Battlefield 1942 Original vs Portal - Weapons Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 07. 2024
- 0:00 HANDGUNS
1:12 SMGs
2:38 RIFLES
5:52 MACHINE GUNS
7:26 LAUNCHERS
Which one is which? - First, Original, second Portal.
"Which is better" playlist:
• Which is better?
BATTLEFIELD playlist:
• Battlefield playlist
Call of Duty playlist:
• Call of Duty playlist
Rainbow Six playlist:
• Rainbow Six playlist
Far Cry playlist:
• Far Cry playlist
---------
All content from this video and this channel is recorded and edited exclusively by me. I NEVER use clips or any kind of content from someone else. - Hry
The Lee Enfield in Portal is probably the only portal weapon that had animations that look almost the same quality as BF1 reload animations
Yeah kinda sucks. Imo the worst reload out of all portal is the aks74u one, literally looks like a doom reload. So very poor effort was put into animations, most of them beein reused in some weapons like the portal bad company 2 snipers
@@Er_Lolers "poor"
Games aren't human beings
The Lee Enfield held 10 rounds. IN BOTH GAMES THEY ONLY HELD 5 ROUNDS
Wrong loading animation. British soldiers were instructed to fire using middle finger and toggle the bolt using thumb and palm (BFV got that right).
@@qingyunwang3802 I notice, just pointing out the quality of the animations alone
Battlefield 2042, and portal, should stand as a shining example of what happens when you release a game WAAAY to early. It had potential to become the best, but alas, it has failed.
Portal was the only enjoyable apart of 2042. even though Ripple Effect had less than 2 years to work on it, it shows more love than the rest of 2042. that said, it is not worth going back to play due to 2042 being a dead game. fuck EA
Can't wait for argument in replies
People will defend bf2042 so hard now.....
@@fallaciousfirm2524 no but actually yes
@@fallaciousfirm2524 I'm surprised that there are still a few of them defending it
*Too
Seeing how stiff and floaty these animations are just makes me wonder why wouldn't they just reuse BFV's animations instead.
Every game tries to copy Modern Warfare animations.....thats why
@@iamnotjeff why People are doing this?...Did they don't understand that instead of making aggressive reloads animations like 2019 ..they fail like a cheap of mw2019 ...My man Modern Fps Games
@@iamnotjeff
which is stupid since nobody ever reloads like that in WWII. even BF1 and BFV got trigger discipline, which is an anachronistic technique.
Theyre so modern that in 1942 they use strippers clip and portal did not
@@siyamsadikshocho3237 exactly man, literally every game copies mw2019 reloads and make them cheaper like Operation harsh doorstep, Zero Hour, Ground Branch etc...Just do something new bruh
1942: Outdated, crunchy as hell, but has nice, deliberate slow movements that are aesthetically pleasing.
BF Portal: Wants to be Vanguard but isn't ready to commit, has weird movement patterns and period-incorrect tacticool reloads. Also some lack of attention to detail that's confusing in light of their previous games.
Honestly just a disgrace to all previous battlefield games
@@Aureus_especially if you keep in mind that BF1 was released in 2016...7 years ago.
i love how the low render distance in BF1942 makes the map seem huge
3:52 NO! How could EA and DICE get something so simple wrong?!
This is an unforgivable sin
Even cod got that right lmao, i think bfv got it right too
To be fair, it's even worse in 1942. Also, you can get a situation where you have to hit the charging handle forward, but that's if your M1 Garand is dirty enough.
@@kivnokai understandable for 2001 game
Not for 2042 portal which is fking new released game were gun reload animation are inaccurate while i2-3 years old games already have achieved them....
@@fallaciousfirm2524 just because video games have evolved doesn't mean all animators nowadays know the full ins and outs of how guns work. The animator behind the reloads probably had a fair idea of how the M1 Garand worked, but didn't know this one small detail. Yes it is quite annoying if you pay attention to the reloads, but it is a pretty small detail.
Something I noticed as well was that the 2042 guns feel like they have some weight compared to 1942, albeit not a lot. 1942's animations look like the guns weigh basically nothing, especially in the case of the M1918 BAR.
2042 Portal's animations may be more or less similar to Vanguard's anachronism on modern handling, but what exclusions should be listed.
It’s really on more the fact that Ripple effect(portal dev) just reused the 2042 base weapon reload animations than making new animations for 1942 weapons(excluding kar98 and Lee enfield), that’s why the reload is more modern looking
This is Portal, not 2042
I would usually point it out, but the original did it too, and this is supposed to be the same but better
I think portal is modern but using ww2 guns
portal is a game mode inside of bf 2042
Weird that modern Battlefield games and most shooters make every weapon fire tracers rather than normal ammo.
game devs dont realize tracers are a thing lmao
@@TerrorOmnibus It’s actually done so you can see where you are shooting and getting shot from.
@@rataide99 well that’s the point of damage indicators
@@lrsb1678 I play mostly milsims like the Arma series and Post Scriptum, rarely mainstream games like COD or Battlefield it's why I find tracers in these games funny from a logistics lore perspective
Yeah I thought about adding tracers in my game but then I played vigor and had severe brain cancer from all the tracers so I think nah
Almost every weapon sounds much better but nothing can replace 1942's Garand and Lee Enfield sound.
The garand ping in 1942 sounded awful. And they got the reload animation completely wrong, the bolt locks back when empty
@@francissauve6685 yeah I know, but nostalgia is what I was talking about.
@@victorjacques5201 The 1942 m1 garand sound was ripped straight from Medal of Honor Allied Assault's m1 garand sound
I dunno about you but the original Garand just sounds like a nail gun to me lol
OK, again, I don’t hate nor dislike any of 2042’s gun sounds, just saying from my point of view that some weapons sound was particularly good in my childhood memory, if anyone wants to disprove my opinion or state any more facts, please continue.
Personaly i really hate when game developers are putting tactical reloading anywhere
Tactical reloading duing ww2,normal civilian and others
Yea they were not pullin that shenanigans
Thats not a WW2 game
@@tomato8933 yeah vanguard was full of disappointment
I thought most of all soldiers back in the day used one-handed grip.
They did
The teacup position didn't exist till Vietnam
They got that right in bfv
@@Aureus_ they taught the teacup for longer range shooting. One handing the gun was for up close point-and-shoot combat
@@Aureus_ the teacup definitely existed in WW2. tons of gi training vids show them shooting 1911's with it
I love how for some guns, when you turn captions on, the captions say [Applause]
I can't think of a single Battlefield game that hasn't had the M1911
2142
and BF2
I played that game and I never see a single M1911 variants
@@CoreRealm bf2 perhaps. But Battlefield 2042 has it as Portal is a part of that game
@@Pyke64 dude, wrong game
2142 is another bf game made in 2006
It's a futuristic shooter
@@CoreRealm You can't buy Portal or BF2042 seperate = so same game
Nice Video👍
after the 4.0 update, a lot of the portal gun animations have been updated :)
Cool
And Stills garbage
A game from 2002 have more meaty gun sounds than game from 2021.
Do you want meaty sounds or realism?
@@onejediboi Sometimes realistic sounds are meaty (like in Escape from Tarkov), sometimes they are not realistic but awful ( like in Call of Duty Vanguard)
the 1911 sounds like a lazer gun💀
i kinda don't agree that the old ones sound better... ik it's nostalgic and all but just imagine the old SFX were in portal its kinda goofy when you had more hd models and animation with those sound design but, hey it's just my opinion
@@zeghuy4082 yea
1942 reloads look like how a actual ww2 would reload their weapon
2042 just looks like a modern gun enthusiast playing around with the weapons
"A actual ww2 would reload" What?
@@FrostyyMcToasty ww2 soldier i forgot a word
I remember the time when my Kar98K magically had 5 rounds after I inserted only one round into it.
One thing I notice is that the MP40's fire sound is faster then the actual fire rate. The casings ejecting from the smg are faster then the bullets themselves. Either they should slow the speed for the sound of the gun shot and the animation for the shells
I just noticed for some reason in the portal version the STG 44 magazine is put in like an AK for some reason.
Nostalgia VS Grim Reality, which one is best..?
Bf1918
@@actdiff it's a mod But I'd dig it
Both
If only they reused BFV and BF1 animations for 1942, and BF3/4 animations for 3 and BC2, it would be great.
2042 animations are so downgraded compared to V and earlier, and they need to be urgently reanimated. I gotta give them props for making the iron sights more realistic than before though.
bruh,its not easy to port animations and sounds
4:30 wtf that bolt animation lol
Those 1942 reloads are killing me lmao, why are you pulling the slide at the end
Its evolving just backwards
God that tac reload with the BAR really just killed my eyes
I'm burn!
Thank you
When the weapon animations in latest game look crankier than those in first game
Old Thompson and MP40 sounds from Bf1942 like: DADADADADADADDADA! xD
1:40 The dudes hands are so shaky during that MP40 reload it looks like he drank way too much caffeine (or ate too much Panzerschokolade) before battle
Here we go, boys...
battlefield 1942 is a true masterpiece for me. Played the heck out of that game
Battlefiele 1942 isnt Battlefield 1942 when you cannot control a aircraft carrier
Good that I have this old games
Sure some of the problems with the weapons and their animations’ problems were fixed but who needs tactical reloads in Portal?
Model design : Portal
Animations : Portal
Sounds : 1942
Bro, gonna be honest, Portal animations are great, but fails in something, they're tactical, you feel like a modern soldier of 2022, but not like a poor bastard in the world war 2
@@mr.pineapple8735 also the operator or character shakes like an earthquake is happening in the reloads
I like Thomspon, MP40, M1 garand and lee enfield!
In BF 1942, why does the character pull the slide back after it already snaps shut?
Did Bush do 9/11?
Its a 2002 game bro
MG42 & M2 Browning In Battlefield Portal...Sheeshhhhh
How can fuck up the M1 grand ping sound it the most iconic sound ever.
What was that Panzerschreck Shield dear God
It genuinely hurts my soul a little to see someone palming a Lee-Enfield bolt.
On the STG the animators were so lazy they didn’t even animate the spring moving. It just phases through the charging handle and stays completely still.
I like how the old has better sound and handling in reloading the new is just pure aggressive and needs to shake that sht idk why
mp40 and tommy gun sound quite nice ngl
Sure but the MP40 reload looks so shaky
The Portal Thompson tac reload is painful to watch (having tried dual mag swaps on old smgs and bruised / cut my hands several times) - also what's with the WW1 / 2 / Nam characters holding handguns w both hands and not in classic target shooting single handed manner?
teacupping their pistols was also an acceptable grip at the time.
Haha loved 1942 when I was 10 years old but alot of those reloads are janky af and I remember back then the painfully slow reloads were pretty problematic in gameplay
I know Dayum will that some reloads will be changed in a new update.
i cant tell if this is portal or vanguard
That's why i only play old games
Unfortunately bf 1942 don’t work on my pc, it’s too old I guess
@@Reupload-Kanal-Von-Lukas-Heil or your PC is not opengl
@@Reupload-Kanal-Von-Lukas-Heil how can you not run 1942? you running on a windows 1?
100 years later
Why were the old BF games so obsessed with bumping their mags during every reload?
It's nice that DICE went old school and maintained some of the clunky stiff animations from the original game.
M1ガーランドのリロードの時、8発フル装填のクリップが飛び出してくるのは何故でしょうか？
spring action or something
What I really don't like about the portal (and why I think some people may also not like it) is that it shies away a lot from the original game. For example, the reload animations are very unfaithful to the original and are mostly just trying to hop on the "tactical reload" trend that is inundating games in this modern age. Also (and this also ties into the unfaithful reloads), the game ignores many of the quirks that made Battlefield 1942 fun (e.g. the slides on the pistols releasing themselves prematurely). Another reason the portal isn't great is that the animations were clearly not put under review, since many of them are just either reused from the base game or incredibly janky. Most weapons just reuse sounds from earlier titles, which also speaks volumes about the lack of effort put into the portals.
In short, the portal is far more than EA DICE bargained for and was definitely just added as an afterthought. They didn't bother to make anything original and instead just reskinned the base game and called it a day. Besides, why should they try to fix something that isn't broken? Players could just go back to the original 1942 game or, if they really want an improvement, Battlefield V.
@Thawne You missed almost every point I made. I didn't say that tactical reloads weren't realistic, I said that many games include tactical reloads and aren't doing a good job at them. Besides, it's a WW2 shooter, where I find it hard to believe that people are pulling a tactical reload on Iwo Jima
@Thawne Hang on, what do you mean by tactical reloads?
@Thawne I'm talking about bringing out a fresh magazine first then reloading while holding both magazines in your hand, like MW2019
Still play the Desert Combat mod.
what the hell is going on with that Kar98k bolt action... like... when he goes to reload he does it right - but that circular, butthole symbol grab of the knob end of the bolt handle has me so painfully confused... and... triggered!!!!
... did pistols in real life have tracers back then?
What if battlefield portal was it's own game?
2042: no good animation?
No
The only good animation in the entire game for me is the .44 Magnum a.k.a M44
6:41 no wonder they called it hilers buzzsaw
Quality of sounds of WWII weapons decreased in recent years
There's no "power" in those sounds. Compare the sounds of Kar98k with the really first 2 CoD's
CZcams thinks this video has a game with a 100 number difference in the title lol
Idk why people really hate bf 2042, but I never played it and i don't really care about gun sounds or any small details, it doesn't ruin the fun for me, as long as it stays as an epic chaos battle ground
Beatifull game
man I'm still playing 1942 with mods
Right off the bat I'm wondering why the fucking M1911 is shooting flares into the sky, I'm aware those are meant to be tracers but tracers aren't that big.
How the fuck do you mess up the Garand reload.
kinda bf5 grafic in 2042 making portal to 1942
Guys can anyone tell me how to play this portal?
You need bf 2042 to play this
the animation quality has declined so much since bf1.
2:58 Hey AK 47 buddy look, it's your dad STG 44
Facepalm…
@@shepardgrey8362Whooosh
I don't get it, where's the battlefield portal footage? All I see is crusty old battlefield 1942
Portal has guns?
Gaved us a lesson not to overhype mwII, but we can overhype gta 6 I guess
Desde cuando el m40 es de camara cerrada?
what the fuck is that kar98k bolt action 😭😭😭
Why can’t video games ever get the garand reload right?
the portal animations are so jittery and shakey. it looks like a weird indie shooter from the late 2000's to early 2010's. the quality that DICE had got sucked into a black hole with this game.
damn i just realised bf2042 animations is probably a failed result of mocapping
(i guees, compared with csgo beta animations)
Viewmodel animations aren't typically done with mocap, and that's the case with Battlefield 2042. It's easier, more practical and probably more cost-effective to just hire animators that are good at viewmodel animations than to get an entire team dedicated to mocap together.
Yeah but they got the Thompson empty reload right.
I'm pretty sure mo-capping would have given them a better baseline than what they have. Given that they're trying to Modern Warfare '19 tacticool everything, I have no doubts that they'd still fuck that baseline up, though.
@@StarkRaven59 like I said, mo-capping is simply not worth it when you have animators that are very skilled at viewmodel animating.
1942 ; Cursed models and some weird animations. The sound design is quite nice for its time. and despite being weird in some places, the animations still have been put care in, I'd say.
Portal ; Too modern reloads that feel like they have no weight and some clipping here and there. Good models though, gotta leave them that. No comment on the sound design, seems something in between for me.
The name of battlefield 2042 confuses me with the stg44 the 44 meaning it was designed in 1944
Good old game
Yeah but not as good as yours
Too bad you're a douche as a person tho
that moment a game from 20 years ago has smoother and more accurate reloads than a game from 2021
Lol ok😂
@@whaym318 i didn't say they where great. but they are 1000 times better than 2042. atleast they aren't clunky, and they are pretty good for 2002
@@CRAZYMUGMAN If you think battlefield 1942 animations are not clunky then you were mistaken
@@CRAZYMUGMAN if you shoot a gun or watch someone shoot a gun it is nowhere near 1942 Animations
@@whaym318okay sherlock
why tf didn't they just port anims from bfv?
They look worse
Bc people like you would call it lazy
how you play battlefield 1942 where you find these games???
Crack probably
@@fallaciousfirm2524 or he just buys them lmao
@@fallaciousfirm2524 you cant crack a multiplayer only game
@@EarthyTeddy yeah but where??
@@ebos6516 he just buys the games on the oficial stores or on some kind of digital games store
xD the m1 garand and stg in 1942
M1 Garand Animation it's just afwul for many reason, StG 44 Animation reuse the Base game's SVK Animation
i'm sorry, M1 & StG44 in 1942? M1 is Mirrored for obvious reason, where StG 44 Charging handle?
What is that reload on the portal mp40
Something tells me DICE did not actually work on PORTAL.
the operator look scared lol
@@WaltherWA-bb2dl considering they are fighting soldiers from the future, it's normal. I'd be scared too lol
It's a correction. In the original, the MP40 reload is incorrect. Portal understood that MP40 is an open bolt smg and the original didn't.
Emmanuel "Emitilty" Rossi Portal got it wrong too except they portray it as a closed bolt. The bolt is suppose to reciprocate Forward and back not back forward.
almost all of the weapon models from portal are all from bfv so sad dude...
Animation, sound and destruction are things bring me to battlefield, but in 2042... So awful.
Bf Portal is at least not that bad but still a bit flawed.
3:44
6:42 Where da ammo go?
invisible empty cartrige.
i might be wrong but i think it goes down
@@HKG11Prototype its not mg34 stupid!
@@HKG11PrototypeIt goes at the right side
Back when pistols had the recoil of anti aircraft cannons. Good times.
why are soldiers from the 1940s tactical reloading 💀
Panzershrek? More like Panzer Shrek
I remember my friend boasting to me that he bought bf2042 pre-order, thank god i didnt follow his advice
Wtf is up with all the tacticool reloads
the animations in portal are wayyy too fast. im pretty sure a soldier in 1942 would reload at a slowish pace
Sounds: Original
Models and Animations: Portal
Say no less.
Alright of course that portal got more great animations and sound but still floaty and awful compare to bf5 or bf1
I think they were trying to make them in the spirit of the original
Don't compare it lol
@@freedoomer2524 If Portal's animations were in the spirit of the original, they'd be slower and deliberate. This looks more like they tried to rip off Vanguard, which itself is just a cheap ripoff of Modern Warfare.
@@StarkRaven59 the originals weren’t all that slow either. I’m just guessing is all
why...why do ALL reload animations need to look like they come from MW2019?????
Because they are cool