Kindergarten Math Curriculum Review & Comparison II Right Start, MathUSee, Singapore Dimensions
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 03. 2020
- Hey friends! I've put together a video sharing some of the math curriculum we have used over the past year for my kindergartner. We have been through quite the process and I wanted to share in case it is helpful for anyone else! Please comment below with your thoughts on the curriculum or an questions you may have that I can try and answer!
5:45 Right Start Math - Level A: store.rightstartmath.com/righ...
9:18 MathUSee - Primer: store.demmelearning.com/math-...
11:54 Singapore Dimensions - KA & KB: www.singaporemath.com/program...
Where you can find me:
GOODREADS
/ angie
INSTAGRAM
/ angiesciencemama
VERY helpful! Thank you for going so in depth! I’ve been bouncing back and forth between so many different K-level curriculums & mostly focused on math and language arts in the beginning...
Thank you for the really thorough review. We were stuck between choosing Singapore or Math U See and you really helped us shape our decision. Looking forward to more of your videos!
Oh good, I'm glad the video helped! Which one did you end up with?
Excellent reviews and your walk through of your decision making process was so helpful!
Thank you so much for this, super helpful comparing the three different math programs. I appreciated the chart at the beginning and the feedback you gave about teach intensive versus open and go.
Excellent review..very informative. Thank you so much for being here, and for taking the time to share. (=
shay j337 Thank you for taking the time to watch - I hope it was helpful!
I almost had the reverse experience of what you describe! I started my oldest son with Singapore and he has thrived in it for years. When it was time for my daughter to start learning math, it didn't even occur to me that I should look into other curriculum options for her. She's left-handed and very artistic, always in her imaginary world creating things. This last year has been a nightmare with Singapore Dimensions. Over the course of the year, I realized that she's very much a kinesthetic learner. I used the Simply Charlotte Mason Delightful Reading with her and being able to move the letter tiles around helped her SO much. I think I'm going to try RightStart with her this coming year, even though it's teacher intensive, it will be worth it in the long run if she's able to understand math in a way that makes sense to her. Thank you for your extensive review! I wasn't looking at Math-U-See, but now that I've seen your overview I might look into the Primer for my son going into Kindergarten. I can tell he already has a grasp of math, he loves his skip counting songs, and it would be a huge help if he can watch someone explain the lesson and do a lot of it on his own. Thank you so much!
L L I’m so glad the review was helpful! This is a great example of why I think homeschooling is such a great option! Every kid is so unique- you should definitely try RS, it is a beautiful program that teaching math in ways that really help kids understand at a deeper level! I’m going to try Singapore with my daughter this year for kindergarten but I have definitely learned to hold it loosely and if we need to switch to something different for her, that is totally fine!!
Thank you so much for this review. By far the most thorough video I’ve seen on the subject. This is my first year homeschooling with my youngest who is 5. I have two children in high school that went to public school since pre school, however with the issues in the world at the moment I don’t feel comfortable sending my youngest to school with a mask and stuff. Anyways, I’m super overwhelmed and this was extremely helpful.
Sparrows Know I’m so glad it was helpful and yes, there is so much uncertainty that I completely understand keeping your 5 year old close! Please feel free to reach out if you need any help as you transition!!
Thank you, super helpful. The chart you used to compare the 3 curriculums was a great visual for me.
Jennifer Sedo I’m so glad it was helpful - the chart was the only way I could organize my thoughts 🤣
Angie, hi! Ok, I just want to say that this is hands down the best and most helpful review on the subject. I've just started homeschooling my 5 yo daughter and your videos and reviews have been a great help in the process. Thank you! Thank you! 🙏
Thank you so much, that means so much to me to hear that! I just put out a phonics review video a few days ago, if you are still looking for a good direction for reading :)
We love singapore dimmensions math. It is nice to see you like it as well. I find if I need to bring in manipulates I easily can. I love your review!
Love Learning Everyday I think I initially saw the dimensions math on your channel in one of your curriculum videos ... so thank you for the inspiration! Yes, I love the flexibility ... I can use manipulatives if I need them, I can speed up or slow down. Such a great curriculum!
Such great information! Thank you for always being so through.
fredra Andrews You’re welcome - I’m glad it was helpful!!
I found you through a shoutout. I’m a new homeschooling mom (not because the pandemic. It was always our choice) and a Booktuber. This is exactly what I needed!😍 Thank you for this video!
How fun!! Do you post both homeschool and book content on your channel? I will have to go check it out 😀
@@sciencemama I did a intro to homeschool when I saw a lot of families switch but there wasn’t a demand for it by me.
Thank you for this awesome comparison of these three programs! I used Signapore KA in the fall and liked it, but was considering switching to Right Start Math for the Spring. Your video has really given me excellent information to consider as I make a decision. THANK YOU!!!
That is wonderful to hear!
Super helpful! Will thought out and well explained. Thank you!
Fantastic review! Thanks for sharing your experience
Chadanse Burgos Oh good, I’m glad it was helpful!
Thanks for the video. Really helped me make my mind up on which to purchase for my child x
Thank you for being concise and clear
Thank you! This review comparison is very good!
Danielle Blue Good! I’m glad it was helpful!
I have used Math-U-See for my oldest from Primer - Algebra 1. I would say my son never loved it but he has progressed steadily with it. I am considering Singapore Dimensions for my Kindergartener & Preschooler as a chance to try something new. I also think she needs something more visually engaging. However, I see it tops out at 8th grade. I am hoping you or another commenter can tell me what people commonly switch to for high school without any struggle of gaps in understanding or teaching style? Thanks!
Also, thank you for the video. It was well planned out and covered good info. 💛
Great review! Very helpful! Thanks so much!
Mae 21 You’re very welcome - glad it was helpful!
This video was exactly what I needed!!
Oh good, I'm glad it was helpful!
Thanks for this review! Would you mind providing more examples of some of the suggested manipulatives in Dimensions? I imagine that my daughter would be frustrated if she didn't get to use something similar to what is shown in the book.
We have mostly used the Unifix blocks and counting bears. Luckily, the picture in the textbook and workbook don’t really represent the manipulatives!
So helpful! This video saved me so much time and money!
So glad it was helpful :)
Thank you! We were looking into all 3 of these.
So glad it was helpful :)
This was fabulous. Thank you!
Glad I found your channel. Thank you for showing all these.
Where do you buy your used curriculum?
Dre You’re very welcome! I mostly get my used curriculum off of Facebook groups, I will link the one I use the most below. I also use eBay and Facebook market - but not as much.
facebook.com/groups/homeschoolcurriculumexchange/?ref=share
Science Mama Thank you!
Great review, thank you!!
Great job.. ! It does take time to get to know how our kids learn.
Animemode Thanks! That is the beauty of homeschool!
Great video! Thank you! Quick question... what (if any) program did you use for Pre-K before engaging in these programs? I use Rightstart Level B for my older son, but wondering if I could start with either Dimensions K or Rightstart Level A with him this year (he is nearly 5). Thanks for your help!
Katie Gallagher I did a little bit of the Mathematical Reasoning books with my son - but we didn’t really push it in preK. After he turned 5 is when we started RS A and went from there. Last year when my daughter was 4 I did Preschool Math by Kate Snow with her. Good luck!
Great review. I think we're going to try Math-U-see for my Kindergartener but I am wondering if we may switch to Singapore later. Do the manipulatives from MathUSee work for Singapore?
elipsixx I’m glad it was helpful!! The MUS blocks don’t really work for Singapore but they are pretty easy to sell if you change your mind. I picked up some unifix cubes for Singapore that work great!
This was super helpful! Thank you!
Liz Hdez Good, I’m so glad!
Great information!! Thank you! 👏🏽
My Littles’ Homeschool You’re welcome!!
Great video! What are some variety of manipulatives you think I can get started with if I’m going with Singapore math?
Susy Rodriguez Haha - just saw your other comment 😀
Very helpful! Thank you! Can you explain the difference between Primary Math and Dimensions Math through Singapore?
Lisa Folkerts Hi! From my understanding, they are really pretty similar. Since filming this video I have discovered that Dimensions is intended more for the classroom (large group game ideas, etc) but can still be used easily for homeschooling. I’m actually considering using primary math for my 1st grader next year. It looks very similar but might be a little more straight forward for school at home 🤷🏼♀️
Hands on maths is an awesome way of teaching maths. We love math u see. My daughter has used the math u see blocks wen doing other math work. I think I did as a kid. We love hands on learning for science as well. We don’t do all the problems wiv math u see.
Thank you for the comparison. I purchased the Singapore set. I remember you mentioned somewhere what manipulatives you used for the this and I think you had already. Also, I believe you linked the Amazon link for it. Could you please share where that is?
Glad it was helpful! I actually just made a full video on what we use for Dimensions, and I have all the manipulatives linked in the description box!! czcams.com/video/dRcGP6ALYrA/video.html
This was amazing! Thank you!!
You're very welcome!
Thank you for this!! 😁😁So helpful!!
Eva Marie Alvarez Del Toro I’m so glad it was helpful - haha we switched around so much I that I thought I might share in case others would benefit 🤣
Super informative. Thanks!
You're very welcome - I'm glad it was helpful!!
Thanks for introducing these 3 Math curr.!! I love all of them and you helped me get more insight.
I do want to search more about the difference In Singapore Math regular vs, Singapore Math dimensions.
You are very welcome! I’m actually just getting ready to record a video on Singapore Dimensions vs Primary math ... so stay tuned 😀
This was super helpful!! thank you
Jessica Riffel I’m so glad it was helpful!!
Hi Angie! Thank you for this comparison video! I find it to be especially helpful because we are leaning towards starting homeschool for this school year. I'm interested in Singapore math for my first grader. He is a lot like your son & wants to do the math in his head! I appreciate the way you observed what works best for your child, that's helping me navigate through this uncharted territory. I'm torn between Dimensions and Primary. Reading some of the previous comments, did you decide between dimensions and primary for the upcoming school year? If so, what factors led you to that choice? Do you know how the two programs differ? Thank you again for super helpful review!
Josephine Dipasupil Hi! I’m glad the video was helpful! I decided to try Primary with my son for 1st grade. I ended up making that decision because we weren’t really using all the extra small or large group activities (that are geared more towards in classroom). Also Primary is designed for homeschool 🤷🏼♀️. So I’m going to try it and if we don’t like it I will be switching back!
Hello! I know this is an older video, but I was wondering about your switch to Primary. Were there still games, scavenger hunts, etc? Could many of those included in Dimensions be used by just Mom and one child, or would you need a larger group?
Very helpful, thank you!
Thanks for this! I picked up Primer parent book and dvd for free a bit ago for my just now 4y, having recognized it but not really knowing about it. It looks like it may work for her, well. Though I really do like the look of the Singapore math too! She is turning 4 next month but we are moving into just starting more Kinder concepts...math sense vs just counting and phonetically sounds and blending, next year!
Ahh, 4 is such a fun age ... my daughter gets so excited to do school. For her we bounce around, we do Preschool Math by Kate Snow and math games. Currently we are loving Tiny Polka Dot!
Science Mama Thanks I will look into those too! Mine gets bored and doesn’t like to do the same activities over again, a lot of the time. Lol
HI! Thanks for the video. I am starting homeschool with my almost 5 years old kid. I was looking between a comparison on RS and MUS because I had in mind that Singapore was too strict, but after your video..I am not longer sure. Do you think that giving 2 for a kindergarten would be too much. I was thinking on RS to have the concept of Math and Singapore Dimensions to master it. I would love to hear your thoughts. Thanks
Oh man, it depends on your 5 year old ... I would say it is probably too much but I can see the desire to add some practice to RS!
Thank you- this was just what I was looking for as I embark on homeschooling my soon-to-be TK eldest. I've seen all of these programs at various levels in my experience as a homeschool support teacher, but haven't been able to get a real deep look at any one in particular (my exposure was brief flip-throughs during student meetings and work samples). I recall being impressed with the focus on number sense that shone through with Dimensions; what is your perspective on how it compares in that regard to RightStart and MathUSee?
I feel like number sense it taught really well with right start bc of the hands on nature - not so sure about MUS.
I think RS as core curriculum with MUS complete program as supplement is the best Math education we can give. So after we cover a level of RS, I do the MUS level that would have already been covered in RS.
Thank you for this video. I am also needing to decide on kinder curriculum for my daughter. She has intellectual disabilities though I personally love math and wanted to presume competence and teach her as much as I can. (We've already taught her to read a bit, to others' surprise!) I am struggling choosing among Dimensions Math, RSM, Singapore Primary Math 2022, and Math with Confidence. I wanted to stick with something common core since we are in CA. I like RSM, but am concerned about the use of abacus (my daughter has really poor fine motor skills). I like Dimensions Math, but wish they have a home instructors guide. I am also concerned that singapore math generally has more expectation of worksheets even at K level as compared to RSM level A. What would you recommend if you are in my shoe?
That is a really hard decision ... as for Singapore worksheets, the sheets in the textbook you will do together ... and honestly we often did the workbook sheets together as well. The new primary math looks great, but I haven't used it so I can't say. RS does have a lot of moving parts which can be a bit tough ... but it is great for kids that struggle!
Thanks so much for this video! I looked at the placement tests for dimensions, and I'm pretty sure my son should be starting with the KB level, so I'd rather not purchase both KA and KB. Do you think KB alone would be enough to cover a full school year, if we do about 3-4 lessons per week, or is it meant to be KA for 1/2 year and KB for the second 1/2? Just want to get an idea of how much material is included in KB and whether it will last us Aug-May? Thanks again!
I think you could definitely stretch out KB to cover the whole year - you could even pick up some fun math games and intersperse them throughout to stretch things 😀
Science Mama thanks! Just bought it today and can’t wait to get started!
Colleen Giannotta Can’t wait time hear what you think!!
Great review! I'm glad we chose Singapore to start out but always wondered how the other programs operate.
I am still LOVING Singapore math!
Such a good review. These are the 3 programs I am considering. I would choose math u see if it wasn’t mastery but I’m planning on doing teaching textbooks the following year and I don’t want her to fall behind. I think I’ll stick with dimensions math that my daughter did this year, but buy some manipulatives. She has doing fine with it and we are almost done with K.
Dimensions is a really good curriculum - I actually made a video on the math manipulatives we were using when we used Dimensions!
What did you find ended up working for your daughter that you mentioned in the video was going to be starting kindergarten?
We're using Singapore Dimensions also for our 6yo/1st grader. We started with KB and are watching Wisdom Wonder Project math videos. Because they use the Primary curriculum, the videos are showing us different imagery, but it's all the same concepts. Once we get through this book (and we're almost done!), I'm going to switch over to Primary so our book matches the videos. But so far, we're loving the curriculum - the use of manipulatives, games and workbook. I may have started my kid one half year behind, but I wasn't exactly sure where he was after the mess crisis learning was last spring in Kindergarten.
Sounds like we are doing very similar things! We are almost done with KB and are planning on switching over to Primary. Thank you for letting me know about Wisdom Wonder Project math videos - they sound perfect for us!
@@sciencemama Seriously, they're amazing. And one less thing I have to fully teach.
@Emily A B I ended up here when I was looking up more about Singapore math and the wisdom wonder project. I haven’t seen very many reviews of the curriculum that aren’t sponsored. If you don’t mind, could I ask how you’ve liked it and how long you’ve used it? I have an up and coming kindergartener. Thanks!
Hi! I used Wisdom Wonder math videos for most of 1st grade. We homeschooled thanks to the pandemic, but in March our 1st grader was really missing having more interactions with kids outside our family. (Moving to a new town during a pandemic is pretty tough.) So we enrolled him in the public school at that time. But for the 6 months we used it, we loved it!
My kiddos really liked Ms. Houser and we all loved the use of manipulatives. My 4yo would watch the videos with her brother and she was learning along with him! When my 1st grader re-entered school, he was behind in reading (which I expected), but totally up to speed or even ahead in math.
Also, the company is super responsive if you have questions or suggestions. They always responded quickly to my emails and I felt like we almost had a working partnership. I highly recommend WWP!
www.wisdomwonderproject.org/ref/emmybeu@gmail.com/
Hi..very nice video...my daughter is 3 yrs 10 months..can you recommend some maths resources or books for her i.e age appropriate..and when can we start with these resources..
Thanks for this video! Do you mind doing a flip through for Singapore Dimensions KA & KB?
Madam Dang You’re very welcome and I would be happy to do a flip though. I feel like there really aren’t that many videos up on Singapore Dimensions!
Science Mama yes definitely not enough videos out there! You’d be the first and I’d love to share it 😊❤️
Madam Dang Just posted the video!! Check it out and feel free to pass it on 😀
Science Mama yay that is awesome! Thank you! Will spread the word :)
Madam Dang Thanks!!
Thanks! I found this helpful. Did you end up sticking with Singapore?
No, I really liked it but my son didn’t - he is doing great with Saxon!
Great video!
Hi! Can you share a link for the bins you use to store the right start math manipulatives?
We've been using Horizons math (which doesn't have the beautiful teacher's manual like Singapore). My oldest daughter (5.5) likes worksheets but I feel like she isn't absorbing enough. Singapore would be easiest for me to teach, however I think the hands on right start MAY be easier for her to absorb. I would appreciate any feedback. I feel like i'm taking a HUGE risk spending so much on rightstart, but I want her to start enjoying math and learning more than how to trace two digit numbers.
Thank you for your help, and for the link to the bins!
Kirsten Homan Hi! It is so hard to know what to do! Sometimes you just have to try it out - and I was able to resell my RightStart manipulatives for about what I paid, so maybe that would help you feel better 😀. I feel like Singapore is a good go between for worksheets and hands-on. You start with the hands on and move to worksheets for each lesson. Good luck - I feel like math is the thing I’ve been changing the most in our homeschool!
Kirsten Homan The bins are 15 quart Sterilite latch bins 😀
your jacket looks so cozy!!
lost in a booKCase Haha, I love that jacket, I’ve practically been living in it all winter 😀
Thank you! I am comparing RS and MUS so I REALLY thank you! Please let me know where you bought your RS set used?
Amanda Nour امينة نور I’m so glad it was helpful! I bought the set off of a Facebook homeschool BST group. I’m actually thinking about selling my set because my daughter is doing well with Singapore and I want to pick up an art program!
@@sciencemama let me know if your open to shipping it?? Im in Texas. 😀
Amanda Nour امينة نور It will probably be about $40-50 to ship because it can’t go media mail. I’m thinking of listing it as $200 including shipping - if that is reasonable to you, send me your email and I can send a list of the items plus pictures. I haven’t posted it to the FB group, so just let me know if that is something you would like to check out 😀
Science Mama thanks for your reviews!!!
D T You’re very welcome - I’m glad it was helpful!
What made you select dimensions for Singapore as apposed to standard or math in focus?
I had a friend that was using dimensions :) Also, primary didn't have a kindergarten program - and I have since moved to primary for my 1st grader.
thank you we are new to homeschooling. and really going through a tough time with not much help from our es. i have 2 kiddos on the spectrum both struggling now i struggling with them first at a school now with a public charter. kids like to interact with me, and I do too. they like hands on with little downtime. my husband is also battling kidney cancer since i am the caregiver of everything for everyone, i also need less reading and preparing for me to get a lesson. I get allot of "aaww sorry but no real help" allot of opinions and links. which makes it hard because i think i am dyslexic, with no time to self care myself at all hence i have to pull allnighters when my toddler has sleep disturbances in order to research links. we like all about reading and moving beyond the page. but the downtime for me to figure out steps through pages of text is difficult because son is already eloping before we start. son is showing lots of interest for iready, abc mouse and online moving beyond the page but when it challenges him he struggles to move to the next level.
Im in search of kinder and 1st grade; math measurement data geometry, spelling, writing, staying on topic, counting by 2,3,5 and 10's for my autistic kiddo kind who struggles with eloping/task avoidance and speech impairment. please help i run into allot of recommendations that either dont work or work but are not our charter vendor
I'm sorry to hear that you are struggling so much, that must seem overwhelming! It sounds like you need something more open and go ... in other words, not much planning for you! It sounds like you have a charter? Does it allow for religious curriculum, because Abeka is really solid and also has a DVD or streaming option ... that would take all the teaching off of your plate. Although, it can be expensive. I also know of some programs through the school systems ... I think it is called K12!
Hello, I'm planning on buying dimensions PK and wondering if it is ok just to buy the workbook and textbook and not buying the teacher's book. Do you think is possible to use the program without the teacher's book? Thank you very much!
We didn't ever use the PreK Dimensions, but I would say you could be fine without the teachers guide ... it just depends if you want the extra ideas for games and activities that can only be found in the teachers guide!
@@sciencemama Thanks!
You mentioned several times that you bought some items used. Which website did you use?
Hi! I've used a number of buy/sell/trade Facebook groups for homeschooling curriculum. There are some general ones but there are also specific ones for some of the curriculum companies. I also know of people who buy off of Ebay, I just haven't done that yet!
Hi.. was thinking of switchi g from dimension maths to right start maths with my daughter struggling with maths. She just completed grade 1 singapore. Which level shld i go for in right starts maths. B or c?. they do not have a detailed placement test
I’m really not sure because we never made it to B or C or rightstart. Maybe call the company?
Hi Kate, any chance you have looked "Kindergarten Math with Confidence"? I would love a comparison between that and Singapore Dimensions..
Rushika Kumararatne Hi! I haven’t looked at that curriculum unfortunately. I will have to go check it out!
@@sciencemama Thank you! How long do you spend a day or week on math with your son on Dimensions math?
Rushika Kumararatne For Kindergarten we did about 20 minutes a day - about 4 times a week because we have an enrichment school for the 5th day.
@@sciencemama Hi! Another question from me. A friend of mine has lent me the Mathusee manipulatives. Do you think I could use them with Singapore Dimensions? THANK YOU.
Rushika Kumararatne Hi! I would say it would be better to get the unifix cubes - the ones that can be built and taken apart really easily! I’m actually planning a video discussing the manipulatives we have used for the Dimensions program - so stay tuned for that!
Math u see isn’t on my list but curious if you looked into math with confidence as a comparison with Singapore and Rightstart
When I made the video Math with Confidence wasn't really that popular ... so I've never used it, sorry!
Do you know where the lady bought the wooden containers for the MUS blocks? I’m looking to buy MUS but I don’t want to keep the blocks in the box they come in.
Brianna Everitt Hi - I’m actually in the process of selling my box and blocks!! If you are interested - do you want to send me a message in Instagram or email me?
Science Mama yes I can email you! Is there a place to find your email?
@@briannaeveritt8757 angie1p57@gmail.com
@@sciencemama would instagram be easier actually? I use that more than my email... What is your name on there?
Thanks for the video. I would be interested to hear if your daughter likes Right Start and How it works with her.
K S I will be interested too 😀. She is a little harder to nail down than my son - so we shall see! How old are your kiddos and how long have you been using RS?
@@sciencemama My mom used Miquon Math (it is a 1st to 3rd grade program that uses Cusinaire Rods) and I loved learning with this. It had a focus on manipulatives and discovering multiple ways to solve a problem. I moved on to Key Curriculum Press and later for high school used Saxon (Algebra 1 through Calculus). All of this made me love math and well prepared me for college and my career as an engineer. I am trying but no children yet and am also looking into adoption and foster care. Math was enjoyable and interesting and I want my child to feel the same way. I know that the programs I used years ago were excellent but want to learn about other programs to see if in the years since I went through this if anything better has come out. I am leaning to Right Start pared with Miquon but time will show. From Critical Thinking Company was used for supplement and extra practice. Just getting prepared early. I looked into Teaching Textbooks but feel that since it ends at Pre-calculus it is not fully college prepatory and not as rigorous as Saxon Advanced Math (the course before Saxon Calculus). I will say for early grades I would not recommend Saxon for the elementary school, my sister used it and while it taught her the info well I think the rote approach so young led to her disliking math.
K S I agree with so much of what you are saying! Having a concrete and hands on approach in the younger year is crucial! We also supplement with critical thinking company books - they are so great! It sounds like your future kiddos are going to be well covered in the math department!!
Hi I'm really interested in the Singapore maths but not sure which level to start. My sons 5 in October. We home school and I think from what you said it would be best suited for him. Can't seem to find the kindergarten series on amazon though. But not sure if level 1 would be too far ahead
what is the difference between dimensions and primary other than its an updated version? Anything major?
Hi! I would say the main difference is that Dimensions is geared towards a classroom (group activities and classroom manipulatives) and primary is geared towards homeschooling. I haven't started primary with my son yet, so I can't say any more than that ... but I think otherwise they are very similar in scope and sequence and general teaching strategy!
@@sciencemama thank you. 🤗
I am beyond thrilled to come across this video. I have been doing my best to research all three of these programs. Do you think Right Start method or games contributed to your sons abilities to do mental calculations, or is he just naturally inclined?
My apologies I was distracted by my one year old the first time watching the video. You already answered my original question. So, would you say Right Start would be worth starting for foundation purposes alone? even if it doesn't work long term due to a child not being able to handle the constant changes.
noticed4what I’m just not sure, we only made it to about lesson 30. I feel like what was covered in the first 30 lessons of RightStart A was also covered in Dimensions. Although the games can be really good and you can pick up the game book separately... I’ve been meaning to play more RS games with my son but he seems to be doing well right now. When we hit a more challenging section, I will probably look up some games that tackle that concept in the RS games book. Does that help? How old is you kiddo?
Science Mama your review was very transparent and your honest response was just as helpful. I was drawn to the uniqueness of Right Starts philosophy, but couldn’t find any long term reviewers. I have 5 kiddos ages 1,3, 5, & 9. As of right now I am newly ( Oct. 19)homeschooling only my 4th grader due to her high anxiety attending school. But I want to make sure the younger ones get a better foundation.
7
noticed4what Yes RightStart would set a solid foundation! Good luck, homeschooling is wonderful- I’m so happy we decided to do it! If it interests you, I’m planning on filming a flip through of the Dimensions KA and KB books later this week 😀
Any opinions on Shiller or minquon math?
Unfortunately, I haven't used either of those programs, sorry!
where do you get used materials?
Sylvia Jackman Hi! I’m part of a number of Facebook homeschool groups for used curriculum! There are some broad groups as well as specific curriculum buy/sell/trade groups. Those groups are pretty much the only reason I’m on FB 🤣
Where is ours case from for the MUS blocks?
Haha, the case was extra ... but I don't know if they sell it anymore!
Hi where do you buy these
Used? What site do you use? Thanks
I can't remember what I bought used - but I often use Facebook BST curriculum groups, or marketplace as well as an app called Mercari :)
Where can I get used books and manipulatives
I search Facebook marketplace as well as all the Facebook curriculum groups :)
Hi, did you end up using right start or math u see with your other kids or did you use dimensions?
Oh man, we went on quite the math journey ... but we ended up switching from Singapore to Saxon math this past September and I'm really happy we did! If you are interested in that switch, I have a video on my channel :)
@@sciencemama oh wow! Yes I’d love to hear more! I’m having trouble deciding which math to use for my seven year old we are currently using dimensions 1b. Although I love the program he still struggles with some math concepts. I just want to build a sold foundation before moving on. Would love to hear your thoughts on Saxon and even more on right start math.
hi what is mental math spiral and mastery math?
Hi! Mental math is the ability to do math in your head ... which some curriculums teach strategies for that. A spiral approach to math is where the topics are introduced but then something new is brought in and the concepts just keep spiraling in to give more practice while new concepts are always taught. As for mastery, the concept is taught exclusively until fully grasped prior to moving on. Hope that makes sense!
Right start say they are spiral and mastery, but definitely looks more spiral than Math u see. ☺️
Agreed!
Thank you for the thorough review. I’m still town between RightStart and Singapore Dimensions for my rising Kindergartener. I would be so appreciative if you could weigh in on my observations!
My child is coming from a Montessori primary program where he used manipulatives. Like most 5 year old boys, he’s very active. Also, his math skills currently exceed his writing skills, though he is a highly competent writer. For these reasons, I am leaning towards RightStart for Kindergarten.
However, a few personality traits give me pause. He is a to-the-point thinker with an innate gift for calculation. He does worksheets for fun, when he needs to focus on something specific to quiet his mind. In my observation, he breezes through them without much thought for the problems. So, I’m torn between challenging him to develop a stronger conceptual foundation through RightStart or honoring what seems to be his natural preference for worksheets with Singapore math.
When we completed the Singapore placement tests he landed between KB and 1A. If I go with Singapore I would start with KB for review and begin 1A when he is ready.
Thanks again for sharing your experiences!
Please pardon my busy mom typos :)
Hi! Those are both great programs and it is so hard to know! My first thought is to try both and see which he responds to - but RS is so expensive! I like Singapore because its not all worksheets - first you work with manipulative, then a textbook with mom, then independent worksheets. The other thing to think about is if your son has a tendency to focus on one thing or prefer to float from thing to thing - because RS was spiral and my son preferred a bit more focus on a topic before moving on! Those are my thoughts - let me know what you think!
Hey! Ur son sounds like my son lol
Can I please know what did u end up getting? N how is it going?