Neil deGrasse Tyson on Chandrayaan-3 landing on Lunar surface: 'Sky is not the limit for India'

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 25. 08. 2024
  • As Chandrayaan-3 lander Vikram touches down on the Moon's South Pole, Astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson speaks to Times Now. ISRO successfully conducted a soft landing on Chandrayaan-3 near the south pole of the moon. As the world congratulates the country, ISRO is also busy looking forward to its next big mission, the Gaganyaan.
    ► Subscribe to The Economic Times for latest video updates. It's free! - www.youtube.com...
    ► More Videos @ ETTV - economictimes.i...
    ► EconomicTimes.com
    ► For business news on the go, download ET app:
    etapp.onelink....
    Follow ET on:
    ► Facebook - / economictimes
    ► Twitter - / economictimes
    ► LinkedIn - / economictimes
    ► Instagram - / the_economic_times
    ► Flipboard - flipboard.com/...
    The Economic Times | A Times Internet Limited product

Komentáře • 3,6K

  • @Maurya1008
    @Maurya1008 Před rokem +4727

    Could have asked more scientific questions to Neil than getting him to rate India.

    • @nikshepamin8570
      @nikshepamin8570 Před rokem +105

      💯 Agreed

    • @bhaskargautam1325
      @bhaskargautam1325 Před rokem +240

      Exactly! I cringed so hard when she started asking such questions

    • @deepankarroy774
      @deepankarroy774 Před rokem +56

      What you expect from them

    • @harshdeepsinghbhatia3302
      @harshdeepsinghbhatia3302 Před rokem +65

      Please take into consideration who is the person interviewing Dr Tyson.. 😂😂

    • @rxonmymind8362
      @rxonmymind8362 Před rokem +28

      Nothing wrong with that. This is a proud moment for them and they are looking for positive vibes or kudos from America.

  • @chandraravikumar
    @chandraravikumar Před rokem +1646

    This lady has, after decades of experience, now reached kindergarten level of journalistic expertise. What an achievement! But to listen to Dr. Tyson is a pleasure.

    • @ArunKeGaane
      @ArunKeGaane Před rokem +61

      I agree that this was an opportunity wasted; Navika appeared too unsuitable to extract the best out of an interview of a person like Dr. Tyson.

    • @Aurora-yo7xm
      @Aurora-yo7xm Před rokem +5

      ​@@ArunKeGaaneTotally!! I agree.

    • @deirdreemmanuel3883
      @deirdreemmanuel3883 Před rokem +17

      You said it !I wish they had someone more articulate and sensible to have had that opportunity.He has schooled her and showed her that he and the rest of the world are well aware of Indian’s capabilities.

    • @pybotixedu2033
      @pybotixedu2033 Před rokem +12

      She wanted to focus only on the last decade. However, Dr. Tyson disagreed and said India was always been great.

    • @Krmiby
      @Krmiby Před rokem +19

      Her type of questioning was so bizarre, as if India is a small kid looking for praises from their parents (other countries)

  • @10ON10
    @10ON10 Před rokem +582

    *Very valid point by Dr. Tyson that India needs to invest heavily into science and tech*

    • @DeeJay003
      @DeeJay003 Před rokem +1

      Yes - forget about the hundreds of millions of people in India living in abject poverty. Let's spend billions on useless/fake lunar projects that never amount to anything of actual use.

    • @r.k.shukla8175
      @r.k.shukla8175 Před rokem +8

      And diversity and inclusivity/inclusive growth

    • @herzog6480
      @herzog6480 Před rokem

      @@r.k.shukla8175 Yes. More Muslims and lower caste Hindus. All brahmins and upper castes should be banned.

    • @eltonlewis4979
      @eltonlewis4979 Před rokem +4

      @@r.k.shukla8175 equality and equity too..for all citizens

    • @FazalMirza
      @FazalMirza Před rokem +1

      *Dr. Tyson

  • @HushingDonner
    @HushingDonner Před rokem +8

    This man is one of a kind. Hoping to meet him one day in person and spend just 5 minutes talking to him.

  • @OpiumR7
    @OpiumR7 Před rokem +391

    What nonsense she is asking, neil is a scientist not a political commentator.

    • @piyushpahwa7897
      @piyushpahwa7897 Před rokem +36

      Yea she was looking for geo political stature validations from an outsider let alone a scientist. Bad

    • @dbkooper
      @dbkooper Před rokem

      Nothing nonsense in her questions. She is just asking people's questions. Indians do look for validation from amrikans. not just Neil. Koi bhi chaman idiot angrez kyo na ho.

    • @thevijayraj34
      @thevijayraj34 Před rokem +14

      Absolutely. Such a crazy questions.

    • @sumanthpaul7724
      @sumanthpaul7724 Před rokem +13

      @@piyushpahwa7897 Yeah, she purposely asked about India's stature in last decade. She is just looking for validation of the current government from a scientist.

    • @moonabhinav
      @moonabhinav Před rokem

      Dont mind Indian news, its shit anyways.
      Really nice to hear comments from Tyson.

  • @Love-dz1um
    @Love-dz1um Před rokem +857

    She didn't feel shameful about her words to describe India... But he is feeling proud to mention the achievements of India and Indians..

    • @Mysticals897
      @Mysticals897 Před rokem +7

      Ironic innit?

    • @devilishworld4259
      @devilishworld4259 Před rokem +12

      This wasn’t an interview for that purpose. The purpose was to know from him whether India is on the right path which he agreed on.

    • @devilishworld4259
      @devilishworld4259 Před rokem +3

      @@bijayyolmo-dh3tv , 🤔! Don’t you think these kinds of technology advancements will bring investments for the betterment of the Country?

    • @amrgg3272
      @amrgg3272 Před rokem +9

      People say the money could have gone to the poor. But think like this, so many industries and people are involved in making the space program a reality. Materials procured from indigeneous manufacturers pays salaries for a lot of people and also boosts these sectors. The money also goes into salaries of all the people involved like the scientists, technicians, mechanics, labourers, vendors etc. Success in a mission means that more investments come in and these jobs are retained or more jobs are created. There is also potential for technology to be shared or sold to other countries to boost revenue. Earth's resources are also being depleted and perhaps 100 years down the line our country can mine resources in other planets rather than rely on other countries. The potential benefits is infinite.
      People who say their tax money is being wasted first of all pay tax not because they want to but because they have to. We need to remember that the space mission is also funded by taxes paid by the corporations and people who are directly being paid for the mission.

    • @TheVernonENT
      @TheVernonENT Před rokem

      Exactly.

  • @bladesolar1
    @bladesolar1 Před rokem +30

    I love Dr Tyson, he is a phenomenal science communicaror to the masses. Congratulations to India on this amazing achievement. Cant wait to see what's next.

  • @gethulked101
    @gethulked101 Před rokem +130

    Love this man. We need more people like him in the scientific community in particular and the world in general.

    • @SloMo7
      @SloMo7 Před 11 měsíci +1

      no tf we dont..he's cool sometimes and he knows a lot of sh*t but dude doesn't know everything. when he doesn't have correct or enough information about a particular subject he gets irritable and turns into a manchild..it's embarrassing. Dr. Loeb however, is a Godsend

    • @EP65
      @EP65 Před 11 měsíci

      Why?

  • @VijayKumar-dn4pz
    @VijayKumar-dn4pz Před rokem +807

    They should really stop asking stupid questions about "stature" and "snake charmers". It doesn't matter what anyone thinks. What matters is facts

    • @kylepatros
      @kylepatros Před rokem +86

      Ikr. This felt less like an interview and more of seeking American validation

    • @PrabhablyAGoodYouTuber
      @PrabhablyAGoodYouTuber Před rokem +27

      @@kylepatros yeah, very egotistical. Who cares what other countries think, actions and results speak louder

    • @scorpioM56
      @scorpioM56 Před rokem

      indians like approval from whites.

    • @vasusingh5046
      @vasusingh5046 Před rokem +11

      indeed, we should focus on our future space explorations and we shouldn't care about what other country's people think of India.

    • @aslamahamed6184
      @aslamahamed6184 Před rokem +9

      It's true when i was a kid any western magazine write about INDIA there used to be a photo of snake charmer on the front page. It changed all after late 90's when indian engineers started to dominate software industries the perception of indians slowly changed. After Mr Modi took over as PM india's image was completely transformed he really projected india as a BRAND. BTW Snake charmers title was given to us by congress before PM Narasimha rao and manmohan singh.

  • @vthecode7078
    @vthecode7078 Před rokem +667

    Interviewing is an art and only intelligent sensible person should be allowed to interview such integent person like tyson

    • @JKBEAST
      @JKBEAST Před rokem +12

      Yup. And answering interview questions is also quite tough, and thats why some people refuse to get interviewed. Iykyk

    • @promethiusunknown2872
      @promethiusunknown2872 Před rokem +17

      Exactly 💯 , she could've directed more scientifically-oriented inquiries towards Neil deGrasse Tyson, instead of seeking his assessment of India. It's questions like these that could singlehandedly dismantle the painstakingly built image of ISRO due to their sheer absurdity.

    • @aniket33591
      @aniket33591 Před rokem +13

      Typical KAREN media anchor asking questions to seek recognition from West instead of asking legitimate scientific questions.

    • @HopDavid
      @HopDavid Před rokem

      Neil is the stupid person's idea of an intelligent person.
      He is a pop science celebrity who has done very little actual research. Moreover much of his math, science and history is wrong. He puts all his effort into being entertaining and doesn't take the time to study his topics to get it right.
      However Neil is correct to praise India and ISRO.

    • @shreenav
      @shreenav Před rokem +9

      Indeed... aliens, really?

  • @BornOfARuby
    @BornOfARuby Před rokem +9

    I hope every Indian is as proud of India as our Personal Astrophysicist is

  • @dhirajbagul8918
    @dhirajbagul8918 Před rokem +7

    It's a pleasure to hear Tyson because his knowledge especially for astronomical science. Liked his appropriate reply on India's potential.

  • @Akhileshpa
    @Akhileshpa Před rokem +316

    Such an opportunity lost by the silly questions asked by the interveiwer😡 I love how Niel answered her silly questions so sensibly, true legend❤

    • @nikkichan_05
      @nikkichan_05 Před rokem +4

      I know right. What got me even more angry is that she called him "Mr. Tyson" on a public media. 😡

    • @ProsperX99
      @ProsperX99 Před rokem +3

      godi media ki adat hai faltu ki bakwas krna

    • @tpb1006
      @tpb1006 Před rokem

      She just wanted him to say good words about India to up her low self esteem. Indians as you know, always want approval of the white.

    • @ShailSonsTech
      @ShailSonsTech Před rokem +6

      Just imagine someone like ravish Kumar getting to interview him. It'll be a way longer interview with lots of interaction for sure.

    • @jaybee666
      @jaybee666 Před rokem +3

      Dr. Tyson is a genius. And I’m not talking about his field but also in geo-politics. He exactly understands the right leaning nature of current Indian media and perfectly claps back at her BS questions. Who said India has developed in last one decade only? Does her Supreme Leader really need so much of validation after all the sycophancy in the country? Not a single question asked about the scientific ramification of this mission 😢

  • @NareshSharma-sm1kp
    @NareshSharma-sm1kp Před rokem +2047

    Dr Tyson is not only a highly acclaimed scientist, but also a prolific story teller by means of his excellent repertoire of books. Thanks for bringing him on the channel.

  • @bobmusil1458
    @bobmusil1458 Před rokem +2

    2 corrections:
    1. There is no dark side of the Moon; there is a far side but no dark side.
    2. India did not land on the far side; China did.
    India landed near the south pole which is still on the side facing Earth.

  • @madrascoolie2627
    @madrascoolie2627 Před rokem +2

    Would the aliens be considered untouchables 😂

  • @shreyassumukha1161
    @shreyassumukha1161 Před rokem +332

    This interview could have been way better by asking some serious science questions. Dr. Tyson is a great explainer of science and that could have been attractive.

    • @pareshpadhi2454
      @pareshpadhi2454 Před rokem +10

      Ua, this was cringe on a lot of level

    • @Akagami753
      @Akagami753 Před rokem +2

      I mean yeah, those questions were kind of childish but those questions need to answered. I also believe that she should have asked better questions like the future after chandrayan 3 or asking questions about other space exploration ideas.

    • @AnkheMiliBadoBadi
      @AnkheMiliBadoBadi Před rokem +3

      Time constraints. Also, his story telling is much better in podcasts. These 4-5mins sessions are utilised by news anchors to sensationalize the matter. 💛

    • @saketsagar2156
      @saketsagar2156 Před rokem +1

      Wasted interview

    • @srimasis
      @srimasis Před rokem +5

      You expect good science questions from Indian news media? 😂🥲

  • @ganesh1987jun
    @ganesh1987jun Před rokem +1148

    I love the way Neil explains.. one thought though - let's not worry too much on India stature, we have already proven it through our tech solutions.. I think India is the only land where elephants, snake charmers and space scientist all can can thrive, coexist with respect.. let's have pride in the same diversity..

    • @kylepatros
      @kylepatros Před rokem +48

      Yeah the interviewer's questions were quite disappointing considering we all know India is no longer just viewed as a land of elephants and snake charmers, and it is quite obvious that India's stature in the world has definitely risen over the past few decades. I hope she would have focused more on the space aspect rather than bringing in geo-politics to the conversation

    • @cybertaiga9534
      @cybertaiga9534 Před rokem +3

      @ganesh1987jun That's a very good point.

    • @prakashm1468
      @prakashm1468 Před rokem +4

      excellent comment bro.. that l Karen lady is one core reason why shit happens everywhere

    • @TheMarketingMan4U
      @TheMarketingMan4U Před rokem

      ​@@kylepatrosShe tries to demean Bharat as she is from anti national news media ET.

    • @tatsat-mg8uq
      @tatsat-mg8uq Před rokem +4

      One could not have said it better.
      Sarve bhavantu sukhinaha 🙏

  • @ayanahmad2873
    @ayanahmad2873 Před rokem +2

    Now i can understand why indian Media has one of the lowest grading

  • @thedudewithvideos4899
    @thedudewithvideos4899 Před rokem +1

    "Real estate on Moon" he got real sense of humor 😂😂

  • @Normalhumman
    @Normalhumman Před rokem +111

    How to not do an interview. Absolutely shameful the questions she asked

    • @amjadm2427
      @amjadm2427 Před rokem +11

      She asked last decade but he avoided that question. She didnt get what she wanted from him.

    • @SystemBot
      @SystemBot Před rokem

      @@amjadm2427 he did a good job. She's stupid asking dumb political questions to a scientist.

    • @liammeech3702
      @liammeech3702 Před rokem

      ​@amjadm2427 what did she want?

    • @farazahmed2204
      @farazahmed2204 Před rokem +2

      She wanted to hear him say that in last 10 years since Modi ji has been PM, India has skyrocketed to the stars and merely a year before that India was a nation of snake charmers in other words every scientific development happened in last 10 years. The compulsion to dedicate every achievement to one person is nauseating.

    • @Normalhumman
      @Normalhumman Před rokem +1

      @@farazahmed2204 I mean there are something’s that are beyond politics. Space exploration being one of them. The Indian news people have sold themselves and worries me that this will take the country down the drain

  • @adityaaima3302
    @adityaaima3302 Před rokem +132

    Couldn’t find anyone better than Navika to talk to one of the prominent thinkers of the world 😅

  • @mohamedshaafi9581
    @mohamedshaafi9581 Před rokem +1

    The last part was very Important on eliminating discrimination !

  • @abhisheknaithani3647
    @abhisheknaithani3647 Před rokem +2

    as a human, I feel good about India's successful chandrayaan-3 mission

  • @KushanDwarsingh
    @KushanDwarsingh Před rokem +647

    I am proud of our elephants and snake charmers and am also proud of our Chandrayaan, Mangalyaan and Gaganyaan.

  • @treddym
    @treddym Před rokem +65

    Poor questions from a, Group Editor rank and making a mockery of India by asking snake charmer and elephants question in these times.

    • @TheShuryansh
      @TheShuryansh Před rokem +5

      Questions are spot on
      The world still sees us as poverty stricken land

    • @noobanimation8503
      @noobanimation8503 Před rokem +2

      ​@@TheShuryansh Dr Tyson is not the world, why we indians always need validation from us and other countries. That is stupid . she should have sak him about science and tech

    • @noobanimation8503
      @noobanimation8503 Před rokem

      @@AnandJoshi yaa but asking political kind of questions to a well known physicist was kinda stupid,when you got only 6mins of his life. india will never be like it's neighbours mainly like Pakistan, they sucks as a country .

    • @Noobmaster69_bro
      @Noobmaster69_bro Před rokem

      Yea … wtf is wrong with these people … they r propagating the propaganda of the colonisers 😂😎

    • @snehalshende9654
      @snehalshende9654 Před rokem

      Its a image drawn by Western media not us

  • @maskyb3509
    @maskyb3509 Před rokem +1

    No one in India is comparing poverty to space. Poverty is caused by corruption not by lack of resources.

  • @ProudIndianYoungster
    @ProudIndianYoungster Před rokem +1

    I don't know how many people are agreed with me that Dr Neil Tyson is just looking like the famous South Indian singer Hariharan 😊

  • @nitinmms
    @nitinmms Před rokem +509

    Dr Tyson completely stumped Navika with his closing comments... Inclusiveness will make us a developed nation... 👏👏

    • @bhakthasingh8198
      @bhakthasingh8198 Před rokem +28

      He understood what was the meaning of the last 10 years and gave a fitting reply that inclusiveness is important. He still feels that India has a lot to do to eradicate poverty.

    • @kool_cj380
      @kool_cj380 Před rokem +7

      Obviously he meant inclusiveness makes us developed but didn't spare the rotten ones to exclude openly

    • @prakashm1468
      @prakashm1468 Před rokem +17

      Reason bcos of illiterate housewives like this woman, sitting on such post due to family favors.

    • @missionpehlapageair1holypdf
      @missionpehlapageair1holypdf Před rokem +19

      ​@@prakashm1468that happens in your favourite Congress dynasts party and used to happen in Bollywood too, now times are changing, look at the leaders in our country, that's why the country is progressing now like never before

    • @r.b.8018
      @r.b.8018 Před rokem

      Is his own country inclusive? I highly doubt. Lecturing other is easily. 100yrs ago Tyson’s (which btw is not an African surname by any means) family were slaves.
      100 years later he has no connection with his African roots. He is living in a colonised country whose natives are living in protected areas with zero govt benefits. Americans don’t want to talk about American before it was Europeans invaded it as if America was an empty land mass.
      So inclusiveness is a word should not be used by Americans.

  • @ferrerolounge1910
    @ferrerolounge1910 Před rokem +281

    Me and my family could listen to this articulate genius all day long!!!

    • @mossadagent9582
      @mossadagent9582 Před rokem +1

      I bet he's never been to India to see the abject poverty and corruption!

    • @NageshT
      @NageshT Před rokem +2

      I get my daily dose of science by listening to Dr. Tyson. He shares great scientific insights in to historical events also.

    • @richardturpin3665
      @richardturpin3665 Před rokem +3

      he just dumbs you down because he is lying.@@NageshT

    • @bulb6222
      @bulb6222 Před rokem

      @@mossadagent9582 Still less poverty than in your brain.

    • @WY94
      @WY94 Před rokem

      ​@@mossadagent9582keep focusing on our Poverty ...we are focused on Mars❤

  • @madmanunchained5917
    @madmanunchained5917 Před rokem +1

    I used to love the HISTORY show of Neil deGrasse Tyson .

  • @bettertube
    @bettertube Před rokem +1

    Neil have been massively underplayed in this interview

  • @DharmeshDaula
    @DharmeshDaula Před rokem +46

    Shame on our reporters, to tag India as a nation of snake charmers, media perception is making us look bad. We donot need validation in this regard. Look at our achievements and our cities.

  • @simracer9163
    @simracer9163 Před rokem +117

    Seeing Dr.Tyson commenting, and having so much information about India is great. Thank you Times for interviewing him.

  • @kens-jr2vv
    @kens-jr2vv Před rokem

    We were told not to come back according to the Ancient Aliens TV Show lol.

  • @MrAwesome744
    @MrAwesome744 Před rokem

    You have such a solid guest and you ask about aliens???😂

  • @apuroop.mahadev
    @apuroop.mahadev Před rokem +57

    We need a different class of interviewers

  • @wagabondpickles6183
    @wagabondpickles6183 Před rokem +283

    Thanks Neil, and thanks for that comment on inclusive participation - sometimes we forget we have become divisive over the years.

    • @AkshayShukla.
      @AkshayShukla. Před rokem +6

      he could see right through her godi questions

    • @bmniac
      @bmniac Před rokem

      Sad but we have always been divided. Nothing new unless you are unaware of history.

    • @AbhijeetDolai-eo6ib
      @AbhijeetDolai-eo6ib Před rokem +2

      Expansionist, imperialist, intolerant, supermacist ideologies need to be called out and the west has no face to talk about Inclusivity to India.

    • @AkshayShukla.
      @AkshayShukla. Před rokem

      @@bmniac no! we weren't always divided...., thats only the case since the company came...

    • @AkshayShukla.
      @AkshayShukla. Před rokem +1

      @@AbhijeetDolai-eo6ib
      they have THE FACE to talk about inclusiveness to India,
      its because their countrywide inclusive programmes, Indian origin people are at the top in their world, be it economy or politics.

  • @puneetsingh01
    @puneetsingh01 Před rokem +1

    Navika was trying to score browny points for her master but Mr. Tyson ended with a very wise statement that India needs to ensure every citizen participates in it's progress.

  • @youarecorrectiamwrongbecau1338

    I don't get how such people get so visible and high paying jobs. I mean India deserves better journalists.

  • @shashiprabha8283
    @shashiprabha8283 Před rokem +142

    He's so matured and humble. Great achievement India 🇮🇳

  • @alex0005
    @alex0005 Před rokem +25

    This interview feels more about the stature of india rather than on chandrayaan 3, why can't we be humble.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 Před rokem

      Bhaiya india always humble hi rha hai

    • @kasibkhan2916
      @kasibkhan2916 Před rokem

      We can't even be humble for being decades behind West in terms of scientific achievement . Rest aside what our attitude would have been if we were at a place where america is today

    • @gauravk6114
      @gauravk6114 Před rokem

      ​@@kasibkhan2916 Sar tan se judaa gang lecturing about Humbleness 😂

  • @VeraHolm
    @VeraHolm Před 3 měsíci +2

    It's not "Mr. Tyson". It's Dr. Tyson!!!

  • @quionario2559
    @quionario2559 Před rokem

    I perceived that Dr Tayson is a kind hearted person as he speak he is very Smart. fan from Philippines.congratulation Bro. India.

  • @xtremeshock
    @xtremeshock Před rokem +157

    Great Job in getting Neil deGrasse on board, but honestly the questions asked were not upto the mark

    • @123sudeepshiram
      @123sudeepshiram Před rokem +15

      This was a great occasion and this das asks still these questions
      It's time navika get's replaced

    • @manab.baruah
      @manab.baruah Před rokem +7

      We see the gap between the intelligence here 🤣😁

    • @saketsagar2156
      @saketsagar2156 Před rokem

      Seriously, I haven’t come to listen snake charmers bullshit

    • @khunevidit15
      @khunevidit15 Před rokem +2

      What else can u expect from navika 😂😂

    • @devilishworld4259
      @devilishworld4259 Před rokem

      This wasn’t an interview for that purpose. The purpose was to know from him whether India is on the right path which he agreed on.

  • @arnpnd
    @arnpnd Před rokem +62

    Problem is, we need validation. Even with Neil, we're trying to get the approval. But at the same time, it fills our heart with the joy that there's community of scientist who are making it possible every second of the day. Kudos to team ISRO.

    • @Amory98
      @Amory98 Před rokem +2

      Validation is a human need. There's no state of existence, personal or societal, devoid of the need for validation; regardless of what godmen might say.

    • @marck.4330
      @marck.4330 Před 11 měsíci

      Exactly you are worthy because you are life, not because of yada ... no outside validation needed. Get in touch with your own life and be.

  • @ujjwalmittal3122
    @ujjwalmittal3122 Před rokem +1

    Clarity of thoughts amazed me

  • @Systemreboot96
    @Systemreboot96 Před rokem +1

    Where is economic times science editor ?? Should have let them do the interview🤦‍♂️

  • @adakot123
    @adakot123 Před rokem +28

    Not sure why Navika came across so defeatist! She is a very proud Indian, disappointed in the line of questioning. Love Neil, but why does she seem so desperate for validation from the west!

    • @ferrerolounge1910
      @ferrerolounge1910 Před rokem

      Did you validate your job with the west?

    • @adakot123
      @adakot123 Před rokem +3

      @@ferrerolounge1910 What do you mean? Your comment is as bizarre and unrelated as asking someone.. Did you brush your teeth today morning! … Yeah exactly, no one cares! foolish remark! I am half cursing myself, dignifying your comment by responding…
      Someday you will stop making assumptions and drawing silly conclusions. Good luck!

    • @satya_te_pratijane
      @satya_te_pratijane Před rokem

      Victory and defeat are artificial definitions.

    • @yashwardhansable5187
      @yashwardhansable5187 Před rokem

      There is a fine line between being humble and being defeatist

    • @user-kt7ds4cl6f
      @user-kt7ds4cl6f Před rokem

      She is so called intellectuals who panders to West. May be she is looking for post with NY Times. !!!

  • @usernamedevan
    @usernamedevan Před rokem +19

    Why are Indians (especially Indian reporters) obsessed with their stature in the world? All you have to do is just get rid of the bureaucracy, corruption and your affirmative action policies that drive the best talent away from India and you will be a shining star.

  • @chukong5
    @chukong5 Před rokem

    It’s people with this type of mindset that bring the nation down . It’s a great achievement and she still needs approval from an outsider on how great India is doing asking irrelevant questions. A great achievement India 🇮🇳

  • @OFi.
    @OFi. Před rokem +1

    Hence proved that Dr Tyson is smart enough to understand the meaning of interviewer's question about the development in the current past decade. He is legit 😎

  • @yohannesaradom8656
    @yohannesaradom8656 Před rokem +26

    My hero Dr Tyson,
    The comment on India 🇮🇳 is very genuinely deserved and appreciated. The Indians are the future of this world. Nobody can stop them it is simple equation 1.3 billion people on the face of the earth will move like a Sunami in every field. Simple political and policy changes will make things go fast. India will be the center for technology and science. Once India conquers poverty and build the infrastructure like China did; the great Indian people will liberate the world for good. I originally came from Horn of Africa all my high school teachers were Indians. They were very intelligent in every field particularly maths and science.
    Congratulations India for the great achievements!
    GO India 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 India! GO

  • @LbLedesma-zp6pm
    @LbLedesma-zp6pm Před rokem

    I Believe that India has Always been a huge player in the global economy spirituality and humanitarian fields. And now it has become a global Elite... Congratulations to the People of India...
    Namaste 🙏🙏🙏

  • @WIN-js3fp
    @WIN-js3fp Před rokem +1

    she can ask more scientific question rather than asking silly & dumb questions, it was the great opportunity for TET to ask good questions to Dr. Tyson but anyways Tyson nailed it

  • @SreeKumar_vijayan
    @SreeKumar_vijayan Před rokem +22

    Questions could have been more scientific, I love him, such a humble person ❤

  • @shardapeeth22
    @shardapeeth22 Před rokem +183

    No one is a better science ambassador than Neil ! He is such an energetic guy!!

    • @user-wj5gr6jm2m
      @user-wj5gr6jm2m Před rokem +1

      His mentor.. carl sagan .. 😁

    • @aryanaman9812
      @aryanaman9812 Před rokem +2

      ​@@user-wj5gr6jm2mwho is no more
      So we can't say carl sagan "IS" best science ambassador lol

    • @abhishekbandhu
      @abhishekbandhu Před rokem +3

      Brian Cox is better

    • @dantex8983
      @dantex8983 Před rokem

      ​@@abhishekbandhucame here to say this

  • @pnmenon1522
    @pnmenon1522 Před rokem

    She got Neil and all they were intrested was to get INDIA validated by him , we could have had a beutiful scientific conversation , he is a master in explaining things

  • @chrismascarenhas7828
    @chrismascarenhas7828 Před rokem +1

    I don't understand why Navika Kumar is bent upon to get his comments in India's development over the decade. We don't need anybody's rating. India has developed since 1947 step by step. For any development strong foundation is a necessity. So, our foundation was quite strong and we are seeing the effects now. Long live our nation. Jai Bharath.

  • @seldom44
    @seldom44 Před rokem +22

    This woman could have came better prepared. Asking senseless questions.

  • @ananthureghu1047
    @ananthureghu1047 Před rokem +76

    One of the respected American Astrophysicists on show. He is the voice of Science. ❤

    • @Da13th_Magician
      @Da13th_Magician Před rokem +2

      voice of deception..no man has ever landed on the moon,,never..

    • @donnasachetti4546
      @donnasachetti4546 Před rokem

      Voice of science. .. been accused by multiple women of sexually misconduct. Why is he acceptable?

    • @SoorajSuseelan10001
      @SoorajSuseelan10001 Před rokem +4

      ​@@donnasachetti4546Doesn't change anything.. Anybody can accuse specially in America there are lots of mad people.. but has anything been proved?

    • @terrymckenzie8786
      @terrymckenzie8786 Před rokem

      @@donnasachetti4546Never. Accused of comments

    • @EdwinTyler
      @EdwinTyler Před rokem

      Yet she didn't ask him a single scientific question.

  • @brillrayel1103
    @brillrayel1103 Před rokem

    Indians are very clever developers. Very focus and their knowledge is outstanding.

  • @terriblydankpersn3815
    @terriblydankpersn3815 Před rokem +1

    Aliens on the moon. Yup I'm done watching.

  • @efficaciousuave
    @efficaciousuave Před rokem +83

    point to note what he says towards the end :i dont know what your perception is within your borders but to us india has always been an important country, not just last decade.

    • @helthwelthandhappiness6248
      @helthwelthandhappiness6248 Před rokem +4

    • @Hanuman1343
      @Hanuman1343 Před rokem +3

      😂😂😂😂And have u noted the point that most of the tech companies in the USA were governed by the CEOs of the Indian origin? Please improve your comprehension skills. He is not the guy who lived in India to know what made many intelligent workers and talents to leave India for good to overseas. He has no idea who is ISRO scientist, Nambi Narayanan is and why Congress imprisoned him for than many years. He has no knowledge that India could have sent the Chandrayaan 2 rover to the South pole of the Moon way before China is Nambi sir was not imprisoned by Congress. He has no odea about the scams and amount of money Congress looted from the Indian public. And he has no idea that Congress has signed an undisclosed treacherous MoU with China in the year 2008 and the fact that Nehru refused the permanent UN seat in the council offerred to him just to appease the Chinese government. If he knew of all this issues plaguing India prior to 2014, he would have praised India's major tranformation within this 9 years of non-corrupted and efficient governance. Whatever u may say, the entire world respect India only after Modiji leads India into its golden era. This kind of respect never existed during the Manmohan Singh's leadership and governance. Sorry, anti-nationalist and Khangress trolls, intelligent Indians know who u are and no matter hoe much u try to peddle this lies about inclusiveness, we will just dump your lies in the trash.

    • @TheB657
      @TheB657 Před rokem +1

      @@Hanuman1343 Exactly. Well summarized and pointed out ! 👏 Indian's as a majority at least in youtube comments and social media show poor comprehension of what the other is actually saying.

  • @Sunnyside24
    @Sunnyside24 Před rokem +28

    Neil Tyson is one of my most favourite ❤ the way he explains things is always so easy to understand.

  • @patriklindholm7576
    @patriklindholm7576 Před rokem +1

    Unfortunately the interviewer couldn't muster that more interest in the subject than to ask but banal questions, to which "MrTyson" still delivered exhaustive answers.

  • @shreyashpandya
    @shreyashpandya Před rokem

    It is like a child asking their parent "See I scored high grades, Do you love me now?" totally an Indian thing.

  • @sri1201
    @sri1201 Před rokem +57

    Wow... Wonderful words Neil Tyson said... Especially the last 15 seconds on what impact of this gives on people's growth.

    • @CataphractVardhan
      @CataphractVardhan Před rokem +3

      You can visibly see the smile fade from her face when she realizes including everyone means Muslims and Dalits as well.

  • @arshbehal6312
    @arshbehal6312 Před rokem +9

    Navika is such an embarrassment. Couldn't have found someone half-decent if not full to speak to a legend like Dr Tyson?

  • @Cosmos273
    @Cosmos273 Před rokem +3

    Even he was like they are stupid AF lmao those dumb questions

  • @dOVERanalyst
    @dOVERanalyst Před rokem +1

    As an Odia so happy to see her wearing our saree.

  • @4799balaji
    @4799balaji Před rokem +32

    Very well said Dr Tyson. Truly an inspiration to a lot of people.

  • @debasishraychawdhuri
    @debasishraychawdhuri Před rokem +21

    Dr. Tyson is an inspiration for every child in the world.

    • @sunnyveerpratapsingh1102
      @sunnyveerpratapsingh1102 Před rokem

      Bro I agree with you but sadly in india few have such children less in quantity, Abhi ki generation is getting more chapri than we could ever imagine

  • @jee2023.
    @jee2023. Před rokem +1

    Dr. Neil degreese Tyson is very humble,, cosmos seriers was his best work

  • @rajnish____
    @rajnish____ Před rokem

    This is first time I have stayed this longer to listen to the news where this lady appears.

  • @Devan20214
    @Devan20214 Před rokem +11

    Poor thing Navika wanted to put all the credits to just last 10 years 🙊.. miserably failed 😂

  • @qwertyali2943
    @qwertyali2943 Před rokem +12

    This man the reason why I got so much connected with the space, his show was my fav back in the school days, and he still sounds like the same, :)

  • @piratenu1
    @piratenu1 Před rokem

    So, I can feel her, she wants to hear Neil saying as many times as possible that India is the best. I get this mentality.

  • @anantanavkar9932
    @anantanavkar9932 Před rokem +1

    Nice comments from Neil. One mistake -- it was not shot put, but javelin throw

  • @darkwolf2275
    @darkwolf2275 Před rokem +27

    Neil tyson degrasse big fan sir ❤
    I'm watching you still from my childhood 😊

  • @MadszTRS
    @MadszTRS Před rokem +58

    Huge respect for Dr. Neil on his amazing views about India and Space. Too Good ✨

  • @kdasbiswas
    @kdasbiswas Před 11 měsíci

    “Mr” Tyson? Seriously? The man deserves more respect than that.

  • @saptarsi7868
    @saptarsi7868 Před 3 měsíci

    After watching all the comments I am getting second hand embarrassment. I can't even bring myself to watch the interview

  • @aram7992
    @aram7992 Před rokem +22

    Wonderful comments Mr. Tyson, thank you very much.

  • @Govind_manav
    @Govind_manav Před rokem +11

    I am a big fan of Neil Tyson ❤ love from India

  • @667SatansNeighbor
    @667SatansNeighbor Před rokem +1

    There are more honor students in India, then there is students in America.

  • @aqteaching
    @aqteaching Před rokem +1

    Asking Neil DeGrasse about Aliens on moon. How dumb could one be?

  • @velavanvijayakumar9759
    @velavanvijayakumar9759 Před rokem +36

    Niel is a great person and makes lots of sense when he talks. Simple and clean on his answers

  • @vuppalanarasimharao1363
    @vuppalanarasimharao1363 Před rokem +10

    Tyson great observations on India’s development is an eye opener to many people 🎉

  • @sagarmehra6634
    @sagarmehra6634 Před rokem

    Man, I wish Neil DeGrasse Tyson was my teacher growing up.

  • @loidplayz1175
    @loidplayz1175 Před rokem

    Hostess asked Neil "How was your day"
    Neil:

  • @sahil200709
    @sahil200709 Před rokem +51

    how stupid to ask someone else if we have grown in stature globally, who is neil deGrasse to say yes/no

    • @roronoazoro276
      @roronoazoro276 Před rokem +8

      This is the Mental barrier many indian still have to this day the need to be acknoledged by the west and that is sad but need to be eradicated completely.
      i also feel disgusted by this line of questioning

    • @Somd55
      @Somd55 Před rokem +1

      You obviously have no idea who he is. He is one of the most celebrated/recognized astrophysicists in the United States and his opinion/view matters.

    • @sahil200709
      @sahil200709 Před rokem +1

      Very well aware of who he is....but he does not have to certify for India to know whether we are there yet or not.

    • @christinas4187
      @christinas4187 Před rokem

      He made very good points, and its true that coming out of poverty will be thru science and technology...I hope it happens soon.

    • @debasisghadai3633
      @debasisghadai3633 Před rokem

      She did ask "stature globally" so global opinion matters.
      And yes, I think it's a stupid question to ask considering we live in an era where information breaks out at the speed of light.

  • @Evolvinggamer371
    @Evolvinggamer371 Před rokem +26

    I love you tyson ♥️ he explains like no other , i started loving physics because of him ♥️ great personality 🙏🙏🇮🇳♥️🇺🇸

    • @promethiusunknown2872
      @promethiusunknown2872 Před rokem

      Exactly 💯 , she could've directed more scientifically-oriented inquiries towards Neil deGrasse Tyson, instead of seeking his assessment of India. It's questions like these that could singlehandedly dismantle the painstakingly built image of ISRO due to their sheer absurdity.

    • @devilishworld4259
      @devilishworld4259 Před rokem

      @@promethiusunknown2872, 😁😁😁! Someone is not pleased that he bragged about India. 😆😆😆!

  • @snakebitmcgee6532
    @snakebitmcgee6532 Před rokem

    India didn’t go to the moon. They just need to boost their international stature

  • @haroonibrahim2620
    @haroonibrahim2620 Před rokem

    At this stage Neil Degrasse Tyson will do an interview for a plate of paav bhaji and biryani.

  • @saimandebbarma
    @saimandebbarma Před rokem +13

    What he is trying to say is we are learning from each other & we as indians like any other countries got inspired from what they did in their past have fueled our present, and all of the upcoming future projects will be a force of inspiration behind our success ! ☝️

    • @serronserron1320
      @serronserron1320 Před rokem +1

      It is inspiring to see your space program achieve great things. Information and technology from these missions is used by many countries to further understanding and one day move Humanity to the stars.

    • @saimandebbarma
      @saimandebbarma Před rokem +1

      @@serronserron1320 Well see exploring or exploration of truth in & out is fine for humans, but ignorance or ignoring mistakes is not & that's where we humans need to focus on, otherwise there are different consequences to it that you know i am sure. And coming to success or achievements, it is to see how truly we have understood it so far i.e what we called achievements or success. Hope you got my point that where i am indicating towards! ☝️Thankyou' God bless 🤍🙏

  • @raknotes
    @raknotes Před rokem +9

    Why is this lady reporter thinks so little of our nation and asking for validation from an American??? This is humiliatingly as an Indian.!!!!

  • @SelvinDesouza
    @SelvinDesouza Před rokem

    The difference in thinking is so great.. what a wise man.

  • @salerio1890
    @salerio1890 Před rokem +3

    All citizens need to participate in the development of India ~ wise words from Dr. Tyson.
    Sabka saath sabka vikas....not the 80-20 bullshit

  • @josephine79
    @josephine79 Před rokem +33

    I love how India used the sling shot effect to keep the cost *much* lower to get there and completed their targeted mission. Not only is landing on the South Pole of the moon difficult, but also perfectly pulling off the sling shot affect in the process. And all without worrying about the fact it would take their vessel longer to arrive there. I just give huge props to India for that and all of their accomplishments! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤
    And, as always, I love Neil deGrasse Tyson! 🙏🙏❤️❤️