After I read about Islam for about a year , I found out that it's doctrine is the most moderate. It takes a central stand in almost everything. Take prayer for example . One extreme is to not pray and other is to abandon everything and just pray (monasticism) . Islam is at mid .
Muhammad (PBUH) is a model of very high personal integrity, compassion for all human beings and all living beings and patience in the face of extreme adversity.
Are you talking about mohamed the mechanic or mohamed the butcher. He even ordered the mass killing of man's best friend (dogs). Pietermartizburg KZN South Africa
@@guzwa2334 You are mistaken. There is a famous hadith that you may not have seen. Hadith 3:551, “Allah’s Apostle said, ‘While a man was walking he felt thirsty and went down a well and drank water from it. On coming out of it, he saw a dog panting and eating mud because of excessive thirst. The man said, ‘This (dog) is suffering from the same problem as that of mine. So he went down again into the well, filled his shoe with water, caught hold of it with his teeth, and climbed up and watered the dog. Allah thanked him for his good deed and forgave him.’ The people asked, ‘O Allah’s Apostle! Is there a reward for us in serving animals?’ He replied, “Yes, there is a reward for serving any animal.”
Islam is Peace, and one of Allah's names and attributes is Al-Salam (Peace). Allah Almighty said: "Fight in the cause of Allah ˹only˺ against those who wage war against you, And do not transgress (1) Allah does not like transgressors." Al-Baqarah :190 (Qur’an) Salam Alaikum, Peace to everyone
I'm reading a book caĺled The preaching of Islam by Thomas Walker Arnold where he explains soft power and great values were behind the expansion of the religion. Wars were never a significant factor in the state expansion.
@@Overthetop438 Mohammed and his army after he moved to Medina fought some 95 military expeditions. Practically that means that they were at war all the time in those last 10 years of Mohammed's life. Fighting war all the time would normally be perceived as hard power. And we know that Abu Bakr straight after Mohammed died fought the Ridda wars as too many subjects wanted to leave Mohammed's empire.
I can’t thank you enough for sharing this and the rest of your works. I’ll pray to God/Allah to guide us all through your works. I’m in love with works and may it spread to countless of people from across the globe thus may foster understanding and tolerance!
Islam did not become a majority religion in the conquered areas until about the 900s. Which shows it took centuries for people to convert to Islam, which also shows people gradually converted by their own free will. The same simply can’t be said about how Christianity was spread, where we know for a fact that Christianity was spread by the sword.
Muslims didn’t become a majority in the Levant until the 1270s onwards. The Christians were practically 50% until the 13 century. So shows us muslims were very tolerant to the Christian population.
Yes, Christianity was spread by the sword during the Late Antiquity and Medieval period and after. But, this was much less the case before the influence of the tradition of Gnosticism. This tradition is where the claim that arguing against their interpretation of scripture is a sign of Satan's influence on the person arguing against them. You will find many Christian denominations have absorbed this influence, and I have little doubt that its thanks to the Byzantine turn in Roman imperialism that aspects of Gnosticism were retained. Before Rome became Christian, Christianity spread because a kinder alternative to Roman rule was being searched for by many imperial citizens in the East and West. After, the political circumstance of needing to defend existing power structures became a prerogative to be more imperialistic in spreading the message of Scripture.
Sure you can jump 1400 years if it suits you and ignore the 600-present era of violent Islam if it also suits you lala land people It seems in lala land History starts with Columbus dicovering America in the West and after Turkey fell in the East, all the way ignoring the Islamic State, Qaeda, Boko Haram, and oh I don't have the time to list them all.
@@nukeplatine We believe the first 3 generations to be the best, the coming generations are further from Islam than the first 3. Therefore the transgressions of the later groups don't represent Islam. For Christians it's the opposite, Trinitarians believe that the first generations were misguided and those who followed Nicean Trinity had it right.
Thank you, Bro. Paul for this and all your videos. Just love the appreciation for scholarship by these open minded historians and authors. May the Rahmatulil 'Alameen be understood for the blessing he truly is.
@@BloggingTheology it's easy , go to youtube studio then click on the video that you want to use the subtitles on , then when you get into it you will see an option which is " subtitles " click on it then add the languages that you want to use , you can upload a subtitle file but you just click on translate automatically and check if there's any mistakes on those subtitles . i hope you got the point and i hope it'll help you
@@BloggingTheology oh and that option of " subtitles " is on the left if you couldn't find it , and here's the link for youtube studio : studio.youtube.com/
So prior to watching this video I had some things in my mind that I would write in comments thinking you might not have covered them or misunderstood them. Only to find out you have addressed those issues better than I could. Love love love ❤️
Muhammad peace be upon is the greatest human being ever born in this world. There was no human being like him and there will be no human being like him in the future. I love him more than anyone in this world including my parents and myself. Trillion salutations to my beloved prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.💘 ❤ 🌹 💐
@@inaaranur1611 The same Quran has mentioned Allah has given somep prophets more virtues compared to others but as you said we should not degrade one prophet to boast another and no one is doing that here.
Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death). Sahih Bukhari 7:62:6 This hadiths tells us that Mohammed at the age of 54 years raped little Aisha when she was a little girl of only 9 years old. So how is a rapist of a little girl the "greatest human being ever born"?
@@johnzuma4688 You know sahih Buhari is not Quran and some references are either weak or not authentic there and everything said there should be compared with Quran. Also, this is the sickness of West and your missionary preachings and written over 1000 books to present the prophet Muhammad peace be upon in negative way. At the beginning and at the end of the day, the greatest prophet Muhammad peace be upon him lives in my heart and I love him more than all the humans on this earth. All his actions are and will be a way to paradise.
@@pashtoonkhan8548 So you are telling me that you do not know that Sahih Bukhari hadiths are considered to be most reliable? And that Sahih Bukhari is the second best source after the Quran? Are you really so ignorant or are you hoping that I am? And you do know that Sahih Bukhari is not a book written in the West or by missionaries, it is written by a follower of Mohammed who is considered a most reliable source. So if a bias person like Bukhari says that Mohammed at the age of 54 years had sex with little Aisha when she was only a little girl of 9 years, then please tell me why I should not consider that to be true? We read in Sahih Muslim 8:3311 >> 'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married her when she was seven years old, and he was taken to his house as a bride when she was nine, and her dolls were with her; and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old.
“ The Quran contain a doctrine of a just war, but not of holy war... it views war as an unfortunate necessity when innocents and freedom of conscience are threatened... “ Wow! Very well written. And I appreciate your commentary a lot sir. Your accent is very interesting to listen.
@@johnzuma4688 By that logic how about you explain the Roman Empire and the Papal States. Not to mention the crusades. Independent monarchs don’t represent a religion. But if you were honest you wouldn’t even have been asking this question. Goes to show.
@Sovereign OK In fact the Muslim occupation of Spain was much more horrible than the Spanish inquisition that followed after the Muslims were defeated in Spain and thrown out of Spain. The inquisition took place over some 350 years and accounted for about 5000 executions. The Muslim occupation of Spain took place over some 800 years and led to many hundred of thousands of death. So as the horror of the Muslim occupation ended so did the oppression of occupiers and the was to get rid of them.
i just hope that most none Muslims would read these amazing books rather than accusing our Prophet phub and Islam as religion of violence . thanks for sharing.
Non-Muslims read the Quran and find it full of verses like Surah 9:29. What conclusion are they supposed to reach when they read this verse? Surah 9:29 >> Fight against those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth [i.e., Islām] from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah1 willingly while they are humbled.
@Sovereign OK “I was sent with the sword .., until Allah alone is worshiped with no associates. My sustenance has been placed beneath the shade of my spear.
@Sovereign OK YOu missed the fact that the tafsier states that it is still valid today. Oh and nothing in Surah 9:29 says anything about dealing with someone who attacks you. It clearly states that followers of Mohammed should fight Christians and Jews. No reason reason given why only the demand that they do. And we see that the early Islamic armies invaded and occupied Christian territories without being attacked by them.
@@johnzuma4688 well there is truly nothing I did to prove that. It is all in their sources. Islam is based on daawaganda, and when faced with the facts quickly falls apart.
Mashallah Paul, this is an aspect of Muhammad (pbuh) that is seldom noticed by non-Muslims as well as Muslims: Muhammad the diplomat. From a diplomatic standpoint, it is nothing short of miraculous that Muhammad (pbuh) managed to ally not only all the Arab tribes, but also maintaining ties with the Byzantines and Ethiopians. It is a stroke of political genius. I must ask though, how many books do you read simultaneously at given time?
@@SuwarModiNoni for example bro... Allah is immortal! he is not nearly immortal! A woman can't be nearly pregnant! She is either pregnant or not! There is only one immortal being! and that's Allah s.w.a. 😊
Subhana Rabbi al A'laa. When unbias scholars reflect the truth onto the open hearted, a path appears. But those who their hearts and minds are closed are blinded by their own hatred. We muslim have been forbidden to hate the disbelievers for their disbelief, thus keep your hearts open.. Muslims have too lost their way, reverts some times pick the fruit from the tree and not the barrel.
Very fair and balanced analysis of the historical facts and proofs from the most authentic Scriptures. You are doing excellent intellectual work to let the facts speak themselves. Keep up the great work to guide the people into reality and the truth.
Thank you Paul, Muhammed (peace and blessings be upon him) is the only messenger/prophet sent to all mankind - as a mercy from God. "We have not sent you but as a mercy to all the world's" 21:107
@@BloggingTheology Well at least your bookshelf isn't immaculately tidy - a good indicator that you actually read the books but i haven't noticed any changes 🤔. Perhaps the occasional tidy up may solve this issue.
@@nukeplatine It is related. If you're, then whether peace is due or not is none of your business. Your business in this world is to be passive and submissive to the rulers o world( Romans 13) , and to not resist evil. Your job is to wait the messiah. That's all. Regarding the greatest man who has evere lived on this earth, the prophet peace be upon him “ *Never has a man proposed for himself, voluntarily or involuntarily, a goal more sublime, since this goal was beyond measure: undermine the superstitions placed between the creature and the Creator, give back God to man and man to God, reinstate the rational and saintly idea of divinity in the midst of this prevailing chaos of material and disfigured gods of idolatry.* *Never has a man accomplished in such a short time such an immense and long lasting revolution in the world, since less than two centuries after his predication, Islam, preaching and armed, ruled over three Arabias, and conquered to God’s unity Persia, the Khorasan, Transoxania, Western India, Syria, Egypt, Ethiopia, and all the known continent of Southern Africa, many islands of the Mediterranean, Spain and part of Gaul.* *If the grandeur of the aim, the smallness of the means, the immensity of the results are the three measures of a man’s genius, who would dare humanly compare a great man of modern history with Muhammad?* *The most famous have only moved weapons, laws, empires; they founded, when they founded anything, only material powers, often crumbling before them. This man not only moved armies, legislation, empires, peoples, dynasties, millions of men over a third of the inhabited globe; but he also moved ideas, beliefs, souls. He founded upon a book, of which each letter has become a law, a spiritual nationality embracing people of all languages and races; and made an indelible imprint upon this Muslim nation, for the hatred of false gods and the passion for the God, One and Immaterial.* *Philosopher, orator, apostle, legislator, warrior, conqueror of ideas, restorer of a rational dogma for a cult without imagery, founder of twenty earthly empires and of one spiritual empire, this is Muhammad.* *Of all the scales by which one measures human grandeur, which man has been greater* …” (Extract from Alphonse de Lamartine’s Histoire de la Turquie Paris, 1854, vol. II, pp. 276-277)
@@Khaledf well FIRST OF ALL, YOU don't get to tell me what I am or am not to do ^_^ Since the one you are following took the right to put his nose in Christian affairs, I get the right to put my nose in your Muslim affairs Second, your false claim that all I have to do is sit on my ass and wait for Christ to come back also has nothing to do with the TRUE FACT from YOUR MUSLIM SOURCES that your so called prophet is a butcher 'Nough said
Thank you Paul another great video .I will the order book . May Peace and blessings be upon Prophet Muhammad seal of the Prophets send to the whole world 🌎
I’m glad the Western world is learning what I learned when I was 7. “No Arab is above non Arab and no black over white or white over black” - Muhammad’s final sermon (PBUH)
Thank you for introducing me to this book. Will try to read it. Could you please recommend a biography of the Prophet Muhammad that makes a rational case for the unique nobility of the Prophet, especially in the context of other well regarded religious figures like the Buddha and Jesus? Many a times Muslims' reverence towards our Prophet is inherited from family and culture, and we are ignorant about the great qualities of our Prophet.
If only these christian missionaries were as dedicated to learning as they are to attacking other peoples religion. Alhamdullilah though, they strengthen my iman and make me thank Allah SWT that he granted me with a functioning brain. Lovely work as always Paul I can't get enough of your videos
What I love about the quran in all of the verses that talks about violence and when it can be used it always says that if they repent to let them be and even in some cases to look after them and take them To their ppl
Sir, i have been following your videos and my humble suggestion is pls keep your mike closer.. We find it very hard to listen to you.. We cant keep your channel at the background and listen but have to hold the mobile close to us which sometimes makes it hard.. Pls adjust your mike! Wish you all the best
Do you have any good books recommendation for topic of human evolution (Darwinism) in either Abrahamic believes (Jews, Christianity, Islam) perspective? Thank you.
On the subject of empires ... can you discuss the letter of the prophet pbuh to Heraclius... on the matter of Arius and Arianism. Where the Prophet clearly threatened Heraclius in his letter... “If you (Heraclius) turn away, you will bear the Arians’ sins” ... is this not a clear message that the council of Nicea was corrupt and Arius was killed by the Byzantine empire! This is as early as Christianity gets ! Its a core subject and I would love to hear your take on it... kind regards
Dear Bro Paul Is there any way to enable english caption of your video so that those who are deaf or lack of power hearing, able to read the caption. Regards and thanks.
One of the most important Hadith for the Prophet Muhammad PBUH for me is this Hadith Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: "When a son of Adam (i.e. any human being) dies his deeds are discontinued, with three exceptions: Sadaqah, whose benefit is continuous; or knowledge from which benefit continues to be reaped, or a righteous child who supplicates for him." [Reported by Muslim]. What is astonishingly in this Hadith is that it includes all humans and not only Muslims. The Prophet mentioned here son of Adam, it means everyone even the unbelievers. And this summarize the message of the Prophet to all mankind. For example if an Atheist came out with a science that benefit humanity, he will receive good deeds for his contribution to humanity when anyone in the future benefit from his science. You can’t find this in any religion, we don’t have this with any Prophet before. So a non believer who do charity like building a school for the poor he would still receive good deeds after his death, what an astonishing fact, here you would ask, what this will benefit him if he is not a believer, and this shows you some cracks of our Islamic understanding. Before, the Jews kept the religion for themselves, for their tribes, although Abraham had a massage for humanity and not only for the Jews, Christianity and Jesus came to correct this, and this is why Christianity expanded rapidly, but later altered and became the only option of Salvation, ie, other beliefs are all wrong. Islam came with the concept of including the Abrahamic faith, and expanded it to anyone one who believe in one God and Judgement day. With this hadith, it includes everyone even the non believers WHY The answer is simple, because God says the he will forgive even some of the non believers even and send them to heaven, especially who were good people in their life The concept here is not only the belief will save you only, your contribution to your society matters too
Juan Cole should know it was wahi, not a mystical experience that predicted the Byzantine victory and rejoicing. Mystical experience are distinct from wahi.
@Alex Ander It had to do with the divine Prophetic mission. For each Prophet the immediate nation was destroyed if they did not accept the truth, either by God or the adherents of the faith. Pharoah and the parting of the seas and 70 AD on rejection of Jesus as messiah.
Thank you for your studies dear Paul. There is scientists also i would like to say that it is impossible that the information that the Prophet bad was made up . At the time of the Prophet
Foretells the story of the chapter of"Al-Alak Isaiah 29:11-18“ And the vision of all is become unto you as the words of a book that is sealed,which[men]deliver to one that is learned,saying,Read this,I pray thee:and he saith,I cannot;for it[is]sealed:And the book is delivered to him that is not learned,saying,Read this,[Ipraythee]:and he saith,I am not learned.Where fore the Lord aid,For as much as this people draw near[me]with their mouth,and with their lips do honor me,but have removed their heart far from me,and their fear toward me istaught by the precept of men:There fore,behold,I will proceed to do a marvelous work among this people,[even]a marvelous work and a wonder:for the wisdom of their wise[men]shall perish,and the understanding of their prudent men shall be hid.Woe unto them that seek deep to hide their counsel from the LORD,and their works are in the dark,and they say,Who see thus?and who knoweth us?Surely your turning of things upside down shall be esteemed as the potter'sclay:for shall the work say of him that mad eit,He made me not?or shall the thing framed say of him that framed it,He had no understanding?[Is]it not yet a very little while,and Lebanon shall be turned into a fruitful field,and the fruit fulfield shall be esteemed as a forest And in that day shall the deaf hear the words of the book,and the eyes of the blind shall see out of obscurity,and out of darkness"
I want to bring your attention to De Lacy O’ Leary’s book “Islam at the cross road”. He said on page 8 that, “History makes it clear, that the legend of fanatical Muslims sweeping through the world and forcing Islam at the point of the sword upon conquered races, is one of the most fantastically absurd myths that historians have ever repeated”. Nine million Christians in Arab nations from generations is a witness to that. The whole of Indonesia becoming Muslim without a war ever taking place in that country is adding to that as well.
اللهم صلي على محمد و على اله محمد كما صليت على ابراهيم و على اله ابراهيم انك حميد مجيد اللهم بارك على محمد و على اله محمد كما باركت على ابراهيم و على اله ابراهيم انك حميد مجيد.
After I read about Islam for about a year , I found out that it's doctrine is the most moderate. It takes a central stand in almost everything. Take prayer for example . One extreme is to not pray and other is to abandon everything and just pray (monasticism) . Islam is at mid .
Muhammad (PBUH) is a model of very high personal integrity, compassion for all human beings and all living beings and patience in the face of extreme adversity.
A true model of discipline as well, mashaAllah.
Are you talking about mohamed the mechanic or mohamed the butcher.
He even ordered the mass killing of man's best friend (dogs).
Pietermartizburg KZN South Africa
@@guzwa2334
You are mistaken. There is a famous hadith that you may not have seen.
Hadith 3:551, “Allah’s Apostle said, ‘While a man was walking he felt thirsty and went down a well and drank water from it. On coming out of it, he saw a dog panting and eating mud because of excessive thirst. The man said, ‘This (dog) is suffering from the same problem as that of mine. So he went down again into the well, filled his shoe with water, caught hold of it with his teeth, and climbed up and watered the dog. Allah thanked him for his good deed and forgave him.’ The people asked, ‘O Allah’s Apostle! Is there a reward for us in serving animals?’ He replied, “Yes, there is a reward for serving any animal.”
@@guzwa2334
Clearly ignorant!!!! Get some education .imbecile !!
“Foot sack “ as they say in south africa!!!!
@@guzwa2334 Foot sack. Imbecile !
Happy to see this channel flourishing by leaps and bounds with researched content.. Masha ALLAH.. Rise and Shine sir.
Islam is Peace, and one of Allah's names and attributes is Al-Salam (Peace).
Allah Almighty said:
"Fight in the cause of Allah ˹only˺ against those who wage war against you, And do not transgress (1) Allah does not like transgressors." Al-Baqarah :190 (Qur’an)
Salam Alaikum, Peace to everyone
"the soft power of the Quran" some of the academics bring forward the nuances of the Quran in a beautiful way.
I'm reading a book caĺled The preaching of Islam by Thomas Walker Arnold where he explains soft power and great values were behind the expansion of the religion. Wars were never a significant factor in the state expansion.
You and I both!!!!!
😊😊😊
Currently reading chapter V.
War *was* a significant factor.
Although it can be said conversions happened much after the conquest.
Thank you for the book reference. Does it mention the influence of the Pact of Umar?
I'm conveying the author's view which I found it convencing. You may differ and precieve that hard power was the main factor.
@@Overthetop438 Mohammed and his army after he moved to Medina fought some 95 military expeditions. Practically that means that they were at war all the time in those last 10 years of Mohammed's life. Fighting war all the time would normally be perceived as hard power. And we know that Abu Bakr straight after Mohammed died fought the Ridda wars as too many subjects wanted to leave Mohammed's empire.
Thanks Paul for the review, definitely will buy this book 🙏😎
Hope you enjoy it!
Did you buy it?
I can’t thank you enough for sharing this and the rest of your works. I’ll pray to God/Allah to guide us all through your works. I’m in love with works and may it spread to countless of people from across the globe thus may foster understanding and tolerance!
What a wonderful reveal & share! Many thanks
Can’t wait to read it
Jzk
Hope you enjoy it!
@@BloggingTheologyit was beneficial for me to lisen...May Allah BLESS you
Islam did not become a majority religion in the conquered areas until about the 900s. Which shows it took centuries for people to convert to Islam, which also shows people gradually converted by their own free will. The same simply can’t be said about how Christianity was spread, where we know for a fact that Christianity was spread by the sword.
Oh my Trinitarian God. Christianity spread by the sword? You guys really are in Lala land.
Muslims didn’t become a majority in the Levant until the 1270s onwards.
The Christians were practically 50% until the 13 century.
So shows us muslims were very tolerant to the Christian population.
Yes, Christianity was spread by the sword during the Late Antiquity and Medieval period and after. But, this was much less the case before the influence of the tradition of Gnosticism. This tradition is where the claim that arguing against their interpretation of scripture is a sign of Satan's influence on the person arguing against them. You will find many Christian denominations have absorbed this influence, and I have little doubt that its thanks to the Byzantine turn in Roman imperialism that aspects of Gnosticism were retained. Before Rome became Christian, Christianity spread because a kinder alternative to Roman rule was being searched for by many imperial citizens in the East and West. After, the political circumstance of needing to defend existing power structures became a prerogative to be more imperialistic in spreading the message of Scripture.
Sure you can jump 1400 years if it suits you and ignore the 600-present era of violent Islam if it also suits you lala land people
It seems in lala land History starts with Columbus dicovering America in the West and after Turkey fell in the East, all the way ignoring the Islamic State, Qaeda, Boko Haram, and oh I don't have the time to list them all.
@@nukeplatine We believe the first 3 generations to be the best, the coming generations are further from Islam than the first 3. Therefore the transgressions of the later groups don't represent Islam.
For Christians it's the opposite, Trinitarians believe that the first generations were misguided and those who followed Nicean Trinity had it right.
Thank you, Bro. Paul for this and all your videos. Just love the appreciation for scholarship by these open minded historians and authors. May the Rahmatulil 'Alameen be understood for the blessing he truly is.
You are very welcome
thanks Paul , the next time can you use the subtitles please ? thanks in advance , may Allah bless you
I’d like to but I don’t know how to do it
@@BloggingTheology it's easy , go to youtube studio then click on the video that you want to use the subtitles on , then when you get into it you will see an option which is " subtitles " click on it then add the languages that you want to use , you can upload a subtitle file but you just click on translate automatically and check if there's any mistakes on those subtitles . i hope you got the point and i hope it'll help you
@@BloggingTheology oh and that option of " subtitles " is on the left if you couldn't find it , and here's the link for youtube studio : studio.youtube.com/
@@nathannate6817 thank you!
@@BloggingTheology don't mention it uncle
So prior to watching this video I had some things in my mind that I would write in comments thinking you might not have covered them or misunderstood them. Only to find out you have addressed those issues better than I could. Love love love ❤️
Great title MashAllah may Allah guide this truthful gentleman
I really appreciate your opinions and topics .bless u brother
thanks
This channel deserves way more subscribers. Thank you for your valuable content, and, please keep sharing your interesting views with us.
Many thanks
@@BloggingTheology you're most welcome.
Congrats on the 10 k, happy to watch this channel up trending,
thanks
Muhammad peace be upon is the greatest human being ever born in this world. There was no human being like him and there will be no human being like him in the future. I love him more than anyone in this world including my parents and myself. Trillion salutations to my beloved prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.💘 ❤ 🌹 💐
The Quran has said that one is not to hold one prophet above the other in any way
@@inaaranur1611 The same Quran has mentioned Allah has given somep prophets more virtues compared to others but as you said we should not degrade one prophet to boast another and no one is doing that here.
Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death).
Sahih Bukhari 7:62:6
This hadiths tells us that Mohammed at the age of 54 years raped little Aisha when she was a little girl of only 9 years old. So how is a rapist of a little girl the "greatest human being ever born"?
@@johnzuma4688 You know sahih Buhari is not Quran and some references are either weak or not authentic there and everything said there should be compared with Quran. Also, this is the sickness of West and your missionary preachings and written over 1000 books to present the prophet Muhammad peace be upon in negative way. At the beginning and at the end of the day, the greatest prophet Muhammad peace be upon him lives in my heart and I love him more than all the humans on this earth. All his actions are and will be a way to paradise.
@@pashtoonkhan8548 So you are telling me that you do not know that Sahih Bukhari hadiths are considered to be most reliable? And that Sahih Bukhari is the second best source after the Quran? Are you really so ignorant or are you hoping that I am?
And you do know that Sahih Bukhari is not a book written in the West or by missionaries, it is written by a follower of Mohammed who is considered a most reliable source. So if a bias person like Bukhari says that Mohammed at the age of 54 years had sex with little Aisha when she was only a little girl of 9 years, then please tell me why I should not consider that to be true?
We read in Sahih Muslim 8:3311 >> 'A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) married her when she was seven years old, and he was taken to his house as a bride when she was nine, and her dolls were with her; and when he (the Holy Prophet) died she was eighteen years old.
Jazak Allah Khair :)
Brother Paul once again beautiful topic yes indeed prophet Mohammed PBUH was sent as mercy to this world. May Allah bless u.
Love you posts, keep up with the Truth.
thanks
“ The Quran contain a doctrine of a just war, but not of holy war... it views war as an unfortunate necessity when innocents and freedom of conscience are threatened... “
Wow! Very well written. And I appreciate your commentary a lot sir. Your accent is very interesting to listen.
Muslims invaded and occupied Spain in 711 AD, How was that invasion and occupation of Non-Muslim territory just?
@@johnzuma4688 By that logic how about you explain the Roman Empire and the Papal States. Not to mention the crusades. Independent monarchs don’t represent a religion. But if you were honest you wouldn’t even have been asking this question. Goes to show.
@Sovereign OK In fact the Muslim occupation of Spain was much more horrible than the Spanish inquisition that followed after the Muslims were defeated in Spain and thrown out of Spain.
The inquisition took place over some 350 years and accounted for about 5000 executions. The Muslim occupation of Spain took place over some 800 years and led to many hundred of thousands of death. So as the horror of the Muslim occupation ended so did the oppression of occupiers and the was to get rid of them.
@@johnzuma4688
rewriting history....
@@Logia1978 Agreed, followers of a totalitarian ideology are generally very good at rewriting history to suit their version of events.
Peace be upon you sir
thanks for the video Sir much appreciation from turkey
Thanks for watching!
JazakAllahu Khairan Kathira...a much needed reference, amidst all the false claims about him SAW..
Really appreciate this... Alhamdulillah..
I've had this book on my list for a long while.
i just hope that most none Muslims would read these amazing books rather than accusing our Prophet phub and Islam as religion of violence .
thanks for sharing.
Non-Muslims read the Quran and find it full of verses like Surah 9:29. What conclusion are they supposed to reach when they read this verse?
Surah 9:29 >> Fight against those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth [i.e., Islām] from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah1 willingly while they are humbled.
@Sovereign OK Prepare against them whatever arms and weaponry you can muster so that you may terrorise them. They are your enemy and Allah's enemy
@Sovereign OK “I was sent with the sword .., until Allah alone is worshiped with no associates. My sustenance has been placed beneath the shade of my spear.
@Sovereign OK YOu missed the fact that the tafsier states that it is still valid today. Oh and nothing in Surah 9:29 says anything about dealing with someone who attacks you. It clearly states that followers of Mohammed should fight Christians and Jews. No reason reason given why only the demand that they do. And we see that the early Islamic armies invaded and occupied Christian territories without being attacked by them.
@@johnzuma4688 Syrah 9 starts at verse 1,how ignorant can you be?
In short and precise, Islam is a balance religion, in time of making the choice between the necessity of peace or war.
Please explain what you mean by a "balanced religion"?
If, as the propaganda claims, Muhammad was a prophet of peace, then he shouldn't wage war for any reason.
@@nukeplatine Thank you for proving that Mohammed was not the prophet of peace.
@@johnzuma4688 well there is truly nothing I did to prove that. It is all in their sources. Islam is based on daawaganda, and when faced with the facts quickly falls apart.
@@nukeplatine I fully agree with you.
Mashallah Paul, this is an aspect of Muhammad (pbuh) that is seldom noticed by non-Muslims as well as Muslims: Muhammad the diplomat.
From a diplomatic standpoint, it is nothing short of miraculous that Muhammad (pbuh) managed to ally not only all the Arab tribes, but also maintaining ties with the Byzantines and Ethiopians. It is a stroke of political genius.
I must ask though, how many books do you read simultaneously at given time?
Thank you for informing about the book...a rare unbiased analyse
Greatest man who ever lived!...
Subhan ALLAH👏🏻💕🌙
Person*
@@SuwarModiNoni "I'm nearly immortal" doesn't make sense! You either are ! Or not! There is no in-between.
@@adnankaba3372 how bro?
@@SuwarModiNoni for example bro... Allah is immortal! he is not nearly immortal! A woman can't be nearly pregnant! She is either pregnant or not! There is only one immortal being! and that's Allah s.w.a. 😊
Thank you mister Williams for the informations and your efforts ❤️
My pleasure!
Thank you sir for another great video, we Muslim believe that he was the mercy to the whole mankind, I salute you sir ❤️
True, in essence to all of universe, including the non living such such as rocks.
Peace be upon him
Asalamualikum brother. amazing topic, keep doing such great jobs.
Thank you, I will
We must not forget our respected Sheikh in our special Duas (supplications) for his long life with good health and wealth, Ameen!
Subhana Rabbi al A'laa. When unbias scholars reflect the truth onto the open hearted, a path appears. But those who their hearts and minds are closed are blinded by their own hatred. We muslim have been forbidden to hate the disbelievers for their disbelief, thus keep your hearts open..
Muslims have too lost their way, reverts some times pick the fruit from the tree and not the barrel.
Very fair and balanced analysis of the historical facts and proofs from the most authentic Scriptures. You are doing excellent intellectual work to let the facts speak themselves. Keep up the great work to guide the people into reality and the truth.
Subtitles 😅? ... great content and great references ... Paul thank you for the knowledge
Working on it!
Thank you Paul, Muhammed (peace and blessings be upon him) is the only messenger/prophet sent to all mankind - as a mercy from God.
"We have not sent you but as a mercy to all the world's" 21:107
Congrats for reaching 10k subs 👍
Thanks! 😃
When the prophet controlled Makka he said to his enemies, go you are free and safe.! إذهبوا فأنتم طلقاء
Makes me want to start reading books again but your packed bookshelf has made me think again. I don't think i have the space.
🤣😆
@@BloggingTheology Well at least your bookshelf isn't immaculately tidy - a good indicator that you actually read the books but i haven't noticed any changes 🤔. Perhaps the occasional tidy up may solve this issue.
@Jolene Thank for that I am not ..... but I do respect this man a lot
@@BloggingTheology Please Sir ... Can you send me an e-mail ... like that I can contact you please ?
@Alex Ander thanks! Context is important: czcams.com/video/7cqNqZFf-eE/video.html
Congratulations on the 10k subscribers 👏
Thank you! 😃
JazakAllah
Salam Alaykum, may Allah SWT bless you more!
You too
@@BloggingTheology Amin, thanks you are doing a great job.
@@adebowaleolowa4027 thank you
Congratulations 10k subscribers
Thank you so much 😀
back at it again with another infirmative video
barakallahu feek brother paul
The prophet peace be upon him is the prophet of peace when peace is due, and he peace be upon him is the prophet of war when war is due.
Exactly, and it seems peace was never due
@@nukeplatine Are you christian?
@@Khaledf what does me being Christ or not have to do anything with the butcherings of Muhammad, human Pieces he left behind him?
@@nukeplatine It is related. If you're, then whether peace is due or not is none of your business. Your business in this world is to be passive and submissive to the rulers o world( Romans 13) , and to not resist evil. Your job is to wait the messiah. That's all.
Regarding the greatest man who has evere lived on this earth, the prophet peace be upon him
“ *Never has a man proposed for himself, voluntarily or involuntarily, a goal more sublime, since this goal was beyond measure: undermine the superstitions placed between the creature and the Creator, give back God to man and man to God, reinstate the rational and saintly idea of divinity in the midst of this prevailing chaos of material and disfigured gods of idolatry.*
*Never has a man accomplished in such a short time such an immense and long lasting revolution in the world, since less than two centuries after his predication, Islam, preaching and armed, ruled over three Arabias, and conquered to God’s unity Persia, the Khorasan, Transoxania, Western India, Syria, Egypt, Ethiopia, and all the known continent of Southern Africa, many islands of the Mediterranean, Spain and part of Gaul.*
*If the grandeur of the aim, the smallness of the means, the immensity of the results are the three measures of a man’s genius, who would dare humanly compare a great man of modern history with Muhammad?*
*The most famous have only moved weapons, laws, empires; they founded, when they founded anything, only material powers, often crumbling before them. This man not only moved armies, legislation, empires, peoples, dynasties, millions of men over a third of the inhabited globe; but he also moved ideas, beliefs, souls. He founded upon a book, of which each letter has become a law, a spiritual nationality embracing people of all languages and races; and made an indelible imprint upon this Muslim nation, for the hatred of false gods and the passion for the God, One and Immaterial.*
*Philosopher, orator, apostle, legislator, warrior, conqueror of ideas, restorer of a rational dogma for a cult without imagery, founder of twenty earthly empires and of one spiritual empire, this is Muhammad.*
*Of all the scales by which one measures human grandeur, which man has been greater* …”
(Extract from Alphonse de Lamartine’s Histoire de la Turquie Paris, 1854, vol. II, pp. 276-277)
@@Khaledf well FIRST OF ALL, YOU don't get to tell me what I am or am not to do ^_^
Since the one you are following took the right to put his nose in Christian affairs, I get the right to put my nose in your Muslim affairs
Second, your false claim that all I have to do is sit on my ass and wait for Christ to come back also has nothing to do with the TRUE FACT from YOUR MUSLIM SOURCES that your so called prophet is a butcher
'Nough said
The final path is peace.
Thank you Paul another great video .I will the order book . May Peace and blessings be upon Prophet Muhammad seal of the Prophets send to the whole world 🌎
May Allah guide All of menkind
Great review in approx 11 minutes.
Glad you liked it!
I’m glad the Western world is learning what I learned when I was 7.
“No Arab is above non Arab and no black over white or white over black”
- Muhammad’s final sermon (PBUH)
Everyday i love him more, The Beloved ﷺ
"... distorted by the later islamic tradition" at 01:09 may be the most true statement in this video. Allah Bless you brother Paul!
I love u so much😭😭
Thank you for introducing me to this book. Will try to read it. Could you please recommend a biography of the Prophet Muhammad that makes a rational case for the unique nobility of the Prophet, especially in the context of other well regarded religious figures like the Buddha and Jesus? Many a times Muslims' reverence towards our Prophet is inherited from family and culture, and we are ignorant about the great qualities of our Prophet.
Yes - please see my latest video
@@BloggingTheology Thank you!
If only these christian missionaries were as dedicated to learning as they are to attacking other peoples religion. Alhamdullilah though, they strengthen my iman and make me thank Allah SWT that he granted me with a functioning brain. Lovely work as always Paul I can't get enough of your videos
Thank so much for your amazing channel.. Can someone please share thus video or mayve send a copy from this book to gordan Peterson!
Before saying " until next time " make some commentary of your owns. We would love hear that.
Allohumma shalli ala Sayyidina Muhammad wa ala alihi washahbihi wasallim
thank you
You're welcome
What I love about the quran in all of the verses that talks about violence and when it can be used it always says that if they repent to let them be and even in some cases to look after them and take them
To their ppl
SO MANY BOOKS IM BURIED AND ITS GREAT
Mashallah Salamun salam. Could you please do some video on linguistic miracles in Quran? Thanks.
good awesome thanks
Have you read Juan cole book or have you watched any of his videos on youtube about the prophet pbuh .highly recommended for hos academic work
Hi Paul, I have a more technical question regarding the setting of this particular video post. Why is the subtitles/cc turned off ?
I am trying to rectify this problem.
@@BloggingTheology Thank you vm. Have a nice weekend.
Sir, i have been following your videos and my humble suggestion is pls keep your mike closer.. We find it very hard to listen to you.. We cant keep your channel at the background and listen but have to hold the mobile close to us which sometimes makes it hard.. Pls adjust your mike! Wish you all the best
Do you have any good books recommendation for topic of human evolution (Darwinism) in either Abrahamic believes (Jews, Christianity, Islam) perspective? Thank you.
Allah❤Muhammad ❤Ali❤
Omar is more famous in inscription xD
The title of the book summirized it.
Salaam br Paul , will you return to speaker corner after lockdown ?
may Allah ( s.w.t ) eward you.
On the subject of empires ... can you discuss the letter of the prophet pbuh to Heraclius... on the matter of Arius and Arianism. Where the Prophet clearly threatened Heraclius in his letter... “If you (Heraclius) turn away, you will bear the Arians’ sins” ... is this not a clear message that the council of Nicea was corrupt and Arius was killed by the Byzantine empire! This is as early as Christianity gets ! Its a core subject and I would love to hear your take on it... kind regards
Arian sins?
3 dislikes. I wonder why?
@Sleem Mostafa 🥰
« Fain would they put out the light of God with their mouths, but God will perfect His light however much the disbelievers are averse. »Quran(61:8)
They are Paul supporter.
Have no idea why anybody would dislike any of your excellent work .!!
They have eyes than can't see, they have ears that can't hear and their hearts are sealed in ignorance...
Dear Bro Paul
Is there any way to enable english caption of your video so that those who are deaf or lack of power hearing, able to read the caption.
Regards and thanks.
I will try
@@BloggingTheology
Thanks
Brilliant
Thank you algerien
There will come a day when people will have the chance to defend these slanders.
One of the most important Hadith for the Prophet Muhammad PBUH for me is this Hadith
Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said: "When a son of Adam (i.e. any human being) dies his deeds are discontinued, with three exceptions: Sadaqah, whose benefit is continuous; or knowledge from which benefit continues to be reaped, or a righteous child who supplicates for him." [Reported by Muslim].
What is astonishingly in this Hadith is that it includes all humans and not only Muslims. The Prophet mentioned here son of Adam, it means everyone even the unbelievers. And this summarize the message of the Prophet to all mankind. For example if an Atheist came out with a science that benefit humanity, he will receive good deeds for his contribution to humanity when anyone in the future benefit from his science. You can’t find this in any religion, we don’t have this with any Prophet before. So a non believer who do charity like building a school for the poor he would still receive good deeds after his death, what an astonishing fact, here you would ask, what this will benefit him if he is not a believer, and this shows you some cracks of our Islamic understanding.
Before, the Jews kept the religion for themselves, for their tribes, although Abraham had a massage for humanity and not only for the Jews, Christianity and Jesus came to correct this, and this is why Christianity expanded rapidly, but later altered and became the only option of Salvation, ie, other beliefs are all wrong. Islam came with the concept of including the Abrahamic faith, and expanded it to anyone one who believe in one God and Judgement day. With this hadith, it includes everyone even the non believers WHY
The answer is simple, because God says the he will forgive even some of the non believers even and send them to heaven, especially who were good people in their life
The concept here is not only the belief will save you only, your contribution to your society matters too
He was a prophet of Justice.....
Peace is one side of the coin 🪙
Being very selective still I feel that I already started liking your approach
Nice 👍💪☝️😇
Juan Cole should know it was wahi, not a mystical experience that predicted the Byzantine victory and rejoicing. Mystical experience are distinct from wahi.
He is not a Muslim
@Alex Ander thanks! Context matters: czcams.com/video/7cqNqZFf-eE/video.html
@Alex Ander It had to do with the divine Prophetic mission. For each Prophet the immediate nation was destroyed if they did not accept the truth, either by God or the adherents of the faith. Pharoah and the parting of the seas and 70 AD on rejection of Jesus as messiah.
Islam is truely a religion of peace 👍
A good analysis in the midst of Islamophobia 👍
AlhamdulillAh 👍
Subhanallah 💪
Allahu Akber ✌️ Laillaha illAllah 💚
Thank you for your studies dear Paul.
There is scientists also i would like to say that it is impossible that the information that the Prophet bad was made up .
At the time of the Prophet
Proverbs 12:19. The lip of truth shall be established for ever: but a lying tongue is but for a moment.
Professor Juan Cole is an عالم indeed.
❤💯
Foretells the story of the chapter of"Al-Alak
Isaiah 29:11-18“ And the vision of all is become unto you as the words of a book that is sealed,which[men]deliver to one that is learned,saying,Read this,I pray thee:and he saith,I cannot;for it[is]sealed:And the book is delivered to him that is not learned,saying,Read this,[Ipraythee]:and he saith,I am not learned.Where fore the Lord aid,For as much as this people draw near[me]with their mouth,and with their lips do honor me,but have removed their heart far from me,and their fear toward me istaught by the precept of men:There fore,behold,I will proceed to do a marvelous work among this people,[even]a marvelous work and a wonder:for the wisdom of their wise[men]shall perish,and the understanding of their prudent men shall be hid.Woe unto them that seek deep to hide their counsel from the LORD,and their works are in the dark,and they say,Who see thus?and who knoweth us?Surely your turning of things upside down shall be esteemed as the potter'sclay:for shall the work say of him that mad eit,He made me not?or shall the thing framed say of him that framed it,He had no understanding?[Is]it not yet a very little while,and Lebanon shall be turned into a fruitful field,and the fruit fulfield shall be esteemed as a forest And in that day shall the deaf hear the words of the book,and the eyes of the blind shall see out of obscurity,and out of darkness"
Seen like Donner's main thesis..
-maybe we discover more inscription in Hejaz to see about transtion of inscription..
عليه افضل الصلاة و ازكى السلام .
☮️🌿
Can you fix the subtitle sir?
trying!
U should use subtitles
I want to bring your attention to De Lacy O’ Leary’s book “Islam at the cross road”. He said on page 8 that, “History makes it clear, that the legend of fanatical Muslims sweeping through the world and forcing Islam at the point of the sword upon conquered races, is one of the most fantastically absurd myths that historians have ever repeated”. Nine million Christians in Arab nations from generations is a witness to that. The whole of Indonesia becoming Muslim without a war ever taking place in that country is adding to that as well.
❤
اللهم صلي على محمد و على اله محمد كما صليت على ابراهيم و على اله ابراهيم انك حميد مجيد اللهم بارك على محمد و على اله محمد كما باركت على ابراهيم و على اله ابراهيم انك حميد مجيد.
Not only Muhammad pbuh was a prophet of peace but he was sent as a mercy to mankind.💙
@@cervezaway7049
If you haven’t anything of value to add!!!! Why don’t you shut up and get out of here!!!!
@@majidbenyounes9008
CW is only talking stating a historical fact. 😭😭
@@cervezaway7049
who the h.. is that?
and how many followers does he have?
Was he able to produce similar book like that of the Quran?
Let's us know!
@@majidbenyounes9008 brother ignore Cerveza Way, he spams nonsense on every video.
He is the typical example of deaf dumb and blind.