Why some Arab states side with Israel | Mapped Out

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 21. 06. 2024
  • Leaders of most Arab countries condemn Israel and the war in Gaza. Yet, some Arab governments maintain close ties with the state of Israel. They have a common enemy - and face an uneasy balancing act.
    Subscribe: czcams.com/users/deutsche...
    For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
    Follow DW on social media:
    ►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
    ►Twitter: / dwnews
    ►Instagram: / dwnews
    ►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
    Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
    #MappedOut #Isreal #MiddleEast

Komentáře • 1,2K

  • @redcloud8444
    @redcloud8444 Před 5 dny +490

    Give neighboring Arabs more money and they are yours. Simple.

    • @DemPilafian
      @DemPilafian Před 4 dny

      In the video there are multiple references to Arab states demanding to be paid for peace. The rulers and the culture of their subjects is morally bankrupt. Sadly, anyone in the West who points this out gets labeled Islamophobic.

    • @val-schaeffer1117
      @val-schaeffer1117 Před 4 dny

      Procreate slightly more, about 7+ fertility rate, and the land is yours. Simple.

    • @nasrihassaan2610
      @nasrihassaan2610 Před 4 dny +18

      reality 😂

    • @AAAA-gs2mw
      @AAAA-gs2mw Před 4 dny +9

      They have enough money to buy their dignity back

    • @ashrafulpayelhn
      @ashrafulpayelhn Před 4 dny +1

      You are right

  • @ccgoh100
    @ccgoh100 Před 5 dny +532

    😂😂 Suddenly autocratic nations’ leaders are good representation of the public…

    • @ahmedshamy6250
      @ahmedshamy6250 Před 5 dny +64

      maan Hats off to you...this is the West, hypocrisy and double standards

    • @arturdobrzynski6531
      @arturdobrzynski6531 Před 5 dny +20

      ​@@ahmedshamy6250I am from the so called West and I have to agree with you.

    • @yubakrarai
      @yubakrarai Před 5 dny +10

      You my friend are one of the few smart people here.

    • @mgronich948
      @mgronich948 Před 5 dny +1

      good reprentation of the public in Israel?

    • @anthonyagbojo1408
      @anthonyagbojo1408 Před 5 dny +4

      Is it your view that autocratic leaders are always against their people especially when the enemy is external?

  • @Faluthe
    @Faluthe Před 5 dny +429

    These cowards are their own worst enemies, Gaza has exposed them.

    • @frankng792000
      @frankng792000 Před 5 dny

      Iran is Arabs worst enemy

    • @toyotaprius79
      @toyotaprius79 Před 5 dny +5

      And because of them, Palestine will set us Free

    • @Porter-88
      @Porter-88 Před 4 dny +62

      @@toyotaprius79 Free from islam lmao.

    • @killerjase1
      @killerjase1 Před 4 dny +17

      @@Porter-88😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 we really need to be rid of it.

    • @riodelleyvettebacho6121
      @riodelleyvettebacho6121 Před 4 dny

      The arab countries supporting Israel are developed and civilized! LOL look at your gaza, they exposed themselves as a terrorist state

  • @starcapture3040
    @starcapture3040 Před 5 dny +379

    Because they are not ruled by their own people... duh

    • @cbs63
      @cbs63 Před 5 dny +10

      Yes they are

    • @ciybersal3499
      @ciybersal3499 Před 5 dny

      Exactly dictatorships suit the west here and they keep silent

    • @naimomohamed7332
      @naimomohamed7332 Před 5 dny +4

      No their is alot of America troops base in whole Middle East

    • @danieltoro4917
      @danieltoro4917 Před 5 dny +14

      yeah, they don't have a lovely democracy like Iran

    • @starcapture3040
      @starcapture3040 Před 4 dny

      @@danieltoro4917 or Israel an ethno colonial supremacist dictatorship

  • @bennett8535
    @bennett8535 Před 4 dny +36

    One aspect of this that wasn't mentioned, but is worth noting, is that by creating a common enemy of Israel, oppressive regimes can distract their populations from their own domestic economic, social and political problems and failures. Every country does this: A boogeyman is a great way to stay in power.

    • @zafar0132
      @zafar0132 Před dnem +3

      also when the bogey man actually is really a bogey man, both a military threat, but also politically looking to undermine the surrounding states at every turn.

    • @hulkhogan5605
      @hulkhogan5605 Před dnem +1

      More oppressive than ***ael ?

    • @elli6220
      @elli6220 Před dnem +4

      @@zafar0132 Israel wants surrounding Arab nations to be stable and peaceful. They don't want to undermine them at all.

    • @artplanb9688
      @artplanb9688 Před dnem +1

      Your geopolitics' skills don't go as far as holding a candle to the class awareness of a 17 yo Hercules Ultras member.
      (You're onto something of course, but you keep looking in the wrong corner perhaps)

  • @ricardo.fontanelli
    @ricardo.fontanelli Před 4 dny +120

    Ok, but we all know the story of the region didn't start in 1947, right?

    • @Bladieblah
      @Bladieblah Před 3 dny +29

      Exactly, DW should do better. Extremely biased take, especially the history section. Israël did not come into being as compensation for the Holocaust or anything like that, that process was long set in motion

    • @spartacusche
      @spartacusche Před 3 dny

      @@Bladieblah indeed it was a compensation for ww2 and an advanced based for the western to install chaos, HENCE the SIONIST mouvement is not so old 100 years ago, it was an iagineable idea that they create a state in arab lands, yes arabs lands for almots 14 centuries

    • @OlviMasta77
      @OlviMasta77 Před 3 dny +9

      @@Bladieblah Truth is you'd need at least 8 hours documentary series, in 30-60 minute parts for people to get a clearer picture of the history of the region, conflict and the concentration to take in that information.

    • @rickycoverrubias6176
      @rickycoverrubias6176 Před 3 dny +6

      european hebrews are not the original hebrews

    • @nholmes86
      @nholmes86 Před 3 dny +7

      arabs just dont accept defeat

  • @lashlarue7924
    @lashlarue7924 Před 5 dny +273

    Ask the Jordanians about what happened when they let the PLO into their country years ago. Hint: it didn't go well.

    • @guraminiro
      @guraminiro Před 5 dny +15

      LOL, tell that to the people fleeing the holocaust in patria disaster!

    • @krayproductions7987
      @krayproductions7987 Před 5 dny +38

      Ask the entire Arab world how it did go when Israel declared their state over the Palestinians land. Hint: it didn’t go well.

    • @disdoncable
      @disdoncable Před 5 dny +65

      @@krayproductions7987 Well, seeing as how almost the entire Arab world either has officially ratified peace/normalization treaties with Israel and/or some form of full acceptance of Israel and are very eager to trade, have technology exchanges, and military alliances with Israel.....they'd say it's going pretty well

    • @krayproductions7987
      @krayproductions7987 Před 5 dny +6

      @@disdoncable Sure only for economic reasons but not with heart. You can see the leaders doing that, ask the people and you will find a different answer. The fact is that Israel has made big problems for the Arab countries with the huge refuge of Palestinians til this day. The wars it made directly and indirectly. Even if you would ask the leaders they would if they had a chance of Israel or no Israel. They would take the later because that would make peace in the Middle East possible and with that economic thrive. Israel is the key issue in the Middle East.

    • @lashlarue7924
      @lashlarue7924 Před 5 dny +56

      @@krayproductions7987 This is true; it did not go well for the Arabs when they started a war in 1948, and again in 1967, and again in 1973, and '87, 2000, and again in 2023 it is still not going well for them. One begins to wonder why.

  • @damham5689
    @damham5689 Před 4 dny +35

    Problem is that " The enemy of my enemy is my friend" has never worked out well.

    • @aaron.aaron.v.b.9448
      @aaron.aaron.v.b.9448 Před 4 dny +12

      It won the second world war though.

    • @josephfreedman9422
      @josephfreedman9422 Před 3 dny +2

      It is a survival mechanism. If, in addition, the US had appreciated the longstanding animosity between Vietnam and China, we could have avoided or curtailed the Vietnam War. 0:00

    • @damham5689
      @damham5689 Před 3 dny +1

      @@aaron.aaron.v.b.9448 and created the cold war

    • @NeoSpacian1237
      @NeoSpacian1237 Před 2 dny

      Says who ?

    • @DaggerofTime
      @DaggerofTime Před 2 dny

      Well it worked in ww2. lol. And in the American revolution (French support) regardless, Israel defeated the Arab world on their own before multiple times so they have a good reason to fear.

  • @IqbalBakht
    @IqbalBakht Před 3 dny +68

    I'm currently studying Persian in Isfahan, and believe me Iranians, regardless of their state narrative are vocal about oppression in all corners of the globe. It's never about religion or a common shared culture. In contrast even though Arab states support Israel, Arabs seem to be soley vocal for their own kind. Kashmir, Kurdistan, Armenia, Turkestan never make it to the list of the oppressed. Sad. It shouldn't be about numbers or religion, or independence movements anyways. Poverty and class discrimination are as much of a human suffering as war, and are prevalent everywhere in Afro-Asia and South America.

    • @lif6737
      @lif6737 Před 3 dny +9

      I applaud Iranians speaking out against oppression, but not the regime that oppresses them.

    • @TheZombaslaya
      @TheZombaslaya Před 2 dny +2

      And do they protest Ukraine?

    • @MichelMrz
      @MichelMrz Před 2 dny +1

      ​@@TheZombaslaya People are people; they are against war and death of innocents. And unlike some Europeans, they don't distinguish if it's a white, non-white, or Arab nation. However, since Ukraine have support of whole western countries, they don't feel the need to protest for Ukraine either. And it's very complex. Iran is in the middle of many conflicts; for instance, the same western nations supporting Ukraine have also made life in Iran almost impossible through sanctions. Although the source of these conflicts is the Iranian government, some people feel threatened by Americans and Europeans. These unjust sanctions based on Israel lobbyists just after signing a nuclear deal with G5+1 are true sentiment toward western animosity based on Israeli interests.

    • @elennet4116
      @elennet4116 Před 2 dny +11

      Worry about oppression of women in Iran 😂

    • @robertw1800
      @robertw1800 Před 2 dny +3

      What a joke.

  • @igbadumefavour
    @igbadumefavour Před 3 dny +66

    Nakba
    When your leaders chose war instead of peacefully building a new country and went on a rampage with a dream of erasing an entire new nation, but failed catastrophically!

    • @listener8228
      @listener8228 Před dnem +24

      Nakba simplified.
      Arabs: *declares war*
      Arabs: *loses war*
      Arabs: *complain*

    • @__Man__
      @__Man__ Před dnem +1

      That's to blame, they were opted to move to the empty land in Patagonia, why do they choose that land with diverse people inhibating it for thousands of years instead?

    • @hulkhogan5605
      @hulkhogan5605 Před dnem +1

      The illusionists pulling wool over everyone’s eyes . All prime land on the West Bank has been usurped for settlements which are growing exponentially, Palestinians reduced to pecuniary and in a day to day survival mode against the murderous excesses of the occupying force , then , where and how can the dream of an independent be realised.

    • @youssof.k.8736
      @youssof.k.8736 Před dnem

      Let me fix it for you.
      Colonizers imposing a new state on the native people by taking away some of their land (with nothing in return) -> the people revolt and don't accept this-> they loose the war because most of the countris just got their independence from the west colonization of the region -> the newly imposed state backed by the west take majority of the land because their army technology is mostly Us andmodern western arm. 👍

  • @Asha-wj7ko
    @Asha-wj7ko Před 4 dny +65

    Dw cleverly skip the timeline of Palestine from 1948-2023

    • @itsme-jibru
      @itsme-jibru Před 3 dny +11

      What about before 1948 ? 😂

    • @yehonatanyaar7330
      @yehonatanyaar7330 Před 2 dny +11

      Not everything is about Palestine’s version of the truth.

    • @mohanedrashed9671
      @mohanedrashed9671 Před 2 dny

      ​@@yehonatanyaar7330 feel free to educate

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 Před 2 dny +7

      This is not a mouthpiece for Hamas.

    • @uamsnof
      @uamsnof Před dnem +2

      @@erikthomsen4768so in those 70 years, nothing bad happened in Gaza? The Palestinians were left in peace and there are no orphans?

  • @jimmyzach5907
    @jimmyzach5907 Před 4 dny +73

    A handful of Arab leaders defending their selfish interests do not represent "Arab States" mind you.

    • @ebonymaw8457
      @ebonymaw8457 Před 3 dny

      Politically, they do. The opinions of Arabs who are allergic to democracy do not really matter, only their leaders' do. That is what Israel and America realised, hence why they dropped their attempts at a charm offensive and went straight to signing deals with the man in charge.

    • @MihaTech
      @MihaTech Před 2 dny +13

      err... yes they do, they control their countries.

    • @ybgamingnl2540
      @ybgamingnl2540 Před 2 dny

      @@MihaTech but here is the thing. Nobody asked them to control their respective country. They are autocratic dictators.

    • @ameyas7726
      @ameyas7726 Před 2 dny

      @@MihaTech No they don't...Iran is the only State that represent "Arab States" mind you.

    • @brandonandreas4659
      @brandonandreas4659 Před 2 dny +2

      Unfortunately or fortunately, depending on who you ask, they do represent the Arab States mindset as they control policy, sometimes with an iron fist!

  • @muhammadhanif4113
    @muhammadhanif4113 Před 5 dny +121

    Money. US and west spending thrillions for that.

  • @rodrigomohr1277
    @rodrigomohr1277 Před 5 dny +256

    Only their corrupt leaders.

    • @Asgoga
      @Asgoga Před 4 dny +21

      Only their smart leaders

    • @rodrigomohr1277
      @rodrigomohr1277 Před 4 dny +2

      @@Asgoga 🤣

    • @randomguy3496
      @randomguy3496 Před 3 dny

      A government cannot rule if all its people are against it. That is cope nonsense excuses. But keep crying and telling yourself they all love Palestine

    • @DeMonty77
      @DeMonty77 Před 3 dny

      @@rodrigomohr1277 dictators are indeed smart

    • @kk-qu1zc
      @kk-qu1zc Před 3 dny +2

      Aww is little poo poo mad not everyone is siding with you?

  • @AbdulkarimBirigigi
    @AbdulkarimBirigigi Před 5 dny +112

    Its simple, they are about money not Humanity, if you find it surprising to us its not

    • @JorgeRzezak
      @JorgeRzezak Před 5 dny +10

      Of course, because you are morally superior and directly connected to Allah

    • @MuhammadAishaBestCouple5206
      @MuhammadAishaBestCouple5206 Před 5 dny +18

      ​@@JorgeRzezakThe same Allah who told Prophet Muhammad to marry a six year old?

    • @abigailkannai484
      @abigailkannai484 Před 5 dny

      Its simple: Iran is the biggest threat in the middle east

    • @johnd2058
      @johnd2058 Před 5 dny

      Power, you forgot power. The US aid for peace has to be in the form of relatively-potent weaponry, that's the absurd part.

    • @xXAlmdudlerXx
      @xXAlmdudlerXx Před 5 dny +2

      Not money. They are rich. As the video says it’s about geopolitics

  • @paolamora6621
    @paolamora6621 Před 5 dny +33

    Money bloody money

    • @playerlive4081
      @playerlive4081 Před dnem

      For Sudan it helped get sanctions lifted, so the people could finally suffer less

  • @terribrad24
    @terribrad24 Před 4 dny +52

    "The arab world is outraged"
    When are they ever not outraged? They are always outraged, unless they committ horrible atrocities themselves, then they stay silent.

    • @CodeLife_12
      @CodeLife_12 Před 4 dny

      These are the people that riot in the street when a comic is made about Mohammed. They are extremely sensitive.

    • @asemalshoura519
      @asemalshoura519 Před 4 dny +13

      170 million native american and austrilia
      80 million in 2 WWs
      50 milion in colonization
      6 million j
      we never reached such insanity you did

    • @DarkRockslizer
      @DarkRockslizer Před 2 dny

      @@asemalshoura519 "170 million native Americans and Austrilia", what are you on about?? Australia had ~1.5 mil natives, which at one point dropped to 1 million and now recovered to 1.5 million again.
      As for Americans, a lot died due to Asian, European and African diseases being introduced (which is hard to determine) 4 centuries before vaccines were invented; no one could control that, same as how Europeans could not control their own deaths due to local diseases in Africa until the invention of quinine - hence, most of African countries are still 98-99% African after colonial rule except maybe SAR.

    • @alexalexalex797
      @alexalexalex797 Před dnem +1

      @@asemalshoura519😂😂😂 what?😂😂😂😂
      Bro, the middle east is a hellhole of wars between arab nations.
      Literally endless religious wars and endless groups of cavemen vs other cavemen.
      Or rebels vs governments etx.
      “But Ww2”😂

    • @thematthew761
      @thematthew761 Před dnem

      @@asemalshoura519you hate all White people then

  • @saffsuff
    @saffsuff Před 4 dny +75

    It's funny how almost every time she mentioned atrocities of Israeli government against Palestinians she used passive voice e.g. they are killed , were displaced etc 😅 DW conveniently drops the subject of these sentences

    • @saffsuff
      @saffsuff Před 4 dny

      @@RachelJ-ki6nt ok

    • @4n4Queen
      @4n4Queen Před 4 dny +10

      ​@@RachelJ-ki6ntbrainrot.

    • @LayLoow
      @LayLoow Před 4 dny +2

      @@RachelJ-ki6ntask Rachael Corrie

    • @reebozo3543
      @reebozo3543 Před 4 dny +1

      @@RachelJ-ki6nt i can name a 100

    • @hemafalcon629
      @hemafalcon629 Před 3 dny

      ​@@RachelJ-ki6ntcurrently the north of gaza is facing a starvation worser than the beginning of the war

  • @enckidoofalling2883
    @enckidoofalling2883 Před 4 dny +7

    I am outraged that the Ayatollah attacks Israel

    • @bmortloff
      @bmortloff Před 22 hodinami

      Israel has attacked Iran more times than the reverse. DW doesn't see that as a significant enough point to include.

  • @samcumdi
    @samcumdi Před 5 dny +114

    The million-dollar question remains, why wasn't it ''occupation'' when Egypt and Jordan occupied Gaza and the WB for 18 years; why did the Palestinians not pursue statehood when these two Arab states had the whole of Gaza and the WB under their watch? It would seem that the agitation has more to do with chasing off the Israelis entirely out of the levant area christened 'Palestine' by the Romans.

    • @richarddefortune1329
      @richarddefortune1329 Před 5 dny

      2 wrongs don't make it right. The occupation of Palestinian lands is wrong, let it be by Israel or anyone else.
      On top of that, Israel is an apartheid state. It oppressing, stealing lands, and it's happening now. That's why the world is not accepting anymore.

    • @richarddefortune1329
      @richarddefortune1329 Před 5 dny +30

      My answer to you was removed. I will try again with a shorter answer. The occupation of Palestinian lands is wrong, no matter who does it. We remember Israel because it has been doing it for 76 years now, applying apartheid and ethnic cleansing on top.

    • @infoseeker1187
      @infoseeker1187 Před 5 dny +15

      I'm not from the area, but I think I can provide an answer to your million-dollar question.
      Not all people are political. End of the day, normal people just want to be able to live a reasonable life. Palestinians could live a few hundred years under Ottoman empire, they can also live under another name, Egypt or Jordan or even Israel, if they are afforded to have a reasonable life.
      This answer is based on experience learnt from history. My country had been occupied multiple times. If the oppression is high, the revolt would be fierce and the occupation would be short lived. If the oppression allowed the people to live reasonable well, the occupation could last for a few hundred years in peace. We also had a situation with best case scenario when the occupation mixed well with the local culture, and created a new mixed race nation prosperous for a few hundred years.

    • @richarddefortune1329
      @richarddefortune1329 Před 5 dny +1

      @@infoseeker1187 words of wisdom 🙌

    • @user-jt8vj1vm6y
      @user-jt8vj1vm6y Před 5 dny +15

      Because the inhabitants of West Bank and Gaza were equal citizens with Jordanians and Egyptians, and spoke the same language.
      With Israel as the occupier they aren't citizens of Israel and belong to a different people, oppressed by the Israeli state.

  • @vinsklortho2008
    @vinsklortho2008 Před 5 dny +6

    Because sometimes your self interests align and the enemy of my enemy may not be my friend but they can at least fight roughly on the same side.

  • @Christmas12
    @Christmas12 Před 4 dny +8

    Friends is a very strong word, you must be joking

  • @MysticScapes
    @MysticScapes Před 2 dny +2

    Greed > Humanity

  • @Abedawn
    @Abedawn Před 4 dny +3

    What os gulf region?

  • @HuiChyr
    @HuiChyr Před 4 dny +3

    Better to have a peaceful enemy than a belligerent brother.

  • @tkling5909
    @tkling5909 Před 4 dny +3

    Because they don’t want to fight and die for an ungrateful and never satisfying neighbor.

  • @philzmusic8098
    @philzmusic8098 Před dnem +1

    When it comes to foreign policy, nations pursue their interests, not their values.

  • @Pyrrhic537
    @Pyrrhic537 Před 2 dny +1

    Even Greek Cypriot ex EOKA B member's sided with the Palestinians and tried to help them out post disbandment. Partly due to the PFLP and PLO helping and training Asala and partly due to both having an occupation. Although EOKA B had possibly received a shipment of assault rifles and ammo originating in Israel via Lebanese Phalange arm's brokers. And it was originally the Cypriot socialists who had connections with the more left wing Palestinian group's.

  • @ramy1190
    @ramy1190 Před 5 dny +8

    Egypt doesn't have foreign military bases

  • @play-doughsrepublic5121
    @play-doughsrepublic5121 Před 4 dny +4

    An excellent documentary - thank you,

  • @moosafarooqi6449
    @moosafarooqi6449 Před 3 dny +2

    *5:35* IF I was in Sadat's place I would not want my economy to prosper at the cost of Palestinians

  • @baddbeliever
    @baddbeliever Před 5 dny +2

    any successful and friendly constant is seen as a possible ally in the middle east. stability is what the region needs when gains cant be made in war and turmoil

  • @mgronich948
    @mgronich948 Před 5 dny +9

    The leaders of Arab states have to be realistic, they see what the US did to Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria. They know this can happen to them. The people of those arab states see what Israel is doing in Gaza and are both horrified and angry.

    • @mgronich948
      @mgronich948 Před 5 dny +1

      THe US empire has the largest military and rules the world by fear. That rule goes away if the US military's pre-eminance is challenged and the fear subsides. Rome also ruled its empire with military force and fear.

  • @a.k.a3742
    @a.k.a3742 Před 5 dny +5

    The leaders are different from the people. Listen to the people not the leaders.

    • @the180degreerule3
      @the180degreerule3 Před 2 dny

      the people are not cows to each their opinion about the matter, I personally would recognize mecca as the capital of Iran if Iran can make my country rich and powerful

    • @quissbird-10
      @quissbird-10 Před dnem

      Then you end up like Syria

  • @greendsnow
    @greendsnow Před 3 dny +2

    Wait... So if Iran weren't like that, you mean things would be very different... How useful

  • @GeoPolica
    @GeoPolica Před 19 hodinami

    “The enemy of my enemy is my friend”

  • @sagartomar3461
    @sagartomar3461 Před 4 dny +4

    Who has the money rules the world no matter how bad they are they can control the narrative

    • @safzah
      @safzah Před 3 dny +1

      No really, and people with money know that but won’t admit it.

  • @rekuku-xq4he
    @rekuku-xq4he Před 3 dny +17

    Those Arab countries know that Israel will abide by the agreement, but Hamas will not. They also want to be free from Hamas' political influence through terrorism. Many Arab countries will support Israel even if they do not say so.

    • @Kabbar_
      @Kabbar_ Před dnem

      Some* cuz you'd be delusional to think all arabs will side with Israel

    • @DarkTruthPlatform
      @DarkTruthPlatform Před dnem

      No Israel broke every agreement, counting 20 UN resolutions. They are just corrupt and paid.

    • @leavesinautumn5959
      @leavesinautumn5959 Před 21 hodinou

      It's money you dunce, pure and simple. No neighbouring country has any other reason to look favourably at Israel in any way. Whether it's Egypt a few decades ago or Saudi Arabia now, it always (without exception) involves an exchange of money.

  • @mkj-IQ313
    @mkj-IQ313 Před 4 dny +2

    What about the Palestinian people who were killed by the Israeli occupation army on the orders of Benjamin Milikowsky?

  • @majd_shoots
    @majd_shoots Před 4 dny +2

    War criminals standing with each other, that's all

  • @aynhiayraadr6599
    @aynhiayraadr6599 Před 5 dny +41

    DW is lying too you guys with this 😂😂😂😂
    Go to Jeffrey Sachs or John mearshimer there more accurate

    • @user-oi6zd3lq6e
      @user-oi6zd3lq6e Před 5 dny +9

      @aynhiayraadr6599 not really they are one sided .

    • @pjhgerlach
      @pjhgerlach Před 5 dny +16

      Those are the real liars.

    • @astragrowth
      @astragrowth Před 5 dny +4

      Nah, we're good.

    • @AymeTinawi
      @AymeTinawi Před 3 dny

      Scott Ritter, Greg Stoker, and Colonel MacGregor also put out some great content. Hindustan Times and Times of India show the explosions and stuff.

    • @AymeTinawi
      @AymeTinawi Před 3 dny +1

      This is a misleading video. Saudi Arabia has said it will not normalize ties absent a state of Palestine. The US acts like we don’t need Saudi Arabia, but drunk dials them at 4 am to say “I miss you” 😂

  • @MrRJG101
    @MrRJG101 Před 4 dny +3

    Some people are just too full of themselves to see what's coming😂

  • @mazaremaabdulkadir512
    @mazaremaabdulkadir512 Před 3 dny +2

    Once the palestaneans remain without a sovereign state of their own, there cuould hardly be any end to the conflict. A spade is a spade, not a bloody shovel!

    • @GG-un7hj
      @GG-un7hj Před dnem

      Jordan was supposed to fill that role.

  • @israel_illuminati_Rothschild

    Inaction does not equate to support. Keep that in mind. Some arab countries are among the wealthiest country in the world, they don't wanna risk losing that status by engaging in a war with any country.

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 Před 4 dny

      When you cut down on aid as Saudi Arabia has done for years, seal your border to keep them trapped as Egypt is during and outright recognise the legitimacy of the State of Israel then you are not neutral. You are proactive.

  • @IssaBenMariamma
    @IssaBenMariamma Před 5 dny +53

    Then they wonder why they dying for the hundreds during Hajj to Mecca. 😒🙄

    • @Sufiyann803
      @Sufiyann803 Před 5 dny +3

      Thousand

    • @Memovox
      @Memovox Před 5 dny

      Meanwhile, millions of atheist Westerners are dying from obesity in front of their computers.

    • @KozmikGizmo
      @KozmikGizmo Před 5 dny +26

      they die for religious fanatism not only in mecca

    • @arupsarkar2509
      @arupsarkar2509 Před 5 dny +6

      Some Indian pilgrims returns and says, there were no bus services for over 40 kilometers in 52 degrees ! I fail to understand...

    • @HUMShaBaK
      @HUMShaBaK Před 5 dny +7

      ​@@arupsarkar2509in hajj they have to complete whole walk on foot in scorching sweltering heat. They will not get any bus.😂our maha kumbh is more better managed than hajj

  • @fatimatuzzahra4036
    @fatimatuzzahra4036 Před 2 dny +5

    I have noticed how DW in particular omits images of mass carnage and destruction in Gaza

  • @saedm2359
    @saedm2359 Před 3 dny +2

    12:53 my countries somaliland and somalia are not arab countries 🤣

  • @mariafantappie8177
    @mariafantappie8177 Před dnem +1

    1:57 Nakba started before the war

  • @topnotch4564
    @topnotch4564 Před 5 dny +3

    This Happens.

  • @warfighter1988
    @warfighter1988 Před 5 dny +59

    Youre missing the fact that most neighbouring countries that took in palestinians ended up expelling them because they were always against the same goverment that accepted them in. This might them understand israel plight more. Palestinians needs a policy and mentality change if they want to win back support.

    • @fatihaslimani4365
      @fatihaslimani4365 Před 5 dny +14

      Les palestiniens ils veulent être libres comme chaque citoyen du monde pas esclave d'un état extrémiste.

    • @cbs63
      @cbs63 Před 5 dny +12

      ​@fatihaslimani4365 nonsense they had freedom and prosperity but got greedy and wanted Israel too.

    • @user-de2np3ds4y
      @user-de2np3ds4y Před 5 dny +2

      @@fatihaslimani4365excuse me who are the extremists?? Let’s get real

    • @user-oi6zd3lq6e
      @user-oi6zd3lq6e Před 5 dny +2

      ​@@fatihaslimani4365Lauren place est france la Terre occupe !!

    • @ansgarm.cordie9659
      @ansgarm.cordie9659 Před 5 dny +3

      ​@@cbs63During which years was this freedom and prosperity thing for Palestinians in Gaza and in the West Bank happening? Was it in a parallel universe?

  • @alelectric2767
    @alelectric2767 Před 2 dny +1

    They realized it’s better to get along and rake in the cash then to war and spend cash

  • @paulobaronceli
    @paulobaronceli Před 4 dny +1

    Want to see if that holds true if a regional war breaks out...

  • @qalbidaryeele
    @qalbidaryeele Před 5 dny +14

    It's not Arab people, but it's the leader's that U.S.A U.K and israil but the position to lead their countries for what they need and their interest not the interest of their people like abdifatax alzizi and king of urdun.....

    • @omosefenelson3450
      @omosefenelson3450 Před 5 dny +3

      Because they need peace

    • @bellohadiza9414
      @bellohadiza9414 Před 5 dny

      YyEeSs !!! .

    • @DeftPol
      @DeftPol Před 5 dny +2

      Middle Eastern peoples choose dictatorships when they kick out American supported regimes anyway. Just look at Iran - and now the Iranian people are increasingly sick of the Ayatollahs, but can’t get rid of them either. If there was something remotely resembling a democratic tradition in the Middle East, this wouldn’t be an issue, but frankly it’s just not a part of the culture of the Middle East to give voice to the people - it has always been a land of imperial conquest. Usually Arab imperialism, but imperialism all the same.

    • @randomguy3496
      @randomguy3496 Před 3 dny

      No country can function if none of their people support it. Delusional take.

  • @philosophy-of-science-and-law

    Superb, excellent video, thank you! History, geography, and international politics are shown quite discernibly from ideologies known to frustrate it.

  • @user-dy9jq4lc5y
    @user-dy9jq4lc5y Před 3 dny +1

    Hint: Arab states are NOT democracies.

  • @rando42069
    @rando42069 Před 2 dny +1

    There is a saying that politics makes strange bedfellows. So does money, for that matter

  • @deanjericevic8912
    @deanjericevic8912 Před 4 dny +5

    Interesting & insightful presentation with cogently argued points! In a succinct way all the players in Middle Eastern geopolitics represented & how they playout in a modern context.

  • @kayn6858
    @kayn6858 Před 5 dny +69

    One side wants islamism and the other side wants tolerance

    • @Sufiyann803
      @Sufiyann803 Před 5 dny +20

      No other side wants dollar 💰

    • @gamingbuddy0074
      @gamingbuddy0074 Před 5 dny

      Who are you trying to fool buddy radical Zionism is the biggest threat today in the middle east.

    • @adamredwine774
      @adamredwine774 Před 5 dny +4

      Exactly. And far too many in the west don’t understand what’s coming to them.

    • @user-nk9eg2pv8p
      @user-nk9eg2pv8p Před 5 dny +2

      Bb destroyed js

    • @user-nk9eg2pv8p
      @user-nk9eg2pv8p Před 5 dny

      This is the beginning of the end of Zionism and western capitalism

  • @theronaldophotography4971

    That was "intense" encapsulated in one video.

  • @ammarturky5402
    @ammarturky5402 Před dnem +1

    They don't represent their people.

  • @VK-no5kj
    @VK-no5kj Před 5 dny +38

    I am Indian and wish for Palestinians to have their own state and freedom. But I can’t support what Hamas did and I can’t support the way Palestinian civilian and children treated captured Israeli hostages.

    • @catalina5382
      @catalina5382 Před 5 dny +10

      What do you mean? How did they treat the Israeli hostages?
      Israel treats their prisoners much worse, some had to have their legs amputated due to the restraints, many died

    • @imadkhaliq2941
      @imadkhaliq2941 Před 5 dny +7

      You are one of those who heared about Israel Palestine after October 7 learn about what Israel's has been doing to the Palestinians from the start 1948. The Israelis have been doing much worse on a daily basis for 70 plus years.

    • @LlowellynMorris
      @LlowellynMorris Před 5 dny

      ​@catalina5382 did you see it was you there

    • @tanvir32
      @tanvir32 Před 5 dny +3

      no hamas in west bank what happening there ? u are another hypocrite nothing else

    • @imadkhaliq2941
      @imadkhaliq2941 Před 5 dny +1

      @@LlowellynMorris did you see what hamas did were you there....what stupidity and audacity.

  • @davidgaskin5417
    @davidgaskin5417 Před 5 dny +47

    Why? Because most Arab countries have grown up and matured. They understand that peace will.come from accepting and working with Israel.

  • @MarkMark-io1vn
    @MarkMark-io1vn Před 3 dny +2

    I am from Yemen, Palestine is free

  • @DavidWalls-sr1pg
    @DavidWalls-sr1pg Před 5 dny +2

    Firstpost's Vantage with Palki Sharma is a great source for international news.

  • @iskandarbushnaq938
    @iskandarbushnaq938 Před 4 dny +24

    U can say some arab gov, but none of the arab nations stand with israel.

    • @heinkle1
      @heinkle1 Před 3 dny

      Nope because they’re all deeply anti-Semitic

  • @lu544
    @lu544 Před 4 dny +6

    The US should not have been an alley to Israel or any middle east country. None of this is our problem or deserving of our money and headache.

  • @oyster4545
    @oyster4545 Před 4 dny +2

    Please rectify your mistakes
    Not Arab countries but Arab tyrants or king who are sweet heart of the west.Dont you see Jordinian, Egyptians,Emiratis,Morrocon demanding end to normalisation unless Palestine is free?

  • @jainepal4844
    @jainepal4844 Před 3 dny +1

    Their guilt lives on 😂😂😂

  • @MS-np2nf
    @MS-np2nf Před 3 dny +16

    its wild calling arabs who are semetic people, anti semetic.

    • @mohanedrashed9671
      @mohanedrashed9671 Před 2 dny +3

      LOL excuse her. She can only say what the zionest allow here.

    • @2livenoob
      @2livenoob Před dnem

      its wild calling once African nations by the name Arab, and not recognizing the violent history that caused it.

    • @mohanedrashed9671
      @mohanedrashed9671 Před dnem

      @@2livenoob How did African coutires adopt the Arabic naming? And what is the history behind that?

    • @davidpeniel7168
      @davidpeniel7168 Před dnem

      @@mohanedrashed9671war, massacres and slavery

    • @mohanedrashed9671
      @mohanedrashed9671 Před dnem

      @davidpeniel7168 any references for that? Like it's well documented the crimes of Germany during WWII, the crimes of Crusaders. The atrocities by the British in India. Do you have a source or something specific? Because all I can find that they controlled North africa by defending the Romans.

  • @toLearn0English
    @toLearn0English Před 2 dny +4

    The story didn’t start on October 7.
    The blue and white gonna lose soon.

  • @DavidMapola
    @DavidMapola Před 4 dny +1

    Mds is a millenial person he knows where to side.. I salute him the most!

    • @Maria-EU
      @Maria-EU Před 4 dny

      You salute a person who has zero respect towards human rights?

  • @kevinholland5000
    @kevinholland5000 Před 4 dny +2

    No real enemies but real victims indeed and they are the ones who suffers

  • @pavelp9887
    @pavelp9887 Před 4 dny +51

    What’s not to understand here? There are two kinds of Arabs. Ones that are stuck in the past and ones that finally began looking towards the future.
    They used to all be into Islamism and jihad and all that but then many of the Arabs realized they actually wanted to you know… live? The UAE for example builds these incredible city’s and they have good relations with Israel. Israel is also a forward looking nation.
    The problem are those who are stuck in the past.

    • @derdez1
      @derdez1 Před 4 dny

      You mean you got people who have no honour and would even sell his mother for money and power like the so called arab leaders. And you got people who you call leaving in the past who have honour and know that this live is temporary and want to achieve victory and freedom.

    • @geofflepper3207
      @geofflepper3207 Před 4 dny +12

      How is not wanting to be forced off of one's own land and into an overcrowded impoverished prison camp and not wanting to be oppressed and not wanting to be the victim of a genocide being "stuck in the past"?
      Would you want those horrific things to happen to you and your people?
      Would accepting that mean that you are a "modern day" person?

    • @geofflepper3207
      @geofflepper3207 Před 4 dny +10

      How the heck is Israel acting like an 18th century colonialist invader forward thinking?

    • @user-xk3dt2zj1v
      @user-xk3dt2zj1v Před 4 dny

      Israel is forward looking? That’s why it constantly bangs on about the Holocaust and Moses?
      Stop lying! What’s wrong with you people??

    • @musiconabudget3712
      @musiconabudget3712 Před 4 dny

      Nope is it's just western supported dictators and arab citizens lol

  • @Mo11824
    @Mo11824 Před 4 dny +10

    Egypt's decision not to support Hamas does not imply support for Israel. Egypt maintains a neutral stance, prioritizing its national security above all else.

    • @erikthomsen4768
      @erikthomsen4768 Před 4 dny +3

      How convenient. I am sure the Palestinians they trapped in Gaza feel the same way.

    • @Deadassbruhfrfr
      @Deadassbruhfrfr Před 4 dny +5

      ​@erikthomsen4768 the Palestinians made their choice. The Egyptians have made theirs. Next time, don't attack a sovereign state that is capable of defending itself.

    • @hansbrick123
      @hansbrick123 Před 3 dny

      @@Deadassbruhfrfr Hamas isn't even official representatives of Palestine but its actions sacrifice Palestinian civilians. Israel definitely do commit bigger crimes but Hamas also has faults.

    • @Deadassbruhfrfr
      @Deadassbruhfrfr Před 3 dny +3

      @@hansbrick123 >hamas isn't even the official representatives
      Hamas is made up of the Palestinian (gaza) people.They don't just come out of nowhere. They definitely have their support.

  • @zulfiakram
    @zulfiakram Před 2 dny +1

    so that's where the star in Jordan's flag coming from

  • @mamunhossain2260
    @mamunhossain2260 Před 4 dny +1

    Because they aren’t in power by their people, they are in power by using their own role.

    • @ebonymaw8457
      @ebonymaw8457 Před 3 dny

      Common Arabs rejected democracy by defeating the Arab Spring, and have chosen for themselves dictators. Now these dictators freely make deals with Israel and the common Arabs cannot do anything about it. You have made your bed now lie in it.

  • @emptyhad2571
    @emptyhad2571 Před 5 dny +59

    Because a lot of aren’t foolish and want peace.☮️

    • @thembastoep733
      @thembastoep733 Před 5 dny +16

      No they want the benefits from the US and have seen how their regimes became vulnerable after the arab spring, if more of them were democratic it would be even harder to have normalized relations to begin with

    • @chillout914
      @chillout914 Před 5 dny +5

      @@thembastoep733 do you think that the saudis and the UAE will wait for the US ? they have alternative , the saudi and emiratis are done with this bs of war in the middle east it will not help their developpement second they found out that the israelis want just peace which is not bad !

    • @TechPrezz
      @TechPrezz Před 5 dny

      as if Israel wants Peace... Israel wants Piece of Lebanon, Piece of Jordan, Piece of Egypt and Piece of Syria... Greater Israel is their dream.... not Peace!!

    • @spinny1737
      @spinny1737 Před 5 dny +3

      @@chillout914 they need US support for the development ,because if the US refuse you then all the western countries will follow US

    • @LogicVsFacts
      @LogicVsFacts Před 5 dny +1

      ​@@chillout914Saudi and UAE both are vibrant Democracies 😅😅.

  • @user-hc8ki1rl4t
    @user-hc8ki1rl4t Před 5 dny +13

    The Palestinians are sick of Israel increasing global protein availability at a competitively affordable cost, lessening the burden of waterborne diseases in developing nations, reducing the use of chemical pesticides, improving energy generation, promoting species conservation, increasing efficiency of agricultural production; protecting plants and animals against biotic and abiotic stress; improving food quality, safety, and security; water quality and quantity; functional genomics and proteomics; sensors and robotics; and, sustainable bio-energy systems.

    • @edgeinscarride
      @edgeinscarride Před 4 dny +1

      Although you were fine with it when the Saudi’s murdered 500,000 Yemenis and have had little to no interest in the Arab North Sudanese prosecuting a genocide on the African South Sudanese. I think the obsession with Israel over all these other conflicts really comes down to one factor, and we all know what it is

  • @sarimansari1
    @sarimansari1 Před 2 dny +2

    Israel-hamas war?? its called israel genocide on palestine, get your terminology correct DW

    • @GG-un7hj
      @GG-un7hj Před dnem

      Since when is self-defense Genocide?
      If Hamas weren’t so cowardly to embed themselves with in the so called Palestinians, the casualties would be much less.
      Therefore Hamas not Israel is guilty of genocide, Hamas are cowards as we all know, Hamas is about death not Life, that’s all that they offer for ordinary so called “Palestinians “ since 1967.

  • @Jen-e-sis
    @Jen-e-sis Před 4 dny +1

    It’s about time someone begins defending the Palestinians if the world court Can’t

  • @ll-eb2rt
    @ll-eb2rt Před 5 dny +65

    The whole middle east is sick of Palestinians. 5 times they refused two state solutions and lost more land each time

    • @joexavier4070
      @joexavier4070 Před 5 dny +27

      Occupiers don't have any shame

    • @ll-eb2rt
      @ll-eb2rt Před 5 dny

      @@joexavier4070the whole Middle East occupied by non natives

    • @norman4588
      @norman4588 Před 5 dny +9

      ​@@joexavier4070
      The two states solution was recognize by the majority by the United Nations members including some Arab Countries.

    • @user-jt8vj1vm6y
      @user-jt8vj1vm6y Před 5 dny

      They weren't offered anything. Israel keeps taking and settling land then reverses roles and claims palestinians are refusing their own state.

    • @SssMmm-ve2eh
      @SssMmm-ve2eh Před 5 dny +4

      Keep you nose out of Arabic Affairs

  • @anismatar
    @anismatar Před 5 dny +4

    Looking again at US army training Shia militias in Iraq and telling them to fight and prevent Sunni regime like Saddam's to come back then depending on Sunni countries to defend Israel and prevent Shia from attacking it makes them look idiotic when looking at mirror 😂

    • @ahmedg9472
      @ahmedg9472 Před 5 dny

      Where can i read or watch about all that stuff?

    • @ahmedg9472
      @ahmedg9472 Před 5 dny

      Where can i read or watch about all that stuff?

    • @nuqwestr
      @nuqwestr Před 5 dny

      No, the shia/sunni schism is what is idiotic, and the internal schisms within both sunni and shia. the sunni and shia only have themselves to blame.

  • @ikids1108
    @ikids1108 Před 2 dny +1

    his sound looks like a monster

  • @yahaaghtv
    @yahaaghtv Před 4 dny +1

    That was fought for Israel. US, UK and France fought the war in Israeli military uniforms. My reason is that, if it was Israel that won the war against all the countries, why can't they repeat the same with Hezbollah?

  • @abdulrafay-rq1hm
    @abdulrafay-rq1hm Před 5 dny +51

    this a damn genocide

    • @OST1350
      @OST1350 Před 5 dny +5

      And so is the war in Ukraine

    • @skeletonking4119
      @skeletonking4119 Před 5 dny

      @@OST1350 take one of 100 years!! and we will talk!

    • @masabamutalechristopher6436
      @masabamutalechristopher6436 Před 5 dny +4

      ​@@skeletonking4119you were born yesterday. Many countries have suffered before and are still suffering under Russian occupation.

    • @vladkv4620
      @vladkv4620 Před dnem

      Holodomor ​@@skeletonking4119

  • @tebogopekane1418
    @tebogopekane1418 Před 4 dny +4

    Don't forget military aid.

  • @pavan9965
    @pavan9965 Před dnem

    It really amuses me how the geopolitics change enemies into friends and friends into enemies

  • @live_free_or_perish
    @live_free_or_perish Před 4 dny +1

    Interesting. Good content

  • @jh5174
    @jh5174 Před 5 dny +5

    There are many Arabs happily living as Israeli's.
    💝 x 120+ 🌿🕊️
    Weren't the conflicts about Israel defending itself?

    • @admar1208
      @admar1208 Před dnem

      how are they defending themselves if their the ones that invaded the ones defending themselves are the palestenians not the other way around.

  • @nesseihtgnay9419
    @nesseihtgnay9419 Před 5 dny +22

    Oh it goes far beyond 1947, it goes all the way to 1517

  • @iidkwhatnameuse
    @iidkwhatnameuse Před 2 dny

    TLDR: United States buys them out either directly or indirectly

  • @TryDotFulfill
    @TryDotFulfill Před 4 dny +2

    Because they are the sla'ves of ameri'can colonialism.

  • @hamzablilet5958
    @hamzablilet5958 Před 3 dny +6

    Morocco is not an arab nation , stop the discrimination

    • @allcatall3931
      @allcatall3931 Před 2 dny +1

      it depends what some mean, whether culturally, demographically, or both ('demographically', original arabs etc, claiming moroccan geography, similar to how other colonies worked, such as french, in seeking to swarm place with natives from elsewhere)..

    • @casanova8762
      @casanova8762 Před 2 dny +2

      it is

  • @thomasthomasphilp4393
    @thomasthomasphilp4393 Před 5 dny +14

    At 0:23 you see Palki Sharma from the FirstPost. She has become one of the best international journalists. If you want to get true news, watch her unbiased reporting

    • @gamingbuddy0074
      @gamingbuddy0074 Před 5 dny

      Unbiased reporting from Indian media? Nice joke, they are all puppets of Modi government

    • @troytroyland746
      @troytroyland746 Před 5 dny

      Palki Sharma is anti israel journalist

    • @lilocapitalT-ix4nz
      @lilocapitalT-ix4nz Před 5 dny +1

      Is it really unbiased? I used to watch her on wion but stopped because wion became biased

    • @thembastoep733
      @thembastoep733 Před 5 dny +1

      I like here a lot, but tbh she is biased against china

    • @thembastoep733
      @thembastoep733 Před 5 dny

      @@lilocapitalT-ix4nz You're right, no single news channel is really unbiased, afterall it carries the biases that the people who make it have, in the case of firstpost they are extremely pro india and anti-china, but then atleast they do say that this is news from an indian perspective. I also used to watch her on wion, I will say on first post its better they give more detail and wion, CNN or BBC do, they give some history while in those others they just say something short and start asking experts opinions which yourself you have ended up concluding.

  • @glako8740
    @glako8740 Před 3 dny +2

    Money money money...for the 1%

  • @hishamalaker491
    @hishamalaker491 Před 2 dny

    This is basically states vs the people.

  • @user-vu6hx2om6t
    @user-vu6hx2om6t Před 5 dny +8

    They understand the danger Iran & its proxies pose to the region.

    • @DaGoyDidGood
      @DaGoyDidGood Před 5 dny +1

      lol the danger is you people

    • @Yas-wu2oh
      @Yas-wu2oh Před 5 dny

      The danger is already happening by the west and the arab countries. Dont try to fool us.

    • @randomguy3496
      @randomguy3496 Před 3 dny +1

      ​@@DaGoyDidGood nah danger is ☪️ancer

  • @stonehorsegaming
    @stonehorsegaming Před 4 dny +11

    We were on the road to stability, but then Iran got involved.

    • @admar1208
      @admar1208 Před dnem

      there's no stability unless the palestenians get their right to statehood that's where the issue lies the arabs have been witnessing what has been happening to the palestinians for decades and they'll not remain silent about it.

  • @linguesta
    @linguesta Před 3 dny +1

    Ehhh I just want to highlight in 1965 it eas israel Britain and France who invaded egypt to take control of suez canal.

  • @zayedkhan1889
    @zayedkhan1889 Před 4 dny +1

    Arab states declared war,OTTOMON EMPIRE was GONE who was there to help arab, Arabs were french and British colonies ,palestine was under British mandate can people of palestine fight British who has won world war 1 ,2