Comparing Seated Exercise Ellipticals - One Big Difference!
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 07. 2024
- Comparing Seated Exercise Ellipticals - One Big Difference!
CZcams Channel: / thebobbradcrew
Website: bobandbrad.com/
Instagram: the_bobandbrad_crew
TikTok: thebobandbradcrew
Alex, Mike & Liz review their favorite seated exercise ellipticals. (Cubii Jr./Desk Cycle 2/Stamina InMotion E1000.)Watch the video to find out which one is right for you.
Interested in learning about the products mentioned in today's video:
1) Cubii Jr. - amzn.to/2QgXm9M
2) Desk Cycle 2 - amzn.to/32iY63D
3) Stamina InMotion E1000 - amzn.to/3hqpYZZ
Welcome to our channel!
This CZcams Channel is a secondary channel associated with "Bob & Brad" The Most Famous Physical Therapists on the Internet.
(In Our Opinion Of Course)
Our goal of this channel is to cover anything related to health, fitness and your overall well-being. Mike, Alex, Liz & others will be reviewing health/fitness/pain relief/therapy products as well as providing content related to Bob & Brad's Channel.
Please subscribe to us and leave comments.
If you have a product related to anything in the health/fitness/therapy industry feel free to contact Mike Kenitz at the email listed below.
For business inquiries and product submissions email: kenitzmike@yahoo.com
Visit us on our other social media platforms:
Website: bobandbrad.com/
Facebook: / bobandbrad
Instagram: / officialbobandbrad
Twitter: / ptfamous
Bob and Brad’s Products:
Grip and Forearm Strengthener: store.bobandbrad.com/
Wall Anchor: store.bobandbrad.com/
Booyah Stik: store.bobandbrad.com
Knee Glide: store.bobandbrad.com
Check out our shirts, mugs, bags and more in our Bob and Brad merchandise shop here:
shop.spreadshirt.com/bob-brad
Check out other products Bob and Brad Love:
www.amazon.com/shop/physicalt...
Check out Bob & Brad on CZcams by clicking here:
/ physicaltherapyvideo
Medical Disclaimer
All information, content, and material of this website is for informational purposes only and are not intended to serve as a substitute for the consultation, diagnosis, and/or medical treatment of a qualified physician or healthcare provider.
Affiliate disclaimer:
Keep in mind that we may receive commissions when you click our links and make purchases. However, this does not impact our reviews and comparisons. We are highly selective in our products and try our best to keep things fair and balanced in order to help you make the best choice for you.
I have had my Stamina in motion, since they 1st came out. I broke my leg in 2010 that is when I really started using it, (used it for rehab). Have rode it 1000's and 1000's of miles (15-50 MILES A DAY 5 DAYS A WEEK, FOR 11 years), with little to no maintenance. We oiled some moving parts. It was sold as a standing machine at first, with no mention of sitting whatsoever. I figured out you could spin it around and use it for sitting, hence perfect for my rehab. I even showed my PT how this would work, and how he could stick one in a corner for clients to sit and warm up. He was impressed with the e1000. Over the course of the next couple of years we started seeing ads for it being used as a rider. PERFECT! Love love love it. I went back to work 5.5 weeks before they said I would be able to go back. Hard work and determination and the correct machine pays off.
The fact that the Cubii did not require exaggerated knee movements was the most important function for me since there is not a lot of space under my desk; 6 inches from knee to underside of desktop, to be precise.
If I had to be honest based on experience…it can feel a little bit unnatural overtime with to much ankle movement. There are cases where I even place my feet so far forward on the pedals just to mimic the more familiar bike pedaling movement which feels less weird.
Thanks for doing this review! Seeing the actual knee movement in comparison between the Cubii and the DeskCycle 2, allowed me to determine that the DeskCycle 2 would be too large for my desk space since I have the keyboard drawer. Cheers!
I really liked your review-- especially your comparative analysis-- thank you for making this video--it's just what I needed.
Excellent review thank you guys. Is very interesting to see the one on the right elevating your knee like a bike where's the other two may be more suited for under the desk
Now that it’s been a year any additional thoughts between these three? I like that the in inmotion you can stand on, that the cubii is smart and that the desk cycle has a lot of movement because I feel like it’ll work out harder? Which is the best workout?
I just love my Cubii Jr. I have it since it came out and have had no problems with it.
Some people do use the display screens, like in our family, we each try to get 10,000 revolutions a day. It's a competition between the kids in online school and parents working from home. I'm getting ready to buy another one, because I have begun to hate sharing, and I want to put in more hours with it under my desk.
on the market for one now, thanks for the vid!
I think they are all good to use for a few minutes every few hours to keep your blood circulation going.
Only desk cycle allows more stationery ankle and better thigh work. Those other ones are constantly flexing your foot which is unnatural for peddeling and going to give you tendonitis in a hurry.
I'm wondering what ergonomic difference there is for your back and long term health between the bike pedals vs the paddle type exerciser. Also is there any concern or issue with having to push down vs pushing forward? Was that what was meant by using a 2x4? to raise the front so you could pedal at more of a foward angle?
Did you get the answer in those 2 years? I have the same doubts.
I am recovering from THR and my PT is ending next week. My PT recommended I join a gym (too expensive) or purchase a stationary bike and/or treadmill. I don't have room for either and they are very expensive. In your opinion, is the Ellitical the best option for me! Thank you for the review, I always turn to Bob and Brad when I have questions regarding my many surgeries, PTs and recoveries. I'm kind of clumsy! The three of you are fantastic and bring the same humor, confidence and knowledge to the website. Cheers!
Based on your video -- which I think is very nicely done -- I chose the Cubii Jr. The price was $179 with free shipping from Costco, and that seemed like too good a deal to pass up. Setup wasn't difficult. I've been using it for an hour on each of the last four days, and I already know that I'm going to return it. Even at maximum (level 8) resistance, I don't feel any sort of burn, and I certainly don't break a sweat. The really annoying thing is that it keeps sliding gradually forward, meaning I have to stop and re-position the unit every 3-4 minutes. This happens whether I use the rubber mat or just place it on my living room carpet. I suspect the only way to prevent that is to anchor the unit against a wall or very heavy stationary object. Since I raised the issue, can you (or any of your viewers) comment on whether the other two ellipticals have the same problem with sliding forward?
Yes, we typically placed them up against a wall in our clinics. But they all slide to a point.
Wow. The Cubii is $339 in Canada. Not sure what country you found it for under $200, but it’s wasn’t in Canada.
I was wondering if these things actually gave users a work out, as it’s looks really really easy,
@@YellowPineappleHoyas I decided to keep mine after figuring out how to take care of the "sliding" problem. I wouldn't call it a serious workout, since I know I can burn a lot more calories on a treadmill or my good old Nintendo Wii Fit. Just the same, it's perfect for when I've blocked out time to watch a movie or sports event on TV.
By now, you have probably seen Cubii's claim that you can burn 150 calories in an hour. I think that's questionable. Based on the unit's own digital readings, I would say 80 to 85 calories per hour would be more accurate, even with the resistance turned up to the maximum setting. If someone else is getting significantly higher calorie burn rates, I hope they'll reply.
@@chowpuppy4537 thanks so much for replying. I think I’m going to give it a try!
question! I want to buy one of these for my grandma at age of 80, she had bad leg functionality, i would like she can have some thing to excercise without standing up for too long and risk of falling. im wondering if this is a good choice
do any of the sitting ellipticals register ''steps / distance'' the way my iPhone program does?
I bought a later version of the inmotion just now second hand. It has a handle and resistance bands. It was 35 dollars!
Perfect Video. Chat GPT rates these as the top three brands for quietness, stability, ability for on-desk app display via your phone or otherwise and some other thing I forgot that was tops in these brands.
Thanks! I have both of the end ones, not the cubi though. Was thinking about it. Great review!
thanks guys ....awesome as usual👍✌
I have the ELLIPSE by LegXersize. It’s around $250-$260+ tax. It has a handle & comes w/ a mat. It’s sturdy, yet not too heavy.
It’s a motorized seated ellipse machine. I absolutely LOVE MINE! Especially if you’re trying to rehabilitate your legs or back. I feel the burn all the way up to my low-mid back!
The price is worth every penny!!
I feel like the highest level of resistance is too easy. Is it supposed to be that way or is mine broken? Can definitely tell a difference between the levels of resistance tho, just not enough.
I found a beautiful Cubii at the thrift store for $14.99!
Found a desk cycle 2 for $15 yesterday, always a great feeling to find a gem!
What do you think about the lateral elliptical or pedal exercisers (like Scoop)? Better or worse than traditional seated elliptical or pedal exerciser? Do they work inner and outer thighs and gluten? Can I still work at a desk while using them?
I hope you're still answering questions on this video... which of these would give the most difficult workout when turned up to the highest level ?
They’re all pretty similar honestly, the Cubii Jr or InMotion may have a little more resistance.
Stamina/InMotion has a much higher resistance level than the cubii
Plus the InMotion can be used like an elliptical, I put it in a doorway, so if I lost my balance I could hold onto the doorframe. So you are getting a full legs, and booty workout. Plus the resistance.
Would these types of bikes help with legs and feet swelling when sitting for long periods of time ?
Great video! Thanks!
which one is the quietest?
The cubi is working your ankles and the other ones seem to work the knees and hips more. Be moderate no mater what you use.
Which one for ACL injury non surgical?
Which is better for TKR Rehab ? Cubii or mini bike.
Thanks for your Extra info about this topics
I have been trying to find out if the Cubii Jr1 has the app! You don't even mention that.
I’d say the 2 on the left are more like ellipticals and the one on the right is like a stationary bike. For people with limited range of motion in the ankles, the two on the left would be difficult to use
But… Those are the people who need that ankle exercise - like me!
Thank you for making this video. It was very helpful.
Strange that you've compared the DeskCycle 2 instead of a DeskCycle Ellipse. The DeskCycle 2 works like an under desk bike than an under desk elliptical like the other two featured here.
I was wondering about that.
Looking for one of these for the office so I can keep active while seating. I like the desk cycle for how it appears to exercise more muscles and closer to actual cycling but I'm concerned about my knees hitting my desk top. There's some cheapo and basic ones on Amazon around $40-$50 that I was curious about trying out before committing $200 for one of the higher end models. Those cheap ones any good?
What's rong with the 40$ one . Cuz I just got that one that has resistant knob and a digital counter the calories and time .
I have a tiny apartment looking for something I can use in the living room standing as well as sitting
Not sure if you're still answering questions on this video, but do you know anything about which positions you must be sitting in so you don't harm your back while using these? I have a chair that is very adjustable and I'm wondering if I can use this in a bit of a reclined position instead of sitting straight up.
Hello I hope you are well. Did you get the answer in these 2 years? I have the same doubts.
Do you think they all burn the same amount of calories??
I would like to know the difference between mini elliptical vs elliptical machine with handles on them
I would love a Cubii since I have a disability which effects my bones and I need to strengthen my legs more becsuee they aren't stable enough when I walk.
Same. I just wish they didn’t cost $300 Canadian
The InMotion Ellipticals have been used for years in our clinics without any problems and they're more reasonably priced.
@@YellowPineappleHoyas They are discounted on TSC right now!
@@blondewglasses thanks. I actually got one already, but my friend got the deal!
Love my Cubii Pro. Connects to my smartphone. Keeps my info and charts it over time. Plus they have free daily workouts on line. Due to severe knee problems I needed something with a smooth motion. I paid $365. I figured $1 a day for the first year. I’m so worth that! It’s worth every penny.
Hey Guys, i'm a fit person looking for a way to do 20 min cardio training to start th day and do a little workout before i go to the gym in the evening. Does such an under desk Eliptical makes sense for me and is it a real alternative to a free standing cardio bike? I have not much space in my flat, so an under desk solution would be perfect for me.
Personally I’d rather use a full size bike like the Schwin airdyne we reviewed or flexispot desk bike.
The in motion as least had the option to stand and you can turn up the resistance
Will this get you ready for the Tour De France?
I just had my 2 week post op visit for a L4L5 laminectomy/discectomy. I do have foot drop. I was told since I am motivated I can do strengthening exercises on my own. Would the seated elliptical help with foot strengthening?
just bought through your link. hope this works
It would be nice if you touched on how much of a workout a user gets.
You can increase the resistance on these ellipticals, we had them set on easy for the video. They're not going to have as much resistance as a NuStep or Stationary Bike but can still do a decent job.
@@TheBobBradCrew thanks very much!
I feel like the Desk Cycle would give more of a full-leg workout compared to the other two? Given how much more the upper legs move?
Thank you, this was very good. Mike and Liz need to speak louder, it was difficult to hear them.
Thanks for the feedback!
Thank you.
Which one is the noisiest or the most quiet?
They’re all quiet
Nice review. Can you give detail as to how loud each one is while being used? That is a make a break for me. Thank you!
They’re all quiet
The cubii is very quiet. I never hear it.
@@nancybanks8151 Yes, I don’t hear it either, thank you.
Yes especially in an apartment building with neighbors living below you?
Love the desk cycle 2 oh it burns if you use it properly
I have a Desk Cycle 2, but my knees hit the top of my desk. Any advice?
I appreciate you guys/ girl, but what are the benefits other than no blood clots???? I bought a Cubii Jr, I’m 71, no one walks with me because I’m too slow
Improved cardio vascular training, strengthening your heart & lungs. Range of motion and getting blood circulation to your legs. Once it becomes easy turn up the resistance knob or go for a longer duration. If you stop moving or walking things will progressive get worse and then transfers may become hard for you. So stay active as long as you can so you have a better quality of life for a longer period of time. 😊
Is this something a bedbound person could place on the bed to use.
Bob and Brad FitGlide
SIMPLE QUESTION.. For someone paralyzed meaning ZERO mobility. Is there an elliptical that will do ALL the work? Nobody is consistent in this answer.. some say yes others say no. Which is it? And which model? Etc..
Legsersize
can you petal with one foot?
Yes you can.
You did not tackle which ones burn the most calories
That all depends upon how hard you train, that has nothing to do with the machine.
I got the Cubi Jr today for $189/no shipping. ✌🏼
Where? I'm interested in getting one myself! :)
Got mine today $189, from QVC.
Free shipping.
Where did you get it
Why can't you stand on the Cubii?
Great review, thanks!
the foot pads are NOT meant for standing in ANY way. They are positioned for optimal seated foot placement. If you want a standing model, go for the Stamina InMotion ellipticals. I would suggest that you NEVER stand on a cubii!
Yes the InMotion pedals are designed for standing or sitting. You have to flip the machine around to stand on it. The other two elliptical pedals aren’t designed that way, they have a different pedal angle.
@@TheBobBradCrew I see, thanks for your reply. I ended up getting the Cubii jr 2. Its good so far!
The cycles with limited range of motion will aggravate the calf’s if you have calf’s prone to cramping. The one the young lady has involves more muscle groups and there is a smaller amount of pull on the calf’s, better for a workout AND less likely to cause calf cramps.
The comment i was looking for, thanks. Can you please expand more about this topic or tell me where I can find more info? These is like the most important thing about these bikes and is not talked about
Which one would you recommend for arthritic ankles?
What about noise level? I'm going back into the office and I don't want to become public enemy #1 among my new coworkers.
This is what everybody wants to know... 🤓🖐️
They replied to another comment and said they were all quiet
Roughly how mnay calories could these burn over 30 mins?
Depends on your weight and the speed you go.
thanks
I just bough the Cubil Jr. Compact from Costco for $70. (Reg. $249.99)
ty
I'm not digging the amount of ankle flexion in the leftmost two cycles. The DeskCycle looks like it actually engages more muscle groups and won't wreck the ankles over time. Probably the better option especially if someone has joint or connective tissue problems.
Why do the guys get named in the song but not Alex? Just weird
Does this help with restless legs?
magnesium and minerals in balance may help... my friend was told to also be sure to hydrate well.
When I cut carbs and sugar, it got rid of the restless legs issue.
And turmeric/1 TB. yellow mustard @ bedtime! @@catgil3
Poor circulation in feet and leg..perhaps this would help the lymphedema.
Yes! It will absolutely help with circulation if you're seated properly. It can get your blood pumping!
A massage is a great way to get the circulation going. I also have the InMotion Stamina and it works great.
Deskcycle elliptical was NOT used in the above video. User lady on the left, is using Deskcycle but again you shouldn't compare it to Cubii elliptical because it is a different type model.
I agree
The lady is a bike not an eliptical
The desk cycle looks better for shorter people, since it tilts up.
I bought the Cubii for $209 CDN at TSC which would be just $164 US
Where ?when?
Tractor Supply Company? hmm!
@@videosrus99 The Shopping Channel
Looks like the ellipticals afford more movement in the ankles which has to be good for strength, endurance, and circulation. The stamina covers this and you can stand on it so it would be similar to what you would get with a stair stepper maybe? I have a desk cycle and use it for legs and arms, I think I want more so I want a stair stepper or elliptical!
If you want to increase the challenge all you need is adjustable ankle weights you tie them a little higher than your knee and reduce tempo to a steady, smooth speed. This works really good for quads
Wait. Where is Bob and Brad?
On their channel! 😁
Anyone purchase one and been using it consistently and have good results?
I have the first one and I add ankle weights. I have not been active since pre covid but I can tell the difference in my legs and my stamina. It's made it easier to ride my Peleton. I use it sitting or standing. When I'm sitting I forget that I am using it. When standing I get a better workout.
I got a Cubii used like new. I’ve been finding the elliptical movement feeling a little weird in result of mostly ankle movement which I find unnatural compared to pedaling on a bike that I feel like I should’ve went for a stationary one like the Desk Cycle. Personal opinion though.
Is the guy in the middle Bobs son? The way he acts and moves and stuff reminds of him big time
Midwest accents... Wisconsin?
Yes MN/WI
Please note: If you do not have a very stable chair, with no swivel and no rollers, you will be hard pressed to use these devices. I bought one for under desk and quickly discovered that without locking down my office chair, this would not work. You can get replacement rollers that either lock under load or lock when not under load. About 55 bucks for the former. However, I had not way of locking out the swivel at work or in my home office chair. I rarely sit in any other type of chair and I need to be able to "slide" to multiple work stations in the office. Great concept and some very nice machines. Just beware, you must have a very sturdy chair to use them.
I have a bath stool that I bought to elevate my leg after I broke my ankle (because I could set it at any height and make my ankle less likely to swell). I sit on it now to use my DeskCycle at work. Not the most comfortable seat, but way better than my attempts in the past to use the tether that came with the DeskCycle and hold myself in place by gripping my desk. (I could do it, but it didn't allow me to type or do anything else at the same time, which defeats the purpose.)
The girls the cycle is a bike and it seems u r getting a better workout!
A better workout but seems more inconvenient for someone using at work because requires a tall desk with enough space under it and more movement of legs.
I got a Cubii in addressing the under desk space problem, but I’ve found that I won’t be using an exercise bike under a desk so it wouldn’t matter if it’s elliptical or stationary for me apparently. At the same time though the Cubii and likely other elliptical bikes does feel a little unnatural due to smaller pedaling and constant movements concentrated on the ankles.
I ordered the exercise bike on January 7th and it arrived on February 12th. czcams.com/users/postUgkxzg0clhbtRf2gGxPkVETFKJJKGqdsorQu The box must have been tossed around quite a bit because one whole side of the styrofoam was destroyed, and the other side foam was cracked. The Two zip ties holding the handlebars had broken loose and handlebars were loose in the box. There are two small holes in the foam on the right side of the handlebars, I guess from rolling around inside the box. Assembly was straight forward and easy. I am 6 ft 5 in 220 lb and the handlebars and seating positions fully adjustable and work great, I'm getting full leg extension. The noise level is very, very low and acceptable. The adjustment knob for the pressure on the flywheel works well also. The exercise bike is very well made, sturdy and easy move around. This is my first exercise bike and will keep me in shape over the winter. Update 3/19/21: when removing the sticker from the wheel, make sure you remove any sticker glue also. I thought mine was clean but I was getting a slight noise from the glue. Once cleaned off, its super quite. Also the monitor didn't work, tracked it down to the pickup device wasn't in the hole. Once I moved in the hole, it works fine. Do NOT put it in until it touches or it will damage the pickup.
You have an interesting accent. Where are you from?
MN/WI
This is very Canadian
I feel like i just watched an episode of Letterkenny.
Can you really use any of these under your desk? Seems like you would bang your knees...
Well I suppose it would depend upon the height of your desk. We mainly use them in skilled nursing facility’s with our rehab patients.
I have the Stamina e3000, as well as the Cubii Jr. I bought the Cubii specifically due to the hgt of my knees on the Stamina. Cubii is the way to go for lowest knee hgt under desk, but Stamina gives a great workout, and you can easily stand on it (w/ added resistance bands to attach to base). Both have great qualities, and are VERY sturdy!
@@cynthiac7434 thanks Cynthia for that added insight
@@cynthiac7434 Would you make a recommendation either way when it comes to noise? I live and work in a second floor apartment and don't want to drive the downstairs neighbors crazy.
@@andrewcrandall2419 Hi Andrew, I am so sorry I didnt see this sooner. I hope you've made a good choice in the interim. If not, I can tell you that the cubii is super quiet (whisper quiet) and doesn't make any noise to speak of. The other option is the InMotion ellipticals. The InMotion is a little higher profile (and your knees come up a little higher) but it is also very very quiet. Between the 2, either is a good option, but there are some differences. I can use the cubii seated only. The InMotion allows for seated or standing (providing you work up to it, or use a chairback next to it to balance yourself), and also some have resistance bands if you want to add to it. Another option is the way you 'pedal' it. You can do the flat-foot seated, and your knees do raise up higher, or you can turn the unit around (backwards, if you will) and put your feet on the ends of the pedal and 'push' with your foot. This keeps the knees lower and also changes the muscles/movement. I really like both units, the cubii and the InMotion, and would recommend either without any reservations. Also, I've had 2 InMotion units (only because I bought one for home and one for work) and the 2nd unit came with the bumpers on the end of the pedals to allow for foot placement on the 2nd option I mentioned above. That being said, I could still do the SAME foot placement & push movement w/o the added bumpers on the earlier model. Best! Cynthia
Mike you sound like Jordan Peterson.
The knees on the guy on the left and the middle guy aren’t coming up as high as the woman on the right, because all they’re doing is flapping their feet up and down.
How much did cubii pay u to review
$0 lol we got ripped off
Why is Liz going backwards, driving me mad!
You can go forward or backwards with all of these. It focuses more on your hamstrings then. 😁
You should have compared better models with the Cubi Jr
Thanks for the feedback
🤣
It doesn't look like your getting a workout....Its good for the elderly maybe...A waste of money
Nothing of value was said.
This could have been 3 minutes. Annoying.
Why do you guys sounds like that? You sound like you are making fun of Bob and Brad. Not funny.
Obnoxious
Guy in left irritates me
Useless video. What's the mechanism, warranty, anything. You gave us nothing.