Dr. Jennifer Ashton On The Science Behind IVF Ruling, Wendy Williams' Diagnosis | The View
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 02. 2024
- GMA3's Dr. Jennifer Ashton weighs in on the Alabama court ruling that embryos are children and discusses the impact it has had on IVF treatments: "We need to stick with the science... What's referred to as a child, a fetus, an embryo in the lay public actually is inaccurate and incorrect when you talk about medicine."
Subscribe to our CZcams channel: bit.ly/2Ybi4tM
MORE FROM 'THE VIEW':
Full episodes: abcn.ws/2tl10qh
Twitter: / theview
Facebook: / theview
Instagram: / theviewabc - Zábava
So happy this doctor is finally putting Sunny’s heels to the fire with a lot of stuff she claims to know, but doesn’t.
She managed to do exactly what Ana and Sarah tried to do to Sunny the last time they'd spoken about this topic.
@jhonathannewell6805. sunny lets her religious beliefs get in the way. She has as much as said so.
It will become a toddler eventually, but Republicans want that to be planted in your mind that that is what they’re doing is killing babies, or killing children. What they’re doing is dealing with things that are microscopic in size.
I have to defend Sunny on this one. She’s only ever said she’s pro-life because she’s Catholic and believes life begins at conception. She’s never said that’s a fact. Just her personal belief.
True... sunnt buckles under facts..even though sunny keeps bragging i bring receipts i bring receipts
Sunny irked me so much with these questions. People really think they know more than doctors on the issue.
The doctor said she respect that Sunny believes that an embryo is a baby even though it’s not scientifically accurate. It’s the very first thing she intimated.
And Sunny’s married to a doctor so wonder what his opinion is.
You know how to turn off your TV. 😳
But if she has these questions maybe others have them too. Why get annoyed if the questions can be properly answered?
Sunny is becoming incredibly problematic for normal-minded democratic-believing people. Her diamonds are proof in the pudding.
Wow, this doctor is really good. Not only she fought back on wrong information and narrative but she actually gave consturctive examples of why they are incorrect. She should visit the panel more often.
Jennifer was rude and disrespectful
@@Tonetare Why? Cause she spoke out with Scientific facts and a medical perspective while also differentiating from scientific facts and Personal beliefs? Personal beliefs do not make it fact or true. It makes it a personal choice, like following any religion of one's choice.
@@Tonetare How exactly? She presented medical FACTS and SCIENTIFIC information, not some religious feelings wrapped inside an individual's faith. FACTS, that as she mentioned come from nearly 10yrs of post-graduate study. When a Dr. tells you that you have a cold or a broken leg or cancer 99.999% of people believe them, but the second this question is raised, now that same Dr. is wrong because their MEDICALLY-BASED opinion isn't what the bible-thumper doesn't want to hear. You can't have it both ways!
When does life begin?
@@Tonetare LOLOLOL. Because she told the MEDICAL truth and not some religious nonsense?
Sunny please listen, call your embryo before or after implanting, what YOU want and believe. Don’t make me define my embryos the way you want. Please, please!
So can we tell a women when she has a miscarriage to stop crying and get back to work since she was not carrying a child?
@@akwumba1- a miscarriage is horrendous and physically awful, but an embryo doesn’t have a heart, a brain a body. There is a lot of hope with an embryo but it doesn’t make it a baby.
@@bcent5758 why is it awful? Just a clump of cells. Doesn't have a heart, brain or anything so why you acting like it's something bad?
@akwumba1 Because its still trauma to their body, mind, and for some their soul? How is this even a question?.Having a child is more than just giving birth and going throughr pregnancy, its also expectation, preparation and commitment during the pregnancy and AFTER the birth.
Which is what this doctor was explaining. Each woman at each step and stage may be experiencing a totally different reality, and mentality and that's THEIR struggle. But you cannot blanket it. You also cannot blanket the unique physical traumas of a miscarriage.
Intentionally being obtuse in such a clear, important, and traumatic medical situation is not only pathetic and embarrassing...it actually completely invalidates the ridiculous point you're trying to sarcastically make.
@@unbothered5240 why are you mentioning child? You said it's not one. Sounds like you want to say what is in her body is a child but refuse to recognize it as such. If it's just a clump of cells this doesn't require your mind body and soul as you mentioned.
If an abortion and a miscarriage are so bad and so traumatic that means what they are carrying is indeed a human. You can't claim it's a big deal but then claim it's just a clump cells or medical situation. If someone kills a 2 month pregnant mother on her way to an abortion clinic a double murder? You can't have your cake and eat it too.
Thank you DOCTOR!!! Sunny is so annoying. Sunny you are an attorney not a medical doctor!
Meanwhile, she IS married to one.......... Sigh..............
But her husband is one, isnt that close enough?
I agree with you! Sunny is so irritating and rude. Now she's pretending to be a doctor!? That woman is a narcissist. I can't wait till she leaves that show. Sunny is NOT a doctor!
@@j.d.contreras392 Sunny pretends to be a lot of things. Let’s not forget her roots. I know it’s bad to dwell on that, but she’s so petty and you know she would.
istg I'm about to stop watching because of Sunny. She's lost it
Thank you doctor for politely shutting down Sunny’s simple minded assessments. Her knowledge of biology is limited
and the doctor is a practitioner, not a scientist. Most biologists believe that life begins at conception/fertilization. Please do your research. From the National Library of Medicine:
Biologists from 1,058 academic institutions around the world assessed survey items on when a human's life begins and, overall, 96% (5337 out of 5577) affirmed the fertilization view
@@angelinamccarvillestop spamming lady
@@angelinamccarville That's a red herring. As the Doctor said, there is no guarantee that a life will result from an embryo.
@@angelinamccarville you are misrepresenting, they believe life begins there but they don't believe it's equivalent to a baby, child, etc. your cells are alive but you won't hold a funeral for them. Just because you can acknowledge something is alive does not automatically give it the quality of humaness that we protect.
@@angelinamccarville You are referring to the Jacob's study about when life begins: Altogether, 62,469 academic biologists were recruited through e-mail. Of those, 5,502 biologists actually provided answers to the question, which is a paltry 9% response rate. The survey IS NOT EVEN CLOSE to being representative of all biologists. It's a complete farce. Yet pro-lifers keep citing this paper like it's the truth without even knowing how bad the survey was conducted and how loaded the question was. This study was based on an improper survey method and does not carry any statistical or scientific weight. It is like asking 100 people about their favorite sport, finding out that only the 37 football fans bothered to answer, and declaring that 100% of Americans love football. Complete nonsense.
Sunny Hostin got on my nerves in this segment 🙄
on every segment!!!
she gets on my nerves every segment, every day
I really like it. By saying what Sunny said, the professional got the chance to answer the emotional question and firmly tell it how it is. That in turn helps others who think like Sunny.
She has the right to question for enlightenment y’all.
Her slave owning Roots came out
DOCTOR Jennifer Ashton was so professional. She even offered a preamble on how she respects everybody’s personal and religious views on when they consider life begins before giving us SCIENTIFIC facts. And there you have Sunny Hostin acting like she is the messenger of the pope, looking completely ignorant and out of place, questioning a doctor that is trying to give a scientific and medical, expert opinion with religious mumbo-jumbo. Child!
I really appreciated her stance, too. She was empathetic, but stuck to her guns, and stayed in the lane of science/medicine.
So can we tell a women when she has a miscarriage to stop crying and get back to work since she was not carrying a child?
Having spent 100K+ on 5 IVFs, it is cells that are transferred NOT embryos - they transfer 200+ cells hoping that 1 or 2 will become embryos and attach to the uterus wall and grow with proper medical nourishment into fetus and after 14 weeks woman knows for sure that she is pregnant and carrying a child even though she is told that IVF is successful and she is pregnant in 2 weeks as cells are not rejected after the procedure - As Dr. Jen tried to explain and if Sunny allowed not to inject her beliefs, it is multi-step process and not a life form unless Alabama residents are trying to treat man's serum as God-like and not be wasted
@@akwumba1That's Harsh!!!!
@@akwumba1That’s a misrepresentation of what she’s saying and something no one believes. If someone gets pregnant intentionally or even unintentionally but they decide they’d like a baby, it’s OF COURSE sad when they miscarry. That doesn’t change the fact that *scientifically speaking,* it isn’t a baby or a fetus at 2 months.
FINALLY! Someone calling sunny out on her bs!
Jennifer should not be invited back for her rude conduct
Dr. Jen Ashton told Sunny Hostin right 👏👏👏👏
About time someone put her in her place. She is such a know it all
Sunny still thinks an embryo is a child!! i do feel sorry for her children!
Sunny seemed like she wanted to argue
Sunny needs to educate herself before speaking and interrupting the specialist.
She is soooo annoying.
I think that's why she's asking the Dr. So that she and others that have those questions get their answer from a professional
She's asking so that she can be educated. You can't be serious with this comment.
@shabbyLaw It was quite obvious that she had a different understanding of it
Sunny got owned 😅
Loved every second
Thank you Dr. Jen for nicely advising people to stop being non credentialed doctors. Going to medical school and studying for years and practicing, makes one an expert in medical field and people who haven’t gone through that shouldn’t be giving medical advice.
the doctor is a practitioner, not a scientist. Most biologists believe that life begins at conception/fertilization. Please do your research. From the National Library of Medicine:
Biologists from 1,058 academic institutions around the world assessed survey items on when a human's life begins and, overall, 96% (5337 out of 5577) affirmed the fertilization view
@@angelinamccarvilletake your religion out of here.
@@vinny7114 I’m just relaying a fact. And the fact is that an overwhelming majority of biologists will tell you that life begins at fertilization/conception. I’m sorry if that offends you.
@@angelinamccarville did you even read the full paper, or did you only read the abstract?
@@angelinamccarville If a doctor builds a medical device and scientifically tests it, she's also scientist.
The voice of sanity! Thank you Jen! Beliefs and facts: different!
Science doesn’t care what you believe. Science and healthcare should be practiced by science and medical professionals not politicians or religious zealots.
Yes Dr. Jen Ashton 👏👏👏👏
Dr. Jen Ashton got Sunny Hostin together in this segment 💯
This is why church and state should remain separated--national policies in a free society should be based on facts, not religious beliefs.
"Stay in your lane." YOU TELL EM, GIRL!
For someone like Sunny who has studied law, cases and facts, it’s incredibly annoying how she can’t understand FACTS when it comes to medicine and science. You can’t interpret facts however you wish because you want to make it fit your narrative or give you some type of peace. Well done Doctor!
Joy stole my heart when she ended the segment that way hahaha
Thank you Doctor! Give credit to Sarah Haines she communicated what you said this past week
I love Dr Jen!!! She kept it professional and was extremely thorough in what she said about embryos.
The way that doctor put Sunny in her place regarding her emotional, non-scientific, religious, nonsensical beliefs 👏👏👏👏
She shut Sunny up. Good!
The doctors statement that alcohol is not good for the brain is short and sweet and true
The view needs to add her to the rotation of guests. She’s meant for this. They have a lawyer now get a doctor
“It was a thorough report, but some things missing” lol
This Doctor was so respectful of everyone's beliefs and thinking and then proceeded to give scientific facts. now, if you choose not to believe them that's okay as well as she said , she was not there to say who was right and who was wrong but give facts and you do with them as you wish....
Potentiality is not actuality. It's an argument old as time, and better minds used to prevail.
Finally someone put sunny in her place...
Ooohhh baby this Dr shook the table
What's with sunny and those questions? girl, drop it already
Sunny wanted her opinion to be fact. She's a lawyer after all, they know how to twist and turn.
Very refreshing to hear an expert talking about this.
“THERE WERE SOME GLARING OMISSIONS!!!”
Absolutely right, doctor! Absolutely right!
This, other than Sunny being out in her place, was my favorite part. The doctor was fair and not hiding that there are some important medical info missing from Bidens exam reports. Most others would try to gaslight us and basically lie or omit. I would like her to come back on.
If Biden wasn't in cognitive decline it would have been included.
Sunny Hostin really is going hard about this topic
The producers knew Sonny would be sitting next to Dr. Ashton, where the camera could show both of them in the same shot.
I love seeing eloquent, knowledgeable women! You go DR!!
Leave your religion out of it...Sunny. Tell the pope, too.
Uhhh I’m sorry, it’s called freedom of speech for EVERYONE
Dr. Jennifer Ashton is fabulous in clearly communicating truth and experience from an expert!! Mahalo😇
I liked this segment the doctor explained it so well about embryos there is a lot I didnt know I learned a lot ❤
Sunny, stick to the law. 🙄
What Sunny doesn't seem to understand is that a million things have to go right for that to become a viable baby. 1 thing goes wrong and it doesn't. That doesn't remove the emotional component, which is what Sunny is focusing on. Emotions don't equate fact
It’s a “NO” Sonny 😂
I see many comments about Sunny being annoying, but I actually think she asked those questions on purpose because that’s how many people out there feel. It was good to hear from an actual professional answer those questions. So if she was being pushy to me that represents all of the other pushy people out there who believe the same thing she does.
Why don't IVF centers use the accurate language and refer to blastocyst implantation. It would help educate the public and patients.
I was intrigued by how Dr. Ashton remarked that there were " glaring omissions" in Biden's released medical report. I'm no medical professional, but hearing that from one certainly confirmed my suspicions.
So true I glad Doctor explained that cells dont have heart beat, not a baby when the science and medical has knowlege.❤
Let me ask this, did Sunny go to her church for an IVF or a hospital?
You want to bring religion into something that is clearly a scientific procedure. Heck, even the act of sex is scientific.
She needs to leave her beliefs out the door when discussing reproductive topics before she goes in again saying "Everyone knows I'm a Catholics and that I'm against abortion, but my attorney-sides says that it should be legal". She always says that. Why not just got on what your professional take, we don't care about your religion nor beliefs.
And her husband is a Dr.!!
All y'all commenting on how Sunny is "annoying" when she's just bringing up the same opinions that other ignorant people bring up. That's the point of the show. Thanks for the clarification, and FACTS, doctor!
Sunny is a pain bc she thinks she knows it all in all areas!😮😮😮
It’s not what she asked it’s how she asked it. There was no impartiality to it, it had a religious push behind it, trying to create some sort of gotcha moment on the Doctor. Sunny as a lawyer should know better than to ask any questions with a loaded agenda, her bias was showing and that doesn’t make for good journalism.
This doctor is a practitioner, not a scientist. Most biologists believe that life begins at conception/fertilization. Please do your research. From the National Library of Medicine:
Biologists from 1,058 academic institutions around the world assessed survey items on when a human's life begins and, overall, 96% (5337 out of 5577) affirmed the fertilization view
@@angelinamccarville That's a red herring. As the Doctor said, there is no guarantee that a life will result from an embryo.
The issue for me was she wouldn't allow the doctor to finish a thought or sentence with her interruptions trying to push her POV on the issue. People also deserve to hear the facts. I wanted to hear a doctors POV nor Sunnys which we hear daily.
Sunny, oh snap! Go back and listen to this and again. 2:50
She did a good job. Nice to see an expert be professional and objective.
Thank you!!!!
Loved 🥰 how Sara let the Dr say exactly what she already said then sipped her tea ☕ 🤣
We need this doctor on the show, give her a seat 😊
She’s there doctor basically for abc .
Thank you 👏🏆
Sonny played into her belief!!! but it needed to be asked and stated!! SO MANY others out here NEEDED to HEAR THIS!!!! SO glad yall bought a DR on!!! She needs to speak on the Congress FLOOR and INFORM them TOO!!!
This doctor is amazing . Invite her back !
When she said science, I would have looked at sunny…. 🙄🙄
Love this❤
Alabama is absolutely Wrong! Learn about Science and the medical facts!🧑🎓
AMEN! Thank You!
Sonny Hostin got seriously corrected from her previous statements on what is an embryo and looking rather foolish for it. When one tries to be a doctor and isn't one....
Great topic.
Love what you say Doc, stay in your lane Sunny!
A layperson should never debate a practitioner about matters in her own wheelhouse.
Praying for Wendy.....
Doctor Ashton did an awesome job explaining this. To bad so many still cant get it through their brain
The dr explained very well scientific terminology is different than the lay person for a reason. IVF only happen because of the advance in science so give the scientist the decision how to regulate the process
THANK YOU DR ASHTON!!! It don't matter what YOU feel Sunny!
I think you will find that those in support of elective pregnancy termination rely on feelings to support their argument more than those who are against elective pregnancy termination.
@@moretactell that to the pricks standing outside abortion clinics with signs yelling at patients as they walk in
Wendy is not driving herself to the store buying herself alcohol this should be criminal to provide her with alcohol
Thank you Dr. Ashton! Science and fact are different from religion and feelings.
"A ball of cells" that's such a disregard for human life. There's no guarantee that your child will live even if you carry the child full term. There's no guarantees with pregnancy period, so that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be considered a child because of that.
Yes!!!!!!!! The unborn human, is human because his or her parents are human. All of the genetic information from the parents as to what this new person will look like as an adult human is present when the father’s sperm fertilized the mother’s egg. For example height, gender, hair color, eye color, and more.
@@michelleo4612 LOL. But NONE of those things can be possible until MANY steps have taken place? Did you not hear the Dr. or do those MEDICAL FACTS not jive with what you want to believe to be true?? Are you drunk?
But the entire point the Dr. made was it's NOT a human life until all the steps she mentioned have taken place. Do you also think the world is flat?? You totally missed her point!
Fact and Science the kind of Doctor I like
This is so random but my girl Sara and Dr. Ashton could be distant cousins lol
I thought she was Sara when I first seen the clip. Lol
God bless you all and your family
Anna cracked me up with the Margarita question. A little levity never hurt. 😅
I found it a bit tacky since they were just discussing Wendy
THANK YOU DOC!!!!!!! It’s a ball of cells. No heart beat, no movement, NOT a fetus, NOT an embryo, NOT a baby in any medical way.
On February 11, 2017, two weeks after the divorce was finalized, her husband Robert, 52, died by suicide by jumping off the George Washington Bridge. And a few years later Ashton became engaged to Boston Red Sox chairman Tom Werner in January 2022. She's terrible 😮😮😮😮
Oh Babeeeeee Sonny got READ😂😂😂
I love smart people.
❤❤❤❤ Dr Ashton!!! What a great explanation.
Good Dr Jen.... believe in the science...love it...
Dr. Ashton is incredible.
I find it interesting that Wendy is suffering with two diseases that affect her ability to communicate after having the type of career she enjoyed.
Karma is a real thing.
She is an alcoholic and uses other drugs so thats a main cause but yeah she is mean spirited and highly narcisistic so yeah karma is real there is a God and he disciplines with karma Agree!!!
I do understand Sunny, because at the end of the day if this embryo goes through the entire process, it does become a child 🤷🏼♀️ that’s why she reacts that way. ❤
That is a huge "if," though. And since these blobs of cells are discarded, or can be discarded, BEFORE the entire process, no one should be giving them personhood or saying that they're a child.
She's entitled to have whatever feelings she has about an embryo. But that's where it ends. No one, and certainly no government, should be interfering in what should be a woman's right to bodily autonomy.
BTW, I think Sunny is being disingenuous, as she frequently invokes her faith, but has gone through IVF herself. The Catholic Church does not condone it at all.
@@user-ci1bd3kg8vI get it’s just a woman thing, just knowing that it can become a child, that’s all it is. Everything else is logical as well…the if’s are hard though, we humans are stubborn. Have a good day!!
IF being the operative word
It's so stunning, as educated as Sunny is, how she digs her heels in on the pro-life issue, she's a lawyer/litigator and she has such massive blinders on in this issue, thankfulky this doc can at least have her concede to reason and not preach from the bible regarding LEGISLATIVE issues, crazy, thankful for this balanced, nuanced segment
She knows the law, but obviously has not invested time in learning basic human anatomy, physiology and reproduction.
Sunny like all anti-abortion people feels like she has the right to force others to conform to her personal beliefs
Fax
Can we like stop everything here and talk about the fact that Joy Behar is 81 years old??? Like wtf.
Why is the sales pitch for abortion, women’s rights?
Didn’t know all women are capable of pregnancy I had assumed there was a biological factor called menopause
The Dr was getting so annoyed with Sunny, LOL. but you know at least Sunny is representing some of the American public who believe that a bunch of cells is a baby.
Great job Dr Ashton.
Nope sunny is right not the Dr
@@chris-gx7rs Sunny is not a Dr
thank you Dr. Jennifer Ashton!
Sing it, Dr. Ashton! I agree with what she said. The government and religious zealots need to leave their opions and beliefs outta the decisions of any medical care, and let the doctors decide the best options of care for any procedures. Whether it be abortions, ivf, health conditions, diseases, etc.
I like Sunny however she comes across as the type of person who wants to be right all the time 👀it’s okay to listen and learn from other experts sis.
Gender of the doctor doesn't matter. It's the competence in skill and knowledge
Very smart woman. People like are the ones that should be making these decisions!
Joy is so funny 😂
Love Dr. jen💕
Really appreciate having an actual professional on about life cycles. Because sonny speaking as if sje knows is the worst. She gives credit to these ridiculous bills
It's not a bill though. It's a ruling on a specific lawsuit.
She must be insufferable to live with. I pray for whomever her children end up marrying.
@sweetsarah27 you miss the point. Sonny speaks like sje knows and she has zero clue because of her religious bias. She's an absolute vile person when it comes to life. She adds to the pain and suffering surrounding women's rights in this country
Please have Dr. Mike on