2 DECADES, SAME MAGIC | Nightwish (Gethsemane 1999 & 2019)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
  • We simply couldn't look at only one version of this and thank goodness I did. Incredible to run it back with Nightwish and can't wait for more new music...and maybe some older bangers I've missed too.
    Any suggestions, leave 'em in the comments or hit me up on
    Twitter: / chasecarneson
    Instagram: / chasecarneson
    Tik Tok: / chase_carneson
    WAYS TO SUPPORT
    ▶️ PREMIERES AND LIVE STREAMS: / @chasecarneson
    ✅ CLAIM FREE PLAYLIST: • CLAIM-FREE VIDEO REACT...
    🎧 SUBSCRIBE TO TWITCH: / chasecarneson
    💪 BECOME A MEMBER ON PATREON: / chasecarneson and choose your tier or make a pledge. Access to blocked videos, early access where possible and a special discord role.
    💰 PAYPAL DONATIONS: Use the email: tinytipjar@gmail.com
    👍 SUB, LIKE, COMMENT & SHARE: / @chasecarneson
    🔊 DISCORD SERVER LINK: / discord
    Any suggestions, leave 'em in the comments or hit me up on
    Twitter: / chasecarneson
    Instagram: / chasecarneson
    Tik Tok: / chase_carneson
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS

Komentáře • 297

  • @WNYretiree
    @WNYretiree Před 4 měsíci +70

    I love that you haven't forgotten Nightwish as you have moved on in your journey. Thank you for remembering that they are in a very large part responsible for the growth of your channel.

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci +23

      Never forgotten them, could never, can’t wait for new music. I think I’ve done over 40 reaction videos to them so always good to explore new music. I’ll always be back with them.z

  • @reactionsaccount3955
    @reactionsaccount3955 Před 4 měsíci +181

    I am forever grateful for Tarja and her operatic singing, because without it, I'm convinced that Tuomas would not have gone in the musical style that he did, but Floor is by far my favorite Nightwish singer.

    • @Kulta87
      @Kulta87 Před 4 měsíci +24

      Tarja is for me. Again I started at 12-13. It is a TV show from 1999. One of their first live performances ever The guys except Sammy are just back from their military service. I believe Tarja is 21. Floor is 38. Tarja at 38 is quite a diff singer. I like Floor’s take. But I just adore Baby Nightwish and the Kitee 5. And both singers sing to fit Tuomas’s vibe at the time. Goth Disney v Metal Zimmer.

    • @reactionsaccount3955
      @reactionsaccount3955 Před 4 měsíci +9

      @@Kulta87 Nope, you have not changed my mind, I still prefer Floor. HEHE! 😉

    • @andresweiland3714
      @andresweiland3714 Před 4 měsíci +5

      @@Kulta87 Not to mention that all the original arrengments for that song was made by Tarja. It is lot easier to grab a song already build it and decorated it and twist it a bit to make it look better. That's why covers that really matters are what change the form of the song in a long way. But you know easy is more affordable.

    • @andreea007
      @andreea007 Před 4 měsíci +3

      ​@@andresweiland3714 Interesting... I've wondered many times why is it that their concerts are focused on older songs, even though they have plenty of new material to use.
      Almost like they don't trust the new songs to make a great concert.
      I thought that the new songs were less popular among the fans due to Tuomas change in composition, but after reading your comment, I think that you have a valid point about how the singer can embellish and bring "color" to a song or not...

    • @nemo78
      @nemo78 Před 4 měsíci +14

      I agree. I think Tarja was necessary for Tuomas and band to develope their style. But Tarja soon became a limitation because she's quite one dimensional as a singer. Anette was one necessary intermediate but with Floor they finally reached their full potential becayse she can pretty much sing anything.

  • @thegirl.frombackthen
    @thegirl.frombackthen Před 4 měsíci +66

    "Without you, the poetry within me is dead..." 🥀

    • @SideBurn12
      @SideBurn12 Před 4 měsíci +8

      Such an incredibly iconic couple of words.

  • @sabertoetiger2582
    @sabertoetiger2582 Před 4 měsíci +22

    On the Tarja version, the boys are trying to grow their "army hair" out 😂 They are sooooo young❤

  • @kevinbrookes6550
    @kevinbrookes6550 Před 4 měsíci +40

    Nightwish + Chase = Magic.

  • @adamparrott797
    @adamparrott797 Před 4 měsíci +39

    I like that we got those singers. that is the end of the argument for me.

  • @Cherlindrea99
    @Cherlindrea99 Před 4 měsíci +32

    Don't forget that Tarja was young when she started to sing with Nightwish. And Floor had a lot of experience when she started to sing with Nightwish. If people want a fair competition, compare Tarja when she was the lead singer of Nightwish with Floor when she was the lead singer of After Forever. I love both singers and I just love Nightwish, any era.

    • @miskatonic6210
      @miskatonic6210 Před 4 měsíci +3

      Floor has always been more versatile...right from the start.

    • @alexandra-md5he
      @alexandra-md5he Před 4 měsíci +10

      ​@@miskatonic6210Old fans did not care about a versatile singer! Tarja made Nightwish what they was.An opera metal band and we adored this....

    • @Cherlindrea99
      @Cherlindrea99 Před 4 měsíci +7

      Tarja was not the first or only lead singer of a (metal) band to sing in an operatic style. Floor was also singing a lot in an operatic style when she was with After Forever. Also was Sharon den Adel with Within Temptation. The Gathering singer Marike Groot was singing in an operatic way in 1992.
      After Tarja left, Tuomas didn't want a singer that sounded like Tarja. They deliberately chose Anette for her poppy singing style. Therefore Nightwish could evolve to a more versatile metal style. Before that awful letter to Tarja, that should have be kept personal, she had already decided to leave the band to be able to focus on her solo career. So she had planned to leave Nightwish anyway and they all knew and agreed. Without the open letter you all would blame Tarja for leaving, thinking it was her fault the band would never sound the same again.
      From 2005 Nightwish was ready to change and Anette made this possible. Some of the very best Nightwish songs were written in this era. When she left and Floor was there, Nightwish could evolve even more. Not just because Floor was the more versatile singer. She had to learn first, by stretching her talents and crash and burn (-out), how much she was capable of and what was too much to maintain her balance and health. The period with her own band ReVamp, and especially the period she couldn't do anything anymore, has made her a strong, well balanced band member and singer. Floor loves the stage, loves performing, knows how to contribute to make a song even better. She knows how to create a song. This is experience. She might have left everything up to Tuomas (and Marko) in creating music if she had started in 1996 with Nightwish. Everything turned out in the best possible way.

    • @alexandra-md5he
      @alexandra-md5he Před 4 měsíci +1

      ​@@Cherlindrea99so every fan base choose to join the era it likes the most and consider each era like a different band.

    • @Cherlindrea99
      @Cherlindrea99 Před 4 měsíci +1

      ​@@alexandra-md5heno, most just love Nightwish 🤘🏻❤

  • @JudaGoethe
    @JudaGoethe Před 4 měsíci +15

    Nightwish had 3 amazing singers, all of them with their own style. But Floor and Tarja always will have a special place in my heart. I love both versions

  • @TimoArula
    @TimoArula Před 4 měsíci +24

    2 DECADES, SAME MAGIC... a perfect summary !!!
    As long we have Tuomas, there is NIGHTWISH.
    Tarja, Anette, Floor, All great in their own way, but Floor is, and always will be, my Absolute Favorite singer and human being !
    NWSU/FloorFan/Epican/Ayreonaut/TWA 🤘😎🤘

  • @neecedarquewulf
    @neecedarquewulf Před 4 měsíci +55

    I call them The Triforce Sisterhood.
    They are always in each other's IG comments.
    Anette recently was in Tarja's IG comments saying she's glad to see Tarja and Marko are happy.
    Both were in Floor's when Floor told everyone she made Cancer kneel.
    I ♥️ the 3 of them.

    • @strabel803
      @strabel803 Před 4 měsíci +2

      👍Remember,there was never a dispute between the 3 female singers of Nightwish,i think i can say that they have respect for each other and in general most female metal singers support each other,don't or have never heard much negative comments towards each other😄 ,wich can not be said about the male singers.😏

  • @pancentricism
    @pancentricism Před 4 měsíci +27

    Gethsemane is a garden in Jerusalem and it is where Judas Iscariot is supposed to have betrayed JC with a kiss.

    • @Boa_Omega
      @Boa_Omega Před 4 měsíci +6

      It is the Garden where Jesus went to pray to Heavenly Father. Where he made the infinite atonement. He suffered every affliction and pain of sin for all humanity for all time.

  • @missrubyphoenix
    @missrubyphoenix Před 4 měsíci +12

    What I love the most about their older songs is how quickly the guys played their instruments, I mean Tarja did a great job vocally, on the new version I love every single thing, my favourite line though, which "Without You The Poetry Within Me Is Dead" I feel like Floor evoked a lot more emotion in it, not that much pain per se, but rather the angst of a poet in love with love and him begging to that person not to abandon him

  • @Rico.at.50
    @Rico.at.50 Před 4 měsíci +20

    I saw Floor perform this in Baltimore on the Decades tour. The whole show was pure magic!

    • @louisminten7889
      @louisminten7889 Před 4 měsíci +7

      I saw the Decades Tour 2018 in Antwerp Belgium. They were amazing

    • @marianohaentjens8588
      @marianohaentjens8588 Před 3 měsíci +1

      ​@@louisminten7889: was daar ook..heel emotioneel...we hadden een spandoek bij.get lost Xena..we ve got our own warrior princess 💪

    • @louisminten7889
      @louisminten7889 Před 3 měsíci

      @@marianohaentjens8588 Geweldig en ze had hetzelfde badass outfit aan als in BA

  • @irenevanderstaak5178
    @irenevanderstaak5178 Před 4 měsíci +15

    This afternoon NIGHTWISH announced their 10th album YESTERWYNDE will come out 20 September next😀 First single Perfume Of The Timeless will be released on 21st May next🎉🎉 🎉🎉

  • @karihaapanen7520
    @karihaapanen7520 Před 4 měsíci +15

    Man I've missed you back with Nightwish. On May 21st they will release a song from their upcoming album. I'm looking forward to it so much. Are you?

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci +9

      Always. Can’t wait for that new one and I’ll be all over it for sure.

  • @johngriffin7255
    @johngriffin7255 Před 4 měsíci +10

    This is the song that got me into Nightwish. Totally unique.

  • @mattihelin5101
    @mattihelin5101 Před 4 měsíci +11

    Please, Beauty of the beast. A song of a hopeless hope. So melodic, sinister, sad, angry and mellow.

    • @InesBeatrice
      @InesBeatrice Před 4 měsíci +1

      Yes, oh a 100 times YES, please!
      I need it so badly!

  • @monikaklimczak9828
    @monikaklimczak9828 Před 4 měsíci +13

    So happy to see you back with Nightwish

  • @hansikemmerling4513
    @hansikemmerling4513 Před 4 měsíci +17

    In the whole singer discussion one may not forget that the whole band, floor and also the live composition itself are more mature now than in the older videos with Tarja.
    If they would play the same song today with Tarja it would also be different than that 1999 version.

    • @helia4161
      @helia4161 Před 4 měsíci +1

      I would love to hear Tarja sing this today

    • @strabel803
      @strabel803 Před 4 měsíci

      Shure👍 but, musicly and in quality it would change and i think i can say Tarja is also a better singer now,vocaly there would always be a big difference in interpretation between Tarja and Floor,wich,in my opinion,is a good thing,so we have a choise who or wich version we prefer,nothing to do with "better" just different.🤘

  • @kimfabritiusdetengnagel2038
    @kimfabritiusdetengnagel2038 Před 4 měsíci +3

    I believe that one of the reasons why Nightwish have grown into what to hey are today - is that Floor first got the call in 2012. If she has got it in 2005 (they wanted her, but didn't call because of diff circumstances). But in 2012 they were all ready!
    If she had started back in 2005, Floor might not have been so versatile in her storytelling, but more operatic, because at that time, she really liked to incorporate opera style in most of her songs (she wrote almost all the After Forever songs, after Mark left - and that was not what Tuomas wanted...
    Luckily we will never know..
    Facts is that she is the perfect storyteller for Tuomas's lyrics - because she makes them her own - without changing the deeper thoughts in the stories - Floor actually enhances them.

  • @kimmikke_
    @kimmikke_ Před 4 měsíci +5

    A Great thing to say, that every member of Nightwish has been equally important to develop and improve the band's music and performance, not only the singers but EVERYONE!

  • @-AD-Astra-0
    @-AD-Astra-0 Před 4 měsíci +33

    Yo! You're always on time! Just today, Nightwish announced their new album, Yesterwynde! It's going to be a hell of an adventure, and I'm really looking forward to getting out and seeing your reaction.

    • @grahambatchelor3576
      @grahambatchelor3576 Před 4 měsíci +2

      And don't forget, the first 'single' off the album comes out May 21st entitled "Perfume of the Timeless".

  • @andraskovacs8959
    @andraskovacs8959 Před 4 měsíci +4

    It's crazy to realize that out of the founding members, only Tuomas and Emppu are still with the band today, and even in this 2019 video.
    New drummer, second new bassist, second new singer, the addition of a "yes" player(as in: "Troy, what instruments do you play?"-"Yes")... but the band's soul is intact.
    I recall an interview question asking Tarja what would become of the band if she left, the short answer was "Tuomaswish". But I reckon it was mostly "Tuomaswish" right from the start :)

  • @brittjannesath2539
    @brittjannesath2539 Před 4 měsíci +9

    My first Nightwish song that i heard was with Tarja. I love all the 3 singers, they have all brought something different to the bands sound. 😀

  • @dreamflight5637
    @dreamflight5637 Před 3 měsíci +2

    I love Tarja and she was soooo good when she was younger ... BUT Floor's voice gives me goosebumbs like noone and when she sings ,, classical '' it is just so strong ( mid notes ) and her interpretation and ability to tell story is something so special.

  • @robertsheeler321
    @robertsheeler321 Před 4 měsíci +10

    Nightwish Army USA (Pa) division saying welcome back to Nightwish , sure have missed your Nightwish breakdowns and really looking forward to more . Thank You

  • @mikeatwork3279
    @mikeatwork3279 Před 4 měsíci +34

    Chase back with Nightwish - what a pleasant surprise !😀🤘

  • @thegirl.frombackthen
    @thegirl.frombackthen Před 4 měsíci +12

    "Metal Mozart" at work! 🎹

  • @karadenizin-kizi
    @karadenizin-kizi Před 4 měsíci +7

    "It's beautiful. It's exactly the way it's supposed to be" this is literally it! Every singer, ever band member brings their all to these performances, they all were chosen, they were meant to perform those songs at that time and that's why trying to talk negatively about one or the other is so tiresome.
    Have your preference but be kind about it. I enjoy all three singers and usually I enjoy them most on the songs from their own eras. This song really profits from Tarja's darker a bit more delicate sound for me, it's beautifully mysterious. :)

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci +3

      Agree. Both beautiful and perfect in their own way. Really appreciate what both singers did for this band and my CZcams journey.

  • @medomedoish
    @medomedoish Před 4 měsíci +3

    Hi, you're right: the- let's called it- Floor version is so unique and rich and... don't know... beautiful. But the original version, the one with Tarja on stage is in 1998, or maybe '99... This Is a revolution! Nightwish changed the way to feel metal music, the way to delivery metal music... they change metal music in it's intimacy: this is Art! 🙂

  • @adamparrott797
    @adamparrott797 Před 4 měsíci +7

    I remember they changed up the structure of the orchestral arrangements for all the older songs when bringing them live, all the parts have been rerecorded for the backing tracks, it was also to fit both Marko and Troy in too.

  • @dolla3975
    @dolla3975 Před 4 měsíci +31

    Woohoo! Chase and Nightwish,! ❤

  • @marcklinker9229
    @marcklinker9229 Před 4 měsíci +13

    Happy to see you back with Nightwish.

  • @louisminten7889
    @louisminten7889 Před 4 měsíci +4

    This song is very underrated imho. I have seen this myself at the Decades Tour 2018 in Antwerp Belgium with Floor and Emppu on guitar killing it

    • @miskatonic6210
      @miskatonic6210 Před 4 měsíci +2

      It certainly doesn't get the reactions it should get compared to other songs.

  • @michaellein2389
    @michaellein2389 Před 4 měsíci +5

    16:17 Today Nightwish announced their new album Yesterwynde. Release date is September 20th.

  • @nemo_8689
    @nemo_8689 Před měsícem

    im late again... this is one of the very rare nightwish songs which I mostly like on album. live too obviously, but the album version is so polished and sounds amazing.

  • @rkempo
    @rkempo Před 4 měsíci +1

    These type of videos illicit comparisons and I was apprehensive to give this watch because it happened, but I am pleased the comment section is clean from such things, so respect to everyone who were mature enough (mostly)

  • @WLsmiling
    @WLsmiling Před 4 měsíci +2

    I LOVE Floor 😍 Her voice!!!!!

  • @pancentricism
    @pancentricism Před 4 měsíci +15

    Chase, have you heard from Julia Nilon recently? She hasn't posted on her youtube channel for three months. Hope she's OK.

  • @PaulOutdoors
    @PaulOutdoors Před 4 měsíci +4

    Ahhhhh Chase back with Nightwish and the look on his face starting at 15:26 is priceless. Gethsemane is my message notification on my phone 😊. I love all three Nightwish leading ladies but Floor as lead is my favourite flavour and Buenos Aires 2018 is where Floor breathed new life in to a number of Nightwish classics that pre-date her time with the band and made them her own. Geniuses at work indeed Chase. Thank you Sir. 🙏😊👍❤️

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci +2

      Thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏 and completely agree.

  • @Mirrigold
    @Mirrigold Před 4 měsíci +5

    I've been a fan of Nightwish since their first album came out. I saw them live in London with Tarja at both the Apollo and the Astoria, I own all the albums and DVDs (three different versions of Once, which remains my favourite album). I still prefer Floor overall within the rest of Nightwish as a whole, I think her voice rounds out their sound in more ways than Tarja, even though Tarja's operatic vocals work beautifully on their earliest stuff and there are a couple of songs I prefer her version over Floor's (Phantom being one of them).
    I think you're absolutely right to point out that without any of their singers, including Anette, (who is often just thrown aside by everyone!) that each of them has brought their unique talents to making Nightwish successful.
    Will be looking forward to their 10th studio album in September and seeing you react to that!

  • @LittlePapaJohn
    @LittlePapaJohn Před 4 měsíci +1

    This is one of the first songs that made me fall in love with them in the 90's. Most likely that is why I prefer the first version. It brings back the memories of that decade. Another band I loved was After forever. But After forever changed when Mark left and created Epica. It was such a great time in seeing those great musicians grow up and give us so much.

  • @lujalainen1
    @lujalainen1 Před 4 měsíci +4

    great labor day,let´s party. thanx to great reaction and have wonderful tuesday. great to see you again in nighwish reactions chase.

  • @Mars-is4un
    @Mars-is4un Před 4 měsíci +2

    🤗🍒🤘🏻 Great Job and I completely agree with you that Floor and Troy bring a lot more than the others

  • @yakovnevsky7897
    @yakovnevsky7897 Před 4 měsíci +4

    Good to see you at it again, Chase ❤

  • @m.vondrake5534
    @m.vondrake5534 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I was also at the San Francisco show. Absolutely magical.

  • @rolandconnor575
    @rolandconnor575 Před 4 měsíci +2

    The latest from Marko - his states he would "consider rejoining Nightwish if they changed how the business end of the band operates"..... a 2026 tour is closer than you think.

  • @perrycleese5987
    @perrycleese5987 Před 4 měsíci +1

    100% agree with you ❤

  • @henryvandenbrand
    @henryvandenbrand Před 4 měsíci +1

    I'm so happy that my first nightwish song was with Floor. If it would have been Tarja I would probably have stopped after one song. I just can't get used to her voice.

    • @eulukeborges
      @eulukeborges Před 3 měsíci +1

      With me was the opposite. Started with floor that is more accessible. But after knew Tarja and the magic with opera mixed with metal, never stopped listening to

  • @lea-anne9133
    @lea-anne9133 Před 4 měsíci

    We all love Nightwish in all of it's forms, but one thing I love is that there are people out there discovering them for the very first time. I think that's amazing❤

  • @Boa_Omega
    @Boa_Omega Před 4 měsíci +2

    This is as far as I know the earliest NW or #babywish footage. And Tarja and Floor are great friends. Support eachother. Tara gave Floor her blessings to join NW. They met in 02 when Floor's then band opened for NW in Europe over the summer.
    Tarja played with floor at FVMF9 in 2013. Called for Love and no hate.
    So as the 2 Queens hugged it out during the singing of Over the hills, how about respect both their wishes. Tarja and Floor even had a live Q&A on IG during lockdown.
    They are not in cometition. So why are the fans?
    I make no secret I am Winterstorm from Canada. But hey I hope the band does well.

  • @kezca
    @kezca Před 4 měsíci +4

    That was a joy

  • @SteveOpstad
    @SteveOpstad Před 4 měsíci

    "Put it in my veins"! When you said that I just blurted out, "Fuck Yeah!"
    Thru some hard times, sickness and physical pain its been the healing power of Nightwish and The Gathering running thru my veins healing from within. I'm grateful for every songwriter and musician who offers up the magic in their soul for the rest of us to feed upon and enjoy. Music is that extra dimension that allows us release and relief from the dimensions that rule our physical world. I'd not want to experience a world without it.

  • @sodayoda5762
    @sodayoda5762 Před 4 měsíci +4

    Great reaction man👌💯 keep doing what you do🤟maybe next song Dead Gardens by Nightwish

    • @PaulOutdoors
      @PaulOutdoors Před 4 měsíci +2

      Yes, Tarja's voice on "Dead Gardens" is wonderful 🙏😊👍❤️

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci

      Don’t know this one so it’s definitely and option.

  • @rob3863
    @rob3863 Před 4 měsíci +3

    Nice to see you, I feel like a soul company😀.

  • @SERGI1974
    @SERGI1974 Před 4 měsíci

    Nightwish has had three great singers. I've always been in love with Floor's voice since I heard her sing on After Forever over 20 years ago, but I first met Nighwish with Oceanborn and Tarja. Tarja will always be the voice that put the group there and that probably paved the way for many other singers with similar characteristics within metal.

  • @NightwishArena
    @NightwishArena Před 4 měsíci +1

    Well, the 1999 version was their first public appearance in Finnish national television in January 1999. So it was not a real gig and most of the audience was probably not metal heads. That explains alittle bit of that "golf-clap".
    And welcome back!

  • @davidellinsworth3299
    @davidellinsworth3299 Před 4 měsíci +4

    Well ... I was searching only last week to see if you'd done this one. Great to see you returning to NW
    All with short hair as they'd not long finished their national service for Finland

  • @mattiniemi7
    @mattiniemi7 Před 4 měsíci

    This is the song that hooked me in so so many years ago. Love the old video. Imagine going to see some up and coming rock band and getting to hear this!
    Can't wait to hear the new single.

  • @laitaa
    @laitaa Před 4 měsíci +4

    Thanks for the reaction! I like both singers, and Anette too. :-) Anyway, nowadays Tarja's own career is the most interesting one.

  • @alexthorpe6583
    @alexthorpe6583 Před 4 měsíci +7

    It was probably just Tuomas and Emmpu that were in both videos.

  • @rickphil9999
    @rickphil9999 Před 4 měsíci

    Hey Chase. Longtime subscriber here... huge Nightwish fan from Phoenix... good to see you back to our beloved band. As several others have said in their comments, I think Tarja is a terrific talent as is exemplified by her ongoing performances and collaborations with Within Temptation and now with Marko Hietala... but, for me, Floor is the one. Now, as you said, Chase, I came to Nightwish a few years ago through a reaction to Floor with Nightwish, and fell in love with her and them. I noted that you said you had a chance to see them perform live in San Francisco, so I am thinking it might have been that same May 18th, 2022 performance at the historic Warfield Theater, that Carol, my wife of 43 years, and I got to travel from Phoenix to see. We loved every second of it, from standing in line outside the venue with the thousands of wonderful fans, and throughout the entire concert. Good to see you back reacting to them again, my friend. Thank you. And have a Damn Good Day!

  • @mae6413
    @mae6413 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Worth the wait Chase, awesome reaction! I love the 2019 Decades tour version so much. The original is on the album Oceanborn, which was recorded before they ever started collaborating with an entire orchestra. I believe they only had a string quartet and a flute on that album. The new orchestrated backing tracks for the Decades tour brought so much detail to the sound and made it so full and sort of magical to me. And to me, Floor is such a story teller with her vocals, and that just elevates the song to a new height for me. None of that is to hate on the 1990's version of course - I've been here for 20 years and loving it all. But I just love to see them elevate their music even beyond the original awesomeness.

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci

      Thank you so much for the supper and for the kind words. Very very much appreciated.

  • @rabidsmiles
    @rabidsmiles Před 4 měsíci +42

    There is nothing like Floor attacking the older material and slaying it.

  • @mautadit_merde
    @mautadit_merde Před 4 měsíci +1

    90s Nightwish had so much energy. Tarja was just this girl from Kitee who sang for the town nerd Tuomas's band. Nothing was polished, no one was cool or pretty, they were just some dweebs from a small town who wanted to rock out.

  • @LDBHX
    @LDBHX Před 4 měsíci +9

    That's my favourite song ❣
    And I prefer Floor 💜 version
    Obviously Emppu 🔥🤘
    Thank you for reaction finally 💜💞🙏🤘

  • @jannepeuraniemi5053
    @jannepeuraniemi5053 Před 4 měsíci +1

    This one the songs that for me is a Tarja song, but that's mostly because I've grown up with Nightwish since -98. But the Decades version with Floor has a special place in my heart, most importantly because of Floor I was able to hear those old songs live for the first time ever (Most of the older song were not played in years, and I couldn't attend to Nightwish shows when Tarja was in the band). Oceanborn is such a great album, in my personal top 2 with Once.
    On another note, Chase, we have to talk about Wintersun. You made a reaction to Sons Of Winter And Stars some 3 years ago, but never really got back in to them. I humbly request that you would react to their song Time (Live at Sonic Pump Studios), it is an absolute masterpiece of music. This band is amazing, and the mastermind Jari Mäenpää is often said to be right up there with Tuomas as the top tier composers coming from Finland in modern day. They also have a new album Time II coming out on August with more epic metal for you to check out as well.

  • @jalthaleakala4113
    @jalthaleakala4113 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Floor ❤️❤️❤️

  • @melaniewinkler9243
    @melaniewinkler9243 Před 4 měsíci

    Thanx for picking this! It's one of my favorites.
    Always a pleasure to watch your reactions. 😊

  • @majbrat
    @majbrat Před 4 měsíci

    Just stunning.
    Original is great.
    New version is exceptional.
    It's like polishing a fine gem.

  • @domfol5515
    @domfol5515 Před 4 měsíci +2

    Nice timing Chase , I believe nightwish have a new album, due for release in September but a single in may !

  • @PittDaddy
    @PittDaddy Před 4 měsíci +1

    You still have it Chase! Miss your Nightwish reviews

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci +2

      Appreciate this a bunch. Thank you 🙏

  • @morbb5691
    @morbb5691 Před 4 měsíci

    The first time I heard any of Nightwish's music was from the Tarja era. I just so resonated with the melodic style of their music with Tarja's operatic vocals. I love hearing her hit the high notes in songs like Wishmaster. I got to see Nightwish in concert in 2015 in Louisville, KY when they were on tour with Delain (did I get that right?) and another band (can't remember their name).
    I actually like all 3 of the vocalists. Floor seems to be the most diverse vocally. She can have moments when she growls, she can hit high notes really well and she can also sound much, but not exactly, like Tarja at times like in this song Gethsemane and the song Stargazers from their live album at Wembley. I liked Annete Olson's voice also, although you can tell that she definitely has her style and vocal range. Annette did a good job on a live version of the song Sahara : )
    AND Nightwish will have another album coming out in September!

  • @papa6036
    @papa6036 Před 4 měsíci +3

    Very nice reaction....love both performances The 2019 version is better for shure because better and newer recording....so or so this song is a masterpiece in my opinion....thx Chase

  • @roooobiin
    @roooobiin Před 4 měsíci

    We have waited far too long chase! Keep em nightwish reactions coming!🤤

  • @gabrielbarrosuccelli6935
    @gabrielbarrosuccelli6935 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I'm expecting SO MUCH from this new album, cannot wait for the single on may 21

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci

      Yeah to say im excited is an understatement. Bring on May and September already.

  • @franciscojaviervazquez2635
    @franciscojaviervazquez2635 Před 4 měsíci

    You should repeat some of your fav songs with this format "before: after". I liked this... I missed you with Nw Songs...
    And I must tell you that Gethsemane was my favourite song for a while... THE ENDING IS SO PURE AND ORGASMIC. I close my eyes always at the end.

  • @hoges412
    @hoges412 Před 4 měsíci +3

    That last vocal line "Without you,
    The poetry within me is dead." One of several Nightwish songs that can still reduce me to tears. Thanks Chase, Gethsemane is one of my all time NW favourites - either version!

  • @judedornisch4946
    @judedornisch4946 Před 4 měsíci +2

    See you on May 21 or 22 when the first song off the new album drops.

  • @papaverweg
    @papaverweg Před 4 měsíci +1

    Hello Chase, welcome back to Nightwish. Gethsemane (Greek: ΓεΘσημανἰ, Gethsēmani, from Hebrew: גת שמנים, Gath-shmanim - literally "oil press") or Gethsemane is a garden or court at the foot of the Mount of Olives famous because Jesus prayed there on the night before his crucifixion . East of Jerusalem is the Mount of Olives; between the Mount of Olives and that city lies the Kidron Valley, containing Gethsemane.
    BTW, although the DVD release is dated 2019, the Decades concert in Buenos Aires was already in 2018.
    The 1999 recording was before Marko joined Nightwish (2001 to early 2021) and took over Sami Vänskä's place.
    I fully realize that Floor's version would not have sounded what it does now without the input and virtuality of both her predecessors. Tarja was also very young in 1999 (22 years old, born August 17, 1977) and was only at the beginning of her singing career. Her own style has developed even further since then. Anette Olson also made a major contribution by adding a different sound with her voice and broadening the sound of Nightwish. Floor was only lucky that her voice was already better trained and, above all, added life experience and empathy. She is highly sensitive and that benefits Nightwish's songs. She now manages to combine the forces of both her predecessors and makes Floor, with the addition of her own qualities, (for me) the most beloved front woman of Nightwish. So it's not that I don't like Tarja, I just prefer Floor's attitude, commitment and dedication. (I just find the former innocent Tarja more pleasant than the current Tarja).

  • @bridgetmccracken1381
    @bridgetmccracken1381 Před 4 měsíci +9

    For me this will always and forever be a Tarja song!!! They were all so young yet so freaking talented!!!

  • @vonniezuid7663
    @vonniezuid7663 Před 4 měsíci

    Nice to see you back on Nightwish, love your reactions!

  • @Susirajantakaa
    @Susirajantakaa Před 4 měsíci +1

    You can like one without dissing the other. If people just learned they can not lift someone by putting others down. I can not imagine any of these singers would like their fans shit talking others.

  • @sheilacorbin521
    @sheilacorbin521 Před 4 měsíci +2

    I like Tarja and she's a great singer however Floor is a musical chameleon. I absolutely love her!

  • @robvanraak
    @robvanraak Před 4 měsíci

    Loved your engaged drumming Chase. Thank you for your honest reaction to this beautiful song. And it's not for comparing singers they are both amazing.

  • @elvwood
    @elvwood Před 4 měsíci

    I think it's fine to have favourite vocalists, and even more fine to have favourite vocalists for particular songs, the only problem is when it becomes a competition or if you mistake personal taste for objectivity. Floor is generally my favourite and I realise that is at least partly because she was my first, however there are songs (and even passages) where I prefer Tarja or Anette. I enjoy them all!

  • @Mary-rf9ui
    @Mary-rf9ui Před 4 měsíci

    Oh my! I still remember watching this from Finnish tv-show called ’Lista TOP 40’ (a show you needed to watch each Friday evening). They also played ’Sacrament of Wilderness’ and that was a life changer for me! Later at the end of ’99 I got the Oceanborn -album and that was it… Still going on with the Nightwish journey! 🤗

  • @LenaDee666
    @LenaDee666 Před 4 měsíci

    So crazy, while watching I was like yeah two different version cause two different lead singers, and both are awesome. But then it hit that of course we have a different drummer (Jukka & Kai), a different bassist (Sami & Marko) and Troy came as an addition. With the changes happening one at a time it kinda hits more here in a direct "comparison"

  • @tomw7043
    @tomw7043 Před 4 měsíci

    So happy you are revisiting Nightwish!

  • @tenaseesherry
    @tenaseesherry Před 4 měsíci +2

    ❤ fantastic!

  • @NeilOosthuizen
    @NeilOosthuizen Před 4 měsíci +2

    Nightwish has had three great front woman.

  • @jakubfranek9995
    @jakubfranek9995 Před 4 měsíci

    When you listen to the studio version, you'll get to understand that, especially in those times, it was, I dare to say that, the best song on the album.

  • @InesBeatrice
    @InesBeatrice Před 4 měsíci

    Thank you for reacting to Nightwish again♥️
    I'm a little sad though because concert version lacks much compared to album version. For egzample: the back vocals were a great part od this song but here they are non existemt or week. That makes me feel that you hadn't been able to hearthis song as its was meant to be.
    The linę: Without you... (With echoeing voise: without you)... all the poetry within me is dead always made me shiver.
    The same situation goes with the line: I knew you never before... (And echoeing over it, starting over the word "before": I see you nevermore...) It was so amazing and the life version, though it Has it own kind of beauty could not mirror the perfect studio version this time. I Hope you'll find time to listen once to the album version. Love you, and your reactions. Your face expressions and voice gives me happines and peace ♥️

  • @claudiabarrera4053
    @claudiabarrera4053 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I love this song...and with Tarja it's magical❤❤❤

  • @sophiepalmer-doran344
    @sophiepalmer-doran344 Před 4 měsíci

    Lyrics
    Toll no bell for me, Father
    But let this cup of suffering pass from me
    Send me no shepherd to heal my world
    But the Angel - the dream foretold
    Prayed more than thrice for You to see
    The wolf of loneliness in me
    ...not my own will but Yours be done...
    You wake up, where's the tomb?
    Will Easter come, enter my room?
    The lord weeps with me
    But my tears fall for you
    Another beauty
    Loved by a Beast
    Another tale of infinitely dreams
    Your eyes they were my paradise
    Your smile made my sun rise
    Forgive me, for I don't know what I gain
    Alone in this garden of pain
    Enchantment has but one truth:
    I weep to have what I fear to lose
    [Repeat chorus]
    "I knew you never before
    I see you never more
    But the love, the pain, the hope, O beautiful one
    Have made you mine, 'till all my years are done"
    Without you
    The poetry within me is dead

  • @AntaryDraconis
    @AntaryDraconis Před 4 měsíci

    Great reaction, thank you and welcome back 😉

  • @perrycleese5987
    @perrycleese5987 Před 4 měsíci

    Hey, so nice to see you again, my bad, you (In my opinion are) best musical disemmator/ explanor out there . Big love from Scotland ❤ ..and all NW singers are amazing❤

    • @ChaseCarneson
      @ChaseCarneson  Před 4 měsíci

      You’re incredibly kind and not to worry at all, life gets busy, my videos will always be here whenever you have some time to watch them. Grateful for the support as always.

    • @perrycleese5987
      @perrycleese5987 Před 4 měsíci

      Thank you,👍. If I may be cheeky, might II request a song (any song) from Anneke van Gierbergene?

  • @darrenhewitt2689
    @darrenhewitt2689 Před 4 měsíci

    Good to see you back again great reaction

  • @monylatorre7969
    @monylatorre7969 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Maravillosa Floor. ❤❤❤

  • @ladislaualbert2807
    @ladislaualbert2807 Před 4 měsíci

    Well done and very well put about the different members of NW throughout time.