How Good Is MoistCr1TiKaL At Commander? | Shuffle Up & Penguinz0 #55 | Magic: The Gathering Gameplay
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
- So just how good is Charlie At Commander? Time to find out! It's MoistCr1TiKaL vs Voxy vs Crim vs The Professor!
▶Are you looking to Shuffle Up & Play games of Magic: The Gathering over webcam? The "Looking For Game" section of our Patron Discord is 100% free and open to everyone: / discord
#magicthegathering #mtgcommander #commander
►Check out my guests' channels!
Charlie:
/ @penguinz0 and / @skillcheckshow
Crim:
/ @mtggoldfish
Voxy:
/ @voxytwitch
►Deck Lists
The Professor
• A Guide To Three Dog, ...
Crim
archidekt.com/...
Voxy
archidekt.com/...
Charlie
archidekt.com/...
►Credits
Lead Editor | Director: Kevyn Wallace
Editor: Theo Nguyen
Assistant Editor: Brian Sirk
Music / SFX: Def Cat @defcatofficial
Intro VFX: Kyle Sullivan, Kevyn Wallace
►Special Thanks
Josh-TheProxyGuy
Andre Garcia
Jebari Dean
►This episode is brought to you thanks to our wonderful Patreon community. Join to support the show, or just Shuffle Up & Play with other awesome people on our Patron Discord by going to / tolariancommunitycollege
►This show is made in part due to Card Kingdom. You can help us out by visiting our affiliate link at www.CardKingdo...
#MagicTheGathering #MTG #commander
►Not A Sponsor But We Love Them!
Infinitokens Rewritable Dry Erase Tokens: www.infinitoke...
What happens when Yugioh CZcamsrs TeamAPS try and play Commander? Watch me Shuffle Up & PLay with them here: czcams.com/video/exV3pXeNcwE/video.html
How does asmo work as commander since it has the ability casting cost you just pay the two more each time?
They didn't win in turn one
hahaha man thats great you gonna introduce them to FAB?
We need MBT at Shuffle Up and Play!
please?
I can't believe the professor has gotten so big that he's now collaborating with the star of the Hunger Games
Katpiss neverclean?
@@Ulubai District 8 Medic
He literally carried the entire movie on his white or black t-shirted shoulders.
Almost as cool as his collabs with that dude who featured on the Spider-Man soundtrack
Who?
Charlie respects Prof & crew so much, he actually spent extra time to dress up. Instead of his usual white shirt, he brought out the black one.
For Charlie, that’s practically black tie. We should all feel honoured.
everything is black in this, shirts and set
Damn, you’re right! What a class act.
@@Pluto137 Not the white shorts/swim trunks.
Black shirt calls for a fancy occasion
"I wonder why this video is so long?"
*turn 2 Arbiter*
"Ah"
which reminds me... I really do need to find a place for sh we oldrrd in my outlaws deck. just in case something like this happens in my games.
"Do you pay the one?" Voxy cackles, as she forces Prof to confront a world where Mana Crypt costs mana.
existentially devastating
Pain
happy to momentarily descend from the blind eternities to consult Crim with dual pollicis approval
Hey, I know you! You're that guy with that youtube channel!
Sam!!
The editor really did cook with that edit there. More of heavenly Sam approval please.
Voxy: "I didn't even do anything wrong!"
Editor immediately zooms in on Grand Arbiter Augustine IV
Immediately scrolled down after this moment to find this exact comment hahaha.
voxy knew how to play that card and what it would do. thus, she deserve to lose first. but her and the professor deserve to lose before crim because of their incessant whining about threat assessment and not doing anything about it, despite having that capability. Blue, white and red all have access to all sorts of removal. no excuse for the whining about threat assessment.
crim did really well though. he used his opponents against each other pretty effectively. I would even say, the guy knew that someone would eventually take care of the Augustine issue.
Charlie was in control the whole time though. you got to give the guy Uber props. I think he was my favorite out of the four
@@unanon_user Honestly Crim actually got a lot of value out of leaving Grand Arbiter alive when he absolutly could have decided to take it out but since he was so far ahead in mana production he used her board to distract while he built out
@@randombystanderd6759 oh, I definitely agree with that.
"There's a finite amount of fun to be had in any given game of magic, so I will steal my opponents' share." -- Voxy, probably
We need Prof Charlie and Kibler in a pod together to see who has the best hair in MtG
And Spice or Wubby
Kyle hill roasted once again
and Kyle hill
And we need YOU in Shuffle Up And Play!!!!!!
kyle hill too
57:23 only Charlie could pull the “in response I’d ask you not too” and have it work
Charisma 100
I wish Charlie dropped omniscience. I’m convinced he had it in his deck. when he kept drawing cards in the color blue my mind goes to omniscience and he was desperately trying to draw it to hand dump.
I've watched Magic content for a good long while now and I think "In response.. I'm gonna ask you not to" is the best play I've ever seen
It was so good imma try it at my next play just to see if it'll work
its like the meme of that kid with a knife;
"What's that in your hand?"
"A sheoldred!"
"NO!"
*runs a circle around the pool*
The flash to Charlie's sheoldred in hand made me crack up 😂
dude me too hahaha
Timestamp?
Edit* yeah that's pretty hilarious 😂
@@Juse2409 24:06
Even funnier that he had to takesie backsie it :D
huge 😂😂
Voxy out here making enemies like a true blue player.
I just built an Azorius flicker deck and a mono blue Octavia, neither deck has a single counter spell or Grand Arbiter diquebag. It was super fun this weekend.
@@BubblewrapHighwayI might make a locust god deck. not include any counters or bound spells. just token creators. could be fun
I haven't finished this yet but I will preemptively say that Crim can not be trusted.
Truer words were never spoken.
I would trust Crim with my board anytime!
I would trust Crim to pass on Consecrated Sphinx draws
We need an episode now with the master Chef @ChefPKR @TolarianCommunityCollege, please!!
Crim brought Prof from 31 to -2 by moving cards around
The editor was on fire this episode. Also I’m legit shocked how well Charlie immediately slotted in with Voxy, Crim, and Prof - it was a crazy fun game to watch
"at insta-speed I'm gonna scoop" 🤣lol
21:57 “I didn’t even do anything wrong!”
THEN IT CUTS TO A CLOSEUP OF AUGUSTIN LMAOOOO
she had to know. after all, she was the one who put that card in her deck in the first place
If a white/blue player says they didn't do anything wrong they're either waiting to do something heinous or are lying.
@@kennethmorgan8795 ain't that the truth? 🤣
The professor did give me some ideas on how to better upgrade my Aura deck. so I don't end up like him...
Prof having Voxy build an Arzorius deck, a colour set she never plays, only to suffer at the hands of Augustin really feels like the second coming of "You handed him dirt, water and a 44 Magnum".
I was not expecting to hear a russian Badger quote in a prof comment section
@@grahamross889Tbh it doesn't even register as a badger quote for me, in my brain it's firmly filed under Lythero.
@@GumshoeClassic that is really fair, I don't think either of them said it but it was badger who chose the fighters thats why I said him
but, there were definitely other cards she could have picked to make blue spells cheaper to cast. like the sapphire medallion.
@@grahamross889one of Badger’s friends said it
"Just a little Crim off the top" was such an underrated joke. None of them even acknowledged it. I did though prof! Kudos!
I am glad you appreciated it.
"No blocks mistress" is going to be regular lingo in our play group now lmao😂
slightly tanned Voxy can't hurt you.
never mind she played grand arbiter on turn 2, tanned Voxy is a menace
Voxy is the future of Blue
May god have mercy on us all.
Blue White, so she can play Mesa Falcon.
I hope the professor isn't the future of Aura users... 😭
The one "fuck you Crim." from Voxy at the end that made it in uncensored was fantastic.
*Elesh Norn*
Holy Gix that one caught me off guard
Timestamp?
1:08:39
I can't believe Crim had difficulty pronouncing Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar. It's not that hard!
It's pronounced just like it's spelled
@@average_person444it's literally in the card
yeah its pronounced Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar
Never trust anyone who can pronounce this card.
@@marc0s158remys song really helps with pronouncing her name
*Voxy raises mana cost
👉👈 “I’m small bean, don’t attack”
Man, it blows me away how kind Tolarian Community College is to collab with smaller CZcamsrs
CZcamsrs? You talking about the hunger games actor right?
1:01:25 "I know you are the teenager at this table because you are just sitting there playing with yourself" is INSANE 😭😭💀
😂😂😂
Target Voxy reveals her mind and puts it into the gutter 😂
Every pod needs a (reluctant) villain 😈
You were far from reluctant. Enthusiastic, some might say.
don’t lie voxy you revel in chaos
Reluctant?
This video is proof of why everyone actually loves you
53:34
You know Crim's c o o k i n g when you hear "what's the life totals" and there's 20 minutes to go
I swear, the moment he brought out mirkwood bat? I know exactly what it was going to happen. that strategy has been used against me so many times. I can't believe none of them went after the bat. The bat deserves the same threat level as Augustine.
@@unanon_user "Oh, it's just a clunky common rarity creature that doesn't even see play in pauper. Meh."
😂 SO MUCH BURN
24:07 may be the funniest thing i have ever seen, especially with the art where sheoldred specifically shushes the camera
Plot twist: Crim purposely didnt get rid of arbiter to keep the heat on Voxy until his board was built
Agreed... he had 2 mana sources that made up for it, so he was ahead the entire time even without considering how many land charlie and prof missed.
The real question is whether he let Charlie win for content. Who is more likely to kill me, the guy with the under-developed enchanter board or the ninjitsu guy with 50 cards
Charlie genuinely seems like a lot of fun to have in the pod.
He's legit a super nice guy.
I think it’s so fitting that Charlie doesn’t like travel so they all went to him
Oh shit yeah he's scared of flying, that explains the set
Ooh now I understand the set! It's very wholesome of them to reach him
Ohhhhhh, I did not get that lol.
@@Neosfotty117yeah that’s his set from skill check I believe, always love when creators can collaborate and are willing to make accommodations for each other
@@Neosfotty117Can you blame him for being scared of flying with all the nonsense happening to practically every 737 every other day? Shits WILD
“Would you rather win the game or draw 25 cards?”
I’ll draw 25. I can always win next game.
I would rather draw 25 and make everyone else work for the win...
I'll draw 25 cards as well. At that point, if I can't win, that's just my own damn fault.
Honestly the 25. If i cant get the land drops i need with 25 cards then i wasnt gonna win anyways 😂
I love how they talked about the evils of blue, but the tax ability is the white side of arbiter.
21:58 Voxy saying I didn’t do anything wrong and it cutting to the arbiter was the greatest edit I’ve seen in a while
Editor, the snap zoom on Arbiter after Voxy said she did nothing wrong was perfect. You are awesome.
I love that everyone is giving the editor props for their comedic timing. It’s deserved because the laughs are appreciated
I’m actually very proud of Charlie. While he’s been collecting for a while, he’s only started learning Magic somewhat recently. But he is learning quick and you can see his grasp on the game increasing with every video. I’m excited to continue seeing him learn and grow
@@jvlian02 really? Tolarian Community College just told me Charlie has been playing Magic his ENTIRE LIFE, literally from birth. Came out in his white shirt just slinging spells
iirc He used to be addicted to MTG and came back recently
@@gtguilty to cracking boxes & collecting, but he has not actually played until a couple months back.
So yeah, he's fairly new to playing.
@@Detwinnn bro why do you think your salty opinions are so important you need to keep repeating them? You sorta fan that makes fandoms worse with your gatekeeping and cynicism. Like why are you even here? Just to try and ruin the vibes?
@@__So___So__ I’m so sorry for making a joke 🙄
43:38 The professor genuinely tweaking after having to deal with taxation without representation for the entire game and not being removal'd by Crim for the second time
1:08:40 Voxy says 'Emrakul' but the real word lol
31:10 “right in front of my salad”
And no one else at the table laughed at that reference
The cultured members of the audience did.
Maybe cos it wasn't funny!
I love cum!
@@brendans1983 No, it was funny
This time tag doesn't show them saying the reference
This has "Dad and his three children playing card games" energy all over it and I could not be happier.
Prof was beset on all sides😂
When the editor zoomed in on the Sheoldred in Charlie's hand I legitimately laughed out loud
Fun fact: you can Ninjitsu in creatures after the first original creature has dealt its damage. That way Charlie could've actually dealt a light slap to prof :)
how can voxy claim this is her first time playing blue? she had crabs!!
The Prof getting knocked out by a commander he chose simply to troll his student into reading a long word was la crème de la crème
Wait! PROF ISNT IN HIS SIGNATURE SEAT
I'm not even in my signature set.
Sus.
Super sus. Sussy baka
Super sussy bake
@@TolarianCommunityCollege that's why you lost
I love how Charlie and Crim have quotes over their names, yet Voxy is just Voxy. Respect.
"The renowned Hearthstone content creator that sometimes play MTG" is too long, it just didn't fit in.
Voxy: “Everybody’s attacking me! I didn’t even do anything wrong!” *close zoom on Grand Arbiter Augustin IV* 😂😂😂
This episode was insane
A wild Hänno appears. This crossover just keeps getting bigger.
Hey it's that MC Thunder guy ❤
“You’re more of an Aeris guy instead of a Tifa guy. That’s pretty interesting, pretty telling I’d say.”
*Aerith
@@Sweetroll_Wolfie You’re wrong and stupid and I hate you. It will never be Aerith. The Japanese were wrong cause that sounds like garbage.
“Oh but it’s kinda how they say Earth”, yeah and that’s dumb. Her name is Aeris.
"Whooooo baby! That's what we've been waiting for, that's what it is all about!" I know MTG is a very popular hobby but I never knew Charlie played MTG. Love it whenever we get celebrities or CZcamsrs as guests on this channel.
He loves collecting and he started getting into opening packs for all sorts of CCGs which eventually led to Magic, which afaik is the one that he ended up liking the most (which yeah it's the best one imo), it's been really cool seeing it happen in real time as a big fan and an even bigger mtg nerd lol
Skill Check is a channel where you can see more of Critical playing MTG if you want.
Charlie has like the full arabbian nights set fully blinged out. He was always a TCG collector, and now introduced to EDH, he became a player. He just didn't like the other formats and never knew of EDH.
lots of people play magic the gathering, even NFL players. that pretty much tells you how popular it really is.
sam just appearing as a holy visage to crim was great
Voxy staxing the table and then forgetting the cost reduction applies to all spells is pretty funny
That was so much fun to watch! I'm in tears! The highlights was definitely the Grand Arbiter, the Charlie Haircut, and the Classic Angry Professor.
The amount of hair on this table is nuts.
It needs Kibler and Hill.
Charlie finding out in one turn why Grand Arbirter is so hated but have to pay 5 mana, to play 3 manas worth of spells, just to not have mana left over to do what you want was just perfect.
Prof, I hope you're aware you can never take back "no blocks, mistress"
So obligatory rules correction for interaction. Chun Li does not cast the spells for free. It simply allows you to copy the spells and then play them if you want. All costs still apply
Yeah, what's crazy is that apparently the "cast for free" version of the card still isn't power crept enough since it doesn't have haste.
I came here to say this. Too bad no one told Crim!
I mean, Voxy literally pointed that out IN the video. Your comment wasn't necessary.
Seeing Crim and Prof interacting reminds me of my high school band director who got me into Magic. The exasperating friendship is hilarious to watch and so, so relatable to me
we, for sure, need another round with this crew. Easily one of the funniest crews alongside any spice + rhysitc study constalation.
Voxy: "Everyone's attacking me! I didn't even do anything wrong!"
Enter Grand Arbiter, center stage
😂
not just on center stage, but doing a nice little striptease for the professor. 🤣
(Charlie’s life total goes to 0.)
“This stinks more than the dumpster SpongeBob was in, looking for his missing name tag. Well that’s about it, see ya.”
Why you spreading misinformation?
@@kathleenmeyerowitz7187 it’s not, it’s a joke on Charlie’s mannerisms is all
Well the poor guy went and said these cursed words 1:07:02
It’s been nearly 15 years since I’ve seen it in play, but the moment Augustin hit the field my entire body twitched.
This has been the funnest shuffle and play I have watched, I would love to see more of this group!!!!!! Funny and entertaining, loved every bit of it :)
Its an amazing episode. The energy of the group feels natural!
We had so much fun!
Was a great group and very fun video!
sure professor, why didn't you have enough removal anyway? you had the colors for it. you could have chaos warped that Augustine into oblivion. then had enough time to vandalblast crim
HE'S PULLING HIS CARD OUT!
Calling Voxy a scoundrel had the perfect amount of salt for a friendly game.
I have two Aura decks? this game told me that I don't have enough removal in one of them. The other, is meant to make me the threat. so I can get through a game a whole lot quicker. I'm going to have to do some figuring....
I love the sass coming from the editor(s) 😂The quick cuts to cards on the board and in hand while the players protest they are not the problem are hilarious!
That fact that the prof is collabing with my favorite youtuber who's also piloting my favorite commanders is amazing
“You can’t play stoke the flames, that’s a red card Voxy🤓” Crim said mockingly followed by laughing at his own joke.
I find this hilarious because I would do the exact same thing.
That Sheoldred reveal in Charlie's hand was gold hahaha i love the editors at TCC
I love how animated Crim was about Chun-li, but he misread the card. She can't cast her spells for free.
Several of them are cheaper because of Arbiter, but that could be solved by removing the damn thing. Not to mention that he had Cookbook for a fourth food to just remove both of them.
The chemistry here was fantastic, love all the guests. favorite episode so far 😆
Very entertaining episode so far.
Voxy has peak little sibling energy or if you are uncharitable Sheldon energy (the big bang one) 22:06
"Everybody is attacking me! I didn't even do anything wrong!"
*hard cut to Augustin sitting on her board*
Crim: yugi would never fuck over Joey their best friend
Series 0 Yugi: are you sure about that
The betrayals in this episode had me SCREAMING!!
Most clutch counterspell I've seen.
That delayed responds made it for me.
@@sethlennberg4516 Absolutely. 😂 I was like NO WAY lmao
LOL 24:08 when Charlies Sheoldred is just exposed 🤣🤣🤣
Prof should have gained 6 life when that creature with lifelink delt six damage to itself
"right in front of my salad?" I'm sorry but that was just hilarious
Turn 1 sol ring into turn 2 grand arbiter is fucking wild. Wouldn't blame the other 3 for scooping immediately.
Swords to plowshares? Lightning bolt?
@@DiscardatRandom Ah yes, the classic, just have the answer to the card, so dumb.
@@zsorens4570 i love that you are insulting someone for a productive answer when your answer is to literally ragequit like a child xD
@@imabossDJ No no. Its a proper response. The answer shouldn't always be "always have removal in hand"
Especially when its a card that makes said removal cost more.
@@imabossDJ in what universe is "o btw here are 2 random cards that can remove arbiter" in any way helpful. It isn't insightful to say this removal spell can remove this creature for 2 mana. Having arbiter out on turn 2 with a sol ring is just disgusting mana advantage and if it lasts for more than a few turns can put you way ahead of everyone else.
I think it's nice that Prof has a painting of Charlie on his new set.
“At instant speed, I’m gonna scoop.”
“Why is everybody attacking me? I didn’t to anything wrong!”
*cuts to grand arbiter*
At 21:57 Voxy say, “I didn’t even do anything wrong.” Then to shot of Grand Arbiter Augustin IV.
Prof's so big he got Floridian Jesus on.
Did you notice the charlie jesus pic behind voxy
Top tier editing on this one lol
This episode was fantastic! One of the best ever on the channel, the table dynamics were perfect! Well done!
Letting that Augustin live so long is like a violent crime xD
Just feels what Prof suffers for so long !
"well you've seen this before.... but now its more expensive" lol
Rookie mistake, Crim! Everyone knows that Joey loses to Yugi in their big showdown at Duelist Kingdom!
Don’t worry, your blind sister will still have her operation.
But remember Yugi didn't pull it off, during the last moment it was joey who shouted at Yugi's creature to attack him
My dream commander game is now Moistcritikal, Maldhound, Smallant and the professor.
I'd watch that game.
"At instant speed, I going to scoop." Love it xD
Voxy sealed her fate when she played that accursed card
It always feels weird seeing the professor outside his set. Like learning that teachers don't sleep at the school.
Charlie really was the hero huh. Both coming with a singular clutch counter and killing the bats abuser. Based
Crossover of the century
I remember being subbed to prof around 20-40 thousand subs a long while ago now and it’s crazy to see how far he’s come along with this wonderful channel:)