REPOST: Palestinians: What do you think of Hamas? (filmed in 2013)
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 10. 2023
- HOW TO HELP
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
To donate to the project:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
WHAT IS THE ASK PROJECT?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
Do you want to know what Israelis and Palestinians really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers. All answers are from random people and all answers are included and unedited. The questions come from you, the viewers.
WHY DO I DO THIS?
▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀▀
See the following videos where I explain the background and goal of the project • The Ask Project interv...
Logic is necessary in order to avoid wars. But logic is hidden by fanaticism, hatred and greed.
Thank you so much, you're doing way more for the good of the world than any big media corporation
Mind Begs the Question:
If a Media
Interviews Israeli Moms
Censors plight of Palestinian Moms
Media - Fair or Propaganda Arm?
Agreed
How could someone think this? As a Jew I feel extreme sympathy for these people. This Corey reporter is wicked and biased in his reactions to these people who have lost everything. His translator purposely gets things wrong to make Palestinians seem aggressive. And he says people are lying during their own interviews! Corey has no self respect or respect for others clearly.
@@saltybrackishfresh Why? It seemed very unbiased to me
@@viperking6573 go look at the difference between what the palestianians said and what his translator said.
Then research Albert Pike “3 world wars”
He’s a 33rd degree Freemason and Multi billionaire in todays standards. And he describes all 3 world wars including the conflict that began the 3rd a few days ago.
With this context you will be able to understand why the Palestinian people deserve empathy and freedom from Colonial Occupation. The occupation of Palestine is a repeat of how American slavery was justified and basically all colonialism. I usually disagree heavily with ultra liberals, but they are right for once about this
"Suicide bombings are wrong because suicide is forbidden in Islam" lmao
Whats wrong with this statement?
@@Mrstan45 The statement itself is probably factually true, but if you think blowing up people is bad because you kill yourself in the process, then there's definitely something wrong with your moral compass
@@Mrstan45don’t interact with this idiot
@@Mrstan45 This answer indicates that her problem with a suicide bomber is with the terrorist killing himself and not with the terrorist killing innocent Israelis
@@Odrd1009 Not just that, but shes letting that evil book dictate her own morals. Since Islam is immoral, hence immoral Muslims.
Everyone seems so calm and pleasant speaking with each other. Certainly not as though they've been engaged in a violent 70+ year long existential conflict with each other. I've seen football fans worse than this.
it is because pro palis take things out of context, share it using misinformation and they all buy it up because they are allergic to doing their own research. just wanted to add this is their one chance to be publicly anti semitic so they jump on it.
That's what I thought when they came in on flying chutes oct. 7th...............
Conflict is all they know.
@jordandale85 that's why no one will take them into THEIR country !
This is being recorded in the West Bank not the Gaza Strip so questions towards Hamas don’t directly affect them. Also, how could you assess their daily lives from an interview in the first place? Believe it or not there have been quiet years over the 70+ year conflict which doesn’t inform the overarching conflict. If the questions in this video were about what are the struggles you face as a Palestinian living under Israeli occupation I’m sure they’d have a long list.
In 11:37 he translated mukawamah word to “violent struggle” but in fact it only means in Arabic “resistance”
True
He restated the question right afterwards and she clarified that she supported violent resistance. She wasn't sure if she felt that only against soldiers or even civilians, she said she guessed only soldiers.
@@BK-bs2eb they only said مقاومة which means resistance
@BK-bs2eb she said "maybe army" but if you already are not sure what the person is asking it's hard to answer correctly. Will give the interviewer a break though because he probably didn't understand what she said either.
Our depends on who is saying it and context. They were talking about the "violent struggle" so it makes more sense
Important notes to put into context:
This is filmed in the West Bank, where Israel (with minimal co-operation of the Palestinian Authority) has control, and because of that control Hamas doesn't rise and take over the West Bank like they did in Gaza.
In the West Bank there are more (or equal, depends on different polls and different times) Hamas supporters than PA supporters, basicaly a bad option and a worse option.
Corey films his videos in areas where he is safe to do so, where generally support for Hamas is not as big. There are many areas in the West Bank that Corey rarely enters, and wouldn't dare ask a controversial questions while there, where Hamas is emphatically admired and pro-Hamas terror cells emerged. For example Jenin Brigades, The Lion's Den, all operating in Jenin a very large city where the Palestinian Authority doesn't have any control or power, and it is used as a Hamas headquarters in the West Bank.
Despite the bloody rivalry between Hamas and the PA, there are no ordinary Palestinians actively acting against Hamas. The PA struggles to deny them control over Ramallah and parts of Bethlehem and some other places, but in most of the West Bank no Palestinian would dare act against Hamas.
When Hamas took over Gaza in ~2007, they did so through murdering PA members, resulting in hundreds of dead including women and children in a very brief period. Ismail Hania one of Hamas's leaders, is notorious for tracking PA members who dared co-operate with Israel, torturing and killing them brutally.
Corey published a video last year where he interviewed people in Jenin, called "Why are there refugee camps in Palestine?" Search his channel for "Jenin" and there will be many hits.
It is true that it is difficult for Corey to go to Gaza, and quite possibly unsafe. It is relatively safer in the West Bank.
@@skoosharama "many areas in the West Bank that Corey would never dare enter, much less ask controversial questions"
If you watch Corey's videos you will rarely see interviews from within Jenin. Corey knows that asking the wrong questions in Jenin could have deadly results, so on the rare occasion he did go in there, the questions will have no controversial connotations. He also talks about it occasionaly in his videos.
Still, "would never" is an exaggeration so I edited it.
@@YotamAlbalach sir if you truly want peace, then you would become a believer in YESHUA HA MASHIACH (IE Jesus THE MESSIAH/CHRIST) then you will have peace in your heart and forgive your neighbor no matter what they have done to you (their judgment is in GOD'S HANDS) and to pray for your enemies. this is how to Truly bring peace in Israel; "to not be overcome with evil but to overcome evil by doing good (to them)" but it can only Truly come about by more and more people becoming believers in YESHUA HA MASHIACH that transforms hearts when we believe in HIM
thanks a lot for the context
@@jasonkemmerer5654 muslim already believe that isa is messiah what you saying ?
Thanks so much for sharing this. It's really admirable that you did
„Take the worst thing you can about Hamas multiply it by a thousand times and it still will not meet the Israeli repression and mass killing and dispossession
of Palestinians.“ - Gabor Mate Holocaust Survivor
YES!!! THANK U! I know i have watched this video some years ago, thank you for reuploading this. The world needs to hear this!!
This is filmed in West Bank not Gaza Strip
Oh you know West Bank have resistance fighters that are fighting with Hamas against idf you do know that right
It's really heartbreaking to see this video. In this world good people never win.
No, good People always win.
@@123_Soleil are you two slow or what? the world isn't divided in a dichotomy of good and evil, but that is too complex for you people to understand
@@jodawgsupThe world is frequently divided into good and evil, simple and complex, intelligent and unintelligent. Predication comes naturally to most people.
@@123_Soleil Only the majority and the strong win. Sry, its the way of nature.
@@analemma.inflection if you don't mind my two cents sir, i would tell you that this is the condition of this fallen world since it fell in The Garden of Eden and the only way to restore what was lost is by more and more people become believers in YESHUA HA MASHIACH (IE Jesus THE MESSIAH/CHRIST) that HE IS GOD, HE became A Man and died to make The Final Atonement for our sins, and 3 days later HE rose from the dead. it is only through this faith in CHRIST that transforms lives and hearts from hating one another to Truly loving one another; this is The Only Way for there to be Truly peace in Israel or anywhere else and this faith is what restores us back to The Perfect relationship with GOD before the fall in The Garden of Eden
In the interview with the girl in minute 11.20 you mistranslated Mokawma ¨مقاومة¨ which means ¨resistance¨ not ¨violent struggle¨.
She said she supports resistance not violence/violent struggle like the subtitles imply.
100% misleading. Mokawma means resistance in a (defensive way). The correct interpretation as an Arabic speaker. When they say Resistance (Mokawma)it means resistance from an unjust aggression and not as aggressors
This needs to be seen more. I shared this in twitter
X
@@GhostPanther_XI hope Elon dick rides for you like you do him 😅
11:34 she only said “Mukawma” which means “resistance” so when you translate it in the subtitle, you should translate it as it is without adding the word “violent” next to it.
Yes it means handing candy to non muz linz......
This guy doesn’t even try to hide his bias
She doesn't mean that Palestinians are going to do spoken word as resistance lol
This channel is clearly biased
@@justinstewart4889And you know that how exactly? To resist can mean many things… resistance in defense, resistance in protesting, resistance in creating media content, and the list goes on. It doesn’t have to be violent.
Since the Hamas taken over of the Gaza, more than $30bn has been donated to the Palestinians in Gaza from around the world, and if those money were being used to develop the Gaza's land instead of building tunnels and manufacturing rockets; Gaza wouldn't have been the open prison as they're calling it and also, the Palestinians wouldn't have had any needs of Israelis passage, for them to be free people.
To buy what? You know Israel continues to manage what gets inside and what doesn’t.
Besides a genuine question, would Israel want a state of Gaza that is strong and industrious as you have mentioned?
There is a huge hatred goes for both ways, Israel can not step back, they wouldn’t want a Gaza that is strong. because they know they are the ones who nourished the Terror in Palestine for years. And If There were to be a peaceful Gaza. They will attack Israel immediately.
If we were to ask them would they agree on Palestinian(Arabic and Islamic) elements to be removed from Israel?
They are planning to forcefully migrate the people in Gaza to south. Even Sinai desert(It was an Israeli official who stated this).
Everyone have free will but Israel bombing Gaza, killing civillians(even if they hide terrorists behind them) is going to do no help but to create a shithole inside Israel
and Egypt, please don't forget that Egypt is particiipating in the Blockade as well, because they also don't want to deal with Gaza terrorism
Israel controls the borders you idiot they can't move or do anything they control the water, electricity and the boarder so if they send 500 million it is still the same.
they're not allowed to built anything. israel controls the land. no imports except through Israel, no ports allowed, no airports, no infrastructure except that which Israel provides. stop the bs
Development for whome? 70% population in Gaza are refugees... their mission is to go home and live with dignity.
Give that 20 billion dollars to those settlers to go back to America/Germany/Ukraine.
Build some logic bro
I hope your channel grows.
Lots has changed these 10 years globally. The good people of the world have been silenced by the screamers and social media. I will always believe in the good no matter what. Love to my Arab brothers and sisters who agree
So true. Peace.
@@telleva7890people define “crime” in different ways and this is a problem I think. It’s clear that for Palestinians what happened on Oct 7 was not a crime - to kill children and women brutally…mind-blowing
@@Nicole-cf3kjthere is no sane palestinian that have said that, social media is actuall showing how legacy media is making lies
@@Nicole-cf3kj Would be interesting to see, if you think like that if that kind of suffering is inflicted on you. The kind of suffering that has been inflicted on the palestinians for many decades now. Its very understandable, that they loose hope for a peaceful solution. Doesnt mean that they condone killing children and women. Most people in Gaza lost family members or friends by the way. Many if not most of them children and women.
On average a 100 palestinian children were killed every year the past decades. People have a right to hate the people who destroy their lives. The slaves in the US had that right, the black people in apartheid south africa had that right, the jews in nazi germany had that right. And the palestinians have that right too. Lets not have double standards here.
And we now know in 2023 that the Israelis are the scammers of the traditional media and their true evil ways are being exposed on social media
Thank you very much again Corey for your work, you are doing more for peace than anyone I've seen on youtube. And watching those old videos reminds me how much better your translator got.
Describe how he is doing more for ‘peace’? What’s peace to you? Israel continuing to control Palestinian Territories while expanding their settlements and crushing resistance?
@@BohoBeads While I understand your point and maybe frustration, what I meant was the prospect of peace. While many people are locked in looking at the past or only blamig the other side; this kind of videos show the nuances, which are often hidden from the eye of the public on the other side. My hope is that by listening, maybe the next generation might have a better grasp and solution, without humiliation, military occupation and blame.
@@Physiker17 You don’t achieve peace by simply holding hands and listening to each other. That’s naiive, at best. And also coming from a place where you haven’t experienced being colonized or oppressed. Do you really think Israel has any interest in listening to Palestinians let alone anyone? The millions of people calling for a ceasefire? The many leaders and humans rights organizations who have called Israel an illegal occupation on most of the lands it controls? How is Hamas a terrorist organization, while the IDF gets to torture, imprisons and kill Palestinians senselessly? Do you really think someone who interviews a handful of Palestinians can give you a full idea of the Palestinian experience and what it means to accomplish peace, when there’s no context to why there is a Hamas in the first place. I’m not dismissing your wish for peace - that should be all work towards. I just wish it was easier for people in the West to understand that we won’t just sit and accept peace on their terms and definitions.
@@BohoBeads True and I agree with you to some extent. But also don't assume my background because of my views. I lived in South Lebanon for 10 years and have family there, I experienced Israeli bombardements first hand, although not to the extend of the people in Gaza of course. Also don't assume that Israel is a homogenous monolith with a single opinion on the matter. Besides the point of those videos is not to give you neither the full Palestinian nor the full Israeli experience, is to give you an insight. The balance of power is much heavier on the Israeli side, which makes peace for their government superfluous but it is not a given that this will stay this way for ever, I just hope soon enough. The noble goal of peace is a challenge, we should all get better to achieve it, but holding to grudges and anger is not helping. I am not saying I don't understand your anger or frustration, I am saying holding so tight to it, won't change anything in the long term.
@@Physiker17I agree with you about grudges, but I do believe anger is not always unhealthy. Anger is far better than apathy. I’m sorry I assumed your origins and I can’t imagine what living in South Lebanon must have been like. I’m also aware that not all Israelis support this government or war. But is that enough? A good example is my home country Sri Lanka, where we have been ruled by nationalists who belong to the major demographic since we gained Independence: Sinhala Buddhist. We had a civil war for 30 years between the government and a militant group that was fighting for a separate homeland for Tamils, a minority ethnic group. Many Sinhalese voted in these leaders as long as it meant their supremacy was guaranteed. But last year, when our economy crashed and we didn’t have electricity or fuel and ran out of everything from paper to medicine and everyone regardless of race or religion was affected, the public decided to open their eyes finally to the corruption and oppression, which led to riots and the president being ousted. But this didn’t come with liberation for minority Tamils and Muslims, the latter whom were the targets for scapegoating in the years after the war. Freedom for the majority has always meant freedom for just them, not the oppressed. This is what I’ve seen and heard from most Israelis today: against a right wing government to protect their own freedoms but how many of them are protesting the illegal settlements? How many are protesting children being bombed? How many of them have not centered their anti government protests on the safe return of hostages? A handful of activists don’t count. Jews living outside Israel have shown far more solidarity and compassion. Which is why I’m not sure peace can only be achieved by either the Netanyahu regime or Hamas falling. It has to come from Israelis first viewing Palestinians as equals, deserving of their liberation, lands and dignity. This is why the Palestinian resistance is so symbolic for oppressed groups living around the world. Sorry this is long lol.
I’ve been watching some of your videos and I’m finding the Palestinians on this video a lot more for peace than the other videos.
I think is because this was on the West Bank.
@@EfeGarza Pretty sure all his videos are either in Israel or the West Bank.
That was back when Israel was less offensive, and settlements were to some point slowed down. Peace really works with Palestinians, Israeli governments don't believe in it.
This was definitely a more peaceful time in their history, a lot of the violence had subsided and generally the Israeli government started to be more accepting of the Palestinians and giving them IDs in their country (not full citizens or rights though), that's why you hear that one guy say the bombings of busses and stuff is no more because really there is a massive imbalance in power and the efforts to incorporate Palestinians into Israeli society gave some people hope and a way out from the endless cycle of violence. However ever since Netenyahu was re-elected the settlements program was funded far more heavily and the general life of Palestinians started being squeezed tight again. Especially considering one of the people in Netenyahu's cabinet, Ben Gvir had Goldstein's picture (the guy responsible for the 1994 Hebron massacre) in his house before being elected, not exactly someone who would see Palestinians anything less than a subjected people, and he's in charge of National Security.
@@EfeGarzago and see what are they doing now in the west bank even there's not H@mmas.. It's all a big lie and propaganda.
Most people want the same things! Safety, health, family and good pay! War only creates suffering on all sides!
Exactly. Israeli and Palestinians are failed by their governments , i wish people unite to fight the system
Thank you for your such videos
Thank you for reposting this❤
What they seem unwilling to say on camera is telling too.
It’s so sad to think about these everyday people being out there right now. Sending prayers.
Your prayers are useless.
@@busterbiloxi3833 thanks for your feedback. I can understand you’re emotional right now. I wasn’t sending them to be useful. I was sending them because that’s all I have.
@idontknowhowigothere33 , wear black pants and pee in them. No one will notice , but you will get a warm feeling anyway. :)
@@MississippiWildlife sounds like you’re talking from experience. Tell me more. Why do they have to be black? Do you only do it when you’re at a funeral? If I wanted to be warmer, why wouldn’t I just put more layers on like a normal person rather than pissing my own pants in public?
These people are from the West Bank so they are safe :) ❤
legend has it that some people still believe this started on oct 7th 2024 to this day
Thanks for reposting.
A little nitpick, at 11:37 Muqawama means RESISTANCE and not VIOLENT STRUGGLE, even if it implies the latter. Also the second time you added the VIOLENT, which once again is not what she said, she just said "resistance".
Peace and love from Italy to the whole world.
Grazie ❤
Hi Corey, I think someone added a subtitle which says some stuff I don't think you'd want there. You might wanna check that out.
You have a good way of reminding people of the facts
I hope everyone in this video is OK 😢 God bless everyone
This is in the West Bank, so everyone is fine :)
@@Liveloud4Himwell… israel has captured and killed many hundreds of palestinians in the west bank. don’t forget.
2,000 palestinians just this month were arrested and more than 150 people killed so west bank is not fine at all @@Liveloud4Him
@@Liveloud4HimIsrael is Bombing there too wtf are u talking about
@@Liveloud4Him not in the refugee camps
Gaza strip has two impermeable borders, not just one. But no one speaks of Egypt here. Is what’s allowed to Egypt not allowed to Israel?
well i hope u understand the difference between a border and a WALL, check the map once more, also they can enter egypt if they want too, many Palestinains live in Egypt for fact.
@@mr_cod3 I meant more the free commercial possibilities. Also, if it is so easy to enter Egypt as you say, then the term “concentration camp” or “jail” is most definitely not applicable.
@@user-kn9qc9lp8u i said they can, the borders from Palestine is controlled by Israel in fact so they can't cross from that side. So technically they can't without some negotiation from both sides
@@mr_cod3 here we come back to my first comment
I love these videos so much.
In 11:34 the girl said مقاومة moqawama = resistance. It does not mean “violent struggle”. You made them seem like they support violence. There is a big difference between violent struggle and resistance. They are struggling from unjust acts of oppression, so they need to resist against it.
You did a nice job, but not always asked specific questions related to HAMAS's targets of violence.
He did same to Israeli side as well.. it’s a raw report
15:38 the Palestinians comment here is kind of filly because if you dig in the ground he’s on you’ll find Jewish/hebrew artifacts showing that they were there and Palestine is a relatively new country to make comparisons to China
Overall people seemed more reasonable and open to compromise (eg two state solution, no violence targeting civilians) ten years ago than today. It's very sad.
Why not a one-state solution though..?
Segregation and apartheid has never worked.
There are many on both sides who would love a one-state solution - for one people.@@velvetunderpants44
@@velvetunderpants44 I think that could work if Palestinians would except a nation of Israel, where they were legal residence, not citizens, and there was no right to return because otherwise you have a Jewish homeland and a right to return for an endless stream of Arabs, who you would have enormous difficulty distinguishing as necessarily an Arab of Palestinian dissent. Rate of return opens it to everyone.
@@velvetunderpants44 no to be clear I do not believe the Palestinians would ever accept that as a legitimate solution, even though their quality of life would be dramatically improved
@@Whoknowsme007 It's not the Palestinians who wouldn't accept these proposals it's the Zionists, who actually sponsor Hamas, that wouldn't. Why would they when they have the power to take more land and expand settlements? This violence has all been fomented by Israel and its disgusting treatment of the Palestinians which actually destabilizes the region and makes civilians on both sides less safe. Ironic how people treated so horribly by the Nazis have adopted their methods, all be it slower to keep the global community placated as much as possible.
Do you see how uncomfortable this question is for them? All the evasive answers scare me. It seems to me that they don't want to say what they really think.
Yeah..it seems like they support hamas silently..but dont want get the consequences of their chosen leader..
Seems like dont want to pay for what they bought to believe..
@@MalistaChristy what are you talking about lol.
they dont wanna talk badly about hamas because they dont wanna be with israel against palestinians. its like betraying their own people
It seen to me that they don't want to totally support hamas in front of cameras to not be assigned as terrorists. But it is possible to see in their eyes that they approve hamas.
They can’t. Go ask the chinese in china, the Koreans in North Korea. You will get the same face
@@albertobenevenuto77
So you want them to see Hamas as the US people see them? Or from a European perspective? LOL. Bro, these people live under oppression for decades. An oppression you know nothing about and you never can understand. People in the West Bank don't like Hamas, that's why they didn't vote for them in the very most times. But also they are aware that if there's no oppression, there wouldn't be Hamas. And yes they can stand with Hamas in the West Bank it's not illegal actually.
I'm struck by how many of the respondents' first comment is 'They are Palestinians". Is this an indication of tribal loyalty - that their affiliation is the most important thing about them?
90% of hamas comprise of children orphaned by IDF. Ofcourse they are palestinians and they have right to resist too
As a Muslim who has met many Palestinians and arabs from other nations, also lived in Egypt for a time, yes that is exactly what they are getting at.
However, the flip side of it is never thought of. "they are Palestinian" indicates an allegiance, however, when the bombs drop and/or rounds fly they are innocent from firing missiles or rockets so they should not be held accountable for hamas' crimes.
And this blind allegiance comes from a desire to survive!!
On the other hand, in america we pledge allegiance to a flag and thereby pledge our loyalty to our constitution (and government system) in school every day. INSANE!!!
@@robertgooding6925 Of course you're right, but then in any war it's first the civilians who have to pay for the nonsense of their governments. It's tragic indeed, but nothing really new.
How about ask them , what does Hamas spend the money that comes in.
Also, can you please ask about the settlements. We know that they are taking possession of Palestinian homes. I’m not pro Hamas but I want Netanyahu to pay for what he has caused here . I am pro Israel but Netanyahu is a right wing fascist. He and his radical government are responsible for this. I’m sorry, I know that Democracy cannot flourish while Islam has power. Look at the facts.
Only in America, where they have no power at all, can Muslims live in peace and prosperity . Ok
Keeping in mind that the evangelicals are trying to turn America into a theocracy. But so far we keep the fight against them going.
Oh btw, I’m an Athiest
What exactly Hamas gonna do with money? Built water infrastructure? Didn’t get permission from Israel gov. Build school and improve education system? Not allowed. Start a business? Border don’t allow any export import? So what exactly you want them to do with money?
@@jeffScotty
The settlements doesn't take palestines's homes but build new settlements on a land that belongs to Israel according to Oslo.
@@shahlakhan2
They got water and food supply from Israel all this time even when they fired thousands of rockets on Israel, that stopped in the beginning of this war only. hamas could develop their own infrastructure but they only attacked Israel. The more they attacked Israel through the years the more things Israel cancelled for them not the opposite.
@@y.l7455 Israel ramps up demolition of Palestinian homes in Jerusalem.Settlement Expansion in Occupied Palestinian Territory Violates International Law, Must Cease, Many Delegates Tell Security Council
So sad to watch this in the mirror of what is happening today... Hope of peace vanished for a while I'm afraid...
Jack in the video knows that the Quran says to judge their ways in according to the Bible and Torah. Meaning to refer to the book, but not many actually read the Torah/Bible before
May God protect all these people who speak on Camera!
These videos are really good, watched and liked a lot of them included questions to Isrealis and your neutrality in the way of asking questions.
Why the double layer of subtitles during the interview with the man starting at minute 3:00 when he is speaking in English and easy to understand ?
There are the original words that he's saying (in white writing). But there is another 'narrative' if you like, transposed on top in a different font, also in English (white lettering on black background) which gives a different account. It appears almost as if the text on top is saying something different which someone else wants us to hear? This begins at 4:02
This is extremely annoying! Who wrote this nonsense? I want to hear what the man is saying without being distracted by the other words written on top which are not his words.
I am very puzzled.
why does youtube give completely different subtitles from what is being said
12:51 "No other nation who is occupied other than us the Palestinians" IDK.. I think many minorities around the world disagree with that statement X:
Edit: ok Corey corrected him later lol
Apparently that guy has never heard of Tibbet.
Germany is still occupied too.
@@burnin8orable tibet or american indian were given citizenship and treated equal.. in one nation..
Compare that to palestine
Isn’t Kashmir occupied as well?
Not the same at all,Palestine was a well existing country, and surely Palestinians weren't a minority, the zionists came and wanted to appropriate the land and did eventually, and as the gentleman said they're working on expanding more and more. For Those cited cities~they were parts of those countries and wanted independence, they could've fight for it if they wanted. Now,if Palestinians preferred to gain back their country ,they have the full right to,that shouldn't be seen as illegitimate . And if the adversary seems to understand only one language, let it be spoken.
Isn't a positive answer to that question basically illegal? So I don't get the question, as long as you film them answering it.
Great conversation..
Aiman speaks his heart out.
❤
Agreed, I hope he’s ok 😢
I wish people would not just appeal to religion for morality and actually take a stance and defend it based on what they think is right or wrong.
You are drinking something.. sorry to be blunt
This is the point of any religion - if you're religious, you must follow the holly statements and always appeal to it, because it is the believing that the god gave you these statements because he knows better than you what is good for you, because you're not able to understand these things due to the limitations of the nature of human being. It is not fixable, because it is the base on which the religion is built. Without this base there will no religion - kind of "imagine" by J.Lenon.
Many people feel safe with religion.
When in fact they should think deep about these things themselves instead of depending on dusty old books.
Which is a madness in itself. Referring to a book written by people, many hundreds years ago , and they let the authority come from people they don't even know/knew.
They drive cars, use smartphones, yet at the same time, regarding spiritual matters, they lean on a very old book.
Such dependent behavior .
Be like a scientist. Do some thinking for yourself.
To me, religions are the same as a sect. The fact that hundred of millions are followers doesn't make it more valid.
czcams.com/video/Cj8n4MfhjUc/video.html
😁😉
There is no true basis of what is wrong and what is right without God. God decides what is wrong and right.
Many of these people don't believe there's right or wrong without religion -it's very scary.
Notice how the guy at 4:10 talks about Israel “killing everything” … this was 10 years ago.. it didn’t start on the 7th
Such a heartbreaking video
כאן אתה מזהה שכולם חמאס. אין הבדל
Suicide is immoral but murder isn't. Excellent psycho lady 👍👍
So you're saying all the Israeli killing of Palestinians is immoral?
Her husband literally said afterwards that Islam doesn't even allow us to cut a tree, let alone kill civilians and kids. Pay some attention
@@meco4068 no. It's self defence and standing up against hooligans
@@happylucky7354 Self-defence 😆
The world is beginning to see who the real hooligans are and it's not the Palestinians.
so when palestinian killed israeli it’s terrorism but when israeli killed palestinian it’s “self defense” lol the double standard 🙄
Q: Are you against suicide bombing?
A: Yes I am against suicide
😂😂
This guy knows how to trickily get some answers that the interviewees would have dodged or answered hesitatingly.
"They dont feel no connection...."
As a person whose family member was ON one of those buses, I can tell you that WE still care!
And how is that guy responsible for what happened??? That's like if we Americans banned all Arabs from our country or made them get permits because of 9/11. Give me a break with your racism.
I'm sorry for your loss. Be safe!
@@alizard9228how is Israel supposed to tell who is a good guy or not?! Also Arab citizens have equal rights. The Arabs who need permits to enter Israel are those from the territories coming into Israel. The fact is that if Israel is expected to create a “Palestinian” state (which I oppose), isn’t it hypocritical for them to also have unlimited access to Israel?! But in any case, when the PA and Hamas are promoting jihadist terrorism and when we see a history of deadly terrorism including suicide bombings, it’s not racist to protect yourself. The security restrictions become necessary including the need for permits. This has zero to do with racism, considering the fact that Arabs Israelis have equal rights and don’t need permits. Also Israel did issue more permits for Gazan labourers to work in the kibbutzim near the border Gaza. And plenty of them worked as spies for Hamas and aided Hamas in the brutal massacres of October 7. The fact that you turn this into some self-righteous rhetoric about racism shows how ignorant you are.
Interviewer was not able to admit that the illegal settlements are a huge issue and are completely connected with the whole problem.
They defiently increased the terror atacks but the plo was created before isreal buipt any settelment and even before isreal stole land palestinians were atacking jews
Israel never stole any land or started any war you need a history book
The gentleman at 2:30 is a gem. Also, major props to the brave man at 18:00 voicing displeasure at the other Arab countries for not helping in the struggle with Israel.
Yes 1:48 guy knows what's up
they also know that every arabic state that tried to help Palestinian refugees only got terror cells in them.
in jordan, egypt and syria, most of the Palestinians were massacred (as is the way of the middle east). read about the black September and similar events.
it became known that gazans are a pressure pot of terrorism.
The guy at 18:00 is wrong though. The Arab leaders did indeed try to help him, they invaded in 1948 and again in 1967. They did try, but they lost. Too bad for him I guess.
What about the Palestinian peoples struggle against Hamas and terrorist government leaders in general within the Arab world ? What of that? Is it inconsequential? You only mention their: "struggle with Israel." Who I might point out is currently LIBERATING them from Hamas. Which would have occured REGARDLESS of the October 7th hostages that were taken. Is that going to be condemned (as in Israel being condemned) by the Palestinians as well? I think not, because we're starting to see the Gazan Palestinians reaction towards Hamas and it's one of OUTRAGE. Which, is EXACTLY what it should be.
I mean, that's a blatent lie. in 1948 war Israel was against all 4 Arab countries surrounding it plus militias from Saudia, Iraq, Yemen so on. 56 again, 67 again, 73 against Egypt and Syria, Israel still gets bombarded from Lebanon. he's not brave he's a moron. the first sentence he says he's pro all violence in the struggle second second he wants peace. he says it's okay for china to torture other people because China is old lol the guy is not the sharpest tool in the shed.
You know most of these people cant speak their full truth because their lives will be in danger.
People in other dangerous situations have spoken up. People can make anonymous videos. People can talk to journalists and say don't identify me but tell everyone this is what we believe. But nobody is doing this.
@@binabina4445 I'm pretty sure he was only talking about this particular video. They might being holding back, given the current situation and the fact that they're on camera. That being said, there are tons and tons of Palestinian people who have spoken out if you're willing to read it. The issue with your comment is what you want is for Palestinians to speak out & give your version of their reality, and if they don't, you can't be bothered.
Doesn't mean everyone can take the same risks. Not everyone can make such videos or talk to journalists (some have if you know how to look for them) so you're wrong that 'nobody is doing this" @@binabina4445
They live in the West Bank where the influence of Hamas is not as strong. Otherwise they would hardly find any interviewee who is willing to criticize them at all.
@@meco4068go to Gaza Strip and ask the questions this is West Bank a lot of different between West Bank and Gaza Strip
Id be very curious to see this question asked today
I live in the uk, i can't leave without my passport, should i call it a prison ? Ridiculous.
All people living in Africa etc have it hard to leave their countries, it is not just them
Well obviously whoever doesn't like what Hamas is doing, are afraid to talk freely about it.
The others instantly loose their line of thought as soon as the conversation turns into a logic discussion. How is that they can't see any connection between bombings and Israelis being super cautious? I mean would you let your neighbor into your house if there was even a slightest chance of him harming you or your family?!
It's unfortunate that all those years have passed and they're still sayin that they're hoping for peace, but they sure do support their terrorist silently or vocally, it doesn't really matter.
The allies didn't ask the Germans one by one whether they supported Hitler since it would be kind of absurd back at WW2.
Stolen land.... 1948 nakba, It's clear who the criminals are...
@@WSmith_1984U should educate yourself in a subject before coment it. So then u would know that this thing about stolen land is a big lie.
@@albertobenevenuto77 is this one sufficient starting material, based on a thesis written by an Israelli Scholar as i remember. czcams.com/video/HNtrUjUNkJw/video.htmlsi=r6JGcsOxGaOxSgAX
@@albertobenevenuto77 Here are some quotes from how you won this land "fair and square"
1. "Tantura was a wealthy town, it had beautiful houses. They were living like Europeans, do you understand? The women of the town used to wear beautiful clothes. Really this town.... One of the soldiers raped a 16-year old girl here."
2. "He gathered the Palestinians and put them in a cage and killed them. He gathered them in a cage made of iron, and surrounded them with iron wires. He gathered all the men and made them sit down. One of the soldiers took the machine gun and shot them."
3. "The soldiers took flamethrowers in their hands, chased the villages, and set them on fire."
4. "I never took prisoners, I killed everyone. When someone raised their hands in the war, I didn't take them as a prisoner of war. In those days, if I even saw school children with their hands raised, I would kill them."
5. "I had a total of 250 bullets in my weapon. I fired and killed everyone. It's impossible for me to count how many people I've killed."
@@WSmith_1984 Of course it is clear. The crazy islamic terrorists.
"There's no reason" for israel to require a permit to cross the border.
Well that didnt age well.
It actually did. It explains how things got to the point where they are.
Egypt too. and i jordan has some trouble in the past. the Gaza will have to find different way out
They literally had to take down the fences of their prison. Who is to live encaged unjustly? And you don't want any resistance? Palestinians live completely opressed. They are very pacific for what they endure.
US citizens need a passport to cross into neighboring countries. We need permits for things in US. All these things don't rationalize Oct. 7.
@@CarlaLuciana-sk6by walls and checkpoints weren't always there. Israelis installed them after.suicide bombings from Palestine.
What would you expect?
That man in the shop is wise. Bless him.
Why does closed captioning have different words? Is it translating differently or hacked?
Honestly, I am wondering what Hamas budget looks like
Nate Diaz once said : "Im not suprised , MF's"
Can you make sure the captions are accurate please!
this channel should be famous with all the expert middle east opinologist in the internet
It's funny that the one man said that 1990s have nothing to do with what's going on Today, but in Fact it has everything to do with what's taking place today. Hamas should have been stopped in the 1990s by the Palestinian People and Imagine the Life they would have had because it would have been TWO STATES would have been no more land claims no more conflicts but because of one group now we have a lot of lives lost of both sides and HAMAS IS TO BLAME!!!
These people live with Hamas and are completely clueless about them.
No way! You're telling me Palestinians in the West Bank, giving opinions about Hamas which only operates in Gaza, are clueless? Especially since it's hard to navigate within the two territories??
Hamas isn’t in the West Bank dumbass
I hope the good ones in this interviews are still alive 🙏🏻
Can you go out and make some interviews rn in the current situation?
Yeah and go in to Gaza Strip this time because this is West Bank
Gaza a Big prison....
1.Gaza has a border with egypt
2. Thousands of people from Gaza everyday Come to work in israel
3. In a prison you dont farm
4. In a prison you dont have roquets
5. In a prison you dont have freely use of water/electricity/gaz/other
6. In a prison you dont see your wife and family freely
7. In a prison you dont build building
8 in a prison you dont open restaurants/shops/others
9. In a prison you dont have the beach and the sea.
10. In a prison you dont have football and sports stadium.
11. In a prison you dont have Access to cinéma/theather/ TV channels .
Its enough?
You cant enter israel freely.
Good morning there IS a name for this "border".
Its a common thing between nation...
Really? Are you blind? What does free Palestine means to you? Millions of Palestine can’t even live there life with freedom. All this innocent lives that been taken away means nothing to you?
You know nothing about prisons. Half the things you said people do have in prison.
Debunking your lies
1.Gaza has only one crossing with Egypt "Rafah" and Israel controls that basically!
2.the poor workers are now being investigated with mild torture
3.In prison you are provided with food directly, so what's the point here?
4.Sure in prison you don't have rockets but they don't bomb you either in the prison!
5.We saw how "freely" they can get water and electricity when the jailers want to take them down!
6.in prison you don't see your family, unless they live with you in the same cell which is Gaza!
7. In prison the buildings are already built ..but they have to build them only to be bombed into ashes later
...etc
@@shahlakhan2
They voted for hamas themselves. Their freedom and they decided to use it to attack Israel. Israel also has the freedom to defend itself.
@@MauriTech-xq1sk
1. Egypt controlling the Rafah crossing and it's still doesn't want to let the palestines escape from Gaza.
2. No one torture the palestines that worked in Israel. They worked there. Tho, they would definitely not work in Israel again.
3. Don't bite the hand that feeds you and expect lately that you would get food again.
4. Israel bombs Gaza only as a response to hamas and the islamic jihad aggression. If they didn't attack Israel - Israel would not attack them back.
5. Don't attack Israel and take hostages and then expect Israel to provide you something. Beside, while they seem to be run out of water and food they still have thousands of rockets. They got billions of aid in the last 15+ years and now we clearly see on what they used these money.
6. If by attacking your enemy you know your family would be in danger - why attack? And if you attacked - why are you suddenly remember your family only now.
7. Don't fire rockets from building if you don't wnat those buildings to be destroyed.
@11:34 and @11:54 she just said "resistance" .. I don't know why is ur captions saying "violent struggle" it needs to be corrected
Is there Hamas in West bank also? What's the reason of tension in that part as well ?? Curious!!
When Israel left southern Lebanon in the 1980’s, it created Hezbollah, and when they left Gaza in 2005, it led to the rise of Hamas. Israel has very legitimate concerns to believe that if they de-occupied the West Bank, the West Bank which is a gigantic piece of land that can be seen from Tel-Aviv would turn into another region for Pro-Palestinians terrorists to operate.
So Hamas isn’t in control of the West Bank, but Israel is currently occupying the West Bank in an attempt to crush any possibility of Hamas, or any other Palestinian terrorist from taking over and becoming a severe threat to innocent Israeli’s living in Israel.
As a result, it has caused severe suffering in the West Bank that has forced innocent Palestinians to live in a severe form of apartheid. The situation is also not helped by Israeli settlements being constructed in the West Bank.
Unfortunately the situation is monstrously complicated, and I personally think both sides have very legitimate reasons to be angry and concerned.
thank you
I visited Israel and Palestine in September . I found that Israeli were not allowed into Palestine but permitted Palestinians were allowed into Israel to work,shop, etc. The man in the striped blue and white shirt , may be part of Hama.
And that is the problem! Jews encounter "No Jews Allowed " signs and checkpoints all over. Arabs don't. So who is the Apartheid towards??
Isralis are not allowed to palestine ? What the 450.000 israli settlers are doing in the westbank ? Is the Westbank israel too ?
Lol what a silly comment
😂😂😂
I have a question for your upcoming video. To ask the Israelis if do they condemned IDF of the recents killing in Gaza?
I was about to say the same thing.
Can we have some new interviews?
Ask again this question what s the point of postint something if 2013..
Mokawama doesnt mean violent resistance! Who translated this for you? Or did you intentionally add that?
think its deliberate how hes bringing this video in but only a few peoples 'views' and completely taking away from what they're saying lmao hes biased
@@me1998j His rule is that he doesn't edit anyone's answers. That's the point of the channel. Not everyone is out to get you.
lol I was going to say that he just inserted violent to paint an image.
@@danielwilliams173 I agree and thats why I love this channel. But why lie about the translation? Its not even close to what it really means!
I was wondering about the same thing .. thank you for pointing out that the translation is wrong
I do agree with that guy that the comparison with Tibet/west Sahara is a bit weird. A better comparison would be Libia, Eritrea or the United States...
Why the US?
Tibet is fitting. It has been occupied by the CCP roughly the same amount of time that Palestine has been occupied by Israel
@@RedgeNumber1 You know nothing about China. Say this to my Tibetan Chinese girlfriend who lives in Qinghai. Qinghai, Xinjiang, and Inner Mongolian citizens all have different rights and privileges than Han Chinese. China also did a Holocaust against the Tibetans in Qinghai in the 50s where they killed 1/6th of their population, and they have a propaganda campaign to tell them to not get married or have kids so they can send Han Chinese into Qinghai to outpopulate them. Their WeChat accounts are all tapped by the nearby police stations, though Xinjiang has it much worse than Tibetans in Qinghai.
But Palestinians? Theyre fine. The Palestinians living in Israel are citizens, vote, are in supreme court, there's freedom of speech, they aren't forced into the IDF despite other Israelis being forced to draft. The Palestinians in Gaza and West Bank have a bad life because Fatah rules West Bank and Hamas rules Gaza. Israel isn't responsible for other governments being bad at governance, yet Israel still supplies them with free food, water, electricity, jobs when they don't need to. Jordan and Egypt aren't doing that for them.
@@RedgeNumber1 But China has not been created over/on-the-top-of Tibet. China was already there
@@Ash_Queen16 Because the US has been established where some indian-americans were living.
Muqawama (مقاومة) means resistance, it doesn't mean violent struggle. You can resist in peaceful ways like protests and boycotting and you can resist in a violent manner. Please correct your translation
the literal translation for for the arabic word مقاومة mukawma is Resistence in english
As an Israeli I fully understand the man on 12:42, and I really sympathize with him... because of propaganda, Israeli citizens don't see humans in Palestinian Arabs, they see animals, and it's heartbreaking. I want to believe, that one day (and hope it's going to be soon) we will live together in peace as equals, and i don't care if it will be a united country or two separated countries for Palestinian arabs and for jews, i just want us to live in piece with these beautiful people... all of us tired of wars
Hamas sees more value in dead babies than living ones. It is the foundation of their propaganda.
In the Qur'an said if islam won means the end is near.. one of the signs that the Messiah will come is when the Palestine water is drying..
I truly hope one day we will co-exist and share love. Many Israelis originate from arabic countries, and enjoy foods and traditions from these countries. We can still be great friends, but maybe it will take another 100-200 years, sadly...
Unfortunately too much damage was done. Would you guys ever be friends with nazis even in 600 years? Don’t think so.
Their tribes can't even live together. In Afghanistan 9 tribes that hate each other, in Iraq Kurds, Shia, Sunni.. do you think they live in peace and have they ever? Syria, Lebanon, Yemen?
@11:50 you can tell she is just trying to sound PC but her face tells a different answer to the question
The guy towards the end, Aiman Jenin, doesn’t even know that Hamas receives billions but doesn’t spend it on infrastructure for the people. Because he said that Israel gets help and Palestine gets no help. Even their water and vegetables , supplied by Israel.
This being filmed in 2013 its really wonderful to watch your perspective evolve over time. You don’t always interject with follow up questions, but when you do, you reveal your perspective. In this video it seems clear to me that you are open to hearing what everyone has to say but still have a head full of israeli talking points. This isn’t an accusation, at all. Watching the ones you shot more recently, especially in israel, its really clear that you’ve gotten a much different perspective. Its wonderful to watch that happen.
correct me if Im wrong but shouldnt their response be immediate without much thought and clear articulation? "no I dont support Hamas way of fighting if that means attack strictly civilians because that supports an evil cycle. Militants should be attacking millitants." The fact that they have to pause to think for so long to say something like this tells me theyre not being completely honest
WOW THE DISCONNECT IS FRIGHTENING
Here from the future 🥴
Really sad to see this video. A lot of those interviewed refused to see things from Israel's perspective. I can understand why a middle ground between both parties can never be realised. Negotiations are a two way street.
The complexity is much higher than two parties:
Arabs against Jews
Muslims against Jews
21 Arab countries against Israel
56 Muslim countries against Israel
Islam vs. Judaism
Shia vs. Sunni
Iran vs. Turkey vs. KSA vs. Egypt
USSR/Russia vs. USA East vs. West
Partial list of drivers of this conflict.
it's always like this. I saw a video of Muslims complaining about Christianity that it ruined it for Islamic missionaries in the West. But this isn't true. The Islamic terrorism, misogyny, authoritarianism, sharia etc. is what ruined it for Islamic missionaries in the West. They can't see it :D
These people were much more understanding and called fpr peace then the Jewish people he interviewd who mostly said this lnad is our birthright
@@ef2718funny you didn't mention Jews against Muslims I.e Israel. If you're gonna make it about religion then do it both ways! Or US against Palestine. Christians against Muslims, Zionists against Palestine. Talk about the pro-zionist Christians and ANTI-ZIONISM JEWS. Plenty of the latter been protesting against Israel. People like you are part of the problem.
If the last three generations of your family have been living under such extreme oppression I can understand it though. Hamas obviously is doing shitty things but there is no option besides standing with Palestine here. The state of Israel is a fascist settler colonialist one that's engaging in methods we know from the genocide of native americans and the south african apartheid. Hamas doing shitty things does not take away from Israel being the prime evil here. If Israelis and Palestinians are supposed to live in peace in the middle east, the fascist state of Israel has to fall and a new one has to be built that gives everybody equal rights, whether they're muslim or jewish, whether they're israeli or palestinian
"extreme is always wrong"
Define extreme.
Interviewer is trying to justify collective punishment...
Very insightful. This kind of stuff is really important right now. Reminding people that Palestinians are not a monolith and their opinions vary drastically. I thought particularly interesting was the man who hadn't been to Jerusalem since 1998 and the guy who said he was angry at the Arab countries for not caring about Palestinians. Although this was 2013, I think its obvious HAMAS really is more than its militant wing. Although they didn't really help Palestinians in rebuilding Gaza, they did supply them with jobs building tunnels and smuggling goods in under the blockade. And Israeli occupation is a legitimate complaint to have. I see why they support HAMAS even though HAMAS has only escalated the situation. I wonder how the opinion is currently, I'm sure its far more divided.
They understate their hatred of Jews. Guaranteed that this man has been going and listening to an imam at a mosque telling non stop anti semitic propaganda and lies since he was the age of 2. They do not live in reality unfortunately. Islamic teachings of the Quran a Muslim is not incentivized to tell the truth they are commanded to deceive and subjugate the non believers… “from the river to the sea” means kill all Jews and take back the land you conquered. Regardless if that’s true or false they believe they once owned it because their “religious overlords” tell them. It’s pride, rage, anger, deception. That’s what Islam teaches…
When it involves je ws , pastalinis are all hamas . Or worse.
Hamas harms more of its own people than Israelis, while its leaders live in luxury in Doha.
Anyway, bear in mind that if you, being based in Judea and Samaria, confess to supporting Hamas's brutal practices, it might have consequences for you as the area is being monitored by IDF.
The security only started because of the attacks from them. The wall was built in 2005 after the intifadas not before. It’s not a chicken and egg scenario here it’s defense.
Before we jump to conclusions, we need to realise a few things. If they denounce Hamas, Hamas might try to silence them, and society might ostracise them for criticising their only hope.
If they support Hamas, Israel and its allies might classify them as a target/imprison them. The world might lose sympathy for them
Very easy for us to judge either side of the conflict. Very hard for them
Remember folks, this is filmed in 2013, which is even before 2017, when Hamas changed their charter and acknowledged 1967 borders.
In min 7:35 your translator was telling the other guy what to say telling him to don’t make a mistake and to say no as he continued you see even that your translator already answering before the interviewed guy says a thing be careful
The sad fact that Palestinians go above and beyond to defend or justify Hamas and their actions, Like Hamas wouldn't execute such abhorrent evil acts on them as well. I'd love to know what they think of Hamas now post their terror attack on Oct 7 or will they blame Israel like they always do?
As the son of the Hamas founder said, Hamas hate Israel more than they love their own children, And it seems like the Palestinians follow suit even when the terrorists use their people and land as chess pieces for their own gain.
Only Allah can stop this, Islam is always the answer
Did you watch the video?
Clearly you didnt see the video. Very sad!
Typical radical Zionist nonsense
Rewatch the video