true. there's a chance that the dark riders are claiming that those tentacles are garnok, but what if they're lying? what if the dark riders + mr. sands worship garnok, a god that doesn't exist?
I adore the second theory with the Embermane and teleportation and missing herd stuff... The sun cercle is probably my favourite cercle: it is so interesting...
About the Elizabeth = Fox theory, Esmeralda Silverforce (SSO CZcamsr and employee) addressed the fox quests (?) in a live stream some time ago. She said that it was made by an employee who was quitting and had made it as a gift to t he players. I really don’t think it could be plausible that a single employee, who was quitting btw, was allowed to make such a big change in the story on their own. Great video, love to see different wild theories, even if they may be purely speculation. Keep up the great work Eleanor!
Okay, so i have this vague idea of a theory. Rember when you posted the ''5 theories i never finished'' video, and the last one was about Buck being important somehow? What if Buck was one of the lifeless cyborg robots created by Big Bonny when she still worked for Dark Core
Thank you for including my theory! I came up with the theory talking with another person in the comments of one of your other videos and I think we both thought of the traditional "warm, bright and sunny" image of the sun when we matched the Foresters to the Sun Circle, rather than Star Stable's very different image of the sun. I love the idea that the Embermane could be part of the missing herd. Maybe this is where the Mistfall Series could start to tie in with the main plot. I loved hearing your opinion on my and other people's theorys. You have such an amazing and unique channel!
For the theory about garnok not existing, what if garnok did exist before Jorvik but then got destroyed by the soul riders. (The old soul rider went with him thats why it became a myth) Mabey the dark riders are trying to scare others by saying garnok will get them but it won’t because he dose not exist “yet”. Mabey that is what the fridge doors are for. They are experimenting and trying to revive garnok so they can take over Jorvik. (The fridge doors are shaped as a star because in the middle of the star that is where garnok will be released) This is also why they only make little attacks or do something that would risk their plan to revive garnok such as soul riding or taking Herman. (I’m not a theorizer but this to me would make a good storyline)
Since we are still in the beginning(or a bit further) or the main story quest, I guess it make sense that à character NEEDS to go... it is part of the process for a good story: They fight, they lose soldiers but in the end they win. And Elizabeth was the perfect one to go it just leaves us hear with no answers at this point you wish that you could talk to Elizabeth to get those answers...(maybe a futur quest with our character entering in contact with Elizabeth's ghost or whatever) Anyways just to say that it was necessary for Elizabeth to die.
The mistfall series have something to do with the missing herds (look at the first scene were the horse is kept in that circle) and their are 5 herds one for us too (sorry for my bad English)
One idea my sleep-deprived brain has at the moment is that the fox could possibly by Catherine?... I mean, Aideen's Path is where we get the fox quest and where we talk to Catherine's spirit during the light ride... possible resemblance?
I have a pretty weird theory. So Aideen made Jorvik, and the soul riders. But if her light spread everywhere, why are there still parts of darkness, like Pi the witches house? My theory is Aideen had a sister that made the darkness of Jorvik. She made the Dark Riders more powerful. I know its weird and crazy, and kind of throws of some other theories, but I believe it.
So here's a little theory that I've had for a while now (also I know that it's gonna sound crazy so don't attack me). The theory is that we are Skye. I know it sounds absolutely crazy, but let me explain: 1. We can buy Skye's horse (Embermane) 2. We were able to buy Skye's clothes 3. Both of us have very special bonds with our horses 4. Both of us have magical powers 5. Both of us don't have exactly "normal" horses 6. Both of us know the rangers pretty well 7. Both of us constantly get ourselves into trouble 8. Every player (even non-starriders) who joined the game on the right time were able to do the quest with Blaze Pretty many connections if you ask me. Even if we aren't Skye she has to be connected to the main story somehow.
I know this is kind of weird but remember how Catherine wanted to be a horse and how the horses in south hoof protected Justin moorland I wonder if Catherine is one of them... this probably isn’t right though just my thoughts and the closed gate in the secret stone circle is kind ok creepy in my mind why is it locked? I bet once mystic valley is revealed it will clear up a lot of stuff at least I hope lol
My biggest theory is that the druids are actually evil and have other motives for recruiting and training the soul riders and that they'll betray us eventually
what if Elizabeth sacrificed her life to us in order to save Jorvik, kind of lacking proof, so it might just be a thought, i think it Elizabeth died for a reason, she might know what would happen to our character if she stayed alive, or maybe a certain ritual might need to be done or something and it cannot be done with her being with us, again this is just a thought, but it might just be possible....
This isn't exactly a theory, more something I'm wondering about, but I thought I'd put it here anyway! So, in Wildwoods, you know the Sentinel Tree? Well, first of all, it's clearly Pandorian (Pandoric?). I mean, it's unnaturally big (its root system reaches all through Wildwoods), it has pink crystals and butterflies all around it (not only are they Pandorian colours, but we've seen those crystals before), and it apparently smells like cotton candy (I believe Ydris once said Pandoria smells like cotton candy? I hate him, so you probably shouldn't trust what I think he said once, I'm not exactly the best source of Ydris information...). Beyond that, though, I have a bigger theory: What if the Sentinel Tree is destroying Wildwoods? If you look around the tree, you can see that there aren't really any normal plants nearby. The only grass is pink, and all the trees are a bit away. In fact, the only animals that are there for any extended amounts of time are the butterflies, which as said earlier are pink. Furthermore, the nearby trees are affected. They have Pandorian things seemingly growing out of them, such as crystals and mushrooms, and several seem to be leaning away from the tree, as if they're falling down and beginning to die due to the Sentinel Tree, or maybe even trying to escape.
I see you've given this a lot of thought! What also strikes me, is how Gary says he won't go near the tree because it leaves a bad taste in his mouth... kinda sounds like Pandoria sickness 👀
I actually think you're right that makes a lot of sense. And it's talked about before how pandorias destroying jorvik right? So it would make a lot of sense if that would start happening in wildwoods since it's so full of life and magic anyway. Great theory!
About the missing herd theory- what if they are the dark horse, what if the Embermane is just the last horse that can be turned into a dark horse and it's on the run, hiding out in Mistfall?
Theory 1: So me and one of my friends came up with this theory a while ago, it’s about the screams in Mistfall In our theory a girl that lived with her mother in the house at the corner a bit outside of Dundull got lured out at night to the old train tracks by some sort of monster, possibly a shapeshifter looking like her father, where she then got run over by a train, the tracks have been out of service since for safety reasons. Her mother wanted to know what happened to her daughter and joined the Jorvik rangers, which made her end up in Redwood Point, there the monster lured her away from the camp, possibly in shape of her daughter, and as soon as they were far away from the camp the monster returned to its true form, the mother hid in the outlook where she then disappeared (she’s the ranger that’s talked about in the wildwoods quests). There’s a bunch of clues at the outlook, the house and around Jorvik, like shoes standing in the empty house or newspapers with train tracks on them laying around, tbf tho, it’s unlikely for something like that to happen in a game directed at children. Oh, but a connection between this and the main story could still be made, the monster could be Garnok itself or another evil creature related to Garnok Theory 2: The dark riders or dark core see the 4th dark rider in us, otherwise they could’ve easily gotten rid of us with their mind control related powers
I have another theory about elizabeth not being dead. Since she had the power of the sun circle (im going out on a limb here), what if she teleported away instead of dying. Like i said, going out on a limb here.
I feel like we will hear from Elisabeth. Maybe in a dream or on a mission. Maybe in next years light ride, or a light ride quest coming in the following years. I believe that elisabeths death has been planned out to something meaningful and that our changes of her appearing again aren’t slim
I love the intro. . ."Hi! It's me again." I have a theory, idk if you will ever get a chance to share it with someone, but here it goes anyways. It's probably been done before but. . . In Starshine Legacy 3, Legend Of Pandoria, the intro really got me. It showed a general coming out of yellow, glowing light. I feel like that's what the fridge doors could be! What if the 4 Dark Riders had came up from the Fridge Door light, and the 5th fridge door is where Garnok will eventually come out, if we don't stop it!?
I feel stupid but I've just now realized that Garnok is basically an eldritch entity. The way it's the depicted, the iconic tentacles, the power it has, the incomprehensibility of its nature... I'm suddenly interested in this game's lore way more
So I had a random theory. What if the Sentinel Tree is actually the spirt of Aideen in a way? The Wild Woods herds refer to the tree as a Life Warden. But the life wardens we’ve seen are the one in the Forgotten Fields, the South Hoof one, and I think this last one is a life warden but it’s the one on the mountain where you get Aideen’s Melody with Lisa. They are all considerably smaller and they don’t seem to have as much magical aura around them, where as the Sentinel Tree has so many Pandoric things, grass, crystals, even pink cracks in the tree. Anyways, if Aideen did come from Pandora it would explain why there was so much of that stuff. I can’t remember but I think in the Wild Woods quests the herds know of Aideen, mainly the Mystics. An out her random theory I had going off of the first one was that Aideen spent most of her time on Jorvik in Wild Woods, bonding with the herds. The Sentinel Tree could be her final resting place or something like that.
Regarding the theory that Elisabeth may be the red fox or at least resurrected. If I remember correctly, Elisabeth was trapped in something or other in the second and third Soul Riders books, but came back without a very thorough explanation. So for all we know it could be that the Elisabeth we know from the game is a spy from Dark Riders or that she resurrects when she dies.
I have a creepy theory about the screams in mistfall… so, it sounds like a deer right? But I think it’s the glue man. In the hallowing trail ride with the rangers by the campfire, they talk about how the glue man traps little girls in the mountains above them (The mountain connecting Jorvik city and mistfall together) so it must be the screams of riders or whoever. it’s a simple theory, but I thought it was cool. Maybe you should do a video like this one but with spooky theory’s?
What about Galloper Thompson, didn't he knock over a rune stone? I honestly think the rune stone created the illusion of Thompson while the witch who promised him he wouldn't die kidnapped him because she could use the illusion (or something). The witch could have been a Vala planning to use him for something or someone like Pi who could have made him use his horse as a dark rider's horse? It's far fetched and probably unlikely, but it would be cool to hear people's opinions on Galloper Thompson as that story surely goes deeper than what it seems to be now.
Remember sometime ago you posted a video that Anne was not really Anne? Well remember in the old story ( star shine legacy) she was nice and all. Well on star stables’ yt in “meet the soul riders” well when it came to Anne it seemed off in a way. She said stuff like “when you need your friends the most they aren’t there to help” (I haven’t watched it in a while). And the when we got the story quest on saving frip she just disappeared. That sus.
Heyyy I’m early! I love your voice and eyes! Glad to see that you are making more videos with your face too 🙃 Currently watching and I totally agree with these theories so far. If you have not already, could you make a theory on what is in that closed off pit by Jorvik stables? The one that was mentioned in the recent quest line with mayas horse. Thanks 🥰
The Fox referencing tails of pixels seems to me as a reference to something to do with development. Pixel Tales made a handful of games such as the Barbie Horse Adventures games (Which always seemed way too similar to SSO for my comfort, after some looking about I discovered sso had involvement/ or still is currently made by Pixel Tales ) . Following the comment about the employee who added it, seems that theory makes sense.
I was thinking about the comeback of star academy for a long time actually! Wouldn't marchenghast castle be the perfect place for it? I don't think this will be a palace-like location as this means there would be some Kind of royality involved which , since we already have the baroness, wouldn't fit in at all
wait how do I play the fox quest?? Elizabeth was one of my favorite NPC'S and I was so sad to see her go!! FYI I gave done my soul riding and gotten my rune runner as well as played the most recent story quest.
Okay I do understand this theory: Warriors; lightning circle Foresters: Star circle Mystics: moon circle but, I also feel like it could be possible that the circles that match the foresters and mystics could be switched. Here's my point of view: The star circle represents healing, love, and music, as well as deep thoughts and feelings (Lisa and her background etc) Whereas the moon circle represents knowledge, curiosity, delicate thinking and wisdom. There are wise characters in both the mystics and foresters, but I am a mystic and I also just love Lisa (I may or may not have a crush on her :/ so I kinda wish she was associated with the mystics instead, just a thought)
I have a Theory that I don't know what to make of so here it is - our starter horse Dies (I'm torn for this one) we have already had Elizabeth Die so I don't think they would kill of another person/horse, and I also don't think that it would be needed for the main story and if our starter horse was once Catherine's we know that they can come back, but then they might only be able to come back a set amount of times, but then.. I just don't know about that one!
About the Ashland theory, I think the Kallters may have lived there. It did say they absorbed a lot of magical energies because they lived so close to Garnok's Fury, the volcano. The volcano in Ashland is called Garnok's Fury. Plus, if Katja is the Ice Witch like you suggested, then Ashland would be a great place to live because it's right next to Dino Valley, where the portal in Icendell is.
Honestly, What if we are the daughter of Garnok and Aideen, but theres one thing. Nobody knows that we are and we ourselves dont know as we were possibly adopted out by them or Aideen sent us off somewhere safer, away from Garnok, and soon we will find this out and same for the Soul riders, we have the powers of all the Soul riders and Rhiannon, But we are far more powerful than Any of the Dark riders. Meaning, with us and the help of the other Soul riders, we could easily defeat the Dark riders, but they have something we need, Our Starter Horse, trapped with Elizabeths horse, I have yet to figure out what could possibly happen next. THIS IS JUST A THEORY! PLEASE KEEP THAT IN MIND!
I'm in the video omg Update: With my best friend, we were making theories, and we think Darko, Sabine or Jessica lives in Ashland:) And oh, you are the first english person who spelled my name correctly🥰
with elizabeth still being alive, it’s basically debunked completely by what alex said if you choose “we’ll find a way to bring her back.” she simply just says, “no, not this time.” implying elizabeth is truly gone.
Ok, I know this video was posted a few months ago but for some reason, I had this little idea just for keeping myself sane and then the more I thought about it it could maybe be true...I know that it probably isn't but...I need to share it or else I'm will go insane 0-0 Ok, so the theory is that we are (the player) Nihili...OK OK yeah I know how it sounds but hear me out...we have no idea where we came from...we are just here in Jorvik when we were somehow told we would only be here for a summer...buuuuut....at the fort pinta festival the soul riders said the new school year was starting soon...aaaannnnnddddd well there is still so much more to do. Ok so attack me if you want but hear me out 0-0 what if...garnok created...us…(pause for dramatic effect) Ok so hear me out what if we were tasked to destroy the soul riders or the druids aka Frip, Elizabeth, etc. but something went wrong in the process and now...we have forgotten everything, how we got to Jorvik, and maybe even our name? So what if...when we created our player, we were really just acting as Garnok creating his 4th general, and maybe the reason Nihili hasn’t shown up is that we are her/them, and maybe that’s also why we are drawn to the runestones and maybe even why we have these amazing powers? This is all just a weird theory pierced together but yeah...I’m just sort of bored. Maybe we are just a failed experiment of Garnok and then he goes and created Buck and it works a bit better??? I dunno at this point...don't even ask what other things I can come up with about this game...
in the book of sso i think it was the second linda gots into the house of darko and in his dairy he roads the name of is girlfriend i dont remeber it anymore but he also road that garnoc said he would bring her back alive if he brings the 4 soul rider horses their magic to garnok can u make a theory abt it?
I know I wrote about it before. And I understand there aren't almost no clues for this. I hope sso team didn't forgot about Avalon and Fort Maria. And we did ritual next to Fort Maria but we didn't go inside!!! :-D Whyyy... I found picture with text from 2018 Halloween party and Avalon said there: "Before joining the Keepers of Aideen, I was librarian at Fort Maria up until... the incident. Perhaps once the Soul Riders are together again we can look into that matter." And now are soul riders almost together again... And one another thing. Near Pony Point is stone with (soul rider's?) runes and start glow when we are near. Another glowing stone is near Gary's Goldtooth camp in small place between rocks. But this stone is broken. I wonder why it is in Wild Woods too.
@@errorw8472 Yes, we opened Fort Maria. But sadly still no explain to Avalon's incident. But. I think Lisa mentioned that incident in the quest! I laughed so hard when I read it. :-D What if sso team saw me writing about Avalon's incident all around the internet??? Just joking. :-D
@@Tulackyvrch I kinda skipped everything so i dont know lmao but it bothers me that theres gonna be a tornado thingy probably till they release the next storyline which i hope is really soon
oh i wasn’t even paying attention to the video and what she was saying i just looked and saw that the tunnel looked like the one at firgrove and wild woods
About the fox, I think it’s like an Easter egg because sso was made by star stable entertainment and pixel something, which star stable bought later on.
Love u Eleanor congrats on ten k and I have a theory that meander village is behind icen gate because how can the klaters get in there so I think meander village is behind icen gate and look at the position of it on the map
I have a question maybe you already sed something about this but why did Catherine die. Could it be that soul riders was not suppose to get children? Or was it her destiny?
i know im late but i think the reason that the wildwoods herds are so hostile towards eachother is because they are obviously based on the series "warriors", where 4 clans of wild cats live in the forest and have to fight for the food and territory that they have, and all the clans are very hostile towards eachother
I have a theory. If you filter the sounds in Mistfall, you can hear a sound like a scream. It can be an animal, but it really sounds like a scream of woman to me. Then there is a question. Whose scream is it? There was a theory that it was Anne trapped in Pandoria and screams for help. But we saved her and we still can hear someone screaming. I think it's someone else. But she is trapped in Pandoria. Also I found a portal in the middle of Dundull. It looks like a statue, but it can be a walled portal and behind it stands a horse with which we had no tasks.
Ok I know this is like a crazy theory but what if we are the reincarnation of Garnock and Aiden, and at the end of the star stable story or near the end we must chose our path or side. Somethings that back up my theory is the reason why the dark riders haven’t killed us are because they see Garnoch in us or they see evil in us that we could harness and actually use and I also think that the reason why we have such a connection to Catherine is because we have Aiden in us, and we have evil in good, and if we don’t choose one side, something might happen
I'm really, really late to this, and this isnt a theory but more just "insane" or weird thoughts, the quest with ydris is quite old now but there is no way he would just "trust" someone like that, or he gave us some choices he somehow knew we would achieve, so I think you get what I mean. My head then spat out: we don't know ANYTHING about our characters background and it seems she either doesn't know about it or doesn't want to talk about it, but why?my theory (it's quite weird and impossible) is that she is or at least has a connection to Pandoria. I know we always helped, but isn't it weird that the soulriders said they aren't experienced enough to fight/go into Pandoria? So why, only with out help apparently were we able to, and why weren't we affected? I mean yeah it takes a while to actually be affected by Pandoria, but we quite literally fought agains a monster that probably hit us once or twice AND we were transported with (I think) Pandorian magic. so my question stands, why weren't we affected, are we connected to Pandoria? Does our character not remember? There was theory that the magic of soulriders run in families, but as we know we aren't related to the last 5th soulrider, but Catherine seemed friendly with us,why? These are just pondering, ridiculous questions i build up in my head 😅
The Garnok theory sparks something in me....what if, what if GARNOK is NIHILI? the missing dark rider! (ye let's ignore the fact that nihili is a girl) The name Nihili means NOTHING, and if Garnok isn't real, what if Nihili is the person who's PRETENDING to be him, creating illusions? Idk LOL
Interessantes Video. Im Norden von Jorvik ist noch ein Dorf namens Meander(das Fawncy kommt dorther) Was mich auch noch interessiert ist ob es noch mehr Pferde mit blauen Mähnen wie Starshine gibt(evtl Leben die ja irgendwo im noch nicht zugänglichen Gebiet) Was es mit dem Yeti im Dinotal auf sich hat Der Zweck der Fridgedoors Das Bild auf dem Boden vom Geheimen Steinkreis Die Hoffnung dass die kalter zurückkehren. Haben wir WIRKLICH Anne befreit?(Bereich den man noch nicht entdecken kann Gefängnis in Pandoria wo Anne eingesperrt ist)
@@eleanornightwalker This is a translation of some sorts (i am dutch so my german isn’t exactly perfect either but i hope it will help) Interesting video. In the north of Jorvik is also a village named Meander (the Fawncy comes from there) I'm also interested in whether there are more horses with blue manes like starshine (maybe they live somewhere in an area that is not accessible yet) What the yeti in Dinovalley is all about (not sure about this translation) The purpose of the fridgedoor The picture on the floor of the secret stone circle The hope that the kalter will return (not sure this is the best translation) Have we really freed Anne (area that cannot be discovered yet, prison in Pandoria where Anne is imprisoned
Me, new to sso, lvl 15 and not rushing the quests: oh man I'm sure this theory video won't spoil anything to me, the story seemed kinda slow anyway :) The video: so basicislly Elizabeth explodes Me: 😶
I do have a a theory are we the next leader of Aideen wat happens if frip dies he was already in an in a coma and almost dead. Theory by Lily Majorhope.
The thing about Garnok not being real, I honestly have no evidence. Have you ever seen this video btw? It's like some sort of horse ritual- I'm very confused by it, but you can like- chat with Garnok and he says some weird things. If that's supposedly a memory, which looks like it is then maybe Garnok is real? If there are people in cloaks trying to summon him or something, he must be real right? I still have no evidence this is true because of course, it could all just be an allusion. Anywaysss, here is the vid: czcams.com/video/32Sx9TC6tUI/video.html
I know I’m pretty late but the house in Ashland is actually the old house from Elizabeth, they probably planned something with Elizabeth in ashland back then
"We have never talked to Garnok"
The halloween trail ride: 👀
Though that could be an illusion as well...
Sorry, I forget a lot of what happened on the Halloween Trail Ride. Could you please tell me more about this; did we speak to Garnok?
@@sagefeather3405 This video sums it up really well: czcams.com/video/32Sx9TC6tUI/video.html
@@QuinnOakhearthSSO Okay, thank you! I think I encountered that, I just never realized you could talk to the tentacle.
@@sagefeather3405 You're welcome!
true. there's a chance that the dark riders are claiming that those tentacles are garnok, but what if they're lying? what if the dark riders + mr. sands worship garnok, a god that doesn't exist?
I adore the second theory with the Embermane and teleportation and missing herd stuff... The sun cercle is probably my favourite cercle: it is so interesting...
About the Elizabeth = Fox theory, Esmeralda Silverforce (SSO CZcamsr and employee) addressed the fox quests (?) in a live stream some time ago. She said that it was made by an employee who was quitting and had made it as a gift to t he players. I really don’t think it could be plausible that a single employee, who was quitting btw, was allowed to make such a big change in the story on their own.
Great video, love to see different wild theories, even if they may be purely speculation. Keep up the great work Eleanor!
HI ZUMBA
Okay, so i have this vague idea of a theory. Rember when you posted the ''5 theories i never finished'' video, and the last one was about Buck being important somehow? What if Buck was one of the lifeless cyborg robots created by Big Bonny when she still worked for Dark Core
SSO if they hire you as a script writer: 📈📈📈📈📈📈📈📈 your ability to make logical connections is exciting
I absolutely believe that our character is the daughter of Garnok and Aideen 🐙
This gives me ideas 👀
@@eleanornightwalker 🥰
the fanfiction writes itself
:O I adore that!!
We need to know more about ourselves! Jeez, we know more about that woman at stable bucks then we do about our backstory
Thank you for including my theory! I came up with the theory talking with another person in the comments of one of your other videos and I think we both thought of the traditional "warm, bright and sunny" image of the sun when we matched the Foresters to the Sun Circle, rather than Star Stable's very different image of the sun. I love the idea that the Embermane could be part of the missing herd. Maybe this is where the Mistfall Series could start to tie in with the main plot.
I loved hearing your opinion on my and other people's theorys. You have such an amazing and unique channel!
I don’t think Elizabeth is alive but i do think we will kinda meet her as a ghost. It would be cool if we did. ;)
For the theory about garnok not existing, what if garnok did exist before Jorvik but then got destroyed by the soul riders. (The old soul rider went with him thats why it became a myth) Mabey the dark riders are trying to scare others by saying garnok will get them but it won’t because he dose not exist “yet”. Mabey that is what the fridge doors are for. They are experimenting and trying to revive garnok so they can take over Jorvik. (The fridge doors are shaped as a star because in the middle of the star that is where garnok will be released) This is also why they only make little attacks or do something that would risk their plan to revive garnok such as soul riding or taking Herman. (I’m not a theorizer but this to me would make a good storyline)
Yea I get it also the cracks i at Steve’s with the hole and the light maybe he knida starts to revive?
My theory: Elizabeth is/was a Vala, and somehow escaped Darko (as far as I know, noone told she's dead) and is now hiding in Devil's Gap
That would be cool
Thats a really good theory!!!
The fox quest thing is breaking the fourth wall. It's shattered, obliterated, gone. It has disappeared, all because of a fox.
Wait what? Sorry I don't understand.
@@ms.horselover2569 "pixel team"
Since we are still in the beginning(or a bit further) or the main story quest, I guess it make sense that à character NEEDS to go... it is part of the process for a good story: They fight, they lose soldiers but in the end they win. And Elizabeth was the perfect one to go it just leaves us hear with no answers at this point you wish that you could talk to Elizabeth to get those answers...(maybe a futur quest with our character entering in contact with Elizabeth's ghost or whatever) Anyways just to say that it was necessary for Elizabeth to die.
The mistfall series have something to do with the missing herds (look at the first scene were the horse is kept in that circle) and their are 5 herds one for us too (sorry for my bad English)
One idea my sleep-deprived brain has at the moment is that the fox could possibly by Catherine?... I mean, Aideen's Path is where we get the fox quest and where we talk to Catherine's spirit during the light ride... possible resemblance?
I have a pretty weird theory. So Aideen made Jorvik, and the soul riders. But if her light spread everywhere, why are there still parts of darkness, like Pi the witches house? My theory is Aideen had a sister that made the darkness of Jorvik. She made the Dark Riders more powerful. I know its weird and crazy, and kind of throws of some other theories, but I believe it.
I personally think that Anne ran off to turn the new Concorde into the old one. Like yk, make the old Concorde come back. Or Elizabeth.
I'm not really a theory person, but I think this video is great! I'm definitely not that creative. 😪 Awesome video as always!! Stay safe ♥️
So here's a little theory that I've had for a while now (also I know that it's gonna sound crazy so don't attack me). The theory is that we are Skye. I know it sounds absolutely crazy, but let me explain:
1. We can buy Skye's horse (Embermane)
2. We were able to buy Skye's clothes
3. Both of us have very special bonds with our horses
4. Both of us have magical powers
5. Both of us don't have exactly "normal" horses
6. Both of us know the rangers pretty well
7. Both of us constantly get ourselves into trouble
8. Every player (even non-starriders) who joined the game on the right time were able to do the quest with Blaze
Pretty many connections if you ask me. Even if we aren't Skye she has to be connected to the main story somehow.
I know this is kind of weird but remember how Catherine wanted to be a horse and how the horses in south hoof protected Justin moorland I wonder if Catherine is one of them... this probably isn’t right though just my thoughts and the closed gate in the secret stone circle is kind ok creepy in my mind why is it locked? I bet once mystic valley is revealed it will clear up a lot of stuff at least I hope lol
I'm excited for Halloween to come so you can drop the theory we spoke about when you were kinda interviewing me
My biggest theory is that the druids are actually evil and have other motives for recruiting and training the soul riders and that they'll betray us eventually
czcams.com/video/3Gd_T2_UTR0/video.html this is what sparked that theory, I firmly believe it
what if Elizabeth sacrificed her life to us in order to save Jorvik, kind of lacking proof, so it might just be a thought, i think it Elizabeth died for a reason, she might know what would happen to our character if she stayed alive, or maybe a certain ritual might need to be done or something and it cannot be done with her being with us, again this is just a thought, but it might just be possible....
I have captions on and when it said “Jorvik” it said “Your week” 💀😂
This isn't exactly a theory, more something I'm wondering about, but I thought I'd put it here anyway! So, in Wildwoods, you know the Sentinel Tree? Well, first of all, it's clearly Pandorian (Pandoric?). I mean, it's unnaturally big (its root system reaches all through Wildwoods), it has pink crystals and butterflies all around it (not only are they Pandorian colours, but we've seen those crystals before), and it apparently smells like cotton candy (I believe Ydris once said Pandoria smells like cotton candy? I hate him, so you probably shouldn't trust what I think he said once, I'm not exactly the best source of Ydris information...). Beyond that, though, I have a bigger theory:
What if the Sentinel Tree is destroying Wildwoods?
If you look around the tree, you can see that there aren't really any normal plants nearby. The only grass is pink, and all the trees are a bit away. In fact, the only animals that are there for any extended amounts of time are the butterflies, which as said earlier are pink. Furthermore, the nearby trees are affected. They have Pandorian things seemingly growing out of them, such as crystals and mushrooms, and several seem to be leaning away from the tree, as if they're falling down and beginning to die due to the Sentinel Tree, or maybe even trying to escape.
I see you've given this a lot of thought! What also strikes me, is how Gary says he won't go near the tree because it leaves a bad taste in his mouth... kinda sounds like Pandoria sickness 👀
i love this!
@@eleanornightwalker Ooh, I'd forgotten that.
@@islacloudknight1717 Thank you!
I actually think you're right that makes a lot of sense. And it's talked about before how pandorias destroying jorvik right? So it would make a lot of sense if that would start happening in wildwoods since it's so full of life and magic anyway.
Great theory!
About the missing herd theory- what if they are the dark horse, what if the Embermane is just the last horse that can be turned into a dark horse and it's on the run, hiding out in Mistfall?
Theory 1:
So me and one of my friends came up with this theory a while ago, it’s about the screams in Mistfall
In our theory a girl that lived with her mother in the house at the corner a bit outside of Dundull got lured out at night to the old train tracks by some sort of monster, possibly a shapeshifter looking like her father, where she then got run over by a train, the tracks have been out of service since for safety reasons. Her mother wanted to know what happened to her daughter and joined the Jorvik rangers, which made her end up in Redwood Point, there the monster lured her away from the camp, possibly in shape of her daughter, and as soon as they were far away from the camp the monster returned to its true form, the mother hid in the outlook where she then disappeared (she’s the ranger that’s talked about in the wildwoods quests). There’s a bunch of clues at the outlook, the house and around Jorvik, like shoes standing in the empty house or newspapers with train tracks on them laying around, tbf tho, it’s unlikely for something like that to happen in a game directed at children.
Oh, but a connection between this and the main story could still be made, the monster could be Garnok itself or another evil creature related to Garnok
Theory 2:
The dark riders or dark core see the 4th dark rider in us, otherwise they could’ve easily gotten rid of us with their mind control related powers
I have another theory about elizabeth not being dead. Since she had the power of the sun circle (im going out on a limb here), what if she teleported away instead of dying. Like i said, going out on a limb here.
I feel like we will hear from Elisabeth. Maybe in a dream or on a mission. Maybe in next years light ride, or a light ride quest coming in the following years. I believe that elisabeths death has been planned out to something meaningful and that our changes of her appearing again aren’t slim
I love the intro. . ."Hi! It's me again."
I have a theory, idk if you will ever get a chance to share it with someone, but here it goes anyways.
It's probably been done before but. . .
In Starshine Legacy 3, Legend Of Pandoria, the intro really got me. It showed a general coming out of yellow, glowing light.
I feel like that's what the fridge doors could be! What if the 4 Dark Riders had came up from the Fridge Door light, and the 5th fridge door is where Garnok will eventually come out, if we don't stop it!?
I feel stupid but I've just now realized that Garnok is basically an eldritch entity. The way it's the depicted, the iconic tentacles, the power it has, the incomprehensibility of its nature... I'm suddenly interested in this game's lore way more
So I had a random theory. What if the Sentinel Tree is actually the spirt of Aideen in a way? The Wild Woods herds refer to the tree as a Life Warden. But the life wardens we’ve seen are the one in the Forgotten Fields, the South Hoof one, and I think this last one is a life warden but it’s the one on the mountain where you get Aideen’s Melody with Lisa. They are all considerably smaller and they don’t seem to have as much magical aura around them, where as the Sentinel Tree has so many Pandoric things, grass, crystals, even pink cracks in the tree. Anyways, if Aideen did come from Pandora it would explain why there was so much of that stuff.
I can’t remember but I think in the Wild Woods quests the herds know of Aideen, mainly the Mystics. An out her random theory I had going off of the first one was that Aideen spent most of her time on Jorvik in Wild Woods, bonding with the herds. The Sentinel Tree could be her final resting place or something like that.
Regarding the theory that Elisabeth may be the red fox or at least resurrected. If I remember correctly, Elisabeth was trapped in something or other in the second and third Soul Riders books, but came back without a very thorough explanation. So for all we know it could be that the Elisabeth we know from the game is a spy from Dark Riders or that she resurrects when she dies.
I have a creepy theory about the screams in mistfall… so, it sounds like a deer right? But I think it’s the glue man. In the hallowing trail ride with the rangers by the campfire, they talk about how the glue man traps little girls in the mountains above them (The mountain connecting Jorvik city and mistfall together) so it must be the screams of riders or whoever. it’s a simple theory, but I thought it was cool. Maybe you should do a video like this one but with spooky theory’s?
What about Galloper Thompson, didn't he knock over a rune stone?
I honestly think the rune stone created the illusion of Thompson while the witch who promised him he wouldn't die kidnapped him because she could use the illusion (or something). The witch could have been a Vala planning to use him for something or someone like Pi who could have made him use his horse as a dark rider's horse? It's far fetched and probably unlikely, but it would be cool to hear people's opinions on Galloper Thompson as that story surely goes deeper than what it seems to be now.
Remember sometime ago you posted a video that Anne was not really Anne?
Well remember in the old story ( star shine legacy) she was nice and all. Well on star stables’ yt in “meet the soul riders” well when it came to Anne it seemed off in a way. She said stuff like “when you need your friends the most they aren’t there to help” (I haven’t watched it in a while). And the when we got the story quest on saving frip she just disappeared. That sus.
i made a theory about this, u can see it on my video!
@@rosivlyz what’s the video called?
@@trueblue8355 its on my channel and it had 5+ theories and im very sure you can find it on there
This was so interesting to watch I can't wait for part 2
Evergray was like Lisa, Linda, Alex you get the point and he also got trapped in pandoria thats why his eye is messed up.
I loved these theories so much!
Please make more of these videos!!
Completely unrelated but i have been thinking about cutting my hair short and your video didnt help stopping me from it haha
Heyyy I’m early! I love your voice and eyes! Glad to see that you are making more videos with your face too 🙃 Currently watching and I totally agree with these theories so far. If you have not already, could you make a theory on what is in that closed off pit by Jorvik stables? The one that was mentioned in the recent quest line with mayas horse. Thanks 🥰
You mean Devil's Gap? 👀
@@eleanornightwalker ah yes that’s the name thank you 😆
I agree on the fact that Eleanor's eyes are gorgeous... and the haircut😵😅
@@diviyah7967 yassss
Nice video!
Btw: Did you noticed that snake under one house in the New Hillcrest?
The Fox referencing tails of pixels seems to me as a reference to something to do with development. Pixel Tales made a handful of games such as the Barbie Horse Adventures games (Which always seemed way too similar to SSO for my comfort, after some looking about I discovered sso had involvement/ or still is currently made by Pixel Tales ) . Following the comment about the employee who added it, seems that theory makes sense.
Dangg, you should've seen some of my theories! I think i found some connections though!
congrats on 11k subs!
I was thinking about the comeback of star academy for a long time actually! Wouldn't marchenghast castle be the perfect place for it? I don't think this will be a palace-like location as this means there would be some Kind of royality involved which , since we already have the baroness, wouldn't fit in at all
Yay!
Thank you!
We are going to be impostor in dark riders group... To get lost book. Wild theory.
I'm so glad you are doing more videos with your irl face!! Ur so pretty!!
wait how do I play the fox quest?? Elizabeth was one of my favorite NPC'S and I was so sad to see her go!! FYI I gave done my soul riding and gotten my rune runner as well as played the most recent story quest.
oh you explained lol my bad
Okay I do understand this theory:
Warriors; lightning circle
Foresters: Star circle
Mystics: moon circle
but, I also feel like it could be possible that the circles that match the foresters and mystics could be switched. Here's my point of view:
The star circle represents healing, love, and music, as well as deep thoughts and feelings (Lisa and her background etc) Whereas the moon circle represents knowledge, curiosity, delicate thinking and wisdom. There are wise characters in both the mystics and foresters, but I am a mystic and I also just love Lisa (I may or may not have a crush on her :/ so I kinda wish she was associated with the mystics instead, just a thought)
theory if catherine was reborn into a horse could it be the players horse that she was reborn into
Early for once love your theory videos🥰
I have a Theory that I don't know what to make of
so here it is
- our starter horse Dies (I'm torn for this one)
we have already had Elizabeth Die so I don't think they would kill of another person/horse, and I also don't think that it would be needed for the main story and if our starter horse was once Catherine's we know that they can come back, but then they might only be able to come back a set amount of times, but then.. I just don't know about that one!
Love you elanor!!!💖
About the Ashland theory, I think the Kallters may have lived there. It did say they absorbed a lot of magical energies because they lived so close to Garnok's Fury, the volcano. The volcano in Ashland is called Garnok's Fury.
Plus, if Katja is the Ice Witch like you suggested, then Ashland would be a great place to live because it's right next to Dino Valley, where the portal in Icendell is.
Loved the video!! 🤩🤩
Honestly, What if we are the daughter of Garnok and Aideen, but theres one thing. Nobody knows that we are and we ourselves dont know as we were possibly adopted out by them or Aideen sent us off somewhere safer, away from Garnok, and soon we will find this out and same for the Soul riders, we have the powers of all the Soul riders and Rhiannon, But we are far more powerful than Any of the Dark riders. Meaning, with us and the help of the other Soul riders, we could easily defeat the Dark riders, but they have something we need, Our Starter Horse, trapped with Elizabeths horse, I have yet to figure out what could possibly happen next.
THIS IS JUST A THEORY! PLEASE KEEP THAT IN MIND!
"Who lives in Ashland?" Me... oh...
I love your channel
I'm in the video omg
Update: With my best friend, we were making theories, and we think Darko, Sabine or Jessica lives in Ashland:)
And oh, you are the first english person who spelled my name correctly🥰
This is great'
This is a little random but you are really pretty ❤️
with elizabeth still being alive, it’s basically debunked completely by what alex said if you choose “we’ll find a way to bring her back.” she simply just says, “no, not this time.” implying elizabeth is truly gone.
Ok, I know this video was posted a few months ago but for some reason, I had this little idea just for keeping myself sane and then the more I thought about it it could maybe be true...I know that it probably isn't but...I need to share it or else I'm will go insane 0-0
Ok, so the theory is that we are (the player) Nihili...OK OK yeah I know how it sounds but hear me out...we have no idea where we came from...we are just here in Jorvik when we were somehow told we would only be here for a summer...buuuuut....at the fort pinta festival the soul riders said the new school year was starting soon...aaaannnnnddddd well there is still so much more to do. Ok so attack me if you want but hear me out 0-0 what if...garnok created...us…(pause for dramatic effect) Ok so hear me out what if we were tasked to destroy the soul riders or the druids aka Frip, Elizabeth, etc. but something went wrong in the process and now...we have forgotten everything, how we got to Jorvik, and maybe even our name? So what if...when we created our player, we were really just acting as Garnok creating his 4th general, and maybe the reason Nihili hasn’t shown up is that we are her/them, and maybe that’s also why we are drawn to the runestones and maybe even why we have these amazing powers? This is all just a weird theory pierced together but yeah...I’m just sort of bored. Maybe we are just a failed experiment of Garnok and then he goes and created Buck and it works a bit better??? I dunno at this point...don't even ask what other things I can come up with about this game...
in the book of sso i think it was the second linda gots into the house of darko and in his dairy he roads the name of is girlfriend i dont remeber it anymore but he also road that garnoc said he would bring her back alive if he brings the 4 soul rider horses their magic to garnok can u make a theory abt it?
I know I wrote about it before. And I understand there aren't almost no clues for this.
I hope sso team didn't forgot about Avalon and Fort Maria. And we did ritual next to Fort Maria but we didn't go inside!!! :-D Whyyy...
I found picture with text from 2018 Halloween party and Avalon said there: "Before joining the Keepers of Aideen, I was librarian at Fort Maria up until... the incident. Perhaps once the Soul Riders are together again we can look into that matter."
And now are soul riders almost together again...
And one another thing. Near Pony Point is stone with (soul rider's?) runes and start glow when we are near.
Another glowing stone is near Gary's Goldtooth camp in small place between rocks. But this stone is broken. I wonder why it is in Wild Woods too.
come back if u played the new story quest already
@@errorw8472 Yes, we opened Fort Maria. But sadly still no explain to Avalon's incident. But. I think Lisa mentioned that incident in the quest! I laughed so hard when I read it. :-D What if sso team saw me writing about Avalon's incident all around the internet??? Just joking. :-D
@@Tulackyvrch I kinda skipped everything so i dont know lmao but it bothers me that theres gonna be a tornado thingy probably till they release the next storyline which i hope is really soon
@@errorw8472 The tornado of chaos. Vala doesn't have everything under control. I need next quest! :-)
all of these make my brain hurt they make sense tho I like the connection of the wildwoods herd to the soul riders
with the "to the north bit" if we were to look at the full map that would be up near pine hill mansion/winter mountains
i didn’t even know about the fox quest at wild woods 🤠
I think you access the fox quest through Aideen's Whisper in Goldenhills, not in Wildwoods. I must get around to finishing that quest...
oh i wasn’t even paying attention to the video and what she was saying i just looked and saw that the tunnel looked like the one at firgrove and wild woods
@@finnsterwinnster I see what you mean. I think the blue mushrooms make it look like Wildwoods.
"There is no 4th heard..." Yes there is.. Oh, not released yet, right...
About the fox, I think it’s like an Easter egg because sso was made by star stable entertainment and pixel something, which star stable bought later on.
Love u Eleanor congrats on ten k and I have a theory that meander village is behind icen gate because how can the klaters get in there so I think meander village is behind icen gate and look at the position of it on the map
Oh and congrats on 11k too
I have a question maybe you already sed something about this but why did Catherine die. Could it be that soul riders was not suppose to get children? Or was it her destiny?
i know im late but i think the reason that the wildwoods herds are so hostile towards eachother is because they are obviously based on the series "warriors", where 4 clans of wild cats live in the forest and have to fight for the food and territory that they have, and all the clans are very hostile towards eachother
I have a theory. If you filter the sounds in Mistfall, you can hear a sound like a scream. It can be an animal, but it really sounds like a scream of woman to me.
Then there is a question. Whose scream is it?
There was a theory that it was Anne trapped in Pandoria and screams for help. But we saved her and we still can hear someone screaming. I think it's someone else. But she is trapped in Pandoria.
Also I found a portal in the middle of Dundull. It looks like a statue, but it can be a walled portal and behind it stands a horse with which we had no tasks.
What is the background music?
Its so calming.
Good video btw
It's called Spirit of Fire, it's available in the youtube audio library 😊
@@eleanornightwalker thank you so much.
Ok I know this is like a crazy theory but what if we are the reincarnation of Garnock and Aiden, and at the end of the star stable story or near the end we must chose our path or side. Somethings that back up my theory is the reason why the dark riders haven’t killed us are because they see Garnoch in us or they see evil in us that we could harness and actually use and I also think that the reason why we have such a connection to Catherine is because we have Aiden in us, and we have evil in good, and if we don’t choose one side, something might happen
I had a theory two seconds ago and I just forgot it :(
I'm really, really late to this, and this isnt a theory but more just "insane" or weird thoughts, the quest with ydris is quite old now but there is no way he would just "trust" someone like that, or he gave us some choices he somehow knew we would achieve, so I think you get what I mean. My head then spat out: we don't know ANYTHING about our characters background and it seems she either doesn't know about it or doesn't want to talk about it, but why?my theory (it's quite weird and impossible) is that she is or at least has a connection to Pandoria. I know we always helped, but isn't it weird that the soulriders said they aren't experienced enough to fight/go into Pandoria? So why, only with out help apparently were we able to, and why weren't we affected? I mean yeah it takes a while to actually be affected by Pandoria, but we quite literally fought agains a monster that probably hit us once or twice AND we were transported with (I think) Pandorian magic. so my question stands, why weren't we affected, are we connected to Pandoria? Does our character not remember? There was theory that the magic of soulriders run in families, but as we know we aren't related to the last 5th soulrider, but Catherine seemed friendly with us,why?
These are just pondering, ridiculous questions i build up in my head 😅
I wonder if the fox is Sabine it’s a weird one but her outfit thingy is the same color as the foxes fur
Im miss Elizabeth sunbeam and im hops Elizabeth sunbeam comes back
The Garnok theory sparks something in me....what if, what if GARNOK is NIHILI? the missing dark rider! (ye let's ignore the fact that nihili is a girl) The name Nihili means NOTHING, and if Garnok isn't real, what if Nihili is the person who's PRETENDING to be him, creating illusions? Idk LOL
This is the reason why I love crazy theories. They really get your imagination running
I don’t rlly believe Elizabeth is alive but I f-Ing hope she is 😭 I love her so much
Interessantes Video. Im Norden von Jorvik ist noch ein Dorf namens Meander(das Fawncy kommt dorther)
Was mich auch noch interessiert ist ob es noch mehr Pferde mit blauen Mähnen wie Starshine gibt(evtl Leben die ja irgendwo im noch nicht zugänglichen Gebiet)
Was es mit dem Yeti im Dinotal auf sich hat
Der Zweck der Fridgedoors
Das Bild auf dem Boden vom Geheimen Steinkreis
Die Hoffnung dass die kalter zurückkehren.
Haben wir WIRKLICH Anne befreit?(Bereich den man noch nicht entdecken kann Gefängnis in Pandoria wo Anne eingesperrt ist)
Okay I may have had some german in middle school but I'm lost 😳
@@eleanornightwalker You can translate It. Google translator
@@eleanornightwalker This is a translation of some sorts (i am dutch so my german isn’t exactly perfect either but i hope it will help)
Interesting video. In the north of Jorvik is also a village named Meander (the Fawncy comes from there)
I'm also interested in whether there are more horses with blue manes like starshine (maybe they live somewhere in an area that is not accessible yet)
What the yeti in Dinovalley is all about (not sure about this translation)
The purpose of the fridgedoor
The picture on the floor of the secret stone circle
The hope that the kalter will return (not sure this is the best translation)
Have we really freed Anne (area that cannot be discovered yet, prison in Pandoria where Anne is imprisoned
sorry i'm so late- But this was posted on my bday this year oop
Me, new to sso, lvl 15 and not rushing the quests: oh man I'm sure this theory video won't spoil anything to me, the story seemed kinda slow anyway :)
The video: so basicislly Elizabeth explodes
Me: 😶
I do have a a theory are we the next leader of Aideen wat happens if frip dies he was already in an in a coma and almost dead.
Theory by Lily Majorhope.
ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!~!
Hello!!
Hi!
holy fuck i've never seen your face before - you look great tho!
Thanks, I had a face reveal last week
who is elisebeth?
Second
But im hops at she liver
The thing about Garnok not being real, I honestly have no evidence. Have you ever seen this video btw? It's like some sort of horse ritual- I'm very confused by it, but you can like- chat with Garnok and he says some weird things. If that's supposedly a memory, which looks like it is then maybe Garnok is real? If there are people in cloaks trying to summon him or something, he must be real right? I still have no evidence this is true because of course, it could all just be an allusion. Anywaysss, here is the vid: czcams.com/video/32Sx9TC6tUI/video.html
third
I know I’m pretty late but the house in Ashland is actually the old house from Elizabeth, they probably planned something with Elizabeth in ashland back then