MILGRAM - Shidou's Second Voice Drama (Aesculapius)
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 03. 2023
- English translation by onigiriico on Tumblr: / onigiriico
It was done very quickly, so please try to thank them for their hard work. I took the liberty of editing some of the lines to sound smoother in English.
Hello everyone! Hope you are doing well!
It was an interesting MV. I feel very bad for Shidou. His family is just adorable. I think it would be worth voting him innocent because, to me, it's clear he wouldn't do the same thing again (or even have the opportunity to, his wife and kids are likely all dead at this point...). I think he'd probably also live the rest of his life trying to atone and be a good person. But like, if my family member was braindead and then randomly had their organs harvested by the doctor, I would probably be pretty upset lmao.
I'll see you next time for Mahiru's.
Voice Actors:
Es: Amami Yurina
Shidou: Nakamura Shuug
![MILGRAM - Mahiru's Second Voice Drama (Love is [Un]Dead)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-Ap498US-A0/mqdefault.jpg)
![MILGRAM / Shidou - Molech [The First Trial Voice Drama | English Subs]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/C4MiQ3V3YjQ/mqdefault.jpg)
milgram.jp/judge
Shidou is gonna get a perfect score of 3 innocents.
Along with girlboss Yuno that committed no crimes and shouldn't even be here
i hope he gets guilty in T3 ngl it'd be so funny
@@Alyssaromantic that is so not true Abortion is murder but the other part about sleeping around is not its just a very self damaging action
@@senritsujumpsuit6021 Abortion isn't murder. It literally is not alive at that stage. It's her choice on what she does with her body.
@@Alyssaromantic that is the BS part their alive very soon and even if their not yet the fact your stabbing them before hand its still murdering a future life
if someone was having a kid and you hit them with a car on purpose an said its not like the kid is real yet then you would be an asshole
Shidou is about to be the only innocent serial killer out there lmao love him
not sure about only one
@@senritsujumpsuit6021 I think the only serial killers are Haruka (animals), Mikoto and Kotoko..? Unless Haruka changes a lot Shidou will probably stay the only innocent one I think.
Ah um, they are all guilty. But Shidou is forgivable. But cannot be trusted being a doctor in the outside world
@@melocan933 I mean, “technically” Yuno also. I’m not trying to make a statement against abortion, but abortion does involve killing an organism regardless of whether it is okay ethically/legally/culturally. And Yuno seems just as likely to get straight innocent votes as Shidou, if not more.
@@aureus3234 Yeah, I meant innocent as in the game’s version but I was using it as a plat on words lol
I think that, instead of him doing transplants to find a way to save his family, he was doing all of these transplants out of his sense of justice and common sense -- begging people to give up their family's on life support and even maybe going against their wishes at times to save other lives -- but when his family was in an accident and in a similar position, he could no longer do the same. He can't bring them back, but he couldn't let them go, and he hated himself for that contradiction, therefore he retroactively saw himself as guilty for all of those 'murders'. Someone in the comments also said that they think his wife was involved in the cover ups in some way. I think that tracks if any were below board.
Its a mater of what he was doing is logical medical action but his mind towards other families was frozen till he could relate directly
12:52 THANK GOD ES SAID IT
Fuuta VD an here ETC shows how he is invested one way or another in these people with conflicting reasonings
Took him a while🙏but finally
THIS HITS SO HARD!!
EASY INNOCENT VOTE!! BABY GIRL INNOCENT!!
NO REGRETS!!! 👏👏👏
I feel like Milgram will find a way to make us regret
@@sophtbagels9508 true but for now at least no regrets 👍
@@Atmospheric_Sky agreed!
czcams.com/video/N1U1KyhoBrw/video.html
Guys, remember in the second trial trailer, Shidou said “You’re in my way, hurry up and die”.? (1:37 of the video). I think this reflects he isn’t really that innocent and noble. If we vote him innocent and he shows his true colours in the final trial it may be too late to reverse the tide
@@hufflepandaleung2648 I feel that can be him towards himself he wants to be hated an even killed but still a part of him still wants to keep people safe which just keeps make him go round an round being in his own way
when ES thanks shidou at the end and he starts crying RAAAH
Honami mochizuki user...
I love her
Shidou’s VA sounding choked up towards the end of the video pulled on my heart strings. Shidou’s struggle with wanting to d1e versus his want to protect the injured was a nice improvement for his character. Also Es saying he was thankful for Shidou being at Milgram and saving Mahiru and Fuuta was a nice change from Es bullying a lot of the other prisoners.
Psst… Shidou if you still want to have a kid like you Haruka is still a child in my country and he’s in need of a positive parental figure. Seriously praise him slightly and he’ll think you’re his mom. Adopt him.
ok that idea is scary interesting if in a later trial we hear him conflicting with the Playhouse of the heart Mu set up
I think that's honestly a really interesting concept, the last part. Unlike Mu; Shidou is older, wise, etc., and ACTUALLY a parent. He knows how to raise children, and it looks like he was a very good father too. Going from having a spoiled teen as a parental figure to an actual father as a parental figure would be a great improvement in many ways for Haruka. Def much healthier.
But I think it wouldn't only help Haruka out, but also Shidou as well! He clearly still misses his sons, so maybe having a son figure in his life again would make him happier and want to live more...?
Of course, that could also cause problems like Haruka and Mu had (e.g. Haruka/Shidou begging for the other to be innocent) but overall it'd be a much sweeter relationship. I wanna see it happen!!!
And heck, maybe it WILL happen. Ignoring the Haruka-Mu stuff going on, since Haruka was voted guilty, it means there's a chance he will be attacked by Kotoko (that depends if she gets innocent or not tho). Since Shidou is now giving himself the role of healing others, he will probably heal Haruka, and maybe they will interact!
@@kyleecopter1160 Its two puzzle pieces finding each other indeed
Haruka is not the piece that is meant to unlock Mu's old self
@@kyleecopter1160 the worry is this (Haruka says in his drama if he is innocent and Mu is guilty he will do SELF-harm of himself) yet I do hope Shidou and others prevent that ever
Interesting that Shidou apparently didn’t hear the voices like the other prisoners, and Es had to tell him their reasoning for his verdict.
@@kaiz5183what about amane??
@@RichanXRikun1we don’t know , amane’s voice drama isn’t out yet (I believe it is being released august 30th or sometime late august ?)
Just a note! at 9:13 Shidou says "Like I previously told you in the interrogation, I've killed for scientific reasons as well. So..."
Onigiriico made a correction on tumblr saying this was supposed to be "Selfish reasons" not scientific
It's selfish to do research technically alot of the time Milgram in real life could be seen as this
My man Shidou deserves the INNOCENT verdict for all the lives he failed to save and all the complicated choices he had to do. He’s just a depressed doctor that got caught up by all the choices he made. Also his banger is sick!
Ahhh, hearing Es thanking Shidou for saving Futa & Mahiru makes me wanna cry 😭 !! It's truly amazing how instinctually I feel that, almost no matter what this guy has done in the past, as long as he's protecting & healing the people we know in here, I'll likely vote to forgive him lol.
Also, all his comments regarding kids hits so much harder now that we know he was a father; still in shock over that, Shidou is a DAD has been the biggest plot twist yet 😂
It was interesting to see in this voice drama how Shidou mentions Es being trapped as much as they are, apart from the fact that they were given different roles from the start. In the sense that we are the one making choices and imposing them on Es, we could suppose that we are the problem in the story. If nobody would vote then nothing would happen.
But at the same time I can’t stop myself wondering if we are not trapped like them. The project Milgram proposes us to interact with the character with only 2 options : Guilty or Innocent ( or forgiven and unforgivable if we follow a more literal traduction from japanese ) But as the songs and the voice drama keep showing us, theirs sins can’t be treat with a black and white vision, as they always flirt in a gray zone. So even us, we are given as only means to interact with the story, something that doesn’t seem fair or right.
As a whole, it would seem that the project milgram in itself is something that gives us a role to play as the others, the prisoners, the guardian, being the bridge between us and the prisoners, and us, the one who were given the role to judge. We seem to all play the role that the project milgram (seem to be incarnated by Jackalope ) gave us, which of course relates to the experiment that gave the name to the project.
Then the question is, can we outsmart the project or can we only play the role that was given to us ? ( As it seems very inconceivable to not vote at all and they not really any other mean to interact with the project that to vote and debate which is what Milgram wants us to do)
His voice actor did such an amazing job I'm in lovee
every VA is this
LET HIM COOK
bro I do feel awful for him 😭
him and yuno are gonna get straight innocent votes they're probably the most forgivable in the cast
also is es slowly desending into insanity or are they slowly becoming aware that their thoughts aren't entirely controlled by them? 🤨
Yuno did murder a child which is big oh no
the other part is less a oh no beyond self harming
@@senritsujumpsuit6021 yuno did not murder a child she had abortions
@@daughterofevil It is stopping a child from being born is murder image your about to be born give everyone so many memories an someone just stabs you am says well yiur not born yet so fuk u
an easy innocent vote with great curiosity towards the third trial.
i'm really starting to wonder if there's something boiling under the surface here...part of me wonders if we're getting the full story. generally considering the way that shidou talks about the film ["oh; so that's what it shows..."] makes me think that there's potentially more nuance to it.
either that, or after two innocent verdicts, shidou's feeling of "indispensability" will override his sense of guilt.
a few crack theories at the end: the anti transplant family is from amane's cult; shidou and kotoko are conspiring in some way; shidou has some sort of mad scientist agenda. *please* don't take any of these seriously.
FREE MAHIRU!!! SHIDOU INNOCENT!!
Everyone has the second part
one my fav anime characters is half very aggressively demanding but also a whimpering child yearning for family :/
@@Aerithymia mahiru seems guilty
Its not about what they did, its about how they feel about the crime, mahiru after being voted guilty and literally beaten to a pulp has lost all meaning of her life and if we vote her guilty again we’re probably gonna go past her breaking point.
not to mentiooon.. theres the mahiru suicide theory
they were all braindead in the first place???? i didnt caught up on that!!!! that man is clear hes fine youre ok shidou my bad
Honestly I want to know more about Es. They're such a mysterious character, and I really want to know their origin as well. I hope we find out more about them later on, because they are like my favorite character and I love them so much 😭
All the audios point to him being a younger family member who could hardly help those around him
the family law part is telling
Es is the embodiment of all of us
@@Idealrecorder Yeah but they have to have a backstory, even if they represent us it doesn't mean they don't have a character of their own. That is what makes a complex character./nm/gen (I am trying to explain it in a nice way I'm really sorry if I sound strict or anything I'm not trying to be 😭)
@@mitsu_yuu true
There are good reasons to vote Shidou innocent - like his ability to treat injured prisoners - but I feel like some crucial details about his murders have been left out. From what Shidou tells Es in this voice drama alone, it sounds like this: He transplanted many organs from braindead patients to living ones (he had to get consent from the braindead patients’ families, it seems), therefore he took the lives of patients who could not be saved so that he could save the lives of people who had a better chance of living. He didn’t see it as wrong back then but now he does, for whatever reason. From that information alone, it sounds like he didn’t do anything wrong at all.
But, from both of his MVs and his talk of valuing family in this voice drama, it’s heavily implied that Shidou committed his murders in order to save a family member of his, likely his wife. Why didn’t he outright tell Es that? Why is that additional layer of sympathy for his character necessary? It makes me wonder if he took more drastic, unethical measures to save his family member, like prioritizing their life over the life of a patient who also had a chance of living, or not getting consent from victim’s family.
No no, it's not like that, I believe. He wasn't harvesting those organs for his wife (cuz really, how many organs does one person need?). He was in charge of transplantation of organs from brain dead patients, and he had to ask for consent of their family members. But not everyone agreed, so he pushed through and tried to logically explain why he needs those organs and that those will basically save so many other lives! It's logical, why can't they understand?
But then his family got into the accident, his kids died and his wife became brain-dead. And that's when he finally realised why those people were against transplantations. He finally understood how hard it was to give up, to literally KILL your family member, for some random peoples life, whose faces you won't even see. He tried his best, to keep her alive but... to no success obviously... And so he himself began seeing those transplantations not like operations, but like murders
I doubt he would harvest organs illegally, to save her, cuz u know. Why would he? If he needed an organ to save her, he would make a request like for any other patient, no??
poor shidou 😭 he was almost crying by the end. dude needs a hug. i already voted him inno but this just reaffirms my decision lol
Es in the tenth trial of part 1 too
Okay but we’re voting Kotoko guilty this round right-
oh definitely
Yes but i have a feeling that she might get killed if we do so. Just a hunch with no logical basis lol
absolutely. It’s shaken up Milgram so much that you can’t have a single interrogation without her or what she did being brought up. You have people who are terrified of her and of what Milgram has become. We have some who have now come to despise us (ES) for the authority we unintentionally gave her or the voting choices we decided and even those who were voted innocent have made it a point to tell us they wouldn’t want to be her friend or enemy and that she’s becoming a problem. Even if we as individuals find her reasoning valid or want to forgive her, her mind has become corrupt with getting “justice.” I’m convinced that if she could she’d even take our position as warden because her having been voted innocent (or forgiven) has solidified those ideals. Honestly it’s terrifying just how much chaos is consuming Milgram.
I gonna vote her guilty too
i lowk wanna vote her inno just to see how crazy she can fet
My boi shidou is having a moral dilemma
Besides Shidou-
I wonder why Es said 'we'. At first I thougt maybe they meant Jackalope, but given that Es was confused themselves I do not think so. If it isn't Jackalope, are we meant with 'we'?
Does that mean we control Es not just in the interactive sense, but that Es notices too? Seems conflictive
Also. Shidou gets an innocent vote from me
There's been numerous hints of a very paper thin fourth wall; as early as Mu's first trial she asked Es why it seemed like he was treating his own thoughts/reasoning like someone else's which caused him to spiral (until Jackalope walked in and the two seemed to mysteriously forget the conversation). I do think they're also responding to overall community feedback rather than just our votes. Obviously some of us have conflicting theories, but a lot of hints have been dropped (Jackalope questioning our reasoning at the end of the first trial, the specific reasons being given relating to the community discussion, etc.) that they're at least taking inspiration from comments and such. I suspect the voices the other prisoners heard were us too (especially with things like Fuuta talking about how he can tell they're enjoying watching the prisoners and the like).
My guess (with much less evidence to support it) is this is some kind of afterlife situation and Milgram has humanity (us) decide where different people go. Presumably "death" in this context would just be the cessation of your soul's existence idk.
@@stars4809 Oh true! I've heard about the afterlife theory. It was much more prominent while Haruka murder wasn't entirely clear though. (some thought his murder Was s*cide after all)
Only time can tell I guess. But if it was ACTUALLY the afterlife, I wonder if their third music video will have signs of their deaths?
@@stars4809 And yeah. Almost forgot about that part. I hope we find out more about Es. I mean, they hint at Es past pretty much every voice drama AND we see them getting murdered in the way the prisoners murdered their victims in the opening
I don't think Shidou even committed a crime it seems like he was just doing his job
It seems that he was performing his normal job as a doctor for the most part, but when patients became braindead, he would harvest their organs and steal them against the family members’ consent. So that part would definitely not be part of his job
@@ac-gf4zt hm but i dont think that would even be possible in a hospital setting. to even perform organ transplant surgery he would need consent from the patient or the patient's family. not only that theres at least around 5 people in an operating theatre at a time, it would be very odd if they all just let him steal organs
@@zzzaras agreed, i don't think he stole the organs either; especially because according to a comment on the triage mv, in japan they require two or more doctors (not including the transplant surgeon) to sign off on brain death before organ transplantation can occur
@@zzzaras I agree, but I’m not sure how his crime would work otherwise (+ the fact that it’s anime logic so it’s not really surprising if he just somehow managed to do it). I had interpreted him talking about previously asking family members to give him permission to take the patient’s organs as it being something he eventually gave up on and just did on his own. And I feel like it’s not very morally gray if he had full permission to take the organs and use them on his wife/child/whoever. It could be that he was purposefully letting the patients fall into braindead states, as suggested by Es mentioning Shidou’s intentions? It seems there are some disagreements on what exactly he did. Most would agree on an innocent verdict despite that though.
@@ac-gf4zt Maybe it's just because he started to feel guilty over killing braindead patients, even if he was given consent? The definition of "crime" used in Milgram is pretty loose, as shown with Yuno.
This makes me very confused as well intrigued.
-He said that he did for scientific purpose.
-He said he remembers very well article 105 because it let a impact in him. Why?
His wife protect him? I was thinking that he maybe steal organs for one of his children (another theory I saw in Twitter). But then, what happened? In the mv he said also that no matter what he do they will never comeback. So I wonder if the organs things happened after or before of whatever happened to his family. If it was before then maybe it was for one of his children (probably the one who he did gave one of those cards in the mv). Also that would explain why his wife protected him (and why he knows about article 105), because everything was for their child. If it was after... What was trying? Also, this conversation with Es makes me think that Shidou had been in the same place that the families of his patients. Maybe his son or the whole family died and he had to decide whether to donate the organs and at that moment he saw that it was not as easy a decision as he thought before.
I still don't buy completely the theory of something happened to his whole family because although he said they would never come back that doesn't mean that they are dead (at least not everybody). Sometimes the family can't deal with the death of a family member, sometimes parents can't deal with the death of one of their children and that drift them apart
(Sorry if something doesn't make sense english isn't my first language TT-TT)
I see it as he did not think much of it all but after being selective over who to protect his family an fails he is left with the fact he hurt so many by being so direct during his fully reasonable job activities an fights his heart with his brain an his brain with his heart
yearn to stop others pain but never resting from the pain he caused
its not scientific, the translation are wrong, Rikoteki means egoistic
利己的 - Rikoteki is not scientific, is egoístic. He says that he killed people for egoistic reasons. Now I think shidou wa harvesting organs for his child, in the MV we can see he given the organ recieving card to his sons, and the "Card" word in the lyrics are the organ recieving cards itself. Or maybe his wife was a doctor too and convince him to do that, and this explain why he metioned the 150 article
Wow I think Es and Shidou's voice drama is the most wholesome one so far...
Another prisoner hinting to stop voting guys-- Leave the buttons alone plsssss
*Votes more*
@@MrThukko we're never escaping milgram at this rate 😭
There's no way to get everyone to cooperate to actually make that happen
id love to see what would happen if no one voted but theres no way to do that
I feel like ppl are going to try and go 50/50 for Amane because both forgiving and not forgiving her will be dangerous. Haruka was at 50% for a week until his 2nd audio drama came out. (They were behind on putting his up online to listen for and the CD shipments were still being delivered. So very few ppl listened to his voice drama until it was available to purchase online.) So it’s definitely doable. I just wonder what Jackalope will do.
MY HEARTTT MY HEART AT THE LAST PART AAAAUGHHHHH
😭😭😭😭💖💖💖✨✨✨
His son ended up being the braindead one and he couldn't bring himself to kill him like he did to other patience methinks
If he ends up saving more lives than he has killed, I believe he can be forgiven.
I wonder what the ‘we’ is when Es mentions it. I know it’s us, but like what are we? Are we feeding what Es is determined to pick or something else entirely. It’s something that is still kinda an enigma and I really want to know more about Es.
I realized that after watching the other dramas that they can actually hear us! That’s crazy
@@miss.fortune4425 Its gonna be real odd seeing Amane in this broken to pieces state and her being able to hear some of our reasonings oh gosh oh gosh
Some thoughts: According to what other people have brought up, Aesclepius was a god in mythology known for his healing abilities and was killed for raising people from the dead. Shidou says that he also killed for scientific reasons here, and in his first voice drama, Molech, he said that he killed so many people for such a selfish reason.
If he did just transplant organs for the sake of helping other people, I doubt he would say these things. He’s obviously not telling Es something (not entirely sure why since Yuno proved that Milgram doesn’t prevent the prisoners from explicitly saying exactly what they did, but it is what it is.) I think he might have tried experimenting with ways to reverse death or revive patients in untreatable conditions in order to see his family again after their apparent accident. He obviously didn’t succeed, so he ended up transplanting organs for nothing and didn’t save anyone.
(If your response is “Stealing organs is impossible,” I don’t think everything needs to be 100% realistic in fiction, and perhaps he was able to experiment without having to steal. It doesn’t make sense to me for him to feel this way if he is just concerned about the ethics of organ transplanting itself.)
The part about possibly trying to do unheard of medical would not be too outlandish for emotionally disturbed people
we have had people claiming that they would jump off a mountain because it will unlock secrets of the world but they don't do it for many reasons ETC
That doesn't really add anything to his crime though unless the experiments are killing people.
I think it could be transplanting organs into a loved one under brain death to keep them alive, so his principles fall apart because now he 1) can no longer see brain dead patients as effectively dead 2) is actively using the organs from people he used to view as no longer needing them, on someone who by his definition also no longer needs them. so if his former definition was right, his actions would be wasting the transplant on his loved one. if his former definition was wrong, his former actions would be murder. all loss situation
Voting forgiven, since the reasoning of paying back to the lives that were lost by giving his own life is something I do not agree with and granting him this would be wrong of me. I also want him to be able to treat the other prisoners, but tbh his MV and drama keep making me sympathize with him. He's kinda winning me over with the complex ethic that surrounds his storyline ngl.
He seems self-aware to me so far, so that's a plus.
I was so ready to vote him guilty bit oh god after all this I just couldn’t
I'm voting him guilty for the funny but i hope he gets the innocent verdict
we stan a shidou that finds meaning and value through his life after overcoming guilt ✨✨
Now let's hope he doesnt take it too literally or too far
Or that his quest for keeping people alive is meaningless, like they are all already dead or something (like yuno hinted)
I have nothing to theorise, just that he looks gorgeous in the thumbnail
Thanks for all you’re hard work uploading all these!!
CRYING I LOVE HIM SO MUCH instantly voted him innocent right after the premiere for his 2nd trial music video ended
Thanks for tour hard Work ❤
Oh nice it uploaded when I was looking for it
thanks for the video!
I thought that maybe we would find out about why amane is so hostile to shidou but guess it’s make more sense if it was found out during her trial
Amane's cult is against medicinal treatment, furthermore it is implied that the reason she was "punished" is precisely for trying to heal her friend. So it is logical that she has an aberration towards doctors, probably under the scoop that "only God can heal and anyone else who tries to do that is a sinner".
But yes, it makes more sense for that to be express in Amane's interrogation, since she is the one with the problem, and it is related to her murder.
I just thought it was because her cult was against the practice of medicine or something like that honestly, so a doctor like Shidou would probably go against everything she believed in :')
Again 50/50. I understand people didn't want to give Muu that leeway, but in Shidou's case, he should be the first to obtain it.
No more innocents or guilty. Just stop playing the game already.
Yes
I'm still so upset over muu 😭😭 i wish we got a 50/50 fr
@@whizkeysh0t She is very much from a gaming angle a 50/50 is the best because she mid MV was clearly cracking a bit but her gassed up personality an view of the world is still so strong
It's hard to imagine Shidou gets anything other then 3 innocents but if I had to guess what would potentially get him a guilty in the 3rd round is if he does something crazy like take an eyeball or an organ from Kotoko (assuming she is found guilty in the 2nd trial which based on her actions I don't see how she doesn't) in order to give Futa a new eye or to save another prisoner. Although I have a feeling that there are at least 3 other people who will either attempt or cheer on her death if she is found guilty. I'm sure an unbound evil Mikoto would love to have another bout with her especially if she can't do anything.
I’m pretty sure Kotoko will die. They hinted prisoners might die in nearly all of the voice dramas in the s2 so someone will probably die hence making us a murderer too so we can also be judged in milgram
Just here to point out that the translator corrected the part at 9:10, the "scientific" there was changed to "selfish".
either word is pretty much the same he did act toward biologicals reasons for his family
Thanks for translating this! I actually waited for this video before watching the new song. I didn't think Kirisaki would do such a face turn. Now forgiving him seems rather easy, so I assume his video will show very conflicting stuff to compensate for it.
Oof
wow this really does hit hard
HOORAY!!!!!!!!!!!
Shidou, while I may have no right to write this. Dont dare you trow away your life, dont you dare to escape to death from your sins, dont you dare to chose the easy way. Atone for your sins in life, atone by saving others, atone by being for them when they need you, just like how Futa and Mahiru now need you and atone by carrying the burden you have. We have judged you innocent again, take up your sins and live with them, there is no easy way out for you, we wont allow it. Also thank you for saving them.
At this point. I just want to hug him. He's too precious and totally confused, if it wasn't for what happened to his wife (edit: Or a family member), he wouldn't have directly/indirectly "murdered" all due to revenge or for violent reasons. The thing is, he knows he's in the wrong. I wanted to vote him GUILTY only to make him happy, but he 100% deserves the INNOCENT so I just did. But it's still sad to think that the reason why he still wanted to live was just for the sake of saving the lives of potential victims of whoever will go feral next after the 2nd trial, if there was no brawl and no one had gotten hurt, he would've found his life meaningless. Hopefully after the MILGRAM ends, this changed something good and positive to Shidou.
Maybe just vote him GUILTY now, and in the last trial vote INNOCENT! I think that'll satisfy him?
Shidou is the most innocent in this prison... Definitely an "INNOCENT" for him:)
Well, most innocent besides the one that didn't even do a crime in the first place (Psst, it's Yuno)
Shidou stans ignoring the girlboss fr
@@whizkeysh0t LMAO
i voted him innocent bc he fixed up my wife Mahiru now i wait to vote her innocent❤️❤️
12:40 was he talking about amane 😂😂
czcams.com/video/N1U1KyhoBrw/video.html
Guys, remember in the second trial trailer, Shidou said “You’re in my way, hurry up and die”.? (1:37 of the video). I think this reflects he isn’t really that innocent and noble. If we vote him innocent and he shows his true colours in the final trial it may be too late to reverse the tide
I'd like to think rather than this being him just going apesh*t, this specific line just represents him before getting into milgram ( maybe him waiting for a patient to die? He said so himself that he wasn't really the same as he is now), but it would be interesting if it was the other way around
Well, we'll only know when it actually happens
The lives he's taken can be honored by staying alive and saving others for a just reason.
I LOVE HIM SO MUCH!!!!! *CRIES*
watching these comments made me realise how little people pay attention to anyone else from their bias 💀 my brother in christ he still saw his patients as less worthy of attention ‼️ that's what his moral grayness is‼️‼️💥
an that is a fully legal action all medical staff can take under conditions hence the title of the second MV
I think the whole thing about Shidou's eyes is the fact that he realised that the prisoners in Milgram actually needed him for once, because during trial 1 he felt dead inside because of the loss of his family - he felt like he was needed as a father or a husband. and therefore was not needed for anything else. Now his eyes have come alive is because he's remembered he still has a purpose as the sole doctor in Milgram, so he's now more focused on the lives of others because he's found someone to care about, someone who hasn't died yet.
0:32 The written translation also said "left anterior compression fracture". Not sure if that was added after this or something.
But I'm really confused now. What does it mean? What's a "partial fracture to the thorax"?
IM SOOO EXCITD lemme watcn now i cant function properly oh my g
Aawwwww shidou is innocent
(I’m using my sisters account please ignore the name)
This makes me curious about why he wanted to die, because now it seems like he is aware he was doing his job
It's because his crime, he felt guilty and still feels that way
im inlove
I LOVE ESSS OMGWMSSBSNHSHAHAAHAHAAAHHHHH
it honestly took me a while to click the video because of how good he looks in the thumbnail
but the long ass chin throws me off every goddamn time
Well once again it seems that my initial vote was off due to me misunderstanding the prisoner’s story 😂 First with Yuno, and now with Shidou because I did not pick up on the organ transplanting thing whatsoever. I’m so dumb lmao
12:50 broke me
My (somewhat wacky) theory:
The "cards of promise he discarded" (lyrics from the MV), are his family's organ donor cards (Likely only his wife's, since I don't think children can have them).
That is his "crime". When his wife was declared braindead after the accident, he was now faced with the difficult choice he presented to patient's families all the time in his line of work.
Instead of letting other sick patients have his wife's organs, per her wishes, he selfishly let them rot (We can see some rotting fruit in the MV as well).
His "murders" are those patients his wife's orangs could have saved.
Indulging this theory for a moment, would you vote him differently?
Can u pls translate mahiru’s second trail voice drama
Idk I think he should still pay for his crimes I get they were basically dead but it’s also against the law to take organs without the patients or there family’s wishes if dead
i feel like something bad is gonna happen to him idk 😭 maybe related to amane, maybe not
0:20 wait i don't understand this. sorry, english isnt my first language. so like is his ribs broken or is his spine broken because if it's the latter...
oh my god idk how to react but is he born an angel?!?!
OUGH...
Shidou makes me so upset...
The fact that a lot of people think he's STEALING O R G A N S is KILLING me
ESPECIALLY after this voice drama
It's straight up CLARIFIED like in every sense of the word that his crime is that he had to take organs from brain-dead paitents as a part of his JOB, and people think he STOLE ORGANS from his PAITENCE to save his WIFE oh my GOD,,,
like there are so many nuanced crimes and stories based on ethical issues from Japan presented in Milgram, (some of which the "murders" wouldn't be considered murders OR crimes in the judicial system) and the thing a lot of people landed on was "yep, mans stole organs to frankenstien his wife back together"
I-
help.
10:00
vote👏amane 👏guilty👏
(i can't believe i have to say this. the 74% innocent is so nerve-wracking)
shut up
@@obbligatopermanentdamageis that the kanata card w the fish