Christian Claims Sanaa Manuscript Discovery Will Destroy Quran
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 02. 2024
- Discord: / discord
Quran Study App: apple.co/46v1Azk
Video Notes: qurantalkblog.com/2024/01/10/...
Spotify: spoti.fi/30MB7Nw
Podcast: apple.co/2lLnsFE
Twitter: / talkquran
Quran Talk Blog: qurantalkblog.com/
Quran Study Website: www.quranstudyapp.com/grid
Additional Resources: www.quraniclabs.com/
Witness A Miracle: qurantalk.gitbook.io/quran-in...
Refuting typical arguments against Quran alone: qurantalk.gitbook.io/hadith-r...
I found you in a jail cell on my tablet they provide us everyday I listened to you and read my Quran I appreciate you brother you helped me a lot you are doing great work ❤
mashaAllah may Allah ease your burden, strengthen your faith and guide you upon the truth you and your loved ones.
Praise God. Thanks for speaking on the server!
Mashaallah,
These refutations videos are really engaging, perhaps you can do more centered around the manuscripts and preservation.
God bless you.
When I started listening to his hype presentation, and he started quoting the verse on screen, I slapped my own forehead and thought to myself: "Oh no he's quoting the wrong verse..", lol.
And he was so happy and excited about it, poor guy.
My guy will never recover from this 😂
Great refutation
Thank you!
He acted out of Desperation.
They will never find fault in this our deen of Islam as there no fault anywhere.
May Allah guide them
Aameen
thank u brother you should deal with these issues in detail and send it to those these people with large followers and tell them preach and research proper information before misleading people.
God Bless, you should do this more often refuting people
MashaAllah 💯
Sameer was humiliated for this kinda claim as well as Dan drudaker and Ishmael. And this kid really think he's done something new? Lol
Ishmael the former Muslim?
mansha ALLAH
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Mā shāʼ Allāh!
Great video for refuting him he
Great refutation, but it brings me no surprise to know that hadith reciters don’t know how to recite Quran. It’s (إليكم) not (أليكم) and (فلمّا) not (فلما).. if you only believe in the Quran, at least make an effort to learn how to recite it correctly from scholars of the Quran as mistakes can change the meaning
💯
👍
Was the Quran perfectly preserved?
ask a sheep
❤ God alone we worship;
God alone we ask for help.
--------
“ إِنَّنى مِنَ المُسلِمينَ “
“I am one of the submitters”
“من یکی از تسلیم شدگان هستم”
“Ben teslim olanlardan biriyim”
Thank you for proving his allegation wrong
Bold of a christian to speak about corruption while the gospels weren't even written by mark, john, luke and john. 😂😂 without lies, christianity dies
Noways
Can you prove that Achmad means, even more praised?
S61:6 does not rely on The Qur'an but The Torah and is a 100% match.
You can't understand the whole Quran if you reject prior scripture. Verse 2:4.
Those who claim Quran alone and call themselves Quranists or submitters can't get it.
Check the lexicons, pretty sure it does mean more praised or something along those lines
@@sal_strazzullo You: "You can't understand the whole Quran if you reject prior scripture..."
Truth: Yes, and that was implicit in my statement. Obviously if you examine The Torah you will find supporting evidence for Islam which is verifiable through the historic record. However The Qur'an is the greatest proof for everything because of its sophistication.
Discussion: The most relevant ayat are S3:119, 10:94, 21:7, but there are also others in support. In terms of Biblical prophecy one could still argue it was a matter of repeated unlikely coincidences supported by naturally occurring phenomena. There are incredible codes in The Torah but nothing like The Qur'an. However The Revelation is on another level in terms of precision prophecy which is verifiable in real time whereas in terms of our differing calendars and poor record keeping The Torah is commonly held in dispute.
@@Scumophobe I can't read Arabic. Is there an equivalent in Hebrew? Nor do I automatically trust what a lot of people say about word meanings as some of it is made up.
The Torah has been corrupted because Abraham was about to sacrifice Ismael his first born not Isaac born 13 uses later, the order in which the earth & skies was created keeps changing in Genesis. How can Moses write a out his death after he has died? The Jews altered the Torah in order to be able to charge interest on money loaned. If they hadn't changed the Torah & the Jews were following the original laws then Christ would not be sent to confirm what the original laws of the Torah were to the lost sheep & there wouldn't actually be any lost sheep.
Bible is not the gospel of Christ but the gospel of 4 other people recorded by anonymous authors who didn't sign their names. That what gospel ACCORDING to Mark means that someone else is telling you what Mark said about Christ. John 3:16 Blasphemous verse regarding a begotten son, learn what begotten means first then understand why Christian scholars threw this lie or fabricated verse out.
What's more important is
that a 9 old year girl ( Ayisha ) can't be touched by anyone, specially by someone that claims to speak to God.
A man doing that now will be arrested.
Sleeping with little girls is in the bible not the Quran. Yahweh himself has 32 little virgin girls
look up the little virgins of yahweh and moses in the buble
John Calvin (protestant reformer)
He had no problem with older men marrying younger girls:
“Farel, now aged sixty-nine, was betrothed to a mere girl, the daughter of his refugee housekeeper. What is more, she had been for some time, and still was, living under the same roof with him” (T.H.L Parker, John Calvin: A Biography [Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press, 2007], p. 184).
“…no, nothing can be done about it. Farel has given his word to the girl and he must keep it. The marriage is not illegal and no one has a right to break it off”
Thomas Aquinas (greatest Catholic theologian who ever lived)
He believed betrothals could be carried out at 7 years old and sometimes even younger:
“…the age of seven years is fixed reasonably enough by law for the contracting of betrothals, for since a betrothal is a promise of the future…it follows that they are within the competency of those who can make a promise in some way, and this is only for those who can have some foresight of the future…”
( source : Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica: Supplement to the Third Part, ed. Anthony Uyl (Ontario, Canada: Devoted Publishing, 2018), p. 138.)
Tertullian (early church father)
He believed girls should marry at 12 years of age:
“Time even the heathens observe, that, in obedience to the law of nature, they may render their own fights to the (different) ages. For their females they despatch [sic] to their businesses from (the age of) twelve years, but the male from two years later; decreeing puberty (to consist) in years,++ not in espousals or nuptials. “Housewife” one is called, albeit a virgin, and “house-father,” albeit a stripling. By us not even natural laws are observed; as if the God of nature were some other than ours!”
(Source: Tertullian, On the Veiling of Virgins, Chapter XI)
1 Corinthians 7:36-38: But if any man think that he behaveth himself uncomely toward his virgin, if she pass the flower of her age, and need so require
Ezekiel 16:7-8: I made you grow like a plant of the field. You grew and developed and entered puberty. Your breasts had formed and your hair had grown, yet you were stark naked.
"Later I passed by, and when I looked at you and saw that you were old enough for love, I spread the corner of my garment over you and covered your naked body. I gave you my solemn oath and entered into a covenant with you, declares the Sovereign Lord, and you became mine.
John 14:16
And I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Advocate to help you and be with you forever. (NIV)
I took a look at the Aramaic wording of this verse, and the Aramaic uses the Greek word, without translating it. So in Aramaic this reads:
wə ˀănā ˁbˁy min ˀăḇy wə ḥrēnā paraqlēṭā net'el lk,uwn d'nehwə ˁamk,uwn lˁālam
wə - and, also
ˀănā - I
ˁbˁy - to seek for something / someone, to ask someone for something, to wish for something / someone, to want (Common Aramaic), to investigate (Qumran), to pray (Biblical Aramaic Daniel, Qumran, Jewish Literary Aramaic targumim, Samaritan, Syriac, Jewish Babylonian, Late Jewish Literary Aramaic), something to be due / to be about to do something (Biblical Aramaic Daniel, Jewish Literary Aramaic targumim, Galilean Aramaic, Palestinian Targumic Aramaic, Samaritan, Jewish Babylonian 'Magic Bowls' text, Jewish Babylonian), to seek (Samaritan), to summon / invite (Galilean Aramaic, Syriac, Late Jewish Literary Aramaic), etc. (first person singular, imperfect)
min - from [indicating agent / cause]
ˀăḇy - [my] (heavenly) father, [my] God (Palestinian Targumic Aramaic, Christian Palestinian, Syriac) - all other usages and meanings pertain to other than God
wə - and, also
ḥrēnā - from ˀoḥrān - other (Common Aramaic), different from, anything else (Syriac), next one (Galilean Aramaic, Christian Palestinian)
paraqlēṭā - advocate (loanword), its meaning is referred to Job 33:23 in the scholarly analysis, I'll come back to this..
net'el - to give, to provide, make available (Common Aramaic), to allow, to grant (Christian Palestinian, Late Jewish Literary Aramaic), to make into, to sell, to exchange for (Official Aramaic, Jewish Literary Aramaic targumim, Palestinian Targumic Aramaic) (third person singular, imperfect)
lk,uwn - to, for you (second person masculine plural mode)
d'nehwə - to be, to become, to endure, to exist, to come to pass, to happen, to come into existence, to change state, to turn into (Common Aramaic), to create, to be created (Syriac), etc. - also used as an augmentative marker of tense and/or aspect; several idiomatic usages exist but don't seem applicable or appropriate in this context, with the possible exception of something indicating repetition or progressivity
ˁamk,uwn / ˁimk,uwn - with you (plural), with, together with, in the presence of, at the same location (Common Aramaic)
lˁālam - forever, eternally (Common Aramaic, Christian Palestinian Aramaic, Syriac, Mandaic, LJLA), from of old (CPA)
Job 33:23
If there is an angelic messenger over him, an intercessor, one out of a thousand, to declare for a man his uprightness.
mê-lîṣ - intercessor, mediator, interpreter, one who speaks indirectly (turning aside), ambassador, figurative of intermediaries between God and man
So the Paraclete is interpreted as a being similar to the angels mentioned in Job; one who communicates and intercedes, or an ambassador. I find this rather peculiar, since Christians maintain that the Paraclete is the Holy Spirit, and that the Holy Spirit isn't an angel. Yet here, their scholars refer Paraclete to the mediating angel from Job 33:23, as to understand his function.
Anyway, some possible translations of the verse:
And I will request from my Father, and another Paraclete He will give to you, to be with you forever.
And I will seek (it) from my (heavenly) Father, and a next Paraclete He will grant for you, to eternally remain beside you.
And I will implore my God to provide for you the following Paraclete, to exist alongside you for all times.
And I shall ask of my God to allow a different Paraclete to emerge and always remain among you.
This sounds like the speaker (i.e. Jesus) is saying that he himself has also been a Paraclete to them, as indicated by wə ḥrēnā paraqlēṭā, i.e. "and an alternative Paraclete", and paraqlēṭā net'el lk,uwn, i.e. "[another] Paraclete in exchange [of the current one] for you". The many possible meanings and usages of d'nehwə, from hwāy, including "to be, be created, come into being, etc." indicate that this Paraclete is a creation, like all beings are (aside from God Himself). He will have a beginning to his existence, in the future from the context of the speaker's perspective. "With you" doesn't specifically mean the individuals that are being addressed directly in that verse, but means "the believers", in general, and over time (into the future). So the Paraclete comes as a successor of Jesus, and is similar to him, but other than him, and when he comes, he will remain with the believers until the end of the world. The word lˁālam can also mean "from of old", and so the idea here might be that the truth or the message has always been the same, and will remain the same, into the future. This expression could simply pertain to the Paraclete's teachings and example. Christians, of course, say that the Paraclete is the Holy Spirit, and that's their prerogative and their understanding to which they are entitled, but I don't really see that being communicated in the Aramaic.
The verse also implies that Jesus wasn't going to be with the believers. He would go, and in place of him, another would come. And that one would stay in the world. What does that mean? If the remaining of the Paraclete in this world, with the believers, refers to the teachings, then Jesus' teachings would vanish. At least for a while and until the Paraclete comes to lead the believers. If the Paraclete is the Holy Spirit, then Christians would say that the Holy Spirit's teachings or inspirations are perfectly in line with Jesus', and so why then doesn't the text say that Jesus will stay with them forever? And why is he called a comforter? How does he comfort the believers? What are they grieving about? Questions, questions.
I don't think this verse contained the name Ahmad, but "advocate" or "comforter" might have been referring to a Messenger of God to come after Jesus; one who would teach them and possibly function as an intercessor for them. He corrects the perverted beliefs concerning Jesus, and thus his coming comforts the true (monotheistic) believers. The religion he teaches, with its specifics, and with the next Divine revelation was going to remain in this world forever. Perhaps that's all from the biased perspective of a Muslim, but Allah knows best.
Gg
Hahaha Bro "that's not in the Sanaa manuscript but Cairo edition" you say right?
To mean that the Cairo edition differs from the Sanaa and the current global version right? To mean that here on your table you've three different variants of Quran?
Islam for sure is a fat lie.