue anymore. There will be no Hamas government of Gaza, for sake of Israelis and Palestinians.
🙋🏻♀️
if you read about israeli oppressor regime history you become an enemey of the state of israel for sure.
Lets not forget the 15,000 Palestinians killed and 700,000 driven away during the Nakba in 1948
24:06 Two State Solution ?? Ha ha ha !!! A corner of Judea Samaria will become a New Country !!
Iran and Turkey will have excess to it's Air and Navel Ports !? What a Joke ! Did you hear that Bibi ?? Ha ha hah !!!
Remember Oct 7th victims. Trump 2024 & God bless Israel.✊
😢😢😢😢
“a new life in Egypt?
that's what germany wanted to bring israel's ethnic cleansing plan to fruition.
i remember at the beginning of the war, the german minister who spent her time justifying the massacre of palestinians because “khamass is evil” put a lot of pressure on Egypt to open the borders
They will spend a whole life of trauma, and not one country would interviene. It's passed diplomacy now and needs a pragmatic approach. Great Britain needs to make amends to the Palestinian people for 75 years. Real declaration.
America need to give the Palestinians a state here in the US!! That is the least they can do
Only after Egypt🤷♂️
Well 🇩🇪 your government is complicit in these atrocities …
Free Palestine 🔻
This makes me Cry My Homeland My Homeland Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸 will rise again 🥹🇵🇸🇵🇸🌿🕊️
What will Egypt be if it accepted Palestine refugees like Lebanon ?
My Allah help people off Palestinian the pain they going through Alahuma Amiin
Why first attack on israel... from Hamas....
History is judging you Israel.
Israel left the Gaza strip to the people of Gaza in 2005 because of people like you.
This experiment (seeing of Gazans can govern themselves instead of making wars) have failed dramatically showing the world that they cannot be trusted.
You can put the blame on Israel because you see from your very narrow eyes the effect of what Gazans have chosen to do.
History judges everybody
yes, history also says there is no such thing as palestine
Shame on these Arab world for letting Palestine
You shouldn't have to leave your home all because the guests from Europe have decided to steal it
OR BECAUSE THEY ELECTED BAD PEOPLE AS THEIR CHOSEN LEADERS.
@@EmmaDeesame thing is happening in the west bank too. What did the people in the west bank do?
We do care for the innocent, what a shame this life is full of blessing for others yet other people suffer and are in pain because others have created it.
Propoganda
Everywhere the Brits go..
🇵🇸
Mashallah they should come to Germany. I demand german government ❤❤
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Palestinians, go and live in Egypt