Classical Musicians React: F(x) 'Rum Pum Pum Pum' vs 'Red Light'
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 05. 2017
- For the 55th video of this series, classical music majors react to F(X)’s ‘RUM PUM PUM PUM’ MV vs ‘RED LIGHT’ MV!
I know I say rum pum pum multiple times in the video instead of rum pum pum PUM please forgive me.
Also 4 Walls is on the to-react list.
FOLLOW MY TWITTER FOR UPDATES & SNEAK PEEKS OF FUTURE REACTIONS: @_emcha_
UPDATED!!!! reaction video release dates:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
Eng subs done by Ash & Umu
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
CZcams (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(Assistant editor & channel manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
CZcams: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
I love how everybody are losing their shit on Red Light.
I agree
They should watch the concert version of "Dracula", everyone gonna losing their shit like this again lol
To be fair, it's as if the composer of Red Light looked at your typical verse-chorus segues and then said, "Screw it, I do what I want."
that concept blow the kpop world..
Lost mine too
F(x) is actually SM's experimental unit/group counterpart to SHINee.. and yes. their music is unlike your usual kpop bop.
chel.tin
I think YG did the same with 2NE1, and they debuted on the same year!
chel.tin experimental unit.. but how amazing they are
Shinee for boy group and f(x) for girl group as their exprimental music!
They're more like a well-crafted, well-produced groups in SM. They sound experimental because their contemporaries do generic, same music over and over.
YES. f(x) ain't your usual Kpop. 👏💜
"Ou the cat with two eye."
"How many cats you know got one eye?"
SHITBALLS IM LAUGHING TOO HARD
walao eh these two together are hilarous😂😂 ah I miss them💔
hes cute
Dying here 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@animegirl1414_random what happen to them
@@zimzalabimdenickimenajzala2003 am pretty sure nothing; they kinda just haven't been reacting together as a duo? afaik umu (the channel owner) often film reactions in batches around this time so for several videos you'll see the same pair again and again then later on on different batches the pairs change. (which, for viewers who're already got used to certain pair dynamics might make them miss the previous pairs.)
"Those boy groups are just little bitches compared to them" (or something like that I don't remember) BUT OMG I'M SO PROUD, I almost cried here literally
Fans: "Rum Pum Pum Pum didn't go hard enough."
_SM listens to fans, has F(x) go harder._
Fans: "Red Light went too hard!"
_SM listens to fans, goes full 180 with 4 Walls._
Fans: "4 Walls is too experimental."
_SM listens to fans, locks F(x) in the dungeon._
That’s the most truthful comment about f(x) on CZcams, aside from Hugo’s “all the boy bands are little bitches compared to these girls”. It’s like SM kept giving f(x) super awesome songs because they know the girls can handle them and make them work, but fans are being scaredy cats. Like come on, people, being out of the world is what makes them f(x), why tf would you want them to do generic K-pop stuff when they’re so damn unique and capable. I wouldn’t say SM did a great job promoting f(x), but they did give them high-quality songs that can only work if they’re f(x) songs, if anything, the fans are responsible for f(x) being underrated. Sorry for the rant, but I’m just too frustrated with MeUs.
PongoXBongo fans, not MeU
PongoXBongo i
LOL
@@floofrules honest question; if sm cant promote fx well, how do you think people will trust f(x)?
I feel so sad that f(x) have always been underrated.. because they're one of the most unique groups out there.
Seolyeon sm treats them like step children especially after sulli leaving. why don't sm give them official fan name 😢
isnt fx's fanclub's name MeU?
Queen Park Bom yup it is
MeU is FX's official fan name
Seolyeon The ironic thing is they have high quality albums compared to Snsd (which is my fave Sm GG). Their MV's are also better in my opinion. But their songs were too eccentric in SK, at least around 09-11 which is the Snsd-2ne1 era that's why f(x) was just stuck with the other gg's. Honestly their vocals, dancing, and visuals as a group are still the best for me.
I am so happy to hear their reaction to F(X)!!!!!!!
Am I the only one that feels like if Yunyi and Amber met they would be best friends?
Jung Taekwoon is a literal angel yeahhhh exactly
Amber could be anybody's best friend, to tell the truth. lol
Yasssss i agreeeee😍😚😘😙
#amberllama
Amber is everybody's best friend hehehehe
@@sfxmong5988 agree HAHA
"all the boy bands are little bitches compared to these girls"
"absolutely!!"
I couldn't stop laughing 😂😂😂 we need an f(x) comeback!
😭
😭😭😭😭😭
🫠
Gwen: it's so cool, it doesn't go at all where you want it!
....
Gwen: AND THEY DON'T APOLOGIZE FOR IT THEY JUST KEEP DOING IT!
THAT'S WHAT QUEENS DO!!
A U9
Henry: -shook- "That bass just changed my life!"
I am exactly like them. Musicians who listens to a lot of music hear patterns. However, Red light doesn't follow any. That's why it's really disturbing for people in general but great for musicians ! it's incredibly surprising, nothing you would except.
if only they were doing that more often.... But SM was the King at that between 2013 - 2015. Now they don't do it anymore and nobody did it except them. Even anywhere else in the world.
Very true, at first when red light was first released many people didn't like it because the sound was so ahead of time. But it's one of my favorite f(x) songs of all time💜
How about NCT songs? Seems really different from what other groups were releasing
It si UNQUIE !!!!
They're doing that again with NCT.
Luisa Regina Not really
"All the boy bands are like little b*tches when it compared to these girls" Hugo.
Someone give him an award. 🙏👏
Hugo Awards are for science fiction only, sorry...
Elise Maître he effing deserves an oscaaaaaaar!!!!!!
Gary C. there are awards for everything lmao
It gets better when you realise they're the sunbae group to most of them :P
This comment made my day ! ✨ Totally agree with you 😉 Now I can't wait for their comeback ! 🙏
f(x) MY ULTIMATE GIRL GROUP OHMYGAWD THIS MAKES ME NOSTALGIC T.T SM bring them back. there's really no other girl group in kpop like f(x), they're irreplaceable
Qian Mint but they can't meet each other now because their some individual activities.
SAMEEEEEEEEEE
Destes Yoyo I'm sure SM can do something about it since SM is their management company... But being a MeU for the past 7 years, I guess i know that SM will not focus on our girls anymore when they have so many new, profitable groups :(
Qian Mint tell me about 😔, SM makes me sick really. How they been treating f(x) over the years is almost repulsive tbh
Qian Mint f(x) was profitable, but the longer a company waits to let them have a comeback, the less fans stick around. I feel like SM does that with their older groups on purpose until they're forced to disband. I have no love for SM anymore as a company whatsoever because of it. It's disrespectful to their artists and to us fans
The "meow" at the end leads into the next song on the album Milk. It's the weirdest freaking song ever, but I love it lol
Red Light and Milk are SO UNDERRATED AF. THEY ARE SO UNIQUE
@æspa winter fanboy it adds creativity and uniqueness to Kpop and makes it more interesting
다른 리액션들은 뭐랄까 너무 뮤비나 가수들의 외관에만 집중해서 평가하는데, 이 채널은 전문가들이라서 그런지 다들 음악에 대해서 더 깊게 얘기해서 보기가 편함. 그리고 다들 각자 취향이 드러나는게 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ케이팝의 반복되는 부분을 별로 안 좋아하는 경우가 많은 것 같고..클래식은 좀 더 기승전결이 있는 느낌이라서 그런가? 되게 예상치 못한 변환을 엄청 좋아하는 것 같음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ누구는 더 나가는 걸 좋아하고 누구는 너무 나가면 별로 안 좋아하고..가수에 대한 게 아니고 ㄹㅇ 음악적 측면에서 말하는 거라서 별로라고 해도 기분이 나쁘지 않음
그러게요 그냥 흔한 방식보단 약간 예상을 벗어난 노래에 평가가 높은 듯
Show them 4walls!
JM Beltran it says in the description that it's on the react list
Show them Pink Tape, Red Light and 4 Walls album!!! lol
JM Beltran I'd love to see them react to Milk (even though it doesn't have a mv😣) just cause the song has so many cool sounds and harmonies.
EXOKAI'S WIFE Oh thank you!
pls show them Pink Tape Art Film too, this literally invented aesthetic, and Shadow is such a freakin boppp
"I LITERALLY CAN'T COMPARE IT TO ANYTHING LIKE THIS IS SO UNIQUE" -LINDSEY *f(x) songs always unique! And as a Meu I'm so proud to them. I cri 😢😭
Kersty Song me too girl me too
Kersty Song me 2 baby
I feel like if u wanna compare blackpink to f(x). U just cant. Everything about f(x) was better. Dont get me wrong. I am a complete blackpink fan. But f(x) was just better. Everything about that group regarding visuals, aesthetics, beats etc. At that time in kpop, THAT sound was so underrated which is why they weren't appreciative. Now it's like "LETS GO BACK IN TIME N GIVE THEM NUMBER ONE STICKERS".
I think blackpink similar to 2NE1 than fx
@@measoy4557 I think fx is more similar to red velvet, not comparing but similar changing concepts
Tori Lea True and they’re similar when it comes to SM experimenting with music (you can add Shinee into the mix too since they’re basically brother group to F(x)).
I mean, she probably meant for HER. She's like, a blackpink stan so, yeah. She was saying that she likes FX almost the same way she likes blackpink.
2NE1 to blackpink, f(x) to red velvet, Snsd to Twice, As much as I love nows generation the queens slayed more back then
I'm freaking crying right now. It hurts my heart so much because they deserved better.
Victoria deserved better.
Luna deserved better.
Amber deserved better.
Sulli, my angel, deserved better.
Krystal deserved better.
f(x) deserved better than what they got. I love these girls with all my heart.
i agree, love them :(
Hugo "All the boy bands are like little bitches when compared to these girls" PREACH HUGO PREACH. ugh f(x) stole my heart with Nu ABO the moment they released it and they're my ultimate kpop group to this day T.T
f(x) is undoubtedly one of the BEST girl groups out there. Personally, I'd say they're in the top 5. And I miss them so much. I love seeing female acts who were bad-ass like they were and 2NE1. All of their albums have been amazing. With Amber's frustration towards SM, I'm a bit worried about the group's future, but I only wish for the best as well as their happiness.
Kirstienne Toledo Previouslt they were on top 3 or 4 :(
Kirstienne Toledo so true i miss them
Kirstienne Toledo The group will be fine. Amber loves f(x) and and has no intention of leaving. They all renewed their contracts late last year. The big thing holding them back right now is the THAAD situation between China and Korea, because it virtually prevents Vic from promoting in Korea.
Phew that's good news. Well, we'll just have to wait and see what happens.
they just have to tour internationally
f(x) may not be my bias group but they have the best and most interesting and rich and and and etc discography in the kpop game (male and female), they were definitely the group (pink tape era) that really made me reconsider the ingenuity in kpop and regard kpop more seriously for its musical value instead of its exotic fun nature
this is the reason why I really love ReacttotheK. instead of pretending they like it, they will say what's on their mind. Their opinion, their real opinion. :)
Because they dont cater to close minded baby bra kpop fans.
It’s their language. Music is a language and they study it! I’m pretty stoked to be going through all these reaction vids👍🏼
Sad those 2 guys didn’t like rum pum pum but that’s their opinion
Kevin: G-G-G-G-G-G-GO
Yunyi: You can't go it's a red light
Kevin: *Smile slowly fades*
f(x) name is super 'DOPE', The name F(x) has two meanings. It’s direct meaning promoted by the members is that of the mathematical function, where X has different values based off of the equation it is put in. This is supposed to mean that the X is each member, and the result of their work will all be different. The other meaning, initially promoted by SM Entertainment, is a bit more abstract. F stands for “Flower” and “X” represents the female chromosome, so there F(x) means Flower Girls (the Korean term for beautiful girls).
f(x) are definitely more Function than they are Flower Girls, imo
Well, you know, form follows function ;)
They went the function explanation at first and got push back for being too boastful so they changed it to the flower girl reasoning. I think it was PR spin and it's the math symbol for a reason.
i thought their name stands for the way it sound f(x) = effects? hahaha stupid me
Makeup Lover i
It's really funny to see the cultural differences, in Rum Pum Pum Pum most of you heard a christmas thing in the song, but as a Brazilian, all I heard at that part was samba. lol
Rayane Vitorassi that made me laugh
meu deus nunca tinha pensado nisso
Reagindo agora eu vi que realmente tem um som de instrumento brasileiro ali
i can understand the samba, but not the christmas lol
증말..sm가수들 노래 리액션 해주는거 너무 좋아요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ sm특유의 자본냄새나고 흥미로운 곡들을 전문가들이 듣고 느낌 말해주는게 넘 재밌음
F (x) is one of the group that has more than 2 hits, literally give them anything they'd make it hit. Love em endlessly
아이스크림옥수수 - If you find someone to translate, anyone can submit subtitles in any language. They would love for more people to do that! 😍
요즘은 한국어자막을 만들고 있는 건데 유창하게 못해요 ㅠㅠ 그리구 고3이라서 너무 바빠요. 번역 열심히 하겠습니다. 능력이 없어서 죄송합니다 ㅜㅜ
Low key wish they could see the red light remix from their Japan tour. That red light performance killed me.
Audrey Ruiz omg thanks for commenting this because I checked it out and I am shocked; loved that remix and Luna's solo was amazing. I really hope they can react to it.
Audrey Ruiz are you talking about the Dimension 4 thing with the amazing solo? When at the end the verse is sang over the chorus?
Because if you listen really closely in the original version of the song, at the end the verse is still there being sun very quietly.
Thanks for commenting tho because it's the best live video ever
Thanks for your comment. I checked it out and got SLAYED at spiritual level.
I was hoping someone would suggest this! Luna's high note KILLS me
비쥬얼이고 실력이고 그룹색이며 이런노래 소화할 여돌이 또 언제나 나오려나
기괴하면서도 귀엽고 미저리같으면서도 쿨한 그룹이었는데ㅠ
Gwen's reaction to Red Light is the definition of eargasm
"Hey... I need a roommate."
"BOI?!"
Peyton, mah boy, always reading my mind.
AAAAH I MISS F(x) SO FUCKING MUCH
AND AMBER IS MY MOST FAVE PERSON IN THE WHOLE KPOP, SHE's JUST SO TRUE TO HERSELF AND I ADMIRE THAT
Danielle Yoon me too I really miss them. they NEED a comeback . let's protect them from the girl group curse going around .
stanbts stantalent YEAH IKR 😭😭😭
Baby Luna is my ultimate bias because she's just so
Danielle Yoon? Dhen? Ikaw to? Is this DHEN?! This is Mike
I was really shookt when Red Light first came out. AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED THAT IT WAS SO UNDERRATED AND DIDN'T GET THE RECOGNITION THAT IT DESERVED. RED LIGHT JUST BLEW MY MIND.
I honestly held my breath the first 10 seconds when it was released. Then the whole first play, I felt my heart beat slowly beating, it was painful the first listen because I couldn't understand anything. I hear music but I'm not a musician, so whatever was going on with these reactors answered all that I felt back then with the correct terminologies. LOL But second watch and the rest, RL still is my favorite f(x) song.
MAN I NEED THE COMEBACK HUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHU
Rewatching because I need to hear people appreciate f(x). It has been uears but nothing beats their music. I miss f(x) so much!
jarod: hey i need a roommate
peyton: BOI!
jarod: ooh cat with two eyes
peyton: how many cats do you know that got one eye?
jarod: like a good kind of dirty
jarod: like you eating lasagna with yo hands
😂😂😂😂😂 100% sure this two is my favorite
They're my faves rn
same tbh!
dubu kyongsu this combo seriously needs more appreciation 😂
dubu kyongsu I honestly appreciate Peyton's reactions to Jarod, because Jarod is great but definitely has this fuckboi thing going that makes me roll my eyes at 90% of his comments, and I live vicariously through Peyton's equally extra comebacks lmao
Just the way that he's the only one to act like he's flirting with the camera, and how weird some of his comments can get, which I know are just him joking around. (Watch the Red Velvet reaction and his comments to "Automatic" for the most obvious example)
I'm not trying to say that he's *actually* a fuckboi, and by no means am I saying that he's a bad dude! He and Peyton are hilarious by themselves, and doubly so when they're together! It's one of those jokey terms that gets thrown around a lot on the internet, I doubt he'll read super deeply into it, if he reads it at all.
F(x) is the best girl group. They're so unique and not afraid to experiment with new styles and sounds. ❤️❤️❤️
KP !!! fx is THE BEST GG. NO ONE CAN BEAT THEM EVER. WE MEUS KNOW IT WELL.
This is the only video that can make me happy after hearing about Sulli news. Appreciating fx as the amazing group they were
RIP Sulli
helenkimstal rip sulli ❤️
i was waiting for someone who'd say "unique" and someone finally said it. f(x) in the kpop community is known for its unique style and i'm glad they noticed that.
I see f(x) i click
me too :D
SAME
Tiffany Deserves Love same, i miss them SO much 😭
Someone Stops Sooyoung I LOVE YOUR NAME
F(x) is one of a kind. Soooo unique. You can't compare it with any other group out there.
the fact that all of you recognized how awesome their harmony was! its just so touching! f(x) is so precious to me. Thank you for the compliment for our girls. i really like your reaction vids!
If Redlight is released now it would swipe every charts, way back those kind of song are so underrated
Lindsey said f(x) is almost up there with BlackPink for her and you know what, she should totally listen to f(x) full albums and I'm sure they're gonna become her ultimate bias group in no time, CAUSE IT'S A LIFE CHANGING EXPERIENCE PLEASE LISTEN TO THEIR ALBUMS I SMELL A NEW F(X) FAN BEING BORN
claudia c Exactly. I would actually say they have the best discography in the whole K-Pop, not only among girl groups. Other groups can't hold a candle to f(x) when it comes to music, to be honest. My subjective opinion, of course. It would be so awesome if they reacted to b-sides too, too bad it's impossible.
CSlove14
I like how new kpop fans always like to say * *insert rookie group name* * can reach* *insert kpop legend's* *level. Like no, that's why they're rookies. YG makes monster rookies but that doesn't mean they can beat the legends. If you want to compare older groups to the newer groups, compare the older groups when they were in their rookie years to the new groups. (pretty sure none of the new groups can beat the old ones)
Yeah, f(x)'s Pink Tape is one of the best kpop albums of all time. Hands down.
YEAH.
THEY STILL DESERVE NEW FANS 🙌🏾
I just want to take a moment to appreciate how you are so organize with the way you upload your videos. Also, the fact that you have the reactions planned for months ahead. Thank you, Umu.
Maricarmen R. Right?! Even when she's on break from school. Me? I would have taken a break for a week or two seeing as how so many videos are already filmed and scheduled. But she went ahead and scheduled more up until next year.
She loves us! Surely! I love this whole channel, and all of the reactors, and I love that it's even introduced me to some groups I hadn't taken the time to listen to yet!
I love being able to look up the schedule and see what's coming up; I was staring at my calendar the other day thinking I had something good planned for the 29th, some general good feeling but I couldn't remember what it was, and then I realised after watching this it's because I'd seen a Vixx reaction was coming up! lol
The way they appreciate f(x) and their music is making me emotional for some reason. This just proves that f(x) was just so ahead of their time that people were not yet ready for them.
I really miss my girls... hope to listen again these kinds of experimental songs of F(x)!!!!
*THE DAY HAS COME, I WAS WAITING FOR THIS SO LONG I CAN'T EVEN. THANK YOU UMU*
lol no ME TOO IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO FOR A MONTH AHHHHHHH FINALLY I CAN SLEEP WELL TODAY
lol no same with me and we have to wait for 5 month for the next fx reaction
SAME, AND I'M SO NOT DISAPPOINTED
SAME I'VE BEEN SITTING ..... WATCHING AND WAITING FOR f(x)
I've watched their f(x) reaction probably 5 times.
I really love it when they musically appreciate the music since f(x) goes with unique musical style comparing to other groups. I remember when f(x) released the red light, people were criticizing but now see guys..
i actually really loved red light when it came out and i remember a bunch of people were hating it especially rv fans bc of the drama with them but i knew only a few people could appreciate it
I was thinking the exact same thing! I've always found it so interesting how more musically inclined people have always loved Red Light but other ppl didn't like it at first listen. Red Light is a gem tho 👌
some koreans dont really like it cause the lyrics touch a political view.
But apparently hollywood said that might be one of the best hiphop song that year.
Jessjess what drama with RV fans? i just wanna know because i dont know about it lol 😂
Kim HanaxD because the promotions for Red Light were suddenly stopped for no reason while f(x) was on a winning streak and RV debuted right after that so MeUs got salty... and rightfully so. (no hate on RV though SM just sucks)
금발 머리 묶은 언니 리액션 너무 좋앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ레드라이트 때 멈추지도 않고 질주한다는 말도 개좋음
pink tape is such a gem, includes so many bops. like shadow, airplane, step, no more and ending page.
lol no Pink Tape should be dubbed as the album of the century every song in there is gold
Qian Mint not a single bad song in it. not being biased and totally agree.
lol no yess i like almost every song in the album
in my case i like every song of f(x) in general, not a single bad or boring song, they always do such unique songs
lol no yeah one of my favorites albums in the kpop scene too bad red velvet cannot live up the fx and their good ass music and style and are getting fx's reject songs instead
Red Light was sooooo ahead of its time. People weren't ready when it was released. Heck, I'm still kinda not ready. Lol.
mrKpooper4 PREACH!!!
mrKpooper4 agree!!! still think it's one of the best kpop song ever
I think f(x) is constantly releasing music ahead of its time. 4 walls was one of the first deep house kpop songs and house music became trendy in 2016
This is so true, pink tape was released 4 years ago but til today it still remains as my favourite kpop album
This makes me so so happy and really nostalgic; Red Light was a cultural reset. Its so textural that everyone I know who had heard it has a part that they like. F(x) remain one of the most important girl groups in music to date. I can’t think of any contemporary kPop groups that have the vocal styling range that F(x) had, and it’s thanks to how well the different characters come through in each member.
The Hallyu 2nd wave of the early 2010s had a lot of artists that paved the way internationally, from the viral nature of Psy to the wonder of large groups like EXO and Girls Generation to 2ne1 being hailed as some of the most fashionable artists in the world and having access to archives of fashion designers. K-Pop gets a justifiable bad reputation for certain aspects (such as idol culture) but the fact that it allowed for the sharing of so many different ideas from different cultures is something quite unprecedented.
it’s why I love react videos because when you’ve been on the fan side it’s always amazing to see musicians reacting to groups that you hold dear.
f(x) was so ahead of their time. and def the best discography in kpop
after this video I realised how much I need fx to make a comeback right now 😭😭😭😭
we really miss you fx and I really proud of you 😍😍😍
meray mahmoud wheres sm when we need them?? 😪😒
they should really react to 4 walls omg the chords and progression in that song alone... also their pink tape/4walls b-sides and even luna's mini album songs!!
K Dude, Breathe, I Wish and My Medicine have me all TT-TT
+Sheryl Yaseen I love all Luna's songs. Galaxy is my jam. Sounded like what hollywood does but way better.
I wiah they could react to Red Light album.Butterfly,milk and all night. That album was a bop.4walls album too.
K
it would be really cool if they could react to some of the live performances, or some of amber's solo songs in english (borders or need to feel needed cause they already reacted to shake that brass)
yeaa love somebody's so gooddddd
i listen to red light JUST for that insane ass bridge ITS LACED WITH CRACK
Coming back because i miss when people talked about f(x) music. I've checked Reacttothek will not react list and both X and Traveler didnt make into the list soooo yeah i'm looking forward to the reaction of that both songs!
haha yunyi's reaction to Amber is unique lol
See SM everybody likes F(x) so give to them a fucking comeback man ✌✌
Dudy Valentim they can't ATM. china won't let Victoria com back. Especially with how Korean and China relationship isn't the best ATM.
Vic is having solo debut in China at the moment, so i doubt it
TheLeoBrand Are you srs?!
ofc she is, victoria want to comeback to korea, but she cant
Dudy Valentim at least some news about their plans on f(x) sched would be nice.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 노래 전개를 마치 내가 드라마 전개 보는 것 처럼 새로운 전개에 감탄하고 통수때리는 전개에 희열을 느끼는 모습 너무 웃김ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이런 세밀한 분석 너무 짜릿행
These videos are so cool, as a classical/musician and kpop fan myself it's badass to see their reactions.
Unique, that's literally the word Victoria used to describe their sound and the reason f(x) is pretty much the only girl group I listen... they're definitely on another level!!
Gosh, I miss them a lot :(
I love their acceptance of f(x)'s unique sound.
Beca YT b!
SM always has experimental groups. They let SNSD do all kind of concept, They made f(x) sounds like their music ahead of time, and now even Red Velvet and aespa's music always experimental as well
That's why i stan SM (for their musics and groups -not company💀)
From my observations, Gwen is pretty hard to please and i love how she lost it with f(x) haha
YAAAASSSSSHHHHH!!!!!!!!! AND LINDSEY & FIONA TOO!
F(x) is totally a girl crush...
Han Yeonri Yeah but f(x) makes me feel really gay. No regrets 💕
I've never loved a girl group so much other than f(x) and it makes me so happy they get praised like this. Thank you for this!
F(x) is one of the best kpop group for me also Shinee, they're the reason why I love Kpop back in my early teenage years.
Obviously their concept was so cool the five team mates :)
f(x) is so unique! I love their music! They will forever be my bias girl group. In my book, nothing can beat Pink Tape and Red Light!!!
"HOW MANY CATS YOU KNOW, HAVE ONE EYE?"
This made my day
레드라이트 진짜 에펙스 전성기다... ㅠ
그립다 저때가..
it's been over a year. watching this video triggered me immensely, but i just wanted to see her perform again.
I love how much Gwen's enjoying it btw :)
OK NOW I MISS f(x)..SM just give f(x) fvcking comeback 😭😭
The world was not totally prepared for f(x). They were so ahead of their time.
I love this channel so much- every reaction makes me feel like I'm listening to the song for the first time again. They always get so hyped, so into it and I'm here for it~!
GOD I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
I KNEW YOU GONNA LOVE F(X) AND I MISS THEM SO BAD
yup. Unique is f(x)'s pride. Basically SM actually.
I mean we have one and only Shinee, freakish but cute Red Velvet, the mellow Grim Brothers version of fairy tales; Exo, the girl's era vibe; SNSD and King of Harmonies; Suju; Kings of Kpop, TVXQ.
Im too excited?
+Not my Name no you arent, SM always has an unique signature fir their group
how about nct?
+Rara 1991 nct is just nct.neo culture is right word. They are like hiphop+grunge kid with cult-like kind of vibe? sooman is a genius but a pain at the same time. Cause its hard to precict the kids future cause koreana dont take culture shock well.
I mean koreans
f(x) is definitely the most unique kpop girl group there is. From their "no concept" concept to their style of music, theyre definitely a fresh breathe of air in kpop industry. There is no group that you can compare f(x) to, literally. And those visuals and talent? ugh. What more can you ask for (well, SM, any sign of comeback yet?)
Throwback! I miss f(x) so much. SM totally fucked up.
Lindsey: I can't compare it to anythings, it's so unique.
Ladies and Gentlemen, the Queen of Concepts F(x)
Sorry, don't mean to spam the comments but for those who really enjoyed the f(x) songs, I suggest watching their Dimension 4 concert. It has a wonderful mix of their old songs and newer songs.
WHEN LUNA DID THE BRIDGE IN RED LIGHT AND I LOST MY SHIT
f(x) has a:
Unique Songs✅
Unique Choreos✅
Unique Voices✅
Unique MVs✅
AND VISUAL ON POINT!!!
I wouldn't say unique MV's, but the rest is very true. SM really loves putting their groups in front of a green screen for the dance, and then having close up shots of individual people. Just look at any Super Junior or SNSD video
I miss f(x) so much
Just look how experimental SM in musics, the thing I love the most. From SNSD, f(x), to Red Velvet, SM is sooo experimental and that's so cool❤
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS REACTION FOR SO LONG! THANK YOU :D
I looove how experimental f(x) is. Maybe it doesn't work for everyone, but you can't deny their sound is hella interesting to listen to and pick apart. Also I love Amber. She's badass indeed.
I'm coming back for your f(x) reactions every now and then whenever I miss them.
I miss F(x) as 5 members😢😢😢
Edit: I also miss them as 4 members cause they still have no comeback yet
My favorite non-title tracks I believe these guys need to listen to are Shadow, All Night, Airplane, and Milk. Hands down I think they'll love all of the tracks. I mean overall f(x) is amazing so this is so appreciative
Cynthia Padilla up!
shadow and milk are ughhhh YESSS
Cynthia Padilla BUTTERFLY TOO
Cynthia Padilla Dracula too😊
they're gonna react to milk!
Those harmoniesss. SM is really an expert and putting together such wonderful harmonies. 😉
JYP can't relate.
Lianass ss just telling the truth. I've been watching their reaction vids and other reaction vids and SM groups always get praised for their harmonies. 😊
erikailapamela yap putting them together then forgetting them 😒😒😒 I hate SM right now 💔💔
Yasss agree
Honestly, when it comes to quality and production value, SM is always first. The management itself is shit, but the stuff SM puts out is always such good quality.
f(x) is my ult group and I'm so glad that they finally get the recognition they deserve! please react to electric shock and four walls next💜
SHOW THEM 4 WALLS I AM BEGGING YOU PLEASE
they already did... I want them to react to "Shadow" so bad!!! I was so creeped out wth that song! Much preferred with the lyrics hehehehe
I am SO SO SO glad you're showing them F(x)!!!!! "Whoa, that is an outfit" (this was back when SM splurged on f(x)'s costumes. :) "What a trippy song" Yes!! "Their voices are so good together" "What a song! What a video!" Gwen said it best: "I love it I love it I love it I love it I love it" ...And that was just Rum Pum Pum! :) :) :)
"All the boy bands are little bitches compared to these girls"
"ABSOLUTELY!"
Me: YAAASSSSSSSSSSSS
Red Light is a bop that must never be forgotten~~
f(x) sets high standard that human that time can't accept right away. Being an f(x) fan that time makes some of us "weird" HAHAHA because idk maybe an introvert thing HAHAHA. But now almost all kpop songs sounds like them. Their songs are timeless. And they are so ahead of their time..
MeU's WHERE ARE YOU? 😍😍💕💕💕✨✨✨
Danielle Yoon ✋
Danielle Yoon *THROWS BOTH HANDS UP IN THE AIR DRAMATICALLY*
Danielle Yoon I am here😎😎😎
WE SRSLY NEED THEIR COMEBACK :"
I NEED THEIR COMEBACK SO BADLY: