Let's look at yoga...
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 08. 2024
- Main Channel: / scienceisdope
Free Pseudoscience Game - Spot the BS: bingobaker.com/#65349335c8b652a6
Biases and Fallacies:
docs.google.com/document/d/1X...
One-time support:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
To join my WhatsApp community: nas.io/scienceisdope
Discord: / discord
Subbreddit: / scienceisdope - Zábava
Pranav speedrunning his way to get blocked by every pseudoscience creator on instagram
Lol he himself blocked me on insta what a hypocrite now crying when someone else blocked him 🤡
@@DeviSapkota-yy5wj you think he care about some fear mongering bozo blocking him? As far as the content goes as he said he could just log out of insta and still react and grt content
@@DeviSapkota-yy5wj you are टणाटण 🥁🥁🥁 so u won't count
@@DeviSapkota-yy5wjlol what did you say ?
(You're a Sadhguru bhakt so i assume you said something stupid.)
@@harsh9023 what kind of logic is that? sadhuguru has his share of intellactual followers who are most likely far more intelligent than you,atleast give a better reason lol
How can you not laugh at the second one! I fuckin died laughing 🤣
The thumbnail got me 🤣
Stopped kids from saying first
Ahegao
@@tgkthebawsemeans
1:59 is she milking Elephant 🐘 or Giraffe 🦒 😢?
An African guy ⬛🟧 ☠️ jk
Dinosaur
@@Jchi737 🤣🤣🤣🙌🏻
Blue Whale
@@harsh9023 😳
Some yoga is good for flexibility and good stretching exercises but it has nothing to do with science (things like dosha and chakra)
Very True!! Couldn't have summed it up any better.
💯
@@lightyagami8760 thanx a lot bro
Yoga is very much scientific in my experience. It is all about personal experience😅. I practiced yoga for 6 months, I was very calm and cool , my sleep was xlent, my anxiety was almost gone. Unfortunately, I stopped practicing, started taking antidepressants, my life is fucked up with side effects of the tablets. If I had practiced yoga for few years, my life would be far better 😢. I used to practice pranayam for 30 minutes, it was amazing experience.
yoga is better, if u start after 10 minute warmup like jogging or rope skipping and doing post warmup after yoga session. pranav u r big pseudo
The woman in thumbnail is doing something else💀💀💀
That's a cheap imitation of Kali I believe.
ah*gao 💀
@@aswinbabu1630 kali’s invention. Wait now some Indians will say that it was stolen from our culture🤣🤣🤣
@@Saanhj78889 I meant the goddess Kali.
@@aswinbabu1630 😂
How to invent yoga:
1) some basic body movements
2) add "asan" word in last
Great!! This is how you can make your yoga
Though a few of those are quite use full. Have tried it myself.
"Somyakurmasan"
lol ignorance at its peak
3:35
bro ive been laughing at this for the past 5 mins lmfaoo
Idk what she was trying to prove 💀
She made the Ahegao face.
Last time I took the word "Chakra" seriously, I was binging Naruto!
Lol😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Yoga can be taught as physical exercise but these people add these pseudoscience and scripture to gain followers(like trying something different)
i once talked with a yoga and meditation teacher, asked if these chakra are real and have real effect. lol, he told me he don't know he explaied me later. Mostly, the basis of these practices espacially, meditation is that you have to think less and lesser your thought, to increase your focus. Hence, these chakra etc are just imaginations, to lesser your thoughts while meditation. Basically, imagine so much that you don't think that much.
there are other ways like, try to recreate your room in your mind etc, i think same is in yoga, you sometimes imagine things. But, i feel, like people have taken them as real things, that actually exists, and for worst, more like treatment of diseases.
Yoga is an exercies, it can keep your healthy if done right, but definitely can't treat you
true,chakra might or might not exist,till it does not have emperical evidence we shouldn't think much about it
Forget chakra, it's just exercise and can help in mindfulness , reducing anxiety, stress and maintain overall good health .
Hey man, if science really studied yoga then it can probably say that this is psuedo science. Maybe research a little bit what science found on swami rama and what he was able to do with yoga and meditation. I agree there are a lot of idiots online spreading fake yoga benifits for clout but yoga and meditation is the only thing that takes years and years to master and results are rarely tested. It is all about the money, nobody is testing a group of people for decades because it will cost millions.
Yoga is the first human science.
I like your channel and subscribe to fact that you debunk myths and andhbhakti but yoga and meditation are areas that have not been studied very well and the parts that have been studied have shown real potential.
Former ex yoga teacher here
Yes he is right
Yoga have so many pseudoscience and anti science stuff
If u just do it as excerise only
Than go for it
But still I would suggest weight training or something else bec it is more effective and it burn more calories.
Thanks again pranav
Yoga itself isnt pseudoscience
Even kids now doing is good
Yoga is the sanskrit name for stretches
But many of the teachers are spreading it the wrong way
i think you are soreading the wrong way , yoga don't means stretches in sanskrit 😂. yoga come from the root word yuj meaning union
@@rumbling178 No I wrote it in a different context
I meant yoga is the Indian/Sanskrit version of stretches
Cuz yoga and stretches are really similar
I mean you get the point right
Pranav is getting funnier as well as videos 😆
Thanks for talking about Yoga.....
I am a victim of this yoga
My father used to forcefully tell me to do yoga and claimed I would be like a super man 🙂
now I hv a fixed spine.....this condition happened mainly due to a yoga called Sakrasana
when you do bad and not learn properly this happens .. go to gym and try to do every exercise with bad technique and form i can bet you will get few disc slipped in you spine and at least one tendon tear .... what are you saying .. its your fault ... that you got yourself injure what a clown
Yoga is a good flexibility and stretching exercise, but expecting anything else from it is wrong. In your case, it's lack of form to be blamed, any exercise done wrong will cause injury.
@@ro0t115 no after my accident I went deep in to this yoga and saw that those sadhus who rr weak and feeble always practice crazy yoga and look at vivekanand!!! Why did he die so young? U ll say hardwork but no ....people don't die of hardwork.....I know people who do 10× the hardwork than the sadhus...but still ok..
I don't think twisting our spine in such a weird level is good....
@@ro0t115 tell me why then your business baba and his partner get admitted to AIIMS 😂 galat aasan nahi tumhari soch hai.
@@dkdk5486 विवेकानन्द जी की वास्तविकता भी पता कहाँ है आपको तब
a well educated, from USA,Hindu visited my accommodation and was questioning why my furniture was not aligned to the earth magnetic field, i think he called it vashu-shastru or something, initially i thought he was joking, but alas he was deadly serious..
Me when the pencil on my desk is not aligned with the magnetic field of a supermassive black hole :
Things that never happened 😕
@@anchitbose4151 seriously, it happened... whether you believe it it up to you...
@@tariq_sharifhow serious was that person did he or she tried to threaten you?
@@shashikantoraon1719 He was Kshatriya so maybe he would have launched a war... but unlikley as he is a friend ... it was just surprising to me that a well educated person should be susceptible to such myths.
I suggested that he should do a double blind experiment by puting a magnet (or similar heavy object) in an envelope and rate how it effects his sleep over several nights (even extend it to other people) ... but he declined; apparently it is easier to just be an andhbhkat i guess.
See... that would have provided empirical data rather than some shatru mashtru baba's say so...
The thumbnail is epic 😂😅
Yoga was not always about physical activities. Though asana is mentioned in Pathanjali's Yoga Sutra, it only meant a comfortable position for meditation. Yoga as a physical activity was developed only in the 17th century. Later on, western excercises like scout drill, circus contortionists, body builders etc. influenced yoga. The so called "Surya Namaskar" was only developed in 1938 by the king of Aundh in his book The 10 Point way to Health. Yoga took some western excercises and refashioned it by just adding a folded hands gesture.
Correct, I too read about the history of Yoga.
LMFAO , Yoga as a physical activity came around only in the 17th century??? 😂😂😂🤣, you probably read history of Yog from WhatsApp 😂
Bro's a true WhatsApp historian
Bro's WhatsApp chats are crazy 💀
Can I get a source on that, unable to find any credible sources supporting your assertions man.
Liver Doc podcast with Beer Biceps: Any clue when it's hitting our ears? 🎙️🍺
The comments by men were more misogynistic than her post. They were blaming urban women and feminism for PCOD and other health issues 🤡
So you're saying work-family imbalance, hookup culture and blunder feminist narratives haven't affected women? 😂😂
pranav i don't really think anyone is stupid enough to believe this bs,many people just create there own version of existing exercise to gain fame
well i do gym but know the importance of yoga .. look at this guy in video never workout lol.... and say anything don't know is suedo science ..
Thumbnail 💀☠️
the thumbnail 😂💀💀
@pranav I request you change your monitor setup a bit so that you look at the camera while reacting. That would be more engaging.
Whats mysog... here. It looks like you have radica. opinions on everything.
Many woman do with their choice too. My family live peacefully. We have divided our duties. Sometimes man also do jadu and pocha.
Claiming yoga as the biggest pseudo science without checking other countries pseudo sciences is extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence kinda fallacy
yeah, very extraordinary claim which he never claimed in the first place.
Very well articulated.
That Thumbnail though 😂
the thumbnail 😭😭😭
Hey whats written in the simha asan video. Something like was underconfident and Hr called. I couldnt read
Yo that thumbnail doh, niceeeeee
I asked in a video about derailed video exposing yoga
Its quite required
And u cant say it is less harm full
Yoga gurus treat spinal problem patients with these asanas and its really worse and affects a lot
And these are very bad practices which needs to be stoped
Yeah my aunt had a spinal problem and it got solved with the help of yoga and ayurveda.
@@sanathanadharma108 is she alive ?
@@y1.5 yeah, she is
@@sanathanadharma108 Yeah my aunt's condition got worse by ayurveda. She required modern medicine after that. What's your point.
@@harsh9023 what condition did she have? And also if someone in my family gets any disease our first medicine is always ayurvedic medicine. ayurveda is always our first option. Especially for diseases related to body pain or stomach related problems. I am also a daily yoga practitioner and i have got benefitted immensely from it. Also for some diseases ayurveda won't work. Ayurveda mostly focuses on prevention of diseases rather than cure. So there are some ayurvedic medicines that we have to consume everyday even if we have no diseases.
Doing some kind of yoga is advised by Psychologists, therapists and psychiatrists, also science is not just about denying, the problem here I feel that people will take it as Yoga don't do anything at all, while some of yoga is just stretching but some yoga is beneficial also it contains breathing exercises like mindfulness recommended by Sam Harris or Yuval Noah Harari. Some Yoga can be dangerous if not done under well trained instructor or done if you have some prevailing conditions, similar to taking medicines if you are allergic to it. Please try doing some easy yoga in morning time with fresh mind with proper breathing and it's not a cure but it will be act like prevention which is better than cure. It's mixed of betterment for mental and physical health for your well being
I completely agree with you.
I felt it was parody video 😂
Chakki chalasana 😂😂
And that thumbnail 😆
The only yoga i do is Suryanamaskar. I spam 12 of them everyday which makes my body warmed up and streched before my main workout
thats good actually for warmup
wth is wrong with thumbnail
please make video on bhavishya malika my feed is filled with a lot of psudoscience videos
Thumbnail OP🍷
Just completed 2 sets of leg raises before taking a look at my notifications and then watching this.
Yoga has been seen to be a good adjuvant, but its not something that is a full cure. If people already have mobility issues, it is also possible.that Yoga will exacerbate these issues sometimes. Stretches are for everyone, yoga is just a form.
Thanks pranav:)
Like the first clip, construction workers also do these yoga. But they are there because they don't have any choice
I don't thing any of bullshit that first lady said is mentioned in yoga
That thumbnail though!!
Recipe of Yoga:
Step1: Find any indian task and select a pose or activity from it.
Step2: Label that pose in its sanskrit equivalent.
Step3: Associate chakra pseudoscience with it.
Step4: Associate this pose or activity as a solution to a random set of emotional and medical issues.
Step5: Formalize the whole thing by publishing books, articles and videos. Litter the whole media space with the same data so that newcomers can feel "oh its everywhere, must be true".
Step6: Because of step4 further label it as scientific
Rinse and repeat for new recipes.
😂😂
so u r sayin same about shaolin
@@Hindu9054 no. its about F1 formula racing.
@@rdm5547 see how shaolin moves got made. By daily home chores excercise
I can't tell if the first one is a joke or she actually thinks so
Similarly there are other dosas, like idly and appam
Category mistake 😂
Also state some which are useful also in main video please 🥺
The thumbnail is crazy 🤣🤣🤣
The first video made me laugh out loud💀💀💀💀unbelievable amount of misogyny and normalizing gender norms
Women were not forced to do house chores bro. In that case, men were forced to do manual labour. But yes, her arguments were not smart, but not misogynistic.
sidha instagram se yahi yoga wali video dekhkr aa raha hun
Pranav a book recommendation for Yoga
Rāja Yoga by Swami Vivekananda
He was the one who 1st introduced Hinduism to the west.
Other classic by him like:
Karma Yoga
Bhakti Yoga
And Jnana Yoga ate also great.
This will help in your research.
Died in his 40s, in spite of doing Yoga
@@matrixsmarther2325yes yoga for age increasing was not done by him.
That too exists in Hatha Yoga but Swami Vivekananda was not a supporter of Hatha Yoga.
@@matrixsmarther2325correction: he died in his late 30s. I hope now you are more happy.
Not happy, just saying Yoga is a set of flexes, poses and exercises. Not a cure all
@@matrixsmarther2325 so what? Heart doctors also die from heart attack. Why you generalise things? This is life. Swami vivekanand used to smoke too. Also, do you know thay he practiced yog daily? You do not even know about his central philosophy.
Learn from his best things.
she was speaking about doshas ,I only know masala dosha.
is it dosa or dosha or dose
I do yoga for health and fitness, and it is good! But i dont believe that it can create magic like changing your luck, curing your dosa, etc
STREET CRED. 🤣🤣🤣
Do a video about shilajit.
3:29 my girlfriend getting ready to say sorry after crashing my car...
Not promoting anything here. But Simhasana is a real yoga pose. It is still practiced in many yoga centres.
what the heck i just watched in second clip
The 2nd one is too damn funny..
all microorganisms watching this video are like gajab bejathi
Can you please make a video on pam reynolds case ?? If any fellow atheist knows about it please clarify
Pranav. Awesome as always.
Like you I do a lot of Atheist vs Believer debates (iam an atheist myself).
Usually 90% of the time I can plow through the opposition arguments, except one.
The "perfect form of our universe" idea.
Like they pull out some percentage on fundamental particles and forces and says if 0.000001% changes we wouldn't exist.
"If God didn't exist how our universe got so fine tuned"
And basically uses these arguments and promotes religious ideas. How to counter that.
Thanks in advance
Universe is just an accident, it's neither perfect nor finely tuned. We just got fit into this, evolved as per conditions of the universe. If God has formed this complex Universe, then he must be much more complex, who created him? How can he come from nothing? If he can come from nothing, then Universe can also be formed on its own.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m ok.
Oh, that's anthropic bias. Imagine you walk into a room filled with a hundred people, and each person is given a lottery ticket with a unique number. The host of the event then announces, "The person with the winning ticket will receive a prize!"
Now, let's say you win the prize and you're standing there thinking, "What are the odds that I would win? It seems so unlikely!" However, if you take a step back and realize that someone had to win, and it happened to be you, it's not as surprising anymore.
In this analogy, you are the observer, and the winning ticket is the set of conditions in the universe that allow for intelligent life to exist. Anthropic bias is like realizing that, of course, you would observe winning because you wouldn't be there to think about it if you hadn't won. The fact that you're there to contemplate the odds is part of the conditions that led to your observation.
In the context of the universe, anthropic bias helps us understand that certain conditions must be in place for observers like us to exist and ponder the nature of the universe. It doesn't necessarily mean the universe was designed for us, but rather that we can only observe conditions that allow our existence.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m You're making a claim dude. Not so Agnostic, are we? We don't know how Universe came to being, that's agnosticism. Change your name to Gnostic.
But that 0.0000001 % will happen right , in that world they will also think and question like this only
what lose my faith in this nation were the comments, people be wilding man.
ps: 5:00 that core strength thou
I love Spinach and Paneer Dosha 🤣🤣🤣
Ahegao-asana
As a misogynistic person I'm completely okay with it.
3:33 even Pranav couldn't hold his smile
w thumbnail
Bhabhiji papad for Corona if can be main stream im India during covid...so these r usual things more could people follow...😂
3:30 Ahegao face... Why?
How come, in olden days, men and women lived long without doing any yoga and meditation? How do people of other countries lead healthy lives without yoga and meditation. ? Because they lead simple lives and ate simple food.
In older days, if a women give birth to 10 kids, 5 would've died. And other 2 would've not survived beyond 40.
@@Agnosticcc-x3m sometimes, the children did die, but those children who survived, lived for a long time with good health. The point here is, does yoga and meditation contribute to good health compared to those who do not believe in yoga and meditation.
@@amalibritto3031 How do you know a good amount of people saw the light of day beyond 50 years? And even if some people did live up to 100 years, how do you know that yoga was the reason?
@@amalibritto3031 yoga and meditation do have there health benefits tho? and where did you get the idea that people in older times lived longer ? tho who practice yoga will be far far healthier than a person who didn'T,and whose who did not have yoga did have different sets of physical exercises
That's myth bro. Barely anyone used to live upto 50 years. Our Grandparents believes that that humans back then used to live 200+ years
thumbnail 🤣🤣
Modern Medicine is wayyyy cheaper than Ayurveda.... If u do cost to benifit analysis
No one washes his clothes keeping such distance between the legs😅
3:33 RoAr LiKe A LiOn 😭😭
Why do you need evidence for practicing yoga?
I practice yoga twice a week, it has greatly increased my flexibility, sense of balance, relieved back pain, and given me a significant boost to my mental health. You could have been more fair to point out the positive benefits. Also; if people describe energy centers as chakras it is fair to be skeptical of the claims, but the fact is that located at each "chakra" is a nexus of vital nerves and/or organs that can be at better or worse states of health and these are affected by yogic practices. Perhaps you should do more research instead of being triggered because of the use of traditional terminology. Yes, there is plenty of psudoscience in the yoga world, but yoga is also a valuable and effective method. Especially as a preventative health measure.
What a thumbnail 😅😅😅
03:35 🥵🔥
💯
The original activities mentioned in the first reel doesn't have the full range of motion and order as the instructor does in demonstration. That itself is enough common sense to realise that it's gibberish.😂
pranav was pitying that girl
Yoga has emigrated to earn in $$$$$
thumbnail lmfao
day 999 of asking pranav to drop the name of his background musics
Bro it's given in desciption
not that bro, the other one which he uses@@harsh9023
1:59 That must be a 20 foot high cow she is milking, with hand movements so high, 20 feet is how tall the cow should be.
2:12 sus👀
03:37 you should !!!
The thing is, people are very attached with the beliefs of Yoga and old Indian traditions that they can't even realize that if those Indians who created the pseudoscience, were somehow made to understand the science wouldn't agree with these practices, even they would disagree. Just because Newton discovered gravity, that doesn't mean everything Newton says is true and every physicist must follow it. Yoga is a way of body stretching which could give you relief and there are many flaws in it too...Just saying 10% of something is so great that the rest 90% is all good is some dumb bullshit!! Same thing goes with religion...ancient people, for their time were advanced but not as good as modern Humans. Similarly if we forward a few 500 years people will be so advanced than us and we can't say this generation is the most advanced. Even though for now, Scientists believe something about Dark matter theories, they might get debunked in few years...but that doesn't mean in future scientists will say "oh people of 20th century were so advanced they knew the concept of say "xyz" because they boycott of Maldives stocks were similar to the pattern of stars in universe.
it's just 'glorified Street Circus'. So doing it have mere so called advantages only, but all the deadly risks.‼️
Bruh seriously. Then why athiest are doing yoga in so called civilized western country. .i myself do yoga and saw clear and effective changes in my body and it is not some simpl e body movements that makeup yoga it is very complex.not like push ups . weight lifting .yoga make overall body healthy &strong from muscle to bones etc.
Traditional Men were so stiff because they didn't do 🦆 aasana
Unless we prove that the Ramayana is purely fictional, hindu nationalists can always make claims about ancient technology etc., well if Rama flew on a winged chariot, sure they can also say that vimana technology or whatver existed
you cant prove that because it aint pure fictional . it is a true story with exaggeration and bringing magic and supernatural to make it interesting . ramayan is like a drama based upon true story with fiction aspects
I am following her for so long and it did cure my headache.
Sarcasm
😂😂
Dont take pranV seriously. He is biased highly. Just do yog daily and do some strength training as well. Yoga is all about making us flexible. Both running and pranayam are great in giving oxygen.
@@theplmotivationofficial yoga is not about making us flexible . its just one part of it . what u talking about is asana which a part of yoga . there are other aspects to it like u mentioned pranayama which focuses on breathing pattern. it is a collective set of 8 aspects including discipline and all
3:30 nahh💀
Naruto universe has ‘chakra’ these pseudoscience peddlers have ‘kachra’ 🙄
Yoga isn't pseudoscience
It is these people who are spreading misinformation
maan, this is too cringe. i have to take breaks watching you 7min videos haha. how can people fall to stuff like this? dont they have critical thinking in india or what