On 27 October 2013, a series of bomb blasts rocked the Indian city of Patna, Bihar at a massive election rally for BJP Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi. Of the estimated 300,000 participants at the "Hunkar" rally, six people were killed and 85 others were injured in eight bomb blasts. Location: Patna Junction; Multiple locations at ... Attack type: Bombings Suspected perpetrators: Indian Mujahideen
Well, just because terrorist attacks happened in the past doesn't mean this government hasn't had failures in security. Just because I murder someone doesn't mean your murdering someone is all right. I will answer for mine and you will for yours. Also, the government that is sitting at the centre is the one we should be concerned about because it has the power to make decisions. I have many problems with previous governments, but what is the use of discussing the security failures of Indira Gandhi when we can't do anything about it today. So concentrate on the government in power- whoever they are.
Sanyal shines thanks to Gupta. His diplomacy and gradual drawing of Gupta into his conversation was brilliant. Many speakers would have been distracted, and irritated.
Hats off to SheGu to sit across a man with an intellectual capacity 10 times his own. Sanjeev didn't even try but demolished SheGu's agenda and many of the Congress cronies in the audience.
Propaganda is used to dehumanize and create hatred toward a supposed enemy, either internal or external, by creating a false image in the mind of citizens . Lenin once said: Of all the reactionary classes, we need to worry about everyone except the intellectuals. They will swallow anything.In simple words the more higher one’s IQ is, the more susceptible s/he is to propaganda, lies, indoctrination and bullshitting.
Why is the interviewer at pains to deny that your country has become safer during the present government as the guest and one of the audience highlighted. Can someone tell me if the interviewer is supporter of the previous regime in India because he keeps denying that one particular matter several times. Btw an interesting interview and India should be proud of having undertaken so many difficult reforms in such a short time.
Because that is what THE ENTIRE WORLD is being forced to believe by the Christians, the muslims, the whites, the commies, the seculars, the "NGOs," the congis, their chamchas, the NEHRU-GANDHI family & their bonded labors
He is a victim of extreme inferiority complex, like many of the pseudo-liberals in India who believe in a one size fits all model of the world politics, economy and culture.
Correct observation! He wrote a full length editorial about UPA should endeavour to come back on the back of Manmohan Singh's integrity (with all the baggage of mega corruptions/scams!). Many of these guys lived (literally) and have been living on the largesse of (fake) Gandhi family/Congress party fund!!
SG very lately has accepted a certain good has happened after BJP took over . He was trying to two the line that democracy is suppressed. To my mind congress started addressing the issue of corruption via scam expose some of which they themselves created by their wrong decisions and BKP is fighting hard to keep the country falling prey to terrorists, drugs ,naxals ,corrupt officials and practices.
I disagree with you, Govt. do wants to publicize it but you must have noticed the question put by the attendees about mental strain after demonetisation and buffalo meat export, I am not saying that these questions aren't important but whatever this govt. does people will only see it with their biases and questions like these are unnecessarily put up.
It's not perfect. My father is a bankrupt businessman but hasn't filed the company under IBC.. If you go this route you can never hold a high position in any company.. My dad wanted to start the business again so he didn't file under IBC
@@satyabodhmutgi1287 Amit Mitra is a great one too. GST was literally his brainchild. Although he was vehemently against the timing of its implementation. So much so that he refused to attend the meeting in delhi when all finance ministers of other states had gone. Jaitley had infact mentioned him in that conference when it was rolled out. Mitra warned about the drawbacks of implementing GST at that time and turns out his prophecy did turn out true. His warning is still available in an interview with NDTV after he refused to go. All things he said have now become true. Amazing economist and finance minister. Probably one of the intelligent members of old TMC.
@@S.Ghosh_221 He is the worst Fin. Min. For bengal He just said in 2011 that We will do capital expenditure & Make bengal great again in terms of Industrialisation But Industrialisation has been even worst Since TMC came Ok & get ur facts right he was not a Founding member of TMC he joined tmc in 2011 Was TMC Founded on 2011 ??
Seriously Shekhar Gupta calls a guest and then he tries to peddle his agenda of being excessive critical of Modi Govt. There is no point of calling a Economist then start asking questions related Terrorism , Beef .Only an idiot will fall to that level .
Agreed on the Kautilyan State. I think with mostly only the taxes and law falling under the State's purview, you get the perfect recipe for capitalist democracy.
Shekar has been less graceful in accepting that security & safety has been a major positive fact of the Modi government. We should recall how the same media and Modi bashers were screaming that our country would face riots blah blah if Modi came to power.
@@email4ady Certainly the protestors are responsible for the violence and the government acted very responsibly unlike congress government which has a record of violent clashes.
@@muraliny6770 central establishment' itself was d perpetrator.. By inciting ppl with we know wich slogans....n d guy who raised d slogan in Delhi z sitting in finance ministry....... Shame... so we know the two faced central politicians....
In any other country, people like Sanjeev would've been placed at the leading edge of the mainstream while the likes of coupta would've been relegated to the ranks of the lunatic fringe.
One of the most informative interview in recent years. Pleople should see this to understand how a general govt economic policies work. What thought gets into it.
sooo versatile, knowledgeable, proficient in thought. He would easily top civil services exam had he given it, which is considered to be one of the world's toughest exams
I don't understand is it becoming leftist is compulsion for educated people. I mea why? Do they think leftist theory is quite tough to understand and hence they will be considered cool? 4 vedas, upnishad are even tougher and higher philosophy. Give it a try. U will understand liberals.
An insightful and vibrant discussion, thanks to Sanjeev Sanyal. Just one qualm, though. While he felt that connecting mental ill-health to demonetisation was little too far-fetched, he need not have been rude to dismiss it. He could have respectfully disagreed. Doesn’t it reflect unwillingness to acknowledge grassroots experience? Doesn’t it reflect insensitivity to potential ramifications of macro-policy decisions?
Sanji snayal has taken tharoor many times without even trying, shekhar gupta is lucky that sanyal didn't want to demolish him he is man of simple nature.
Despite Gupta trying hard to discredit everything the Modi government has done, Mr Sanyal has smartly shut him up using facts and figures. Very talented man.
I'm sure the govt is also looking at the systems used in other countries...for learning about new approaches and for benchmarking purposes.....It could be much faster that "reinventing the wheel" ourselves...But I enjoyed listening to the big improvements happening in India..from a person I greatly admire
I watched the whole video to know about govt policies and working but at the end shekhar gupta could not control himself from showing his true colour just like rajdeep.
This guy Sanyal is one of the brightest in the Bjp camp. He is practical. Want to see him as the FM and not as his adviser. Jaitley is zero compared to him.
I came to know about Shekhar Gupta only a few months back. After watching a few of his videos, it was clear to me that he has a clear agenda, to discredit the current Indian government. I only watched this interview because Sanjay was being interviewed.We are tired of critics and naysayers. What we need is constructive suggestions.
If you ask me the lady's accusation was truly offensive. In the Nov 3rd week of 2016 when i went searching for an atm with cash i fell and fractured my foot...and then rendered home-bound for 7 weeks... a cousin of mine was teasing me saying "now there is one more cause that can be dumped on demonetization"... if economists think that was a good move, normal ill-equipped (economics-wise) people - including the host - who specializes in word-soups in every lecture scenario...should just shut up.
Great discussion Shekhar Gupta- thank you for inviting people like Sanjay Sanyal to offer up critical insights/context that warrant peeling off more layers than is done in common discourse of political issues. Re: the woman who asked about mental health issues when this happened, glad you stuck up for the woman who perhaps didnt frame the issue well but raised a good question-- does the state bear responsibility for the more serious consequences of major reform like aggravated mental illness and death (some deaths also occurred in the aftermath of demonetization) and which part of the funnel of event progression is best designed to deal with it
Sanjeev Sanyal is the best person to become the FM of India. I use his videos to counter liberal narrative that BJP has done nothing for the economy. Hats off to NDA for clearing the fiscal mess that UPA created during their regime. And yes looking at the standards of bongs going down, as a fellow bong I look upto Sanjeev as a huge mark of respect. This man will be an asset for Modi post jaitley era. Foreign diplomacy has jaishankar, Security has doval, internal security has Amit shah. All are jewels in the cabinet, only piece missing is the economy. Sanjeev can be as good as the other 3 in economics.
Shekhar Gupta admitted in the first minute that he had opposed Sanjeev's nomination to the World Economic Forum as he was in a "monitoring" role for people of Indian origin. I wonder what the reasons could be that were hopefully rational and justified.
Shekhar constantly pointing to audience to tell someone where to run with the mike is very distracting. Why can't he just focus on keeping the discussion going instead of also being some sort of a captain Kirk ?
shekhar gupta is interrupting the flow of discussion with his wanna be type attitude. informative and smart economist, yet so defensive, plus critical against opponent.
I agree with him on email process all important govt mail communication is don't on Gmail. That's really surprising we are at the helm of technology innovationstart up etc but still govt doesn't have proper mail management process
When the person in audiance gives a observation saying he felt really safe for the first time because there where no bomb blast no terrorism. Guptaji ka mu aur kala ho gaya.
@@hadizaidi2971 Cool then India should import beef from outside countries and transfer the cost to the customers. So pay more for expensive beef. But no cow shall be killed in India. Along with that, any cow sacrifice in any Id festival should be banned. There is no place in the world where cows are sacrificed except in India because of some jingoist two-nation theory believer muslims.
@@samlee3039 As I said, India should import beef if there is demand for eating and transfer the cost to the customers but no cow shall be killed in India. That is fair.
@@sadenb btw Cow is not suppose to be sacrificed on EID, also many Muslims believe that if the sentiments of hindus are heart by eating beef than it is prohibited for us to eat. But here the issue is not about eating but rather an economic one. Today farmers are crying over how cows are ruining their fields and many more. What I say is that IF COW is sacred built worship places specially where cows are there so people can go and worship them. Don't you think its sad when cows roam around on road eating plastic, as an animal lover I am ashamed of myself as a member of this society
Huge admiration for Mr Sanjeev Sanyal for gracefully putting the NGO lady in her place.
That was lacking in grace. I was taken aback.
Sanjeev Sanyal as the future NDA PM of India!!Please NDA promote a man like him as the new face of NDA.
He is not a politician,
I'm BJP supporter but I appreciate critics like Shekhar gupta.
These type of critics are necessary.
Fabulous interview. Truly a man of ideas. So refreshing
Every time I hear from Sanyal, my admiration for him increases !
On 27 October 2013, a series of bomb blasts rocked the Indian city of Patna, Bihar at a massive election rally for BJP Prime Ministerial candidate Narendra Modi. Of the estimated 300,000 participants at the "Hunkar" rally, six people were killed and 85 others were injured in eight bomb blasts.
Location: Patna Junction; Multiple locations at ...
Attack type: Bombings
Suspected perpetrators: Indian Mujahideen
Shekar said he goes by facts. lol. He should have said he goes by sonia and pappu
BJP need to promote this man FAST...make parts of this video to clear the air about down Economy...!!!
One day Sanjeev will be cabinet minister mark my word.
Finance minister
I would want sanjeev sanyal to be education minister .just because the no of hats he wears successfully.
@@vivekt4896 yes
Guptaji was quite quick to discredit this government on safety and forgot that Delhi saw bomb blast in September 2011.
2013 in Bangalore too .. this shekhar gupta is pidi ..
Before 2014, terrorists attack was the regular thing in metro cities
Well, just because terrorist attacks happened in the past doesn't mean this government hasn't had failures in security.
Just because I murder someone doesn't mean your murdering someone is all right. I will answer for mine and you will for yours.
Also, the government that is sitting at the centre is the one we should be concerned about because it has the power to make decisions.
I have many problems with previous governments, but what is the use of discussing the security failures of Indira Gandhi when we can't do anything about it today. So concentrate on the government in power- whoever they are.
@@samlee3039 but isn't the credit for no terror strike goes to this govt.
,@@RahulKumar-ng2gh when you do that, you are disrespecting Sam Lee by playing down & not singing praises of HIS achievements, which is KILLING
Sanyal shines thanks to Gupta. His diplomacy and gradual drawing of Gupta into his conversation was brilliant. Many speakers would have been distracted, and irritated.
I am watching this video just for Sanjeev Sanyal. Its always great to hear him.
Sanyal is a talented economist.
He was rhodes scholar, mean full scholarship to Oxford
probably you are missing out a Historian...
O
@@RahulKumar-ng2gh so?
Recently read his short stories-have ordered one more. Appreciate the way he gives it back where required.
Hats off to SheGu to sit across a man with an intellectual capacity 10 times his own. Sanjeev didn't even try but demolished SheGu's agenda and many of the Congress cronies in the audience.
Propaganda is used to dehumanize and create hatred toward a supposed enemy,
either internal or external, by creating a false image in the mind of
citizens .
Lenin once said: Of all the reactionary classes, we need to worry about everyone except the intellectuals. They will swallow anything.In simple words the more higher one’s IQ is, the more susceptible s/he is to propaganda, lies, indoctrination and bullshitting.
Auxo Moxoa and we saw how Lenins form of governance, politics and economic development worked out.
Damn..! u killed it😂🤣
But is a mouthpiece of bee jay pee cronies
Why is the interviewer at pains to deny that your country has become safer during the present government as the guest and one of the audience highlighted. Can someone tell me if the interviewer is supporter of the previous regime in India because he keeps denying that one particular matter several times. Btw an interesting interview and India should be proud of having undertaken so many difficult reforms in such a short time.
Because that is what THE ENTIRE WORLD is being forced to believe by the Christians, the muslims, the whites, the commies, the seculars, the "NGOs," the congis, their chamchas, the NEHRU-GANDHI family & their bonded labors
He is a victim of extreme inferiority complex, like many of the pseudo-liberals in India who believe in a one size fits all model of the world politics, economy and culture.
Correct observation! He wrote a full length editorial about UPA should endeavour to come back on the back of Manmohan Singh's integrity (with all the baggage of mega corruptions/scams!). Many of these guys lived (literally) and have been living on the largesse of (fake) Gandhi family/Congress party fund!!
John...you are spot on...intelligent observers grasp quickly
SG very lately has accepted a certain good has happened after BJP took over . He was trying to two the line that democracy is suppressed. To my mind congress started addressing the issue of corruption via scam expose some of which they themselves created by their wrong decisions and BKP is fighting hard to keep the country falling prey to terrorists, drugs ,naxals ,corrupt officials and practices.
Such a brilliant Individual, we need more personalities like this to take India ahead
IBC is the single biggest achievement of Modi govt, too bad they don’t advertise it properly.
People don't understand that complex topic
I disagree with you, Govt. do wants to publicize it but you must have noticed the question put by the attendees about mental strain after demonetisation and buffalo meat export, I am not saying that these questions aren't important but whatever this govt. does people will only see it with their biases and questions like these are unnecessarily put up.
It's not perfect. My father is a bankrupt businessman but hasn't filed the company under IBC.. If you go this route you can never hold a high position in any company.. My dad wanted to start the business again so he didn't file under IBC
@@RanveerSingh-xf5uk bhakti babus don't know reality
53:00 ,Truth is told, For last 5 years, Indian middle class has not faced any terrorist blast.
We middle class feel very safe now while travelling.
This Criminal cuts off the "Urban Naxalits" Sanjeev says at 1:14:25 ..
Haha good catch
I am shocked to see Shekhar Gupta almost acting like an advocate for the UPA government.
What is shocking in that? It's been routine for Sg for many years now
WHY? hE DOING ONLY WHAT HE IS... an advocate for the UPA & A PART OF THE anti modi-anti bjp-anti hindu ARMY
Why socked? He has been so since time immemorial. But Mr Sanyal defended and also broght financial reforms to notice that current government has done.
That means you have not his articles prior to 2014 May!!!
Congress pimp he is
Finally,a Bong on whom I can feel pride upon as a fellow Bong.
There is another one. Bibek. Debroy.
he belongs to the family of great Indian-Bengali revolutionary Sachin Sanyal
True that!!
@@satyabodhmutgi1287 Amit Mitra is a great one too. GST was literally his brainchild. Although he was vehemently against the timing of its implementation. So much so that he refused to attend the meeting in delhi when all finance ministers of other states had gone. Jaitley had infact mentioned him in that conference when it was rolled out.
Mitra warned about the drawbacks of implementing GST at that time and turns out his prophecy did turn out true. His warning is still available in an interview with NDTV after he refused to go. All things he said have now become true. Amazing economist and finance minister. Probably one of the intelligent members of old TMC.
@@S.Ghosh_221 He is the worst Fin. Min. For bengal He just said in 2011 that We will do capital expenditure & Make bengal great again in terms of Industrialisation
But Industrialisation has been even worst Since TMC came Ok & get ur facts right he was not a Founding member of TMC he joined tmc in 2011 Was TMC Founded on 2011 ??
Shekhar Gupta has no interest in listening to the answers. He came with his agenda.
Seriously Shekhar Gupta calls a guest and then he tries to peddle his agenda of being excessive critical of Modi Govt. There is no point of calling a Economist then start asking questions related Terrorism , Beef .Only an idiot will fall to that level .
this is probably i watched, first video on ThePrint, just because of Sanjeev Sanyal....
Agreed on the Kautilyan State. I think with mostly only the taxes and law falling under the State's purview, you get the perfect recipe for capitalist democracy.
A man of refreshing and energetic ideas. India needs this kind of leaders more.
Jus love sanjeev when he dwells deep into history...
Sanjeev is simply superb! I wish he becomes RBI Governor soon!!
Shekar has been less graceful in accepting that security & safety has been a major positive fact of the Modi government.
We should recall how the same media and Modi bashers were screaming that our country would face riots blah blah if Modi came to power.
Delhi riots
@@email4ady
Certainly the protestors are responsible for the violence and the government acted very responsibly unlike congress government which has a record of violent clashes.
@@muraliny6770 central establishment' itself was d perpetrator.. By inciting ppl with we know wich slogans....n d guy who raised d slogan in Delhi z sitting in finance ministry....... Shame... so we know the two faced central politicians....
Would be a real treat to have Arvind Subramaniam, Raghuram Rajan and Sanjeev Sanyal having a healthy debate on the way forward for Indian Economy.
It's alternative voice which were denied eaelier!
Welcome to the mainstream sir to strengthen the nation in Kautaliyan way
Read his books brother, i am following this person for last three year, i even read his books, he is gem intellectual
In any other country, people like Sanjeev would've been placed at the leading edge of the mainstream while the likes of coupta would've been relegated to the ranks of the lunatic fringe.
@@RahulKumar-ng2gh i only found him from srijan talks..yes he is a gem
The more I hear Sanyal sir the more I like him
One of the most informative interview in recent years. Pleople should see this to understand how a general govt economic policies work. What thought gets into it.
sooo versatile, knowledgeable, proficient in thought. He would easily top civil services exam had he given it, which is considered to be one of the world's toughest exams
This man is simply class apart👌
57:06 Sankriti Jethani got Schooled badly by Sanjeev Sanyal from 59:00 onwards. ROFL. 😄😄
Got to love Sanyal
sanjeev has great in depth and macro corrective visionary ideas. Gupta as usual is ........
Sanjeev Ji you have done a lot at this small age and you are a true Patriot. I like your writings very much.
Intellectual Sekar Gupta certifies whether people evolved or not based on whether they can kill buffaloes or not ...lol..."Intellectual".
Liberal logic brother, killing buffalo and cows for meat is okay but killing dogs and cats are animal rights
I don't understand is it becoming leftist is compulsion for educated people. I mea why? Do they think leftist theory is quite tough to understand and hence they will be considered cool? 4 vedas, upnishad are even tougher and higher philosophy. Give it a try. U will understand liberals.
An insightful and vibrant discussion, thanks to Sanjeev Sanyal.
Just one qualm, though.
While he felt that connecting mental ill-health to demonetisation was little too far-fetched, he need not have been rude to dismiss it. He could have respectfully disagreed.
Doesn’t it reflect unwillingness to acknowledge grassroots experience?
Doesn’t it reflect insensitivity to potential ramifications of macro-policy decisions?
Just wOw
Strong slap on mr gupta.
This guy should head a ministry
Shekhar Gupta is a bad journalist he is overly opinionated.
😂😂💯
shekhar Gupta on fiscal deficit at 30:50 was like "2009 me sonia ji se puchaa tha to unhone 3 bataya tha"
WOW THE CUTS IN 1.07 TO 1.08 VERY SIGNIFICANT
Slapped to NGO lady hard, indirectly to SheGu
Sanjeev is one of the best minds in new India.
Great interview
Its good to see young motivated professionals working for the govt. brings a sense of security to people
Shekhar needs to learn some humility and how to be less dismissive, cynical and a know-it-all.
Incredibly talented Sanyal ....an economist...historian..thinker...
Sanji snayal has taken tharoor many times without even trying, shekhar gupta is lucky that sanyal didn't want to demolish him he is man of simple nature.
Coupta tried to peddle his agenda but we have a very competent orator here named Sanjeev who did not give him a chance.
Despite Gupta trying hard to discredit everything the Modi government has done, Mr Sanyal has smartly shut him up using facts and figures. Very talented man.
Jay hind bharat mata ki jay.....
Yeah demonetization definitely caused my depression...what a ridiculous question.
A great scholar and thinker. May his thoughts guide us in future
Sekhar Gupta was trying to talk more himself than listening to Sanjeev Sanyal
I'm sure the govt is also looking at the systems used in other countries...for learning about new approaches and for benchmarking purposes.....It could be much faster that "reinventing the wheel" ourselves...But I enjoyed listening to the big improvements happening in India..from a person I greatly admire
I just love Print! Thank you for bringing talent like this on stage.
I watched the whole video to know about govt policies and working but at the end shekhar gupta could not control himself from showing his true colour just like rajdeep.
This guy Sanyal is one of the brightest in the Bjp camp. He is practical. Want to see him as the FM and not as his adviser. Jaitley is zero compared to him.
Only here for Sanjeev Sanyal. This anchor doesn’t know anything and have an opinion on everything! Completely ignorant congressi as usual !
I came to know about Shekhar Gupta only a few months back. After watching a few of his videos, it was clear to me that he has a clear agenda, to discredit the current Indian government. I only watched this interview because Sanjay was being interviewed.We are tired of critics and naysayers. What we need is constructive suggestions.
Trying to look for one positive comment for Couptaji. Seems like none is there. Maybe the lutyens tribe is dwindling after all.
Why would Sanjeev appear with #UrbanNaxal "Coupta ji"
gupta ji ne than li he govt ko koi credit nh dena he
Ab unhein paise hi is baat ke liye miltey hain... iske alawa inko koyi aur kaam aata hi to nahi hai
Absolutely admire Sanjeev Singhania
Sekhar : "she sounded sincere", sure like you also do :-|
If you ask me the lady's accusation was truly offensive. In the Nov 3rd week of 2016 when i went searching for an atm with cash i fell and fractured my foot...and then rendered home-bound for 7 weeks... a cousin of mine was teasing me saying "now there is one more cause that can be dumped on demonetization"... if economists think that was a good move, normal ill-equipped (economics-wise) people - including the host - who specializes in word-soups in every lecture scenario...should just shut up.
How does eating Buffalo meat makes person more evolved.. ?? 1:13:50.
Great discussion Shekhar Gupta- thank you for inviting people like Sanjay Sanyal to offer up critical insights/context that warrant peeling off more layers than is done in common discourse of political issues.
Re: the woman who asked about mental health issues when this happened, glad you stuck up for the woman who perhaps didnt frame the issue well but raised a good question-- does the state bear responsibility for the more serious consequences of major reform like aggravated mental illness and death (some deaths also occurred in the aftermath of demonetization) and which part of the funnel of event progression is best designed to deal with it
Sanjeev sanyal,grt thoughts... excellent talks
Amazing guy - Sanjeev
Remove Nirmala as FM and put Sanjeev Sanyal as FM
1:10:42 gupta is not letting any chance to defend his madam. lol
if someone sees his actions behind words farm laws working started already before this meet @39:00
Sanjeev Sanyal is the best person to become the FM of India. I use his videos to counter liberal narrative that BJP has done nothing for the economy. Hats off to NDA for clearing the fiscal mess that UPA created during their regime. And yes looking at the standards of bongs going down, as a fellow bong I look upto Sanjeev as a huge mark of respect. This man will be an asset for Modi post jaitley era. Foreign diplomacy has jaishankar, Security has doval, internal security has Amit shah. All are jewels in the cabinet, only piece missing is the economy. Sanjeev can be as good as the other 3 in economics.
🙏🙏🙏...very well said..Sanjeev.....
MODI FOR 2019
If the Judicial reforms are carried out, our nation will improve leaps and bounds !!!
Awesome reply
Shekhar Gupta admitted in the first minute that he had opposed Sanjeev's nomination to the World Economic Forum as he was in a "monitoring" role for people of Indian origin. I wonder what the reasons could be that were hopefully rational and justified.
Excellent discuss
Great Conversations...
Shekhar constantly pointing to audience to tell someone where to run with the mike is very distracting. Why can't he just focus on keeping the discussion going instead of also being some sort of a captain Kirk ?
This is the type of discussion you won't see on mainstream media
Shekhar Gupta is that khadoos, khusatth buddha that deserves to be marginalised and made irrelevant.
Burnol moment of Guptaji.
Proud to be a fellow indian
shekhar gupta is interrupting the flow of discussion with his wanna be type attitude.
informative and smart economist, yet so defensive, plus critical against opponent.
Shekhar ji unhappy at 34 😀 another place I am big critic of this gov, then corrected.. any other gov..
Sanjeev Sanyal will change the Indian Economy - mark my words
He is one hell of a technocrat and a diplomat too ...
Not a diplomat
@@hopechangesht6020 i meant ..a diplomatic
I agree with him on email process all important govt mail communication is don't on Gmail. That's really surprising we are at the helm of technology innovationstart up etc but still govt doesn't have proper mail management process
When the person in audiance gives a observation saying he felt really safe for the first time because there where no bomb blast no terrorism. Guptaji ka mu aur kala ho gaya.
This man explains really well how government is run, admits the problems faced by govt and they deal with it
Two of my favourite persons in conversation. Looking forward to the next edition.
Good answers sir
Beef MUST BE BANNED. SAVE COWS.
Why? If you don't wanna eat it, don't. Why should you dictate what others can or cannot do.
but they are tasty
@@hadizaidi2971 Cool then India should import beef from outside countries and transfer the cost to the customers. So pay more for expensive beef. But no cow shall be killed in India. Along with that, any cow sacrifice in any Id festival should be banned. There is no place in the world where cows are sacrificed except in India because of some jingoist two-nation theory believer muslims.
@@samlee3039 As I said, India should import beef if there is demand for eating and transfer the cost to the customers but no cow shall be killed in India. That is fair.
@@sadenb btw Cow is not suppose to be sacrificed on EID, also many Muslims believe that if the sentiments of hindus are heart by eating beef than it is prohibited for us to eat. But here the issue is not about eating but rather an economic one. Today farmers are crying over how cows are ruining their fields and many more. What I say is that IF COW is sacred built worship places specially where cows are there so people can go and worship them. Don't you think its sad when cows roam around on road eating plastic, as an animal lover I am ashamed of myself as a member of this society