Meta Quest Pro vs. Vive Pro Eye (Eye and Face Tracking tests)
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 07. 2023
- We check in VRChat how both headsets perform for the eye and face tracking for same situations or expressions.
The Quest Pro is used as a remote user, so there might be a bit of delay and so, but overall it performed pretty well!
In the end I think so far the Quest Pro has more benefits than the Vive Pro Eye. But of course, you may find it easier to get a second handed Vive Pro Eye if you already have base stations or so. - Hry
Just watching you guys test the tracking capability was way more amusing than anything I watched on CZcams all week
The avatars are so cute
he grooms minors bet
The background music sound so ominous and mysterious with a blend of awe and Final Fantasy vibe.
then search up kingdom hearts ur probably gonna like it
@@okareijiOh I always wanted to play Kingdom Hearts. But sadly I don't have any of those old consoles cause no one's selling them anymore.
@@marcuscarana9240 don’t you have a good pc, maybe a ps3-ps5, or even a Xbox one? You’re able to play kingdom hearts through those
I was trying to figure out which headset to buy for eye and facial tracking. But you’ve helped solidify my choice. Quest pro seems like the best value to me, no tongue tracking, but it’s a small sacrifice I can live with. Hopefully they unlock the tongue soon though. Good video!
Thanks for the comment! I'd honestly go for a Quest Pro too if I didn't have my Vive Pro Eye.
But ofc, the setup is different if you are gonna use FBT or the index controllers, beware xD
@@KnightXVRC yeah the setup is genuinely terrible for lighthouse trackers. it's perfectly fine if you want to use slime or haritorax tho, doesn't require any calibration. you can also emulate index controllers while using quest pro's hand tracking and just use the cameras for hand tracking through alxr.
@@KnightXVRC Is it possible for you to make a guide on how to get face tracking activated on the quest pro? I can’t seem to figure it out myself yet 😅
@@Evoccat Here is a 3-minute video I used in the past for the Quest Pro: czcams.com/video/Keh__Lw7dEk/video.html
The tongue now works!
Vive pro eye performs so well that it brings tears in my eyes. I just wish every headset would have equally good tracking or better. I hate that the quest pro has no OLED or worse face tracking… it would also be nice if future headsets would implement both inside out and lighthouse tracking in one headset. Bruh we’re asking for the same damn features every year. A comfortable headset with good headphones, a good mic, pancake lenses, micro OLED displays, full eye tracking, full lip tracking, inside out tracking together with lighthouse tracking, finger tracking, full body tracking, and a light weight headset. You know it could literally be the beyond with the face tracking modules and headphones of the vive pro eye, the cameras of the quest 3, finger tracking of the index, and full body tracking of htc 4.0. If those companies would work together, every one of them would make money and their headsets would work like fresh’n warm buns.
Thank you! I've been wanting to see a video like this since the Quest Pro came out!
Fun demo, but really need to keep in mind that tuning the face tracking rigs is pretty important. My personal rig for my Rex doesn't work the same for other people, because you'll have tiny nuances like differences in face shapes and what not that will make the trackers look like they aren't working properly, but they are.
Thank you for this! I've been looking into getting one and this is the first video that had a great comparison. Thank you thank you thank you!
Pupil dilation seems super cool and also entirely useless lol
I'm sure if you wanted to enhance immersion by adding it, you could just simulate the effect. That said, it probably helps the tracking software to understand better where the pupil is if it also understands the size of the pupil, even if that data isn't revealed to the game/application.
That smile melted my heart omg
Thank you so much for making this video!, i been wonding this for a very time!. this has helped me out.
Vive Pro mouth animations looks fricking sick - made it 100% more immersive to observe
This is a beautiful video, thank you for posting.
Love your guys quirky personality 🥰
The animatronics… they get a little… quirky at night
Very cool and informative video
The music in the background is saying I should be terrified. Especially when you said *Smile*, then the spooky music kicks in.
Quest Pro can have facial tracking data transferred via Virtual Desktop. So using Meta software is no longer needed.
true but you can only use the finger tracking through alxr so far (by emulating index controllers w/it). VD can track hands but not fingers. wish VD would enable that, i cannot get alxr to work
I went with the Pro Eye for the OLED displays, they are so much more immersive in dark worlds.
besides the eye tracking, CAN I JUST ADMIRE THE FACT YOU ARE IN THE NOBODIES CRIB AND PLAYING THEIR THEEEEME
This was so wholesome :)
Oh, also do note: the quest pro does the face and eye calculations on the headset, meaning that you don't get the performance penalty that SRanipal gives. This is cool!
UPDATE: Quest Pro can now track the tongue! It exists as a simple out/in boolean, not much else. Maybe this will change in future revisions!
With The Quest 3 Not Even Having Eye-Tracking
I'm Left Here Wondering How Blinking/Winking Is Gonna Work...If At All-
I Can't Even Do A Bombastic Side-Eye With It-
Claim your "i did the faces along with them" ticket here
honestly makes me want to get into the quest pro because as a first time vr buyer it looks like it has everything but at a budget compared to the vive pro eye
I use the Focus 3 with eye, face, and ultimate body trackers all wirelessly. It's pretty mind blowing stuff.
I can see the Vive Pro Eye has better facial tracking & expression, but sure the Meta Quest Pro has a much better comfort, thank you so much for making this video, i hope you have good day!
The avatars are cute but I think y’all are even cuter
Officially the cutest video ever made ❤
The background music kind of reminds me I think cross between Mario Galaxy on Zelda twilight princess
Super cool!
Thankfully the tongue tracking has been added to QPro, as well as Steam Link, so the Oculus software is no longer required!
omg, thanks for this piece of info! Still unsure if I want the quest 3 or pro but for the facial tracking I may just get the pro
Looking forward for Vive Pro Eye, so i can make an usage of base stations.
The eye movement on the vive sells me.
Yeh, I can't move my brows, but I can roll my eyes when I want. I can dart them around, without moving my head.
While the vive might have have slightly worse tracking in some ways, it is much more expressive IMO.
Cant wait to se the mq3
You and your avatar is both cute! New sub `:3
Why do I have the feeling that the Quest Pro actually does track the tongue, but they don't expose that data because Zucc is too much of a prude and thinks it's gross
Nice
Dark souls mini boss music in the background💀
FR LMAO, just sampled it cuz of this
Super cool how far VR has come, can't wait until it becomes easier to run.
Also, what's the music? Sounds calming.
czcams.com/video/XCfiqTxCEXQ/video.html
Quest Pro has tongue tracking now! It took longer than expected but it's here.
need to know the music behind
The blue character is so cute :o
First off thanks for making this! Helped a lot to decide for a future headset. ALso, I love your pfp, the art is so cool!!! Love the style so much. Do you think its worth it to get the pro atm? I feel like since valve is rumered to be making a head set I should maybe wait but I'm not sure
Loved the teeth chomping XD
Off topic you guys' avatars are actually adorable?? Didn't realise how expressive vr avatars could be until I could look at them up close (i unfortunately don't have a headset)
Get a separate cable for the mouth tracker that might fix that eye tracking getting stuck issue.
Gonna give this a try! I'll update later if this makes any change.
@@KnightXVRC Great. First before going out and spending money. Try the headset without the mouth tracker. If the headset no longer does that. Then getting a separate cable for the mouth tracker will fix that issue with the eyes.
I bundled the usb cable that goes with my mouth tracker to my main headset cable. I also have a vive pro eye, using the mouth tracker. Though it is not plugged into the headset. The time i had it plugged into the headset i had so many issues. The mouth tracker started cutting out. Then the eye tracking started to break exactly like that. Then lastly the headset tracking started to have issues soon after. Then a few hours later the headset was no longer detected. Had to get a replacement. On my second vive pro headset. The second vive did not break. Been using it for almost a year now. When i did not have the mouth tracker plugged into the headset the headset was flawless. Also the plastic piece that covers the headset connectors. Just take it out, it is to keep the connector cool enough. Also never place the headset upside down either because that will cause the headset to go off on thermal overload and shut off and show a red led. It will only take you doing that 3 times and the headset will more than likely break in some way.
I was surprised to see this issue. I've never had my Vive do this before on tether or wireless(my primary). Usually when I get into a game with it, all I have to do is "calibrate it" by exercising all of the face movements and then I never have any issues with the trackers for the rest of the session.
@@thunderbolt10031 Do you use a mouth tracker with the headset?
@@jbsthegamer Yes. It's a fully kitted Pro Eye
The dramatic music 😂
Besides getting the Meta Quest Pro and Vive Pro headsets. Are there other accessories that I can equip on my vr for face tracking?
When XR Elite face/eye modules goes out. Including 4.0 Trackers. Ima enjoy Tongue Tracking 24/7. Wrist trackers they are great but not as fun as an Index
I didn’t watch for the tracking. I watched for the adorable furries! So cute. I love it
hoping that the Index 2 comes with these features when it releases in 2035
New Half-Life 3 situation
@@KnightXVRC Valve is gonna be how they're gonna be
v60 has added tongue tracking baby!
What vrc world is this?
Any updates on the tongue tracking or Pupil Tracking on the Quest Pro?
what kind of visems does the avatar need to support all those facial expressions? just the standard ones?
Oculus software isn’t required now using the virtual desktop streamer 1.29 release
I wish the Vive Pro Eye was a bit easier to find...I love my Vive Pro though
Should I go with the pico 4 pro or the quest pro for face tracking
Can you do a comparison between pico 4 pro user (pico 4pro has eye and face tracking ) vs a quest pro?
I also want that comparison
I have had face tracking on the VIVE pro eye for a long while, and I don’t have to calibrate for months, and I don’t have the random surprised issue you’re having :0
It is possible that my unit has something wrong then? Idk, I even changed cables and it still has this weird issue from time to time. If I move my eyes around it autofixes, but I cant tell.
I'm a bit late, but I'm currently working on implementing eye and facial tracking to my Quest 2, I'm waiting for all the parts required to get in the mail, but hopefully it won't be too long.
and it will be superior than the Quest Pro because it *will* have tongue tracking :3
Thats quite the effort tho. Good luck xD
@@KnightXVRC yeah, it'll be worth it tho.
@@trashyone2907I'm sorry, but how are you gonna implement eye tracking on Q2??
I do own other devices but not the Quest Pro (and Quest 3). Yet. What about full body tracking? I mean - how does the comparison lean to if you also wished to make it work with body/arm/fingers tracking solutions?
With Vive Pro Eye of course it's more simple, because it's lighthouse tracking. So the FBT callibration is instant.
With the Quest Pro it's a bit more annoying I admit. The best solution many people propose is to have another tracker attached on the head for the continuous callibration, which works pretty well, but of course its a bit more expensive solution.
It also depends on what you want in the end with the FBT.
People who dance will sure enjoy a wireless experience better. People who just casually move a little, will work well with both.
As for finger tracking I've only used the Index Controllers, so I cannot advice on that matter!
This is something i been really wanting to get into im tryin to figure best setup. Tho idk anything bout vr or equipment. But eye and face tracking is must, is quest pro best option with that? Shame bout no tongue tho lol. Vive tho neat bout pupil size, i wonder how hard that setup is.
Vive for me. Meta was 😢😢😢 when it came to the tongue thing honestly. Everything was smooth as cutting butter. Meta was like a rock.
Wouldn't this test only be valid if the results were each recorded locally as the compression of the tracking data across vrchat servers would affect one side?
Kind of. The VRChat avatars we are using have a Smoothing option so we wouldnt see each other jitter that much. This is just to test the capabilities of the headsets and how good the expressions are reflected. In the end you will need a smoothing option because VRChat wont update these values for other people as quick as the headset renders them
that's so cute xD
Starts a comedy show!
cross eyes and show eyebrow movements! Individual eye tracking does not exist for quest pro I've heard.
Also can the tongue tracking be fixed by attaching a vive facial tracker to the quest pro?|
I have trouble with my quest playspace needing to be recalibrated with my base station playspace every time I launch it. I use space calibrator for it but it's annoying to have to do it every time. I've heard virtual desktop can solve this issue, but this is the main reason I want a base station tracked headset over standalone.
What song is this?
what game you use ?
Are these the only two headsets that have eye tracking?
There are more headsets that have eye tracking like the Varjo headset, but these two are the ones that have Eye tracking and Face tracking capabilities. You could technically attach the Vive's face tracker module to some other headset, but it requires adaptation and it's a bit more complicated.
cute ❤❤
Your test would have been more precise if you use the same avatar. Perhaps some features for avatars designed for quest pro or not included for whatever reason such as eyebrows. Thank you.
It is the same avatar base, just different textures and different hair, but thats about it x)
Finneeee im spending 1800 to get it then
This so fucking cute OMG
1:55 lmao
1:50 *clack clack clack!*
Sounds like a ASMR for me uwu
just 2 cuties being cute
I like the smoothing from the Quest Pro more. The Vive looks more like RAW Data with no smoothing :3
ye its automatically smoothed because its a different player
vive pro eye has a higher refresh rate, so it actually is just getting a lot more data. i think it's twice the refresh rate of the qpro.
Kingdom hearts 2 *sigh* good old times
Technically its days music. This is the main lobby.
Any updates for the quest pro?
The only good thing 'till now is that you can use Virtual Desktop to stream all the Eye and Face tracking to the computer.
@@KnightXVRC Yee, I have one now and it’s a blast on how much better the picture looks on the quest pro compared to the index
Would quest 3 do the same tracking
Quest 3 does not have face or eye tracking
@@KnightXVRCWait Quest 3 and Quest Pro are 2 separate headsets? Uhhh idk I don’t follow meta nowadays cuz fuck Meta but damn I did not know hta
ciute
What is this? How does this work?
It’s face tracking.. It works by tracking your face
I cannot pull out my tongue 😭
bowers castle ahh music
i very much dont want to buy a meta headset bc i kinda hate them (and i dont want to make a whole new account for meta itself when i already have a fb/ig account) but man it seems to be a lot better for people just starting vr
No Games, Apps or technology can find the rate of fire on my MG58, which is 4 MG42-Ms which firerate is 80,000 RPM.
vive still looks better and looks more responsive
Am I the only one that thinks that the Vive Pro Eye overall looks better?
OWWWWWWWW
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
dawwwwwwww ~
If user launch vrc on quest pro through his pc, can he still use all this abilities of his headset there? or only if he gonna launch it right on the headset, not on pc?
i remember how i was talking with my russian friends, some of them have random quests like me (thanks oculus for blocking your sh1tty servers on headsets) and our "pro" user didnt know how to turn on this eye tracking, when he actually bought pro version only for this eye tracking. ;D
Hmmm, the quest pro user here is using Air Link to connect the Quest Pro to the PC. And then launch VRChat from SteamVR, so this is a PC user, not a stand-alone VRChat in the headset.
Yea, but steam vr is understand that user is on quest pro, is this possible to somehow turn on eye tracking in vrchat if all info from steam vr(about headset) is going into vrchat?
@@RadioBot05 It really doesnt matter what SteamVR sees. If you want to pass the Eye tracking / face tracking information to VRChat you need the program "VRCFacetracking" in parallel. If you dont run this program, the tracking info will not reach VRChat.
What about ear tracking?
There is no such thing. Ears are only moved according to your expressions with eyes and mouth
I think that’d be completely unnecessary, it’d just remove the actual movement of the ears because it’s not like you can move your actual ears like wolf ears
Battle Brothers stay strong and destroy the disease! for the Emperor!
jokes on you ı did a program that does that on pc head tracking eye tracking annddd face tracking >:^3
Why did you have to wear those avatars?
music??
It's Sacred Moon from Kingdom Hearts
@@KnightXVRC Would you recommend the quest Pro after the quest three came out if I'm interested in face tracking.
@@discordo206quest 3 does not have face tracking. so if you want face tracking you need the quest pro
@KnightXVRC yea if I find one near 600 - 800 I'll hope on it. Love your videos!
And then they try to remove their tracking headsets and get sucked into vrchat for a loooooong time, being stuck in their respective avatars, gladly without hunger and thirst and any other bodily needs ^^"