Sergei Shoigu sacked as Putin faces war funding trouble | Dr Samuel Ramani
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 06. 2024
- “Russia suffered many humiliating defeats, like in late 2022. And I think that the dismissal is probably linked to the desire to integrate economic and defence policy more closely.”
Economic resistant to Western sanctions have been more successful than Russia’s military says associate fellow at RUSI, Dr Samuel Ramani.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
He didn't get fired. He got promoted.
Let's not quibble with the actual facts! This is Russia, promotion = being sacked in the Wests upside-down world 🙄
Shoigu was also not a military officer but a civilian
Same as previous and next one
how'd he get all those medals? Merit badges?
Of course he was promoted after a decade of strategic stagnation. No one expected him to take more than a sliver of neighboring land and spend so little. What a bargain!
Better think about yourself.
He's moving into sheltered accommodation, preferably a bungalow.
With your Mum?
Didn't fire him pulled him out the frying pan to replace him with a scape goat,, he needs his bunker buddy,, there retreating to there bunker,,
They're,their*
There’s a window with his name on it.
I'm taking bets that it's above the fifth floor.
Yah, the "Sergei Shoigu Memorial Window", complete with LED eternal flame.
He just needs to go out and say he doesn't support Vladimir Putin's invasion of Ukraine, blam instant retirement
Never interrupt your enemy
I guess he better stay away from windows in tall buildings
Joint staff is responsible for military matters.
New defence minister is resposible for cash flow management as you know.
They hired a banker with no military expertise to take his position. Incompetence abroad. The Russians just can't get it right 😂😂😂
We shall see 😂
Shoigu wasn’t a military man either. He never served in the military before being appointed minister. This fellow is being brought in because of the vast monetary problems the military has had under Shoigu. Additionally, there is finally some concern about individual troops, something Shoigu has never understood. As is everything in Russia, it’s more complex than it seems.
Neither can you get it right. You really don’t see what’s going on. Biased blindness.
he is not supposed to fix the military, he is supposed to fix the economy to keep the military going🤡
Sure they can. Look at a) the maps and b) catastrophic UKR losses
Russia got it right every which way.
Russians are obviously very nervous about how this firing is viewed by the world.
It's not raining in the studio. You can take the hat off.
As a man with unruly hair, I'm guessing he has the same problem.
The western is ignorant towards what is happening in Russia. This is the promotion. They guy was supposed to be retired in 2022.
Actualy he got promoted ....taking Parushev s position .
There was internet chatter that the Russian 45th Guard Spetsnaz Division in Moscow made a statement about 9 days ago. If Shoigu and other generals are removed, the 45th brigade would start a military coup. Hmmmm....
how many are still alive after 2022?
He retired after staying on until after the election.
Shoigo is the fall guy.
Western media and their consumers.....😂 😂 😂
This is nonsense, he’s been promoted to head the national security council. An extremely powerful position
Not fired promoted
Shoe Glue is gone. The new Defense Minister Be A Louse is an economist. Does he know anything about military matters? No, but his job is to figure out how to run a war and the nation of Russia with no money. If he can pull that off, I'll tip my hat to him. 😆🤣🤑
"Nothing over two stories!...don't drink the tea!...no more airplanes!...in fact, no more anything with a key and an ignition!...wear gloves when touching anything!...and, and...OK, deep breaths Sergei, you can handle this!"
~A man seen stumbling around Moscow talking to himself.
Shoigu would be wise to stay away from open high rise Windows not drink Tea and not take airplane flights.😂
❤Ukrainian ❤
Retired.... Lying isn't helping your cause
He was promoted stop the lies.
😂😂😂😂
He has been promoted to head the security ministry'..
Cabinet reshuffle is normal administration issues
Slurping tea😂
Hes gonna fall out of a window
I feel bad for Dr. Ramani having to live with that voice for life, that was greating
He's not been sacked He's actually been promoted.
Laughable.
Head of Defense ministry, to basically nothing but an adviser isn't exactly a promotion.
Needs to stay away from windows.
The idiots on here don’t know the difference between promotion and firing . shoighu was promoted .
😂😂😂
To a high rise office🏬
Can i send my condolences to shoigus family in the next few days , because thats all the time he might have left . I'm guessing .
Shoigu and his bunker buddy Putin will now have more time to spend together in one of their Siberian forest hideaways. Imagine.
modern warships have just released a new update maybe some of the ,"top tier players" 🤭 will provide enough funds to make more turtle tanks 😉
Shameless propaganda.he was actually promoted
I’m ready promotion.
The Ukrainian commander responsible for the northeastern Kharkiv frontline has been replaced after Russia launched a surprise offensive, a military spokesperson said on Monday.
Nazar Voloshyn told RBC-Ukraine media that the decision to appoint Brigadier General Mykhailo Drapatyi to the position was taken on May 11. He gave no reason for the decision.
It comes amid reports that Ukrainian defences were “built in the wrong place” to halt Russia’s Kharkiv offensive.😂
Russia copped a flogging there, looking for a scapegoat now
Sacked? The position he got = is a promotion
Romoted to an office with a nice big window
How many changes Ukraine did? What did you say? This is a promotion. The guy actually retired in 2022.
tired old men
Love this Russian website
Why on earth is Times Radio bringing forth 'experts' who are expressing surprise at Shoigu's dismissal. Ukrainian channels have been predicting this for weeks following Timor Ivanov's (Shoigu's deputy) arrest for corruption, Shoigu has been caught with his fingers in the till?
I don't think usa will continue a huge amount money every year for Ukraine if they continue that amount money to Ukraine China will have good chance learning and experiencing from Ukraine war for the future confrontation with western countries
A promotion to the security council. Russian forces withdrew because of a peace agreement 2022 that got ditched at the very last moment (help from Boris). since then there has been a war of attrition, that continues, if it wasnt effective we wouldnt need to keep sending weapons. The Russian economy is the fastest growing economy in Europe, and out produces the west in key industries. Russia is now considered to have the most powerful army in the world.
Another day another lie from times radio
Shoigu is the first Russian official who hasn't suddenly died from an unknown medical condition, or accidentally fallen out of a high-rise window.
Give it a little time. Many trip hazards on the floors in Moscow.
@@sidgarrett7247 🤗
YET.........
Putin is in his new term as President! it is time to shuffle his cabinet and Shoigu requested for retirement a few years ago but Putin asked him to stay! And he is now promoted into the core part of the security committee, who sacked him? Who knows he might be the next president??? The media should not get so excited about!
By the way Russia is taking Ukraine territories everyday. Ukraine military demoralized.
Pootin’s regime is a weird one, as most dictatorships. Apparently, Shoigu is more of a logistics guy, at least in a broader sense.
The new dude is also an economist, which makes a lot of sense. If Pootin isnt a complete idiot, he realizes that the only way the West can truly break him, is if sustained economic pressure comes into effect. The west can break him militarily any day, but both parts realize that implies ww3-noone is interested in that. IMO it makes a lot of sense to place an economist in Shoigu’s role to beef up what is left of Russian economy. The Russians are learning by doing. Its going to be interesting to see who is going to replace Gerasimov, too.
Their a Kleptocracy, there's no intelligence behind anything they do, just self serving strategy
The guy got promoted and you are misinforming your audience that he was fired!😆
Nothingness…
Hate to break the news .. shoigu has been promoted 👍🏽… its well known he asked putin to retire before the Ukraine conflict.. but putin wanted his best and most loyal officer at his side for the conflict.. putin and Shoigu go on holidays fishing and hunting together FFS ! 👍🏽… this whole analysis is nonsense propaganda 😆😆
Well, he was removed from his post, and put into a higher post.
Times Fantasy Radio, Shoigu wanted to retire over 2 years ago. He agreed to stay on till after the presidential election.
Hello again Robert, this means you've lasted longer than shoglue.
"Robert" didn't make that Daily Sport joke again 😂😂😂😂
Propaganda Radio😂😂ever heard of a reshuffle ?????😂😂😂.....Maybe a demotion but fired??...common you guys can do better😂😂
Let's give it time. Russia is playing chess
Shameful lies
Is this a comedy
0:09 ffs stop sipping tea while recording, you gawd darned stereotype
Please give us some fantasy stories about the reason for shuffling. By the way, the word sack is used inappropriately
Read up on the definition of sinecure. They put him in a position where he can do no harm.
Parushev is Out Shougo takes his position the Usual post election reshuffle.
Yeah, like Ukronazis route from Avdeivka was called a "retreat ".
@@alexanderlazarev3570 "ukronzs" is newspeak. The only force espousing nahtseelike ideology in Ukraine today is Russian.
@@alexanderlazarev3570 "ukronzs" is newspeak. The only force espousing nahtseelike ideology in Ukraine today is Russian. You are by definition a nahtsee, except for some irrelevant minutiae.
Shoigu got the job because hes friends with Putin, thays it, he had zero military experience before he was made defence minister 😂
No one is putins friend just puppets
what a terrible speakers one talks thru his nose. And the other it's Shoi gu like toy Shoi like glue gu
if this propaganda channel did any research shoigu was in fact promoted and not fired. This channel has been making such false claims since the start of the war that they make the sun look like a unbiased news agency😂
no, Shoigu was not promoted, he was sidelined to a position where he can not steal so much money any more, Russia is having cash flow problems due to sanctions, and this is why Putin put an economist in the position instead
Er no, promoted get your facts right. Propaganda this whole channel.